FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN A PLANNING FRAMEWORK FOR THE FERTILE SAND HILLS
CITY OF FERTILE
October 2019
FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN 1 PLANNING TEAM
Wayne Goeken, NRSDP Natural Resources Work Group member Dan Wilkens, Mayor of Fertile; AELC Board Member Danielle Spiten, Agassiz ELC Education Program Director Wendell Johnson, Agassiz ELC Board member Lisa Liden - City Administrator Craig Engelstad, Agassiz ELC Board member Stanton Wang, Agassiz ELC Board member Reid Jesrud, Agassiz ELC Board member Nicole Bernd, District Manager for West Polk SWCD, Agassiz ELC Board member Kirsten Fagerlund, Polk County Public Health Gary Kiefert, Agassiz ELC Board member Al Pierson, Agassiz ELC Board member Laurie Fairchild, Agassiz ELC Board member Linda Kingery, Northwest Regional Sustainable Development Partnership Executive Director Jacob Mans, Assistant Professor School of Architecture Thomas Fisher, Director of Minnesota Design Center Alejandra Cervantes Enriquez, Master of Science in Architecture - Research Practices candidate
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This project is supported in part through student research assistance provided by the Community Assistantship Program (CAP), a program of the University of Minnesota’s Center for Urban and Regional Affairs (CURA). Funding for this project also includes the Northwest Regional Sustainable Development Partnership and the Northwest Minnesota Foundation.
The planning team would like to thank Agassiz ELC Board and staff, as well community members from in and around the City of Fertile who participated in this planning project.
2 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Table of Contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5 Part 1 - INTRODUCTION 7 PART 2 - PROPOSER AND IMPLEMENTING AGENCIES 13 PART 3 - SETTING AND REGIONAL CONTEXT 15 PART 4 - SITE INFORMATION 21 PART 5 - VISION, TRENDS, AND PUBLIC VALUES 23 PART 6 - REGIONAL SIGNIFIGANCE STATEMENT 25 PART 7 - PUBLIC INPUT AND PARTICIPATION 27 PART 8 - DESIGN 37 PART 9 - MANAGEMENT, OPERATIONS & ECOLOGICAL RESTORATION 59
APPENDIX A - ACCESSIBLITY REPORT BY OPTIONS GROUP
3 Master Plan Project List 13 11 projects not indicated on the map are spread throughout the entire Fertile Sand Hills Property** 16 12 14 *Upper Campus Site and the RV/Camp Site are both Future 5 recommended but require more detailed design* Upper Campus 2
Signage 1 - Wayfinding 8 2 - AELC Campus Signage 3 - Interpreta�ve Signage 1 4 - Interpreta�ve Signage 2
Future Accessibility 6 RV/Camp 5 - River Trail Outdoor Recrea�onal Access Route Site 6 - Sand Hills Outdoor Recrea�onal Access Route 7 7 - Improved Van Access along Perimeter 8 - Accessible River Access 15 9 - Informa�on Plan 10 - Motorized Vehicle Access Policy
Facility an Groun s Im rovements 11 - The Deck 12 - Exis�ng Visitor Center Phase 1 13 - The Bridge 14 - Exis�ng Visitor Center Phase 2 15 - Remote Support Buildings 16 - Camper Cabins 17 - Property Maintenance
Maintenance an Management 18 - Sand Dune Management Plan 19 - Prairie Management Plan 20 - Sand Hill River Management Plan 21 - Buckthorn Management Plan 22 - Bike Area Restora�on Plan 23 - Regula�ons Enforcement Policy
Figure 1: Master Plan Project for Fertile Sands Hills
4 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Executive Summary
The design of the phyiscal Master Plan for In pursuit of its mission, the AELC: the Fertile Sand Hills focuses on increasing access to this unique ecological resource and 1. Provides hands-on, engaging education pro- providing improvements that connect all users grams for all ages with emphasis on youth. to this environment. The design sets out to • To this end, the master plan includes im- develop a vision that will help transform the provements to the AELC facility indoors and Fertile Sand Hills strategically into a world- outdoors to support the educational pro- class park system. The plan carefully balances gram. the Agassiz Environmental Learning Center’s • The visitor/education center is accessible mission to foster a greater awareness of the • Partnerships with schools and communities interrelationships between humans and nature are strengthened with the City of Fertile’s continued commitment to conserve this landscape for long-time use by 2. Emphasizes protection of the rare ecosystems local, regional, and global communities. found at the Fertile Sand Hills • The master plan describes management for open sand areas, oak savannahs, prairies, Mission river and riparian forests. To foster a greater understanding of the interre- • Partnership with UMC, DNR and TNC provide lationships between humans and nature. management expertise.
Vision 3. Provide a space for mental and physical The Agassiz Environmental Learning Center wellness through a variety of recreational provides high quality environmental education opportunities programs and premier recreation experiences • Signage for wayfinding and facility informa- utilizing the diverse and unique ecosystems of tion is improved throughout. the scenic Fertile Sand Hills. • Trails and river access is accessible • Remote support structures offer shelter and creative space. Goals The Fertile Sand Hills property is designated as a park of regional significance by the Greater Min- nesota Regional Parks and Trails Commission.
5 Figure 2: Pasque Flowers
6 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN PART 1 - INTRODUCTION
"The Fertile Sand Hills are a unique convergence of ecological biomes including oak savanna, dry A primary goal of this master plan is to help the sand prairie, sand dunes, aspen forest and a riv- FSH achieve designation as a park of regional erine corridor. The 640-acre property is located significance. Further, this master plan provides immediately southwest of the city of Fertile, in a working document that can append to future south central Polk County. The City of Fertile ac- Park & Trail Legacy Funding applications as quired the FSH in 1976, as part of the U.S. Bicen- well as to prioritize development projects and Figure 3 - Student stream survey of the Sand Hill River tennial Celebration. In 1985, a grant established marketing strategies that will help make the formation of the AELC and the recreation area's Fertile Sand Hills financially sustainable. primary trail system and in 1991 the AELC was incorporated as a non-profit entity. The Greater Minnesota Regional Parks and Trails Strategic Plan outlines specific criteria that parks The Fertile Sand Hills (FSH) is home to the Agas- pursuing a regional significance distinction in siz Environmental Learning Center (AELC), and Greater Minnesota must meet: is located immediately southwest of the city of Fertile, in south central Polk County. The City of Natural resource-based settings and range Fertile and the AELC seek to preserve this sci- of activities offered: The park should provide entifically significant area and offer educational a natural setting and offer outdoor recreation opportunities. Figures 3-5 show students engag- facilities and activities that are primarily natural Figure 4 - Students playing at Death Valley 1 ing the FSH. resource-base. The City of Fertile and the AELC are looking to extend this local asset to the greater Minnesota The FSH offer a unique diversity of ecosystems community by enhancing its physical infrastruc- including: oak savanna, dry sand prairie, sand ture and educational/recreational programming dunes, poplar forest, and a riverine corridor. to attract expanded regional and state visitors. Visitors to the Fertile Sand Hills can make use In the fall of 2017, the City of Fertile partnered of over 12 miles of hiking, horseback riding, with the University of Minnesota’s Northwest snowshoeing and cross-country ski trails, a Regional Sustainable Development Partner- campground, an observation deck overlooking ships and Minnesota Design Center to develop the Sand Hill River, and the AELC, which provides a master plan to assess the assets of the Fertile restroom facilities and a multipurpose space for area and develop planning guidelines for the FSH environmental education and community events. that build on local resources and help meet the Attracting more than the average outdoor en- Figure 5 - Student conducting field survey broader needs of the community. thusiast, the FSH hold tremendous potential to Designation 7 expand natural recreation experiences and envi- • Fertile Conservation Club hosts 3D Archery Polk County and extended regional partners that ronmental educational programs from students Events. include healthcare, public health boards includ- to regional, state-wide and international visitors. • MN Conservation Corps completed river tree ing Norman, Mahnomen, and Polk Counties that snagging to facilitate safe river access for are actively promoting work-life wellness through Regional Use: Evidence that the park serves at paddling and fishing. nature. least a regional clientele; other related factors may include evidence that the facility currently The FHS are a valuable public health asset that Additionally, parks pursuing a regional signifi- or potentially may draw tourists and generate this master plan is seeking to leverage through economic impact from outside the local area. additional partnerships with the City of Fertile,
The FSH are open to use which it broadens through several partnerships that bring together neighboring communities through environmental programming, recreational opportunities and early childhood educational programs facilitat- ed by the AELC with the Fertile-Beltrami School district.
Some of the existing projects with other partner- ships include:
• University of Minnesota Crookston -- Limnol- ogy class uses Sand Hill River as outdoor lab and Ecosystem Restoration class has taken on several service projects restoring open sand areas. • Sand Hill Watershed District implemented fish passage project in partnership with West Polk Soil and Water Conservation District, (make reference to Lessard Sams and/or oth- er funding/partners (Enbridge) involved) • MN DNR and The Nature Conservancy assist with prescribed burns and prairie restoration Figure 6: Google map locating Fertile
8 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN cance distinction in Greater Minnesota must also meet at least one of the following:
Size: The park should be significant in size; in southern Minnesota, a park of 100 acres is signif- icant, and in northern Minnesota, the acreage is generally larger
The 640-acre property is located immediately southwest of the City of Fertile, in south cen- tral Polk County (Figure 6). The City of Fertile acquired the Fertile Sand Hills In 1976, as part of the U.S. Bicentennial Celebration. In 1989, grant support helped establish the formation of Figure 7: Sand Hill River Figure 8: Native Prairie the AELC and the recreation area’s primary trail system and in 1991 the AELC was incorporated as a Non-Profit. The 640 acre Fertile Sand Hills meet the size requirement, and are augmented by nearby and adjacent properties. The Nature Conservancy manages the Agassiz Dunes Scien- tific and Natural Area (SNA), a similar but smaller preserve approx one mile south of the Fertile Sand Hills with land between these two units also protected through enrollment in the Prairie Bank program and an additional DNR SNA tract. The Minnesota Natural Heritage Program surveyed the Fertile Sandhills in 1987 and 1988, noting “A preserve will protect the most significant dune area in northwestern Minnesota. The Natural Heritage Program considers the Fertile Sandhills to be one of the highest protection priorities in Figure 9: Oak Aspen Woods Figure 10: Sand Dunes the state.”
Special features: Unique or unusual landscape 9 features, historically or culturally significant sites, of Fertile rich clay deposits were discovered or parks containing characteristics of regional or which led to formation of the Fertile Brick and statewide significance. Tile Company in 1897,a robust brickyard which operated until 1960--producing 3 million bricks The Fertile Sand Hills feature a diverse group of in a 5-6 month season at peak production. Many rare plant communities (Figures 7-12) present buildings in Fertile and the region are made of at this unique intersection of prairie, oak savan- brick from the Fertile Brick and Tile Company. nah and aspen parklands that allow people to traverse through the Sand Hills and learn about Scarcity of recreational resources: The park pro- Minnesota biomes. For example, the Northern vides public natural resource-based recreational Dry Savannah community is rare in Minnesota, opportunities that are not otherwise available and much of it occurs in the FSH. within a reasonable distance.
Figure 11: Aspen Forest Extensive erosion occurred when glacial melt- TheFSH are uniquely positioned to become the waters flowed between glacial lakes Climax and first park of regional significance in Polk County Koochiching, flowing on the south edge of the (Figure 13). Currently there is not a State Park retreating glacier--outletting both to Lake Superi- within 60+ miles of Fertile (Figure 14). The coun- or and River Warren and leaving the largest sand ty does have several recreational parks (Figure deposits on the Minnesota side of the Red River 15), but none of these host the combined ame- Basin at the Sand Hill River delta. Westerly winds nities (such as ski trails, hiking, and other public created the area’s rare sand dunes after glacial outdoor recreation opportunities) that the FSH Lake Agassiz began to drain into Hudson Bay. does. While one-third of Minnesota used to be covered by prairie, the combination of plants now found The Fertile Sand Hills not only meet the mini- within the Fertile Sand Hills are no longer avail- mum number of requirements for designation, it able anywhere else. meets all of the requirements.
The beach ridges of glacial Lake Agassiz are concentrated in the Fertile area with the Upper Herman beach ridge coinciding with the historic Figure 12: Bur Oak Savanna Pembina oxcart trail which crosses the Sand Hill River just east of the FSH. Also on the eastern edge of the FHS and western edge of the City
10 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Figure 13: Recreational Resources
11 Figure 14: State parks, recreation areas, and wayside mrea map Figure 15: Polk County park and management area map
STATE PARKS POLK COUNTY REGIONAL PARK SYSTEM (27) Lake Maria (53) Red River (1) Lake Bronson (1) Tillberg County Park (28) Fort Snelling (54) Old Mill (2) Split Rock Creek (2) Melland Memorial Park (29) Afton (55) Lake Bronson (3) Camden (3) Polk County Tillberg Park (30) St. Croix Islands (56) Hayes Lake (4) Lake Shetek (4) Lessor State Wildlife Management Area (31) William O’Brien (57) Zippel Bay (5) Kilen Woods (5) Polk State Wildlife Management Area (32) Interstate (58) Garden Island (6) Myre Big Island (6) Minnesota Farmers Union Park (33) Wild River (59) Franz Jevne (7) Lake Louise (7) County Fishing Park (34) St. Croix (60) Big Bog (8) Forestville/ Mystery Cave (8) County Park (35) Banning (61) Scenic (9) Beaver Creek Valley (9) Sand Hill Recreation Area (36) Father Hennepin (62) McCarthy Beach (10) Great River Bluffs (10) Stipa State Wildlife Management Area (37) Mille Lacs Kathie (63) Lake Vermillon-Soudan (11) Whitewater (11) Maplewood Park (38) Charles A. Lindbergh Underground Mine (12) Carley (12) Grand Forks Park District (39) Lake Carlos (64) Bear Head Lake (13) John A. Latsch (13) Stauss Park (14) Frontenac (40) Glendalough (65) Iron Range Off-Highway (15) Nerstrand Big Woods (41) Maplewood Vehicle (16) Rice Lake (42) Buffalo River (66) Gooseerry Falls (17) Sakatah Lake (43) Crow Wing (67) Split Rock Falls (18) Minneopa (44) Cuyuna Country (68) George Crosby Manitou (19) Flandrau (45) Moose Lake (69) Temperence River (20) Fort Rigely (46) Jay Cooke (70) Cascade River (21) Upper Sioux Agency (47) Savanna Portage (71) Judge C.R. Magney (22) Lac qui Parie (48) Schoolcraft (72) Grand Portage (23) Big Stone Lake (49) Hill Annex Mine (73) Greenleaf Lake (24) Glacial Lakes (50) Itasca (74) Minnesota Valley (25) Monson Lake (51) La Salle Lake (26) Sibley Lake (52) Lake Bemidji 12 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN PART 2 - PROPOSER AND IMPLEMENTING AGENCIES
Beginning in the fall of 2017, the City of Fertile nomic disruptions of our time. life balance for both adults and young ones. and the Agassiz Environmental Learning Center Besides hosting social events on-site, public (AELC) worked on a project with the Minnesota The Fertile Sand Hills (FSH) Recreation Area has health agencies and the local school district have Design Center (MDC) at the University of Min- been both the subject and backdrop for a range vested interest in promoting and implementing nesota to conduct a comprehensive asset as- of environmental and educational initiatives. nature-based play programming for users to in- sessment of the surrounding Fertile area to help College and high school students assist with teract directly with nature whilst learning about inform the development of a master plan for the restoration activities. Regional grade school ac- the ecology and environment within the FSH. Fertile Sand Hills. To better understand how the cess the AELC through environmental education City of Fertile and the AELC’s goals and strategies programs. Special events are hosted by a variety The FSH are uniquely positioned to provide could act as a catalyst for recreation, environ- of local, regional, and state agencies that include: more than recreation to Fertile and the broad- mental education, and economic development in , West Polk County Soil and WaterConservation er community. Increasing awareness about the the region, the MDC team broadened their scope District, The Nature Conservancy , Polk County amenities and overall experience at the FSH will to see beyond the Fertile city limits. 4-H club, Fertile Early Childhood Initiative, Polk not only attract a wider audience, but also attain County Public Health, and others. better exposure to statewide initiatives that Funding for the work was made available through could be undertaken at this site. The combina- the Northwest Minnesota Foundation, the The City of Fertile owns and maintains the FSH tion of an ecologically diverse landscape, a ded- Northwest Regional Sustainable Development and provides staff on a part-time basis and en- icated management program for environmental Partnership, and the University of Minnesota’s gages volunteers from the community to keep protection and restoration, and a vested interest Center for Urban and Regional Affairs. The MDC, the AELC open and accessible. by the local and broader community are key to an interdisciplinary research center housed maintaining the FSH unique and hidden gem for within the University of Minnesota’s College of The organizations listed above have, over the visitors. Design, worked with City of Fertile officials and years, made use of the FSH to further environ- AELC members to reach out to the community for mental awareness and restoration efforts such help in identifying regional and local assets that as controlled burns, prairie restoration, river could be translated into recreation, education, stabilization and tree snagging, and fish passage and economic development opportunities. The restoration, all of which would not have been mission of the MDC is to work with communi- possible without the support and engagement of ties to find innovative design solutions for both local,regional, state, and federal agencies as well physical systems such as infrastructure and open as private sector partners. space as well as non-physical systems such as public health or service delivery that can help Public health and early education initiatives have our region seize the opportunities that lie in the also been key to promoting wellness, environ- social, technological, environmental, and eco- mental awareness, healthy lifestyle, and a work-
13 Figure 16: Sand Hill River
14 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN PART 3 - SETTING AND REGIONAL CONTEXT
Context - Overview Ojibwe struggled over the possession of the wild Land Use Location rice waters , a struggle that eventually forced the Today, the region offers a wide variety of out- The Fertile Sand Hills (FSH) are located in the Sioux southwest across the Minnesota River. door recreation activities including: forests and northwest Minnesota in southcentral Polk Coun- lakes, paved trails for biking, hiking, golfing, ty. The Northwest region of Minnesota is also Settlement bird-watching in a variety of habitats, fishing home to Kittson, Roseau, Lake of the Woods, Early settlers in the northwest region of Minne- charter trips, lake and river fishing. Other cultur- Marshall, Pennington, Red Lake, Clearwater, sota include people of French and Scandinavian al events that add tremendous value and diver- Beltrami, Norman, Mahnomen, Clay, and Wilkin descent.2 In 1858, the number of settlers in the sity to the region include music festivals, theater counties. Home to over 200,000 Minnesotans, Minnesota region had made it possible to enter performances, and heritage festivals. Lastly, this region is known for its agricultural produc- the Union as a state. With little to no settlement winter activities are crucial to the versatility of tion, manufacturing, and healthcare sectors as in the upper northwestern area of the state, the region and include snowmobiling, ice fishing, well as a diversity of outdoor recreation and the 1862 Homestead Act became key in shifting skiing and more. Agricultural land use drives the tourism offerings. settling patterns in the state. The Homestead Act majority of the economy in Polk County. The Polk provided settlers with an allowable 160 acres of County Agricultural Profile, published in 2013 Cultural History land free provided they build a home, improve by the Minnesota Department of Agriculture, The first people in the Red River Valley were an- and live on that land for five years. Additional showed the county leading in crop production, cestors of the American Indians, whose presence incentives could lead to increased acreage for soybeans, spring wheat, sugarbeets, dry edible dates backs 10,000 years. This estimate is based settlers. The ongoing land struggles between the beans, and barley.5 on findings at several archaeological sites with Sioux and Ojibwe eventually left the latter victo- either radiocarbon dates, or diagnostic artifacts rious over the region in 1863. The following year, The Watershed known from other parts of the continent to date a treaty was signed between the Chippewa and The Sand Hill River (Figure 16) is a tributary to that time period, known to archaeologists the US Government opening the land for settle- to the Red River of the North. Polk County is as the Paleoindian. Before the 1700s, various ment.3 The City of Fertile was platted on May 25, situated within the Red River of the North Basin American Indian Tribes inhabited today’s Polk 1887 under direction of Andrew Gilken, which Watershed, is host to unique lake/river basin soil County, and records before this time are scarce originally included 19 blocks with 239 lots and remnants from Glacial Lake Agassiz, These fertile and incomplete1. The first identified tribes to in- a public park. There are records of first settlers lake deposits provide rich, productive soils for habit the region were the Cree. The Ojibwe (also in the area dating back to 1879, when John S. agriculture in Polk County. Four major water- called Chippewa) also had a presence in the re- LaDue and his family arrived from Fertile, Iowa, sheds are predominant within the jurisdictional gion given the close relations and lineage among giving the area its name.4 boundaries of Polk County including: Red River the tribes. In the mid 1700s, the Sioux and the of the North-Grand Marais Creek, Red Lake River, 2 Ibid. 1 Holcombe, R.I. Maj. “History and Biography of Polk County 3 “An Early History of Fertile.” Robert Heckman. http://www. 5 “Polk County Agricultural Profile”. Minnesota Department Minnesota” http://umclibrary.crk.umn.edu/digitalprojects/polk2/His- cityoffertile.org/PDF/History/An%20Early%20History%20of%20Fertile. of Agriculture. 2013. http://www.mda.state.mn.us/food/business/ toryBiographyPolkCnty.pdf pdf agmktg-research/~/media/Files/food/business/countyprofiles/econ- 4 Ibid. rpt-polk.ashx
15 TALL GRASS ASPEN PARKLAND CONIFEROUS FOREST PRAIRIE GRASSLAND DECIDUOUS FOREST
Red River of the North-Sand Hill River and the Clearwater River Watersheds. Three other major watersheds have small acreage within the county including: Wild Rice, Snake, and Marsh Water- Figure 18: Tall grass aspen parkland sheds. The City of Fertile is part of the Red River of the North-Sand Hill River Watershed. With the only exception of Kittleson Creek, the Sand Hill River is predominantly unbranched as it crosses the land. Most of this land is low relief and used in agricultural production.6
Climate Fertile lies within the USDA’s zone 3b hardiness zone, the coldest of all the USDA garden zones Figure 19: Coniferous forest in the United States. This zone has the shortest growing window, with a last frost date of approx- imately May 15th and first frost date of Sep- tember 15th7. Average temperature lows dip to approximately 0⁰F in January and crest up around Figure 17: Biome Map of Minnesota 80⁰F in July and August.8 mulated created Lake Agassiz. While the lake Glacial Lake Agassiz drained in many directions, it helped shape the Dating back to the ice age, the climate was colder Minnesota River Valley, later creating an outlet Figure 20: Praire and glacial ice covered a large portion of North river draining south, Glacial River Warren. The America. During the most recent glaciation peri- last change in drainage occurred 8,500 years ago 9 od, the Wisconsin Glaciation, portions of glacial when it shifted to the Hudson Bay . ice were pushed across Minnesota’s landscape. Minnesota Biomes When these glaciers melted, about 12,000 years ago, the meltwater that was trapped and accu- The northwest region of Minnesota is a diverse landscape, shaped by climatic events at the 6 “Polk County Local Water Plan”. West Polk Soil and withdrawal of the last ice age and is home today Water Conservation District. http://westpolkswcd.com/up- loads/3/5/5/7/3557851/waterplan_final_version.pdf 7 “USDA Plant Hardiness Zone map”/ USDA Agricultural 9 “Minnesota River Valley Formation”. Minnesota River Basin Research Service. http://planthardiness.ars.usda.gov/PHZMWeb/ Data Center. http://mrbdc.mnsu.edu/minnesota-river-valley-forma- 8 Data provided by energy design tool Climate Consultant. tion Figure 21: Deciduous forest
16 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN to a variety of unique plant communities at the Major post-secondary educational institutions and economic benefits to the community from intersection of three major biomes. Remnants include the University of Minnesota-Crookston visitation and increased public use. The purpose of aspen parkland, maple and basswood (decidu- and Northland Community Technical College of the AELC is to “foster a greater awareness ous) forests, and tallgrass prairie are the makeup (East Grand Forks) campuses. Other K-12 schools of the interrelationships between humans and of the region’s landscape today. Just to the east in Polk County include Climax-Shelly, Crookston, nature”. It has served the Fertile area providing the property is Minnesota's fourth biome, the East Grand Forks, Fertile-Beltrami, Fisher, Foss- environmental programs for adults and students coniferous forest (Figures 17-21). ton, Win-E-Mac, Riverside Christian School, and of all ages year-round. Sacred Heart. Major recreational parks in Polk County include Context - Regional Setting Polk County has a unique history with the water- the Glacial Ridge National Wildlife and Rydell shed it manages leading governments to creat- National Wildlife refuges. Other parks and rec- With a population of just under 32,000, Polk ing two Soil and Water Conservation Districts reational areas within Polk County include Polk County is recognized as an agriculturally-based (SWCD). “SWCDs are local units of government County Park, Cross Lake-Tilberg Park, Roadside county producing spring wheat, dry beans, and that manage and direct natural resource manage- Park, East Shore, and Agassiz Recreational Trail, sugar beets. The county is home to a range of ment programs at the local level. Districts work and several recreational lakes. Scientific and Nat- industries and institutions. In 2014, the Univer- in both urban and rural settings, with landowners ural Areas (SNA) close to Fertile include the Agas- sity of Minnesota Extension published findings and with other units of government, to carry out siz Dunes SNA and the Prairie Smoke Dunes SNA, of an economic analysis of the Northwest region a program for the conservation, use, and devel- where research is conducted on a daily basis. of Minnesota and looked at industry outputs, opment of soil, water, and related resources.” While none of the assets listed above operate as employment and wages, and interdependencies. a designated regional park they help situate the Among their key findings were three primary in- Fertile Sand Hills within a broader network of dustries driving the economy: agriculture, manu- Context - Parks and Trails natural areas that provide residents and visitors 10 facturing, and wholesale trade. Major industries with a wealth of natural resources and ample in Polk County include two American Crystal Sug- The FSH is host to a wide range of activities for space for outdoor recreation. If collectively en- ar Company processing plants. Top employers in local residents, the greater Fertile community, gaged, programmed and marketed this regional Polk County include RiverView Health, New Flyer and regional/statewide outdoor enthusiasts. network could become a state asset that attract a of America, UMN Crookston Campus, Crookston Owned by the city the FSH is also home to the wider range of users. Public schools, and the city of Crookston. 11 Agassiz Environmental Learning Center (AELC), a space dedicated to implement environmental Today, the FSH site and AELC programs serve education programs for people of all ages. Es- 10 “Economic Composition of Northwest Minnesota”. students from over a 100-mile radius (Figure 22), University of Minnesota Extension. September 2014. https://www. tablished in 1991, the AELC developed programs ranging from elementary to college who come to extension.umn.edu/community/economic-impact-analysis/reports/ that feature the diversity of the area which also docs/2014-Northwest-MN.pdf learn of the prairie, the sand hills, river studies 11 “Community Profile: Crookston, MN”. Prairie Business Mag- provide compatible recreation to raise aware- azine. January 11, 2010. http://www.prairiebusinessmagazine.com/ and the unique flora and fauna found at the site. news/3962709-community-profile-crookston-mn ness, appreciation, and support for the area—
17 Context - City of Fertile over 200 businesses registered, the Fertile com- munity is also very engaged in promoting well- Platted in 1887, the City of Fertile originally ness, environmental education, and community included 19 blocks with 239 blocks and a public resilience. Among the most active organizations, park. Founded by Andrew Gilken, Fertile’s first the University of Minnesota Extension and the settlers in the area date back to 1879 when John Fertile-Beltrami School District have pioneered S. LaDue and his family arrived from Fertile, efforts and programs engaging residents of all Iowa, giving the city its name. With fur trading as ages. The Fertile 4-H Club and the Fertile Early one of the main trade activities in the late 1880s, Childhood Initiative are a few examples of groups Fertile was founded along the Sand Hill River on developed within these broader organizations. a beach ridge of Glacial Lake Agassiz, near the Pembina oxcart trade trail. The area is the largest The Fertile-Beltrami Public School has a K-12 en- sand dune complex in Minnesota associated with rollment of 460 students and is key in positioning Glacial Lake Agassiz. students within the larger Fertile area by pro- viding environmental education opportunities. In 1976, the City of Fertile acquired the Fertile Many of the initiatives in place at this time range Sand Hills as part of the U.S. Bicentennial Cele- from after-school programs to technology-based bration. The 640 acre site, located less than one learning experiences. The Early Childhood Ini- mile west of the City of Fertile, has served as a tiative is managed and developed through the source of wellness, recreation, and environmen- Fertile-Beltrami School and has as its mission: tal education for Fertile and the broader commu- “Enriching lives of young children birth to five Figure 22: Statewide context map nity. The site features a diverse group of eco- and their families and caregivers through liter- With over 12 miles of trails, the FSH provides systems, allowing locals to traverse through the acy, quality childcare and family support. If we opportunities for hiking, bird watching, geo-cach- Sand Hills and learn about Minnesota biomes as are concerned about the future of our commu- ing, cross-country skiing, and snowshoeing. With they hike. A wilderness sanctuary of its own, the nity, we need to make long-term investments in initial assistance by the Minnesota Conservation Fertile Sand Hills’ biomes include dry sand prai- our youngest community members by nurturing Corp and ongoing tree clearing by local user, rie, dry sand and bur oak savanna, sand dunes, them right from the beginning. Our investments the Sand Hill River through Fertile has become a oak/aspen woods, and riverine forests situated pay off in lower crime rates, less need for public popular kayaking corridor. An emerging mountain along the Sand Hill River. assistance, better public schools, and better lives bike trail system is being developed by local users for families. We all benefit when our youngest on site between the Sand Hill River and the City As of 2016, the population in Fertile was of 842 citizens thrive, growing into adults who can give of Fertile. Horseback and snowmobile trails also residents and, according to the U.S. Census Bu- back to their communities.” Some of their com- pass through the site, engaging members of the reau, the city has a land area of 2.13 mi2. With pleted projects include acquiring funding for the broader Fertile area and region.
18 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN early childhood playground equipment and sup- flooding. Historically, the activities of the RR- WMB have centered on flood control. porting the construction of a natural play-space. WMB have centered on flood control. Most recently, the ECI successfully raised funds Along with the University of Minnesota Crook- to build a splash pad at J.D. Mason Park. ston Campus holding courses in the Fertile Sand Hills, the University of Minnesota Extension in Along with the University of Minnesota Crook- Northwest Minnesota is also home to the West ston campus holding courses in the Fertile Sand Polk County 4-H Club. Originating in 1902, 4-H Hills, the University of Minnesota Extension in clubs engaged young adults teaching them about Northwest Minnesota is also home to the West farming, creating a network across states. Today, Polk County 4-H Club. Originating in 1902, 4-H 4-H clubs explore a wide range of professional clubs engaged young adults teaching them about fields, but many still related to farming. In the farming, creating a network across states. Today, past decade, opportunities have expanded within 4-H clubs explore a wide range of professional the 4-H clubs in Minnesota involving art, music, fields, but many still relate to farming. In the past communications, leadership, career develop- decade, opportunities have expanded within the ment, home improvement, and computer tech- 4-H clubs in Minnesota involving art, music, com- nology. munications, leadership, career development, home improvement, and computer technology. For over 100 years, Fertile has been the host of For over 100 years, Fertile has been the host of the Polk County Fair, one of the region’s most the Polk County Fair, one of the region’s most popular and longest running county fairs. Featur- popular and longest running county fairs. Featur- ing activities and exhibits for all ages, the Polk ing activities and exhibits for all ages, the Polk County Fair has an average attendance of 50,000 County Fair has an average attendance of 50,000 visitors each year. The Polk County Fair provides visitors each year. The Polk County Fair provides 4-H members with the opportunity to highlight 4-H members with the opportunity to highlight their experiences, project exhibits, animal shows, their experiences, project exhibits, animal shows, performances, etc. performances, etc. The Sand Hill River is one of the eight watershed The Sand Hill River is one of the eight watershed districts of the Red River Watershed Manage- districts of the Red River Watershed Manage- ment Board (RRWMB). The RRWMB was created ment Board (RRWMB). The RRWMB was created by an act of the Minnesota legislature in 1976 by an act of the Minnesota legislature in 1976 to provide a basin-wide perspective concerning to provide a basin-wide perspective concerning flooding. Historically, the activities of the RR-
19 Figure 23: 20 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN PART 4 - SITE INFORMATION The Fertile Sand Hills (FSH) a 640 acre natural area managed by the City of Fertile. The City of Fertile purchased a 640 acre tract (Figure 24) of land known as the FSH as part of the 1976 U.S. Bicentennial Celebration. It features a unique diversity of ecosystems including oak savanna, dry sand prairie, sand dunes, poplar forest and a riverine corridor. The FSH is located just over one mile west of the city of Fertile and adja- cent to the Sandhill River Golf Course. The Sand Hill River crosses the FSH, flowing west from the southeast border with the golf course to the northwest boundary of the City’s property. Bordered by private property and farmland, the sand dunes that form part of the FSH is identified by the Nature Conservancy as regionally signifi- cant landscape.12 The Agassiz Dunes Scientific and Natural Area is located just under 3 miles south of the FSH. The Agassiz Dunes was designated a Scientific and Natural Area in 1981, after all the land was acquired into the preserve by the area farmers. Visitors to the site include researchers, faculty, and students, including groups from the UMN Itasca Biological Station. Between the city land and the preserve is 240 acres of private land that the owner has registered with The Nature Conservancy. 13 12 “Minnesota, Agassiz Dunes Scientific and Natural Area”. The Nature Conservancy. https://www.nature.org/ourinitiatives/ regions/northamerica/unitedstates/minnesota/placesweprotect/ agassiz-dunes-scientific-and-natural-area.xml 13 Ibid. Figure 23: Fertile Parcel Identification 21 Figure 25: Fertile Sand Hills creek in Winter 22 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN PART 5 - VISION, TRENDS, AND PUBLIC VALUES Demographic information Recreational trends information amenities for both local and visiting users. In 2009, the population of Northwest Minneso- According to a 2004 statewide recreation partic- ta (Figure 26) was approximately 448,000 peo- ipation studies, the outdoor recreation activities Public health values ple (approximately 9% of the total state). The that Northwest residents most frequently partici- Good health and healthy habits begin in our University of Minnesota’s Center for Changing pate in are walking or hiking, picnicking, boating, homes, schools, workplaces, neighborhoods, Landscapes predicts that by the year 2035 the swimming and driving for pleasure, which par- and communities. We know that taking care region’s population will have grown by 17%. allel statewide participation figures. However, of ourselves by eating well and staying active, All of the counties in the region have a greater Northwest Region residents are more likely to and avioding tobacco and vaping products are proportion of older residents (residents 65 years participate in hunting, all-terrain vehicle driving, all critical factors that influence our health. In of age or older) and have a smaller proportion and snowmobiling than other residents from addition to our personal habits, we also know of younger residents (residents under 18 years across the state. In addition nature observation, that our health is in part socially determined. of age) than the state overall. The general pro- visiting nature centers, golfing, and playing out- Access to social and economic opportunities; the portion of female residents in the region is 50.2 door sports also showed relatively high regional resources and supports available in our homes, percent (this proportion is consistent across the and statewide participation (approximately 20% neighborhoods, and communities; the quality of state). 14 or higher).15 our schooling; the safety of our workplaces; the cleanliness of our water, food, and air; and the It is important to offer a wide range of activi- nature of our social interactions and relation- 14 “ Minnesota’s Network of Parks and Trails” University of ties for various audiences. Demographic trends ships are all factors that contribute to the overall and recent engagement throughout Polk Coun- health of people and places.16 ty Public Health reveal that providing outdoor recreational opportunities that support aging The Fertile Sand Hills are an important local and populations is a critical component of meeting regional public health asset. Public access to the existing demographic profile of the re- safe natural places where people can play, learn, gion. Attracting visitors from Fargo/Moorhead, and relax not only directly increases physical Grand Forks, Thief River Falls, Crookston and activity, but they can also teach us about systems audiences further afield such as the Twin Cities attached to proper nutrition and create social requires providing active outdoor opportunities networks that are more supportive of healthy for younger audiences as well as family oriented lifestyles. The FSH public trail network and Agas- siz Environmental Learning Center already pro- Minnesota Center for Changing Landscapes. January 2011. https:// www.changinglandscapes.umn.edu/sites/changinglandscapes.umn. vide many of these opportunities. Improvements edu/files/Northwest_Profile_2011.pdf 15 Kelly, T. (2005a). 2004 Outdoor recreation participation 16 Rudolph, L., Caplan, J., Ben-Moshe, K., & Dillon, L. (2013). survey of Minnesotans: Report on findings. Saint Paul, MN: Minnesota Health in All Policies: A Guide for State and Local Governments. Wash- Figure 26: Regional Profile Map Department of Natural Resources, Office of Management and Budget ington, DC and Oakland, CA: American Public Health Association and Services. Public Health Institute. 23 identified through this plan are intended to not Given the region’s aging demographic profile, only increase the kinds and frequency of physical and the public health challenges observed due activities supported by the FSH, but to also make to increasingly sedentary lifestyles, one of the these healthy activities accessible to segments of clearest opportunities to increase visitor use the community that are often socially excluded. and to identify financial partnerships is to align Direct physical improvements include provid- the physical improvements and programming of ing an accessible trail loop, improving public the Fertile Sand Hills to improve public health. bathroom facilities, adding signage that is easily Ensuring that public and private health providers interperetted by the general public, and adding have accurate information about the amenities, rest areas along extended trail loops. Direct eco- programming, and public health benefits of the logical improvements include increasing critical FSH is a priority. conservation areas, increasing access to ecologi- cally important zones, and strengthening ecolog- Building on the economic opportunity of public ical education. Indirect economic improvements health partnerships is the direct and indirect will include increased local spending and visitor revenue opportunity attached to nature-based purchases, and the development of new full-time tourism. All of the major outdoor recreational staff positions that support healthy living wages. activities can be found in the City of Fertile and the Fertile Sand Hills. Of particular note are the Additional Public Health efforts will focus on fish passage projects recently completed with strengthening partnerships within Polk County the Sand Hill River Watershed District that are and creating new regional partnerships that will helping to facilitate the repopulation of game- support more frequent, and diversified use of the fish in the Sand Hill River-- as fishing is identified FSH. as the leading nature-based tourism activity in the region. River maintenance projects done in Economic development/tourism opportu- collaboration with the Department of Natural Re- sources to enhance the use of the Sand Hill River nities for kayaking and other water play activities. The Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development identifies that the sec- ond largest employment segment in the region is that of health care and social assistance.17 17 “Economic Development Region 1: Northwest, 2017 Re- gional Profile.” DEED Labor Market Information Office. August 1, 2017. https://mn.gov/deed/assets/rp_edr1_2017_tcm1045-216551.pdf 24 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN PART 6 - REGIONAL SIGNIFIGANCE STATEMENT The Fertile Sand Hills (FSH) and the Agassiz Envi- ronmental Learning Center (AELC) are a cluster of ecological, educational, and recreational assets for communities in Northwest Minnesota to use, to learn from, and to conserve. The FSH hosts a range of nature experiences (Figures 27-32) within its aspen parkland,s maple and basswood forests, and tallgrass prairies. Also within the sand hill area there are rare sand dune forma- Figure 27: Horseback Riding Figure 28: Winter Survival Training tions as well as diverse ravine ecologies support- ed by the Sand Hill River. Existing hiking, biking, skiing and horseback riding trails allows users to accessthese natural assets and programming from the AELC allows our communities to learn abou the value of these kinds of increasingly rare natural places. The FSH and AELC are located in county with only state recreation area and no parks of re- gional discinction. It is a diverse place uniquely positioned between several conservation prairie Figure 29: Kayaking areas that make it both an incredibly valuable Figure 30: Community Education foraseet for recreation as well as an incredibly valuable to place to conserve. Bcoming a Park of Regional Distinction will the FSH balance these different intrests and will insure that our com- munities access to this place for generations to come. Figure 31: Outdoor and Nature Play Figure 32: Cross Country SKiing 25 Figure 33: Community Walk through Death Valley, April 2018 26 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN PART 7 - PUBLIC INPUT AND PARTICIPATION The Fertile Sand Hills master planning process year round would produce a significant risk to tion and participants discussed the future of the included an extensive community participation the ecosystem as well as diminish the quiet expe- Sand Hills at the Sand Hills. Each workshop had component that offered a range of opportunities rience that those visiting the FSH currently enjoy. a planned activity to help guide conversation and for community members (Figure 33) to contrib- The group of community members advocating generate ideas. Workshop/cook times and topic ute ideas and/or address concerns regarding the for ATV use saw it as an opportunity to generate themes were advertised in the community paper, current and future uses of the property. This revenue and to extend access to the Sand Hills on the radio and through social media. process included public outreach through an for those who are not physically able to engage it online blog, the City of Fertile and the Agassiz unassisted and argued that this revenue is need- Environmental Learning Center social media ed to support the extended maintenance and platforms, the local community paper The Fer- staff to keep the FSH operational. tile Journal, and on the local radio station KROX. In order to determine what was legally possible The team gathered public input through a series under the conditions of the original purchase of on-site design workshop/cookouts as well as agreement between the State and the City of through an online form that participants could Fertile, the Minnesota Department of Natural fill out if they were not able to attend the input Resources was contacted to advise on the envi- sessions in person. Below is a detailed summary ronmental impacts on the suggestions and ideas of the process and its findings. collected through the community input sessions. Summary of findings Community input and design workshop Two distinct groups within the community see process and findings the value of the Fertile Sand Hills in two very The master plan process was communicated different ways. The first of these groups focuses through an online blog, social media, and the on a minimal impact conservation agenda and local paper. The master plan team developed a improving trails and buildings to extend current strategy to gather general community input along uses and attract more, but similar, users. The three key topic areas; (1) Trails and Access; (2) second group focused on extending the use of Art and Education; and, (3) Public Health. Each the Sand Hills area to ATV and other motor vehi- of these topics became an area of community cle users. Depending on the input sessions, more focus at one of three design workshop/cookouts. of one group or another would be in attendance These cookouts were held from 5:00 – 8:00pm on but both groups were consistently engaged May 30th, June 6th, and June 13th 2018 at the throughout the public input sessions. Agassiz Environmental Learning Center building In general, the first group felt that opening the at the FSH. Dinner was provided by the planning Sand Hills to unrestricted motorized vehicle use committee to encourage community participa- 27 Figure 34: Community cookout and design workshop, June 2018 28 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Trails and Access Summary – May 30th, Key Community Conversation Points: 2018 • Signage is a primary concern. As it stands, current signage is not sufficient for those who do On May 30th, 2018 the Fertile Sand Hills Master not regularly use the Sand Hills to venture out onto the property without fear of getting lost. Planning team hosted the first of three commu- • Numerous people exchanged anecdotes about getting lost at the Sand Hills. nity engagement cookouts at the Nature Center • It was felt in general the better signage would enhance increased use of trails (birders, at the Fertile Sand Hills. Prior to the cookout, hikers, bikers, snowmobiles, cross-country skiing, kayaking, etc.), but Interpretive signage was the event was advertised in the Fertile Journal also discussed at length for two weeks, posted on both the City of Fertile • Apart from an accessible trail – the idea of adding more trails was not brought up as an and the Agassiz Environmental Learning Cen- option for increasing use. People seemed content with trail quantity – quality drove the ter’s (AELC) Facebook pages, and notices of the discussion. event was sent to AELC members. The event was • Distance markers and color coded “use” restriction signs are needed to control the mode of attended by 54 people and focused on gathering trail use in specific locations. community input on the design of Trails, Signage, • Adding a paved accessible trail loop received unanimous support by those in attendance and Access strategies for the master plan. From and is thought to increase access to all types of users, especially those with disabilities, aging 5:00-6:30 pm the team grilled for the communi- populations, and families with young children. ty and from 6:30-8:00 pm the discussion and a • Some argued that this should be made accessible to golf carts while others argued that this short design activity were facilitated to get the should have no motor use. community thinking about alternative futures • Accessible path should host interpretative signage and be used to support access to for the FSH. Everyone in attendance introduced educational programs. themselves to the group and stated their prima- • A large portion of those in attendance would like to see usage of the Sand Hills opened to ry interests or concerns with future uses of the ATVs and side-by-sides. Fertile Sand Hills. Notes from the meeting, as • This action is contested by those who are concerned with this user group misusing the Sand well design handout and survey documents, were Hills and damaging its sensitive ecologies. collected to record the community’s input. • It was noted in the opening comments that there is a restriction in the purchase agreement of the land prohibiting motorized use on the property; however, motorized vehicles (snowmobiles) are allowed limited access in the winter. • It was articulated by many that the Sand Hills need to develop a financial model that can support its maintenance and pay for permanent staff neededto facilitate the extended programming many were recommending. • Develop RV camping in the prairie • Camper cabins • More regular camping 29 • Equipment rents • Charge fees on high maintenance uses • More events like haunted trails • Extended educational programming • The conservation of the unique ecologies within the Fertile Sand Hills is critical – additional use of the Sand Hills should minimize the risks to these environmental assets. 30 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Art and Education Summary – June 6th, Key Community Conversation Points: 2018 • People engage (play, learn, use) nature differently today than they used to. Today’s social On June 6th, 2018 the Fertile Sand Hills Mas- norms do not extend opportunities for unstructured engagement with nature, particularly for ter Planning team hosted the second of three children. As a result, a lot of people (at multiple ages and demographics) simply do not have the community engagement cookouts at the Nature skills needed to engage nature (this is an opportunity). Center at the Fertile Sand Hills (Figure 34). Prior • Key to enhancing education is to develop funding strategies for both human assets (i.e. to the cookout, the event was advertised in the full time staff and part-time volunteers) as well as physical improvements and ecological Fertile Journal for two weeks, posted on both the maintenance. City of Fertile’s and the Agassiz Environmental • There are two broad kinds of educational programming: on-site and outreach. Learning Center’s (AELC) Facebook pages, and • On-site teaching is based on day programming that is run out of the AELC with short hikes to notices of the event was sent to AELC members. outdoor learning spaces. Transporting students to the site in the first place is a major expense The event was attended by 42 people and fo- and barrier for many schools. cused on gathering community input on Art and • Existing building needs improvement Education within the master plan. From 5:00- • The main meeting/teaching space needs to be separate from the public space. 6:30 pm the team grilled for the community and • Bathroom facilities from 6:30-8:00 there was a discussion centered • Parking and Bus turn around around a set of questions that got the commu- • Deck needs to be fixed nity thinking about alternative futures for the • Bigger and safer Fire Pit Fertile Sand Hills. People worked in small groups • Extended educational buildings could both extend existing day programming into different that formed around a particular “user group” to parts of the Sand Hills as well as extend it to overnight programming. which they thought about improvements to the • New buildings and/or educational sites could be built “from nature” – didactic and in support Fertile Sand Hills. Notes from the meeting were of education. collected to record the community’s input. • Sited to integrate w/ nature. • Improvements need to be flexible (portable/adaptable) • Shade/picnic pavilions, winter camping (10x10-15x15), learning kiosks, benches, etc. • There need to be opportunities for unstructured exploration. People learn and explore in different ways, some people watch (indirect) some people need to touch (direct). Quiet reflective learning is also very important. • Provide signage that describes what is happening – nature is a great teaching tool if you could communicate what is going on. • Increase accessibility – Hard-surfaced low impact trails, get the van back out, electric golf carts, etc. 31 • Increase access to the river • Learn from active management of the Sand Hills • Prairie burns, sand dune restoration, river clearing / fish ladders, trail grooming • Camping is a great opportunity to learn about nature • There could be more summer camping near the AELC, no hotel in Fertile. • Programming ideas • Youth • Reach kids at a younger age • Art + science (entomology and astronomy) • Teach gateway activities that encourage other outdoor activities • Making programming more attractive for parents / co-programming? • Young Adult • Basic skills training like survival, archery, fishing, trapping, etc. • Specialist skills training like cold weather survival, settler skills. • Shelter/bridge building • Community service opportunities • Artist in Residence • Develop a program to teach regional crafts (North House Folk School). • Having a rotating artist in resident would keep people coming back and generate sustained revenue. • Engage older generations to get back into nature • Sharing experiences and telling stories • Teaching skills to youths • Academic Institutions • Research/land management collaborations • Research/writing residencies 32 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Public Health Summary – June 13th, 2018 Key Community Conversation Points: On June 13th, 2018 the Fertile Sand Hills Master • Nature plays a key role in our health. This is true for our physical health by affording us Planning team hosted the final of three commu- opportunities to be active, to spend time outside in the fresh air, and to eat healthy foods. nity engagement cookouts at the Nature Center This is also true for our mental health by affording quiet reflective space and wonderfully at the Fertile Sand Hills. Prior to the cookout, complex views to admire and contemplate. For both our physical and mental health, no single the event was advertised in the Fertile Journal environment or activity for everyone and thus everyone should have the opportunity to define for two weeks, posted on both the City of Fer- their own relationship to nature. tile’s and the Agassiz Environmental Learning • For the Fertile Sand Hills to be a true public health asset to its community it needs to Center’s (AELC) Facebook pages, and notices of sustain a wide range of adaptable use patterns that do not diminish the experience of others to the event was sent to AELC members. The event simultaneous use the land. It is also critical that the Sand Hills not be used in ways that increase was attended by 20 people and focused on gath- the risk of future generations from not being able to take advantage of this public health asset. ering community input on the role the Fertile • Multiple use options and activities Sand Hills could play in Public Health within the • Everyone is different and enjoys using nature in different ways. The more activities available master plan. From 5:00-6:30 pm the team grilled the better. for the community and from 6:30-8:00 there was • That said, without improved access and signage increasing the kinds of use at the Sand Hills a discussion centered around a set of scenarios will only add more confusion and conflict. that got the community thinking about alter- • These activities need to be age and skill level appropriate – ideally multiple kinds of native futures for the Fertile Sand Hills. People experiences for each use. worked in small groups centered around each • Family friendly activities scenario and then thought about how the Fertile • Cooking and Eating together Sand Hills could positively affect their situation. • Having picnic pavilions and places for people to cook and eat together helps with mental Notes from the meeting were collected to record health because it brings families together. the community’s input. (see appendix for ques- • These facilities should be fully accessible tions) • More camping • Also a great family activity • Different levels of ruggedness • Increase accessibility – Hard-surfaced low impact trails, golf carts, river access, etc. • Signage and Information • Better signage on trails (distance, difficulty, educational, wayfinding, etc.) • Better information about the Fertile Sand Hills online (website, social media) • People need to know what they can do at the FSH and if it matches their need, not knowing is a turn-off. 33 • Mental health opportunities Scenario Example • Many health conversations focus on physical activity, but mental health is just as important. • Quiet reflective places to hike, enjoy a view, etc. are critical. One of the scenario teams developed a venture • Working together – do not default to zero-sum thinking idea based on using ATVs and/or golf carts to • Every group has an ideal context that they would like to operate within, if we do not work get senior citizens out of nursing homes and together there will be winners and losers – we can work creatively together to compromise and into the Sand Hills. The concept was based on avoid people completely losing out. a ride-sharing concept and leveraged required • Integrate Technology high-school volunteer hours with the desire of • Today people are increasingly dependent on technology. We can leverage more interactive nursing home occupants to access the Fertile technological experiences to get young generations exposed to nature. Sand Hills. This has the added cultural benefit • We can synch digital information to physical signage to minimize signage costs and to create of putting two different generations into direct more easily updatable interpretative experiences. communication with each other to share values • Align or partner with other interests to be co-supportive and knowledge. The large group attached En- • Farmers markets, seasonal craft/art fairs, corporate outings, etc. glish and Science coursework idea to this experi- • People already travel to these activities and having the added benefit of being in a beautiful ence so that the knowledge exchanged through setting would only help them while simultaneously exposing a lot of new users to the FSH. these interactions would be recorded in some way. This an example where differing community positions converged in a limited way to meet the public health needs of the broader community through a creative programming and usage de- sign at the Fertile Sand Hills. 34 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Areas of Conflict Conclusions tions, and families with young children. Since this trail will be fully accessible, it should have The Primary area of conflict centered around Over the course of the three community input interpretative signage and connect to key educa- the proposed new use of ATVs at the Fertile sessions several key concerns and ideas were tional program areas. Sand Hills. It was stated that under the original settled on. purchase terms no motor vehicles where allowed on the property but the documentation of this Signage was ambiguous. The MN DNR was brought into The most consistent concern by community consult on the environmental impact of the pro- members centered around signage. It was felt duced new uses and physical improvements. that the Sand Hills are an amazing resource on their own and that the single most useful im- It was agreed upon that the FSH would follow provement would be to redesign the way finding the MN DNR guidelines for OTHER POWER-DRIV- and interpretative signage systems. As it stands, EN MOTORIZED VEHICLES (OPDMV) within the current signage is not sufficient for those who do Fertile Sand Hills to ensure that accessibility is not regularly use the Sand Hills to venture out maximized with minimal negative impact critical onto the property without fear of getting lost. It natural resources. Proposed policy is outlined was also felt that in general the better signage design section. would result in increased use of trails (birders, hikers, bikers, snow mobiles, cross-country ski- ing, kayaking, etc.), and that Interpretive sig- nage would help those who use the trails better understand the uniqueness of the Sand Hills. Information to be included on the trail should include key distances, times of travel, Key plan maps identifying “you are here”, type of use al- lowed on travel, difficulty of trail, trail name, and key interpretative information. Accessible Trail Loop Adding a hard surfaced accessible trail loop came up at each session and was thought to increase access to the Sand Hills to all types of users, especially those with disabilities, aging popula- 35 Master Plan Project List 13 11 projects not indicated on the map are spread throughout the entire Fertile Sand Hills Property** 16 12 14 *Upper Campus Site and the RV/Camp Site are both Future 5 recommended but require more detailed design* Upper Campus 2 Signage 1 - Wayfinding 8 2 - AELC Campus Signage 3 - Interpreta�ve Signage 1 4 - Interpreta�ve Signage 2 Future Accessibility 6 RV/Camp 5 - River Trail Outdoor Recrea�onal Access Route Site 6 - Sand Hills Outdoor Recrea�onal Access Route 7 7 - Improved Van Access along Perimeter 8 - Accessible River Access 15 9 - Informa�on Plan 10 - Motorized Vehicle Access Policy Facility an Groun s Im rovements 11 - The Deck 12 - Exis�ng Visitor Center Phase 1 13 - The Bridge 14 - Exis�ng Visitor Center Phase 2 15 - Remote Support Buildings 16 - Camper Cabins 17 - Property Maintenance Maintenance an Management 18 - Sand Dune Management Plan 19 - Prairie Management Plan 20 - Sand Hill River Management Plan 21 - Buckthorn Management Plan 22 - Bike Area Restora�on Plan 23 - Regula�ons Enforcement Policy Figure 34: Master Plan Project for Fertile Sands Hills 36 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN PART 8 - DESIGN Planning Statement Through input from community workshops and implemented. Section 2 & 3 provide only design ongoing planning conversations with regional outlines and general locations of improvements The design of the phyiscal Master Plan for the land managers, county and state officials, and are intended to be further development Fertile Sand Hills (FSH) focuses on increasing and accessibility experts, the Master Plan has in the future with additional funding and in access to this unique ecological and recreational established a set of priority areas to focus on response to the implementation of Section 1. resource and providing improvements that and lays out a set of near, mid, and long-term connect all users to this environment (Figure 34). improvement projects to help guide the City of The design sets out to develop a vision that will Fertile in reaching its goals. These priority areas help transform the Fertile Sand Hills strategically include signage, accessibility, facility and grounds into a world-class park system. The plan carefully improvements, and ecological restoration and balances the Agassiz Environmental Learning maintenance. Center’s mission to foster a greater awareness of the interrelationships between humans Plan Organization and Implementation and nature with the City of Fertile’s continued commitment to conserve this landscape for The design is organized into three sections. long-time recreational use by local, regional, and Section one is the most detailed and contains global communities. the largest number of projects. It organizes all of the near-term, small-scaled improvements Regionally, the Fertile Sand Hills is a key that were identified and prioritized through the connective landscape that helps link a network of community engagement sessions to ensure safe prairie, oak savanna, dry sand prairie, and natural use and increased access the FSH. Section two sand dune protected areas together including the proposes a long-term transition of the Agassiz Glacial Ridge National Wildlife Refuge, the Rydell Environmental Learning Center campus away National Wildlife Refuge, the Agassiz Dunes SNA from its current location adjacent to the Sand properties, and the Prairie Smoke Dunes SNA. Hill River toward an upper campus located on the This plan seeks to leverage both the ecological ridge west of its current location. Section three value of the Fertile Sand Hills to these other proposes the long-term development of the open protected landscapes as well as the collective prairie area south of Summit Ave toward an RV value that this network of preserved prairie/dune and tent camping facility. This development places provides as a regional amenity to attract will support the increased use of the FSH and to an extended group of users to the Fertile Sand help generate review to support the increased Hills. maintenance costs of the property once the improvements from Sections 1 and 2 have been 37 Part 8.1 - Design Plan Section 1 Design Section 1 ‐ Implementation and Budgect Schedule 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Project Signage Wayfinding $15,000 $15,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 AELC Campus Signage $25,000 $25,000 $25,000 $25,000 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 Interpretative Signage 1 $2,000 $2,000 Interpretative Signage 2 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 Accessibility River Trail Outdoor Recreational Access Route $10,000 $10,000 Sand Hills Outdoor Recreational Access Route $5,000 $5,000 Improved Van Access along Perimeter $15,000 $15,000 Accessible River Access $15,000 $15,000 Information Plan $2,000 $2,000 Motorized Vehicle Access Policy Facility and Grounds Improvements The Deck $25,000 $25,000 Existing Visitor Center Phase 1 $3,000 The Bridge $25,000 $25,000 Existing Visitor Center Phase 2 $25,000 $25,000 Remote Support Buildings $10,000 $15,000 $15,000 $15,000 $15,000 Camper Cabins $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 Property Maintenance $2,000 $2,000 $3,000 $3,000 $3,000 $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 $7,000 $7,000 $7,000 Maintenance and Management Sand Dune Management Plan $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 Prairie Management Plan $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 Sand Hill River Management Plan $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 Buckthorn Management Plan $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 Bike Area Restoration Plan $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 Regulations Enforcement Policy $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 Annual Totals $85,000 $127,000 $145,000 $165,000 $135,000 $32,500 $17,500 $17,500 $19,500 $19,500 $19,500 $783,000 Figure 35: Plan Implementation, Budget, and Maintenance Chart 38 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Master Plan Project List 11 projects not indicated on the map are spread throughout the entire Fertile Sand Hills Property** *Upper Campus Site and the RV/Camp Site are both recommended but require more detailed design* 5 2 Signage 1 - Wayfinding 12 14 2 - AELC Campus Signage 3 - Interpreta�ve Signage 1 4 - Interpreta�ve Signage 2 Accessibility 2 5 - River Trail Outdoor Recrea�onal Access Route 6 - Sand Hills Outdoor Recrea�onal Access Route 7 - Improved Van Access along Perimeter 8 - Accessible River Access 8 9 - Informa�on Plan 10 - Motorized Vehicle Access Policy Facility an Groun s Im rovements 11 - The Deck 12 - Exis�ng Visitor Center Phase 1 13 - The Bridge 14 - Exis�ng Visitor Center Phase 2 15 - Remote Support Buildings 16 - Camper Cabins 17 - Property Maintenance Maintenance an Management 18 - Sand Dune Management Plan 19 - Prairie Management Plan 20 - Sand Hill River Management Plan 21 - Buckthorn Management Plan 22 - Bike Area Restora�on Plan 23 - Regula�ons Enforcement Policy Figure 36: Physical Masterplan - Enlargemnt at Agassiz Environmental Learning Center 39 Figure 37: Planning team waklking the property with accessibility spacialist Corey Birkholz 40 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Signage and Accessibility Projects Given the unique beauty of this landscape, the Fertile Sand Hills Trail Signage Concept community, planning team, and our accessibility consultant identified that improving communication and wayfinding is the highest priority improvement for the master plan. It speaks volumes of the property that improving the ways people learn about it and then better understand where and how 120 mm 300 mm 1200 mm Site Information Biking Rules Tiger Beetle Habitat Fertile Sand Hills Recreation Area FERTILE SAND HILLS RECREATION AREA FERTILE SAND HILLS RECREATION AREA to use it, eclipses any kind of natural or physical ŝƚLJŽĨ&ĞƌƟůĞ Site Name ŝƚLJŽĨ&ĞƌƟůĞ City of Fertile For information on other sites within the Fertile Sand 37 Hills Recreation Area, refer to the park folder or call xxx-xxx-xxxx Dus. Os doluptaturit quam 15 mph max. speed limit aut o c temolorrunt atur Bell/horn/whistle required; Do Not Disturb Sound it within 100 feet rem facia voluptatur, temolup when passing taspero exerit aped quatesci Ride single le con possequ osantist ut Stay right except to pass 600 mm quiatest, occae. Bus. 300 mm Yield to pedestrians/horses Agassiz Environmental Ihilluptate nonsequat improvement to the property. The key challenge Local helmet laws apply Image apicaborum autecat ectius voloratinum qui dolorunt et, etur? Ibus audisque aut moluptas Learning Center Trail Regulations Fertile Sand Hills FERTILE SAND HILLS RECREATION AREA FERTILE SAND HILLS RECREATION AREA ŝƚLJŽĨ&ĞƌƟůĞ Trail Name ŝƚLJŽĨ&ĞƌƟůĞ Recreation Area to this issue is also the Sand Hills’ greatest asset For information on other trails within the Fertile Sand Image Hills Recreation Area, refer to the park folder or call xxx-xxx-xxxx Activities allowed on trail. Agassiz Environmental .2 miles Learning Center Activities prohibited on trail. - its unique terrain and distinctive biomes. This Death Valley #1 .7 miles landscape makes it easy for users to get lost and because so many of the ecological interactions that people find throughout the property are rare and spark curiosity in the user, wayfinding information needs to be carefully placed and different kinds of information strategically deployed. Design Section 1 of this plan establishes 4 near-term signage Figure 38: Signage Design Guide projects: 1. Wayfinding 2. AELC Campus Signage 3. Interpretative Signage 1 4. Interpretative Signage 2 Trail Marker One or Two-Sided Sign (Trailhead/Facility info) - Trail Iden�fier Side One 41 - Distance to N.C. - Rules + Regula�ons - Difficulty - Community Pos�ngs - Des�na�ons Side Two (trail head) - Ecological/Historical Info - Key plan (you are here) Side Two (Info) - Supplimental informa�on Sign Project 1 - Wayfinding expressed that they would use the trail system be referenced for detailed sign design and con- more if they understood more about the charac- struction). The wayfinding system contains the Timeframe: 1-2 years teristics and difficulty of the existing trail system. following sign types: Budget: $30,000 ($1,000 annual upkeep there This plan provides guidelines for an affordable The way-finding system contains the following after) wayfinding system that can be implemented im- sign types: mediately and continuously enhanced over time. Many existing users expressed difficulty in nav- The system uses the National Park Services Uni 1. Trailhead igating the property and suggested that they Guide standards to determine user icons, fonts, 2. Trail Regulations would use the property more often if there signage layouts, and sign sizes ( the UniGuide 3. Key Plans/Map was not the concern of getting lost. Others standard is attached as an appendix and should 4. Informational Signs 5. Posted Trail Use Signs Warning Biking Rules Fertile Sand Hills Trail Regulations FERTILE SAND HILLS RECREATION AREA FERTILE SAND HILLS RECREATION AREA City of Fer�le Recreation Area City of Fer�le Trail Name 6. Distance/Time Markers 37 37 For information on other trails within the Fertile Sand Hills Recreation Area, refer to the park folder or call xxx-xxx-xxxx 15 mph max. speed limit Activities allowed on trail. Hikers Stay on Path; 150mm Agassiz Environmental .2 miles habitat restoration in Bell/horn/whistle required; Learning Center Sound it within 100 feet process. when passing Key information contained with these signs in- Activities prohibited on trail. Ride single file Stay right except to pass 300mm Yield to pedestrians/horses Death Valley #1 .7 miles cludes: Local helmet laws apply a) Trail distances and time of travel 150mm 300mm b) Trail slopes c) Critical accessibility information Trail Information FERTILE SAND HILLS RECREATION AREA City of Fer�le Trail Name d) Trail difficulty rating For information on other trails within the Fertile Sand Hills Recreation Area, refer to the park folder or call xxx-xxx-xxxx Activities allowed on trail. e) Maps – key plans Activities prohibited on trail. f) Key attractions/Sand Hills natural history info g) User regulations and rules h) Trail use restrictions 600mm Trail Map 300mm Trail Signage Figure 39: Trail Signage Design Guide 42 FERTILE SAND HILLS MASTER PLAN Signage Project 2 - AELC Campus Signage procedures, Fertile Sand Hills trail system, and In addition to general signage, the plan also rec- will generally help to organize the grounds and ommends that three large welcome signs be pro- Timeframe: 2-5 years provide guidance to users. vided; one for the Fertile Sand Hills Recreation Budget: $10,000 ($500 annual upkeep there Area, one for the Agassiz Environmental Learning after) This campus signage package includes the follow- Center, and one for the Visitor Center. These ing kinds of signs: three signs should be consistent in their design and should reinforce to visitors the mission, the Beyond the immediate priority of improving the 1. General Parking – (near road, turnaround, regulations and rules of use, payment informa- overall quality of the Fertile Sand Hills wayfinding and camping sites) tion, and the geography of the property. As new system, the team identified improving the sig- 2. Accessible Parking (adjacent to existing buildings and other physical improvements are nage at the Agassiz Environmental Learning Cen- building, with directional info at the road) implemented, similar signage should be included ter campus as an additional near-term signage 3. User regulations and rules within their project scopes to further reinforce project. Improving the AELC signage will focus 4. Maps – key plans consistent messaging and branding. on communicating accessible parking and trail 5. Critical accessibility information access, AELC facility rules, restrictions, payment Fertile Sand Hills Recreation Area