RECORD PACKET COPY W3a
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
, . CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION FREMONT, SUITE 2000 N FRANCISCO. CA 94105- 2219 • VOICE AND TDD (415) 904- 5200 FAX ( 415) 904- 5400 RECORD PACKET COPY W3a TO: ALL COMMISSIONERS FROM: PETER DOUGLAS, EXECUTIVE SUBJECT: MINUTES OF MEETING OF MARCH 12-16,2001 Bahia Hotel 998 West Mission Bay Drive San Diego Monday, Marchl2, 20()lpagesJ to.7~5J ".,,//'''" '"'''''''"//,,',.. ''/ 1. CALL TO ORDER. The meeting ofth~CCalit§f~i<:J Coastal Commission was called to order on Monday, March 12, 2001, at 10 a.m. by Choirrnan .Wan. • 2. ROLL CALL Present: Ch~irnJ.an Wan, CommissionersDean, Desser, Dettloff, Estolano, Hart McCoy,. (Alternate) Orr, NeaL (Alternate) Rose and Woolley. Absent: Kruer and Sanders. McClain-Hill arrived at 11 :20 a.m.; Sweeney arrived at 11 :40 a.m.; and (Alternate) Weinstein arrivedqt 2:45p.m. YSOUTH COAST DISTillGT. ,:,;~g£ >3. OE~~TY DIRECTOR'S REPORT.. Deputy Director Lee reported on matters not requiriq~p~blic hearings,a8.d~h comments from the public. John Davis, representing Coalitiontg&gve the Marl(laSierra Club, submitted a request to speak. Sean Finnegan, representing s Group (Treasure Island), submitted a request to speak if necessary~.······· a. Long Beac:JlPgrfPian Amendment No. 15 Certification Review. Staff recommended apr:>roval. Robert Kanter, representing Port of Long Beach, submitted a request to answer • questions. ... Motion & Vote: Woolley moved staff recommendation, seconded by Orr, and • Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed. b. Request to file amendment number A-5-01-1 0-A (~:~~t-? Postponed. ,·,->;-::; 4. CONSENT CALENDAR (removed from RegHl~r. alendgr): .Stcl~·'f)l.Q... .three items {7d, 7e & 8b} to the Calendar, and recommendEiditt . LwithsR~~ .,i~QqitiQ '~- -::,w;;·' -- --e 2 Motion & Vote: Estolano moved staff recommenda 1 nded by Orr)1 &nai": Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous.~k -?:.t. 5. LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAMS (LCPs). a. Dana Point LCP Amendment N~. ~~OO(N~~:i~gnf~rming Signs) nme Extension. Staff recommended approval. ·····••·• '' ' ''. .;::::'1~:··. £2%: --~------- ' :- "':~./0?'-:.f:"'- :<<4£: ·::~' 1 Motion & Vote: Woolley moved staffr~eb;mmenadh~~~·ise~~p§~d by Orr, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimoUs. Passed~ ::\::~:~T;i:_,:_--=:': ~::::·_-:~<--- -: · : ;-~, 7 ~=t~-- >~: ::_-:>·~·;2·\:< .. ·:=:-:::=~;=:.:,:\"~-:.·: :·</ b. Long Beach Port Mast~.r .Plan AmendmenfNo~ 16. Staff recommended approval. ·:, .;F· .. • 7 Robert Kanter, rep;~s~h~ti~~;~prt of Long Beach, submitted a request to answer questions~ · ·· · · '-,;-' ';.~_;; Motion & Vote: u:::nTI~TT moved sta'fffecqmrnendation, seconded by McCoy, and Chairman Wan vote wds unanimous. Passed. NEW APPEALS. :•a: Application No. (Marina Pacific, Los Angeles Co.} Staff re2omrnended that the .d"8o1eorraised substantial issue. There being no objection, Chalrrnan W · mmission found substantial issue. Chairman Wan opened the merits of the project. Staff recommended approval with special con in addendum and orally. Alan Block, ting the applicant, submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. John Davis, representing Coalition to Save the Marina/Sierra Club, spoke.• James Morris, representing Coalition to Save the Marina, spoke in opposition to the MINUTES OF MARCH 12-16, 2001 PAGE2 ,. project. Barry Kurtz, representing County of Los Angeles Dept. of Public Works, submitted a request to speak. Three speakers representing L.A. County submitted requests to speak in favor of the project: Bob Fisher, Roger Moliere and Aaron Clark. • Motion & Vote: Desser moved staff recommendation, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed. McClain-Hill and Sweeney arrived during the following item. ·-; '' ,' b. Appeal No. A-5-01-8 (City of L.A. Dept. of Parks & Rec.) Staff recommeJ1ded that the appeal raised substantial issue. There being no objection, Chairman Wan ruled that the Commission found substantial issue. Chairman Wan opened the hearing on the merits of the project. Staff recommended approval with special conditions. Michael Bonin, representing Councilmember Ruth Galanter, spoke in favor of the project. Kathleen Chan, representing Rec. & Parks City of L.A., spoke in favor of the project. Jesse Martinez, representing Venice Skateboard Association, spoke in favor of the project. John Holtz spoke in favor of the project. Jimmy Hanson, representing Venice Skate Park, spoke in favor of the project. Scott Brown, representing Venice Skatepark, spoke in favor of the project. Heidi Lemmon, representing Venice SK8 PK, spoke in favor of the project. Tim Clark spoke in favor of the project. Dan Levy spoke in favor of the project. Geri Lewis, representing Venice Skateboard Association, spoke in favor of the project. Alex Romeno & Shoun Small, both representing Venice Skatepark, submitted requests to speak in favor of the project. John Davis, • representing Coalition to Save the Marina Sierra Club, spoke. Motion & Vote: McClain-Hill moved staff recommendation, seconded by Desser, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed. 7. COASTAL PERMIT APPLICATIONS. a. Application No. 5-00-50 (Long Beach, permit parking) Staff recommended approval with special conditions. Mark Sandoval, representing City of Long Beach, spoke in favor of the project. Doug Korthof spoke in opposition to the project. Motion & Vote: Orr moved staff recommendation, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed . • MINUTES OF MARCH 12-16,2001 PAGE3 b. Application No. 5-00-424 (Spriggs, San Clemente) Staff recommended .. approval with special conditions as modified in addendum deleting condition # 1. Michael Luna spoke representing the applicant. • Motion & Vote: Woolley moved staff recommendation, , and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Pa PUBLIC STATEMENTS. John Davis, representing requested enforcement actions against Los about the archaeological investigation of Hellm LUNCH RECESS. The Commission recessed for lun l :35 p.m. ,, ---·:_"'',.-, ,<,'·>;,_" c. Application No. 5-00-449 (Via uao CgmrruJ6lty, ~~~port Staff recommended approval with specialcqriditionsqs me(~"""'· <:>rally. -'><;,"'"' ''' ', :~:",'' '~;:: ' Three speakers, representing Lid c·:cor-prpunity As~oCiafiOn, submitted requests to speak in favor of the project: Hygh elm, d.i.tnSalomofrand Paul Wilkinson. Fifteen • speakers submitted requests .. to$g~ak in oppg~itionto.the project: George Bissell, Laurie Darnall, Bettina Laughlin Deininger, Philip deCespin8y,s~~ldon H. Dobkins, Paul Faranda, John M. Franco, Nancy Harris, Judithlongye~ar, Judy B. Rosener, Louise Shaver, Raymond 0. Vincenti; Elaine Weinberg, Martin B. Weinberg, and Paul Weinberg. ····· Motion & Vote: McClain-Hill mdV~(j ~tdffrecommendation, seconded by Dettloff, and Chqirmah Wan ruled thotJhe votewa~prfg,rg1mous in opposition to the motion. Failed. ,- ---~ '' ''0''--'• ':\.~ y \: n::z> ~~- -~li;:\~-:-j;,,-,,- ;:':>r••• ;~~;. d. Application N~.~~ilo;. 6 (Steffensen, Seal Beach} Moved to expanded ... a~t-.n Calendar. Appr~: ' '~ e~ ... ~pplifalion No. •467 (P.R.S., Dana Pt) Moved to expanded Consent Calendar: ApprQyed . .:/: • MINUTES OF MARCH 12-16, 2001 PAGE4 f. Application No. 5-00-484 (L.A. & Parks Dept. skating park) Staff • recommended approval with special conditions. The hearing was combined with item 6b above. Motion & Vote: McClain-Hill moved staff recommendation,. seconded by Desser, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed. g. Application No. 5-00-407 (Leeds, Los Angeles) __..;_ _..;..;~ ; ;.. _____ _ ::;;;;::-/: ;,;;;:'_, ___ :::T; :;::·:·: _ _-;-;,-.;,_ h. Application No. 5-99-260 (Marble Head, San Cl~.rri~nt~l Staff recom~~n ed denial. The presentation for the applicant included: Jim Johnson, David Kelley, Rod Meade, Claude Edwards, and Chris Webbrepres(7ntir;tg Moffatt & Nichol Engineers. Speakers supporting the project incJuded: Ri~kt\riderson; Mark Bazick; Cary Brockman representing Capistrano Unifie(::J SchooiDist.; Bill .Ccmkli.Q; Steve Craig; Charlotte Crockett; Jim Dahl representiQg City Council ofSan.Ciemente; Dorothy Klaasen; Roy Proctor; Mayor Sco.tt Diehl of San Clemente; .t.lorence Magill; Lucy Ahams representing San Clemente Senior Center; Dr Marilyn L. Ditty representing South County Sr. Servs.; Wayne Egglerton representing City CouncilotSan Clemente; Lillian Le • Cantore representing San Clemente Senior Center Grpup;tynn Wood representing San Clemente Chamber ofCommerce; Lewis Elia; peJia Frankel; Dorothy Fuller; Lynne M. Geyser; Adrienne Proctor; Marty Hoffman representing So. County Senior Svc; City Planner James B. Hare repre~enting £ity of San Clemente; Bruce Edwards; Mary Devereux; James C. Hill; Communityt)Eavelp Dir. Jim Holloway representing City of San Clemente; Sandy Condello representing San Clemente Womens Club; Carol Beasley; Peggytdcayo, Direc;torotSummefC()r)CertSeries; David Lund, Economic Devlpt & Pub Wks Director representing City of SbnCiemente; Frank H. White; Ruth Aldrich; Byron .. M(lrshall; Murray Ohren; r.:>Iane.Ledgerwood; Mike Parnesi, City Manager, City of San Clemente; Mary Campbell; ty\g'fie Hughes; Peter Rock; Ron Runolfson; David Steffensen; John Tengdin; ~olliony Wood; and Donald Young. /('' '/, --- -;:, :->}>"· Speakers opposed tofheproject included: Bob Joseph representing San Clemente.Citizens for Resr:>Qr1~!ble Development; Loren M. Barnett representing Colony Cove; RayBep~dicktusr(7pf~senting Riccardo Nicol former City of S.C. Planning Commissioner;Marg()~ishpp; Gilbert Blount; Garry Brown representing Orange County Coastkeeper;