THE IMAGES of WOMEN in the NOVELS of SINCLAIR LEWIS By
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE IMAGES OF WOMEN IN THE NOVELS OF SINCLAIR LEWIS By ALICE LOUISE SODOWSKY II Bachelor of Arts University of Iowa Iowa City, Iowa 1952 Master of Arts Oklahoma State University Stillwater, Oklahoma 1970 Submitted to the Faculty cf the Graduate College of the Oklahoma State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY July, 1977 lhe<:,.,s \911D Slo \C\ .\_, CQ\:)· J._ THE IMAGES OF WOMEN IN THE NOVELS OF SINCLAIR LEWIS Thesis Approved: ' ~Ch"Dean of the ~----- Graduate College 997114 ii PREFACE A few years ago I read, by chance, Sinclair.Lewis's novel Ann Vickers, published in 1933, and I was surprised to find in its story the concepts and rhetoric of a feminist movement as contemporary as the cur rent ideas and expressions being espoused by the various women's libera tion and rights groups. The question of women 1 s roles occurred to me: are women's roles today different from those in the earlier part of the century? What are the changes, if any, in their roles in fiction? I was particularly interested in Lewis's fiction because he was from the Midwest, wrote about middle-class people, and remains a severe critic of our towns and cities a.s well as of our social institutions and values. A study directed towards examining the images of women in his novels, which cover a period of about thirty-seven years of our history, would, I thought, not only shed light on who the midwestern woman is, but also on who we'are all becoming. Several people were especially helpful in assisting me \.'Jith th·is study. The expertise in reading the chapters and valuable comments of my thesis adviser, Dr. Mary Rohrberger, enabled me to shape what at times seemed like a morass of material. Also, I am fortunate to have had as members of my thesis committee Dr. Clinton Keeler, Dr. Jennifer Kidney, and Prof. John Schweitzer, whose constructive corrij11ents and encouraging remarks made the work seem lighter. Finally, I thank my husband, Roland, who shared the good moments as well as the bad, each step of the way, and who understood it all. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page I. INTRODUCTION ......•.. 1 II. PROTOTYPES IN THE EARLY NOVELS 7 III. CAROL KENNICOTT: VILLAGE WIFE . 36 IV. STEREOTYPES: CITY WIVES .... 68 V. FRAN DODSWORTH: DESTRUCTIVE WIFE 107 VI. ANN VICKERS AND BETHEL MERRIDAY: CAREER WOMEN . 138 VI I. JINNY TIMBERLANE AND PEONY PLAN I SH: PARASITIC CHARMERS 172 VIII. ROXANNA ELDRITCH: IDEAL WOMAN . 204 A SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY . 220 iv CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION Over a period of thirty-nine years Sinclair Lewis published twenty- three novels, two collections of short stories, three plays, essays, re views, and ephemera. He recorded middle-class America through periods ranging from the suffragist movement, prohibition, the depression, and two world wars. D. J. Dooley comments on Lewis 1 s scope: 11 Looking outward rather than inward, he attempted to analyze the forces which affected the behavior of his fellow citizens in a confusing transitional period; he tried to discover what were the sources of hope and frustration in the lives of typical young women, white collar workers, engineers, and garage mechanics of his time. 111 Dooley adds that 11 he was influenced by H. G. Wells, G. B. Shaw, and Thorstein Veblen; his themes were: (1) the barri ers of provincialism; (2) the waste of mis-education; (3) the possibili ties of socialism; (4) the promise of science and technology; (5) the precariousness of marriage in modern society, especi.ally as it is affected by job security. 112 Writers Carl Van Doren and E. M. Forster use such adjectives to describe Lewis's ability to record the ambience of the social scene as seismographic and photographic, respectively. The subject of this work is the image of women in Lewis's novels; the original intention was to examine the American woman portrayed by a writer whose method of writing lent itself to the socio-cultural approach of criticism or examination, but after the novels were analyzed, some of the 1 2 portrayals were found to function aesthetically within the structure of the novel, as well as thematically as specific social types, so that the ·approach varies from the social ···cultural to the formal . Further, this writer felt that one could find, in Lewis's fiction, many facets which Taine said 11 must be the principal method by which society and men are ob served, analyzed, and classified. Fiction should be the scientific labo ratory of society--the laboratory in which the complex components of our social system are mixed with each other, so that the race may watch the experiment, see the result, and be better able to make decisions affecting its life. 113 By examining the roles of women in American society in the literature of an author whose photographic method and seismographic responses trace and reflect, over a long period in our history, a variety of images of women, we can, by 11 observing, analyzing, and classifying, 11 better imagine ourselves. Lewis's approach to his characterizations varies from the realistic to the satiric, or from the fully representational to the caricaturistic. With a major figure like Carol Kennicott, Lewis supplies many details con cerning myriad aspects of her thoughts and actions, but with Peony Planish, Lewis limits the details to those aspects of her nature that revea1 her acquisitiveness and her degenerate, rococo taste. This latter method, the satiric, is indicative of his concern with social injustices and reform. Sheldon Grebstein comments on this method of characterization, which he says stems from the Theophrastian Character: The 11 Character 11 writer differs from the novelist in two special ways: (1) he deliberately ignores all qualities which would distinguish an individual; (2) he selects, invents, and borrows from a large number of individuals only those qualities or man nerisms or attitudes which express a particular type or trait 3 (the Flatterer, the Braggart, the Pretender to Learning); then he makes these into a composite character who becomes the per fect and typical representative of the desired trait .... The novel is an imitation of life, eliciting a direct response from the reader and permitting the reader's projection into it, while the creator of 1rcharacter 11 deliberately kept the reader and the work apart in order to evoke an intellectual response, an evaluation.4 Often Lewis's intention is to evoke an evaluation of the society or the forces that are shaping the characters, and one technique of his method is to show the relationship between the character and his posses sions. He said, 111 By your eyebrow pencils, your encyclopedias, and your alarm clocks shall ye be known. 1 " 5 For example, if Lewis wants to empha- size a grasping, acquisitive woman like Fran Dodsworth or Caprice Chart he describes their bedrooms, elaborate affairs full of silver toilette articles, lavender chaise lounges, damask drapes, and other expensive clutter. Edith Cortright, on the other hand, enjoys the spartan simplicity of a small Italian villa of bare walls and shining stone floors, an indi cation that Edith's spirit reflects Lewis's deepest values. And Leora Arrowsmith, who, Lewis says, best exemplifies qualities of loyalty and love, is free from all acquisitive instincts; even her clothes show her disregard for appearance and fashion: buttons missing, a spot here and there, an uneven hemline. Another factor Lewis uses to shape or mold a character is that character's point of view which Lewis delineates in a ratio of realism to sentimentalism. Lewis's use of the two terms is the following: the realist views the world primarily intellectually or objectively, seeing behind appearances or through pretense, sham, and shoddy values; the sentimentalist views the world primarily through his or her feelings and emotions, and consequently, although the view may be enchanting, it often proves to be distorted. For example, Carol Milford 4 in Main Street views life in the small town of Gopher Priarie (before she actually goes there) through some blurred photographs that her husband-to be, Will Kennicott, trying to entice her to marry him,shows her. What Carol sees in the photographs about Gopher Prairie springs from her roman tic feelings--a pastoral beauty surrounding simple, hard-working, kind people; she sees herself in the town working hand in hand with the people to enrich their lives; in short, Carol's view is sentimental, distorted by her feelings for Will as well as by a thousand myths about the sunny decencies and the pure heart of the American village. When Carol actually goes to live in Gopher Prairie she views the town objective]y and finds a vast distance between her closely observed impressions and her precon ceive.d, sentimental view; hence Carol's character is shaped by the conflicting elements within her of realism and sentimentalism. Thus Lewis shapes character in two important ways: through the external (objects, possessions, etc.), he communicates the internal, and through point of view he projects thoughts and feelings which are of primarily two types, the realistic and the sentimental. For the purpose of this work, the women in .Lewis's novels are classi fied in seven chapters: the first deals with prototypes found in his apprenticeship novels; the second with Carol Kennicott and other wives who live in a small mi.dwestern town in the years before the l920 1 s; the third with wives in cities and suburbs who, under the impact of mass production and mass communication become stereotypes; the fourth .with an acquisitive woman, a product of a society bent upon consumption, who seeks culture and people for her own adornment; the fifth with women who concentrate their lives in careers rather than domestic affairs; the sixth with wives whose relationships· with their husbands are, to a degree, destructive; and the 5 seventh with a woman who represents Lewis 1 s ideal companion or wife.