Slocan Valley Elk Study
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Slocan Valley Elk Study Aerial Survey Report 2004 Prepared for: Columbia Basin Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program Prepared by: Leo DeGroot Ministry of Water, Land, and Air Protection Nelson, BC March 2005 Slocan Valley Elk Study – Aerial Survey Report March 2005 ABSTRACT An aerial survey was completed in February 2004 to provide a population estimate for the Slocan Valley Elk Study area. This survey covered the complete study area below 1200 meters in elevation. 188 elk were spotted including eight of the 43 collared elk. Two different mark – resight programs estimate the population at 923 and 1010 animals respectively. A sightability model was also used; it determined a population estimate of 362 elk. The large discrepancy in population estimates may result from a combination of the high vegetative cover over much of the study area, the lack of fresh snow, and the lack of complete snow cover. Current harvest levels are based on an elk population of 375, we believe the harvest could be based on a population of 600 – 700 elk. ii Slocan Valley Elk Study – Aerial Survey Report March 2005 TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................................... ii TABLE OF CONTENTS .............................................................................................................................. iii INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................................................1 STUDY AREA................................................................................................................................................1 METHODS......................................................................................................................................................2 Elk Capture and Collaring ...........................................................................................................................3 Aerial Survey...............................................................................................................................................3 Mark Resight ...............................................................................................................................................3 Sightability Model.......................................................................................................................................3 RESULTS........................................................................................................................................................4 Mark Resight ...............................................................................................................................................6 Sightability Model.......................................................................................................................................7 DISCUSSION .................................................................................................................................................7 MANAGEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................................................................7 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.............................................................................................................................8 LITERATURE CITED....................................................................................................................................8 APPENDIX A ..............................................................................................................................................11 APPENDIX B...............................................................................................................................................13 iii Slocan Valley Elk Study – Aerial Survey Report March 2005 INTRODUCTION Rocky Mountain Elk (Cervus elaphus nelsoni), are an indigenous ungulate in the Kootenay region of British Columbia. Some populations in the West Kootenays were supplemented in the early 1970’s with transplants of 75 elk into the Syringa Creek area and 49 elk into the Blueberry – Paulsen area (Demarchi, 1973). These elk were taken from Banff and Jasper National Parks. Many residents place a high value on the elk for hunting, viewing, or simple aesthetic reasons. For some other residents, they are considered to be problem wildlife due to the damage that they cause to gardens, orchards, and crops. Wildlife managers are attempting to satisfy the differing sets of values, but lack critical local information, especially in the West Kootenay (Serrouya, 2002). The Slocan Valley Elk Study, initiated in 2002, is designed to supply this missing information, so that management efforts can meet a wider range of values. The project is jointly funded by the Habitat Conservation Trust Fund (HCTF) from the Arrow Wildlife Trust Account, the Columbia Basin Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program (CBFWCP) and the Ministry of Water, Land, and Air Protection (MWLAP). The MWLAP is implementing and administering the project. This aerial survey and determination of a population estimate was a key component of the overall study. The February 2004 survey was primarily funded by the CBFWCP. This report presents the results of the aerial survey. STUDY AREA The study area is approximately 800 km2 and is located in the West Kootenay region of south-east British Columbia. It includes the southern 20 km of the Slocan Valley from Passmore south-east to where the Slocan River joins the Kootenay River, 20 km of the Kootenay River Valley from this point south-west to Castlegar, and the Pass Creek Valley – Krestova area north and east of Castlegar (Figure 1). This area is in Wildlife Management Units 4-08, 4-15, 4-16, and 4-17, the Nelson – Creston Electoral Area, and the Arrow/Boundary Forest District. Valley bottoms are generally narrow, between 450 and 600 meters above sea level in elevation, and are largely private land in a rural residential setting. Approximately 5000 people reside in this area (Statistics Canada, 2001). There is some small scale agriculture which includes beef cattle farming, hay production, and fruit and berry crops. Areas above the valley bottoms are predominately Crown land, and are generally of a steep gradient. Commercial forestry is a major use of the Crown land. The area is in the interior wet belt, and falls within several biogeoclimatic zones. Areas below approximately 1500 meters in elevation fall within the Interior Cedar Hemlock (ICH) zone, areas between approximately 1500 and 2000 meters are in the Engelmann 1 Slocan Valley Elk Study – Aerial Survey Report March 2005 Spruce – Subalpine Fir (ESSF) zone. Areas higher in elevation are in the Alpine Tundra (AT) zone (Braumandl and Curran, 1992). L C T , T Willow Point Lebahdo N I n L a m S h p r o E o u W l Gr e S k Pas sm ore e e (at map centre) r y Cr i C A r e e k Granite C k Taghum Slocan Park e o e r t C x Beasley R e E p Corra V A I Blewett R Bonnington Linn F Falls o r t y South n N i n a t Slocan e n r e c C n s e r Kres tov a r s r C , C Valley Cre e k Shoreacres G oo s e C r Y e e , k Glade A Copper N Mtn E T Tarrys O k O C Pass Creek b o teK B a r r a t Siw ash e a k S g Mtn h ac in Gibson Creek Thrums Re r ! y ! S Raspberry Kraf t Robson Brilliant Robson C O West E L U r M B Gras sy I Castlegar i A Mountain e Kinnaird Ootischenia R C r I e e y V r k C r E e r b R e e k Blueberry 202Kilometers 1:250,000 Figure 1. The area covered by the Slocan Valley Elk Study is outlined by the ellipse. The contour (grey) lines are 200 meters in elevation apart. METHODS We captured and attached collars to fifty elk within the study area during the 2002/03 and 2003/04 winters using corral traps. The collars were attached to monitor elk movements, however the presence of collared elk allowed the use of mark – resight methodology of population estimation (Krebs, 1989, Seber, 1982, White, 1996). A sightability model developed by the Idaho Department of Fish and Game (Unsworth, et al, 1999) provided an alternate population estimation method from the aerial survey data. 2 Slocan Valley Elk Study – Aerial Survey Report March 2005 Elk Capture and Collaring Sixteen of 49 elk collared received both a VHF collar (Lotek Wireless, Newmarket, Ontario) and a visual collar with a unique letter identifying the individual (Wheelers Custom Upholstery, Nelson, BC). Twenty five elk received only a visual collar. Eight elk received a Global Positioning System (GPS) collar (Advanced Telemetry Systems (ATS), Isanti, Minnestota) (four GPS collars were actually used, they were removed after 10 months, refurbished, and attached to different animals the second winter). The VHF and four GPS collared elk were all within the study area at the time of the survey. We presume that all of the elk fitted with visual collars were also within the study area. One collared elk had been taken by a hunter, and another killed on a highway. As a result, we estimate that 43 marked elk were within the study area. Aerial Survey We divided the study area into 12 sub units using boundaries developed previously by the CBFWCP (Heaven et al, 1998). Areas above 1200 meters in elevation were not included in the sub units as elk were not expected to use these areas during the winter due to the deep snow depth. (Snow depth was very close to the long term average at 1200 meters elevation and at lower elevations (MWLAP, 2004)). The sub units were of