Trail Conditions Research Report
2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey
PREPARED FOR Saint Cloud Area Planning Organization BY Parks & Trails Council of Minnesota About the Parks & Trails Council
Parks & Trails Council of Minnesota is a 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to acquiring, protecting, and enhancing critical land for the public’s use and benefit. Founded in 1954, the Parks & Trails Council acquires threatened and critical parcels of land, advocates at the Minnesota Capitol, supports volunteers, and produces original research on issues and trends facing Minnesota’s parks and trails.
More information about Parks & Trails Council is available at www.parksandtrails.org.
Acknowledgments Special thanks to the dedicated staff of the Saint Cloud Area Planning Organization for their guidance, assistance, support and patience with this project: Brian Gibson, Vicki Johnson, Fred Sandal, Alex McKenzie, and Amber Blattner.
The Research Bike was made possible by support from Erik’s Bike Shop.
Author: Andrew Oftedal
Cover: Mississippi River Walk near the St. Cloud River’s Edge Convention Center. Photo by Andrew Oftedal.
This report was designed using resources from FreePik.com.
Published September 2020 Trail Conditions Research
FINAL REPORT September 2020
Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey
PREPARED FOR Saint Cloud Area Planning Organization 1040 County Road 4 Saint Cloud, MN 56303
Prepared BY Parks & Trails Council of Minnesota 275 East 4th Street, Suite #250 St. Paul, MN 55101 Table of Contents
Index of Figures and Maps v
Executive Summary vi
Introduction 1
How to Understand Our Ratings 3
Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Ratings 5
Pavement Condition Reference Maps
System Overview...... 7 Saint Cloud...... 8 Saint Joseph...... 9 Sartell and Sauk Rapids...... 10 Sauk Rapids and Saint Cloud...... 11 Waite Park and Saint Cloud...... 12 Saint Augusta and Rockville...... 13
Segment-by-Segment Ratings
Benton County...... 14 LeSauk Township...... 15 Saint Cloud...... 16 Saint Joseph...... 25 Sartell...... 27 Sauk Rapids...... 34 Stearns County...... 37 Waite Park...... 39
Appendix A: Detailed Methodology 42
Appendix B: The Research Bike 45 Index of Figures and Maps
Figure 1 Saint Cloud MPA Shared-Use Paths...... 2
Figure 2 Research Bike on the Lake Wobegon Trail...... 2
Figure 3 How the Trail Roughness Index Works...... 3
Figure 4 Trail Roughness Index Rating Classifications...... 4
Figure 5 Summary of Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions...... 5
Figure 6 Shared Use Path Conditions by Type...... 5
Figure 7 Shared Use Path Conditions by Jurisdiction...... 6
Figure 8 Concrete Path Expansion Joints...... 43
Figure 9 Limitations of the Trail Roughness Index...... 44
Map Locator:
System Overview...... 7 Saint Cloud...... 8 Saint Joseph...... 9 Sartell and Sauk Rapids...... 10 Sauk Rapids and Saint Cloud...... 11 Waite Park and Saint Cloud...... 12 Saint Augusta and Rockville...... 13 Executive Summary
Project Background: Well-maintained active transportation facilities — such as bicycling and walking paths — are vital components of healthy, sustainable communities. As part of a larger active transportation planning process, the Saint Cloud Area Planning Organization contracted with the Parks & Trails Council of Minnesota to survey the existing pavement conditions of the metropolitan area’s shared-use paths. Gathering such data is essential to understand existing facilities, identify re-investment locations and anticipate future needs.
Summary of Shared-Use Path Map of Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions: Pavement Conditions: Very smooth Very Smooth 38.3 miles Smooth Smooth 26.0 miles Fair Rough Fair 19.9 miles Very Rough Rough 8.1 miles
Very Rough 11.1 miles 10
Pavement conditions as percentage of overall system:
37 25 19 8 11 23
Very Smooth Fair Rough Very 94 Smooth Rough
Pavement Photo Examples: 23 10 94
15
North
Very smooth Fair Very rough Healthy Living Trail 15th Street South Whitney Park 0 3 miles Waite Park Sartell St. Cloud
Methodology: All the data was collected by the , an electric-assist bicycle outfitted with sensors and cameras to collect data on the user experience of paved bicycle paths. The Research Bike uses an accelerometer in an iPhone to measure how rough (or smooth) the pavement is to ride and takes photos at regular intervals to document and rate pavement conditions. All data was collected in May 2020. Introduction
In 2020 the Saint Cloud Area Planning MPA currently has 103.6 miles of paved shared-use Organization (APO) contracted with Parks & paths. The purpose of this project, which is just Trails Council of Minnesota (P&TC) to study the one component of the APO’s active transportation conditions of the Saint Cloud metropolitan area’s planning process, was to understand the pavement shared-use path network. The APO is responsible surface conditions of the APO’s existing shared-use for coordinating surface transportation planning paths. Specifically, project goals included: for the Saint Cloud Metropolitan Planning Area (MPA), including the cities of Saint Cloud, Saint •• Gather surface roughness data for every mile of shared-use paths within the APO’s planning area Joseph, Sartell, Sauk Rapids, and Waite Park; Le Sauk Township; and portions of Stearns, •• Identify needed re-investment locations so that Benton and Sherburne Counties. The APO serves rough pavement can be rehabilitated approximately 130,000 people. This report contains •• Compile a comprehensive database of photos the results of P&TC’s pavement condition survey of documenting existing pavement conditions the area’s shared-use path network. Collecting this data is important not just for Project Background and Purpose characterizing current conditions, but also to Active transportation facilities — such as bicycling serve as a foundation to develop models projecting and walking paths — are vital components of future conditions; monitor how conditions change healthy, sustainable transportation networks. over time; develop treatment recommendations, Communities with robust active transportation schedules, and cost estimates; and analyze the networks tend to be healthier by having performance of different pavement designs. cleaner air and encouraging physically-active lifestyles. Active transportation facilities can Project Scope also stimulate economic growth by creating This project was limited to paved (i.e., asphalt vibrant, interconnected neighborhoods with or concrete) shared-use paths within the Saint ample recreational opportunities that promote Cloud MPA (Figure 1). Shared-use paths are entrepreneurship, increase property values, spur off-road facilities on exclusive right-of-way tourism and attract skilled workers. and with minimal cross flow by motor vehicles. Shared-use paths are designed for a wide range Recognizing the importance of active of users, including but not limited to bicyclists, transportation, the Saint Cloud APO is developing in-line skaters, roller skaters, wheelchairs, and an Active Transportation Plan to promote pedestrians. active transportation in the Saint Cloud MPA by identifying specific projects or policies that will Importantly, active transportation networks facilitate convenient and safe active trips for all include many types of facilities other than shared- peoples, needs and purposes. The Saint Cloud use paths. Facilities such as natural-surface paths,
www.parksandtrails.org 1 on-road bicycle lanes, and sidewalks were all Figure 1 beyond the scope of this project yet are integral Saint Cloud APO Shared-Use Paths components to active transportation networks.
Project Approach All the data in this report was collected using the Research Bike, an electric-assist bicycle outfitted with sensors and cameras to collect data on the user experience of paved bicycle paths (Figure 2). The Research Bike uses an accelerometer in an iPhone 10 to measure how rough (or smooth) the pavement is to ride and takes photos at regular intervals to visualize and document on-the-ground conditions. 23
The Research Bike was developed by P&TC in 2018 St. Cloud and has also been used to inventory pavement conditions of Minnesota’s State Trail system.
Data collection took place over six days during 94 May, 2020. See Appendix A for more details on methodology. 15
Figure 2 Research Bike on the Lake Wogebon Trail
2 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey How to Understand Our Ratings
The shared-use path condition ratings in this report how rough the pavement is to ride on a bicycle. The answer a simple question: How rough (or smooth) higher the TRI, the rougher the pavement surface. is the shared-use path’s pavement? Path roughness Pavement that is very smooth to ride generally is measured using the Trail Roughness Index (TRI). has a TRI under 30, whereas pavement that is very The TRI metric was created by P&TC in 2016 and rough to ride has a TRI above 75 (Figure 4). The TRI updated in 2018 as a method to objectively measure is objective, reliable, and rooted in user-experience. the conditions of trails and shared-use paths across Minnesota. What our Ratings Don’t Measure TRI measures how rough pavement is to ride on Trail Roughness Index is calculated using data a bicycle, which is related to but not identical collected by the Research Bike (Appendix B). The to the pavement’s condition. Consequently, our Research Bike uses the accelerometer sensor in ratings don’t measure poor pavement that is easy an iPhone mounted to the bike’s handle bars. As to avoid while riding (e.g., longitudinal or edge the bicyclist rides down a path, the accelerometer cracking). Additionally, pavement roughness is measures and records all the jolts and vibrations only one component of a safe, well-maintained felt along the way (Figure 3). The TRI is a statistical shared-use path system. Our ratings do not summary of the accelerometer data and indicates consider the integrity of trail bridges, culverts or
Figure 3 How the Trail Roughness Index works
The Trail Roughness Index (TRI) measures the variation in g-force felt by the Research Bike as it’s ridden on a shared-use path. The g-force is measured by an accelerometer in an iPhone mounted to the Research Bike. The higher the TRI, the rougher the ride.
When the Research Bike rides along a As paths age, bumps and cracks start to When a path is nearing the end of its smooth path, the accelerometer shows a form in the pavement. The accelerome- useful life, bumps and cracks are g-force on relatively �lat line. ter records these imperfections when prevalent. Accelerometer readings on vertical (Z) axis: the Research Bike rides over them. such trails show a rocky, jagged line.
Each “spike” on the accelerometer graph indicates a bump on the trail
www.parksandtrails.org 3 Figure 4 Trail Roughness Index Rating Classsifications
TRI < 30 TRI 30-45 TRI 45-60 TRI 60-75 TRI >75 Very Smooth Smooth Fair Rough Very Rough
Path feels like new and Path o�fers a Path has intermittent Path has frequent Path is in disrepair with provides excellent comfortable ride for bumps and depressions, bumps and depressions very frequent bumps conditions for bicyclists bicyclists and inline but is tolerable to ride and is uncomfortable to and depressions. Path and inline skaters. Small skaters, with infrequent for the majority of ride for bicyclists. Many may be suitable only for blemishes and crack bumps and depressions. bicyclists. Some sections sections may be di�ficult mountain and fat-tire sealing may be present Path may require minor may be di�ficult for for inline skaters. Path is biking. Path is past its in isolated areas but do rehabilitation and crack inline skaters. Path may likely at the end of its useful life and likely not negatively impact sealing in isolated areas. require moderate life and requires major needs to be entirely user experience. rehabilitation and crack rehabilitation. rebuilt. sealing in several areas.
the underlying trail foundation. Our ratings do not consider visitor amenities, such as parking areas, interpretive displays or wayfinding signs. And our ratings only indirectly measure levels of day-to-day maintenance (e.g., routine path sweeping removes debris which is rough to ride over).
Supplemental Photo Database All of our TRI scores are supplemented with photos taken during the data collection process. The photos were used to verify roughness classifications and are helpful to visualize on-the-ground conditions. The full catalog of photos (17,313 in total) are available in a standalone database. See Appendix A for more details on our methodology.
4 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Ratings
Overall, the Saint Cloud MPA shared-use path Figure 5 system is in mixed condition (Figure 5). Nearly Summary of Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area two-thirds of the system (62%) is rated as being Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions in smooth or very smooth condition. Significant portions of the system are in rough condition, Very Smooth 38.3 miles however. About one-fifth of the system (19%) is Smooth 26.0 miles rated as being in rough or very rough condition. In total, 19.2 miles of shared-use path across the Saint Fair 19.9 miles
Cloud Metropolitan Area are likely in need of major Rough 8.1 miles rehabilitative work. Very Rough 11.1 miles
Conditions by Path Type Not Rated 0.3 miles Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area’s shared-use paths are classified broadly into three types of paths: Pavement conditions as percentage of overall system: •• Regional paths are generally long-distance, serve the regional population, offer “destination- 37% 25% 19% 8% 11% quality” experiences and facilitate connectivity within and between regional centers and regional Very Smooth Fair Rough Very or state-level parks. Smooth Rough •• Local/neighborhood paths serve a local population, often just a single neighborhood and are typically short in length. Such paths typically follow low- Figure 6 volume residential streets or provide access to Shared-Use Path Conditions by Path Type small neighborhood parks. •• Connector/collector paths fall between regional Rough or Very Rough Fair Smooth or Very Smooth paths and local/neighborhood paths. Such paths Total miles % of system often follow arterial roads and/or commuting Local / routes, creating connections between different 45.4 31 21 49 Neighborhood neighborhoods.
Of the three types of paths, the local and neighborhood path network requires the greatest Regional 26.9 12 19 69 levels of rehabilitative work (Figure 6). Nearly one-third of local/neighborhood paths, 13.8 miles total, are rated as either being in rough or very Connector / 31.1 7 17 76 rough condition. Only half of local/neighborhood Collector paths are rated as being in smooth or very smooth 0% 50% 100% condition.
www.parksandtrails.org 5 Figure 7 In comparison to local and neighborhood shared- Shared-Use Path Conditions by Jurisdiction use paths, regional and connector/collector paths are in relatively good condition. Over two-thirds Rough or Very Rough Fair Smooth or Very Smooth of regional paths (69%) and nearly three-fourths of Total miles % of system connector/collector paths (74%) are rated as being Sauk Rapids 9.7 15 46 39 in smooth or very smooth condition. Only 3.2 miles of regional paths, and 2.1 miles of connector/ Saint Cloud 36.0 28 18 54 collector paths are rated as rough or very rough.
Conditions by Jurisdiction Waite Park 7.2 20 19 61 Saint Cloud MPA’s shared-use paths exist within eight different jurisdictions, across which Sartell 27.0 17 21 62 pavement conditions are relatively consistent (Figure 7). Some variation does exist across Saint Josepth 8.5 15 10 75 jurisdictions, however. Nearly half of Sauk Rapids shared-use paths, for example, are rated as being Stearns Co., Other 12.0 4 9 87 in fair condition, which is more than twice the regional average. Conversely, the shared-use paths Benton Co., Other 0.8 8 92 within portions of Stearns County, Benton County, and LeSauk Township are in better-than-average condition. Shared-use path conditions within Saint LeSauk Township 2.4 100
Cloud, Waite Park, Sartell and Saint Joseph are 0% 50% 100% generally reflective of the overall metropolitan area.
More detailed descriptions of shared-use path conditions, as well as detailed maps, are included in the following pages.
6 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey System Overview: Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions
How smooth is the path to ride? St. Stephen Very smooth Smooth Fair Rough Very Rough
10
Sartell
Sauk Rapids
23 St. Joseph
94 St. Cloud
Waite Park
23 10 94
15 Rockville
St. Augusta North
0 3 miles
www.parksandtrails.org 7 Saint Cloud: Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions
23 Waters Edge 15 Saint Cloud
Lake George 2nd Street S 23 Park
Division Street 1st Street S 23 Saint Cloud State University
23 University Dr Stearns University Dr History Roos Museum evelt Rd
Beaver Island Trailhead t S in a 2nd St SE rm Riverside e G t Park S W
15 SCooper Ave 22nd St S
R
o
o
s
e
v
e
l t
R
d Oak Grove Rd SW Rd Oak Grove
C o u n t y R d
8 S W
33rd St S
Beaver Island Trailhead
River Blu s
Cooper Ave SCooper Ave Regional Park
R o o s e v e l t R d
94
Very smooth City / Regional Park North Smooth How smooth Fair Asphalt surface is the path to ride? Rough Concrete surface 0 1 mile Very Rough
8 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Saint Joseph: Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions
S n E N L is e Ir
v
A
133
e
g e l l o Millstream C Park 2 y a w Lake Wobegon Trailhead h r
g i D
H d
n y
t a
l
n
h
u
t
r
o
o C
N 75
E Minnesota St
t ota S innes W M
E Baker St
E
S
S
e
v
e
v
A
A
e
g 2
1
e
College of l
l
o Saint Benedict C
e
v
A
t
s
1
9
94
Co llege Ave S
Very smooth City / Regional Park North Smooth How smooth Fair Asphalt surface is the path to ride? Rough Concrete surface 0 0.5 mile Very Rough
www.parksandtrails.org 9 Sartell & Sauk Rapids: Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions
35th Street N
27th Street N Pinecone Rd N Rd Pinecone
Pinecone Central Park
7th Street N 10
2 1/2 St N Sartell 1st Street N
2nd Street 19th Ave S 19th Ave
R i v 6th Street e r s i d e 15 A v e
H S er ita ge Dr. Sauk Rapids 4
P in e c on e Rd S
120
Very smooth City / Regional Park North Smooth How smooth Fair Asphalt surface is the path to ride? Rough Concrete surface 0 1 mile Very Rough
10 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Sauk Rapids & Saint Cloud: Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions
1st St NE 35th St NE
E N
d Mayhew Creek R
15 e
k Park
a
L
10th Ave N Ave 10th
18th St N 10 w e
B h e y n a
to M n D r
R i v e r s i d e A v e S 11th St N
Rd NE n Spike Golde
E
N
d
R N N
e Be e n v k to A a
L
n d D n S r 2 u m
hew m
y
i a t
M
A
v e
15 Sauk Rapids
Sauk River Regional Park
N 5t h e St v S
A
h
t
9 Whitney Park 2 S 10th St NE n B d en t A on v D M e r a Saint Cloud S yh Technical and ew La Community College ke R d NE
t S
n i a m r Wilson e W G t Park ils S 23 Saint Cloud o E n A 10 v e Hester N Park E
Very smooth City / Regional Park North Smooth How smooth Fair Asphalt surface is the path to ride? Rough Concrete surface 0 0.5 mile Very Rough
www.parksandtrails.org 11 Waite Park & Saint Cloud: Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions
S
d
R
e
n
o
c
e
n
i P
Saint Cloud V e te 15 Technical and ra n Community College s
D r Saint Cloud VA Health Care System 12th St N
Rd od wo Veter ge N ans Rid Dr e 8th St N v
A
h
t
4
5 15 Saint Cloud
3rd St N
S St 1st Division St
23
N
Waite Park
e
v A
23 Univ ersity Dr S
d Roo r sevelt Rd
3
3
S
e
v
S
A
e
v
d
A
n
2
h
t
0
1
7th St S
S
e
v R 23 A
o o h
t s 22nd St S SCooper Ave e 8 v 2 t e S l t n i a R m d er t G S W
Quarry Park and
Nature Reserve Oak SW Rd Grove Scienti c Natural Area 15
137 33rd St S
Very smooth City / Regional Park North Smooth How smooth Fair Asphalt surface is the path to ride? Rough Concrete surface 0 1 mile Very Rough
12 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Saint Augusta & Rockville: Shared-Use Path Pavement Conditions
Saint Augusta 7
94 238th St Ki meyer Park
Hidden Lake
e
Park v
A
d
r
3
4
230th St 7 44
228th St
0 0.5 mile
Rockville Pleasant Lake Lions Park
6
Rockville County Park and Nature Preserve
ake Rd St L way road B Rockville
8 Pleasant Lake
23 d R nt sa ea Pl
0 0.5 mile 0 0.25 mile
Very smooth City / Regional Park North Smooth How smooth Fair Asphalt surface is the path to ride? Rough Concrete surface Very Rough
www.parksandtrails.org 13 Benton County: Segment Ratings
System Summary:
Very Smooth 0.7 miles 86% Smooth 0.1 miles 6% Fair 0.1 miles 8%
Rough 0 miles 0% Very Rough 0 miles 0% Not Rated 0 miles 0%
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I.
Sauk Rapids Township Golden Spike Rd NE (319) Golden Spike RD NE Golden Spike RD NE 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.5 24.3 - 28.7 Golden Spike Rd NE (320) Golden Spike RD NE Golden Spike RD NE 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.6 25.3 - 27.8 Golden Spike Rd NE (321) Golden Spike RD NE Mayhew Lake RD NE 0.49 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.0 21.2 - 24.7 Golden Spike Rd NE (322) Golden Spike RD NE Quary RD NE 0.05 Asphalt Smooth 38.6 27.6 - 49.4 Golden Spike Rd NE (323) Golden Spike RD NE Golden Spike RD NE 0.07 Concrete Fair 52.2 50.5 - 53.7 Golden Spike Rd NE (324) Golden Spike RD NE Quary RD NE 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.6 23.5 - 23.5
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
14 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Le Sauk Township: Segment Ratings
System Summary:
Very Smooth 1.8 miles 77% Smooth 0.5 miles 23% Fair 0 miles 0% Rough 0 miles 0% Very Rough 0 miles 0% Not Rated 0 miles 0%
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 19th Ave N (23) 1st ST N CSAH 133 0.74 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.2 28.8 - 29.5 23rd St S (44) 23rd St S 23rd St S 0.08 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.4 20.5 - 22.2 23rd St S (45) 23rd St S 23rd St S 0.20 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.7 12.0 - 33.2 CR 120 (260) County Road 134 County Road 134 0.30 Asphalt Smooth 33.9 30.1 - 37.6 CR 120 (261) 20th St N 20th St N 0.29 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.6 22.6 - 24.5 CR 133 (270) CSAH 133 19th AVE S 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 33.7 27.3 - 40.1 CR 133 (271) 19th AVE S Heritage DR 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 30.7 28.7 - 32.6 Leander Ave (426) 23rd St S 20th St N 0.19 Asphalt Smooth 35.4 24.6 - 46.2 Pinecone Road N (518) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.50 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.7 24.4 - 24.9
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 15 Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
System Summary:
Very Smooth 11.9 miles 33% Smooth 7.6 miles 21% Fair 6.4 miles 18% Rough 3.5 miles 10% Very Rough 6.5 miles 18%
Not Rated 0.2 miles 0%
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 18th Ave SE (21) 18th Ave 18th Ave 0.03 Asphalt Very Rough 91.9 80.9 - 102.8 18th Ave SE (22) 18th Ave 18th Ave 0.03 Asphalt Rough 65.3 27 - 103.5 24th St SE (48) 24th St Oak preserve Ct 0.09 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.1 20.0 - 38.0 24th St SE (49) Oak preserve Ct 24th St 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.3 27.6 - 30.8 33rd St S (69) 33rd ST S Spalt AVE 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.7 22.5 - 28.8 33rd St S (70) Spalt AVE Southway DR 0.13 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.2 17.9 - 28.5 33rd St S (71) Southway DR 33rd ST S 0.16 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.3 20.7 - 25.8 33rd St S (72) 33rd ST S 33rd ST S 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.6 10.3 - 36.7 33rd St S (73) 5th Ave S 33rd ST S 0.15 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.8 20.0 - 21.6 33rd St S (74) 33rd CIR S Red River Tr 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.7 26.7 - 28.5 33rd St S (75) Navaho Tr 33rd ST S 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.3 27.9 - 30.6 33rd St S (76) Sante Fe Tr Navaho Tr 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 30.3 20.0 - 40.5 33rd St S (77) Red River Tr 33rd ST S 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.1 16.4 - 35.7 33rd St S (78) 33rd ST S 46th AVE S 0.01 Asphalt Closed for construction 33rd St S (79) 33rd ST S Old CSAH 74 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.5 12.3 - 38.5 33rd St S (80) Old CSAH 74 CSAH 84 0.27 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.3 22.7 - 23.8 33rd St S (81) CSAH 84 CSAH 84 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.5 6.3 - 36.6 33rd St S (82) CSAH 84 Granite PKWY 0.06 Concrete Smooth 39.2 29.4 - 48.9 33rd St S (83) Granite PKWY Granite PKWY 0.02 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.7 14.6 - 28.7 33rd St S (84) Granite PKWY CSAH 84 0.09 Concrete Smooth 35.5 29.4 - 41.6 33rd St S (85) 46th AVE S 33rd ST S 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 122.2 106.5 - 137.8
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
16 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 44th Ave N (96) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.19 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.2 20.3 - 27.9 44th Ave N (97) 8th ST N 44th AVE N 0.11 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.6 18.9 - 30.3 9th Ave N (113) 9th AVE N 9th AVE N 0.42 Asphalt Smooth 33.9 31.7 - 35.9 9th Ave Ped Bridge (114) 3rd St N 2nd St N 0.13 Concrete Rough 73.7 71.7 - 75.5 9th Ave S (115) 9th AVE N 6th Ave N 0.01 Asphalt Smooth * NA Anderson Trucking Service (116) 8th Ave S 8th Ave S 0.01 Asphalt Fair 54.1 43.5 - 64.6 Anderson Trucking Service (117) 8th Ave S 8th Ave S 0.08 Asphalt Fair 48.7 34.9 - 62.5 Anderson Trucking Service (118) 8th Ave S Opportunity DR 0.10 Asphalt Smooth 44.6 36.7 - 52.4 Anderson Trucking Service (119) Opportunity DR Opportunity DR 0.05 Asphalt Fair 59.2 56.1 - 62.1 Anderson Trucking Service (120) ISTH 94 8th Ave S 0.18 Asphalt Fair 50.9 47.5 - 54.2 Apollo Bridge (121) MNTH 15 38th Ave N 0.09 Concrete Fair 58.3 57.4 - 59.1 Apollo High School (122) 44th AVE N MNTH 15 0.46 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.9 29.7 - 30 Apollo High School (123) MNTH 15 44th AVE N 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 30.6 29.9 - 31.2 Apollo High School (124) MNTH 15 12th ST N 0.19 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.3 15.3 - 41.3 Apollo High School (125) MNTH 15 44th AVE N 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 40.8 26.1 - 55.4 Apollo High School (126) 12th ST N 12th ST N 0.08 Asphalt Rough 65.4 21.8 - 108.9 Augushire Park (127) 4th Ave S 4th Ave S 0.02 Asphalt Very Rough 78.2 70.0 - 86.3 Augushire Park (128) 4th Ave S Waite Ave S 0.01 Asphalt Rough * NA BBC Park (135) 2nd St N 37th Ave N 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 38.7 33.9 - 43.4 Beaver Island Trail (136) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 1.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.0 25.6 - 32.2 Beaver Island Trail (137) Sportsmans Island Rd Aldon Dr 0.52 Asphalt Very Rough 77.9 74.5 - 81.1 Beaver Island Trail (138) Clearwater Rd Clearwater RD 0.27 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.7 22 - 23.3 Beaver Island Trail (139) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.17 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.0 19.6 - 22.4 Beaver Island Trail (140) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.9 7.9 - 37.8 Beaver Island Trail (141) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 15.0 5.6 - 24.4 Beaver Island Trail (142) 1st Ave S 14th St S 0.25 Asphalt Very Rough 95.3 92.5 - 98 Beaver Island Trail (143) 14th St S 1st Ave S 0.25 Asphalt Very Rough 82.7 76.4 - 88.8 Beaver Island Trail (144) 14th St S 3rd Ave S 0.13 Asphalt Very Rough 80.4 75.8 - 84.9 Beaver Island Trail (145) 14th St S 3rd Ave S 0.09 Asphalt Very Rough 84.3 19.6 - 148.9 Beaver Island Trail (146) 3rd Ave S 3rd Ave S 0.10 Asphalt Fair 51.8 34.9 - 68.6 Beaver Island Trail (147) Clearwater RD Golf View La 0.32 Asphalt Rough 67.5 49.3 - 85.7 Beaver Island Trail (148) Montrose Rd 33rd ST S 0.11 Asphalt Fair 52.6 52.4 - 52.6 Beaver Island Trail (149) Clearwater RD Clearwater RD 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA Beaver Island Trail (150) 33rd ST S 33rd ST S 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 30.1 28.8 - 31.3 Beaver Island Trail (151) 33rd ST S Clearwater Rd 0.76 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.2 21.3 - 24.9 Beaver Island Trail (152) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.01 Concrete Fair * NA
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 17 Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Beaver Island Trail (153) Clearwater RD Heatherwood RD 0.18 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.1 20.1 - 22 Beaver Island Trail (154) Clearwater RD Clearwater RD 0.03 Asphalt Fair 59.3 46.1 - 72.4 Beaver Island Trail (155) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.03 Asphalt Very Smooth 17.4 4.6 - 30.1 Beaver Island Trail (156) 1st Ave S 1st Ave S 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 147.4 85.1 - 209.6 Beaver Island Trail (157) 1st Ave S 1st Ave S 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 39.7 22.1 - 57.2 Beaver Island Trail (158) 3rd Ave S 3rd Ave S 0.21 Asphalt Very Rough 86.5 77.4 - 95.5 Beaver Island Trail (159) 7th Ave S 3rd Ave S 0.32 Asphalt Fair 49.7 41.8 - 57.6 Beaver Island Trail (160) Viking Dr 7th Ave S 0.15 Asphalt Very Rough 86.7 70.7 - 102.6 Beaver Island Trail (161) Aldon Dr Viking Dr 0.37 Asphalt Fair 53.4 38.8 - 67.9 Beaver Island Trail (162) Golf View La Sportsmans Island Rd 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 35.3 13.7 - 56.8 Boulder Ridge Trail (174) Old CSAH 74 42nd Ave S 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 31.8 22.5 - 41 Boulder Ridge Trail (175) 42nd Ave S 41st Ave S 0.36 Asphalt Fair 48.7 44.5 - 52.7 Boulder Ridge Trail (176) 41st Ave S Old CSAH 74 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 35.2 21.7 - 48.6 Boulder Ridge Trail (177) Old CSAH 74 24th ST S 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 38.0 25.7 - 50.1 Boulder Ridge Trail (178) 24th ST S Old CSAH 74 0.13 Asphalt Smooth 30.8 18.3 - 43.3 Boulder Ridge Trail (179) Old CSAH 74 40th AVE S 0.01 Asphalt Smooth 34.1 31.4 - 36.7 Calvary Hill Park (182) Allendale Dr Roger Rd 0.06 Concrete Very Rough 78.6 63.7 - 93.4 Calvary Hill Park (183) Roger Rd Roger Rd 0.03 Concrete Very Rough 90.0 36.8 - 143.2 Centra Care Plaza (184) CentraCare Cir County Road 134 0.05 Asphalt Smooth 32.7 24.2 - 41.2 Centra Care Plaza (185) CentraCare Cir County Road 134 0.05 Asphalt Smooth 42.7 42.3 - 43.1 Centra Care Plaza (186) CentraCare Cir CentraCare Cir 0.33 Asphalt Rough 68.1 42.7 - 93.5 Centra Care Plaza (187) CentraCare Cir CentraCare Cir 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 41.9 32.1 - 51.6 Centra Care Plaza (188) CentraCare Cir CentraCare Cir 0.10 Asphalt Fair 50.7 25.2 - 76.2 Centra Care Plaza (189) CentraCare Cir CentraCare Cir 0.13 Asphalt Smooth 39.1 36.5 - 41.6 Centra Care Plaza (190) CentraCare Cir 20th St N 0.09 Asphalt Fair 53.3 44.7 - 61.8 Centra Care Plaza (191) CentraCare Cir CentraCare Cir 0.15 Asphalt Rough 62.2 58.2 - 66.2 Centra Care Plaza (192) CentraCare Cir CentraCare Cir 0.11 Asphalt Smooth 38.2 33.1 - 43.2 Centra Care Plaza (193) CentraCare Cir CentraCare Cir 0.10 Asphalt Fair 49.8 45.3 - 54.3 Cherry Park (194) 7th ST NE 47th AVE NE 0.20 Asphalt Smooth 36.7 † Clearwater Rd (207) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.12 Asphalt Fair 55.7 24.6 - 86.7 Clearwater Rd (208) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.5 24.8 - 30.2 Clearwater Rd (209) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.2 22.1 - 22.2 Clearwater Rd (210) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.4 15.8 - 35.0 Clearwater Rd (211) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.01 Concrete Fair * NA Clearwater Rd (212) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.01 Concrete Fair * NA Clearwater Rd (213) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.03 Concrete Rough 69.8 32.1 - 107.4
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
18 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Clearwater Rd (214) Loudenbach Ct Clearwater Rd 0.05 Asphalt Fair 54.6 47.3 - 61.9 Clemens Gardens (215) University Dr SE Kilian Blvd SE 0.18 Asphalt Very Rough 75.9 67.2 - 84.5 Clemens Gardens (216) Riverside Dr SE Riverside Dr SE 0.03 Asphalt Very Rough 106.6 85.3 - 127.7 Concord Park (236) Chelms Ford La Chelms Ford La 0.16 Asphalt Smooth 33.5 29.3 - 37.6 Concord Park (237) Walden Way Chelms Ford La 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 44.2 35.2 - 53.2 Concord Park (238) Walden Way Walden Way 0.18 Asphalt Smooth 32.6 31.1 - 33.9 Concord Park (239) Walden Way Chelms Ford La 0.19 Asphalt Smooth 36.7 33.3 - 40.1 Cooper Ave Trail (246) Cooper AVE S Cooper AVE S 0.09 Asphalt Smooth 37.1 24.3 - 49.8 Cooper Ave Trail (247) Cooper AVE S Cooper AVE S 0.02 Asphalt Very Smooth 17.1 3.1 - 31.0 Cooper Ave Trail (248) Cooper AVE S Cooper AVE S 0.16 Asphalt Smooth 43.4 28.1 - 58.7 Cooper Ave Trail (249) Cooper AVE N 3rd St N 0.31 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.5 28.5 - 30.5 CR 134 (276) County Road 134 County Road 134 0.23 Asphalt Smooth 32.3 24.6 - 39.9 CR 4 (283) Walnut DR Somerset BLVD 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.4 22.5 - 24.2 CR 4 (284) Rolling Ridge RD Veterans DR 0.16 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.3 14.3 - 38.1 CR 4 (285) Veterans DR County Road 134 0.20 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.2 16.9 - 25.4 Goldthorpe Park (325) 12th Ave NE 12th Ave NE 0.09 Asphalt Very Rough 85.3 45.6 - 124.9 Greenway Trail (330) Aurora La 31st Ave N 0.05 Concrete Rough 61.3 39.6 - 83 Greenway Trail (331) Stearns Way 29th Ave N 0.18 Asphalt Very Rough 127.3 116.1 - 138.4 Greenway Trail (332) Stearns Way 15th St N 0.14 Asphalt Very Rough 104.5 93.6 - 115.3 Greenway Trail (333) Polaris Ct Stockinger Dr 0.30 Asphalt Rough 74.2 70.2 - 78.1 Greenway Trail (334) 24th Ave N Northway Pl 0.11 Concrete Fair 49.0 48.9 - 48.9 Greenway Trail (335) 29th Ave N Aurora La 0.06 Concrete Fair 52.7 49.5 - 55.8 Greenway Trail (336) Polaris Ct Colony Cir 0.04 Concrete Rough 66.5 52.4 - 80.6 Greenway Trail (337) Polaris Ct Polaris Ct 0.03 Concrete Very Rough 98.3 87.4 - 109.1 Greenway Trail (338) Stearns Way Stearns Way 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 79.4 45.5 - 113.2 Greenway Trail (339) Park Dr Polaris Ct 0.09 Asphalt Fair 45.5 41.5 - 49.5 Heritage Park (354) 2nd St S 2nd St S 0.01 Asphalt Very Rough * NA Heritage Park (355) MNTH 15 MNTH 15 0.07 Asphalt Very Rough 97.8 94.2 - 101.3 Heritage Park (356) MNTH 15 MNTH 15 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 140.1 126.8 - 153.4 Heritage Park (357) 2nd St S 2nd St S 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 81.9 40.3 - 123.4 Hester Park Trail (358) 9th St N 6th Ave N 0.17 Asphalt Very Rough 103.9 92.6 - 115.1 Hester Park Trail (359) 9th St N 9th St N 0.02 Asphalt Rough 74.6 67.1 - 82 Hester Park Trail (360) 6th Ave N 6th Ave N 0.01 Asphalt Rough 61.2 54.1 - 68.2 Hester Park Trail (361) 6th Ave N 6th Ave N 0.01 Asphalt Rough 63.9 43.2 - 84.5 Hester Park Trail (362) 6th Ave N 5th Ave N 0.15 Asphalt Rough 67.2 62.2 - 72.1 Hester Park Trail (363) 6th Ave N 6th Ave N 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 81.5 63.2 - 99.7
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 19 Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Hester Park Trail (364) 6th Ave N 6th Ave N 0.02 Asphalt Rough 64.7 48.1 - 81.1 Hester Park Trail (365) 5th Ave N 5th Ave N 0.02 Asphalt Fair 56.9 29.7 - 83.9 Highlands (369) 27th St SE 20th Ave SE 0.21 Asphalt Rough 72.4 65.8 - 78.8 HWY 23 to Riverside Dr (373) Riverside Dr SE 3rd St SE 0.09 Concrete Smooth 40.2 37.9 - 42.5 Knights of Columbus Park (383) 54th Ave N Rilla Rd 0.08 Asphalt Rough 64.7 53.2 - 76.0 Lake George (387) 12th Ave S 12th Ave S 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.4 27.2 - 27.6 Lake George (388) 12th Ave S 12th Ave S 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 43.8 20.6 - 66.9 Lake George (389) 7th St S E Lake Blvd 0.15 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.6 24.0 - 35.1 Lake George (390) 12th Ave S 12th Ave S 0.04 Asphalt Rough 62.4 19.1 - 105.6 Lake George (391) E Lake Blvd E Lake Blvd 0.01 Concrete Staircase — Not Rated Lake George (392) 7th St S 12th Ave S 0.02 Asphalt Very Rough 97.1 71.6 - 122.5 Lake George (393) 7th St S E Lake Blvd 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 30.8 30.7 - 30.8 Lake George (394) 10th AVE N 10th AVE N 0.09 Concrete Smooth 38.7 22.3 - 54.9 Lake George (395) 7th St S 7th St S 0.03 Concrete Fair 57.0 9.6 - 104.2 Lake George (396) E Lake Blvd E Lake Blvd 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 40.6 40.3 - 40.9 Lake George (397) E Lake Blvd E Lake Blvd 0.16 Asphalt Fair 52.8 32.8 - 72.7 Lake George (398) 12th Ave S 7th St S 0.13 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.3 27.4 - 29.2 Lake George (399) 2nd St S 12th Ave S 0.13 Asphalt Smooth 40.7 22.1 - 59.3 Lake George (400) E Lake Blvd 2nd St S 0.15 Asphalt Smooth 30.8 27.8 - 33.6 Lake Wobegon Trail (401) Ridgewood Rd Saukview Dr 0.68 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.2 19.5 - 20.9 Lake Wobegon Trail (402) County Road 134 Ridgewood Rd 0.30 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.8 21.3 - 24.2 Lake Wobegon Trail (403) Saukview Dr Maywood DR 0.17 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.7 22.4 - 22.9 Lincoln Elementary School Bridge (436) 3rd St SE 3rd St SE 0.10 Concrete Smooth 41.3 39.1 - 43.3 Marco (448) Clearwater RD Clearwater RD 0.09 Asphalt Fair 45.3 43.8 - 46.6 Marco (449) Clearwater RD Clearwater RD 0.09 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.6 20.5 - 32.6 Marco (450) Clearwater RD Clearwater RD 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 43.7 9.4 - 77.8 Marco (451) Clearwater RD Clearwater RD 0.14 Asphalt Smooth 36.7 28.8 - 44.5 Mill Creek (453) Stockinger Dr 24th Ave N 0.10 Concrete Fair 56.6 29.8 - 83.3 Mississippi River Walk (460) 2nd St N 5th Ave N 0.17 Concrete Very Rough 79.7 47.8 - 111.4 Mississippi River Walk (461) 1st ST N 4th Ave N 0.07 Concrete Fair 45.2 35.4 - 54.8 Mississippi River Walk (765) 4th Ave N 2nd St N 0.21 Concrete Smooth 44.4 42.8 - 45.9 Mississippi River Walk (766) 3rd Ave S 4th Ave N 0.24 Concrete Fair 56.4 53 - 59.8 Montrose Rd (462) Clearwater RD Montrose Rd 0.17 Asphalt Fair 53.2 23.7 - 82.6 Municipal Athletic Complex (463) Veterans DR Veterans DR 0.04 Asphalt Fair 55.5 51.0 - 59.8 Munsinger Gardens (465) Riverside Dr SE Riverside Dr SE 0.06 Asphalt Fair 54.5 †
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
20 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Natures Trail (467) Edward Dr Edward Dr 0.02 Concrete Rough 68.7 12.1 - 125.2 Natures Trail (468) Edward Dr Curve Way 0.05 Concrete Smooth 39.7 30.6 - 48.6 Oak Hill Elementary School (477) M-691 Oak Grove RD 0.25 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.5 21.4 - 21.5 Oak Hill Elementary School (478) 24th Ave S 24th Ave S 0.03 Concrete Very Rough 75.3 58.3 - 92.2 Oak Hill Elementary School (479) 24th Ave S Oak Grove RD 0.15 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.0 19.7 - 30.1 Oak Hill Elementary School (480) 26th Ave S 26th Ave S 0.01 Asphalt Fair 48.6 † Oak Hill Elementary School (481) 26th Ave S 26th Ave S 0.03 Asphalt Very Rough 214.3 200.5 - 228 Oak Hill Elementary School (482) 26th Ave S 23rd St S 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 134.9 122.5 - 147.2 Oak Park (484) Liberty Glen LOOP Liberty Glen LOOP 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 36.5 22.9 - 49.9 Oak Park (485) Liberty Glen LOOP CSAH 8 0.03 Asphalt Fair 50.6 43.3 - 57.8 Opportunity Dr (488) Opportunity DR Opportunity DR 0.09 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.5 17.6 - 31.2 Opportunity Dr (489) Opportunity DR Opportunity DR 0.06 Concrete Smooth 34.6 31.5 - 37.6 Opportunity Dr (490) Opportunity DR 8th Ave 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.5 20.2 - 26.6 Pinecone Road S (530) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.23 Asphalt Smooth 33.1 30.2 - 36.0 Pinecone Road S (531) Pine Cone RD County Road 134 0.20 Asphalt Smooth 30.3 27.2 - 33.4 Quail Pond Park (555) Spruce St Spruce St 0.08 Asphalt Very Rough 147.0 93.1 - 200.8 Quail Pond Park (556) Timberdoodle Dr Spruce St 0.17 Asphalt Rough 70.0 54.1 - 85.7 Quarry Woods (558) Topaz Pkwy S Tamarack Dr 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 30.2 14.5 - 45.8 Quarry Woods (559) Topaz Pkwy S 26th Ave S 0.31 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.7 24.9 - 28.5 Quarry Woods (560) Topaz La S Topaz La S 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA River Bluffs Regional Park (563) Clearwater Rd Clearwater Rd 0.03 Asphalt Fair 55.8 49.4 - 62.0 River Bluffs Regional Park (564) Loudenbach Ct Loudenbach Ct 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 33.8 31.1 - 36.4 River Walk (565) 1st Ave S 1st Ave S 0.11 Concrete Fair 55.1 46.9 - 63.1 Riverside Park (586) Kilian Blvd SE University Dr SE 0.14 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.4 24.0 - 34.8 Roosevelt Road (610) Roosevelt Rd Roosevelt Rd 0.05 Concrete Very Rough 112.6 91.9 - 133.1 Roosevelt Trail (611) Roosevelt Rd 16th Ave S 0.30 Asphalt Rough 64.1 57.0 - 71.0 Roosevelt Trail (612) McKinley PL S McKinley PL S 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 44.8 † Roosevelt Trail (613) Roosevelt Rd McKinley PL S 0.20 Asphalt Rough 68.3 59.4 - 77.0 Roosevelt Trail (614) Roosevelt Rd University DR S 0.29 Asphalt Fair 55.0 37.7 - 72.2 Roosevelt Trail (615) University DR S University DR S 0.01 Asphalt Smooth * NA Roosevelt Trail (616) Roosevelt Rd Roosevelt Rd 0.03 Concrete Rough 62.4 39.5 - 85.1 Roosevelt Trail (617) Roosevelt Rd 16th St S 0.02 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.1 21.2 - 32.9 Roosevelt Trail (626) Roosevelt Rd Roosevelt Rd 0.11 Asphalt Fair 57.4 31.8 - 83.0
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 21 Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Roosevelt Trail (627) Roosevelt Rd Roosevelt Rd 0.08 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.8 19.9 - 27.6 Rose Richter Park (628) 38th St S 38th St S 0.05 Asphalt Fair 51.4 45.1 - 57.6 SCSU (653) 16th St S 3rd Ave S 0.09 Asphalt Very Rough 93.4 91.6 - 95.2 SCSU Ped Bridge (654) University Dr S University Dr S 0.02 Concrete Smooth 38.2 28.8 - 47.5 Serenity (655) 26th St S Tranquility Dr 0.08 Asphalt Very Rough 112.0 60.8 - 163.2 Southwood Heights (657) 36th St S 36th St S 0.35 Asphalt Very Rough 77.7 69.2 - 86.1 Southwood Heights (658) Plum Creek Dr Plum Creek Dr 0.01 Asphalt Smooth 43.2 36.5 - 49.8 Southwood Heights (659) Plum Creek Dr Plum Creek Dr 0.03 Asphalt Very Rough 92.5 29.9 - 155 Stone Gate (660) Nothingham RD S 42th AVE S 0.13 Asphalt Closed for construction Stone Gate (661) Nothingham RD S Nothingham RD S 0.26 Asphalt Smooth 43.7 35.9 - 51.4 Stone Gate (662) 30th ST S 30th ST S 0.05 Asphalt Smooth 39.0 25.8 - 52 Talahi Park (666) Liberty Glen LOOP Liberty Glen LOOP 0.11 Asphalt Smooth 37.2 19.9 - 54.4 Tech High School (667) 33rd ST S 33rd ST S 0.26 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.5 22.4 - 24.4 Tech High School (668) 33rd ST S 33rd ST S 0.03 Concrete Very Smooth 25.1 17.7 - 32.4 Tech High School (669) 33rd ST S 33rd ST S 0.09 Concrete Very Smooth 27.6 25.1 - 29.9 The Sanctuary (670) 20th Ave 20th Ave 0.13 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.0 20.9 - 31.0 VA Medical Center (671) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.17 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.5 25.4 - 31.4 VA Medical Center (672) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.14 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.3 22.0 - 30.4 VA Medical Center (673) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (674) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (675) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.54 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.9 19.2 - 24.6 VA Medical Center (676) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.03 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.5 21.4 - 27.6 VA Medical Center (677) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (678) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (679) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (680) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (681) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.0 17.8 - 22.1 VA Medical Center (682) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (683) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (684) Veterans DR 44th AVE N 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 13.8 5.9 - 21.5 VA Medical Center (685) Veterans DR Veterans DR 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (686) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (687) Veterans DR Veterans DR 0.03 Asphalt Very Smooth 19.9 18.0 - 21.7 VA Medical Center (688) Veterans DR Veterans DR 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (689) Veterans DR Veterans DR 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA VA Medical Center (690) 44th AVE N 44th AVE N 0.04 Concrete Rough 63.1 30.1 - 96.0
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
22 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Waters Edge (699) 45th Ave NE 45th AVE NE 0.16 Asphalt Smooth 43.0 39.6 - 46.2 Waters Edge (700) 45th Ave NE 45th Ave NE 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.6 17.4 - 33.7 Waters Edge (701) 45th AVE NE 45th Ave NE 0.17 Asphalt Smooth 33.0 21.5 - 44.3 Waters Edge (702) 45th Ave NE 47th AVE NE 0.15 Asphalt Smooth 39.0 38.6 - 39.3 Waters Edge (703) 47th AVE NE 47th AVE NE 0.09 Asphalt Smooth 34.3 33.5 - 34.9 Waters Edge (704) 47th AVE NE 47th AVE NE 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 32.6 26.3 - 38.9 Waters Edge (705) 6th St NE 5th ST NE 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 32.6 15.8 - 49.3 Waters Edge (706) 47th AVE NE 47th AVE NE 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 30.2 25.8 - 34.6 Waters Edge (707) 4th St 3rd St NE 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.5 16.8 - 30.1 Waters Edge (708) 3rd St NE 2nd St NE 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 40.6 39.9 - 41.1 Waters Edge (709) 47th AVE NE 2nd St NE 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.8 22.2 - 33.3 Waters Edge (710) 47th AVE NE 7th ST NE 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 36.5 29.9 - 43.0 Waters Edge (711) 47th AVE NE 47th AVE NE 0.06 Asphalt Fair 56.2 29.6 - 82.8 Westwind Apartments (712) Savannah Ave Savannah Ave 0.15 Asphalt Fair 48.9 38.8 - 58.9 Westwood Elementary School (713) Veterans DR Ridgewood RD 0.35 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.2 18.9 - 39.4 Westwood Elementary School (714) Maywood DR Driftwood Dr 0.06 Concrete Fair 52.3 43.9 - 60.6 Westwood Parkway Trail (715) Rolling Ridge RD Cory LN 0.18 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.6 24.7 - 26.4 Westwood Parkway Trail (716) Aspen La Rolling Ridge Rd 0.20 Asphalt Fair 57.1 53.1 - 61.0 Westwood Parkway Trail (717) Westwood PKWY Westwood PKWY 0.29 Asphalt Smooth 40.7 20 - 61.2 Westwood Parkway Trail (718) Manor Ct Manor Ct 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 40.7 17.8 - 63.4 Westwood Parkway Trail (719) Cory LN Cypress RD 0.15 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.0 22 - 25.9 Westwood Parkway Trail (720) Cypress RD Savannah Ave 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 36.1 30.6 - 41.5 Westwood Parkway Trail (721) Cape West Ct Cape West Ct 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 35.2 29.3 - 41.0 Westwood Parkway Trail (722) Savannah Ave Savannah Ct 0.21 Asphalt Rough 68.6 60.0 - 77.2 Westwood Parkway Trail (723) Westwood PKWY Westwood PKWY 0.10 Asphalt Fair 48.6 40.8 - 56.3 Westwood Parkway Trail (724) M-1529 Westwood PKWY 0.12 Asphalt Smooth 38.2 17.1 - 59.2 Westwood Parkway Trail (725) Westwood PKWY Aspen La 0.14 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.2 13.0 - 31.2 Westwood Parkway Trail (726) Westwood PKWY Westwood PKWY 0.17 Asphalt Fair 45.3 32.7 - 57.9 Westwood Parkway Trail (727) Cypress RD Westwood PKWY 0.14 Asphalt Fair 51.0 25.3 - 76.6 Westwood Parkway Trail (728) Cory LN Westwood PKWY 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 37.8 29.6 - 45.8 Westwood Parkway Trail (729) Cypress RD Cape West Ct 0.18 Asphalt Smooth 44.1 17.3 - 70.8 Westwood Parkway Trail (730) Westwood PKWY Rolling Ridge Rd 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 44.8 34.7 - 54.7 Westwood Parkway Trail (731) Sierra La Sierra La 0.13 Asphalt Fair 56.1 52.7 - 59.3 Westwood Parkway Trail (732) Sierra La Sierra La 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 37.5 26.9 - 48.0 Westwood Parkway Trail (733) Sierra La Savannah Ave 0.07 Asphalt Very Rough 121.1 69.7 - 172.4
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 23 Saint Cloud: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Westwood Parkway Trail (734) Sierra La Sierra La 0.05 Asphalt Very Rough 102.0 79.9 - 124.1 Westwood Parkway Trail (735) Manor Ct Manor Ct 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 35.2 25.0 - 45.2 Westwood Parkway Trail (736) Manor Ct Voyageur ST 0.15 Asphalt Rough 64.1 0.0 - 128.2 Westwood Parkway Trail (737) Manor Ct Voyageur ST 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 32.0 30.5 - 33.3 Westwood Parkway Trail (738) Voyageur ST Yosemite St 0.08 Asphalt Very Smooth 19.9 11.2 - 28.4 Westwood Parkway Trail (739) Sierra La Savannah Ave 0.14 Asphalt Fair 48.7 41.1 - 56.2 Westwood Parkway Trail (740) Savannah Ct Savannah Ave 0.14 Asphalt Fair 54.6 27.0 - 82.1 Westwood Parkway Trail (741) Savannah Ave Cypress RD 0.05 Asphalt Very Rough 85.2 2.3 - 167.9 Westwood Parkway Trail (742) Westwood PKWY Cypress RD 0.10 Asphalt Fair 47.6 46.6 - 48.5 Westwood Parkway Trail (743) Cape West Ct Rolling Ridge Rd 0.10 Asphalt Rough 64.8 57.7 - 71.9 Westwood Parkway Trail (744) Savannah Ave Sierra La 0.13 Asphalt Smooth 41.5 34.6 - 48.4 Whitney Park Trail (745) Northway Dr Forest Dr 0.40 Asphalt Very Rough 108.9 102.1 - 115.7 Whitney Park Trail (746) Northway Dr Northway Dr 0.03 Asphalt Fair 56.9 41.0 - 72.6 Whitney Park Trail (747) 11th Ave Stockinger Dr 0.92 Asphalt Very Rough 144.6 142.9 - 146.2 Whitney Park Trail (748) Summit Dr 11th Ave 0.06 Asphalt Very Rough 124.4 101.3 - 147.3 Whitney Park Trail (749) Northway Dr Northway Dr 0.08 Asphalt Very Rough 88.0 84.3 - 91.6 Whitney Park Trail (750) Forest Dr Forest Dr 0.14 Asphalt Very Rough 116.0 102.8 - 129 Whitney Park Trail (751) Stockinger Dr Stockinger Dr 0.12 Asphalt Very Rough 99.9 62.8 - 137.0 Whitney Park Trail (752) Summit Dr Forest Dr 0.21 Asphalt Very Rough 82.0 80.5 - 83.4 Whitney Park Trail (753) Forest Dr Forest Dr 0.31 Asphalt Very Rough 98.5 94.7 - 102.3 Whitney Park Trail (754) Stockinger Dr Stockinger Dr 0.23 Asphalt Very Rough 124.0 79.0 - 168.9 Whitney Park Trail (755) 11th Ave Northway Dr 0.00 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA Whitney Park Trail (756) Northway Dr Northway Dr 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA Whitney Park Trail (757) Forest Dr Stockinger Dr 0.19 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.1 22.4 - 29.7 Whitney Park Trail (758) Stockinger Dr Northway Dr 0.25 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.1 13.0 - 41.2 Whitney Park Trail (759) Northway Dr Northway Dr 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.9 27.3 - 30.4
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
24 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Saint Joseph: Segment Ratings
System Summary:
Very Smooth 3.7 miles 44% Smooth 2.6 miles 31% Fair 0.8 miles 10% Rough 0.5 miles 16% Very Rough 0.8 miles 10%
Not Rated 0 miles 0%
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 4th Ave SE (100) Faith LN Elena LN 0.14 Asphalt Smooth 40.1 34.5 - 45.5 7th Ave SE (107) 7th AVE SE 7th AVE SE 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 41.9 25.5 - 58.2 7th Ave SE (108) 7th AVE SE Klinefelter WAY 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 35.6 35.5 - 35.6 College (219) Callaway ST E Callaway ST E 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 32.4 19.1 - 45.7 College (220) Callaway ST E Callaway ST E 0.08 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.2 22.6 - 35.6 College (221) College CIR Callaway ST E 0.12 Asphalt Smooth 31.5 27.7 - 35.1 College Ave S (222) Jade Rd Lanigan WAY SW 0.30 Asphalt Smooth 38.4 32.4 - 44.2 College Ave S (223) Lanigan WAY SW CR-121 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA College Ave S (224) Lanigan WAY SW CR-121 0.25 Asphalt Fair 49.2 45.5 - 52.7 College of Saint Benedict (225) St Ben Complex St Ben Complex 0.44 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.8 21.4 - 34.0 College of Saint Benedict (226) Ellie CT St Ben Complex 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.2 25.3 - 32.9 College of Saint Benedict (227) St Ben Complex Ellie CT 0.03 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.8 22.0 - 25.4 College of Saint Benedict (228) Ellie CT St Ben Complex 0.17 Asphalt Smooth 36.8 16.7 - 56.8 College of Saint Benedict (229) St Ben Complex St Ben Complex 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.3 15.0 - 29.5 College of Saint Benedict (230) St Ben Complex College Ave S 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.5 18.9 - 34.0 College os Saint Benedict (231) College Ave S St Ben Complex 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.3 22.6 - 29.9 Country Manor (250) Lanigan WAY SW Lanigan WAY SW 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.9 16 .0- 35.7 Country Manor (251) Lanigan WAY SW Lanigan WAY SW 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.4 22.2 - 28.5 Country Manor (252) Lanigan WAY SW Lanigan WAY SW 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.2 11.4 - 42.9 Elena Ln (298) Elena LN Elena LN 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 35.9 35.0 - 36.8 Elena Ln (299) 7th AVE SE 7th AVE SE 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 33.4 30.5 - 36.3 Field Street (305) Field ST St Ben Complex 0.09 Asphalt Smooth 31.9 28.6 - 35.0
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 25 Saint Joseph: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Field Street (306) St Ben Complex Field ST 0.17 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.2 26.7 - 29.5 Field Street (307) Field ST Field ST 0.15 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.9 24.5 - 29.3 Fortitude Senior Living (308) 7th AVE SE 7th AVE SE 0.12 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.6 15.3 - 25.8 Fortitude Senior Living (309) 7th AVE SE 7th AVE SE 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 30.1 26.0 - 34.0 Graceview Estates (326) 4th Ave SE 7th AVE SE 0.32 Asphalt Smooth 40.5 39.4 - 41.5 Graceview Estates (327) Graceview Loop 4th Ave SE 0.34 Asphalt Smooth 39.5 27.3 - 51.7 Graceview Estates (328) 7th AVE SE Graceview Dr N 0.20 Asphalt Fair 53.6 43.3 - 63.7 Hallow Park (344) 5th Ave NW 6th Ave 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 31.1 30.1 - 32.0 Indian Hill Park (375) E Cedar St Fir St E 0.09 Asphalt Rough 74.1 68.8 - 79.4 Klinefelter Park (380) Klinefelter WAY Klinefelter WAY 0.55 Asphalt Very Rough 99.4 85.5 - 113.2 Klinefelter Park (381) 12th Ave SE 12th Ave SE 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.6 18.4 - 40.7 Klinefelter Park (382) Klinefelter WAY Klinefelter WAY 0.06 Asphalt Rough 72.2 63.1 - 81.2 Lake Wobegon Trail (404) CSAH 2 Northland Dr 0.46 Asphalt Smooth 43.9 25.2 - 62.5 Lake Wobegon Trail (405) 8th Ave NE CSAH 133 0.24 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.4 24.4 - 28.2 Lake Wobegon Trail (406) CSAH 2 1st Ave NW 0.21 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.6 23.2 - 32.0 Lake Wobegon Trail (407) Northland Dr 8th Ave NE 0.17 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.5 20.8 - 32.0 Lake Wobegon Trail (408) County Road 134 CSAH 133 0.63 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.8 21.8 - 23.6 Liberty Pointe (431) 18th Ave SE 18th Ave SE 0.19 Asphalt Fair 52.1 44.9 - 59.2 Liberty Pointe (432) 18th Ave SE Jefferson Dr 0.06 Asphalt Rough 65.3 41.4 - 89.2 Liberty Pointe (433) Jefferson Dr Jefferson Dr 0.17 Asphalt Rough 66.3 39.8 - 92.8 Liberty Pointe (434) Jefferson Dr Jefferson Dr 0.02 Asphalt Fair 46.9 31.4 - 62.2 Liberty Pointe (435) 16th Ave SE Jefferson Dr 0.12 Asphalt Fair 51.2 40.9 - 61.4 Little Saint Academy (445) Callaway ST E Callaway ST E 0.14 Asphalt Very Rough 79.8 51.7 - 107.8 Little Saint Academy (446) E Baker St 2nd Ave SE 0.11 Asphalt Rough 63.3 63.1 - 63.3 Little Saints Academy (447) Callaway ST E E Baker St 0.15 Asphalt Very Rough 81.9 55.9 - 107.8 Millstream (454) Minnesota St Minnesota St 0.27 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.9 23.1 - 24.6 Northland Heights (469) Iris La Iris La 0.05 Asphalt Fair 59.8 17.2 - 102.4 Northland Park (470) Hickory St E Hickory St E 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 30.5 29.3 - 31.5 Northland Park (471) Iris La Iris La 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 34.4 22.4 - 46.3 Northland Park (472) Gum Tree St E Gum Tree St E 0.03 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.1 22.2 - 35.9 Northland Plat Six (473) Iris La Jasmine La 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 44.0 35.4 - 52.4 Saint Joseph Park and Ride (632) Minnesota St CSAH 2 0.64 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.5 18.8 - 24.1 Water Tower Park (698) College AVE N CSAH 2 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 32.8 25.7 - 39.9
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
26 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Sartell Segment: Segment Ratings
System Summary:
Very Smooth 8.6 miles 32% Smooth 8.1 miles 30% Fair 5.7 miles 21% Rough 2.3 miles 9% Very Rough 2.1 miles 8%
Not Rated 0.1 miles 0%
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 12th Street N (5) 12th St N 12th St N 0.19 Asphalt Fair 58.6 36.8 - 80.3 12th Street N (6) 12th St N 12th St N 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.4 18.3 - 40.3 12th Street N (7) 12th St N 12th St N 0.12 Asphalt Fair 56.2 48.5 - 63.7 12th Street N (8) 12th St N 12th St N 0.12 Asphalt Smooth 34.7 30.7 - 38.7 15th St S (9) Pine Cone RD Pine Siskin Ave 0.22 Asphalt Smooth 41.6 27.8 - 55.2 15th St S (10) Pine Siskin Ave Oriole Ave 0.05 Asphalt Smooth 41.3 0.9 - 81.5 15th St S (11) Oriole Ave Nightingale Ave 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 32.8 27.3 - 38.1 15th St S (12) 15th ST S Morning Glory Ave 0.12 Asphalt Smooth 38.3 27.4 - 49.1 15th St S (13) Morning Glory Ave Lavender AVE S 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.2 23.0 - 23.4 15th St S (14) 15th ST S Killdeer AVE 0.05 Asphalt Fair 53.3 46.8 - 59.7 15th St S (15) Killdeer AVE 19th AVE S 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 31.8 29.6 - 33.9 19th Ave N (24) 7th St N 19th Ave N 0.09 Asphalt Rough 66.4 57.5 - 75.3 19th Ave N (25) 10th St 65th Ave 0.13 Asphalt Smooth 40.8 37.6 - 43.8 19th Ave N (26) 19th Ave N 10th St 0.13 Asphalt Rough 60.6 3.7 - 117.4 19th Ave N (27) 19th Ave N 4th St N 0.11 Asphalt Very Rough 100.7 84.3 - 117.1 19th Ave N (28) 11th St N 19th AVE N 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 33.1 22.3 - 43.8 19th Ave N (29) 19th Ave N 19th Ave N 0.06 Asphalt Fair 52.9 45.6 - 60.0 19th Ave N (30) 19th Ave N 19th Ave N 0.23 Asphalt Very Rough 77.8 70.8 - 84.7 19th Ave N (31) 4th St N 19th Ave N 0.11 Asphalt Very Rough 112.4 66.8 - 158.0 19th Ave N (32) 19th Ave N 19th Ave 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 44.0 36.9 - 51.1 19th Ave N (33) 19th Ave Boulder Dr 0.04 Asphalt Rough 60.5 0.0 - 122.3 19th Ave N (34) Boulder Dr 1st ST N 0.14 Asphalt Fair 55.4 52.7 - 57.9
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 27 Sartell: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 2 1/2 St N (35) 2 1/2 St N Sierra Loop 0.22 Asphalt Fair 46.9 37.2 - 56.5 2 1/2 St N (36) Pine Cone RD 2 1/2 St N 0.06 Asphalt Fair 58.6 43.4 - 73.8 2 1/2 St N (37) 10th Ave N 9th Ave N 0.07 Asphalt Fair 55.5 31.6 - 79.2 2 1/2 St N (38) 17th Ave N 2 1/2 St N 0.11 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.4 20.3 - 32.4 2 1/2 St N (39) Sierra Loop 17th Ave N 0.26 Asphalt Smooth 35.2 20.6 - 49.7 2 1/2 St N (40) Sierra Loop Sierra Loop 0.06 Asphalt Fair 49.3 36.4 - 62.2 2 1/2 St N (41) 2 1/2 St N 2 1/2 St N 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 40.6 40.5 - 40.7 2 1/2 St N (42) 2 1/2 St N 2 1/2 St N 0.06 Asphalt Fair 55.4 51.9 - 58.7 2 1/2 St N (43) 2 1/2 St N 10th Ave N 0.05 Asphalt Rough 60.7 37.1 - 84.1 23rd St S (46) 23rd St S 23rd St S 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 34.3 33.4 - 35.0 23rd St S (47) Pine Cone RD 8th Ave S 0.09 Asphalt Smooth 36.5 33.5 - 39.4 2nd Ave N (51) 2nd Ave N 7th St N 0.24 Asphalt Very Rough 99.9 94.2 - 105.4 2nd St S (61) 13th Ave 2nd ST S 0.17 Asphalt Smooth 30.5 26.6 - 34.4 2nd St S (62) 13th Ave 2nd ST S 0.30 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.4 21.0 - 25.7 2nd St S (63) Sartell St 2nd ST S 0.28 Asphalt Rough 60.7 38.3 - 83 2nd St S (64) Pine Cone RD 2nd ST S 0.19 Asphalt Fair 48.2 24.8 - 71.6 2nd St S (65) Dezurk St 2nd ST S 0.07 Asphalt Fair 53.7 31.6 - 75.7 2nd St S (66) Zakrajshek Ct S 2nd ST S 0.05 Asphalt Fair 46.3 34.4 - 58.0 2nd St S (67) 2nd ST S 2nd ST S 0.05 Asphalt Fair 48.2 6.6 - 89.8 2nd St S (68) 2nd ST S 2nd ST S 0.15 Asphalt Fair 53.2 47.5 - 58.8 35th St N (89) 35th ST N Clemson Ave N 0.11 Asphalt Smooth 41.4 40.0 - 42.6 35th St N (90) Clemson Ave N Southbridge Ave N 0.05 Asphalt Fair 48.0 14.3 - 81.6 35th St N (91) 35th ST N Waterford Ave 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.2 27.5 - 28.7 35th St N (92) Waterford Ave 35th ST N 0.05 Asphalt Smooth 38.1 37.4 - 38.7 35th St N (93) 35th ST N 35th ST N 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 42.4 29.1 - 55.7 35th St N (94) Pine Cone RD 35th ST N 0.20 Asphalt Smooth 31.2 27.1 - 35.1 3rd Ave N (95) 5th St N 3rd Ave N 0.10 Asphalt Very Rough 102.2 100.2 - 104.1 4th Ave S (98) 4th AVE S 3rd St S 0.10 Asphalt Smooth 34.2 29.6 - 38.6 4th Ave S (99) 4th AVE S 4th AVE S 0.72 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.1 22.0 - 28.2 4th St N (101) 4th St N 4th St N 0.09 Asphalt Very Rough 81.5 52.6 - 110.3 5th St N (102) 5th St N 5th St N 0.14 Asphalt Very Rough 91.4 76.8 - 105.9 5th St N (103) 5th St N 5th St N 0.49 Asphalt Smooth 39.1 36.3 - 41.9 5th St N (104) 5th St N 5th St N 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 101.0 74.0 - 128 5th St N (105) Pine Cone RD 5th St N 0.04 Asphalt Rough 66.8 19.1 - 114.3 5th St N (106) 2nd Ave N 5th St N 0.07 Asphalt Rough 75.0 65.5 - 84.4 7th St N (109) 7th St N 7th St N 0.45 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.1 23.1 - 25.1
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
28 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Sartell: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 7th St N (110) 7th St N Pine Cone RD 0.20 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.8 24.1 - 27.5 7th St N (111) 7th St N 7th St N 0.23 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.4 22.8 - 31.9 8th Ave S (112) 8th Ave S 8th Ave S 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.6 21.3 - 37.8 Avalon Village (129) Kings Way Kings Way 0.02 Asphalt Rough 68.6 6.3 - 130.7 Avalon Village (130) 3rd St N 4th ST N 0.12 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.9 23.3 - 36.3 Avalon Village (131) Queens Ct Queens Ct 0.03 Asphalt Fair 48.5 35.9 - 61.0 Avalon Village (132) Kings Way 3rd St N 0.11 Asphalt Rough 67.7 51.1 - 84.2 Avalon Village (133) Queens Ct 3rd St N 0.10 Asphalt Smooth 44.7 43.7 - 45.5 Avalon Village (134) 3rd St N Avalon Ct 0.06 Asphalt Fair 45.3 35.3 - 55.2 Bernicks Pepsi Arena (168) 16th St S 16th St S 0.03 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.2 23.1 - 27.2 Bernicks Pepsi Arena (169) 16th St S Pine Cone RD 0.15 Asphalt Smooth 37.1 33.3 - 40.8 Blackberry Ridge Estates (170) 35th ST N Blackberry Cir 0.71 Asphalt Rough 66.6 48.6 - 84.5 Blackberry Ridge Estates (171) Blackberry Cir Blackberry Cir 0.11 Asphalt Fair 54.2 37.4 - 71.0 Blackberry Ridge Estates (172) 33rd St Blackberry Cir 0.06 Asphalt Fair 52.0 34 - 69.8 Blackberry Ridge Estates (173) Blackberry Cir 34th St 0.11 Asphalt Fair 54.2 48.4 - 59.8 Brianna Dr (180) Brianna Dr Brianna Dr 0.14 Asphalt Smooth 43.9 20.6 - 67.1 Brianna Dr (181) Brianna Dr Brianna Dr 0.10 Asphalt Fair 46.9 34.2 - 59.4 City Hall (204) Sierra Ct Pine Cone RD 0.12 Asphalt Smooth 37.7 35.0 - 40.4 City Hall Trail (205) Pine Cone RD 2 1/2 St N 0.10 Asphalt Fair 53.2 50.1 - 56.1 City Hall Trail (206) Pine Cone RD 16th St S 0.28 Asphalt Smooth 31.5 28.7 - 34.1 CO RD 78 (217) 2nd St S Riverside AVE S 0.09 Concrete Fair 55.2 47.6 - 62.6 CO RD 78 (218) Riverside AVE S Riverside AVE S 0.04 Concrete Fair 45.7 30.9 - 60.4 Connecticut Ave S (240) 23rd St S Connecticut Ave 0.21 Asphalt Smooth 35.7 33.5 - 37.7 Connecticut Ave S (241) Connecticut Ave Connecticut Ave 0.03 Asphalt Very Rough 115.7 0.0 - 240.0 Connecticut Ave S (242) Connecticut Ave 19th St S 0.18 Asphalt Smooth 39.5 29.4 - 49.5 Connecticut Ave S (243) Connecticut Ave Connecticut Ave 0.07 Concrete Rough 69.6 61.3 - 77.8 Connecticut Ave S (244) Dehler Dr 23rd St S 0.27 Asphalt Smooth 35.5 28.8 - 42.1 Connecticut Ave S (245) Connecticut Ave Connecticut Ave 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 37.5 34.9 - 40.1 CR 1 (254) Riverside AVE S Heritage DR 0.05 Asphalt Smooth 35.2 34.0 - 36.4 CR 1 (255) Evergreen DR Heritage DR 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 36.0 26.6 - 45.4 CR 1 (256) Evergreen DR Riverside AVE S 0.14 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.5 24.1 - 24.9 CR 1 (257) Riverside AVE S Riverside AVE S 0.13 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.3 18.1 - 30.3 CR 1 (258) CSAH 1 CSAH 1 0.33 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.1 25.1 - 30.9 CR 1 (259) CSAH 1 CSAH 1 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 30.1 22.8 - 37.2 CR 120 (262) 20th St N 20th St N 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.7 22.1 - 37.3 CR 120 (263) CSAH 120 CSAH 120 0.02 Concrete Smooth 35.1 34.5 - 35.7
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 29 Sartell: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. CR 120 (264) CSAH 120 CSAH 120 0.08 Concrete Smooth 31.7 30.2 - 33.0 CR 120 (265) CSAH 120 CSAH 120 0.02 Concrete Very Smooth 23.6 13.3 - 33.8 CR 120 (266) Connecticut Ave CSAH 120 0.09 Concrete Very Smooth 27.9 17.9 - 37.9 CR 120 (267) CSAH 120 Dolores DR 0.02 Concrete Smooth 38.5 30.7 - 46.3 CR 120 (268) Dolores DR County Road 134 0.01 Concrete Fair 46.0 32.9 - 58.9 CR 120 (269) County Road 134 CSAH 1 0.18 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.3 22.9 - 29.5 CR 133 (272) Heritage DR Pine Cone RD 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 31.8 31.7 - 31.9 CR 133 (273) Pine Cone RD Victory Ave 0.24 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.8 22.8 - 24.6 CR 133 (274) Heritage DR Victory Ave 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 35.1 22.4 - 47.7 CR 133 (275) 19th AVE S Heritage DR 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 30.9 25.7 - 36.0 Cypress Park (286) 5th St N 19th Ave N 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 34.4 30.3 - 38.5 Dehler Dr (287) Dehler Dr Dehler Dr 0.20 Asphalt Smooth 32.0 29.0 - 34.8 Dehler Dr (288) Dehler Dr Dehler Dr 0.09 Asphalt Fair 53.8 42.4 - 65.1 Eagle Creek Hydro (293) Riverside AVE N Riverside AVE N 0.09 Asphalt Fair 59.4 40.9 - 77.8 Eastside Kiddie Park (295) 2nd Ave 2nd Ave 0.00 Concrete Smooth * NA Edgewood Senior Living (296) Brianna Dr Brianna Dr 0.10 Asphalt Smooth 30.2 29.3 - 31.1 Edgewood Senior Living (297) Roberts RD Roberts RD 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 32.7 32.7 - 32.7 Ferche South Pinecone (302) Wyoming Ct Troop DR 0.06 Asphalt Rough 62.7 18.9 - 106.4 Ferche South Pinecone (303) Wyoming Ct Wyoming Ct 0.09 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.3 25.2 - 29.4 Ferche South Pinecone (304) Vermont Dr Wyoming Ct 0.09 Asphalt Very Rough 79.0 67.0 - 90.9 Geoffrey Park Trail (318) Tennessee Dr Utah Rd 0.12 Asphalt Smooth 42.2 29.8 - 54.6 Grizzly Ln (340) 20th Ave N 19th Ave N 0.15 Asphalt Very Rough 84.1 43.7 - 124.4 Grizzly Ln (341) Grizzly La Grizzly La 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 38.0 22.0 - 53.9 Grizzly Ln (342) Grizzly La 20th Ave N 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 39.0 20.1 - 57.9 Grizzly Ln (343) 21st Ave N Grizzly La 0.02 Asphalt Fair 50.6 44.6 - 56.6 Heritage Dr (351) 7th Ave S Heritage DR 0.52 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.9 22.1 - 25.6 Heritage Dr (352) Heritage DR 7th Ave S 0.35 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.9 22.5 - 29.3 Heritage Dr (353) 50th AVE Huntington Dr 0.14 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.8 20.4 - 39.0 Huntington Park (370) Huntington Dr Connecticut Ave 0.25 Asphalt Smooth 37.2 32.5 - 41.8 Huntington Park (371) Connecticut Ave Pheasant Dr 0.08 Asphalt Fair 52.6 23.3 - 81.8 Huntington Park (372) Connecticut Ave Connecticut Ave 0.07 Asphalt Fair 45.1 31.7 - 58.4 Lake Francis Trail (384) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.63 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.4 29.4 - 29.4 Lake Francis Trail (385) 19th ST S 19th ST S 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 40.2 27.6 - 52.8 Lake Francis Trail (386) 19th ST S 19th ST S 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 41.0 22.3 - 59.6 Leander Ave (427) 50th AVE Roberts RD 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 30.7 26.4 - 34.8 Leander Ave (428) 50th AVE 23rd St S 0.02 Concrete Smooth 39.6 37.2 - 41.9
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
30 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Sartell: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Leander Ave (429) 50th AVE 50th AVE 0.02 Concrete Smooth 35.3 18.2 - 52.4 Leander Ave (430) 50th AVE 50th AVE 0.02 Concrete Smooth 41.1 20.3 - 61.9 Lions Park Trail (442) Pine Cone RD 1st St N 0.18 Asphalt Fair 47.7 46.0 - 49.2 Lions Park Trail (443) 1st St N Pine Cone RD 0.10 Asphalt Fair 53.9 53.8 - 53.9 Meadow Lake Park (452) 10th St S 10th St S 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA Natures Edge Park (466) 3rd St S 3rd St S 0.01 Asphalt Fair * NA Northside Park (474) 9th St N Meadowland Ct 0.14 Asphalt Very Rough 84.1 44.3 - 123.7 Oak Ridge Elementary School (486) 27th ST N 27th ST N 0.45 Asphalt Fair 48.1 33.5 - 62.7 Oak Ridge Elementary School (487) 27th ST N 27th ST N 0.13 Asphalt Fair 46.3 26.4 - 66.2 Pine Meadow Elementary (508) Pine Cone RD 5th St N 0.19 Asphalt Fair 52.2 50.0 - 54.4 Pine Meadow Elementary School (509) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.01 Asphalt Smooth 43.5 17.2 - 69.7 Pine Meadow Elementary School (510) 7th St N 7th St N 0.09 Asphalt Smooth 41.4 22.1 - 60.7 Pine Tree Pond Park (511) 5th St N 5th St N 0.01 Asphalt Fair 56.6 40.5 - 72.7 Pinecone Central Park (512) Pine Cone Central BLVD Pine Cone Central BLVD 0.02 Asphalt Very Rough 80.7 76.6 - 84.8 Pinecone Central Park (513) Pine Cone Central BLVD Pine Cone Central BLVD 0.17 Asphalt Smooth 30.2 29.5 - 30.8 Pinecone Central Park (514) Pine Cone Central BLVD Pine Cone Central BLVD 0.25 Concrete Very Smooth 26.9 26.2 - 27.4 Pinecone Central Park (516) Pine Cone Central BLVD Pine Cone Central BLVD 0.17 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.9 21.6 - 26.1 Pinecone Central Park (517) Pine Cone Central BLVD Pine Cone Central BLVD 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.8 17.9 - 31.6 Pinecone Road N (519) 1st St N Pine Cone RD 0.34 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.1 25.5 - 26.5 Pinecone Road N (520) 7th St N 12th St N 0.53 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.4 21.8 - 28.8 Pinecone Road N (521) Pine Cone RD 1st St N 0.12 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.0 16.8 - 39.2 Pinecone Road N (522) 4th St N Pine Cone RD 0.12 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.0 20.6 - 23.3 Pinecone Road N (523) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.21 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.3 18.8 - 21.6 Pinecone Road N (524) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.02 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.9 0.0 - 53.2 Pinecone Road N (525) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.23 Asphalt Very Smooth 18.8 16.2 - 21.3 Pinecone Road N (526) 12th St N Pine Cone RD 0.24 Asphalt Very Smooth 18.6 18.2 - 18.9 Pinecone Road N (527) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.25 Asphalt Smooth 33.3 30.9 - 35.6 Pinecone Road N (528) 5th St N Pine Cone RD 0.11 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.4 20.2 - 22.6 Pinecone Road N (529) 16th St S 2nd ST S 0.15 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.7 22.9 - 34.3 Pinecone Road S (532) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.30 Asphalt Fair 45.7 37.6 - 53.7 Pinecone Road S (533) 2nd ST S Pine Cone RD 0.19 Asphalt Smooth 33.7 25.7 - 41.6 Pinecone Road S (534) Sundance Rd Pine Cone RD 0.14 Asphalt Fair 52.6 48.0 - 57.1 Pinecone Road S (535) Pine Cone RD Scout DR 0.21 Asphalt Fair 52.2 38.4 - 65.9 Pinecone Road S (536) Scout DR Pine Cone RD 0.34 Asphalt Fair 49.6 39.1 - 60.0
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 31 Sartell: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Pinecone Road S (537) Pine Cone RD 20th St N 0.15 Asphalt Fair 48.8 47.1 - 50.4 Pinecone Road S (538) Pine Cone RD Heritage DR 0.18 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.3 22.5 - 36.1 Pinecone Road S (539) Heritage DR Pine Cone RD 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.1 26.0 - 32.1 Pinecone Road S (540) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.40 Asphalt Fair 54.2 37.4 - 70.9 Pinecone Road S (541) Pine Cone RD Pine Cone RD 0.13 Asphalt Smooth 30.5 29.1 - 31.9 Regional Medical Arts Campus (561) Connecticut Ave 19th St S 0.10 Asphalt Rough 66.0 48.2 - 83.6 Regional Medical Arts Campus (562) 19th St S Amber Ave 0.27 Asphalt Very Rough 91.7 67.5 - 115.7 Riverview Int (587) 2nd Ave N 2nd Ave N 0.01 Asphalt Closed due to COVID-19 Riverview Int (588) 2nd Ave N 2nd Ave N 0.01 Asphalt Closed due to COVID-19 Riverview Int (589) 7th St N 2nd Ave N 0.08 Asphalt Closed due to COVID-19 Riverview Int (590) 2nd Ave N 2nd Ave N 0.01 Asphalt Closed due to COVID-19 Roberts Rd (591) 7th Ave S Pine Cone RD 0.72 Asphalt Smooth 30.7 21.0 - 40.3 Roberts Rd (592) Pine Cone RD Roberts RD 0.15 Asphalt Fair 47.3 43.7 - 50.7 Roberts Rd (593) 7th Ave S Heritage DR 0.25 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.6 26.6 - 32.5 Rolling Meadows East Park (601) 9th Ave N 4th St N 0.04 Asphalt Fair 47.4 31.8 - 62.9 Rolling Meadows East Park (602) 4th St N 9th Ave N 0.04 Asphalt Fair 54.0 14.8 - 93.0 Rolling Meadows East Park (603) 10th Ave N 10th Ave N 0.20 Asphalt Very Rough 78.9 72.1 - 85.6 Rolling Meadows West Park (604) 10th Ave N 10th Ave N 0.03 Asphalt Fair 45.3 40.5 - 50.0 Rolling Meadows West Park (605) 4th St N 4th St N 0.02 Asphalt Fair 46.8 30.2 - 63.2 Rolling Meadows West Park (606) 4th St N Elenor Ct 0.05 Asphalt Rough 65.2 27.0 - 103.3 Rolling Meadows West Park (607) Lawrence St 5th St N 0.03 Asphalt Very Rough 87.7 79.5 - 95.9 Rolling Meadows West Park (608) 11th Ave N 11th Ave N 0.03 Asphalt Fair 52.6 51.4 - 53.7 Rolling Meadows West Park (609) 2 1/2 St N 2 1/2 St N 0.23 Asphalt Rough 67.4 64.5 - 70.2 Sabre Oaks Park (629) 3rd St S 3rd St S 0.00 Asphalt Rough * NA Sandstone Loop N (633) Sandstone LOOP N Sandstone LOOP N 0.03 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.6 15.9 - 35.1 Sartell Middle School (634) 7th St N 7th St N 0.11 Asphalt Very Rough 78.5 55.5 - 101.4 Sartell School (635) 3rd Ave N 2nd Ave N 0.02 Asphalt Rough 61.6 33.5 - 89.6 Sauk River Regional Park (643) Dolores DR Dolores DR 0.06 Asphalt Smooth 35.1 † School (647) 7th St N 7th St N 0.01 Asphalt Smooth 39.3 32.4 - 46.0 School (648) 7th St N 7th St N 0.01 Asphalt Very Rough 90.3 10.7 - 169.9 Scout Dr (649) Pine Cone RD Scout DR 0.33 Asphalt Smooth 42.8 42.4 - 43.2 Scout Dr (650) Scout DR Scout DR 0.16 Asphalt Smooth 43.7 18.9 - 68.5
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
32 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Sartell: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Scout Dr (651) Scout DR Scout DR 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.4 26.1 - 28.7 Scout Dr (652) Scout DR Scout DR 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.8 23.3 - 30.3 Val Smith Park (691) 4th Ave NE 4th Ave NE 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.6 17.3 - 41.9 Val Smith Park (692) 4th Ave NE 1st St NE 0.24 Asphalt Smooth 30.5 27.9 - 33.1 Val Smith Park (693) 4th Ave NE 4th Ave NE 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 40.2 31.1 - 49.2 Val Smith Park (694) Park Ave Park Ave 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 37.4 18.8 - 55.9 Val Smith Park (695) Park Ave Park Ave 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 40.7 39.8 - 41.4 Victory Ave S (696) Victory Ave Victory Ave 0.11 Asphalt Smooth 37.9 37.3 - 38.5 Victory Ave S (697) 5th ST S Victory Ave 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 33.5 29.4 - 37.6 Wilds (760) 19th Ave N Falcon Ct 0.06 Asphalt Rough 60.3 50.6 - 69.9 Wilds Park North Trail (761) Grizzly La Cougar La 0.14 Asphalt Fair 50.0 43.2 - 56.6 Wilds Park North Trail (762) Cougar La 18th Ave N 0.17 Asphalt Rough 73.9 56.7 - 91
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 33 Sauk Rapids: Segment Ratings
System Summary:
Very Smooth 0.4 miles 4% Smooth 3.4 miles 35% Fair 4.5 miles 46% Rough 0.7 miles 7% Very Rough 0.7 miles 8%
Not Rated 0 miles 0%
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 10th St NE (Co Rd 46) (1) 10th ST NE Hillside Dr 0.12 Asphalt Smooth 39.5 35.7 - 43.2 10th St NE (Co Rd 46) (2) 10th ST NE 15th St NE 0.15 Asphalt Fair 46.7 30.3 - 63.0 10th St NE (Co Rd 46) (3) 10th ST NE 10th ST NE 0.11 Asphalt Fair 48.1 40.8 - 55.3 10th St NE (Co Rd 46) (4) Strawberry Ct Garden Brook Dr 0.04 Asphalt Rough 61.4 57.5 - 65.2 2nd St N (52) 3rd Ave N Golden Spike RD NE 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.1 7.1 - 37.0 2nd St N (53) Golden Spike RD NE Golden Spike RD NE 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.0 22.1 - 31.7 2nd St N (54) 5th Ave N 6th AVE N 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.8 20.1 - 25.4 2nd St N (55) 6th AVE N Golden Spike RD NE 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 33.6 0.0 - 83.5 2nd St N (56) 7th Ave N Golden Spike RD NE 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 18.4 8.6 - 28.1 2nd St N (57) Golden Spike RD NE Golden Spike RD NE 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.0 14.3 - 33.7 2nd St N (58) 9th Ave N Summit AVE N 0.08 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.9 23.3 - 24.3 2nd St N (59) Summit AVE N Golden Spike RD NE 0.25 Asphalt Smooth 30.6 22.4 - 38.8 2nd St N (60) Golden Spike RD NE Golden Spike RD NE 0.13 Asphalt Smooth 30.9 22.5 - 39.2 Benedict Acres Park (163) 10th Ave N Benedict Dr 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 36.5 27.1 - 45.7 Benton Dr S (164) Benton Dr S Benton Dr S 0.06 Concrete Smooth 38.5 33.8 - 43.1 Benton Dr S (165) Benton Dr S 7th St S 0.07 Concrete Smooth 42.3 36.9 - 47.6 Benton Dr S (166) Benton Dr S Benton Dr S 0.13 Concrete Smooth 30.3 24.0 - 36.5 Benton Dr S (167) Summit Ave NE Benton Dr S 0.04 Concrete Fair 47.0 39.4 - 54.5 Church Hill East Trail (195) Olympus DR NE Olympus DR NE 0.43 Asphalt Smooth 39.3 31.3 - 47.3 Church Hill East Trail (196) Orchid Dr NE Orchid Dr NE 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 38.8 7.5 - 70.0 Church Hill Heights Park (197) Ocarnia Dr Ocarnia Dr 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 40.9 35.8 - 46.0 Church Hill Heights Trail (198) Ocarnia Dr Olive La 0.30 Asphalt Fair 50.9 42.5 - 59.1
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
34 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Sauk Rapids: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Church Hill Heights Trail (199) Ocarnia Dr Ocarnia Dr 0.03 Asphalt Fair 51.2 45.5 - 56.7 Church Hill Heights Trail (200) Ocarnia Dr Olive La 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 44.8 35.5 - 54.0 Church Hill Heights Trail (201) Ocarnia Dr Ocarnia Dr 0.01 Asphalt Fair 46.7 19.5 - 73.8 Church Hill Heights Trail (202) Ocarnia Dr Ocarnia Dr 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 39.6 37.5 - 41.7 Church Hill Heights Trail (203) Olive La Olive La 0.03 Asphalt Rough 61.6 59.4 - 63.7 Eastern Star Trail (294) Eastern Star Cir 18th St N 0.56 Asphalt Fair 47.8 40.5 - 55.1 Fairview Farms Trail (300) Owl St NE Owl St NE 0.05 Asphalt Rough 60.3 41.6 - 78.9 Fairview Farms Trail (301) Oxen Tr NE Owl St NE 0.13 Asphalt Very Rough 76.0 65.1 - 86.8 Garden Brook Trail (310) Fieldstone Dr Fieldstone Dr 0.02 Asphalt Fair 57.9 32.2 - 83.4 Garden Brook Trail (311) Garden Brook Dr Hillside Dr 0.10 Asphalt Fair 54.1 48.8 - 59.3 Garden Brook Trail (312) Strawberry Ct Garden Brook Dr 0.05 Asphalt Fair 52.4 44.7 - 59.9 Garden Brook Trail (313) Fieldstone Dr Fieldstone Dr 0.01 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA Garden Brook Trail (314) Fieldstone Dr Garden Brook Dr 0.26 Asphalt Rough 63.3 61.9 - 64.6 Garden Brook Trail (315) Garden Brook Dr Garden Brook Dr 0.21 Asphalt Fair 48.3 40.1 - 56.5 Garden Brook Trail (316) Garden Brook Dr Garden Brook Dr 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 32.5 28.8 - 36.1 Garden Brook Trail (317) Fieldstone Dr Fieldstone Dr 0.21 Asphalt Very Rough 79.3 51.2 - 107.3 Helix (350) N River Ave 2nd St N 0.08 Concrete Fair 48.7 37.9 - 59.3 Island View Park (376) N River Ave MNTH 15 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 37.5 31.1 - 43.8 Little Acorn Park (444) Oak Crest Dr Oak Crest Dr 0.04 Asphalt Rough 68.6 53.4 - 83.7 Oak Lane Park (483) Oak La Oak La 0.11 Asphalt Fair 58.8 50.7 - 66.7 Osauka Road NE (491) Osauka Rd NE Osauka Rd NE 0.23 Asphalt Fair 47.1 43.9 - 50.1 Osauka Road NE (492) Mayhew Lake RD NE Osauka Rd NE 0.21 Asphalt Fair 52.8 48.7 - 56.8 Osauka Road NE (493) Osauka Rd NE Osauka Rd NE 0.09 Asphalt Fair 50.6 43.6 - 57.4 Oxcart Trail (494) N River Ave N River Ave 0.16 Asphalt Fair 50.2 23.7 - 76.5 Oxcart Trail (495) N River Ave N River Ave 0.19 Asphalt Smooth 42.1 29.9 - 54.1 Oxcart Trail (496) N River Ave N River Ave 0.23 Asphalt Fair 52.6 50.0 - 55.0 Oxcart Trail (497) N River Ave 10th St N 0.12 Asphalt Very Rough 92.8 69 - 116.4 Oxcart Trail (498) N River Ave N River Ave 0.10 Asphalt Very Rough 103.9 73.1 - 134.6 Oxcart Trail (499) N River Ave N River Ave 0.21 Asphalt Smooth 37.1 36.3 - 37.7 Oxcart Trail (500) 10th ST N N River Ave 0.09 Asphalt Rough 71.2 59.7 - 82.7 Oxcart Trail (501) N River Ave N River Ave 0.02 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.4 5.4 - 39.2 Oxcart Trail (502) N River Ave River Ave S 0.26 Asphalt Fair 58.5 46.0 - 70.9 Oxcart Trail (503) PVT-11 N River Ave 0.48 Asphalt Fair 53.9 52.3 - 55.5 Prairie Lane Trail (545) 6th Ave N 12th St N 0.08 Asphalt Very Rough 85.1 72.4 - 97.7 Prairie Lane Trail (546) Avian Pkwy Allisons Mdw 0.65 Asphalt Smooth 41.9 39.1 - 44.6 Prairie Lane Trail (547) Avian Pkwy Avian Pkwy 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 30.7 28.7 - 32.6
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 35 Sauk Rapids: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Prairie Lane Trail (548) Havens Moor Havens Moor 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 30.1 26.7 - 33.5 Prairie Lane Trail (549) Rosewood La Rosewood La 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 34.8 28.4 - 41.1 Prairie Lane Trail (550) Schooners End Schooners End 0.03 Asphalt Smooth 39.5 11.7 - 67.2 Prairie Lane Trail (551) Wildflower La Wildflower La 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 30.7 26.8 - 34.4 Prairie Lane Trail (552) Allisons Mdw Praire La 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 41.0 22.7 - 59.2 Prairie Lane Trail (553) 18th St N Avian Pkwy 0.07 Asphalt Fair 59.0 31.6 - 86.3 Prairie Lane Trail (554) Allisons Mdw 18th St N 0.06 Asphalt Rough 65.2 40.3 - 89.9 Sauk Rapids Bridge (636) 2nd St N 6th Ave N 0.25 Concrete Smooth 43.4 40.9 - 45.8 Sauk Rapids Bridge (637) Benton DR N CSAH 1 0.31 Concrete Fair 47.1 46.6 - 47.4 Sauk Rapids Bridge (638) Benton Dr N 2nd St N 0.08 Concrete Rough 72.0 49.8 - 94.2 Sauk Rapids High School (639) Osauka Rd NE Osauka Rd NE 0.07 Concrete Smooth 35.0 28.3 - 41.6 Sauk Rapids High School (640) Osauka Rd NE Osauka Rd NE 0.07 Concrete Smooth 36.4 30.1 - 42.6 Sauk Rapids High School (641) Osauka Rd NE Osauka Rd NE 0.23 Concrete Fair 48.6 46.7 - 50.4 Sauk Rapids Middle School (642) 10th Ave S 10th Ave S 0.15 Asphalt Fair 51.6 34.4 - 68.7 Scenic View Park (644) 6th St N 6th St N 0.02 Asphalt Rough 68.0 63.2 - 72.7 Scenic View Park (645) 8th St N 8th St N 0.03 Asphalt Rough 67.0 50.5 - 83.4 Scenic View Park (646) 7th Ave N 7th Ave N 0.03 Asphalt Rough 60.4 59.2 - 61.5 Southside Park (656) N River Ave N River Ave 0.17 Concrete Smooth 38.5 34.8 - 42.2 Summit Ave S (663) Golden Spike RD NE Summit Ave S 0.28 Concrete Fair 56.7 56.3 - 57 Summit Ave S (664) Cross St S Summit Ave S 0.05 Concrete Very Rough 81.8 66.2 - 97.2 Summit Ave S (665) 1/2 St S Summit Ave S 0.04 Concrete Very Rough 85.6 76 - 95.2
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
36 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Stearns County: Segment Ratings
System Summary:
Very Smooth 8.7 miles 73% Smooth 1.7 miles 14% Fair 1.1 miles 9% Rough 0.5 miles 4%
Very Rough 0 miles 0% Not Rated 0 miles 0%
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I.
Rockville Country Side (253) Cypress Ct Ptarmigan Dr 0.08 Asphalt Fair 56.0 49.0 - 62.8 Pleasant Lake Lions Park (542) Lake Rd White Oak Rd 0.59 Asphalt Smooth 37.4 34.0 - 40.8 Pleasant Lake Lions Park (543) White Oak Rd White Oak Rd 0.07 Asphalt Fair 59.0 52.1 - 65.8 Pleasant Lake Lions Park (544) White Oak Rd Lake Rd 0.32 Asphalt Fair 47.0 27.6 - 66.4 Rockville DT (595) Chestnut St Mill St 0.13 Asphalt Smooth 34.2 25.2 - 43.1 Rockville DT (596) Broadway St Broadway St 0.11 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.8 23.8 - 27.7 Rockville DT (597) Cedar St Elm St 0.07 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.7 26.1 - 27.1 Rockville DT (598) Broadway St Pine St 0.07 Asphalt Smooth 31.3 26.7 - 35.9 ROCORI Trail (599) Mill St Chestnut St 0.12 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.6 23.0 - 24.1 ROCORI Trail (600) Chestnut St 235th St 1.51 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.2 18.3 - 22.0
Saint Augusta Hidden Lake Park (366) 230th St 43rd Ave 0.27 Asphalt Smooth 34.0 27.6 - 40.3 Hidden Lake Park (367) 43rd Ave 43rd Ave 0.11 Asphalt Smooth 35.9 35.1 - 36.6 Hidden Lake Park (368) 43rd Ave 43rd Ave 0.04 Asphalt Very Rough 107.8 106.4 - 109 Kiffmeyer Park (377) CSAH 7 CSAH 7 0.48 Asphalt Rough 60.7 57.6 - 63.7 Kiffmeyer Park (378) 238th St 238th St 0.01 Asphalt Very Rough * NA Kiffmeyer Park (379) 238th St CSAH 7 0.23 Asphalt Fair 50.9 46.7 - 55
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 37 Stearns County: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I.
Saint Joseph Township Lake Wobegon Trail (409) CSAH 3 1st Ave NW 0.58 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.6 18.6 - 30.5 Lake Wobegon Trail (410) Collegeville Rd CSAH 3 0.58 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.3 25.6 - 32.9 Lake Wobegon Trail (411) County Road 134 Batzer DR 0.24 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.8 17.7 - 25.9 Lake Wobegon Trail (412) Batzer DR County Road 134 0.93 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.6 21.0 - 22.1 Lake Wobegon Trail (413) Old Highway 52 County Road 134 0.13 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.5 15.7 - 27.3 Lake Wobegon Trail (414) CSAH 3 CSAH 3 0.14 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.5 24.3 - 28.6 Lake Wobegon Trail (415) Collegeville Rd Collegeville Rd 0.42 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.1 19.7 - 20.4 Millstream (455) Minnesota St CSAH 75 0.75 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.2 22.4 - 25.9 Millstream (456) CSAH 2 CSAH 2 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 32.1 24.6 - 39.6 Millstream (457) M-128 CSAH 3 0.22 Asphalt Smooth 35.8 30.3 - 41.3 Millstream (458) CSAH 75 M-128 0.11 Asphalt Smooth 35.7 17.1 - 54.2 Millstream Park (459) M-128 M-128 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.8 23.0 - 32.6 Saint Joseph I-94 (630) CSAH 2 CSAH 2 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.2 13.1 - 33.2 Saint Joseph I-94 (631) CSAH 2 Frontage Rd 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 21.4 16.8 - 25.9
Saint Stephen Parkway Park (504) 1st St NE 1st St NE 0.20 Asphalt Smooth 37.5 25.9 - 48.9
Saint Wendel Township I-94 Ped Bridge (374) Old Collegeville Rd Old Collegeville Rd 0.36 Asphalt Fair 54.2 47.5 - 60.8 Lake Wobegon Trail (416) Norway Rd Norway Rd 0.43 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.8 27.5 - 28.1 Lake Wobegon Trail (417) Norway Rd Collegeville Rd 0.91 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.1 25.4 - 28.6 Lake Wobegon Trail (418) Old Collegeville Rd Collegeville Rd 0.29 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.2 19.5 - 20.8 Lake Wobegon Trail (419) Norway Rd Norway Rd 0.22 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.7 23.3 - 26 Lake Wobegon Trail (420) Norway Rd Norway Rd 0.29 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.9 19.7 - 35.9 Lake Wobegon Trail (421) Collegeville Rd Old Collegeville Rd 0.13 Asphalt Very Smooth 20.4 18.0 - 22.7 Lake Wobegon Trail (422) Collegeville Rd Collegeville Rd 0.14 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.5 19.3 - 25.6 Lake Wobegon Trail (423) Collegeville Rd Collegeville Rd 0.24 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.5 10.2 - 34.7 Lake Wobegon Trail (424) Collegeville Rd Collegeville Rd 0.26 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.2 18.8 - 29.5
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
38 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Waite Park: Segment Ratings
System Summary:
Very Smooth 2.4 miles 34% Smooth 2.0 miles 28% Fair 1.4 miles 19% Rough 0.6 miles 8% Very Rough 0.8 miles 12%
Not Rated 0 miles 0%
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. 17th Ave S (16) 17th AVE S 17th AVE S 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.8 27.0 - 30.6 17th Ave S (17) 17th AVE S 17th AVE S 0.06 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.0 13.0 - 36.9 17th Ave S (18) 17th AVE S 17th AVE S 0.19 Asphalt Smooth 30.9 23.0 - 38.8 17th Ave S (19) 17th AVE S 17th AVE S 0.08 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.1 20.5 - 33.7 17th Ave S (20) 4th ST S 17th AVE S 0.05 Asphalt Very Smooth 26.5 11.3 - 41.6 28th Ave S (50) MNTH 23 Meadow La 0.69 Asphalt Very Smooth 22.7 21.5 - 23.8 33rd St S (86) Granite PKWY Granite PKWY 0.02 Asphalt Very Smooth 19.8 9.0 - 30.4 33rd St S (87) Granite PKWY Graniteview RD 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.4 23.5 - 27.2 33rd St S (88) Graniteview RD Granite PKWY 0.02 Asphalt Smooth 31.4 22.6 - 40.1 Community Park (232) 13th Ave N 13th Ave N 0.05 Asphalt Fair 47.8 47.4 - 48.1 Community Park (233) 13th Ave N 13th Ave N 0.01 Asphalt Smooth * NA Community Park (234) 13th Ave N 13th Ave N 0.04 Asphalt Smooth 37.1 17.5 - 56.6 Community Park (235) 13th Ave N 13th Ave N 0.01 Asphalt Smooth * NA CR 137 (277) 7th St S 7th St S 0.12 Concrete Smooth 30.2 26.8 - 33.5 CR 137 (278) 7th St S CSAH 137 0.34 Asphalt Fair 57.9 52.7 - 63.0 CR 137 (279) CSAH 137 CSAH 137 0.17 Asphalt Smooth 43.4 27.5 - 59.3 CR 137 (280) CSAH 137 23rd AVE S 0.33 Asphalt Smooth 32.3 30.7 - 33.8 CR 137 (281) 23rd AVE S CSAH 137 0.11 Asphalt Fair 52.5 41.7 - 63.2 CR 137 (282) CSAH 137 CSAH 137 0.19 Asphalt Smooth 36.4 10.4 - 62.4 Discovery Community School (289) Sunwood Park Dr Sunwood Park Dr 0.03 Concrete Fair 45.4 42.8 - 47.9 Discovery Community School (290) Sunwood Park Dr Sunwood Park Dr 0.15 Asphalt Very Rough 90.1 56.4 - 123.7
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 39 Waite Park: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. Discovery Community School (291) 9th St S 4th Ave S 0.08 Asphalt Smooth 31.1 30.3 - 31.8 Discovery Community School (292) Sunwood Park Dr 9th St S 0.06 Asphalt Very Rough 108.1 86.3 - 129.7 Graniteview Rd (329) Graniteview RD Graniteview RD 0.09 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.1 24.2 - 29.9 Healthy Living Trail (345) Waite Ave N 4th Ave N 0.60 Asphalt Very Smooth 29.4 26.2 - 32.6 Healthy Living Trail (346) Great Oak Dr 3rd St N 0.11 Asphalt Very Smooth 24.2 19.5 - 28.9 Healthy Living Trail (347) 6th Ave N Great Oak Dr 0.12 Asphalt Very Smooth 25.2 20.2 - 30.2 Healthy Living Trail (348) 4th Ave N 6th Ave N 0.12 Asphalt Very Smooth 23.0 20.4 - 25.5 Healthy Living Trail (349) 3rd St N 3rd St N 0.01 Asphalt Closed for construction Lake Wobegon Trail (425) Maywood DR 54th Ave N 0.32 Concrete Smooth 32.0 29.6 - 34.3 Lions Park (437) 7th St S Andrews Dr 0.16 Asphalt Very Rough 91.0 42.5 - 139.3 Lions Park (438) Andrews Dr Andrews Dr 0.01 Asphalt Fair 50.8 † Lions Park (439) Nevis La Nevis La 0.01 Concrete Rough * NA Lions Park (440) 7th St S 7th St S 0.04 Asphalt Very Smooth 28.6 23.1 - 33.9 Lions Park (441) 7th St S 7th St S 0.00 Asphalt Very Smooth * NA Parkwood (505) Division St Frontage RD N 0.27 Asphalt Very Rough 81.8 70.8 - 92.7 Parkwood (506) Frontage RD N 22nd AVE N 0.10 Asphalt Very Smooth 18.3 8.9 - 27.6 Parkwood (507) 22nd AVE N Frontage RD N 0.09 Asphalt Very Smooth 27.4 27.1 - 27.7 River's Edge Park (566) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.12 Concrete Smooth 30.8 26.5 - 35.0 River's Edge Park (567) 54th Ave N 3rd St N 0.12 Concrete Smooth 33.8 27.4 - 40.1 River's Edge Park (568) 3rd St N 54th Ave N 0.09 Concrete Fair 46.6 36.8 - 56.2 River's Edge Park (569) 3rd St N 54th Ave N 0.06 Concrete Very Smooth 29.2 23.1 - 35.3 River's Edge Park (570) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.06 Concrete Smooth 44.2 33.5 - 54.8 River's Edge Park (571) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.08 Concrete Fair 48.8 45.5 - 52.1 River's Edge Park (572) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.03 Concrete Fair 49.6 † River's Edge Park (573) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.03 Concrete Fair 45.5 † River's Edge Park (574) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.02 Concrete Smooth 43.9 † River's Edge Park (575) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.01 Concrete Smooth 42.7 † River's Edge Park (576) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.26 Concrete Fair 55.8 46.8 - 64.7 River's Edge Park (577) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.04 Concrete Fair 50.9 46.0 - 55.7 River's Edge Park (578) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.02 Concrete Smooth 44.1 40.9 - 47.2 River's Edge Park (579) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.03 Concrete Smooth 44.4 38.7 - 50.0 River's Edge Park (580) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.01 Concrete Smooth 41.9 29.3 - 54.4 River's Edge Park (581) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.11 Concrete Smooth 30.1 28.3 - 31.8 River's Edge Park (582) 54th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.03 Concrete Smooth 30.4 23.6 - 37 River's Edge Park (583) Maywood DR 3rd St N 0.06 Asphalt Fair 49.9 31.2 - 68.5
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
40 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Waite Park: Segment Ratings continued
Segment Ratings:
Shared-Use Path Segment Start Point Segment End Point (Segment ID) (Nearest Road) (Nearest Road) Miles Surface Rating TRI 95% C.I. River's Edge Park (584) 15th Ave N 54th Ave N 0.15 Asphalt Fair 52.6 37.6 - 67.6 River's Edge Park (585) 54th Ave N 3rd St N 0.07 Asphalt Fair 58.2 39.4 - 76.9 Rock Island Park (594) 3rd St S 3rd St S 0.58 Asphalt Rough 72.3 65.6 - 78.9 Willow Creek Park (764) Willow Creek Dr Willow Creek Dr 0.20 Asphalt Very Rough 84.5 82.7 - 86.2
* Segment too short for reliable TRI. Rating based on photos. † Insufficient data
www.parksandtrails.org 41 Appendix A Detailed Methodology
Project Scope photos every two seconds (approximately every 50 This project was limited to paved (i.e., asphalt or feet). A total of 17,313 photos were taken. All these concrete) shared-use paths within the Saint Cloud photos have GPS location markers and are available Metropolitan Planning Area (MPA). Shared-use in a standalone database to assess and visualize on- paths are off-road facilities on exclusive right-of- the-ground pavement conditions. way and with minimal cross flow by motor vehicles. Shared-use paths are designed for a wide range Data was collected riding in both directions on each of users, including but not limited to bicyclists, shared-use path. Due to equipment malfunctions, in-line skaters, roller skaters, wheelchairs, and data was only collected traveling in one direction pedestrians. for 0.5 of the 103.4 miles we surveyed.
There are 103.6 paved miles of shared-use paths Data Analysis within Saint Cloud MPA. A small fraction of All of the data was analyzed on a segment-by- the system — 0.3 miles — was closed due to the segment basis. Path segments are based on St. COVID-19 pandemic or construction. Data was Cloud APO’s Shared-Use Path GIS database, collected on 103.4 miles. and further demarcated using a spacial analysis that identified clusters of data points with Data Collection accelerometer readings greater than 0.7g. In total, All of the data was collected by Parks & Trails this process resulted in 760 segments with an Council using the Research Bike, an electric-assist average length of 0.14 miles (Mdn = 0.09; Max = 1.5, bicycle equipped with cameras and sensors (see Min = 0.004). Appendix B). Tire pressure on the Research Bike was checked daily and kept constant throughout Pavement condition ratings are based on TRI the data collection process (45 psi on front, 50 psi scores. TRI is equal to the standard deviation of on rear). Data was collected between May 6, 2020 the g-force felt along the vertical (Z) axis of the and May 28, 2020. Research Bike while riding a given path segment (excluding road intersections, driveways, wood- An accelerometer in an iPhone SE mounted to the decked bridges and railroad crossings), multiplied Research Bike’s handle bars collected the data used by 100 for scale, and adjusted for speed. to calculate Trail Roughness Index (TRI) scores. Accelerometer data, along with location data TRI scores are categorized as either very smooth and speed, was collected twice per second using (TRI > 30), smooth (TRI = 30-35), fair (TRI = 45-60), the SensorLog app. In total we collected 110,107 rough (TRI = 60-65) or very rough (TRI > 65). These accelerometer data points used for analysis. categories are assigned for interpretive purposes, Additionally, a rear-facing GoPro camera took
42 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey are based on past research and verified with Figure 8 pavement photos. The cutoffs between categories Concrete Path Expansion Joints are approximate, however, and actual TRI scores will provide better comparisons between segments. For example, a path with a TRI of 29 (classified as very smooth) will be nearly identical to a path with a TRI of 31 (classified as smooth).
Speed Adjustment Controlling for speed is important to ensure TRI scores are comparable across data samples. We attempted to maintain a consistent speed throughout the data collection process, but the
lack of a speed control mechanism on the Research TRI is not a reliable indicator of pavement quality for concrete Bike made speed fluctuations unavoidable. Across paths because each expansion joint is recorded as a crack. all of our samples (n=1,480), the average speed was 5.4 meters per second (Mdn = 5.5, SD = 1.0). We calculated a simple adjustment factor to control Saint Cloud MPA, concrete paths are consistently for this variation by analyzing 729 paired samples “rougher” than asphalt paths. For example, our for the effect of average speed on TRI. On average, ratings categorized 39% of asphalt paths as very increasing speed one meter per second increased smooth, compared to only 8% of concrete paths. TRI by 7 points (R2 = 0.05, p <.001). All of our TRI scores are adjusted to reflect the average speed of Even though the TRI is not a reliable indicator of 5.5 m/s (12.3 mph). rehabilitation needs on concrete surfaces, it’s still a meaningful measure of user experience. For most Asphalt vs. Concrete Surfaces bicyclists and inline skaters, knowing whether The TRI was originally designed, and is best suited or not the path is rough is more important than for, asphalt surfaces. A small number of Saint Cloud knowing why the path is rough. For this reason, we MPA’s shared-use paths are concrete (6.9 miles, or (1) report TRI scores for concrete paths and asphalt 7% of the system), however, and we extended the paths side-by-side, and (2) also identify the surface use of the TRI to concrete surfaces for the purposes type wherever applicable. of this project. Because concrete paths are typically constructed with expansion joints (Figure 8), they Margin of Error are often “bumpy” for a bicyclist to ride even when The TRI for any given shared-use path will always the concrete is in excellent condition. Consequently, vary (at least slightly, sometimes significantly) each whether or not a concrete path has a high TRI time the path is ridden, depending on which cracks rating is not a reliable indicator of whether or and bumps are ridden over (or avoided). For each not the path has rehabilitation needs. Across the segment we report the average TRI score based on
www.parksandtrails.org 43 Figure 9 Limitations of the Trail Roughness Index
Some shared-used paths may have failing pavement but still provide smooth lanes for bicycles (e.g., longitudinal cracking on the Lake Wobegon Trail, above le�t). Alternatively, unswept debris can cause rough conditions for bicyclists that isn’t attributable to pavement conditions (e.g., above right, taken on the Beaver Island Trail). The TRI may not be an accurate indicator of pavement conditions under these conditions. two samples (i.e., riding the path once in either if there is a lot of debris on a surface (e.g., twigs or direction). In most cases TRI scores are similar gravel deposits), a path may be rough to ride even across samples, but can vary for numerous reasons: if the underlying pavement is in good condition different lines taken by the bicycle, error associated (Figure 9). with the speed adjustment and random noise associated with vibrations in the bicycle frame and Despite these limitations, the TRI is an objective rider movements. We estimate our TRI scores have measurement of path roughness, has a replicable an average margin of error of +/- 6.9 points at the methodology, and is grounded in the user 95% confidence level, which is acceptable. experience. The TRI is just one of numerous methods to measure and classify pavement Additional Limitations conditions, and should always supplement — not TRI measures how rough pavement is to ride on replace — assessments conducted on-the-ground a bicycle, and as such is only an indirect measure by trained engineers. of the pavement’s actual condition. The TRI only measures the smoothness of the route taken by the bicycle, and consequently doesn’t account for poor pavement that is easy to avoid while riding (e.g., longitudinal or edge cracking). Conversely, the TRI accounts for all bumps the bicyclist feels regardless if they’re caused by pavement flaws. For example,
44 2020 Saint Cloud Metropolitan Area Shared-Use Path Pavement Condition Survey Appendix B The Research Bike
1 The is an initiative of the Parks & Trails Council of Minnesota. It’s a electric-assist bicycle outfitted with sensors and cameras to collect data on the user experience of paved bicycle trails. The Research Bike uses an app that senses the roughness of pavement, and also collects photos used to visualize conditions and create virtual trail tours. This data can be used to improve trail planning and maintenance, support funding requests, market trails to the public, and enhance adventure planning.
3
2
1 2 3
A 360-degree camera A rear-facing GoPro Hero 5 The SensorLog app on mounted above the rider’s camera takes up-close, an iPhone SE records head takes 360° photos geo-located photos of accelerometer data used to (not included in Saint Cloud trail conditions. rate trail roughness. APO project)
www.parksandtrails.org 45 Parks & Trails Council of Minnesota 275 East 4th Street, Suite #250 St. Paul, MN 55101 651.726.2457 www.parksandtrails.org