Change in Practice Patterns of an Academic Division of Vascular Surgery
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PAPER Change in Practice Patterns of an Academic Division of Vascular Surgery Houman Solomon, MD; Alexander B. Chao, MD; Fred A. Weaver, MD; Steven G. Katz, MD Hypothesis: Technological advances have required that Results: In 2000, 453 open and 44 endovascular index faculty of academic divisions of vascular surgery ac- procedures were performed. In contrast, by 2005, open quire new technical skills and significantly alter their past index cases had decreased by 47.0% (239) and endovas- clinical practice patterns. cular index cases had increased by 679.5% (299). Open abdominal aortic aneurysm repairs had decreased by 54.5% (68 vs 31), carotid endarterectomies by 28.8% (139 Design: Retrospective medical record review. vs 99), suprainguinal arterial reconstructions by 47.5% (40 vs 21), infrainguinal arterial reconstructions by 56.5% Setting: An academic tertiary referral center and a com- (186 vs 81), and renal/visceral arterial reconstructions munity teaching hospital. by 65.0% (20 vs 7). In 2005, 62 endovascular abdomi- nal aortic aneurysm repairs and 45 carotid stents were Patients: All patients undergoing 10 specific vascular performed, whereas none were performed in 2000. In ad- procedures during a 5-year period. dition, infrainguinal PTA/S had increased by 675.0% (12 vs 81) and suprainguinal PTA/S by 20.0% (20 vs 24). Main Outcome Measures: We analyzed volumes for Conclusions: Although the total number of proce- 10 specific open and endovascular index procedures dures performed has remained relatively constant, there performed by 5 vascular surgeons during a 60-month has been a dramatic increase in the number of endovas- period. Procedures reviewed included open abdominal cular procedures as well as an associated decline in the aortic aneurysm repair, endovascular abdominal aortic number of open procedures. This change in practice pat- aneurysm repair, carotid endarterectomy, carotid artery tern has allowed the members of our division to main- stent, suprainguinal arterial reconstruction, suprain- tain a significant role in the care of patients undergoing guinal percutaneous transluminal angioplasty/stent vascular surgery, as evidenced by stable overall proce- (PTA/S), infrainguinal arterial reconstruction, infrain- dural volume. This will provide a platform for future out- guinal PTA/S, renal and visceral arterial reconstruction, come-related analyses of open vs endovascular proce- and renal and visceral PTA/S. In-hospital length of stay dures performed within a single specialty group. was compared between open procedures and their endo- vascular counterparts. Arch Surg. 2007;142(8):733-737 HE USE OF THE AORTIC HO- the 1950s made the treatment of extracra- mograft by Gross et al,1 Ou- nial carotid disease commonplace. These dot,2,3 and Dubost et al4 in procedures established open surgical tech- the mid-20th century be- niques as the gold standard for the treat- gan the modern era of vas- ment of peripheral vascular disease. cular surgery. Development of fabric grafts More than 50 years ago, Seldinger12 de- T 5 6 by Voorhees et al and DeBakey et al al- veloped the technique of femoral artery lowed abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) catheterization used today. In 1964, Dot- repair to become routine. The pioneering ter and Judkins13 performed the first suc- work of Dos Santos7 and Leriche8 in end- cessful arterial dilatation. Ten years later, arterectomy formed the basis for success- Gruntzig14 created the modern angio- Author Affiliations: Division of ful treatment of arterial occlusive dis- plasty catheter. In 1990, Palmaz et al15 pub- Vascular Surgery and ease. Adaptation of Carrel’s suturing lished their initial experience with the de- Endovascular Therapy, Keck 9 School of Medicine, University technique to arterial bypass by Kunlin led ployment of balloon expandable stents, of Southern California to the treatment of infrainguinal occlu- ushering in the modern era of endovas- University Hospital, Los sive disease using vein bypass. The land- cular management of arterial disease. Re- Angeles, and Huntington mark reconstructions of the carotid bifur- searchers such as Fogarty et al,16 Green- Hospital, Pasadena, California. cation by Eastcott et al10 and DeBakey11 in field et al,17 and Parodi et al18 have played (REPRINTED) ARCH SURG/ VOL 142 (NO. 8), AUG 2007 WWW.ARCHSURG.COM 733 ©2007 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 09/23/2021 Table 1. Volume and Percentage Change Table 2. Comparison of Median LOS Between Open of the Index Procedures and Endovascular Procedures Volume, Median No. of Cases Procedure LOS, d P Value Change, Procedure 2000 2005 % Carotid endarterectomy 1.0 .01 Carotid artery stent 1.0 Carotid endarterectomy 139 99 −29 Open AAA repair 7.0 Ͻ.001 Carotid artery stent 0 45 NA EVAR 1.5 Open AAA repair 68 31 −54 Suprainguinal arterial reconstruction 3.5 Ͻ.001 EVAR 0 62 NA Suprainguinal PTA/S 1.0 Suprainguinal arterial reconstruction 40 21 −47 Infrainguinal arterial reconstruction 4.0 Ͻ.001 ϩ Suprainguinal PTA/S 20 24 20 Infrainguinal PTA/S 1.0 Infrainguinal arterial reconstruction 186 81 −56 Renal and visceral arterial reconstruction 6.0 Ͻ.001 ϩ Infrainguinal PTA/S 12 81 675 Renal and visceral PTA/S 1.0 Renal and visceral arterial 20 7 −65 Total open 3.0 Ͻ.001 reconstruction Total endovascular 1.0 Renal and visceral PTA/S 12 6 −50 Total open 453 239 −47 Abbreviations: AAA, abdominal aortic aneurysm; EVAR, endovascular AAA Total endovascular 44 299 ϩ680 repair; LOS, length of stay; PTA/S, percutaneous transluminal ϩ Total 497 538 8 angioplasty/stent. Abbreviations: AAA, abdominal aortic aneurysm; EVAR, endovascular AAA repair; NA, not applicable; PTA/S, percutaneous transluminal angioplasty/stent. amination passage rates for general and vascular surgery resi- dents during the study period were noted. The Mann- Whitney test was used to determine differences between significant roles in the minimally invasive treatment of variables with continuous outcomes, and the Fisher exact test arterial embolus, pulmonary embolism, and aortic an- was used to analyze differences between the categorical vari- eurysm. However, those in disciplines other than vas- ables. Statistical significance was assumed at PϽ.05. Data cular surgery have advanced most developments in the analysis was performed using SAS statistical software (SAS Inc, endoluminal treatment of arterial disease. With the Cary, NC). ever-increasing demand for minimally invasive proce- dures, members of our vascular surgery division re- RESULTS trained to develop catheter-based skills. In 2000, we began to perform minimally invasive vascular procedures.19 This In 2000 and 2005, the University of Southern California article describes the evolution of our practice during the Division of Vascular Surgery and Endovascular Therapy ensuing 5 years. performed 1035 index procedures. Of the patients, 62.9% were male and 37.1% were female. Their ages ranged from METHODS 49 to 92 years (mean age, 76.8 years). In addition, 45.9% of the patients confirmed a history of smoking more than We reviewed the records of all patients who had undergone any 20 cigarettes per day, 40.9% had hypercholesterolemia, of 10 open or endovascular index procedures performed by the 37.0% had coronary artery disease, 20.9% had diabetes 5 members of our division during a 60-month period. Patient mellitus, 7.8% had chronic obstructive pulmonary dis- data were collected from inpatient and outpatient medical and ease, and 5.0% had renal impairment. There were no sig- billing records. Patient demographics and comorbidities were nificant differences in the demographics or comorbidi- recorded, and comparisons were made between those under- ties of patients operated on in 2000 and 2005 or in patients going minimally invasive procedures and those undergoing open undergoing open or minimally invasive repair (PϾ.16). repair. Procedures reviewed included open AAA repair (rup- In 2000, 453 open repairs and 44 minimally invasive tured AAAs were excluded), endovascular AAA repair (EVAR), procedures were performed for the 10 index cases. In con- carotid endarterectomy (CEA), carotid artery stent (CAS), su- prainguinal arterial reconstruction, suprainguinal percutane- trast, by 2005, 239 open repairs and 299 minimally in- ous transluminal angioplasty/stent (PTA/S), infrainguinal ar- vasive procedures were completed. By the final year of terial reconstruction, infrainguinal PTA/S, renal and visceral the study, CEAs had decreased by 28.8%, open AAA re- artery reconstruction, and renal and visceral PTA/S. pair by 54.5%, suprainguinal arterial reconstructions by The volumes of each of these procedures, as well as their 47.5%, infrainguinal arterial reconstructions by 56.5%, corresponding in-hospital lengths of stay and mortality rates, and renal and visceral arterial reconstructions by 50.0%. were recorded. Length of stay was defined as postoperative days There was a corresponding increase in the number of until discharge or completion of care by the vascular service. minimally invasive procedures performed (Table 1). Postoperative mortality was considered to occur within 30 days When compared, patients undergoing minimally in- of the procedure or during the patient’s procedural hospital- vasive procedures had significantly shorter hospital stays ization. Comparisons of case volume, length of stay, and peri- Ͻ operative mortality rates were made between the first and last than those having open repair (1 day vs 3 days; P .001). years of the study. Vascular procedures performed by the gen- This held true when all endovascular procedures were eral surgery residents in our institution in 2000 and 2005 were compared with their open counterparts (Table 2). Pa- recorded, as were the number of open and endovascular proce- tients undergoing CEA had a much greater variation in dures performed by the vascular surgery residents. Board ex- the range of their length of stay (range: 1-19 days vs 1-8 (REPRINTED) ARCH SURG/ VOL 142 (NO. 8), AUG 2007 WWW.ARCHSURG.COM 734 ©2007 American Medical Association. All rights reserved.