2006/04/12-Memorandum to Files from Emile L. Julian Re Form
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-0001 April 12, 2006 DOCKETED USNRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY April 13, 2006 (1 1:06am) OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND MEMORANDUM TO FILES ADJUDICATIONS STAFF FROM: Emile L. Julia Assistant for Rulemakings and Adjudications SUBJECT: FORM COMMENTS SUBMITTED IN RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR COMMENTS ON PR-63 (70FR 53313) Attached is a representative sample of 3,188 identical e-mail messages submitted in response to the Federal Reqister Notice on PR- 63, the proposed rule on "Implementation of a Dose Standard After 10,000 years." Also attached is a list of those who provided identical e-mail comments. r-SECY =?ANSI~X3.4-1968?Q?Comments~on~Proposed~Revision~of~Yucca~Mountain~Radia?= =?ANSI-- From: David Wasserman [email protected]~ To: <[email protected]> Date: Fri, Sep 30, 2005 12:16 PM Subject: =?ANSI~X3.4-1968?Q?Comments~on~Proposed~Revision~of~Yucca~Mountain~Radi a?= =?ANSI-X3.4-1968?Q?tion-Protection-Standard,-?= =?ANSI-X3.4- 1968?Q?Docket~lD~No.~OAR=3F2005=3F0083?= Dear Ms. Vietti-Cook: I am writing to OPPOSE your recently revised radiation protection standard for Yucca Mountain. This proposal is inadequate for protecting public health and does not comply with federal law. The standard ignores the scientific consensus on the health impacts of radiation, as well as the many unresolved problems surrounding radioactive waste. It will also burden future generations of Nevadans with significantly higher radiation exposure than ourselves, and set a terrible precedent; lowering the bar for radiation protection around the country. The DC Circuit Court of Appeals decision in July 2004 found EPA's previous standard - a 15 millirem per year radiation exposure limit for 10,000 years - to be illegal. According to the ruling, the standard EPA sets for Yucca Mountain must be consistent with a National Academy of Science (NAS) study on the subject, which recommended that the standard extend through the time of highest risk to the public ("peak dose"). The Department of Energy estimates peak dose at several hundred thousand years. EPA's recently revised standard, however, fails to comply with the court ruling and the intent of the NAS recommendations. Instead of extending the 15 mremlyr limit through the time of peak risk, EPA has proposed a two part standard - 15 mremlyr for 10,000 years, and then a 350mremlyr standard thereafter (up to a million years). Such a standard is not scientifically justified, and would be the least protective radiation standard in the world. No other U.S. or international radiation protection standard permits a dose of 350 millirems per year to individuals. In fact, EPA's proposed standard is not even consistant with the agency's own previous recommendations. I ask you to withdraw this standard immediately, and propose a standard that is truly protective of public health and future generations. David Wasserman 41 1 Highland Ave. Apt. B-4 Palisades Park, NJ 07650 / c:\temp\GW)00001.TMP Page 1] Mail Envelope Properties (433D64DE.3F6 : 24 : 25590) Subject: =?ANSI X3.4- 1968?~?Comments-on - Proposed Revision of-Yucca-Mountain-Radia ?= =?ANSI X3.4-1968?Q?tion protection Standard,-?= =?ANSI- X3.4- 1968?Q?~o;ket --ID No. - 0~~~3~2005=%0083?= Creation Date: Fri, Sep 30,2005 12:03 PM From: David Wasserman <[email protected]> Created By: [email protected] Recipients rlrc.gov owf5qo.OWFN_DO SECY (SECY) Post Offke Route owf5qo.O~DO nrc.gov Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 1954 Friday, September 30,2005 12:03 PM Mime.822 3 105 Options Expiration Date: None Priority: Standard Reply Requested: No Return Notification: None Concealed Subject: No Security: Standard PR-063 (70FR53313) FORM LETTERS TOTAL: 3,188 re Implementation of a Dose Standards after 10,000 Years David Wasserman Shawn Branch Kathleen Morris 411 Highland Ave., Apt. B-4 3706 Moon Drive 181 E. Beechwood Blvd. Palisades Park, NJ 07650 Mesquite, TX 75150 Columbus, OH 43214 Marshall Goldberg Regis DiGiacomo Jane Mills 12338 Starduster Drive 2333 N. 113th Street 217 Jerome Nevada City, CA 95959 Wauwatosa, WI 53226 Silverton, OR 97381 Harold Hodes Kelly Leibold B. Thiele 202 First Street 1058 Valley Road 2031 Wagner Road Ithaca, NY 14850 Mertztown, PA 19539 Glenview, IL 60025 D.A. Wagner Kristen Gottuso Patty Meyer 109 Fairview Drive 3873 Mandian Woods Dr. N 2435 E. Balboa Drive Lansdale, PA 19446 Jacksonville, FL 32223 Tempe, AZ 85282 Mitch Triplett George Shanhan Joan Hackel 6060 Claremont Ave. , 48 Dry Hill Road 120 Mark Trail South Apt. F Norwalk, CT 06851 Wetumpka, AL 36093 Oakland, CA 94618 Julie Crego Lucile Reeder Thomas Severn 5923 Century Avenue 1054 Overbrook Lane 5510 Burnet Rd, Rear Middleton, WI 53562 Fallbrook, CA 92028 Austin, TX 78756 Brandon Meister Ron Rattner Roark Dority 521 W. Brompton Ave. #310 1998 Broadway #1204 3606 State Street #3 Chicago, IL 60657 San Francisco, CA 94109 San Diego, CA 92103 D. Rex Miller Martine Grost Sonja Stupel 268 Appalachian Drive 9715 W. Broward Blvd. #239 923 W. Wanda Vista Place Bboone, NC 28607 Plantation, FL 33324 Tucson, AZ 85704 Melody Good Jo Sippie-Gora Darlene Raunio 1810 SE Everett 4 Dogwood Trail W 9343 Highway 86 Camas, WA 98607 Kinnelon, NJ 07405 Tomahawk, WI 54487 Rosel Pine Evelyn Shellberg Daniel Lutzker 3040 Oak Road W 9343 Highway 86 24 Lake Celeste Drive Orange Park, FL 32065 Tomahawk, WI 54487 Garrison, NY 10524 Larry Raunio Stephen Callas Mark Morgan W 9343 Highway 190 Hunting Lane 704 Kings Highway Tomahawk, WI 54487 Fair Haven, NJ 07704 Moorestown, NJ 08057 Lauren Sorkin Charlie Hogue Andrew Edmonds 5 Boston Post Road 1721 Chestnut Lane NE 3344 S. Carpenter Street East Brunswick, NJ 08816 Cedar Rapids, IA 52402 Chicago, IL 60608 Gary Childers Philip Callas Barbara Jurgens 127 Fairfax Avenue 11 Chase Street, Apt. 1 13005 NE 71st Street Asheville, NC 28806 Salem, MA 01970 Kirland, WA 98033 Sharon Dupree Margaret Caro Karl Leal 154 June Street 2514 SE Micah Place 1113 West Parr Avenue Worcester, MA 01602 Corvallis, OR 97333 Campbell, CA 95008 Tia Triplett Peter Shaw Paul Skiba 4073 Bledsoe Avenue 7048 N. Wabash Avenue 176 R Street Los Angeles, CA 90066 Portland, OR 97217 Salt Lake City, UT 84103 Katherine Nair Mark Burwinkel Sandra Cutter 442 E. North Water St. 4686 Hamilton #1 712 Sterling Drive Chicago, IL 60611 Cincinnati, OH 45223 Martinez, CA 94553 Alexandra Gruskos Larry Bulling Norm Cohen 1317 Macon Avenue 2321 NW Mulkey Avenue 321 Barr Avenue Pittsburghm PA 15218 Corvallis, OR 97330 Linwood, NJ 08221 Jeremy Schneider Garry Mirabile Dave & Tami Ballard 15 Donna Street 812 Waterford Drive 2607 Camp Phillips Road New City, NY 10956 Edison, NJ 08817 Wausau, WI 54403 Jerome Feinstein Julie Brown Ronald C. Betty C. Fass 89 Norman Road 2504 Camden Road 1650 E. Clark Ave. #248 P.O. Box 133 Greensboro, NC 27403 Santa Maria, CA 93455 Harrington Park, NJ 07640 Corinne Di Stephan Lori Caniglia Robert Meurer 171-16 84th Road 11423 T Circle 12616 Moorpark Street Jamaica, NY 11432 Omaha, NE 68137 Studio City, CA 91604 Cynthia Heinze Christopher Mason Lee Darrah 138-01 64th Avenue 8592 Eagkes Walk Lane 7716 Constannso Ave. #103 Flushing, NY 11367 Cincinnati, OH 45255 Las Vegas, NV 89128 Michelle Forcxe Constance Kosuda Fortunato Stanziale 41 Manseau Street P O Box 621303 71 Talmadge Hill Road Winooski, VT 05404 Las Vegas, NV 89162 New Canaan, CT 06840 Jennifer Singley Susan Hirsch Bob Sutter 167 Bishop Drive 9612 NE 188th St. #202 208 S. Renellie Drive Aston, PA 19014 Bothell, WA 98011 Tampa, FL 33609 Shannon Teel Ursula Mosley Heather Jackson 2204 Commonwealth Ave. 1468 NW 3rd Avenue 4528 Grand Ave. S #2 Charlotte, NC 28205 Ontario, OR 97914 Minneapolis, MN 55419 Phillip Rockey Patti Byra Steven Langer 547 Del Rio Circle 2765 Lewisberry Road 309 Herndon Street Oakdale, CA 95361 York Haven, PA 17370 Park Forest, IL 60466 Michael Thomason Janet Schafer Gregory Nerode 530 South 43rd Street 727 Torchwood Circle 406 Cayuga Heights Road Boulder, CO 80305 New Brighton, MN 55112 Ithaca, NY 14850 John & Denise Madonna Joseph Valenchis Paul Dallaire 4136 Woodsdale Avenue Tarrant Street 335 W. 29th St., Apt. 1C Erie, PA 16510 Longs, SC 29568 New York, NY 10001 Kathleen Sgamma Patsy Lowe Kevin Rofles 2371 Clermont Street 942 Breton Avenue 14006 N Green Hills Loop Denver, CO 80207 Simi Valley, CA 93065 Auston, TX 78737 Larry Meyers Florian Wasik Steve Savitch 19916 Court of the Lions 2607 N. Chestnut Avenue 4532 E. Glenn Boca Raton, FL 33434 Arlington Hgts., IL 60004 Tucson, AZ 85712 Don Mutchler Joan Forman Sholey Argani 109 N. 34th Avenue 1743 Axenty Way 217 Spring Avenue Hattiesburg, MS 39401 Redondo Beach, CA 90278 Takoma Park, MD 20912 Gia Grier N M Postlethwaite Maureen McMahon 5506 Groveland Avenue 1716 NW 10th Terrace 377 W 11th Street Baltimore, MD 21215 Gainsville, FL 32609 New York, NY 10014 Marie Overall Kimberly Jones Derek Olfky 3165 S 500 E 15606 Oakworth Court 5006 Willowmere Drive Salt Lake City, UT 84106 Sugar Land, TX 77478 Dayton, OH 45459 George Mierisch Mario Menocal James LaJocies 3165 S 500 East 7985 SW 86 Street P O Box 1942 Salt Lake City, UT 84106 Miami, FL 33143 Snohomish, WA 98291 N M Postlewaite Roseann DeLuca Harry Hazelton 1716 NW 10th Terrace 6 Hamilton Avenue 3990 Humbert Road Gainesville, FL 32609 Auburn, NY 13021 Alton, IL 62002 Rashid El Amin John Morrison Scott Stuckman 5757 North Sheridan Road 1582 King Street 2971 Badger Drive Apt. 8F Santa Rosa, CA 95404 Hilliard, OH 43026 Chicago, IL 60660 Roger Zinn Rachel R. Noll Nancy Rader 5514 Oakmont Avenue 1673 Louser Road 1198 Keith Avenue Bethesda, MD 20817 Annville, PA 17003 Berkeley, CA 94708 Dan & Bonnie Hudson Bert Greenberg Sarah Lanzman 9485 Manzanita Avenue 6166 Montgomery Place 8907 Dick Woods Road Ben Lomond, CA 95005 San Jose, CA 95135 Afton, VA 22920 Helen Zelnick Daniel Nieliwocki Sharon Anderson 40 West Eable Street 14333 W.