_~- ..-. -_" - ,.-~~--~----~_- :- -====:.o....::::~= ------.------._------.-~.------NOVA -SCOTIA LA NE

Vol. 2, No.3 January, 1976

~------. - Overrcdi&lg In• by Charles W. Macintosh, Q.c. and M. Lynne Cavin, Land Registration and Information Service of the Council of Maritime Premiers.

Many practitioners do not become aware of 21. Flooding Rights the existence of overriding interests - that mis­ 22. Beaches Preservation and Protection cellaneous group of , charges and restrictions 23. Historic Artifacts upon the use of real - until their attent- 24. Trove 1 is forcibly drawn to the matter by reason of a 25. Mining leases and ~ent having purchased a property subject to one 26. Salvage Yards Act .... of these interests. The majority of overriding in­ 27. by improvements by adjoining owner terests are enforceable without registration in the 28. Condemnation under Public Health Act Registry of . Thus, not e\'en the most ex­ 29. Lease for less than three years, accompanied haustive title search would reveal their existence. by actual 30. Street Tree . In the research connected with the develop­ 31. Quieting Titles and Land Titles Clarification ment of draft legislation for the proposed Land Applications Titles Act for Nova Scotia, all statutorially created 32. Airport Zoning Regulations incidents affecting the title to were categorized and analysed. A surprisingly long list We are living in an age of increasing public resulted and those which can properly be called concern for, the manner in which property is used overriding interests are as follows: and this concern finds expression in the number and form of and regulations prohibiting con­ 1. Civic Tax Lien , duct considered undesirable and vesting in gov­ 2. Civic Betterment Charge ernment authority to make use of privately owned 3. Tax Lien lands. It is evident that a lawyer must make in­ 4. land Tax Lien quiries and investigations in several places other 5. Non-resident Income Tax lien than the Registry of Deeds to determine not only 6. Nova Scotia Power Corporation Bill Lien' who is the true owner of a property but to what 7. Lien Under Workmen's Compensation Act use the land may be put and to what government 8. Liens under labour Standards Code rights it might be subject. 9. Mechanics' liens during unexpired regiS- In some cases this simply means a careful tration period look at the statute creating the interest. In others 10. Unpaid Vendor's liens 11. Dower Rights it means a telephone call or letter to the govern­ 12. Public Highways __ -' ment department charged with the administration of the statute. ~~~ 13. Abandoned Highways " -~.- . 14. Restrictions under Public Highways Act ~ ~ Difficulties Frequently Encountered - 15. Necessary Rights of Way-Private Ways Act .6. Crown Rights of Expropriation, Access, User . Some of these overriding interests are of 17. Utility Corporation , to Maintain such importance that the prudent ~olicitor deal­ overhead wires. . ing with property matters should be familiar with 18. vVatercourses-vVater Act them. Lawyers deal with several of them frequent­ 19. Marshland Reclamation ly but even the most common interests are not 20. Rights to Access and to Fish without difficulties. For example, do\'\"er rights are particularly vexatious to the practitioner since there preclude de\elopment or c\cn replacement of an is no certain means of determining from a title existing structure if it is damaged. search whether or not a property may be subject These few examples should serve 10 illustrate to a claim for dower. the importance of overriding interests to the pro­ likewise, several rccent experiences by ­ perty practitioner. A lawyer can always endeavour yers in the Maritimes involving tax sales should to protect himself against liability by giving his alert the profession to the possibility that although client a certificate of title sufficiently restrictive in it may not show in the Registry of Deeds, the pro­ nature as to relieve himself from such liability with perty may have been sold (or taxes under the respect to the existence of most overriding in­ name of a previous owner. terests. HO\vever, the more professional approach to the problem is seen as a duty to become know­ Opinions still differ as to the effect of a mech­ ledgable of these interests so that they can be de­ anics' lien placed on record within the forty-five tected and their nature and effect explained to the days allowed for the filing of the claim but fol­ client before a purchase is finalized. lowing a sale to a for \'alue without notice. The safest course with respect to a purchase of a new house is to require a holdback or satisfactory that there are no outstand­ PUBLIC ACTS 1975 ing liens. Acts passed at the November-Dec€:mber 1975 sitting of the Most of the interests referred to in the list Nova Scotia Legislature. hov\,cver, are those which come to the attention In the case of amending acts, refere;")ces in brackets are 10 of the solicitor afler a property transaction has the chapter 01 the Re\'i5ed Slat utes (1967) of the ori£inal acl, been completed. Under the Land Tax Act every unless otherwise noted. owner of more than 1,000 acres of land in the An Act to Amend the As~essmcnt Act (c.14) province must pay a tax of 1 % of the value of the "An Act to Amend the Public Service Act (c.255) land, each acre being valued at S2.00. This tax is • An Act to Amend the Execulive Council Act (c.95) An Act to Amend the Health Sen·ices Tax Act (c.126) a first lien upon the land and any portion thereof. An Act to Amend the I;")rome Tax Act (c.134) The lands are subject to forfeiture for non-pay­ An Act to Amend the Social A~<;istance Act (c.16 of the ment of the tax. Accordingly any purchaser of a Acts of 1970) parcel of land from the owner of more than 1,000 An Act to Amend the !ntest,~te Succession Act (c.153) An Act to Amend the [miror-menlal Proleclion Act (c.6 of acres may be subject to a Land Tax Act lien. the Acts of 1973) •• An Act 10 Establish a Rent Review Commission and to Liens under the Workmen's Compensation Act Provide for the Rcvicw of Rents ( and Labour Standards Code attach to land whether An Act to Amend the \\·od,men's Compensation Act (c65 registered or not. It should be noted that Labour of the Acts of .1968) Standards Code liens are deemed to be mortgages •• An Act 10 Amend the ResidLntial Tenancies Act (c.13 of the Acts of 1970) enforceable by foreclosure proceedings and that " •• An Act Respecling Control of Beverage Confainers these liens attach to all the real and personal pro­ ••• An Acl Respl'cting the f':ational Anti-Inflation Program perty of the employer, not only his industrial pro­ "In force Decl'mber 18, 1975 perty. "!n force December 22, 1975 ". 'Subject to proclamation Many old public highways are not document­ Copies of these Acts are a\ailable at 25c each, post­ ed in the Registry of Deeds and in many cases paid, Irom: buildings are constructed within the limits of such NOVA SCOTIA GO\,ER~MENT BOOKSTORE highways. P. O. Box 637 The Public Highv';ays Act sets out numerous Halifax, Nova Scotia restrictions with respect to the use of land adjacent B3J 2T3 to a high\vay. These restrictions and prohibitions are frequently ignored. The Act covers such mat­ ters as the erection of structures on highways 300 "There are some general considerations that feet from the highways' centre line; the construct­ support the view that I would take. It is no longer ion of fences, utility poles and signs and the plant­ sensible to pretend that a commercial lease, such ing of trees near the highway and the sale of mer­ as the one before this Court, is simply a convey­ chandise within 150 feet of the limits of a con­ ance and not also a . It is equally unten­ trolled access highway. able to persist in denying resort to the full arm­ oury of remedies ordinarily available to redress By virtue of the Water Act, the title to every repudiation of covenants, merely because the \vater course, including the bed and source thereof,. covenants, may be associated with an estate in is vested in . land. Finally, there is merit here as in other situ­ Airport zoning regulations preclude building ations in avoiding multiplicity of actions that may in areas surrounding airports. Each airport has its otherwise be a concomitant of insistence that a own set of zoning regulations which are published landlord engage in instalment litigation against a in the Canada Gazette at the time of approval. In repudiating tenant." laskin, J.,in. Highway Pro- t.1 some cases the flight path extends several miles perties Ltd. v. Kelly, Douglas and Co. Ltd.~ l1971] 1 from the centre of the airport and the regulations S.CR. 562. . .'. :

Page 2