Update on Diets; What Works, What Doesn't and What Can Be Dangerous

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Update on Diets; What Works, What Doesn't and What Can Be Dangerous Update on diets; What works, what doesn’t and what can be dangerous Carrie Gardache MPH, RD, LDN, CDE Diets out there….. • Vinegar and water diet (1820) • Scarsdale diet (1978) • The Fexitarian diet • The Graham diet (1830) • Cabbage soup diet (1990) • Volumetrics • Banting’s “low carbohydrate diet” • Weight Watchers (1863) • Eat Right 4 Your Type diet (1996) • Fletcherizing diet (1903) • Cheaters diet (2006) • MIND diet • Counting Calories (1918) Cotton ball diet (2013) • Ornish Diet • Cigarette diet (1925) • Detox diet • Dubrow Diet • Inuit meat and fat diet (1928) • Noom Diet • Caveman diet • Stoll diet aid (1930) • Carnivore diet • Atkins diet • Grapefruit diet (1930) • Optavia diet • Hallelujah diet • Hay diet (1930) • Dr. Gundy diet • Tapeworm diet (1954) • Hollywood diet • FODMAP diet • Zen macrobiotic diet (1960) • Mediterranean diet • The Shepherds diet • Sleeping beauty • Dash diet • Prolinn diet (1970s) What Works.... • Mediterranean Diet • DASH Diet • LESS CALORIES and MORE EXERCISE Mediterranean Rich in olive oil, legumes, unrefined cereals, fruit, and vegetables, low in meat and meat products, and with moderate contents of dairy products, fish and wine. The total fat in the diet is typically 25-35% of calories, with saturated fat ≤ 8% DASH (Dietary Approach to Stop Hypertension) Aims at reducing one’s sodium intake. Overall reinforces a healthy eating plan. Main points: 8-10 servings of fruits and vegetables, 2-3 servings low fat dairy, 2400 mg Na/day, and lean meats What Doesn’t Work • Diets that focus on only a few foods or food groups • “Detox” diets • Diets with “Miracle” foods or ingredients • Fasting and very low-calorie diets • Diets that sound too good to be true What Can Be Dangerous • Fasting – Intermitting Fasting Diet • Keto Diet Keto Diet Eat These Avoid These • Avocados • Milk • Cheese • Bread • Full-fat Greek Yogurt (small portions) • Pasta • Chicken and Turkey • Cereal • Fish and Shellfish • Beans • Pork and Beef (small portions) • Fruit (other than berries) • Nuts and Nut butters • Root Vegetables (carrot and • Sunflower and Pumpkin Seeds potatoes • Raspberries • Corn • Blackberies • Alcohol • Strawberries • Low carb vegetables • Unsweetened fortified almond milk • Olive, canola, avocado, and nut oils Recommendations to making it Work • RD visit and have Body Comp test done • Assessment – consider log or track • Evaluate labs • Talk with patient about what they are willing to do • Follow up References • Ansel K, What you need to know about ketogenic diet Diabetes Forecast, 2019; 71-75. • Wolfram T, Staying away from fad diet Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 2017, January 2 • Zelman K, The worst diets ever: Diets that don’t work WebMD Weight Loss Clinic Foundation, 2009, October 9 • American Journal of Clinical Nutrition; 2013, 97: 505-16. Systematic review and meta-analysis of different dietary approaches to the management of type 2 Diabetes. .
Recommended publications
  • Nutrition and the Cancer Survivor
    NUTRITION AND THE CANCER SURVIVOR CANCER SURVIVOR SERIES AICR Research Grants 2015 (partial list) CONTENTS Women’s interventional nutrition study (WINS) long- term survival analysis 1 Introduction . 2 Rowan Chlebowski, MD, PhD, Harbor-UCLA Medical Diet and Cancer . 3 Center Weight and Cancer . 4 . Gene-environment interactions among circulating vitamin D levels, vitamin D pathway gene Physical Activity and Cancer . 4 . polymorphisms, BMI and esophageal adenocarcinoma prognosis 2 Adopting a Healthy Lifestyle . 5 David Christiani, MD, PhD, Harvard University Tips for Healthy Eating . .5 . Targeted disruption of cancer cell metabolism and Handle Food Safely . 8 growth through modification of diet quality Barbara Gower, PhD, The University of Alabama at Watch Your Waist . .9 . Birmingham Be Physically Active . 12 A mail- and video-based weight loss trial in breast cancer survivors 3 Evaluating Nutrition Information . 13 Melinda L . Irwin, PhD, Yale University 4 Common Questions . 16 Effects of fish oil on lipid metabolites in breast cancer Greg Kucera, PhD, Wake Forest University Health Should I take supplements? . .16 . Sciences Will a vegetarian diet protect me? . 17 Impact of physical activity on tumor gene expression What about eating only organic foods? . 17 . in women with newly diagnosed breast cancer Jennifer Ligibel, MD, Dana Farber Cancer Institute Are macrobiotic diets advisable? . 18. Impact of resistance training and protein 5 Need More Help? . 19 supplementation on lean muscle mass among childhood cancer survivors About AICR . .22 . Kirsten Ness, PhD, St . Jude’s Children’s Research Hospital About The Continuous Update Project . 22 Pilot study of a metabolic nutritional therapy for the AICR Recommendations for Cancer management of primary brain tumors Prevention .
    [Show full text]
  • Functional Foods in Fad Diets: a Review
    Functional Foods in Health and Disease 2017; 7(9): 702-715 Page 702 of 715 Review Article Open Access Functional Foods in fad diets: A review Daniela Abigail Navaro1; Olga Raz1; Sharon Gabriel1; Vered Kaufman Shriqui1; Esther Gonen1, Mona Boaz1,2. 1Department of Nutrition Sciences, Ariel University, (Ariel), Israel; 2Epidemiology and Research Unit, E. Wolfson Medical Center, (Holon), Israel Corresponding Author: Mona Boaz, PhD, Professor, Chair, Department of Nutrition Sciences, Ariel University, Kvish 36, Ariel, 40700, Israel Submission Date: March 18th, 2017, Acceptance Date, September 27th, 2017, Publication Date: September 30th, 2017 Citation: Navaro D.A., Raz O., Gabriel S., Shriqui V.K., Boaz M., Functional Foods in Fad Diets: A Review. Functional Foods in Health and Disease 2017; 7(9); 702-715. https://doi.org/10.31989/ffhd.v7i9.346 ABSTRACT Fad diets can be defined as any diet making claims that are unrealistic and not supported by evidence-based data. Having been developed since the early 19th century, fad diets promise drastic weight loss and/or other unsubstantiated health claims while often omitting entire food groups. Their popularity with the public makes them an important topic for nutritionists and clinicians, especially in the framework of the obesity epidemic. Additionally, it is conceivable that components of fad diets can indeed facilitate weight loss, even if the diet overall is without merit. The grapefruit diet, the cabbage soup diet, and the human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) diet are among the most popular fad diets and are reviewed within this study not only in terms of the diet plan itself, but also in terms of possible and known weight loss and health benefits provided by the foods on which the diets are based.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dot Study
    LIFESTYLE INTERVENTIONS FOR NON-ALCOHOLIC FATTY LIVER DISEASE Kirsten Coppell, Public Health Physician Senior Research Fellow, Department of Medicine, University of Otago; Training Programme Supervisor, NZCPHM Principles of Healthy Eating In 9 words….. • Eat less • Move more • Eat mostly fruits and vegetables For additional clarification – a 5 word modifier…… • Go easy on junk foods Nestle, Marion (2006). What to Eat. New York: North Point Press (Farrar, Straus and Giroux). ISBN 978-0-86547-738-4. HOW? How much does weight loss surgery cost? Weight Loss Surgery Fees Initial Consultation $280 Gastric Banding Surgery $18,500 Gastric Sleeve Surgery $20,750 Gastric Bypass Surgery $23,500 Additional Fees The Optifast pre-surgery meal replacement diet must be purchased separately from your local pharmacy. Other additional costs may include staying extra nights in hospital, extra theatre time, blood transfusion and/or x-rays. PLEASE NOTE: 99% of patients do not incur additional costs. Based on these costs……… To provide BS for 192,000 210,000 with BMI ≥40kg/m2 @ $20,000 per operation = $3,840,000,000 $4,200,000,000 $74.46M PHARMAC 2017 Year in Review 570,000 PHARMAC 2016 Year in Review The prevalence of overweight and obesity in NZ adults by age group, 2016/17. 100 Overweight Obesity 90 80 70 60 39.3 32.4 37.2 38.4 27.0 50 31.1 40 24.0 30 14.7 Proportion (%)Proportion 12.3 20 10 0 0-14 15-17 18-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65-74 75+ Age Groups Ministry of Health.
    [Show full text]
  • Superfoodswap STARTER-KIT.Pdf
    1 Welcome! You did not show up here by accident. The universe has brought us together and I’m so glad our paths have crossed! This plan is different than everything out there because the first step is for you to decide what you WANT to eat. It isn’t about prescriptions of what I want you to eat. It’s about what you want. And then with the help of my genius ratio guide & suggestions on how to swap in more superfoods…you can enjoy eating, lose weight, and be healthy. The Superfood Swap plan is how I eat, how I teach my thousands of clients to eat, and I know it will be just what YOU need to lose weight & get healthy. This plan was featured & kicked butt on ABC’s WEIGHT LOSS REALITY SHOW: “My Diet is Better Than Yours.” The TV show contestant who followed this plan lost a shocking amount of weight in 14 weeks. This superstar contestant, Jasmin Queen, has become one of my closest friends and is a MEGA inspiration. So much of this STARTER KIT was inspired by working with her & her family on the show. è What is the Superfood Swap? Superfood Swap is a simple way to lose weight AND get healthy. è What’s the Superfood Swap philosophy? Eat what you crave made w/ superfoods instead of CRAP. è What results can I expect? Make to lose weight, increase energy, and give your body the complete SuperSwaps nutrition it needs. è How is this different than other diets out there? The BIG difference is this plan EMBRACES CRAVINGS.
    [Show full text]
  • MIND Diet Slows Cognitive Decline with Aging
    Alzheimer’s & Dementia 11 (2015) 1015-1022 MIND diet slows cognitive decline with aging Martha Clare Morrisa,*, Christy C. Tangneyb, Yamin Wanga, Frank M. Sacksc, Lisa L. Barnesd,e,f, David A. Bennette,f, Neelum T. Aggarwale,f aDepartment of Internal Medicine at Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL, USA bDepartment of Clinical Nutrition at Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL, USA cDepartment of Nutrition, Harvard School of Public Health, Harvard University, Boston, MA, USA dDepartment of Behavioral Sciences at Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL, USA eDepartment of Neurological Sciences at Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL, USA fRush Alzheimer’s Disease Center at Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL, USA Abstract Introduction: The Mediterranean and dash diets have been shown to slow cognitive decline; how- ever, neither diet is specific to the nutrition literature on dementia prevention. Methods: We devised the Mediterranean-Dietary Approach to Systolic Hypertension (DASH) diet intervention for neurodegenerative delay (MIND) diet score that specifically captures dietary compo- nents shown to be neuroprotective and related it to change in cognition over an average 4.7 years among 960 participants of the Memory and Aging Project. Results: In adjusted mixed models, the MIND score was positively associated with slower decline in global cognitive score (b 5 0.0092; P , .0001) and with each of five cognitive domains. The differ- ence in decline rates for being in the top tertile of MIND diet scores versus the lowest was equivalent to being 7.5 years younger in age. Discussion: The study findings suggest that the MIND diet substantially slows cognitive decline with age.
    [Show full text]
  • Healthy Nutrition at Work Feeling Healthy and Consuming Nutritious Foods Go Hand in Hand
    Healthy Nutrition at Work Feeling healthy and consuming nutritious foods go hand in hand. Employees often have a variety of responsibilities on their plates between work and family life, and turn to quick fixes they think will help them have more energy. Fad diets and nutritional trends have been around for decades, and people have been trying things in search of that one trend that will help them. Some of those diets and nutritional trends include: • Cabbage soup diet • HCG diet • Grapefruit diet • Juicing cleanses • SlimFast • Fat replacers • Master Cleanse • Giving up gluten • Atkins • Artificial sweeteners • Alli • Powders Nutritional trends change over the years. Some current nutritional trends include: • Fasting • Focus on gut health • Ketogenic diet • Convenience superfoods • Plant-based diet • Protein-powered foods • Mindful eating practices • Sustainable foods But nutritional trends typically come and go like fashion trends. The best thing to do is develop long-term healthy eating habits to ensure you maintain an optimal relationship with food and your health: • Set realistic expectations for what’s right for you and • Be sure to hydrate. your family. • Plan and prep where you’re able. • Balance your meals. • Don’t be too restrictive. • Remember portion sizes. • Keep it simple and make small changes. • Choose healthy snacks. As an employer, you’re in a unique position to help your employees reach their nutritional goals. Here are a few tips: • Ensure onsite cafeterias and vending machines are stocked with healthy food options. • Offer refrigerators and microwaves onsite so employees can bring their own meals. • Offer programs that help employees improve their eating habits and move more rather than focusing directly on weight loss.
    [Show full text]
  • Senior Nutrition Meal Service Guide
    Senior Nutrition & Meal Service Guide FOR YOUR OR A LOVED ONE AGE IN PLACE WITH PROPER NUTRITION Features 10 NUTRITION TIPS FOR SENIORS What Is The MIND Diet? MEAL SERVICE OPTIONS How To Find The Best Personal Chef Service proving healthy, balanced meals. The idea was simple: MESSAGE FROM "We would place chefs in our clients' homes to make customized meals for the week THE FOUNDER while offering companionship and a nutrition safety check" Nathan Allman started Chefs For Seniors with his father Barrett, a long-time restaurant owner, in 2013. My father and I started cooking for clients in the Madison, Wisconsin area ourselves, but quickly realized By Nathan Allman that we'd tapped into a real need in the community. We were soon hiring About 15 years ago, my great-grandmother Virginia stopped cooking. It was chefs and expanding to new markets. As of 2018 we have franchises getting hard for her to stand for long periods of time in the kitchen, and she was operating throughout the country, and just simply tired of cooking. Who could blame her? She'd made meals for her have served over 100,000 meals to husband and seven children daily for over 60 years! seniors in their homes. I've seen firsthand the impact proper The problem was, when she stopped for over 50 years. The financial cost nutrition has had on our client's lives, cooking her health took a dramatic of the facility was an issue to, and and that's why we put together this turn for the worse.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hip Chick's Guide to Macrobiotics Audiobook Bonus: Recipes
    1 The Hip Chick’s Guide to Macrobiotics Audiobook Bonus: Recipes and Other Delights Contents copyright 2009 Jessica Porter 2 DO A GOOD KITCHEN SET-UP There are some essentials you need in the kitchen in order to have macrobiotic cooking be easy and delicious. The essentials: • A sharp knife – eventually a heavy Japanese vegetable knife is best • Heavy pot with a heavy lid, enameled cast iron is best • Flame deflector or flame tamer, available at any cooking store • A stainless steel skillet • Wooden cutting board • Cast iron skillet Things you probably already have in your kitchen: • Blender • Strainer • Colander • Baking sheet • Slotted spoons • Wooden spoons • Mixing bowls • Steamer basket or bamboo steamer 3 You might as well chuck: • The microwave oven • Teflon and aluminum cookware Down the road: • Stainless-steel pressure cooker • Gas stove • Wooden rice paddles You know you’re really a macro when you own: • Sushi mats • Chopsticks • Suribachi with surikogi • Hand food mill • Juicer • Ohsawa pot • Nabe pot • Pickle press • A picture of George Ohsawa hanging in your kitchen! Stock your cupboard with: • A variety of grains • A variety of beans, dried • Canned organic beans • Dried sea vegetables • Whole wheat bread and pastry flour • A variety of noodles • Olive, corn, and sesame oil • Safflower oil for deep frying 4 • Shoyu, miso, sea salt • Umeboshi vinegar, brown rice vinegar • Mirin • Sweeteners: rice syrup, barley malt, maple syrup • Fresh tofu and dried tofu • Boxed silken tofu for sauces and creams • A variety of snacks from the health-food store • Tempeh • Whole wheat or spelt tortillas • Puffed rice • Crispy rice for Crispy Rice Treats • Organic apple juice • Amasake • Bottled carrot juice, but also carrots and a juicer • Agar agar • Kuzu • Frozen fruit for kanten in winter • Dried fruit • Roasted seeds and nuts • Raw vegetables to snack on • Homemade and good quality store- bought dips made of tofu, beans, etc.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparison of Barriers and Facilitators of MIND Diet Uptake Among Adults from Northern Ireland and Italy Deirdre Timlin1, Barbara Giannantoni2, Jacqueline M
    Timlin et al. BMC Public Health (2021) 21:265 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-021-10307-9 RESEARCH ARTICLE Open Access Comparison of barriers and facilitators of MIND diet uptake among adults from Northern Ireland and Italy Deirdre Timlin1, Barbara Giannantoni2, Jacqueline M. McCormack3, Angela Polito2, Donatella Ciarapica2, Elena Azzini2, Melanie Giles4 and Ellen E. A. Simpson4* Abstract Background: The aim of the study was to identify and compare components of the COM-B (capability, opportunity, motivation and behaviour) model, that influences behaviour to modify dietary patterns in 40–55-year olds living in Northern Ireland (NI) and Italy, in order to reduce the risk of cognitive decline in later life. Methods: This was a qualitative study examining factors influencing Mediterranean-DASH (Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension) Intervention for Neurodegenerative Delay (MIND) diet behaviour. This study further elaborated the COM-B components into the 14 domains of the Theoretical Domains Framework to further understand behaviour. Twenty-five Northern Irish and Italian participants were recruited onto the study, to take part in either a focus group or an interview. Participants were both male and female aged between 40 and 55 years. Results: Thematic analysis revealed that the main barriers to the uptake of the MIND diet were; time, work environment (opportunity), taste preference and convenience (motivation). Culture (motivation), seasonal foods and lack of family support (opportunity) to be a barrier to the Italian sample only. The main facilitators reported were; improved health, memory, planning and organisation (motivation) and access to good quality food (opportunity). Cooking skills, knowledge (capability) and heathy work lunch (opportunity) reported as a facilitator to the Italian sample only.
    [Show full text]
  • Century?BY HELEN SIGNY
    PUBLIC HEALTH Is that macrobiotic, super food, açai-filled health snack really the breakthrough to healthy eating you thought it was – or just the latest in a long line of trendy marketing ploys aimed at selling products? Is DietYour LastSo Century?BY HELEN SIGNY EALTHY EATING ADVICE seems to be constantly in flux: are eggs good or bad? Should you opt for ancient grains or go gluten-free? In reality, dietitians say, the popularity of eating crazesH are often based on a bestselling book, canny sales ploy or a new piece of research that is extrapolated meaninglessly to the general population. “Government dietary guidelines really haven’t changed all that much over the decades,” says accredited dietitian Rachel Jeffrey. 38 | October•2014 ILLUSTRATION: JAMES GULLIVER HANCOCK September•2014 | 39 IS YOUR DIET SO LAST CENTURY? “Sometimes new studies cause a change in our eating habits as science advances. But often people’s choices are based on select information or the influence of fashion,” says Jeffrey. Mapping how our tastes have ebbed and flowed over the decades proves the point. We take a nostalgic look back at what we once thought was the best way to eat – and what we’ve discovered along the way. THE NATURAL 1970S We were told: Counting kilojoules now that a kilojoule isn’t just a (calories) would make us thin. kilojoule, there’s a whole lot of Eating was all about: Reduced other things that come into it,” says caloric intake. This was the decade accredited clinical dietitian Gabrielle that saw the introduction of kilo- Maston.
    [Show full text]
  • Lech Lecha.Qxd
    THE OHR SOMAYACH TORAH MAGAZINE ON THE INTERNET • www.OHR.Edu O H R N E T SHAbbAT PARSHAT SHEMOT • 19 TEvET 5772 • jAN. 14, 2012 • vOl. 19 NO. 13 parSha inSighTS Kvelling “And these are the names of the children of Yisrael.” (1:1) magine a grandmother sitting with a stack of photos of her Because something that is dear and highly-prized is grandchildren. She takes out the pictures after breakfast repeated and re-examined many times. Iand leafs through them, reciting the names of each of her Like the photos of a doting granny. beloved treasures, one by one. The children of Yisrael are likened to the stars. Just as G-d After lunch she has a nap, and then, well, she takes out counts t he stars and calls them by name when they come her photos again and recites their names again. out, and again when they pass from the world and are gath - And last thing at night, out come the pictures for a last ered in, similarly he counts the children of Israel both when time, kissing them and calling each of them by name. they enter this world and when they are gathered in. The name of the book of Exodus in Hebrew is “Shemot”, The Book of Names. We should remember that since we are compared to the It starts with a list of the names of the children of Yaakov. stars we must emulate the stars. Just as the purpose of the Even though the Torah had already detailed the names of stars is to radiate light to the darkest and most distant cor - Yaakov’s children in their lifetimes, the Torah lists their ner of the universe, so too it is the job of the Jewish People names again here after their passing from the world, to show to radiate spiritual light to the most benighted corners of the how dear they are to G-d.
    [Show full text]
  • Plant-Based Eating Is About Choosing To
    Copyright 2016 by Ryan D. Andrews [email protected] All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by an information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the the author. In other words, don’t copy any of my work, sell it for profit, or pass it off as your own. That would be wrong. But you already knew that. The suggestions recommended in this book are not intended as a substitute for any dietary regimen prescribed by your doctor. As with any nutritional intervention, you should obtain your doctor’s approval before beginning. Further, and preferably, your physician should perform an overall assessment of your health and readiness. Ryan D. Andrews hereby disclaims any liability or loss in connection with the use of this guide and advice herein. 1 “One of the greatest opportunities to live our values - or betray them - lies in the food we put on our plates.” ― Jonathan Safran Foer 2 3 “Go too long without it on this earth and you leavin’ it Americans wastin’ it on some leisure shit And other nations be desperately seekin’ it” -New World Water by Mos Def I remember listening to the song New World Water by Mos Def back in 1999. As a rap ​ ​ fan, I quickly realized this wasn’t your typical rap fare. He wasn’t talking about bling, booty, or Cristal. He was talking about being responsible with water. Yes, water. The song challenged me. It was different.
    [Show full text]