Review of Insect and Disease Challenges to Alberta Coniferous Forests in Relation to Resistance Breeding and Climate Change
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
H.F. Cerezke Research Scientist (retired), Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forestry Service, Edmonton N.K. Dhir Manager, Genetics and Tree Improvement (retired) L.K. Barnhardt Manager, Alberta Tree Improvement and Seed Centre, Smoky Lake, Alberta Abstract Increasing temperatures with climate change during the coming decades are predicted to drastically alter forests and forest ecosystem dynamics. These changes will impact forest insects and diseases in many ways through changes in host tree distributions, population dynamics, moisture and nutrition, tree defence compounds, and through effects on natural predators, parasites, and mutualist feeders. Predicted changes in Alberta’s forests with climate change provide many new challenges for the integrated management of forest pests. To explore the scope of these challenges, a list was developed of insect and disease species considered to be currently the most economically important pests of concern in the management of Alberta’s coniferous forests, based on their past historical presence. Each of the 20 pest species identified is rated in relative economic importance according to management priority and on potential levels of damage impact they cause to forest values. The biology of each of the 20 species is briefly reviewed, their damage impacts are described, and information is summarized on likely interactions and potential responses to the changing climate. The science of genetics and tree breeding for pest resistance is reviewed to examine and explore possible opportunities that could have application in the management of future forests and pest populations in the province. Case history studies of four high-profile pests, including white pine blister rust (Cronartium ribicola), white pine weevil (Pissodes strobi), dwarf mistletoe (Arceuthobium americanum), and mountain pine beetle (Dendroctonus ponderosae) are reviewed in detail. Information is provided on life histories, populations, epidemiology, damage impacts, current management practices, climate relationships, and emphasis on genetics and tree breeding for pest resistance. The information in this report is intended to serve as a guide to help select and prioritize opportunities for genetic tree resistance breeding as part of climate change adaptation strategy, and to incorporate any new strategies into integrated pest management practices for protecting the health, productivity, and diversity of Alberta’s coniferous forests. Acknowledgements Initial planning and discussions for the content of this report involved contribution by Dr. Donald Lester. We also thank Dr. Deogratias Rweyongeza for his review of the manuscript and suggestions for improvement and Pearl Gutknecht and Pat Franchuk for providing secretarial assistance toward finalizing the report. This publication may be cited as: Cerezke, H.F., Dhir, N.K. and Barnhardt, L.K. 2013. Review of insect and disease challenges to Alberta coniferous forests in relation to resistance breeding and climate change. Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development. Forest Management Branch. Edmonton. 122 pp. ISBN: 978-1-4601-1278-6 (Printed Version) 978-1-4601-1279-3 (Online Version) Printed: July 2014 insect and disease challenges Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................1 2.0 Review of Important Forest Pests of Conifers in Alberta .............................................................4 3.0 Review of Science Pertaining to Genetics and Breeding Applicability.........................................6 4.0 Review of the Role of Climate Change on Identified Pest Species,Their Life Histories, Damage Impacts, and Prediction of Future Changes of Pests and Impact on Forest Health ........................................................................................................................13 4.1 Overview of Climate Change Issues in Alberta .................................................................13 4.2 Review of Potential Climate Change Effects on Insects and Diseases ............................15 4.3 Review of Potential Climate Change Effects on Important Insect and Disease Pests in Alberta ..................................................................................................21 4.3.1 Mountain pine beetle (Dendroctonus ponderosae Hopkins) .................................21 4.3.2 Spruce budworm (Choristoneura fumiferana [Clemens]) ......................................23 4.3.3 Spruce beetle (Dendroctonus rufipennis [Kirby]) ...................................................25 4.3.4 White pine weevil (Pissodes strobi [Peck]) ............................................................27 4.3.5 Whitespotted sawyer beetle (Monochamus scutellatus [Say]) ..............................28 4.3.6 Yellowheaded spruce sawfly (Pikonema alaskensis [Rohwer]) .............................30 4.3.7 Western spruce budworm (Choristoneura occidentalis Freeman) ........................31 4.3.8 Douglas-fir beetle (Dendroctonus pseudotsugae Hopkins) ...................................33 4.3.9 Warren rootcollar weevil (Hylobius warreni Wood) ................................................35 4.3.10 Spruce cone maggot (Strobilomyia neanthracina Michelsen) ...............................37 4.3.11 Armillaria root disease (Armillaria ostoyae [Romagn.] Herink) ..............................38 4.3.12 Tomentosus root rot (Inonotus tomentosus Karst.) ................................................41 4.3.13 Red ring rot (Phellinus pini [Brot. Fr.] Ames) .........................................................43 4.3.14 Stalactiform and comandra blister rusts (Cronartium coleosporioides Arthur and C. comandrae Peck) ..............................44 4.3.15 White pine blister rust (Cronartium ribicola J.C. Fischer) ......................................47 4.3.16 Western gall rust (Endochronartium harknessii [J.P. Moore] Y. Hiratsuka) ......................................................................................49 4.3.17 Atropellis canker (Atropellis piniphilia [Weir] Lohman & Cash)..............................52 4.3.18 Pine needle cast (Lophodermella concolor [Dearn.] Darker) ................................54 4.3.19 Dwarf mistletoe (Arceuthobium americanum Nutt.) ...............................................56 5.0 Review of Some Case Histories of Successful Programs and Approaches ..............................58 5.1 Case History 1: White Pine Blister Rust (Cronartium ribicola J.C. Fisch) .........................58 5.1.1 Taxonomy of pine susceptible species to WPBR ..................................................58 5.1.2 Distribution, infection and disease development of WPBR ...................................59 i insect and disease challenges 5.1.3 WPBR control and limber/whitebark pine restoration strategies ...........................61 5.1.4 Research and development of WPBR-resistant trees ...........................................62 5.1.5 Strategies, guidelines, and research for WPBR resistance breeding programs ...64 5.2 Case History 2: White Pine Weevil (Pissodes strobi [Peck]) .............................................68 5.3 Case History 3: Lodgepole Pine Dwarf Mistletoe (Arceuthobium americanum Nutt.) .......71 5.4. Case History 4: Mountain Pine Beetle (Dendroctonus ponderosae Hopkins) ...................76 5.4.1 Hosts, distributions, and life history .......................................................................76 5.4.2 Host selection, behaviour, and associated microorganisms ..................................77 5.4.3 Natural control and management strategies .........................................................80 5.4.4 Genetics and tree resistance .................................................................................81 5.4.5 Mountain pine beetle and pine host genomics ......................................................83 6.0 Reviews and Prioritization of Coniferous Pests for Resistance Breeding and Climate Change Adaptation Work ...........................................................................................................87 7.0 Discussion of Important Pests that Need to be Addressed through Genetics and Breeding in Alberta ....................................................................................................................90 8.0 Conclusions ..............................................................................................................................96 9.0 Literature Cited ..........................................................................................................................98 List of Tables Table 1. List of important forest insect and disease pests of conifers in Alberta and their current relative management priority and potential impact ratings on the forest resource values in the province. .........................................................................................5 Table 2. Categories and the number of points allotted in each category for rating important insect and disease pests of conifers in Alberta. ................................................................88 Table 3. Summary of the number of point ratings for each insect and disease species identified in Table 1 and according to the seven categories given in Table 2. ...................89 Table 4. List of important conifer pest species in Alberta and priority ratings from highest to lowest for considering the development of new or strengthening of