BORDERS AND IDENTITY A Resource Guide þr Teachers

IDENTIDAD Y FRONTERAS

Una guía para maestros O NTE NTS

Preface: BRcrcnouND To TnE BORDERS AND IDENTITY Mnrrntnls u

Introduction: Wnnr Dors B0RDERS AND IDENTITY Mrnn? 2l

TEACHER INTRODUCTION 23 MAP EXERCISES 27 Wuar Is a BoRoen? 27 Rerorr.¡c Mnps 27 IDENTITY EXERCISES 29 Depr¡r¡¡c loeNrrrv 29 A Srarev¡Nr or loextttv 3L ANorxen Loor¡r loeHrrv 3l NrcrNames 3t Desrcxrnc YouR OwH lornrlrv Cano 35 SUMMARY WHAT'S NEXT'7 37

Part 1: Hrsronv AND IDENTITY ts

TEACHER INTRODUCTION 4I DIScUSSIoNQUOTATION 43 VIDEOVIEWING 4' ExeRcrses 45 Vroeo CRrneue 45 Cnoosr n Quorarroru 45 I CULTURAL MAP 47 ExeRcrs¡s 47 HrsroRv: lNvrsrlcan¡¡c OuR P¡sr 47 Tue People oFrHE BonpeR 47 lunc¡s oF THE BonoeR: l¡lreRpRrrlHc Puorocnapgs 49 READING: BORDER HISTORY 5l Qursrrols AND ExERctsEs 55 SUMMARY 57 WHAT'S NEXT 57

Part 2: CrLrgnRnoNS AND lornrtrv js

TEACHERINTRODUCTION 6I DrscussroNQUorATloN 6t VIDEOVIEWING 65 Exencrses 65 CeLeeRAr¡ot¡At¡¡¡ouNceueHt 65 SuntNes rH Evenvonv Llpe 67 ExploRrruc Evrnvonv Rlru¡ls 69 PmNNr¡lcYouR OwH Flssr¡ 7L READING:THEVIRGIN OF GUADALUPE 75 QuesroNs ¡Ho ExeRctse 77 SUMMARY 8I WHAT'S NEXT 8I

Part 3: ExpnrssrvE TRADIT¡oNS AND IDENTITY 83

TEACHERINTRODUCTION 85 DrscussloN QUorATloN 87 VIDEOVIEWING 87 Exçncrses 89 Anr CHanr 89 CoRnloos:Tse StHclNc or a Stonv 89 LowRloens: A Srnreu¡nr FRoM THE Stneers 9t Tsenren lmpnovlsnrlo¡¡ 97 READING:THE STORY OFTHE DUO EL PALOMOY EL GORRIóN 99 Qursrons f0t READING: MURALS 103 Quesrotts tNo ExrRclses 107 SUMMARY IO9 WHAT'S NEXT IO9 Part 4: OccurRroNs AND lornrlrv ul

TEACHERINTRODUCTION II3 DrscusstoN QUoTATIoN ll7 VIDEOVIEWING II7 Exencrses I I9 Loorc¡¡c nt Occupnnorus I19 TouRrsv: Occupnrlo¡¡s nHo Econovv ll9 tNreRvrew: PnoressloNs lNYoun CoNvuN¡rv lt9 Usrr.¡c WHar's AnouNo lzl READING: INDUSTRY: CHEAP LABOR AND ASSEMBLY PLANTS 12' Quesrrorus aNo ExeRc¡ses 125 READING: R¡DINGTHE INTERNATIONAL FRONTIER I27 Quesrtons eruo ExeRclses l3l SUMMARY I35 WHAT'S NEXT T35

Part 5: Bonorns AND IDENTITy tN Youn Own Communlrv ß7

TEACHER INTRODUCTION I}9 sruDENT PRO|ECT 14l YOUR OWN MAP I4I ExeRcrses l4t DesrcurucYoun Pno¡ecr l4t Outlrrue 145 CaRRvrNc Our rse PnoJecr L45 PurrNc lrAllToc¡rnen 147 FOLLOW.UP I5I

Appendix: r5t

KEY DATES I55 KEYWORDS IóI coRRrDo l7l BIBLIOGRAPHY 173 VIDEOTRANSCRIPT I83 REPRINTS 207 TKOJLCT TLA¡.A,I LQU ODLTKAbAJO

C¡¡¡ren roR Folrllre PRocnaus & Vroeo PnooucrloN Currunal Sruoles: PnooucclóN oe vtDEo:- Writers Escritores: Betty Belanus, Emily Dialogue Productions : Farzin lllich and Botein,- Olivia Cadaval Martha Sipple Designer and lllustrator - Díseñadora e Orsen CoLLneoRATING lrusrlrur¡o¡rs llustradora: Joan Wolbier Ornas l¡.¡srltuclo¡¡es Design Assistant de diseño: -COLABORADORAS: Karin Hayes -Asistente Centro de lnformación de Historia Regional, Editors Editores: Carla Borden, Richard Kurin Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León Project -Assistants al proyecto: -Asistentes Consejo Nacional para las Culturas y las María Crespo, Mary Richards, Elena Artes, Programa Cultural de las Fronteras Williams John E. Conner Museum,Têxas A & M Et- Colec¡o DE LA FRo¡¡rena Nonre University (coLEF): Cultura Fronteriza, A.C. PrimaryAdvisor and Spanish Editor El Paso Community College Asesora principal y editora del español:- Margarita Miranda de Mascareñas Foundation Patricia Fernández de Castro Museo Regional de la Universidad Autónoma Spanish-language Producers of Narration and de Baja California en Mexicali Subtitles forVideo - Productores de Pimería Alta Historical Society narración y subtítulos en español del video: R. Ayuntamiento de Nuevo Laredo - María Eugenia de la O, Departamento de lnstituto Municipal de Educación y Cultura Estudios Culturales y Departamento de Raza Forever Comunicaciones TexasA & M University-Kingsville Pno¡ecr Aov¡sons TexasA & M lnternational Texas Foll

Tiju o n o, Bojo Califo r ni o Angel M.Yucupicio Olga Lidia Cortés Jesús Juan Yucupicio Peter Juvencio Extrada Maceda S.Yucupicio Guadalupe lsabel Flores de Extrada Gudad Juárez, Chihuohuo Gloria López López Brigada por La Paz Elia Hilda Maceda Flores Alonso Encina Herrera Ofelia Santos López Gustavo "Sleepy" Grado Tiscareño Francisco Paulino Sierra Cruz Jesús Alberto "Pee Wee" Rodríguez Sonto Cotorino, Bojo Colifornia Medina Benito Peralta Miguel Angel "El Tandy" Sandoval Lira Oscar Ramírez Tecote, Bojo Colifornio Los Alegres del Norte José Luis Lee Sandoval Emilio Chaírez Muñoz Mexicoli, Bojo Colifornio José Flores Cordova Andrés García Moreno Diego Hidalgo Alvarez Pedro Gabriel Gonzâlez Castro El Divisodero, Chihuahua Angel Norzagaray Norzagaray Guadalupe Carrasco Leyva Heriberto Norzagaray Norzagaray Poso de Lojitos, Chihuahuo Alejandra Rioseco de la Peña Baltasar Rodríquez Puentes Loreto Ramón Tamayo Rosas Nocimiento, Chihuahuo Cath e d ro I Gty, Califo r n i o Gertrude Factor Vásquez Carmen Cristina Moreno Alice F. Lozano

Nogo/es, Sonoro Monterrey,Nuevo León María Gloria Moroyoqui de Roques El Palomo y el Gorrión lmuris, Sonora Moisés Garcia Anastasio León Cirilo "El Palomo" Luna Franco Francisco Silva Miguel"El Gorrión" Luna Franco

Mogdeleno, Sonora El Pcsq ïexos Carlos Callejo Felipe de Jesús Valenzuela Agustín Castillo Son Simón Villoge, Arizono Romy Frías Mike L. Francisco Lojitas,Texos Joseph Alonzo Garcia Victor Augustine Garcia Adolfo Rodríguez Blaine W.Juan Presidio, Iexos Marie Leon Richard Mark Bernholz DelRio,Texos Ritchie, Suzie Reyes, Daniel Sheehy, Emily Ethel l.Warrior Socolov, Michael Stone,Thomas Vennum, José William F.Warrior Manuel Valenzuela, Felipe de Jesús Valenzuela, Kathy Vargas, Cynth ia Vidau rri, Lau ra Velasco Loredo,Texas Armando Flores CooRor¡¡anoRs FoR THE T¡lleRes DE LA María Paredes de Solís FRo¡¡renaWonrsuoP AND PenronvrNcE SERIES Son Diego,Iexos CoonorxrDoREs DE LA- sERtE TALLERES Omar Galván DE LA FnO¡¡renA O. Mendietta José Norma Cantú, Laredo,Texas Alberto Treviño Hector Romero, Nuevo Loredo,Tomoulipos E/so, ïexos Gene Mueller, E/ Poso,ïexos Los Hermanos Layton Socorro Tabuenca, Ciudod luárez, Chihuohuo Gilbert González Te resa Leal, Nogo/es, SonorolNog ol es, Arizo n a AntonioV. Layton Helen Mackay López, EI Centro, Colifornio Benigno Layton Patricia Fernández de Castro, Mexicoli, Norfilia Layton González Bojo Colifornio René Layton Maricela Gonzâlez télix, Mexicoli, Bojo Californio Brownsville,Texos Julius Collins SpecralrxANKs AcR¡oeceMos EN- ESPEcIAL A: R¡senRcnERs AND PRrseNrens - I ¡¡vesrtcnDoREs Y PRESENTADoRES: Rebecca Barrera,Tiffany Belka, Patricia Enrique Avilés, Guillermo Berrones, Norma Berrones, David Bosserman, Salvador Cantú, Jessica Chapin, Andrew Connors, Calderón Rodriguez, Robert Calphee, María Eugenia de la O, Everardo Garduño, Márgara de León,Armando Flores, Nelson Celso Garza Guajardo, Maricela Gonzâlez García Canclini, Joe Graham,Victor Guerra, Felix, Mary Lou Gortárez,James Griffith,lan Helen Mackay López,losé Manuel Mas- Hancock, Pat Jaspeç Blaine Juan, Enrique careñas, Amado Padilla, Diana Parker, Lamadrid, Laura Larco, Enrique Madrid, Horacio Quintanilla, Margarita Roque, Francisco Javier Moreno, Angel Norzagara¡ José Luis Sánchez, Barbara Strickland, Manuel Peña, Kathy Raglan, MichaelJames LisaYarger, Angela Yancius

@ 199ó Smithsonian lnstitution, center for Folklife Programs & cultural Studies Cosponsors/ Coouspiciodores: El Colegio de Ia Frontera Norte and/yTexas Folklife Resources This project has been made possible with major support of/ Este Proyecto se ho reolizado con el apoyo principal de.' Smithsonian lnstitution's Special Exhibitions Fund. ln addition, the project has been supported byl El proyecto tombién ha recibido el opoyo de: Arizona Commission on the Arts, California Arts Council Multi-Cultural Arts Development Project, International Bank of Commerce, Meadows Foundation, Smithsonian Educational- Outreach Fund, Southwest Airlines, Southwestern Bell Telephone t í .'-. -' Compan¡Têxas Committee for the Humanities, & US-Mexico Fund for Culture l.;.:-- (Fideicomiso para la Cultura México/USA) Fundación Cultural Bancomer,The lr- - ., '! - '..': Rockefeller Foundation, & the Fondo Nacional para la Cultura y las Artes. . ) ''. llftts.c0 This project has been recognized by UNESCO as an activity of the World Decade for Cultural Development./ Este proyecto se ha reconocido por UNESCO como uno octívidod del WORLD DECADE FOR CULTUEAL OEVELOPMENT DÉcEilNtE M0NDraL[ DU DÉvELoppEMErr cULTUREL Decenio mundiol para el desorrollo culturol. Preface:

BNCKGROUND TO THE BORDERS AND IDENTITY MATERIALS

Prdacio:

AnTEcEDENTEs DE Los

MATERIALES DE IDENTIDAD Y FRONTERAS PREFACE

In the summer of 1993, the Smithsonian lnstitution's Festival of American Folldife featured a program on the culture of the United States-lYexico borderlands. Over one hundred residents of the U.S.-Mexico border regìon gathered on the Nationaì Mall in Washington, D.C., to demonstrate their knowledge and sl

The Festival program provided a gìimpse of the many different components that shape border culture: different histories, religious beliefs, occupations, local and regional identities, music, art, crafts, theaten heal i ng practices, foodways, and storytelling, t3 The Festival was held in Washrngton, D.C., but the research took place along the border:The success of Gloriø Moroyogui, of Nogoles, Sonora, shores åorder stories with íefr the Festival encouraged to rìght) Enrique Lomddrid, of Albuquerque, New Mexico,Arturo Corrillo Strong of lucso n, Arizono, and Reynoldo Hernández, of Nogales, Arìzono. Smithsonian stafí and Festival t Glorio Moroyoqui de Nogoles, Sonoro, com|arte historios de Ia vìdø en researchers and particrpants lø fronterø con (ìzquierda ø derecha) Enrique Lomodrid de Albuquerque, to pursue production of Nuevo México,Arturo Cdrrìllo Strong de lucson,Arizono,y Reynaldo Hernández de Nogoles, Arizono. Photo bytfoto de Ricñord strouss, cou¡tesy/co.tesío educational materials, for Smitäson¡øn rnst¡tution PREFACE

use along the border and beyond,The Borders ond ldentity educational materials are based on the photographs and video and audio documentation from the 1993 Festival research and presentation,

These materials aim to contribute to an increased understanding of the complexities of border culture through a focus on the peoples and places of the U.S,-Yexico bordenThe materials encourage students to explore different kinds of borders and to examine how borders shape identities,through close examination of the experi- ences of border residents and also of students themselves. Planned activrties will challenge students to thinl< critically and creatively and will stimulate them to form conclusions through careful observation and analysis. Students will be encouraged to express themselves through role-playing, writing, and art worl<

The Borders ond ldentíty materials include this teacher resource guìde, a founpart video, and a poster-size cultural map with additional exercises.The goals for the materials are: I to introduce students to the peoples and cultures of the U.S.-Mexico border;

I to guide students in an investigation of borders in their own communìties and to think about how such borders affect their lives and identities;

* to introduce students and teachers to ethnographic investigation methods (close observation and documentation of living persons) used by foll

I to engage students in critical thought through the use of oral interviews, photographs, videos, maps, documents, and topical readings. Student exercises take a variety of forms: wrìtten, per formed, recorded. t5 This guide is written for teachers and students. Each section begins wìth an introduc- tion for the teachen The loose-leaf format allows teachers to reproduce pages as needed and to add new materials to "customìze" the materials for each classroom. Exercises and readìngs are wrìtten for a student audience and are meant to be xeroxed from this bool<.

The overall structure of the teacher resource guide is as foìlows: I an introductìon to the concept of borders and identrty with related exercises; PREFACE

t four sections corresponding to the four parts of the video (History, Celebrations, Expressive Trad itions, occu pations). Each section i ncludes: a discussion quotation wrth questions to be completed prior to viewing the video;

questions and exercises to follow the video;

- a short reading with discussion questions and exercises. I a concluding section to guide students in their own documen- tation pro.lect;

I appendix with key dates, l

The content of the six sections plus Appendix is as follows: lntroduction:What Does Borders ond ldentity Mean? This sectìon locates the U.s.-lYexico border through the use of maps and intro- duces the topic of borders,what is a border? How does it affect people's lives? What does identity mean? Discussion questions and exercises encourage students to examine maps - both of the u.s,-lYexico border as well as their own com- munities - and to guide students to understand how borders shape people's identities as well. Part l: History and ldentity This section stresses the importance of historical circumstances in the formation of today's border culture. In addition to Part I of the video, students will use the cultural map. A short reading provides more in-depth inlormation about the his- tory of the U.S.-Mexico border:

Part 2t Celebrations and ldentity This section lool