DOCSLIB.ORG

Downloaded from Brill.Com10/08/2021 08:21:09AM Via Free Access 88

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Downloaded from Brill.Com10/08/2021 08:21:09AM Via Free Access 88 /r.1m:.1tion:1! St,,dit1 Re1·iew V9/ I:? Nn 2 /Otumbtr20/ II: 95-115 87 R<'<:cived Sep«mbcr 15. 2011 Rev·iseJ November 17, 2011 Accepml November 30. 20 I I Who is the Strongest in Washingto n , D.C.?: A Comparative Study on the Korean­ American Comfo rt W omen Movement and the Ja panese-Arnerican Redress Movement EUNJUNG LIM• Washingcon. D.C. is noc only che national capital of the U nircd Scares. but it is also an imernacional arena in which world political issues :ire substancially dealt with. Immig rants in the: lJ nice<l Scares represent influence in world polirics, exemng cheir leverage on policy makers in Washington, D.C. Tht: Korean-Amcrica111 Comfort W omen Movement in 2007 and rhe Japanese-Amc:rican Redress Movement from 1970 ro 1992 share common grounJ in ct:rms of their norms and strategies for success. This article conducrs comparative analy­ sis on thtc t wo g rassroots movements based on Resource Mobiliz:irion Theory, and suggests their realistic implications ro political dynamics in Washington, D.C. · Keywords: Washington, D.C. , Grassroots Politics, Immig rants Group, Resource Mobilization Theory . Comfort \X1omcn Movement. Redress Movement • Ph.D. 0.nd,dacc, & hool or Advo1nced lmemational Studies, Johns Hopkins Univc,rsity Visiting Fellow, lntcrfaculty lnitinive in lnformacion Studu~s. The University uf Tokyo E-mail: tlim6@ jhu.edu Downloaded from Brill.com10/08/2021 08:21:09AM via free access 88 1. INTRODUCTION n che conrexc of foreign policy ,1n<l internacional r<:lacions, Washing.con, I D.C. is in ;1 league- of ics own. lcs rornl population of roughly 600,000 and total area of 68.3 square miles may nor qualify ic as a global cicy un<lN Sasscn (2002)'s definition, bu1 not even New York City is comparable co the scale and m,1gnicuJe of impact Washingron plays inccrnacionally. 1c is for chis reason chat officials from Japan, for instance, incenrionally make regular round trips between Narica and Dulles for official meerings wich Capirol Hill and a<lminiscracion personnel, chac lases only one or two days ac any one time. South Korean Presideac Lee Myung-bak spent nearly a full week in Washington during his official visit, an indication chat world leaders recognize the dividends one reaps by being in chis town physically. The ongoing economic recession, che ep1cenrer of which was Wall Stre<:c, has nused qu(:sr1ons as co whc:ch<:r rhe Uniced Scates is slipping from its srnrus as che preeminenc policical and economic power in the world; nevercheless , ir will remain .it lc:ast one of the most influential players, with \Xlashingcnn remaining in its uniqu.- pruminl·nce. U.S foreign policy is not confinl-<l w high levd diplomatic: mi:erings in \Xlashing­ con, D.C. Alrhough che revolving door rc-lacionship inherenr co chis cown between lobbyisrs and elected politici.rns ofcc.-n involve domestic agenda. many lobbyists also r<'pr<,senc internanonal business and governmenr diencs as well. In chis reh1civdy less-public forum played br ocnup:ints of K Screec officc:s, influemial phtyers seek to shape and influence U.S. foreign policy relevanr co cheir areas o( inct.-rl'St. 1\n txtrem<' example of chis pr:1c cicc- is in 199). when chen-Taiwan President Lcc- Teng-hui hired Cassidy and Associaci:s co pressure.- rhe U.S. Stare Department inco reconsidering its initial rejecrion of a visa request by Lee co travel co Cornell University. his alma macer. Lee's success in playing rhc K stret'c game had immediate geopolitical 1mplicacions. China responded co Washingcon's U-curn over Lee's visa by !:lunching missile tescs and rnilicary exercises in che Taiwan Scraic, which ulcimacely lead co the Third Taiwan Straits Crisis (Sheng 2001, 24-28; Ross 2000). Nevertheless, U.S. foreign policy evolves not only within public official meetings and private lobbyists; inceraccions. Bottom-up, grassroots movements also bave che potencjaJ co influence how Washingcon gets involved in incernacional cop ies. This article discusses two successful examples of chis category: namely rhe Korean-American Comfort Women Movcmenr in 2007 and the Japanese-American Redress Movement from 1970 co 1992. In presenting the cwo grassroots move­ ments, the paper serves co examine dynamics of immigram groups' mobilization in Washington, D .C., and hopes co contribute cowards a more holistic under­ scanding of rhe underlying dynamic forces char influence and shape chis city. Downloaded from Brill.com10/08/2021 08:21:09AM via free access (1,;NJUNG LIM 89 I. The Carns to be Studied "Comfort women" 1s a euphemiscic term for Asian women forceJ co serve as sex slavt-s for the Japanese Imperial Army. While the mosc prommenc stories come from the Korean Peninsula and China, Japan has vicumizt-d women ebcwherc in Asia, such as the Philippines and Indonesia, following its start o( a foll -scale warm rhe region in 1937 clial cvrnlu,illy di,,1l,u1:J imo WorlJ War li's Pacific Theater in 1941 . The foll excem of che victimization of chese women 1s difficult co measure; in face, the issue di<l noc come into the public spotlight even in South Korea until August 1991, when Kim Hak-Sun went public with her story as a comforc woman (Scecz and Oh 200 I, 16). lnspire<l by Kim's courage, former comfort women and civil activists have held "Wednesday Procesrs" in front of the Japanese Embassy building in Seoul every week since J anuary 8, 1992. Their voit<:"S Jem:tnding chat Tokyo apologizt· and make appropriarc compcn­ s:uions have foll 1:trgely on deaf ears for years. However, mobilizacion of Korean­ Americans m chi.' Uniced Scates to pass a resolucion m che U.S. House of Repn:sencacivcs cm,cizing the Japanc-se government on chc issue awakened Tokyo to July 2007 , forc ing 1t co engage in unsuccessful aJ h()c measurc:s such rus b11 y111g a full -page Waslungcon Post .uJ chac conJemneJ chc Comfort Women Movement, as cxplamed tn che l:icer secnon. 1l owevcr, chis rs not chc: only example of g rassroots movements in0ucncing 1ncern:1rion:1l nffairs. Twcmy years ago. J apanese-Americans succeedcJ in having ch,· ll.S. government :tpologize for its dccainmenc of 120.000 Japanc-se-Americans ltvrng in che Unrced Scates mainland into ten concentration camps, which were euphcmiscirnll y calkd ''relocation centers ." Following th<:' shocking ;mack o n Ptarl Harbor by J apan in 194 I. Franklin Roosevck issued Exern~ive Order 9066 due co suspicions rhac Japanese-Americans had been collaborating with their ancestral homeland in the war and hence needed to be locked up in prison camps. While chis tragedy cemained a taboo among J apanese-Americans for dc-cadt-s. as in the comfort women situation in South Koce:t. a grassroocs rnovemem seeking co redress che issue began tn che 1970s. le culminaced in 1992 when the U.S. government apologiied for che mass lockups and paid $20,000 for each of the surviving victims as compensation (Niiya 2001, 120-125; McPhee 2006, 13-16; Daniels ct al. 1986, 3-6). There is a two-decade time lag between these two movements. However, che cwo movements share several common characteristics for analytical interests. Firsc, boch cases are rclaced co compensation issues for World War 11 victims. Second, the rwo movements define a specific government as responsible for che victims' plighr and soughc justice. In ocher words, both o( chese mobilizations were boccom -up actions. Third, both movements employed the U.S. legislative system co achieve their goals. Fourth, they are g rassroots movements in che sense char respective Foreign Miniseries did not mobilize chem. Lastly, both Downloaded from Brill.com10/08/2021 08:21:09AM via free access 90 Who 11 tin Strongm in \fla1h111g1011, O.C.i movements involve Asian-American communmes. A compa.rarive analysis of these rwo cases may lead ro a bercer understanding of how Asian-American g roups mobilize co make a political impact 111 Washington, D.C., and ulcimacely shape U .S. foreign policy. 2. Theoretical Frnmework ,md Outline lJj the Article Two major cheoretical frameworks provide comrascing explanacions when analyz­ ing key factors of social movements. On rhe one hand, classical Collecrive Behavior Tiheory (CBT) characterizes social movcmcnrs as emotional, impuls.ive, and un­ ocganized phenomena based on unpredictable mass enthusiasm (Morris 2000). Resource Mobilization Theory (RMT ), on rhe ocher hand, recognizes socia.1 move­ ments and movement participants as political, well-planned, and organized. Morris's ( 1992) explanacion on che American Civil Rig hcs Movemenc , for mscance, is analycically relevant co rhe scudy c-0nducrc:d in rhis :micle. Morris suggests rhac che RMT Model firs che analysis of che Civil Righrs Movement, and he concludes dlar colkctivc acrion is rational and it develops from pre('xisci n,!! social scrucrures and poli tical processes. RMT is useful especially when invesrigating che abili ri cs uf groups to organize, mobilize, and manage the necessa.ry resources for success of a movemenc. As Morris ( 1984) scares, RMT illuminates the UTiporcance and necessit)' of rhe resm,rces ro inici11ce and J<:v<:l op :1ny social movemc:nt. The resources incluJe form:d or in formal organizacions , leaders, money, r>eople. amJ rhc ,ummunicy's necwurk. RMT does noc focus on governance. psychic strain, and ocher psychological sr:ares of members who participaced in a movement for ,cs anal)'SIS. I nsread. chc theory mainly annlyzcs chc: ability of groups cu organize, mobil ize:, and manage valuable resources chat determine whether the)' will be able co engage in social pcocest.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Arts, Culture and Media 2010 a Creative Change Report Acknowledgments
    Immigration: Arts, Culture and Media 2010 A Creative Change Report Acknowledgments This report was made possible in part by a grant from Unbound Philanthropy. Additional funding from the Carnegie Corporation of New York, Ford Foundation, Four Freedoms Fund, and the Open Society Foundations supports The Opportunity Agenda’s Immigrant Opportunity initiative. Starry Night Fund at Tides Foundation also provides general support for The Opportunity Agenda and our Creative Change initiative. Liz Manne directed the research, and the report was co-authored by Liz Manne and Ruthie Ackerman. Additional assistance was provided by Anike Tourse, Jason P. Drucker, Frances Pollitzer, and Adrian Hopkins. The report’s authors greatly benefited from conversations with Taryn Higashi, executive director of Unbound Philanthropy, and members of the Immigration, Arts, and Culture Working Group. Editing was done by Margo Harris with layout by Element Group, New York. This project was coordinated by Jason P. Drucker for The Opportunity Agenda. We are very grateful to the interviewees for their time and willingness to share their views and opinions. About The Opportunity Agenda The Opportunity Agenda was founded in 2004 with the mission of building the national will to expand opportunity in America. Focused on moving hearts, minds, and policy over time, the organization works closely with social justice organizations, leaders, and movements to advocate for solutions that expand opportunity for everyone. Through active partnerships, The Opportunity Agenda uses communications and media to understand and influence public opinion; synthesizes and translates research on barriers to opportunity and promising solutions; and identifies and advocates for policies that improve people’s lives.
    [Show full text]
  • Analyzing the Tea Party Movement, the Coffee Party Movement, and The
    Syracuse University SURFACE Syracuse University Honors Program Capstone Syracuse University Honors Program Capstone Projects Projects Spring 5-1-2012 Analyzing the Tea Party Movement, the Coffee Party Movement, and the Occupy Wall Street Movement’s Use of the Internet: Case Study on How the Internet Influences Grassroots Social Movement Tsubasa Morioka Syracuse University Follow this and additional works at: https://surface.syr.edu/honors_capstone Part of the Communication Technology and New Media Commons, Mass Communication Commons, Social Influence and oliticalP Communication Commons, and the Social Media Commons Recommended Citation Morioka, Tsubasa, "Analyzing the Tea Party Movement, the Coffee Party Movement, and the Occupy Wall Street Movement’s Use of the Internet: Case Study on How the Internet Influences Grassroots Social Movement" (2012). Syracuse University Honors Program Capstone Projects. 159. https://surface.syr.edu/honors_capstone/159 This Honors Capstone Project is brought to you for free and open access by the Syracuse University Honors Program Capstone Projects at SURFACE. It has been accepted for inclusion in Syracuse University Honors Program Capstone Projects by an authorized administrator of SURFACE. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Analyzing the Tea Party Movement, the Coffee Party Movement, and the Occupy Wall Street Movement’s Use of the Internet: Case Study on How the Internet Influences Grassroots Social Movement A Capstone Project Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements of the
    [Show full text]
  • Daca Eligible Students Should Not Be Removed from This
    DACA ELIGIBLE STUDENTS SHOULD NOT BE REMOVED FROM THIS COUNTRY AND SHOULD BE ELIGIBLE FOR ADVANTAGES LIKE FINANCIAL AID By Selene C. Vázquez A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of The Harriet L. Wilkes Honors College in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts in Liberal Arts and Sciences with a Concentration in Law and Society Wilkes Honors College of Florida Atlantic University Jupiter, Florida May 2017 DACA ELIGIBLE STUDENTS SHOULD NOT BE REMOVED FROM THIS COUNTRY AND SHOULD BE ELIGIBLE FOR ADVANTAGES LIKE FINANCIAL AID by Selene C. Vázquez This thesis was prepared under the direction of the candidate’s thesis advisor, Dr. Mark Tunick, and has been approved by members of her supervisory committee. It was submitted to the faculty of The Honors College and was accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Arts in Liberal Arts and Sciences. SUPERVISORY COMMITTEE: ___________________________ Dr. Mark Tunick ___________________________ Dr. Timothy Steigenga ___________________________ Dean Ellen Goldey, Wilkes Honors College ___________ Date ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Foremost, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my thesis and academic advisor, Dr. Mark Tunick, for the continuous support throughout my undergraduate experience, for his patience, motivation, mentoring, insightful comments, and hard questions. His guidance has been instrumental not only in writing this thesis but also in and outside the classroom, in Moot Court competitions the past four years, and throughout every summer internships I have been a part of, which include the most recent one in Washington, D.C. I would also like to thank my Spanish Advisor, Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Immigrants, Politics, and Local Response in Suburban Washington Audrey Singer, Jill H
    SURVEY SERIES FOR THE METROPOLITAN POLICY PROGRAM AT BROOKINGS Immigrants, Politics, and Local Response in Suburban Washington Audrey Singer, Jill H. Wilson, and Brooke DeRenzis Findings Following the failure of national immigration reform in 2006 and 2007, local leaders in many areas with fast-growing immigrant populations stepped in to address the issue, capturing media and public atten- tion with scores of proposed immigration-related ordinances. A case study of the local, regional, and, ultimately, national factors that led Prince William County—an outer suburb of Washington, DC emblem- atic of the trend—to adopt new policies towards unauthorized immigrants finds: n Prince William County, VA has experienced rapid population growth and dynamic change. The “ Municipalities county’s total population more than doubled between 1980 and 2006, while its immigrant population swelled to more than 14 times its 1980 size. Between 2000 and 2006, Prince William’s Hispanic popu- across the country lation tripled in size, making it one of the nation’s top counties for Latino growth. confront tough n Housing and jobs drove population growth in Prince William County, drawing newcomers from around the region and the nation, including immigrants. Relatively stable during the 1990s, home choices as they prices in the Washington region soared from 2000 to 2005; job growth and decentralization made farther-flung suburbs like Prince William County more affordable than those in the inner core. undergo rapid n Long-time residents—particularly in older neighborhoods where many Hispanic newcomers concentrated—perceived a decline in their quality of life and feared a drop in property values due change due to to visible signs of neglect and overcrowding.
    [Show full text]
  • Do Model Minorities Drink Wine Or Beer? the Representation of Race, Elitism and American Identity*
    【특집】 Do Model Minorities Drink Wine or Beer? The Representation of Race, Elitism and American Identity* Konrad Ng (University of Hawai‘i, Mānoa) Introduction In August 2008, NPR and ABC political analyst Cokie Roberts criticized then-Democratic Presidential Candidate, Barack Obama, for choosing to vacation in Hawai‘i, the state of his birth and where his late-grandmother and other relatives lived. Roberts argued that Obama should have chosen to vacation in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, stating, “I know Hawaii is a state, but it has the look of him going off to some sort of foreign, exotic place.”1) The implication, as New York Times editorial * A version of this article appears in The Obama Effect: Multidisciplinary Renderings of the 2008 Presidential Election Campaign, eds. Heather Harris, Kimberly Moffitt and Catherine Squires. (New York: State University of New York Press, 2010). 1) Media Matters for America, “Cokie Roberts on Obama’s Vacation: ‘I know His Grandmother Lives in Hawaii and I Know Hawaii Is a State,’ but It Looks ‘Foreign, Exotic,’” (Washington, DC: Media Matters for America, August 10, 2008), accessed August 10, 2008, http:// mediamatters.org/mmtv/200808100001; Media Matters for America,“Roberts 144 Konrad Ng writer Lawrence Downes noted, was that “Hawaii is elitist while South Carolina is not, and that Mr. Obama was foolishly squandering votes by walking on the wrong beach in the wrong state.”2) Indeed, Roberts’s comments suggest that Hawai‘i, a state that is predominantly Asian, Pacific Islander and Native Hawaiian in history, culture and population, is dissonant with mainstream America and that a trip to Hawai‘i would be a mistake for the first minority Democratic Presidential nominee.
    [Show full text]
  • Immigration and American Society
    IMMIGRATION AND AMERICAN SOCIETY Tufts University Sociology 70 Spring 2014 Professor: Dr. Helen B. Marrow Email: [email protected] Phone: 617-627-2140 Office: Eaton Hall 116 (in the basement) Office hours: Tuesdays 4:30-5:30pm and Thursdays 1:30-2:30pm (a weekly signup sheet is posted on my office door) Course time: Tuesdays/Thursdays 3:00-4:15pm (I/I+ Block) Course location: Eaton 206 Course blog: http://sites.tufts.edu/soc70spring2014/ Prerequisites: None Course Description No other phenomenon is remaking contemporary societies more than international migration. According to the United Nations, in 2008 there were 214 million international labor migrants (10-15% of them unauthorized) and 15.2 million officially-recognized refugees worldwide. In the United States alone, there were roughly 38 million foreign-born individuals in 2008 (roughly one third of them unauthorized), and together with their children, they made up almost a quarter of the total U.S. population. The movement of people across nation-state boundaries and their settlement in various receiving societies – from the European nations that used to send their citizens to the United States more than a century ago, to oil-rich Middle Eastern states and developing nations – has the potential to alter the nature and significance of fundamental institutions and organizing categories, such as citizenship, the nation-state, race, ethnicity, gender, and class. This course provides an introductory look into the topic of, and the major debates surrounding, international migration, using the United States as a local lens for understanding important phenomena that are occurring in other countries, too.
    [Show full text]