Le Morte Darthur"

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Le Morte Darthur W&M ScholarWorks Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects 1978 "The tale of Sir Tristam": its role in Malory's "Le morte Darthur" Barbara Ann Crump College of William & Mary - Arts & Sciences Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wm.edu/etd Part of the English Language and Literature Commons, and the Medieval Studies Commons Recommended Citation Crump, Barbara Ann, ""The tale of Sir Tristam": its role in Malory's "Le morte Darthur"" (1978). Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. Paper 1539625025. https://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21220/s2-htc5-sz84 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects at W&M ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects by an authorized administrator of W&M ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. "THE TALE OF SIR TRISTRAM”--ITS ROLE IN *V MALORY'S LE MORTE DARTHUR A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Department of English The College of William and Mary in Virginia In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts by t Barbara Crump 1978 APPROVAL SHEET This thesis is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Barbara Crump Approved, April 1978 / Q^^JbuL^* ^ s f o \ \ x \W. Conlee, Ph.D. Charles E. Davidson, Ph.D. fCter D. Wiggins^^hTo. ii 6 8 810 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS. iv ABSTRACT ... v INTRODUCTION . 2 Chapter I. THE KINGS AND THEIR COURTS. 4 II. ISOUD AND GUENEVERE 13 III. TRISTRAM AND LANCELOT . 20 CONCLUSION.. .... 31 NOTES............. ..... 34 BIBLIOGRAPHY . .... 36 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I wish to thank Dr. John W. Conlee for his suggestions, criticisms, and most of all his patience in the preparation of this thesis. Without his support, the paper never would have been completed. ABSTRACT In his late medieval retelling of the Arthurian legends, Sir Thomas Malory purposefully included "The Tale of Sir Tristram" to provide a literary counterpoint to the tale of Camelot. In particular, Malory created each of the characters in the Mark/Isoud/Tristram love triangle to serve as a foil to his or her parallel character in the Arthur/Guenevere/ Lancelot triangle. Mark is systematically blackened, making him a complete antithesis to the noble King Arthur. Isoud, portrayed as a more noble heroine than in the earlier romances, is made more appealing not only to justify the conflict between Mark and Tristram for her love, but also to enable her to function as a foil to the less appealing, albeit romanticized, Queen Guenevere. Tristram’s divided loyalties and inner conflicts as he tries to decide to whom he owes loyalty serve to mirror the equally agonizing dilemma tormenting Lancelot, while at the same time emphasizing the weaknesses inherent in the chivalric code. Therefore, it becomes apparent that Malory included "The Tale of Sir Tristram" in his work to provide a principal contrast to the Arthurian love story. Although there is still critical discussion as to the wisdom of Malory's inclusion of the Tristram section within Le^ Morte Darthur, nevertheless "The Tale of Sir Tristram," when viewed in conjunction with the central love story, aids the reader in seeing the Arthur-saga in a clearer perspective. v "THE TALE OF SIR TRISTRAM"--ITS ROLE IN MALORY'S LE MORTE DARTHUR INTRODUCTION Sir Thomas Malory's decision to include "The Tale of Sir Tristram" in Le Morte Darthur creates a major obstacle for critics who view Malory's great work as having a coherent unity. By including the story of Tristram with the story of Arthur, Malory has introduced materials which had never before been linked closely with the Arthurian legend and which have no direct bearing on the rise and fall of the fellowship of the Round Table. One must consider, then, what purpose, if any, "The Tale of Sir Tristram" was intended to serve in relation to the larger work. Thomas C. Rumble, the author of the Tristram chapter in Robert Lumiansky's book Malory's Originality, provides the most extensive justification for Malory's inclusion of "The Tale of Sir Tristram."^ For Rumble the chief importance of the Tristram section lies in the fact that this section contains certain crucial events in the feud between Gawain and Lamorak. In one sense Rumble's point is well taken: the Gawain-Lamorak feud is_ vital to the final outcome of the Arthur story. But the inclusion of this material within the Tristram section is not in itself sufficient justification for the existence of the entire Tristram section: there is no apparent reason why Malory felt it necessary to position the Gawain-Lamorak material within the Tristram section rather than elsewhere in the Morte. In a way, then, Rumble1 discussion is beside the point, for the fundamental question still remains: why did Malory Include the material relating to Tristram, Isoud, and Mark in Le Morte Darthur? Rumble does, however, touch in passing on a more per­ tinent justification when he suggests that Malory uses "The Tale of Sir Tristram" in order to magnify the virtues of Camelot when compared with the turmoil and unrest plaguing Cornwall, thereby serving to intensify the pathos created when Arthur's "ideal" society of peers ultimately collapses. But Rumble is content to leave this important observation unexplored and unsubstantiated. I intend, therefore, to explore the ways in which Malory uses the Tristram section of the Morte as a principal contrast and literary counter­ point to the tale of Arthur, Guenevere, and Lancelot. I wish to demonstrate that through his use of parallel themes, motifs, and episodes, Malory unites the "Tristram" with the rest of the Morte and in so doing he creates for his readers a "correlative of, not a sequel to, the story of Arthur's 2 fellowship." Of particular importance are the love triangl of Arthur/Guenevere/Lancelot and Mark/Isoud/Tristram; there­ fore, this study will focus on the various parallels which Malory so carefully draws for his readers between the kings and their courts, the ladies, and the knights. CHAPTER I THE KINGS AND THEIR COURTS At the end of Book III, when all of his knights have returned to Camelot, King Arthur sets forth the chivalric code by which the Round Table - the very life-blood of his kingdom - shall be governed: . never to do outrageousity nor murder, and always to flee treason; also, by no means to be cruel, but to give mercy unto him that asketh mercy, upon pain of forfeiture of their worship and lordship of King Arthur for ever­ more; and always to do ladies, damosels, and gentlewomen succour, upon pain of death. Also, that no man take no battles in a wrongful quarrel for no law, nor for no world's goods.3 The code is lofty in its idealism and sentiment; as the knights of the Round Table strive to uphold it, the kingdom of Camelot comes to represent the pinnacle of earthly power and glory: Also Merlin made the Round Table in tokening of roundness of the world, for by the Round Table is the world signified by right, for all the world, Christian and heathen, repair unto the Round Table; and when they are chosen to be of the fellowship of the Round Table they think them more blessed and more in worship than if they had gotten half the world; . (XIV.ii). Unfortunately, there are inherent contradictions and weak­ nesses in Arthur's chivalric code, for it ignores human frailties and failings. For example, although a knight was expected never to betray his country or his liege lord, and he was expected always to serve ladies in time of need, there is no provision for establishing the knight's priorities if these ideals should conflict. Arthur's subjects strive to 4 5 live by these high standards of behavior, and as a result Camelot becomes a model for the ideal society; yet the inability of Arthur's knights to live up to these standards ultimately results in the collapse of the Round Table. In contrast with Camelot, the court of Cornwall is known for its ineffectual government and its cowardly knights. Perhaps Sir Kay best expresses this view: "Fie on you false knight, said Sir Kay, for ye of Cornwall are not worth" (IX.xxxviii). This judgment of Cornwall's knights reappears often in the Morte. Thus Camelot is viewed as the potentially ideal society while Cornwall is viewed with disfavor. In Book VIII, Malory presents an incident which links the two kingdoms and clearly reveals the manner in which each is regarded. In this incident Morgan le Fay sends a horn of adultery to Arthur's court. The horn is intended to reveal Guenevere as an adulteress and Arthur as a cuckold. Lamorak confiscates the horn, diverts it to King Mark's court, and is chided by Tristram for doing so. Lamorak replies that he would rather disgrace Mark's court than Arthur's, "for the honour of both courts be not alike" (VIII.xxxviii). The reputation of each of these kingdoms is closely bound to the reputation of its monarch. Just as there is a huge chasm between the way the courts of Camelot and Cornwall are viewed, so also is there a significant difference between Mark and Arthur as monarch and as men. In the early French versions of "The Tale of Sir Tristram," King Mark is por­ trayed as a kind and generous ruler who becomes the hapless victim of the tragic but unconquerable love shared by Tristram 6 and Isoud.
Recommended publications
  • Having Ado with Lancelot
    Having Ado with Lancelot: A Chivalric Reassessment of Malory's Champion by Jesse Michael Brillinger Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts (English) Acadia University Fall Convocation 2010 © Jesse Michael Brillinger 2010 This thesis by Jesse M. Brillinger was defended successfully in an oral examination on ___________. The examining committee for the thesis was: ________________________ Dr. Barb Anderson, Chair ________________________ Dr. Kathleen Cawsey, External Reader ________________________ Dr. Patricia Rigg, Internal Reader ________________________ Dr. K. S. Whetter, Supervisor _________________________ Dr. Herb Wyile, Acting Head This thesis is accepted in its present form by the Division of Research and Graduate Studies as satisfying the thesis requirements for the degree of Master of Arts (English). …………………………………………. ii I, Jesse M. Brillinger, grant permission to the University Librarian at Acadia University to reproduce, loan or distribute copies of my thesis in microform, paper or electronic formats on a non‐profit basis. I, however, retain the copyright in my thesis. ______________________________ Jesse M. Brillinger ______________________________ K.S. Whetter, Supervisor ______________________________ Sep. 19, 2010 iii Table of Contents Introduction: Malory, Chivalry and Lancelot ............................................................................... 1 Chapter 1: Medieval Chivalry in Literature and Life ............................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Tristan and Isolde Movie Plot
    Tristan and Isolde Movie Plot The film is set in Great Britain and Ireland, in the Dark Ages, after the fall of the Roman Empire in the 5th century. Lord Marke of Cornwall (Rufus Sewell) plans to unify the peoples of Britain - Celts, Angles, Saxons and Jutes - under himself as high king to resist Irish domination. Most lords agree to this, as Marke is highly regarded and respected as a fair and courageous leader. The Irish king Donnchadh (David O'Hara) discovers this and sends troops to attack a Jutish castle where a treaty between the British tribes is being discussed. The raid claims the lives of the castle's lord and his wife, and Marke saves their son Tristan at the cost of losing a hand. Feeling compassion for the young boy whose father loyally supported him, Marke welcomes Tristan (James Franco) into his home and regards him as a son. Tristan grows to be a fierce, courageous warrior whose loyalty to Marke is not that of a knight to his lord, but rather a son to his father. Tristan and other Cornish warriors launch an attack on an Irish slave caravan: in the battle, he finds himself fighting Morholt, Donnchadh's champion and leader of his army, to whom Princess Isolde (Sophia Myles) has been promised in marriage. Though he kills Morholt and Donnchadh's forces are overrun, Tristan is severely wounded in the fight and believed dead, though he is in fact only suffering the effects of Morholt's poisoned sword. Tristan's body is put out to sea on a funeral boat which eventually washes up along the shores of Ireland.
    [Show full text]
  • Cligès by Chrétien De Troyes
    Cligès by Chrétien de Troyes Translated by W. W. Comfort For your convenience, this text has been compiled into this PDF document by Camelot On-line. Please visit us on-line at: http://www.heroofcamelot.com/ Cligès Table of Contents Acknowledgments......................................................................................................................................3 PREPARER'S NOTE: ...............................................................................................................................4 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY: ...............................................................................................................4 The Translation..........................................................................................................................................5 Part I: Vv. 1 - Vv. 2278..........................................................................................................................5 Part II: Vv. 2279 - Vv. 4574...............................................................................................................31 Part III: Vv. 4575 - Vv. 6784...............................................................................................................58 Endnotes...................................................................................................................................................84 2 Chrétien de Troyes Acknowledgments Cligès was written by the French poet Chrétien de Troyes in the twelfth century. Chrétien is a well-known poet
    [Show full text]
  • Actions Héroïques
    Shadows over Camelot FAQ 1.0 Oct 12, 2005 The following FAQ lists some of the most frequently asked questions surrounding the Shadows over Camelot boardgame. This list will be revised and expanded by the Authors as required. Many of the points below are simply a repetition of some easily overlooked rules, while a few others offer clarifications or provide a definitive interpretation of rules. For your convenience, they have been regrouped and classified by general subject. I. The Heroic Actions A Knight may only do multiple actions during his turn if each of these actions is of a DIFFERENT nature. For memory, the 5 possible action types are: A. Moving to a new place B. Performing a Quest-specific action C. Playing a Special White card D. Healing yourself E. Accusing another Knight of being the Traitor. Example: It is Sir Tristan's turn, and he is on the Black Knight Quest. He plays the last Fight card required to end the Quest (action of type B). He thus automatically returns to Camelot at no cost. This move does not count as an action, since it was automatically triggered by the completion of the Quest. Once in Camelot, Tristan will neither be able to draw White cards nor fight the Siege Engines, if he chooses to perform a second Heroic Action. This is because this would be a second Quest-specific (Action of type B) action! On the other hand, he could immediately move to another new Quest (because he hasn't chosen a Move action (Action of type A.) yet.
    [Show full text]
  • A Critical History English L'iterature
    A Critical History of English L'iterature VOLUME I DAVID DAICHES A Critical History of English Literature IN TWO VOLUMES ~~ VOLUME I ~~, London SEeKER & WARBURG 1961 Prinud in Great BriJlJin by Morrison & Gibb Ltd., Lrmdall alld Edillburgh and published in Great Britain b_lI klartin Seeker & Warhurg Ltd. 7 John Street, London W.C.l Copycight © J 960 by THE RONALD PRESS COMPANY First pllblished September 1960 Reprin ted December 1960 Reprinted February 1961 To my former students • on both sides of the Atlantic pero pur va ed andanda asealta Preface TillS IS AN AGE of specialist .schoiars, and for one man to attempt a complete history of English literature is now both rash and unusual. I cannot claim to be a specialist in all the periods on which I have written, nor, in spite of my best attempts, have I been able to keep abreast of all new developments in English studies. But I have been reading English literature continuously and closely ever since I be­ gan my studies at Edinburgh University in 1930, and I have long felt the urge to describe the whole scene as I see it. This, therefore, is one man's history of English literature; it is intended less as a work of reference than as a. work of description, explanation, and critical interpretation. It is not meant to be looked up, but to be read. I have given myself generous space in dealing with major figures such as Shakespeare and Milton, without bothering whether, in strict terms of relative greatness, they deserve so much more than I have given to some other writers.
    [Show full text]
  • ACROSS LANDS FORLORN: the EPIC JOURNEY of the HERO, from HOMER to CHANDLER Volume One Sergio Sergi
    ACROSS LANDS FORLORN: THE EPIC JOURNEY OF THE HERO, FROM HOMER TO CHANDLER Volume One Sergio Sergi ACROSS LANDS FORLORN: THE EPIC JOURNEY OF THE HERO, FROM HOMER TO CHANDLER. SERGIO SERGI B.A. University of Adelaide M.A. University of Ottawa M.A University of Sydney A thesis submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Canberra. March 2006 i Certificate of authorship of thesis. Except where clearly acknowledged in footnotes, quotations and the bibliography, I certify that I am the sole author of the thesis submitted today entitled ‘Across lands forlorn: The epic journey of the hero from Homer to Chandler.’ I further certify that to the best of my knowledge the thesis contains no material previously published or written by another person except where due reference is made in the text of the thesis. The material in this thesis has not been the basis of an award of any other degree or diploma except where due reference is made in the text of the thesis. This thesis complies with University requirements for a thesis as set out in http://www.canberra.edu.au/secretariat/goldbook/forms/thesisrqmt. pdf …………………………. Signature of Candidate …………………………. Signature of Chair of the supervisory panel Date: ……………………………. Acknowledgements I acknowledge a number of people who have helped with the realization of this thesis which was begun at the University of New England. Professor Peter Toohey, before he left that University, listened to my ideas about the hero and encouraged me to develop them into this thesis. I am most grateful to him for the confidence he placed in my abilities to conduct a complex study.
    [Show full text]
  • Prisons and Punishments in Late Medieval London
    Prisons and Punishments in Late Medieval London Christine Winter Thesis submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the University of London Royal Holloway, University of London, 2012 2 Declaration I, Christine Winter, hereby declare that this thesis and the work presented in it is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, this is always clearly stated. Signed: Date: 3 Abstract In the history of crime and punishment the prisons of medieval London have generally been overlooked. This may have been because none of the prison records have survived for this period, yet there is enough information in civic and royal documents, and through archaeological evidence, to allow a reassessment of London’s prisons in the later middle ages. This thesis begins with an analysis of the purpose of imprisonment, which was not merely custodial and was undoubtedly punitive in the medieval period. Having established that incarceration was employed for a variety of purposes the physicality of prison buildings and the conditions in which prisoners were kept are considered. This research suggests that the periodic complaints that London’s medieval prisons, particularly Newgate, were ‘foul’ with ‘noxious air’ were the result of external, rather than internal, factors. Using both civic and royal sources the management of prisons and the abuses inflicted by some keepers have been analysed. This has revealed that there were very few differences in the way civic and royal prisons were administered; however, there were distinct advantages to being either the keeper or a prisoner of the Fleet prison. Because incarceration was not the only penalty available in the enforcement of law and order, this thesis also considers the offences that constituted a misdemeanour and the various punishments employed by the authorities.
    [Show full text]
  • Lancelot, the Knight of the Cart by Chrétien De Troyes
    Lancelot, The Knight of the Cart by Chrétien de Troyes Translated by W. W. Comfort For your convenience, this text has been compiled into this PDF document by Camelot On-line. Please visit us on-line at: http://www.heroofcamelot.com/ Lancelot, the Knight of the Cart Table of Contents Acknowledgments......................................................................................................................................3 PREPARER'S NOTE: ...............................................................................................................................4 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY: ...............................................................................................................4 The Translation..........................................................................................................................................5 Part I: Vv. 1 - Vv. 1840..........................................................................................................................5 Part II: Vv. 1841 - Vv. 3684................................................................................................................25 Part III: Vv. 3685 - Vv. 5594...............................................................................................................45 Part IV: Vv. 5595 - Vv. 7134...............................................................................................................67 Endnotes...................................................................................................................................................84
    [Show full text]
  • Writing and Literary Study Spring 2010 the Chivalrous Sir Gawain If
    Ahmed 1 Sarin Taslima Ahmed College Writing II: Writing and Literary Study Spring 2010 The Chivalrous Sir Gawain If a man does not open the door for a woman, she may think chivalry is dead or forget that it ever existed at all. Today's woman is not a damsel in distress, but rather stands on equal ground with her masculine counterpart. She has no need to acknowledge that there was ever a time when men lived and died for the sake of honor. However, around 1066 a.d. to 1485 a.d., that was exactly what European knights, and those around the world, did (Achlin). Of these brave soldiers, the most famous were the Knights of the Round Table, subjects of Camelot and King Arthur. Perhaps the most acclaimed knights are dubbed Sir Lancelot and Sir Gawain. Lancelot is still known as the greatest of all knights, the perfect knight, but based on Gawain's actions in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight by the Pearl Poet and those of Lancelot in The Once and Future King by T.H. White, I've come to the conclusion that Gawain is a greater model of chivalry than Lancelot. Following the code of chivalry, Gawain is faithful to God, his King, and he is respectful to women. Lancelot is very talented, but he does not feel the need to follow the laws of knighthood, and ends up disregarding King Arthur, Queen Guinevere and even God because of it. "Two virtues above all else were held to mark the good knight and bring him honor.
    [Show full text]
  • Malory's Launcelot and Guinevere Abed Togydirs Betsy Taylor
    Malory's Launcelot and Guinevere abed togydirs Betsy Taylor In Malory's account of the ambush of Launcelot in Guinevere's chamber he obliquely denies the authority of his sources: For, as the Freynshhe booke seyth, the quene and sir Launcelot were k>gydirs. And whether they were abed other at other maner of disportis, me lyste nat thereof make no mencion, for love that tyme was nat as love ys nowadayes.1 · Both his sources put Launcelot and Guinevere abed,2 but Malory says he prefers not to discuss the matter ('me lyste nat thereof make no mencion'); instead he links the lovers' activities here with the love he anatomizes, however cumbersomely, at the beginning of 'The Knight of the Cart' episode: But the olde love was nat so. For men and women coude love togydirs seven yerys, and no lycoures lustis was betwyxte them, and than was love trouthe and faythefulnes. And so in lyke wyse was used such love in kynge Arthurs dayes. (p. 1120, II. 2...{1) The benefit of Malory's reticence is twofold: he places (or attempts to place) the lovers beyond contemporary criticism, 'for love that tyme was nat as love ys nowadayes'; and he ensures that the image of Launcelot which dominates in this episode is that of the 'noble knyght' who 'toke hys swerde undir hys arme, and so he walked in hys mantell ... and put hymselff in grete jouparte' (p. 1165, 11. 5-7). In Malory's version of the episode we pass from this image to 'Madame,' seyde sir Launcelot, 'ys there here ony armour within you that myght cover my body wythall?' (p.
    [Show full text]
  • The Use of the Arthurian Legend by the Pre-Raphaelites
    University of Colorado, Boulder CU Scholar University Libraries Digitized Theses 189x-20xx University Libraries Summer 6-1-1905 The seU of the Arthurian Legend Matilda Krebs University of Colorado Boulder Follow this and additional works at: http://scholar.colorado.edu/print_theses Recommended Citation Krebs, Matilda, "The sU e of the Arthurian Legend" (1905). University Libraries Digitized Theses 189x-20xx. 2. http://scholar.colorado.edu/print_theses/2 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by University Libraries at CU Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in University Libraries Digitized Theses 189x-20xx by an authorized administrator of CU Scholar. For more information, please contact [email protected]. University Archives THE USE OF THE ARTHURIAN LEGEND BY THE PRE-RAPHAELITES A THESIS PRESENTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO BY MATILDA KREBS A Candidate for the Degree of Master of Arts BOULDER, COLORADO JUNE, 1905 PREFACE. The following pages are the result of many happy hours spent in the library, in an earnest endeavor to become better acquainted with Truth and Beauty. The author does not pose as a critic for she has little knowledge of literary art either theoretical or practical, and none of pic- torial. Should this self-imposed task prove to be of even the slightest benefit to other students, the pleasure to the writer would be multiplied many fold. M ATILDA KREBS. OUTLINE OF THESIS. I. The Arthuriad. 1. The origin of the Arthuriad. 2. Development of the Arthuriad. 3. Use of the Arthuriad by early writers. 4. Revival of interest in the Arthuriad through Rossetti's “ King Arthur's Tomb.” II.
    [Show full text]
  • Arthurian Legend
    Nugent: English 11 Fall What do you know about King Arthur, Camelot and the Knights of the Round Table? Do you know about any Knights? If so, who? If you know anything about King Arthur, why did you learn about King Arthur? If you don’t know anything, what can you guess King Arthur, Camelot, or Knights. A LEGEND is a story told about extraordinary deeds that has been told and retold for generations among a group of people. Legends are thought to have a historical basis, but may also contain elements of magic and myth. MYTH: a story that a particular culture believes to be true, using the supernatural to interpret natural events & to explain the nature of the universe and humanity. An ARCHETYPE is a reoccurring character type, setting, or action that is recognizable across literature and cultures that elicits a certain feeling or reaction from the reader. GOOD EVIL • The Hero • Doppelganger • The Mother The Sage • The Monster • The Scapegoat or sacrificial • The Trickster lamb • Outlaw/destroyer • The Star-crossed lovers • The Rebel • The Orphan • The Tyrant • The Fool • The Hag/Witch/Shaman • The Sadist A ROMANCE is an imaginative story concerned with noble heroes, chivalric codes of honor, passionate love, daring deeds, & supernatural events. Writers of romances tend to idealize their heroes as well as the eras in which the heroes live. Romances typically include these MOTIFS: adventure, quests, wicked adversaries, & magic. Motif: an idea, object, place, or statement that appears frequently throughout a piece of writing, which helps contribute to the work’s overall theme 1.
    [Show full text]