A Phenomenological Understanding of Acquaintance Rape and the Subsequent Trauma As Experienced by Young South African Women
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A PHENOMENOLOGICAL UNDERSTANDING OF ACQUAINTANCE RAPE AND THE SUBSEQUENT TRAUMA AS EXPERIENCED BY YOUNG SOUTH AFRICAN WOMEN By LAUREN MOSS A dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of D. LITT ET PHIL (PSYCHOLOGY) in the FACULTY OF HUMANITIES at the UNIVERSITY OF JOHANNESBURG PROMOTER: PROF. C.R. STONES 2011 DECLARATION I hereby declare that this thesis is my own, unaided work and that recognition has been given to the references used. It has not been submitted for any degree of examination at any other university. ______________________ __________________ Lauren Moss Date ABSTRACT A PHENOMENOLOGICAL UNDERSTANDING OF ACQUAINTANCE RAPE AND THE SUBSEQUENT TRAUMA AS EXPERIENCED BY YOUNG SOUTH AFRICAN WOMEN With the prevalence of rape in South Africa being the highest in the world, it is important for there to be a sound understanding of how the rape experience impacts the individual victim. A majority of rapes in the South African context are perpetrated by someone known to the victim, making acquaintance rape the most prevalent of all rape types in this country. The current understanding of the impact of all types of rape on a victim predominantly emerges from international studies which for the most part, considers the presence of traumatic distress in the victim. These studies are essential to the understanding of the impact of rape, although they are predominatly obtained through quantitative research. A qualitative understanding of the lived experience of the victim after her rape enhances and deepens the already substantive quantitative data regarding rape trauma. The practical implication is that clinicians can have a better understanding of the factors that are present in the rape experience and the complex interaction of those factors with the victim and the resulting rape trauma. As this study explores the lived experience of acquaintance rape of South African female rape victims, a qualitative methodology is utilised. Phenomenology lends itself best to the exploration of lived experience as it describes the meaning of the lived experience of individuals as that meaning pertains to a particular phenomenon. In this case the study phenomenologically explores the lived experience of being raped by an acquaintance as it applies to two young South African women who were raped by someone that they know. Through various phases of explication, the data, which is obtained through interviews with the participants, is transformed from a holistic description of the lived experience of the i participants into profiles, which are essential descriptions of the raw data, and then into categories of meaning clusters. These categories are then used to achieve an extended description of the phenomenon of acquaintance rape as experienced by the participants of the study. The phenomenon of being raped by an acquaintance as experienced by the participants of this study emerge as the following themes: the specific meaning of being raped by someone that you know to those victims, the life changes which occur after the rape, the reactions of others, culpability attributed to the rape incident, the mixed emotional reactions of the victims, dealing with possible HIV infection, disruptions in interpersonal trust, social support received or not received regarding the rape and the meaning that is made of the rape experience. Each of these aspects is relevant when considered in relation to the existing body of knowledge regarding rape experiences. Certain aspects are seen to be specific in the South African context, such as the increased possibility of HIV infection. Although the small sample size means that the conclusions of the study cannot be generalised to the greater population of South African acquaintance rape victims, the observations do give readers a deeper understanding of the concept that each rape experience is unique and yet at the same time can be understood when considered in relation to the existing body of knowledge. It is recommended that future South African studies explore the phenomenon of acquaintance rape by interviewing more participants, as well as interviewing them in their mother tongue, as this would allow for an enhancement of the depth of the descriptions obtained. It is also recommended that future research takes into account the prevalence of traumatic experiences in South Africa and explores the impact of previous traumas on the recovery experience of rape victims. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to take the opportunity to express my heartfelt gratitude to the following people for their support, without which this study would not have been accomplished: Firstly to my family - Adrian, you have always believed in me and your sacrifices and support were paramount in helping me through this long process. Thank you for always standing by me and supporting me, even when the road seemed long and full of obstacles. To Aaron, thank you for your smile and laughter, this always made the long hours spent working feel worthwhile. To Richard, you have endured so many hours of me having to focus on this study, and yet you are still so full of life and love. To my parents - I am so blessed to have four parents who have supported me unconditionally. I always knew I could turn to any of you and you would be there to encourage or empathise. Thank you Mom, Dad, Beverley and Peter. To Professor Chris Stones – I will be forever indebted to your willingness to see the opportunity for my work to become what it is today. Thank you for your kindness and your time. I truly feel that you have gone beyond what is expected in your support and encouragement. My final thank you is extended to the participants of this study. The courage to share an experience that is traumatic and very personal will not be forgotten. The understanding that I have gained from your experience will be of benefit to many others who have endured the pain of rape, them and I will be forever grateful. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter 1: Motivation, aims and terminology • Introduction 1 § Global view of rape 1 § Rape in South Africa 2 § The impact of rape on the individual 3 • Motivation for the present study 4 • Aims and objectives 6 • Understanding the terms used 7 § The Victim and the Survivor 7 § Theoretical understandings of the term rape, acquaintance rape and lived experience 9 • Overview of the present study 12 Chapter 2: Understanding the experience of rape trauma as presented in existing literature • Introduction 15 • The nature of Trauma – What it is and how it is experienced 16 § The experience of trauma in general 16 § Understanding Post Traumatic Stress Disorder 17 § The presence of PTSD in rape victims 18 § Rape Trauma Syndrome 20 § The trauma of acquaintance rape 22 • Factors influencing the extent of rape trauma 23 § Who the victim is 24 § Who the perpetrator is 25 § Pre-rape experiences 26 § The level of violence experienced during the assault 28 § Possible HIV infection 29 § Secondary victimisation 31 § Choosing to disclose the incident 32 § The reactions of others 34 iv § Victim credibility and precipitation 35 § Coping strategies employed after the rape 37 § Cognitive appraisals of culpability and self-blame 38 § Social support 40 • The experiences that could be seen to be part of rape trauma 41 § Fear 42 § Anxiety 43 § Anger 44 § Shame and guilt 45 § Depression 47 § Disruptions in self-esteem 49 § Disturbances in interpersonal interactions 50 • The process of recovering from rape trauma 51 § Understanding the process of recovery from three perspectives 52 • Harvey’s ecological model of recovery 52 • Herman’s understanding of recovering from trauma 54 • Smith and Kelly’s three staged process of recovery 56 § Factors affecting the duration of recovery processes 56 • Conclusion 57 Chapter 3: Methodology • Introduction 59 • Explication of selection of the methodology 59 § Qualitative approach 60 • Phenomenology - “to the things themselves” 61 § Defining phenomenology 61 § Phenomenological concepts 62 • Phenomenology as a research method 67 § The focus on lived experience of having been acquaintance raped 68 § The influence of the researcher 69 • Research procedure 70 § Selection of participants 70 v • Selection of participants in phenomenological research 71 • Criteria for selection of participants in the study 72 § Data collection 73 • Interview 73 § Analysis 74 • The scientific explication of the data 74 § An intuitive holistic grasp of the data 74 § Spontaneous emergence of natural meaning units 75 § Constituent profile descriptions 75 § Second order profiles 75 § Hierarchical categorisation 76 § Extended descriptions 76 • Ethical considerations 77 • Summary 78 Chapter 4: Results and discussion • Introduction 79 • Introducing the participants 79 § Participant One 79 § Participant Two 81 • The extended description of the data 83 • Themes emerging from the data analysis 86 § Being raped by someone you know 86 § Changes in life after the rape 88 § Reactions of others to the disclosure of the rape 90 § Considering culpability 93 § Mixed emotional reactions 95 § Dealing with possible HIV infection 100 § Interpersonal trust 102 § Social support 105 § Making meaning – perspectives on the meaning of being raped 107 • Conclusion 108 vi Chapter 5: Evaluation, recommendations and conclusion • Introduction 110 • Summary of findings 110 • Personal reflections 111 • Strengths and limitations of the study 114 • Recommendations for future research 116 • Finale 117 References 118 Appendices • Appendix A – Information letter