DOCSLIB.ORG

Ecosystem Services Assessment at Steart Peninsula, Somerset, UK

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Ecosystem Services Assessment at Steart Peninsula, Somerset, UK Ecosystem Services Assessment at Steart Peninsula, Somerset, UK Lia Vieira da Silva September 2012 A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science and the Diploma of Imperial College London DECLARATION OF OWN WORK I declare that this thesis: Ecosystem Services Assessment at Steart Peninsula, Somerset, UK is entirely my own work and that where material could be construed as the work of others, it is fully cited and referenced, and/or with appropriate acknowledgement given. Signature …………………………………………………….. Name of student: Lia Vieira da Silva Name of Supervisor: Robin Welcomme i TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................1 1.1 The Steart Coastal Management Project .....................................................................2 1.2 Study aims and objectives...........................................................................................3 2 BACKGROUND ...............................................................................................................3 2.1 Overview of the valuation of ecosystem services .......................................................3 2.2 Absolute versus marginal change in ecosystem services ............................................4 2.3 Valuing non market impacts in the environment ........................................................4 2.3.1 Total Economic Value .........................................................................................4 2.3.2 TEV and valuation techniques.............................................................................5 2.4 The use of value transfer .............................................................................................7 2.4.1 Flood and coastal erosion risk management context ...........................................8 2.4.2 Value transfer case studies...................................................................................9 2.5 The study site: Steart peninsula...................................................................................9 2.5.1 Context of Steart peninsula and Steart village.....................................................9 2.5.2 Road and footpaths ............................................................................................11 2.5.3 Power lines.........................................................................................................11 2.5.4 Land use and nature conservation importance...................................................11 2.5.5 Flood risk ...........................................................................................................11 2.5.6 Importance of intertidal habitat to the Severn Estuary ......................................13 2.5.7 Description of the project...................................................................................13 3 METHODS ......................................................................................................................15 3.1 Methodological framework.......................................................................................15 3.1.1 Environmental baseline......................................................................................16 3.1.2 Qualitative assessment .......................................................................................16 3.1.3 Quantification of impacts...................................................................................18 3.1.4 Economic valuation of changes in ecosystem services......................................18 3.2 Steart ecosystem services assessment in the context of previous research studies...19 ii 4 RESULTS ........................................................................................................................20 4.1 Environmental baseline.............................................................................................20 4.1.1 Current main ecosystem types ...........................................................................20 4.1.2 Current significant ecosystem services..............................................................21 4.2 Qualitative assessment ..............................................................................................22 4.3 Quantification and economic valuation of changes in ES ........................................27 4.3.1 Food ...................................................................................................................27 4.3.2 Climate regulation..............................................................................................30 4.3.3 Water regulation.................................................................................................32 4.3.4 Water purification and waste treatment .............................................................33 4.3.5 Recreation and tourism ......................................................................................34 4.3.6 Education ...........................................................................................................35 4.3.7 Soil Formation ...................................................................................................36 4.3.8 Primary Production ............................................................................................37 4.3.9 Nutrient cycling .................................................................................................37 4.3.10 Water cycling.....................................................................................................38 4.3.11 Photosynthesis....................................................................................................38 4.3.12 Provision of habitat............................................................................................38 4.4 Summary results........................................................................................................41 5 DISCUSSION..................................................................................................................42 5.1 Key outcomes............................................................................................................42 5.1.1 Efficacy of the ecosystems approach.................................................................42 5.1.2 Economic benefits of the Steart Costal Management scheme ...........................42 5.1.3 ‘Winners and losers’ and spatial scale of ES provision.....................................43 5.2 ES and economic benefits in the context of previous studies ...................................43 5.3 Research gaps and opportunities for further research at Steart.................................45 5.4 Learning beyond the scheme.....................................................................................46 5.4.1 Recommendations for improved sustainability and public value......................46 5.4.2 Stakeholder engagement ....................................................................................46 5.4.3 Economic values in policy-making....................................................................47 5.4.4 Funding opportunities and constraints...............................................................47 iii REFERENCES ........................................................................................................................48 APPENDICES .........................................................................................................................53 Appendix A - The MA classification of ecosystem services and examples ........................53 Appendix B – Valuing ecosystem services: TEEB and UK NEA conceptual frameworks 54 Appendix C – Economic techniques for valuation of ecosystem services ..........................55 Appendix D – Review of meta-analyses valuation studies for wetlands.............................58 Appendix E – Selecting relevant studies under the value transfer approach.......................60 Appendix F – Existing and future agriculture income potential at Steart............................67 Appendix G – Methodology used in Luisetti et al. (2011) to estimate fish production values ...................................................................................................................................70 Appendix H – Potential future number of visitors to Start beyond 2016 ............................71 Appendix I – Specification of wetlands environmental economic values derived from Brander et al. (2008) meta-analyses ....................................................................................72 iv LIST OF FIGURES Figure 2-1 Total Economic Value framework (taken from Defra, 2007)................................5 Figure 2-2 Techniques for monetary valuation (taken from Defra, 2007) ..............................6 Figure 2-3 Steart location plan...............................................................................................10 Figure 2-4 Designated nature conservation areas at Steart Peninsula ...................................12 Figure 2-5 Steart coastal management project.......................................................................14 Figure 2-6 Steart peninsula land use change (current and future scenarios) .........................14 Figure 3-1 Methodological framework of Steart ecosystem services assessment study .......15 LIST OF TABLES Table 2-1 Economic valuation evidence from wetlands studies..............................................8
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Social Care and Support for Adults the Somerset Directory 2016/17
    Social Care and Support for Adults The Somerset Directory 2016/17 Sunset at Berrow The comprehensive guide to choosing and paying for care and support Community support • care at home • care homes • specialist care For adults of working age, older people who have disabilities, mental health conditions, a sensory loss or general frailty. Publications Also available electronically at www.carechoices.co.uk and in spoken word through Browsealoud In association with www.carechoices.co.uk www.somerset.gov.uk Untitled-1 1 19/04/2016 10:55 Contents Welcome from Somerset County Council 4 How can Somerset County Council help you? 45-47 Regions covered by this Directory 4 Needs assessments 45 How can this Directory help? 5 Care eligibility 46 What is the difference between care and support? 5 Reablement 46 Where do I start? 5-8 Occupational therapy assessment 47 Help and advice 6 Paying for care 47-53 Independent advice and support 6 Financial eligibility 47 Wellbeing 7 Paying for home care 48 Writing your support plan 8 Paying for care homes 50 Help for carers 9-11 Third party payments 50 Compass Carers – the carers’ support service for What happens to your home? 51 Somerset 9 Running out of money 51 Carers’ assessments 9 NHS Continuing Healthcare 52 Carers’ information, support and counselling 10 Support for people who lack capacity 52 Health and wellbeing 11-13 Specialist care 53-55 Staying safe from falls 12 Dementia care 53 The Silver Line 13 Residential dementia care checklist 54 Mental health 55 Support in the community 13-23 Learning disability
    [Show full text]
  • Habitats Regulations Assessment for the Preferred Strategy
    THE WEST SOMERSET LOCAL PLAN 2012 TO 2032 DRAFT PREFERRED STRATEGY HABITAT REGULATIONS ASSESSMENT January 2012 This report was prepared by Somerset County Council on behalf of the Exmoor National Park Authority, as the 'competent authority' under the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2010. Copyright The maps in this report are reproduced from Ordnance Survey material with the permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of the Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office. © Crown copyright. Unauthorised reproduction infringes Crown copyright and may lead to prosecution or civil proceedings. (Somerset County Council)(100038382)(2011) 2 Contents 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................. 4 2. Screening Exercise ..................................................................................................... 6 3. Characteristics and Description of the Natura 2000 Sites ........................................... 8 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 8 Identification of Natura 2000 sites................................................................................ 8 Ecological Zones of Influence .................................................................................... 11 Description and Characterisation of Natura 2000 Sites ............................................. 11 4. Potential Impacts of the Plan on Ecology .................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Bridgwater Tidal Barrier Order A17/1G Environmental Statement
    Bridgwater Tidal Barrier Order Transport and Works Act 1992 Transport and Works (Applications and Objections Procedure) (England and Wales) Rules 2006 A17/1g Environmental Statement Volume 7 – Chapters 19 to 25 December 2019 19. In-combination effects 19.1 Introduction and scope 19.1.1 The Environment Agency, in partnership with Sedgemoor District Council, are delivering the Bridgwater Tidal Barrier (BTB) Scheme to reduce tidal flood risk to Bridgwater and surrounding areas. 19.1.2 Definitions of cumulative, intra-project and in-combination effects for the purpose of this Environmental Statement (ES) are provided in Chapter 7 (Environmental assessment methodology, Paragraph 7.5.2). Cumulative and intra-project effects are considered within the environmental topic assessment chapters (Chapters 8 to 18) of this ES, as required, and are therefore not discussed further here. 19.1.3 In-combination effects occur when the residual effects of a proposed development act in combination with the residual effects of other proposed projects to generate combined effects that are different or of a greater magnitude than the effects of the proposed projects alone. An assessment of in-combination effects considers other proposed and approved projects that have not yet been constructed and are not operational, i.e. developments that are in addition to the baseline. For proposed, but not yet approved projects, only those projects that have entered a formal process within the public domain are considered, e.g. projects undergoing public consultation, Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) screening or scoping, a consenting process, or proposals that are identified in approved policies, plans or programmes.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Countryside and Rights of Way (CROW) Act 2000 PROPOSAL for a LONG-TERM DIRECTION by the RELEVANT AUTHORITY SUMMARY for PUBLI
    Countryside and Rights of Way (CROW) Act 2000 PROPOSAL FOR A LONG-TERM DIRECTION BY THE RELEVANT AUTHORITY SUMMARY FOR PUBLIC CONSULTATION Prepared by Natural England 1. INFORMATION ABOUT THE PUBLIC CONSULTATION Case Reference Number: 2020049167 Name of site/ land parcel: Steart Peninsula (ST274459) Access Authority: Somerset County Council Relevant Authority: Natural England Local Access Forum: Somerset Local Access Forum Natural England has received a representation under section 26 of the Countryside and Rights of Way Act for a direction to exclude access to the public as indicated on the attached map in order to prevent disturbance to sensitive bird species. Natural England proposes to give a direction on the site that would exclude access for longer than six months continuously. The CROW Act requires us to consult publicly on all such proposals for long-term directions. 2. SUMMARY OF RELEVANT AUTHORITY PROPOSAL Background The 93 km (58 mile) stretch of the England Coast Path (ECP) from Brean Down to Minehead (BDM) was opened to the public on 15 March 2016. Coastal access rights came into force along this stretch of coast by order of the Secretary of State (SoS) at that time. The area covered in this consultation has had access excluded under a direction that was proposed and approved by the SoS, excluding access to saltmarsh and flats under s25A, since that time. The area of concern at Steart Peninsula is part of the Bridgwater Bay National Nature Reserve (NNR). It is heavily designated, being part of the following designated areas: • Bridgwater Bay Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) 1 • Severn Estuary Ramsar • Severn Estuary Special Protection Area (SPA) • Severn Estuary/ Môr Hafren Special Area of Conservation (SAC) Bridgwater Bay NNR contains one of the biggest intertidal mudflats in Britain as well as the largest area of salt marsh in Somerset.
    [Show full text]
  • Bridgwater Bay to Minehead Jenny Mccubbin Volunteer Parish Path Liaison Officer
    Beach and Coastal Walks – Stewart Collins Adult Participation Manager SASP East to West Burnham, Berrow and Brean. A vast 8 mile+ stretch of Sandy Beach with sand dunes one side and fabulous view of Wales the other, accessible from multiple points on the coast road. Can be busy particularly around the holiday camps in high summer , though so huge it is never crowded, but outside this period it is very peaceful. At low tide do not venture on to the mud as there is a danger of getting stuck (why on earth anyone would want to is beyond me!) and keep your eye on an incoming tide if you have parked on the beach, spring tides come right up to the dunes. A pleasant National Trust Café at the Brean Down end and many refreshment options near the holiday camps at the Berrow end SC Brean Down itself, at the Eastern end is a great climb for the energetic and offers great views over Weston Super Mare (on no account clamber down and try to walk to Weston, it looks close but the mud is deadly). The steps are very steep and difficult to successfully Social Distance but the road (only used by service vehicles) is a much easier and safer option. SC Steart Marshes TA5 2PU Steart Marshes is the first of the Wildfowl and Wetlands Trust’s working wetlands and is a fascinating walk at any time of the year. It provides flood defence for local homes and businesses, showcases productive farmland and is home to a thriving nature reserve.
    [Show full text]
  • 6.35 Acres at Steart
    B r i d g w a t e r , T A 5 2 P X A single parcel of pastureland measuring 6.35 acres (2.570 ha), with great amenity potential subject to gaining the necessary consents. The la nd benefits from direct road access from Stert Drove and is bounded by a mixture of stock proof fencing and dry stone walling. The land is located at Steart Marshes, which is a designated nature reserve with a large volume of native species. The land lies in close proximity to the beach providing excellent hacking out. Also in a convenient location to the larger villages of Cannington and Combwich. 3.8 miles – C ombwich 5.2 miles – Cannington 9.5 miles – Bridgwater * Distances are approximate & sourced from Google Maps Sedgemoor District Council. | Tenure: Free hold . {. TO ARRANGE A VIEWING OR FOR FURTHER INFORMATION ON THIS PROPERTY PLEASE CONTACT OUR SALES TEAM 01278 458 241 properties @tamlyns.co.uk The land has previously been registered with the Rural Payments The property is sold subject to any Rights of Way, Wayleaves, Agency . Entitlements are available by separa te negotiations . Rights or Easements which exist at the time of sale whether they Potential purchasers are advised to make their own enquires. are mentioned in these particulars or not. The land is identified as being within a High Priority area for We understand that any sporting rights and mineral rights are Countryside Stewardship, setting the land in a good position for held in hand and will be transferred with the sale of the property.
    [Show full text]
  • 142: Somerset Levels and Moors Area Profile: Supporting Documents
    National Character 142: Somerset Levels and Moors Area profile: Supporting documents www.naturalengland.org.uk 1 National Character 142: Somerset Levels and Moors Area profile: Supporting documents Introduction National Character Areas map As part of Natural England’s responsibilities as set out in the Natural Environment White Paper1, Biodiversity 20202 and the European Landscape Convention3, we are revising profiles for England’s 159 National Character Areas (NCAs). These are areas that share similar landscape characteristics, and which follow natural lines in the landscape rather than administrative boundaries, making them a good decision-making framework for the natural environment. NCA profiles are guidance documents which can help communities to inform theirdecision-making about the places that they live in and care for. The informationthey contain will support the planning of conservation initiatives at a landscape scale, inform the delivery of Nature Improvement Areas and encourage broader partnership working through Local Nature Partnerships. The profiles will also help to inform choices about how land is managed and can change. Each profile includes a description of the natural and cultural features that shape our landscapes, how the landscape has changed over time, the current key drivers for ongoing change, and a broad analysis of each area’s characteristics and ecosystem services. Statements of Environmental Opportunity (SEOs) are suggested, which draw on this integrated information. The SEOs offer guidance on the critical issues, which could help to achieve sustainable growth and a more secure environmental future. 1 The Natural Choice: Securing the Value of Nature, Defra NCA profiles are working documents which draw on current evidence and (2011; URL: www.official-documents.gov.uk/document/cm80/8082/8082.pdf) 2 knowledge.
    [Show full text]
  • Otter-Tales-March-2019-Final.Pdf
    www.combwich.org.uk COMBWICH, OTTERHAMPTON AND March 2019 STEART NEWSLETTER Issue 23 Published with the generous support of Otterhampton Parish Council Welcome to Combwich Inside this issue Page 2 Parish Council Offcuts Page 3 Traffic monitoring C182 A big thank you Page 4 OPRA Report Page 5 What has the parish coun- cil done for us? Page 6 Profile- Dick & Rosie Best Page 7 Otterhampton School Pages 8 and 9 Combwich Traffic prob- lems Sure signs that spring is in the air! OPC Notable minutes Page 10 Village Hall and Social Club Page 11 Walking for health Page 12 & 13 WWT Steart Marshes Page 14 Neighbourhood Police team Page 15 Otter Wheels, Short Mat Bowls & Pilates Page 16 Mobile Library & Diary of events Early morning on the river Combwich Boat Club Gig section rowers Otterhampton Offcuts Snippets from the February & March 2019 Parish Council Meetings Temporary Chair and Vice Chair Contact details for the parish council Following the resignation of Dave Cather from the parish council, our existing Vice-Chair Julie Evans, will PARISH COUNCILLORS temporarily take on the role with Dick Best as Julie Evans (Acting Chair) 01278 652735 temporary Vice-Chair until the May election. We thank Dick Best 01278 651063 Dave for his service as both councillor and Chair over Barry Leathwood 01278 652399 the past couple of years. He was a very effective Chair Bob Birkenhead 01278 653127 and we wish him our very best wishes for the future. Rachel Perrett 01278 652958 Forthcoming District and Parish Council Elections Murray Lister 07802 823497 These will take place on 2 May 2019.
    [Show full text]
  • River Parrett Trail
    t River ParrettThe Trail River Route Parrett Text Trail Section Area 1 Chedington to Merriott 2 Merriott to Ham Hill 3 Ham Hill to Langport 4 Merriott to Gawbridge Mill via South Petherton 5 Langport to Bridgwater Docks 6 Bridgwater Docks to Stert Point The River Parrett Trail Following a River from Source to Mouth Maps: You are advised to carry with you OS Explorer Map 116 Lyme Regis & Bridport 48 miles from Chedington, Dorset to the Bristol Channel 129 Yeovil & Sherborne SECTION 1: CHEDINGTON TO MERRIOTT Waymarking: The route is waymarked. Length of walk: 6.75 miles General description: Waterproof boots are advisable as much of this first section is through fields close to the 1. ST 491 062 WINYARD’S GAP PUB, CHEDINGTON River; in particular the fields between the start and South (Interpretation boards in Pub garden with superb views) Perrott are wet as there are many springs in this area. The With your back to pub turn L down road for 400 yds route is primarily level. There may be livestock in the towards Chedington to reach signed footpath on R. Go fields. through gate, head diagonally L to marker post and then This section crosses 4 A roads where extreme care should bear R towards gate. Go straight across next 2 fields. In be taken. next field bear R of 3 large trees and aim for gate in This route passes through beautiful hamstone villages. bottom R hand corner. Start point & Parking: – Winyards Gap Pub. (Parking in 2. ST 483 063 pub car park if permission asked from Landlord).
    [Show full text]
  • Steart Marshes L
    National Nature Reserve Steart Village Bridgwater Bay Estuarine mudflats Steart Gate Enjoy this amazing place but please respect other car park Parrett Trail visitors and the guidance given on the signs and marker posts. Horseriders, use the designated bridleways and keep Estuarine mudflats Welcome to to the verge of the surfaced paths. Please keep your dog under close control or on a lead. Steart Marshes Some paths are permissive and may be closed from time to time to protect wildlife. Steart Marshes Breach In the event of a major problem please ring Coastal marsh map information 07717 505966 or, in an emergency, 999 l Working in partnership with Grazing marsh Pylons WWT Main Polden hide car park Steart Drove Estuarine mudflats Wetland Saltmarsh walkway Mendip hide Stockland Marsh Public footpath and Grazing marsh permissive cycle path River Parrett Arable & wild Stockland Bristol bird mix Public bridleway Flower rich grassland Otterhampton Marshes Accessible path Coastal marsh for pedestrians and wheelchairs Parrett Trail Bird hide Permissive footpath Otterhampton View point and/or camera point Arable & wild bird mix Please wash your hands as all animals can 1 kilometre Parrett Trail Working in partnership with carry diseases i Combwich The Steart landscape i Useful information Help us protect the wildlife here What’s happening here? i How big? The tidal area is almost 3km in length and over We need you! 1km wide – from end to end, it takes about an hour to walk Our coastline is constantly changing. We’re To manage the site and welcome visitors, we need volunteers working here to help form special new habitats i Admission is FREE with a range of skills.
    [Show full text]
  • Stockland Bristol Parish Meeting Comments
    Mr John Sivyer Miss Caroline Leddy STOCKLAND BRISTOL Chairman Secretary PARISH MEETING Wayland Farm Washers Farm Stockland Bristol Stockland Bristol Near Bridgwater Near Bridgwater TA5 2PY TA5 2PY Telephone: 01278 653805 Email: [email protected] Web Page: http://www.sedgemoor.gov.uk/index.aspx?articleid=478 Service Manager – Policy Strategy and Development Sedgemoor District Council Bridgwater House King Sqyaure Bridgwater TA6 3AR 18 December 2015 Dear Sir, STAGE 1 LOCAL PLAN CONSULTATION – STOCKLAND BRISTOL PARISH MEETING COMMENTS Introduction On behalf of the Stockland Bristol Parish Meeting, I wish to submit the following comments, based upon my close inspection of the Local Plan Consultation Document as supplied to this Meeting by SDC, and many informal discussions held between myself and those parishioners who have, upon public invite expressed their views and opinions to me. Where I have gained a general consensus of opinion, I report that, and as where this was not forthcoming, I have expressed any divergence of or minority opinion. Whilst these are challenging times, this Parish also regards them as exciting times that offer opportunities for all and this Parish Meeting would like to be involved in whatever small ways possible, in contributing to the shaping of local plans for the future. Question 3 The consensus of opinion regarding the Local Plan Objectives for this question, was that this Parish is in broad agreement with all the Objectives and in particular with regard to: a. Flood Risk (“Approximately half of the Parish is located within Flood Zone 3 and is therefore at high risk of flooding”.
    [Show full text]
  • 23Offshore and Inter-Tidal Archaeology
    23 Offshore and Inter-Tidal Archaeology 23 OFFSHORE AND INTER-TIDAL ARCHAEOLOGY 23.1 Scope of the Assessment 23.1.1 This section of the Environmental Appraisal provides an assessment of the potential impacts to submerged and inter-tidal archaeology during the construction and operational phases of the Hinkley C development. 23.1.2 Figure 23.1 shows the location of the development area and the wider study area considered in this report. 23.1.3 The geographical extent of the development area includes: the location of intake/outfall tunnel heads; and the proposed jetty site located at the western edge of Hinkley Point. 23.1.4 Both areas are contained within the box ‘Development Area’ in Figure 23.1. 23.1.5 A detailed description of the proposed development is provided in Volume 2 Chapter 2. 23.2 Objectives of the Assessment 23.2.1 The objectives of the assessment are: to identify all known heritage assets within the study area boundary below the Mean High Water Mark (MHWM); to assess the potential for submerged and buried archaeological remains and their likely level of preservation; to assess the likely extent of previous impacts on the heritage resource; to assess the potential impact of the proposed development on the heritage resource; and to recommend mitigation strategies aimed at reducing the impacts of the proposed development, if necessary. 23.3 Legislation, Policy and Guidance 23.3.1 The proposal site is located within West Somerset District. 23.3.2 Aspects of International, European and UK legislation, planning policy and guidance of relevance to the site are presented below.
    [Show full text]