Proceedings of the 15Th Meeting of Karnataka State Coastal Zone

Proceedings of the 15 th meeting of Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority (KSCZMA) held on 08.07.2016 at 11.00 A.M. at Room No. 253, 2 nd Floor, 2 nd Gate, M. S. Building, Bengaluru under the chairmanship of Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Forest, Ecology & Environment Department.

Members Present: As per the list enclosed

The Chairman welcomed the members present. All the files were placed before the Authority for perusal and the subjects were deliberated as per the Agenda.

15.1 Confirmation of the proceedings of the previous KSCZMA meeting held on 05.04.2016.

The proceedings of the previous KSCZMA meeting held on 05.04.2016 were read out. The proceedings were confirmed as there were no comments or amendments received from the members.

15.2 Action Taken Report on the proceedings of the previous KSCZMA meeting held on 05.04.2016.

Action Taken Report at Annexure – I was perused and the Authority noted the action taken.

15.3 Preparation of State Coastal Zone Management Plan :

Government of India vide Gazette Notification has extended the validity of CZMP approved in 1996 upto 31 st January, 2017.

The MoEF & CC have entrusted preparation of HTL and LTL lines to National Centre for Sustainable Coastal Management, Chennai which is an autonomous institute under MoEF, GoI. The CZMP maps are to be got sanctioned from CCZMA as early as possible as most of the development activities are linked to obtain CRZ Clearance from Karnataka Coastal Zone Management Authority based on the sanctioned CZMP maps.

NCSCM has already completed the process of demarcation of draft HTL and it has been submitted to MoEF & CC.

In connection with the demarcation of Ecologically Sensitive Areas by NCSCM, a team of officers lead by Special Director, Forest, Environment and

Ecology Department visited NCSCM on 18.05.2016 for the validation of Ecologically Sensitive Areas of coastal districts of Karnataka. During the visit, the maps of the following Ecologically Sensitive Areas were verified online.

1. Areas/structures of Archeological importance 2. Mangroves 3. Mud Flats 4. Salt Marshes 5. Sand Dunes 6. Reserve Forests

The following were the observations:

1. Identification of ESA’s have been completed for the entire stretch of Coastal Karnataka based on satellite imageries, Aerial photographs, topo sheets and information from Archeological Department and IISc, Bangalore. 2. The Mangrove areas identified are by and large acceptable. 3. In case of identification of Mud Flats, Salt Marshes and Sand Dunes revisiting is required and the centre was requested to revisit. 4. Under Corals and Coral Reefs, St. Marry’s Island in Udupi District and Netrani Island in Uttara Kannada District can be considered after verification in the field. 5. Under Archeological structures, Kaup Light House in Udupi Taluk may be considered after clarification from the Archeological Department. 6. In case of Reserve Forests of Uttara Kannada District, the latest documents of the Forest Department are to be verified before finalizing.

NCSCM has been requested to provide draft maps of ESA’s in PDF form for taking up field verification by all the Regional Directors. The draft maps are yet to be received from NCSCM.

The Regional Directors are instructed to take up the field verification immediately and to submit the details at the earliest.

The Authority in its 14 th meeting held on 05.04.2016 had decided to get quotation from National Centre for Earth Science Studies (NCESS), Thiruvananthapuram and NCSCM, Chennai regarding quote and time line for the preparation of CZMP and to finalize the institute for CZMP preparation. Accordingly, letters were addressed to NCESS, Thiruvananthapuram and NCSCM, Chennai to furnish their quotation for preparation of CZMP of Coastal

Page 2 of 75

Districts of Karnataka. Both institutes have furnished their quotations. Details are as below:

A. NCSCM, Chennai:

(i) Cost of preparation Cost of preparation of CZMP maps for Karnataka Rs. 1,93,43,058.00 Additional cost for additional products. (ii) Deliverables: • CZMP maps on 1:25000 scale demarcating HTL/LTL/CRZ Categories. • Regulation lines 200/500/100 etc and buffers as applicable and recommendations/ suggestions on CRZ categories viz., CRZ-I, CRZ- II, CRZ-III etc. • Land use/land cover and ESAs map at 1:25000 scale. • Submission of final CZMP report along with 3 hard copies of each map and pdf format. Duration is 3 months from the date of receipt of advance payment and date of receipt of advance payment will be the start date. (iii) Facilities and Digitalized Cadastral maps preferably in Arc GIS materials to be format with Sy.Nos, roads, existing buildings and furnished by infrastructure (1:4000/1:5000 scale) of the entire KSCZMA are study area covering a distance landward of 750m from the sea coast and 200 m for creek sides as hard copy with grid value as well as soft copy. If digitalized maps in Arc GIS format are not available, hard copy of original Cadastral mps to be produced.

B. NCESS, Trivandrum :

(i) Cost of preparation Rs. 50,000 per running km of HTL + Service Tax 15 for preparation of CZMP in 1:25000 scale, based on survey of India, Toposheets etc.

The NCSCM, Chennai has informed that the total length of HTL pertaining to coastal districts of Karnataka including all tidal influenced water bodies is about 2690 km. Considering this length of

Page 3 of 75

HTL the cost quoted by NCESS, Trivandrum will be 2690 km x Rs. 50,000 = Rs. 13.45 Crores. (ii) Deliverables • CRZ mapping as per the guidelines in the Annexure-I of CRZ Notification, 2011 and other MoEF and CC guidelines issued from time to time. • Demarcation of HTL, LTL, ESAs, CRZ Categories and regulation zones including NDZ along the coastal stretches and along the tidal influenced in land water bodies will be based on detailed physical verification in the field. (iii) Facilities / The cadastral maps with survey plot information. Materials to be provided:

The above information is placed before the Authority for deliberation and decision regarding selection of an Institute for entrusting the preparation of CZMP of Karnataka and for obtaining concurrence of Finance Department.

Further, in this regard, Secretary, Ecology and Environment and Special Director (Technical Cell) attended a meeting at MoEF on 24.05.2016 to review status of CZMP preparation by Secretary, MoEF&CC. In that meeting, the Secretary, MoEF&CC directed all the States to complete CZMP preparation including public consultation within 3 months from the date of receipt of HTL soft copy from MoEF. The soft copy is yet to be received from MoEF. Meanwhile, we should finalize the Agency to prepare CZMP so that once we get HTL we can request the agency to complete CZMP at an early date.

In the same meeting, the MoEF made it clear that they are going to launch online portal for request for CRZ Clearance on the lines of FC&EC proposal from July first week. This is for the information of Authority.

The Authority after discussion and deliberation decided to obtain the clarification from NCSCM, Chennai regarding, whether the cost quoted by them includes the cost of preparation of CZMP maps in 1:4000 scale demarcating HTL/LTL/CRZ areas also.

Further, the Authority also decided to obtain the details of HTL length of coastal Karnataka and the total cost for preparation of CZMP maps of Karnataka instead of rate for per Km. of HTL length from NCESS Trivandrum so as to enable

Page 4 of 75

proper comparison of quotes submitted by the institutes. It was also decided to ascertain from NCESS Trivandrum whether their quote includes the preparation of CZMP on 1:4000 scale also.

The Authority decided that the institute for preparation of CZMP maps of Karnataka may be selected as per Rules after obtaining the above details and clarification from both the institutes.

15.4.1 Integrated Coastal Zone Management Plan (ICZMP) Phase II :

1. The Ministry of Environment and Forests has initiated the World Bank assisted Integrated Coastal Zone Management Project (ICZMP) with a budget outlay of Rs. 1155.63 crores (US$262 million). 2. For implementation of the above project the Society of Integrated Coastal Management (SICOM) has been established as a registered body at MoEF & CC. 3. SICOM is implementing the following four components, namely, (i)National Coastal Management Programme (ii)ICZM West Bengal (iii)ICZM Orissa (iv)ICZM Gujarat. 4. Sharing pattern: 90:10. Only 10% sharing by State Govts. 5. Now GoI took decision to extend the project to all coastal states with increased budget outlay.

Broad objective of the ICZMP as follows :

1. The overall objective of the project is to support the Government of India and selected states in developing and implementing an improved strategic management approach for India’s coastal zone to preserve the long-term productivity of this highly populated region for continued sustainable development and economic growth. 2. This objective will be achieved through specific project components both at national and state level. 3. Approaches to achieve specific objectives are different for state to state.

The salient features of the project are as under :

1. The funding pattern is 90 : 10 ratio, wherein state has to contribute only 10% of the project cost 2. The project is integrated in nature, aiming at building sustainable management of coastal resources to provide livelihood for the coastal population. The activities included; protection, conservation and

Page 5 of 75

development of natural resources like estuaries, back waters, mudflats, mangroves areas, eco sensitive coastal zones, breeding and spawning grounds of economically important marine resources. 3. Apart from the above, the project also aims at building up of infrastructure for the coastal population both in urban and rural areas, which includes roads for fishermen colonies, erosion prevention structures, salt water intrusion prevention structures and providing basic amenities to local population. 4. The size of the project may vary from Rs. 400 crs to 1000 crs depending on the identification of components. 5. The MoEF has identified the National Centre for Sustainable Coastal Zone Management, Chennai, an autonomous organization of MoEF, to prepare DPR for all coastal states. 6. Various components included in the ongoing projects in West Bengal, Gujarat and Odissa are as follows:

a. Conservation(Mangrove afforestation, coral reef generation, turtle nesting sites, conservation of other ecological sensitive areas) b. Livelihood c. Infrastructure d. Tourism e. Pollution f. Coastal erosion g. Disaster h. Climate change related i. Capacity building and awareness j. Fisheries and allied activities k. Scientific research l. Coastal Zone Management Plans/ICZMP m. Non-Conventional energy n. Portable water o. Carrying capacity study p. Area coverage

The following are the decisions taken in the meeting held on 17.08.2015 at Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change, New Delhi :

1. State/ UT Government shall identify and establish a nodal agency and nominate a nodal Officer, this nodal agency shall be declared as SPMU and the same shall be informed to SICOM by 1 st September, 2015. Page 6 of 75

2. The Senior Officers from the existing SPMUs namely, Gujarat, Odissa and West Bengal shall assist the neighboring States/ UTs in setting up of SPMUs with requisite personnel’s including experts in the area of finance, procurement and other specialized areas. 3. State/UT Government shall identify two to three priority sites in their respective State/UT where ICZM project shall be taken up. However, the UTs which have very small coastal stretch could include the entire stretch of the UT or the entire geographical area in case of Islands as per the Island Protection Zone (IPZ) Notification, 2011. The above details will be informed to SICOM within two weeks i.e., by 1 st September, 2015. State/UT Governments shall make a commitment for 10% financial contribution to the total cost estimate that is being projected by the State/UT Governments. 4. The budget for the preparation of the DPRs and establishment of SPMU shall be borne by SICOM as per the budget approved by the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) on 21 st July, 2015. 5. With regard to upper budget limit for each State/UT, the State/UT Administration shall make a reasonable estimate keeping in view the financial structure or the limits being followed in the ongoing ICZM Project. 6. NCSCM shall assist the State/UT Governments to prepare the DPRs based on the template accepted by the State/UT Government 7. The draft DPRs shall be prepared by the State/UT Administration in consultation with NCSCM and the same shall be submitted by end November, 2015. 8. A Priority activity relating to remediation of critically polluted coastal areas shall be included as a National Component. 9. The preparation of DPRs and establishment of the SPMUs in the remaining ten coastal States/UTs shall be within the budget earmarked in the CCEA which is approximately Rs. 5 crore per State/UT.

As per the decision taken in the meeting, the EMPRI has been designated as nodal agency to coordinate with the NCSCM, Chennai for preparation of DPR. Accordingly, EMPRI has written to all line departments to furnish the baseline data required for DPR as well as the activities to be proposed in the ICZMP. Further, the EMPRI conducted a workshop involving all line department technical officers to create awareness on collection of data for DPR with the help of Director, NCSCM, Chennai on 22.02.2016 at Bengaluru. Very detailed discussion were taken place in the said workshop.

Page 7 of 75

Further to have in depth knowledge on the DPR preparation, on 08.03.2016, a team of officers from Department of Forest, Ecology & Environment and EMPRI lead by the Secretary to Government, Ecology & Environment Department visited NCSCM, Chennai to have detailed discussion regarding preparation of DPR. During the discussion, the NCSCM officials shared the information regarding preparation of Base document preparatory to DPR which has to be sent to MoEF. Apart from the above, the various criteria to be adopted for selection of sites were also discussed. During the discussion, the officials of NCSCM have emphasized that once, the area are selected for the project, the same has to be discussed and approved in the State Coastal Zone Management Authority. In this direction, a meeting was organized under the chairmanship of the Secretary to Government, Ecology and Environment Department to discuss about selection of area for ICZMP. The Regional Directors of all 3 Coastal districts and Director, EMPRI have been involved in identification of sites for the project based on the critical nature of the coastal zone and the biodiversity richness. Accordingly the following Talukas have been proposed :

District Taluka Criteria for selection

Uttara Karwar The Karwar town is on the bank of Kali estuary and Kannada highly sensitive and as per the CRZ Notification Karwar is identified as Critically Vulnerable Coastal Area. Kumta Because of Aghanashini estuary complexes, entire Kumta Taluk is selected. Aghanashini estuary complex is very critical from the point of its marine biodiversity and its inter dependency for the livelihood of local inhabitants.

Udupi Udupi The following are the sites in Udupi district.

St. Mary’s Island: It is very unique and fragile geological formation within the marine ecosystem. It is rich in coral reef. From the point of zonation potential as also it is very important.

Malpe: Major fishing harbor with high dependency of fisherman community for coastal resources. Apart from the above, there is Udyavara estuary which is very critical from conservation point of view.

Page 8 of 75

Kundapura As per CRZ Notification, this town is classified as Critically Vulnerable Coastal Area. Apart from Critically Vulnerable Coastal Area, there are good number of variety of Mangroves on the banks of river Sita, Kollur, Chakra and Haladi which require conservation efforts. Mangalore Mangalore Mangalore is considered as Economic Growth Centre of coastal Karnataka. As large number of industries are located on the coast and Gurupura estuary, the site is taken as important for consideration in ICZMP. Apart from the above, Ullal area is known for sea erosion.

The preparation of Base Documents for the above three Taluks has been entrusted to EMPRI and they are in the process of preparation after obtaining the base line data from the concerned departments. Accordingly, the EMPRI has already sent a soft copy to NCSCM, Chennai for their documents.

The Authority after discussion and deliberation directed the EMPRI to submit the Base document of ICZMP phase II project prepared by them so as to enable the department to send the same to MoEF & CC at least by 15.07.2016 as it has already been delayed considerably.

15.5 New proposals:

15.5.1. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Prema V. Shetty W/o Veerappa T. Shetty for construction of Compound wall at Sy. No. 61/7 of Hejamadi Village- regarding (FEE 126 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Prema V. Shetty W/o Veerappa T. Shetty has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of Compound wall at Sy. No. 61/7 of Hejamadi Village, Udupi Taluk in an area of 1.32 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 20 mts from HTL of Sea. The distance from the HTL of sea is 20 mts. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 06’ 16.2” and E 74 0 46’ 07.5”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of Compound wall submitted by Smt. Prema V. Shetty W/o Veerappa T. Shetty along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, compound wall plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized

Page 9 of 75

CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended for rejection of the proposal as it is a new construction, which is not a permissible activity.

However, during the discussion Regional Director (Environment) Mangaluru, Brought to the notice of the Authority that there is a court order stating that compound wall is not a building and hence does not require a license or pervious permission in writing. Further a copy of Hon’ble High Court order was obtained from Regional Director (Environment) Mangaluru and the same was perused . This case was about constructing a compound wall around a vacant land on Magadi Road, Bengaluru between Sri. Bhawarilal Corporation of the city of Bengaluru, having a W.P. No. 1922 of 1989. The Judgment date was 15.06.1989.

The Authority after discussion and deliberation decided to refer back the proposal to concerned Regional Director, in view of the above Hon’ble High Court order for re-consideration at DCZMC regarding appropriate action and to report the action taken to the Authority in this regard.

15.5.2. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Madhavi N. Gunasheela D/o Mavalli Gunasheela for construction of Compound wall at Sy. No. 305/1P5 of Kodavoor Village- regarding (FEE 127 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Madhavi N. Gunasheela D/o Mavalli Gunasheela has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of Compound wall at Sy. No. 305/1P5 of Kodavoor Village, Udupi Taluk. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 50 mts from HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 27’ 02.3” and E 74 0 41’ 52.4”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of Compound wall submitted by Smt. Madhavi N. Gunasheela D/o Mavalli Gunasheela along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey

Page 10 of 75

Map of the Site, compound wall plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended for rejection of the proposal as it is a new construction, which is not a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and.deliberation decided to refer back the proposal to concerned Regional Director, in view of the above Hon’ble High Court order for re-consideration at DCZMC regarding appropriate action and to report the action taken to the Authority in this regard.

15.5.3. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Vishwanatha G. S/o Late Bijju for reconstruction of Bhajan Mandir at Sy. No. 216/20 of Paduthonse Village- regarding (FEE 128 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Vishwanatha G. S/o Late Bijju has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of Bhajan Mandir at Sy. No. 216/20 of Paduthonse Village, Udupi Taluk. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea(as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 80 mts from HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 24’ 15.0” and E 74 0 41’ 53.0”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of Bhajan Mandir No. 172 in an area of 0.08 acre submitted by Sri. Page 11 of 75

Vishwanatha G. S/o Late Bijju along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the year 1988-89, Certificate from Kemmannu Gram Panchayath for change of door No. dated. 18.02.2016, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 700 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Vishwanatha G. S/o Late Bijju for reconstruction of Bhajan Mandir at Sy. No. 216/20 of Paduthonse Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.4. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Chandrahasa Kotian S/0. Ramappa Karkera for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 75/CIP-1-P1 of Hejamadi Village- regarding (FEE 129 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Chandrahasa Kotian S/o. Ramappa Karkera has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 75/CIP-1-P1 of Hejamadi Village, Udupi Taluk. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 170 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 05’ 41.1” and E 74 0 46’ 20.6”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house no. 7-72A in an area of 0.09 acre submitted by Sri. Chandrahasa Kotian S/0. Ramappa Karkera along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the year 1988-89, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 814 Sq.ft. The DCZMC Page 12 of 75

recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

As per the provisions under the para 8(i) III CRZ III A of the CRZ Notification 2011 no construction shall be permitted within NDZ except for repairs or reconstruction of existing authorized structure not exceeding existing FSI, existing, plinth area and existing density and for permissible activities under the notification including facilities essential for the said activities. Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Chandrahasa Kotian S/o. Ramappa Karkera for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 75/CIP-1-P1 of Hejamadi Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.5. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Akkani Marakalthi W/o Theja Marakala for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 6/10P3 of Handadi Village- regarding (FEE 130 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Akkani Marakalthi W/o Theja Marakala has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 6/10P3 of Handadi Village, Udupi Taluk. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river(as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 35 mts from the HTL of river. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 27’ 58.0” and E 74 0 44’ 19.2”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house in an area of 0.10 acre out of 0.20 acre submitted by Smt. Akkani Marakalthi W/o Theja Marakala along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax paid receipt dated 12.01.1972, Certificate from Handadi Grama Panchayath for change of door No. dated 17.12.2015, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 972 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

As per the provisions under the para 8(i) III CRZ III A of CRZ Notification 2011 no construction shall be permitted within NDZ except for repairs or Page 13 of 75

reconstruction of existing authorized structure not exceeding existing FSI, existing, plinth area and existing density and for permissible activities under the notification including facilities essential for the said activities. Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Akkani Marakalthi W/o Theja Marakala for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 6/10P3 of Handadi Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.6. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Rukka Poojary and others S/o Late. Venku Hengsu for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 66/1A2B of Hejamadi Village- regarding (FEE 131 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Rukka Poojary and others S/o Late. Venku Hengsu has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 66/1A2B of Hejamadi Village, Udupi Taluk. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 100 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 06’ 11.4” and E 74 0 46’ 11.3”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house H.No. 8-100A in an area of 0.09 acre submitted by Sri. Rukka Poojary and others S/o Late. Venku Hengsu along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the period 1988-89, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 660 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

Page 14 of 75

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Rukka Poojary and others S/o Late. Venku Hengsu for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 66/1A2B of Hejamadi Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.7. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Gulabi Poojarthy D/o Late Koosu Hengsu Alias Koosu S. Poojarthy for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 59/3P-1-P1 of Hejamadi Village- regarding (FEE 132 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Gulabi Poojarthy D/o Late Koosu Hengsu Alias Koosu S. Poojarthy has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 59/3P-1-P1 (H.No. 9-24) of Hejamadi Village, Udupi Taluk. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 125 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 06’ 29.6” and E 74 0 46’ 07.8”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house in an area of 0.11 acre submitted by Smt. Gulabi Poojarthy D/o Late Koosu Hengsu Alias Koosu S. Poojarthy along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the period 1988-89, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 692 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Gulabi Poojarthy D/o Late Koosu Hengsu Alias Koosu S. Poojarthy for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 59/3P-1-P1 (H.No. 9-24) of

Page 15 of 75

Hejamadi Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.8. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. B. Sarvothama S/o Annappa Poojary for construction of Ice plant, Fish Freezing plant/cold storage and Fish processing unit at Sy. No. 138/2A1 and 138/2A2 of Paduthonse Village- regarding (FEE 133 CRZ 2016).

Sri. B. Sarvothama S/o Annappa Poojary has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of Ice plant, Fish Freezing plant/cold storage and Fish processing unit at Sy. No. 138/2A1 (1.60 acre) and 138/2A2 (0.50 acre) of Paduthonse Village, Udupi Taluk. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 125 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 23’ 35.3” and E 74 0 41’ 53.5”. The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of Ice plant, Fish Freezing plant/cold storage and Fish processing unit submitted by Sri. B. Sarvothama S/o Annappa Poojary along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Building plan, Project report, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

As per the provisions under the para 8(i) III CRZ III A (iii) (1) of CRZ Notification 2011; facilities required for local fishing communities such as fish drying yards, auction halls, net mending yards, traditional boat building yards, Ice plant, ice crushing units, fish curing facilities and the like are permitted. Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. B. Sarvothama S/o Annappa Poojary for construction of Ice plant, Fish Freezing plant/cold storage only at Sy. No. 138/2A1 (1.60 acre) and 138/2A2 (0.50 acre) of Paduthonse Village as per recommendations of DCZMC, since these are permissible activities under CRZ Notification, 2011. The Authority decided not to issue CRZ clearance to fish processing unit since it is not a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

Page 16 of 75

15.5.9. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Robert D’Silva S/o Liyam D’Silva for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 225/1P2- P3 of Anagalli Village- regarding (FEE 134 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Robert D’Silva S/o Liyam D’Silva has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 225/1P2-P3 of Anagalli Village, Kundapur Taluk in an area of 0.19 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river or width of the creek whichever is less (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 15 mts from the HTL of river (width of the creek is 50 mts). The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 38’ 44.6” and E 74 0 41’ 45.9”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house bearing No. 1-11 submitted by Sri. Robert D’Silva S/o Liyam D’Silva along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax paid receipt dated 06.04.1988, certificate from Anagalli Grama Panchayath for change of door No. dated 03.09.2015, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 300 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Robert D’Silva S/o Liyam D’Silva for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 225/1P2-P3 of Anagalli Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.10. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Sanjeeva T. Naik S/o. Thimmappa for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 178/7B of Hakladi Village- regarding (FEE 135 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Sanjeeva T. Naik S/o. Thimmappa has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 178/7B of Hakladi Page 17 of 75

Village, Kundapur Taluk in an area of 0.70 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-I. The site is located at a distance of 35 mts from the HTL of river. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 41’ 32.2” and E 74 0 41’ 34.9”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (H.No. 1-98) submitted by Sri. Sanjeeva T. Naik S/o. Thimmappa along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the period 1988-89, certificate from Hakladi Grama Panchayath for change of door No. approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 62 Sqm. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. Since the Authority has granted special permission for reconstruction/repairs in CRZ-I Area in several cases.

As per the provisions under the para 3(i)(e) reconstruction, repair works of dwelling units of local communities especially fisher folk is allowed in accordance with local town and country planning regulations within CRZ area. The above site falls in CRZ-I and there is no specific mention of reconstruction/ repairs in CRZ Notification, 2011 under norms for regulation of activaties permissible under CRZ – I area (para 8(I) CRZ -I) . only new constructions have been prohibited under CRZ –I (expect the listed activities under para CRZ –I area).

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Sanjeeva T. Naik S/o. Thimmappa for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 178/7B of Hakladi Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is not a prohibited activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.11. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Joyce Fernandes W/o Inas Fernandes for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 51/15 of Paduvari Village- regarding (FEE 136 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Joyce Fernandes W/o Inas Fernandes has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 51/15 of Paduvari Village, Kundapur Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as

Page 18 of 75

CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 95 mts from the HTL of river. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 51’ 26.6” and E 74 0 37’ 11.3”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (H.No. 5-132) submitted by Smt. Joyce Fernandes W/o Inas Fernandes along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the period 1989-90, Tax paid receipt dated 21.01.1986, certificate from Paduvari Grama Panchayath for change of door No. dated 31.12.2015, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 600 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Joyce Fernandes W/o Inas Fernandes for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 51/15 of Paduvari Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.12. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Julekabi and others W/o Late. K. Usman Saheb for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 249/10A1 and 249/11A1 of Kodavoor Village- regarding (FEE 137 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Julekabi and others W/o Late. K. Usman Saheb has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 249/10A1 and

249/11A1 of Kodavoor Village, Udupi Taluk in a total area of 0.14 1/2 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-I. The site is located at a distance of 45 mts from the HTL of river. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 20’ 30.8” and E 74 0 42’ 34.5”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (H.No. 29-67) submitted by Smt. Julekabi and Page 19 of 75

others W/o Late. K. Usman Saheb along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the period 1989- 90, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area of the site is 726 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. Since in several cases the Authority has granted special permission for reconstruction / repairs in CRZ-I area.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Julekabi and others W/o Late. K. Usman Saheb for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 249/10A1 and 249/11A1 of Kodavoor Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.13. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Stella Rodrigues W/o. Inthru Rodrigues for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 12/5B2 of Paduvari Village- regarding (FEE 138 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Stella Rodrigues W/o. Inthru Rodrigues has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 12/5B2 of Paduvari Village, Kundapur Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river or width of the creek whichever is less (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 50 mts from the HTL of river (width of the creek is 80 mts). The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 51’ 11.5” and E 74 0 37’ 23.5”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (No. 7-26) submitted by Smt. Stella Rodrigues W/o. Inthru Rodrigues along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the period 1989-90, certificate from Paduvari Grama Panchayath for change of door No. dated 31.12.2015, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 475 Sq.ft. The DCZMC Page 20 of 75

recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Stella Rodrigues W/o. Inthru Rodrigues for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 12/5B2 of Paduvari Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.14. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Aithu Poojary for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 71/3 of Mattu Village- regarding (FEE 139 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Aithu Poojary has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 71/3 of Mattu Village, Udupi Taluk in an area of 0.23 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 15 mts from the HTL of river. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 16’ 11.8” and E 74 0 43’ 49.2”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (No. MT 4-119) submitted by Sri. Aithu Poojary along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax paid receipt dated 21.02.1984, certificate from Kote Grama Panchayath for change of door No. dated 23.03.2016, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 519 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

Page 21 of 75

existing, plinth area and existing density and for permissible activities under the notification including facilities essential for the said activities. Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Aithu Poojary for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 71/3 of Mattu Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.15. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Hassan Saheb S/o Shekhabba Saheb for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 47/6 of Navunda Village- regarding (FEE 140 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Hassan Saheb S/o Shekhabba Saheb has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 47/6 of Navunda Village, Kundapur Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre out of 0.13 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance 90 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 44’ 52.1” and E 74 0 38’ 10.0”. The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (No. 3-119) submitted by Sri. Hassan Saheb S/o Shekhabba Saheb along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the period 1988-89, certificate from Navunda Grama Panchayath for change of door No. dated 24.11.2015, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 56 Sqm (8x7 Sqm). The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

As per the provisions under the para 8(i) III CRZ III A of CRZ Notification 2011 no construction shall be permitted within NDZ except for repairs or reconstruction of existing authorized structure not exceeding existing FSI, existing, plinth area and existing density and for permissible activities under the notification including facilities essential for the said activities. Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity. The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Hassan Saheb S/o Shekhabba Saheb for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 47/6 of Navund Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011. Page 22 of 75

15.5.16. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. P. Subrahmanya Bagilthaya S/o Jayarama Bagilthaya for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 80/4 of Thenka Village- regarding (FEE 141 CRZ 2016).

Sri. P. Subramanya Bagilthaya S/o Jayarama Bagilthaya has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 80/4 of Thenka Village, Udupi Taluk in an area of 0.50 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 60 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 09’ 01.1” and E 74 0 45’ 31.1”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (No. 7-99) submitted by Sri. P. Subramanya Bagilthaya S/o Jayarama Bagilthaya along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the period 1982- 83, certificate from Tenka Grama Panchayath for change of door No. dated 26.12.2015, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 79 Sqm. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. P. Subramanya Bagilthaya S/o Jayarama Bagilthaya for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 80/4 of Thenka Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.17. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Kanoji Devaraya Kharvi S/o. Erayya Kharvi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 22/3 of gangolli Village- regarding (FEE 142 CRZ 2016). Page 23 of 75

Sri. Kanoji Devaraya Kharvi S/o. Erayya Kharvi has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 22/3 of Gangolli Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.80 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-II. The site is located at a distance of 265 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 39’ 19.1” and E 74 0 39’ 53.2”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Kanoji Devaraya Kharvi S/o. Erayya Kharvi along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

As per the provisions under the para 8 II CRZ – II (i) of CRZ Notification 2011 buildings shall be permitted only on the landward side of the existing road, or on the landward side of existing authorized structures; and (ii) buildings permitted on the landward side of the existing and proposed roads or existing authorized structures shall be subject to the existing local town and country planning regulations including the “existing” norms of Floor Space Index or Floor Area Ratio. Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Kanoji Devaraya Kharvi S/o. Erayya Kharvi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 22/3 of Gangolli Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.18. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Sarojini D/o Mookambike for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 36/5BP11 of Vandse Village- regarding (FEE 143 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Sarojini D/o Mookambike has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 36/5BP11 of Vandse Village, Kundapur Taluk in an area of 0.04 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 35 mts from the HTL of river. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 41’ 57.3” and E 74 0 45’ 21.6”. Page 24 of 75

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (No. 2-158) and (2-158/1) submitted by Smt. Sarojini D/o Mookambike, along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the year 2015-16, Certificate from Vandse Gram Panchayat, Udupi District for change of Khatha name dated 16.11.2015, approved CZMP sheet, draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is about 941.60 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Sarojini D/o Mookambike for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 36/5BP11 of Vandse Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.19. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Ganesh Poojary S/o Late. Deju Poojary for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 84/20B of Padu Village- regarding (FEE 144 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Ganesh Poojary S/o Late. Deju Poojary has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 84/20B of Padu Village, Udupi Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre out of 0.18 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 120 mts from the HTL of sea . The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 13’ 04.6” and E 74 0 44’ 24.8”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (No. 5-121) submitted by Sri. Ganesh Poojary S/o Late. Deju Poojary, along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the year 1989-90, approved CZMP sheet, approved digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed Page 25 of 75

reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 400 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Ganesh Poojary S/o Late. Deju Poojary for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 84/20B of Padu Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.20. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Ganga Poojarthy W.o Soora Poojary for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 118/2A of Navunda Village- regarding (FEE 145 CRZ 2016). Smt. Ganga Poojarthy W.o Soora Poojary has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 118/2A of Navunda Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre out of 0.30 acres. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 90 mts from river (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 75 mts from the HTL of river. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 44’ 57.1” and E 74 0 39’ 13.7”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (No. 2-8) submitted by Smt. Ganga Poojarthy W.o Soora Poojary, along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the year 1990-91, Certificate from Navunda Gram Panchayath for change of door No. dated. 10.03.2016, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 56 sqm. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

notification including facilities essential for the said activities. Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Ganga Poojarthy W.o Soora Poojary for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 118/2A of Navunda Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.21. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Inas Rodrigues S/o Marcel Rodrigues Alias Ludrik for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 12/8P2 of Paduvari Village- regarding (FEE 146 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Inas Rodrigues S/o Marcel Rodrigues Alias Ludrik has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 12/8P2 of Paduvari Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.03 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 100 mts from river or width of the creek whichever is less (as per the CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 26 mts from the HTL of river. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 51’ 09.8” and E 74 0 37’ 21.0”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house (No. 7-117) submitted by Sri. Inas Rodrigues S/o Marcel Rodrigues Alias Ludrik along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, Tax assessment extract for the year 1989-90, Certificate from Paduvari Gram Panchayath for change of door No. dated. 31.12.2015, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The plinth area is 699 Sq.Ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

Page 27 of 75

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Inas Rodrigues S/o Marcel Rodrigues Alias Ludrik for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 12/8P2 of Paduvari Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.22. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Padmavati D/o Devi Mogaveera for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 121/2P10 of Shiruru Village - regarding (FEE 148 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Padmavati D/o Devi Mogaveera has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 121/2P10 of Shiruru Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.10 acre out of 0.30 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 210 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 54’ 45.7” and E 74 0 35’ 29.2”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Smt. Padmavati D/o Devi Mogaveera along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

As per the provisions under the para 8(i) III CRZ III B (vii) of CRZ Notification 2011 construction or reconstruction of dwelling units is permitted activity so long it is within the ambit of traditional rights and customary uses such as existing fishing Villages and goathans. The construction shall be subject to local town and country planning rules with overall height not exceeding 9mts with two floors (ground+one floor). Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Padmavati D/o Devi Mogaveera for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 121/2P10 of Shiruru Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

Page 28 of 75

15.5.23. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Mohammad Fayaz S/o B. Yusuf for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 194/2B of Maravanthe Village- regarding (FEE 149 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Mohammad Fayaz S/o B. Yusuf has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 194/2B of Maravanthe Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre out of 0.60 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 330 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 44’ 19.4” and E 74 0 38’ 23.9”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Mohammad Fayaz S/o B. Yusuf along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Mohammad Fayaz S/o B. Yusuf for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 194/2B of Maravanthe Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.24. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Shekhar P. Kundar S/o Porala Suvarna for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 114/15P2 of Mattu Village- regarding (FEE 150 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Shekhar P. Kundar S/o Porala Suvarna has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 114/15P2 of Mattu Village, Udupi Taluk in an area of 0.20 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site Page 29 of 75

is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 305 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 16’ 21.2” and E 74 0 43’ 43.2”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Shekhar P. Kundar S/o Porala Suvarna along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Shekhar P. Kundar S/o Porala Suvarna for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 114/15P2 of Mattu Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.25. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Chandravathi Jayasheela Kotian W/o Late Jayasheela Kotian for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 73/3A3CP1-P2 of Hejamadi Village- regarding (FEE 151 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Chandravathi Jayasheela Kotian W/o Late Jayasheela Kotian has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No.

73/3A3CP1-P2 of Hejamadi Village, Udupi Taluk in an area of 0.22 1/2 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is at a distance of 260 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 05’ 54.0” and E 74 0 46’ 20.8”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for reconstruction of residential house submitted by Smt. Chandravathi Jayasheela Kotian W/o Late Jayasheela Kotian along with application in the prescribed

Page 30 of 75

format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Chandravathi Jayasheela Kotian W/o Late Jayasheela Kotian for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 73/3A3CP1-P2 of Hejamadi Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.26. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Hilda Fernandes W/o Late Denis Fernandes for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 108/6 of Badanidiyur Village- regarding (FEE 152 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Hilda Fernandes W/o Late Denis Fernandes has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 108/6 of Badanidiyur Village, Udupi Taluk in an area of 0.03 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 350 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 22’ 54.1” and E 74 0 41’ 57.2”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Smt. Hilda Fernandes W/o Late Denis Fernandes along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

As per the provisions under the para 8(i) III CRZ III B (vii) of CRZ Notification 2011 construction or reconstruction of dwelling units is permitted Page 31 of 75

activity so long it is within the ambit of traditional rights and customary uses such as existing fishing Villages and goathans. The construction shall be subject to local town and country planning rules with overall height not exceeding 9mts with two floors (ground+one floor). Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Hilda Fernandes W/o Late Denis Fernandes for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 108/6 of Badanidiyur Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.27. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Sheena Kharvi S/o Govinda Kharvi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 159/1E of Maravanthe Village- regarding (FEE 153 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Sheena Kharvi S/o Govinda Kharvi has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 159/1E of Maravanthe Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.33 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 480 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 43’ 17.1” and E 74 0 38’ 40.0”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Sheena Kharvi S/o Govinda Kharvi along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

Page 32 of 75

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Sheena Kharvi S/o Govinda Kharvi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 159/1E of Maravanthe Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.28. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Marli D/o Late Machi Mogera for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 298/11AP1 of Shiruru Village- regarding (FEE 154 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Marli D/o Late Machi Mogera has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 298/11AP1 of Shiruru Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.10 acre out of 0.31 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 265 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 53’ 19.9” and E 74 0 35’ 52.3”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Smt. Marli D/o Late Machi Mogera along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Marli D/o Late Machi Mogera for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 298/11AP1 of Shiruru Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.29. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Nagaraja S/o Gange Poojarthy for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 7/8 of Kotathattu Village- regarding (FEE 155 CRZ 2016). Page 33 of 75

Sri. Nagaraja S/o Gange Poojarthy has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No.7/8 of Kotathattu Village, Udupi Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre out of 0.15 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 340 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 31’ 25.5” and E 74 0 41’ 15.1”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Nagaraja S/o Gange Poojarthy along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Nagaraja S/o Gange Poojarthy for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 7/8 of Kotathattu Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.30. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Vinoda Devadiga W/o Manjunatha Devadiga for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 160/1A3P1 of Shiruru Village- regarding (FEE 156 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Vinoda Devadiga W/o Manjunatha Devadiga has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 160/1A3P1 of Shiruru Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.07 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 430 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 54’ 09.8” and E 74 0 35’ 46.8”. Page 34 of 75

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Smt. Vinoda Devadiga W/o Manjunatha Devadiga along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Vinoda Devadiga W/o Manjunatha Devadiga for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 160/1A3P1 of Shiruru Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.31. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Devamma Poojarthy W/o Late Sheena Poojary for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 74/2A1P20 of Parampalli Village- regarding (FEE 157 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Devamma Poojarthy W/o Late Sheena Poojary has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 74/2A1P20 of Parampalli Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.10 acre out of 0.60 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 320 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 30’ 06.7” and E 74 0 41’ 23.6”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Smt. Devamma Poojarthy W/o Late Sheena Poojary along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on

Page 35 of 75

02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Devamma Poojarthy W/o Late Sheena Poojary for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 74/2A1P20 of Parampalli Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.32. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Puttayya S/o Gange Poojarthy for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 7/7 of Kotathattu Village- regarding (FEE 158 CRZ 2016). Sri. Puttayya S/o Gange Poojarthy has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 7/7 of Kotathattu Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre out of 0.15 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 320 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 31’ 25.2” and E 74 0 41’ 14.4”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Puttayya S/o Gange Poojarthy along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

with two floors (ground+one floor). Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Puttayya S/o Gange Poojarthy for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 7/7 of Kotathattu Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.33. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Govindu D/o Durgi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 312/2CP6 of Shiruru Village- regarding (FEE 159 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Govindu D/o Durgi has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 312/2CP6 of Shiruru Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre out of 0.52 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is at a distance 340 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 53’ 11.9” and E 74 0 35’ 58.8”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Smt. Govindu D/o Durgi along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Govindu D/o Durgi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 312/2CP6 of Shiruru Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

Page 37 of 75

15.5.34. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Basava Poojary S/o Narayana Poojary for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 5/20 of Kotathattu Village- regarding (FEE 160 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Basava Poojary S/o Narayana Poojary has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 5/20 of Kotathattu Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.05 acre out of 0.10 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 265 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 31’ 25.8” and E 74 0 41’ 12.6”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Basava Poojary S/o Narayana Poojary along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Basava Poojary S/o Narayana Poojary for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 5/20 of Kotathattu Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.35. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Ganapathi Mogera S/o Subbayya Mogera for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 26/2 of Shiruru Village- regarding (FEE 161 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Ganapathi Mogera S/o Subbayya Mogera has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 26/2 of Shiruru Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.10 are out of 0.64 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site Page 38 of 75

is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 365 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 55’ 33.4” and E 74 0 33’ 13.0”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Ganapathi Mogera S/o Subbayya Mogera along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Ganapathi Mogera S/o Subbayya Mogera for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 26/2 of Shiruru Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.36. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Sri. Moulana Mohammad Ismail S/o Late Raheemabi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 34/11 of Gangolli Village- regarding (FEE 162 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Moulana Mohammad Ismail S/o Late Raheemabi has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 34/11 of Gangolli Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.13 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 425 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 39’ 33.2” and E 74 0 39’ 55.7”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Sri. Moulana Mohammad Ismail S/o Late Raheemabi along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing Page 39 of 75

the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Moulana Mohammad Ismail S/o Late Raheemabi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 34/11 of Gangolli Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.37. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Godu Poojarthy D/o Bachhi Poojarthy for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 122/7C2A2 of Parampalli Village- regarding (FEE 163 CRZ 2016). Smt. Godu Poojarthy D/o Bachhi Poojarthy has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 122/7C2A2 of Parampalli Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.03.75 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 220 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 29’ 51.6” and E 74 0 41’ 22.9”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Smt. Godu Poojarthy D/o Bachhi Poojarthy along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

with two floors (ground+one floor). Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Godu Poojarthy D/o Bachhi Poojarthy for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 122/7C2A2 of Parampalli Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011.

15.5.38. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Durgi W/o Late Narayana Kharvi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 119/2 of Maravanthe Village- regarding (FEE 164 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Durgi W/o Late Narayana Kharvi has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 119/2 of Maravanthe Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.10 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The site is located at a distance of 490 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 43’ 41.8” and E 74 0 38’ 36.2”.

The Regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for construction of residential house submitted by Smt. Durgi W/o Late Narayana Kharvi along with application in the prescribed format, RTC, Survey Map of the Site, building plan, approved CZMP sheet, approved CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of CRZ Clearance in the DCZMC meeting held on 02.05.2016.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Durgi W/o Late Narayana Kharvi for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 119/2 of Maravanthe Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011. Page 41 of 75

15.5.39. Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Smt. Hilda Fernandes W/o Late Denis Fernandes for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 108/5A of Badanidiyur Village- regarding (FEE 165 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Hilda Fernandes W/o Late Denis Fernandes has applied for issue of CRZ Clearance for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 108/5A of Badanidiyur Village, Kundapura Taluk in an area of 0.03 acre. The Regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is within 500 mts from sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The siet is located at a distance of 360 mts from the HTL of sea. The GPS Readings of the site is N 13 0 22’ 54.2” and E 74 0 41’ 57.4”.

As per the provisions under the para 8(i) III CRZ III B (vii) of the CRZ Notification 2011 construction or reconstruction of dwelling units is permitted activity so long it is within the ambit of traditional rights and customary uses such as existing fishing Villages and goathans. The construction shall be subject to local town and country planning rules with overall height not exceeding 9mts with two floors (ground+one floor). Hence, the above proposal is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt. Hilda Fernandes W/o Late Denis Fernandes for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 108/5A of Badanidiyur Village as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under CRZ Notification, 2011 .

15.5.40. Request for issue of Modified CRZ Clearance for construction of Lakshadweep Administration, Lakshadweep Public Works Department, Circle Office, Kavaratti for construction Lakshadweep Terminal at Sy. No. 52/1A1A, 52/1A2 and 491/1 of Mangaluru Thota Village –regarding (FEE 1 CRZ 2016).

Page 42 of 75

The Regional Director (Environment), Mangaluru vide his letter dated 03.10.2015 had submitted a proposal for construction of terminal building in Thota Village of Mangaluru Taluk at Sy. No. 52/1A1A, 52/1A2 and 491/1 coming under CRZ-II area by the Lakshadweep Public Works Department Circle Office, Kaveratti. The proposal was submitted along with DCZMC meeting proceedings and other relavant documents. As per the proposal, the built up area of the proposed building was 16034.49 Sqm and net area is 11,783.21 Sqm. It was proposed to build G+7 Floors. The DCZMC had recommended to issue CRZ Clearance but had not mentioned about number of floors for which clearance is to be issued. The decision regarding number of floors was left to KSCZMA. The proposal was placed before the 11 th KSCZMA meeting held on 15.10.2015. In the meeting no discussion had taken place regarding number of floors to be considered for CRZ Clearance. The decision taken in the meeting is as follows:

“Since the Sy. No. 491/1 falls within CRZ Area. The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ Clearance for construction as per the recommendations of the DCZMC.

In the agenda notes of the above KSCZMA meeting, it is mentioned as construction of Lakshadweep Terminal under subject no. 11.4.5, but in first para under this subject it is mentioned as “construction of Residential apartment”. Accordingly CRZ Clearance has been issued for construction of Residential Houses on 07.12.2015.

The Executing Engineer, Lakshadweep PWD Division Office, Kochi vide his letter dated. 15.12.2015 has requested to effect the change in address and type of building which has been wrongly mentioned in the CRZ Clearance issued. This letter was referred to RD (Environment),, Mangaluru, instructing him to submit a report. RD, Mangaluru vide his letter dated 25.04.2016 has requested to effect the modification sought by the applicant.

Hence the subject is placed before the Authority for deliberation and decision regarding issue of Modified CRZ Clearance for construction of Terminal building (Office Housing and godown) as per the existing Local Town and Country Planning Regulation including the existing norms of floor space index or floor area ratio and also to effect the change of address as requested by the applicant.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue Modified CRZ Clearance for construction of Terminal building (Office, Housing and Godown) as per the existing Local Town and Country Planning Regulation including the existing norms of floor space index or Floor Area Ratio prior to 1991 to Page 43 of 75

Lakshadweep Public Works Department Kavaratti and also to effect the change of address as requested by the applicant. [As per para 8 II CRZ II (i) and (ii)]

15.5.41. CRZ clearance for proposed Fishing Harbour project at Kulai Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshina Kannada District by Deputy Director, Fisheries, South Wharf, Fishing Harbour, Mangaluru –regarding (FEE 124 CRZ 2016).

Deputy Director, Fisheries, Mangaluru has applied for CRZ clearance for proposed Fishing Harbour Project at Kulai, Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshina Kannada District. The regional Director (Environment), has inspected the proposed site and reported that the project site is in CRZ-IB, CRZ-II & CRZ IV as per CZMP. The GPS Readings of the site is South: N 12 0 57’ 54.70” E 74 0 47’ 54.00” North : N 12 0 58’ 09.80” E 74 0 47’ 50.80”.

The Regional Director (Environment), reported that there are provisions for 3 No of waterside facilities and 24 No of Land side facilities in the project. The proposed fishing harbour development project is having fish handling capacity of 27100 MT/Annum and the proposed cost of the project is Rs. 230.00 crores. The proposed activities are as below.

Sl. Location Facilities No. 1. Quay and Jetty Waterside 2. Dredging and Reclamation facilities 3. Break waters 4. Fish handling & Auction Halls 5. Fish loading area 6. Vehicle parking area 7. Fishery Administrative office 8. Sea water supply and distribution system Fresh water supply and distribution 9. system Land side facilities 10. Fuel supply and storage 11. Fishermen gear sheds 12. Net mending sheds and net drying yards 13. Fishermen rest shed 14. RC sloping hard and boat parking areas 15. Boat repair shop 16. Radio-communication tower

Page 44 of 75

17. Restaurant 18. Public toilet blocks 19. Internal roads and hard surfaces 20. Drainage and sewerage 21. Power and lighting 22. Compound wall 23. Security/Guard house 24. Effluent Treatment plant 25. Civic amenities 26. Greeneries and landscaping 27. Fire Extinguishers

It is explained in the proposal that facilities have been designed for a fleet size of 275 mechanised fishing boats comprising of 120 no’s of 12m. long trawlers, 110 no’s of 18m. long trawlers and 45 no’s of 18m. long purse seiners to avail the landing and berthing facilities at site.

It is further reported that by development of above fishing harbour at proposed location in Kulai Village of Dakshina Kannada District, the fishermen of the surrounding villages are benefitted as they will be provided with a nearby harbour. These fishermen are now travelling up to mangalore fishing harbour which is about 10 km south of the NMPT, as a result of construction of NMPT at Panambur.

The project site has been selected considering the following factors.

• Back up land area available. • Facilities like ice plant, freezing plant etc., in the vicinity. • Availability of wide range of fish species. • Harness to NMPT and mangaloe port for business related opportunities. • Connectivity by road. • The site is a non-agricultural land. • Availability of man power etc.,

The regional Director (Environment), has submitted the proposal for proposed Fishing Harbour Project at Kulai, Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshina Kannada District submitted by the Deputy Director, Fisheries, Mangaluru along with Checklist, Form – I, EC application Form-I, Pre- Feasibility report, CEIA Report, Undertaking, CRZ Map and Google map, Inspection Report of Regional Director

Page 45 of 75

(Environment), and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 01.04.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal to KSCZMA for issue of CRZ Clearance.

The activity of constructing fishing harbor is permissible under para 3 (i)(a) & 4 (i)(f) of CRZ Notification 2011.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for construction of Fishing Harbour project at Kulai Mangaluru Taluk by Deputy Director Fisheries, Mangaluru, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, since it is a permissible activity under para 3 (i)(a) & 4 (i)(f) of CRZ Notification, 2011 .

15.6 Note on Violation Cases :

The MoEF&CC, vide D.O. letter dated: 29.04.2016 has directed to report on the identification of violations of the provisions of the CRZ Notification,1991/2011 and the follow-up action taken. A format for reporting of identification of violation cases and the action taken there upon has been designed by the MoEF&CC and it has been sent to the state along with the above letter for taking further action by the state.

The matter regarding reporting of violation cases have been seriously reviewed in the NCZMA meetings held on 29.02.2016 and 24.05.2016.

In this regard, all the 3 Regional Directors (Environment) of the state were instructed to furnish the details of CRZ violations in the prescribed format by addressing a letter on 17.05.2016. Further, all the 3 RDs have been frequently reminded over phone to furnish the details sought as above.

As per the reports of the RDs the details, are as follows (received by e- mail).

Details Balance details No. of Sl. furnished in to be furnished District cases No. the in the identified prescribed prescribed format format 1 Mangalore District 39 39 - (Dakshina 2 Udupi District 65 54 11 3 Karwar District 106 91 15 (Uttara Kannada) Total 210 184 26

Page 46 of 75

Details furnished in the prescribed format by three RD’s are enclosed vide Annexure II, III and IV.

The above information is placed before the Authority for decision regarding reporting the same to the MoEF&CC.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue directions to the concerned Regional Directors to re-examine the violation cases and to submit the proposals along with spot mahazar, map, photos, present legal status and other relevant records for taking appropriate decision by the Authority.

15.7 Violation Cases :

15.7.1. Violation of CRZ Notification, 1991 in Kundapura Town Municipal limits by Sri. K. Sripad Upadya - regarding (FEE 224 CRZ 2012).

Sri. Sripad Upadya, Kundapura had requested for CRZ Clearance for development of residential layout within Kundapura Municipal limits Sy. No. 158, 197 and 198.

The Authority examined the proposal in the meeting held on 16.04.2010 and decided to get field inspection report from Regional Director (Environment), Udupi. Regional Director (Environment), Udupi submitted a report on 09.09.2010 stating that the proposed land of 10.3425 acres lies adjacent to the back water and is classified as CRZ-I and no new construction is permitted in this zone and also that adjacent creek is having fringe mangrove. Project was proposed for 26 residential sites. The Chief Officer, Municipal Council, Kundapura had reported that the project area falls within the town municipal limits and lies in new 19 th ward of municipal council vide letter dated:06.08.2010. The proponent claimed that the proposed land is well connected with electricity, water supply, road and all civic amenities. It can be classified as CRZ-II.

The Authority after considering all the points presented by proponent and that of report submitted by RD, finally decided to issue CRZ Clearance to Non- CRZ area with conditions that no development should be taken in CRZ area and Non-CRZ area should be determined as per the distance criteria laid down in the GoI letter No. 11-66/2005-IA-III of February, 2006 from the HTL determined by Institute of Remote Sensing, Anna University, Chennai and that the drainage pattern of the area shall remain unaltered and the development of mangrove along the creek is not affected.

Page 47 of 75

Further, there was a complaint by the locals to RD on 22.03.2010 that the proponent had reclaimed at Vittalawadi Village, an area south of Sitarama Tiles Factory by raising the ground level higher than that of the adjoining agricultural lands thereby obstructing natural flow of water and due to this adjoining agricultural lands have become inundated. In this regard, Regional Director (Environment), Udupi had written letter to Assistant Commissioner, Kundapura, Chief Officer, Municipal Council, Kundapura and to the concerned Tashildar to examine the complaint and to take necessary steps as per the law on 29.03.2010 and 31.05.2010 respectively.

Then as per the directions of the Government vide D.O. Letter dated: 25.08.2010, Regional Director (Environment), Udupi had inspected the spot on 31.08.2010 and submitted a report on 09.09.2010.

In this report, it is mentioned that the proposed area falls under CRZ-II and in an area of 100m X 150m, existing Kandla plant have been removed and the place is filled-up (reclaimation) with Red Soil, obstructing natural flow of water in the area, thereby taking up prohibited activity as per para 2 (viii) of CRZ Notification, 1991. As per para 6 (2) under CRZ-I, no new construction is permitted in CRZ-I except those listed out. But as per the report of Regional Director (Environment), Udupi, the proponent had constructed revetments, erected compound wall with concrete poles and barbed wire fencing. Finally Regional Director (Environment), Udupi opined that there is CRZ Violation from the proponent. Further, RD had called for documents for having taken up prohibited activities as per para 2 (viii) of CRZ Notificaiton, 1991. But there had been no reply from the proponent.

It is reported by the Regional Director (Environment), Udupi that as per the report of Municipal Council, Kundapura dated: 20.07.2010, the works have been stopped.

The DCZMC had discussed this case in the meeting held on 23.08.2012 and had recommended to take further action at KSCZMA. The Regional Director (Environment), Udupi vide his latest report dated:07.05.2016 has confirmed the violations and has requested to take action as per the report submitted on 05.09.2012 to the Government.

In this regard, credible action as per the Section 19 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 may be initiated. The Authority may direct the concerned RD to conduct spot mahajar and authorise to file a case in the jurisdictional court for further necessary action. Page 48 of 75

The Authority examined the representation dated 06.07.2016 submitted by the applicant/violator.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to direct the concerned Regional Director to issue final notice Sri. Sripad Upadya directing him to remove the structures which are obstructing natural water course and to restore the original status of the area and to report compliance to the Authority.

15.7.2. Establishment of S.G. Lake resort at Sy. No. 142/12A2 of Nadsal Village by Sri. Ganesh Poojary - regarding (FEE 54 CRZ 2013).

The S.G. lake resort was established in violation of CRZ guidelines in Sy.No. 142/12A2 of Nadsal Village in Udupi Taluk by Sri. Ganesh Poojary S/o Hariyappa Poojary. The site is located at Kadipatna near Nadipatna road, Padubidri. The G.P.S readings of the site is N 13 0 07. 664’ E 74 0 45. 870’. There is a building of around 40 ft height with ground floor and two upper floors. 50 feet eastward of this is another RCC building of around 25 ft height with ground and first floor. This site is located at a distance of 90 mtr from HTL of Sea surrounded by Kamini River towards its south and east. As per approved CZMP this falls in CRZ-III within NDZ, where no new constructions are permitted as per CRZ Notification. Two notices dated:02.11.2009 and 19.01.2010 were issued to the applicant by the concerned RD. No reply was received either from the owner of the resort or from the Gram Panchayath. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 03.12.2011. The DCZMC recommended the proposal as CRZ Violation for taking necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with notices issued dated:02.11.2009 and 19.01.2010 to the applicant, CZMP Sheet, Draft CRZ map showing the site of violation, Photos of the building and copy of DCZMC proceedings held on 03.12.2011.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 02.04.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

Page 49 of 75

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to authorize the concerned Regional Director to file a case in jurisdictional court as per the Section 19 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 after conducting spot mahazar and recording statement of the violator.

15.7.3. Construction of a residential house at Beejadi Village in Sy. No. 306/4 by Sri. Dhruv Choudhary, Bangalore - regarding (FEE 27 CRZ 2013).

Sri. Dhruv Choudhary S/o Samir Choudhary, Malleshwaram, Bangalore had constructed a residential house at Beejadi in Sy. No. 306/4 without obtaining CRZ Clearance and violated the norms of CRZ Notification 1991 and 2011.

The site is situated at a distance of 30 mtrs from HTL of Sea in NDZ of CRZ- III area. The compound wall construction starts from 30 th mtr. from HTL and the building commences from 95 th mtr. from HTL of Sea. Proponent has constructed building, compound wall and carried out land levelling. Proponent is a non traditional local inhabitant of CRZ area. Further, as per para 8 (i) III CRZ III A (ii) CRZ Notification 2011 no construction shall be permitted within NDZ except for repairs or reconstruction of existing authorized structure. Hence, notices were issued by RD to the applicant on 10.08.2012 and to Panchayath Development Officer on 17.08.2012. Applicant replied that there are no documents with him and local authority also failed to produce documents relating to the permission given by them for construction. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 23.08.2012. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with Sy. Map of site, RTC, copy of letter from Beejadi Grama Panchayath, Tax receipt dated:09.07.2010 and 23.03.2011, Site plan and estimation, CZMP sheet and draft CRZ map showing the site of violation.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 01.03.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

15.7.4. Construction of restaurant and rest room “Thonse Par” in violation of CRZ regulations at Malpe by Sri. Suresh Shetty - regarding (FEE 55 CRZ 2013).

Sri. Suresh Shetty S/o Krishna Shetty, Thonse Par at Malpe beach has constructed and is operating restaurant and rest room at Malpe beach in Kodavoor Village of Udupi District. It is located in unsurveyed beach land, 30 mtr from HTL of Sea north of Malpe circle and south of Sulabh Shouchalaya. The G.P.S reading of site is N 13 0 21.685’ E 74 0 41. 939’. It has following structures (NDZ of CRZ III of Notification).

• Hotel with brick wall and tiled roof building of around 620 sq. ft. • Chat centre of around 645 sq. ft. in front of the above. • Wooden rest room around 100 sq. ft. • Round rest room with stone walls of around 250 sq. ft. • Rest rooms of thatched roof – 532 sq. ft. and 300 sq. ft.

The RD issued notice on 07.12.2009 to the applicant regarding the CRZ violation committed by him and the applicant replied that he has constructed temporary structures to facilitate beach tourists and has not produced any documents. Further, the applicant was asked to give records by serving another notice on 25.01.2010. The applicant has produced license from CMC, Udupi, copy of Trade license and lease agreements, but not the ownership records. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 03.12.2011. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with CZMP sheet, draft CRZ map showing the site of violation, copy of DCZMC proceedings held on 03.12.2011.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 12.02.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

Page 51 of 75

15.7.5. Construction of residential house at Gopadi Village in Sy. No. 3/3P6 and 3/2P4 by Smt. Savithramma, Bangalore - regarding (FEE 28 CRZ 2013).

Smt. K. Savithramma, # 137, 13 th main, 7 th cross, HSR Layout Sector 5, Bangalore-560102 had constructed a residential house at Gopadi in Sy. No. 3/3P6, 3/2P4 without obtaining CRZ Clearance and violated the norms of CRZ Notification 1991 and 2011. The site is situated at a distance of 30 mtrs from HTL in NDZ of CRZ-III. The compound well partition construction starts from 30 mtr of HTL and the building commences from 50 mtr of HTL of Sea.

A notice was served to PDO on 17.08.2012 by RD to provide all relevant records regarding construction of residential building by the applicant in NDZ of CRZ-III in violation of the provisions of CRZ Notification 1991 and 2011. Similar notices were also issued to the applicant on 10.08.2012 to produce relevant records for the authenticity of the building construction. The reply submitted by the applicant on 17.09.2012, do not have any supporting records to establish the existence of old building prior to 1991 and permission given by local authority with valid CRZ clearance. Local authorities also failed to produce the necessary documents for permitting the construction. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 23.08.2012. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with Sy. Map of site, RTC, copy of letter from Beejadi Grama Panchayath, Tax receipt dated 17.11.2006, 29.06.2009, 08.07.2008 and 30.12.2009, site plan and estimation, CZMP sheet and draft CRZ map showing the site of violation.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 01.03.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures. Page 52 of 75

15.7.6. Construction of building at Sy. No. 68/F1 in Badanidiyur Village, Udupi Taluk by Sri. Prasad Kotyan S/o Gopala Kotyan, Chitrapu Village, Mulki - regarding (FEE 918 CRZ 2014).

Sri. Prasad Kotyan S/o Gopala Kotyan, Chitrapu Village, Mulki has constructed a building at Badanidiyur village in Sy. No. 68/F1 without obtaining CRZ Clearance. The concerned RD inspected the site on 26.10.2013 based on complaint from Sri. Yatish, Badanidiyur. The G.P.S. readings of site is N 13 0 22’ 54.9’ E 74 0 41’ 47.0’ and the site is at a distance of 25 mtr from HTL of Sea. A letter was addressed to Panchayath Development Officer, Badanidiyur Grama Panchayath by RD on 27.03.2014 informing that no water and electricity connection is to be given to the above building since it is a case of CRZ violation vide para 8 III CRZ III A (ii) (NDZ of CRZ III of Notification).

Based on complaint by Smt. Meena Lakshmi beach castle Badanidiyur regarding violation to DC, Udupi, RD (Env), Udupi inspected the spot on 13.02.2014 and reported that the construction has been stopped after completing plastering works to the walls of the building. There were no documents to prove that the old building existed before 1990, either with applicant or with local panchayath. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 07.06.2014. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with Sy. Map of site, CZMP sheet, draft CRZ map showing the site of violation and copy of proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.06.2014.

15.7.7. Construction of commercial building, Sunlight Beach Resort in Sy. No. 27 of Trasi Village, Kundapura Taluk by Sri. Prabhakar. N Chandan S/o Naga Nayak - regarding (FEE 31 CRZ 2005).

Sri. Prabhakar N. Chandan has constucted unauthorised building (sunlight beach resort) at Sy. No. 27 (0.05 acres), Thrasi Village, Kundapura Taluk, Udupi District. The above constuction includes 3 RCC buildings (plinth area 137.06 Sqm) with a Compound Wall (of area 206.36 Sqm) covering a total area of 343.42 Sqm in violation of provisions of the CRZ Notification. The construction is at a distance of 140 m from HTL of Sea (NDZ of CRZ III of Notification).

The issue was discussed in the KSCZMA meeting held on 29.06.2005 and further notice was issued by Senior Director (Technical Cell), DFEE and MS, KSCZMA on 05.09.2006 and 09.11.2009 to the proponent asking him to clear the structures built violating CRZ Notification. The proponent has given reply on 28.11.2009 and the reply has not been accepted and the case is considered as violation.

The issue was deliberated again in DCZMC meeting held on 03.12.2011. Since, no action was taken by the applicant, as per the directions of the Government. The DCZMC recommended the case for further necessary action.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 22.03.2016 and in this report RD has informed that violation has not been cleared. Latest photo of the structures is submitted with this report.

15.7.8. Reconstruction of residential house No. 11-220 in Paduthonse Village violation CRZ notification 2011 by Smt. Arundathi D/o K. Ramachandra Rao - regarding (FEE 7 CRZ 2013).

Sri. B. Rajeev Shetty S/o Shivarama Shetty, 11-2-70E, “Padmaja”, Pragathinagaram, Udupi-576101 (GPA Holder of Smt. Arundhathi D/o K. Ramachandra Rao, House No. 403, Vars Clara Mant, Kaggadasapura Road, C.V. Ram Nagar, Bangalore) had applied for reconstruction of the residential house No. II-220 in Sy. No. 2510-B of Paduthonse Village. The said land of 0.48 acre was purchased from Thukaram Salian and others by Smt. Arundathi D/o K. Ramachandra Rao with a dilapidated tiled house building measuring about 300 sq. ft. plinth area. The G.P.S. reading of the site is N 13 0 24. 424’ E 74 0 41.896’. Since, the building was prior to 1991, CRZ Clearance was issued after site inspection for reconstruction not exceeding the plinth area of 300 sq. ft subject to being traditional coastal community.

The proponent has constructed a huge building (more than 1000 sq. ft. plinth area) with compound wall on all sides, thereby violating the CRZ Clearance issued. As per Para 8 (i) III A (ii) no construction is permitted within NDZ expect for repairs or reconstruction of existing authorised structure not exceeding existing Floor Space Index, existing plinth area and existing density. Hence, the CRZ Clearance given earlier was withdrawn on 20.10.2012. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 28.11.2012. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with copy of CRZ Clearance, copy of letter of Thonse Grama Panchayath, copy of show cause notice dated:28.09.2012, CZMP sheet, draft digitized map showing the area of violation, extract of the DCZMC meeting and photos of newly constructed building.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 12.02.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

Page 55 of 75

15.7.9. Construction of residential building at Sy. No. 11/17 of Kadekar Village, Udupi Taluk by Sri. Ganesh Bangera, Ganavi, Kadekar Village - regarding (FEE 120 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Ganesh Bangera, Ganavi, Kadekar Village and post, Udupi Taluk has constructed a residential building in Sy. No. 11/17 in 0.05 acres of land out of total area of 0.18 acres. The site is at a distance of 50 mts from river HTL. The construction has taken place without obtaining CRZ Clearance. The G.P.S. reading of the site is N 13 0 19, 54.0’’ E 74 0 43’ 08.7”. RD issued notice to the applicant on 09.01.2015 and to PDO on 20.01.2016 and 11.02.2016. No reply has been received from the PDO. Further, DCZMC has given directions to PDO to take action for demolition of building on 27.11.2015. But from the latest report regarding the violation received from the concerned RD on 03.03.2016 it is found that the violated building structure has not been cleared (NDZ of CRZ III of Notification). The RD submitted the proposal along with RTC, Sy. Map of site, CZMP sheet, draft digitized map showing the area of violation, photo of old building and building sketch.

The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 23.11.2015 and 16.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended for taking necessary action against PDO for not following the directions of DCZMC.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to direct the concerned Regional Director to submit a report after re-examining proposal and

Page 56 of 75

verifying the details regarding the existence of old house at the above site for taking appropriate decision by the Authority.

15.7.10. Construction of building at Sy. No. 177/6A (Door No. 9-106A) of Hejamadi Village, Udupi District by Sri. Arunkumar S/o Mahabala Suvarna - regarding (FEE 58 CRZ 2013).

Sri. Arunkumar S/o Mahabala Suvarna and Gowri Arunkumar purchased Building of tiled house with plinth area around 650 sft at Sy. No. 177/6A (Door No. 9-106A) of Hejamadi Village from Sri. Sanjeeva Rama Kotian as per the sale deed. The panchayath vide letter No. 14/05-06 has given approval for a plinth area of 4040 sq. ft with a condition that the work should commence after obtaining CRZ Clearance. The proponent constructed a building at a distance of 40 mtr from HTL of Sea and 16 mtr from HTL of River in violation of CRZ Notification. The building is around 288.m 2 ground area with a first floor of 162m 2, with a height of 28ft. The applicant is a resident of Bombay and has not obtained prior CRZ Clearance. As per CRZ Notification 1991 within NDZ of CRZ- III repair of authorized buildings are only permitted activity and not construction/reconstruction. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 03.12.2011. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with CZMP sheet, draft CRZ map showing the site of violation, Photos of structure in violation and abstract copy of DCZMC proceedings held on 03.12.2011.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 21.03.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to authorize the concerned Regional Director file a case in the jurisdictional court as per Section 19 of the EP Act after conducting spot mahajar and recording statement of the violator.

Page 57 of 75

15.7.11. Construction of building at Sy. No. 90/1A5 in Yermal Padu, Bada Village by Sri. K. Ganesh - regarding (FEE 56 CRZ 2013).

Sri. K. Ganesh, Palm Beach, Yermal Padu, Bada Village has constructed the building in Bada Village within 60 mtr from the HTL of Sea. The G.P.S. readings of the site is N 13 0 10’ 52.2’ E 74 0 44’ 59.3’. The proponent had purchased the property from Sri. Raju Kanchan S/o Kittu Puthran, Yermal Bada Village as per the sale deed dated:14.05.1999 and there is no reference to the existence of old building. The RD has issued notices to applicant on 23.11.2009 and reply received from him on 10.12.2009. This reply was not convincing and acceptable as per the report of RD. Hence, further clarification was sought from the applicant on 25.01.2010 for which no reply was received from the applicant. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 03.12.2011. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with CZMP sheet, draft CRZ map showing the site of violation, abstract copy of DCZMC proceedings held on 03.12.2011.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 22.03.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

15.7.12. Construction of residential building at Sy. No. 212/3B of Kotathattu Village, Udupi District by Sri. Venkataraman - regarding (FEE 228 CRZ 2011).

Sri. S. Venkatraman, Flat No. 2203, Heeranadani meadows, Gladys Alvars roard, Thana West, Mumbai has constructed a residential building near the sea shore flouting the CRZ norms. The site of construction is around 40 mts from the

Page 58 of 75

Sea. The G.P.S. readings of the site is N 13 0 30. 799’, E 74 0 41. 211’ and the area is classified as CRZ-III as per approved CZMP. As per the documents produced it is in an extent of 0.59 acre of Sy. No. 212/3B. The site is fenced at sea front and on sides by concrete structures. The applicant has replied to the notice dated 29.06.2011 on 08.09.2011 and has claimed that there was old house bearing no 5-51 witb floor area of 1120 sq. ft in the name of Smt. Abbakka Marakalthi from whom he purchased the property on 04.05.2010 and also claims that the existing building was repaired because it was in dilapidated condition. The applicant does not belong to traditional coastal community as per the address furnished by him and he had also given old house photo as proof and Kota Grama Panchayath has given the tax paid receipt paid before 1991. As per the sale deed, the house was thirty years old and having 800 sq ft., plinth area built with wood, stone and mangalore tiled roof. He has demolished old building and built a new concrete building along with overhead water tank, concrete fencing at sea front and on sides, concrete flooring and shower bath provision and hence violated the CRZ norms. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 23.08.2012. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action

The RD submitted the proposal along with necessary documents and latest photos of the building and the surrounding area on 06.09.2012.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 29.02.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

15.7.13. Construction of upper floor to residential building at Sy. No. 6/5A1 of Kundapura Kasba Village, Kundapura by Sri. Raghavendra Kharvi S/o Purusha Kharvi - regarding (FEE 109 CRZ 2011).

Sri. Raghavendra Kharvi S/o Purusha Kharvi, Bahadur Sha road, Kundapura Kasba Village, Kundapura has constructed upper floor to his Page 59 of 75

residential building in Sy. No. 6/5A1 of Kundapura Kasba Village. The site falls in CRZ-I and no CRZ Clearance was given. The site was around 130m from main river and 60m from adjacent creek. As per CRZ Notification, 1991 and approved CZMP because of the river width>300m, CRZ jurisdiction was maximum of 150m. the applicant claims that the adjacent creek touching the main river belongs to Forest Department and there was shrimp pond and not to consider this creek as tidal influenced water body. On perusal of the documents submitted by the party the said land is 5 cents in Sy. No. 6/5A1 was converted for residential purpose vide D.C. Office letter dated:24.05.2002 and license for construction of farm house was granted by Kundapur Municipality vide order dated:17.01.1998. Hence, the present building with door no. 54-2B/III was built after the issue of CRZ Notification 1991 and being in CRZ-I is a case of violation. The RD issued notices to applicant on 07.12.2010, 11.02.2011 and 10.03.2011 and reply was received from the applicant on 01.04.2011 and was not acceptable as per the report submitted by the RD. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 23.08.2012. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with CZMP sheet, F.M.B. of Sy. No. 6 of Kundapura Kasba Village, draft digitized map showing the building.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 07.04.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to authorize the concerned the Regional Director to file a case in the jurisdictional court after conducting spot mahajar and recording statement of the violator. 15.7.14. Reconstruction of residential unit at Sy. No. 124/5Ap of Uppoor Village, Udupi Taluk by Sri. Joseph Suvaris S/o Pedru Suvaris - regarding (FEE 175 CRZ 2012).

Sri. Joseph Suvaris S/o Pedru Suvaris, ‘River View’, Heruru, Uppuru Village has reconstructed the residential unit [house no. 6-69(1)] at Sy. No. 124/5AP (0.06 acre) of Uppoor Village without prior CRZ Clearance. The G.P.S. readings of the site is N 13 0 24. 492’ E 74 0 44. 806’. The site is within 500 mts from Sea and Page 60 of 75

100 mts from River. The site is located at a distance of 20 mts from HTL of river and the area falls in NDZ of CRZ-III. The proposed building is about 900 sq. ft. area. There was a complaint from Sri. Thomas Suvaris that the above applicant has applied for CRZ Clearance giving false information and documents. RD concerned after examination has reported on 14.03.2013 that the above case is a violation of CRZ Notification 2011. The construction has taken place without prior CRZ Clearance. The PDO of Grama Panchayath has also reported that the said building has been constructed without the approval of Grama Panchayath and a building of nearly 1000 sq. ft. in area and is nearing completion in his letter dated:13.02.2013 addressed to RD. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 26.03.2013. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with Sy. Map of site, RTC, Tax assessment extract for the year 1980-81, grama panchayath certificate for the plinth area of the house, approved CZMP sheet, draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed construction and photo of old house.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 01.03.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

15.7.15. Reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 79/1B3 of Thenka Village, Udupi Taluk by Sri. Gunakara Shetty S/o Honnayya Shetty - regarding (FEE 119 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Gunakara Shetty S/o Honnayya Shetty, Alivekodi Mane, Yermal Thenka, Udupi Taluk has reconstructed residential house at Sy. No. 79/1B3 (0.08 acre), Thenka Village. The site falls in CRZ-III and is at a distance of 50 mts from Sea HTL and the plinth area of the building is 1020 Sq. ft. During site inspection it was found that the applicant has constructed a building of 1200 Sq. ft. instead of 1020 Sq. ft. The DCZMC in its meeting dated:23.11.2015 has decided to retain the

Page 61 of 75

old area of 1020 sq. ft existed prior to 1991 and ordered the concerned PDO to take action for demolishing the excess built up area vide order dated:27.11.2015. Since PDO has not taken any action to demolish the excess built up area. The DCZMC recommended to take necessary action against the concerned PDO and also regarding violation committed (NDZ of CRZ III of Notification).

The RD submitted the proposal along with RTC, Sy. Map of site, tax paid receipt for year 1977-78, documents for proof of old house, CZMP sheet, digitized map showing the building, photo of old house and building sketch.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 10.03.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to direct the concerned the Regional Director to issue final notices to the violator and concerned Panchayat Development Officer to remove the excess plinth area constructed and to report compliance to the authority.

15.7.16. Construction of fish peeling shed at Sy. No. 13/1P2 of Kodi Village, Udupi Taluk by Sri. K. Shankar Kundar S/o Narasimha Kanchan - regarding (FEE 221 CRZ 2012).

Sri. K. Shankar Kundar S/o Narasimha Kanchan, ‘Sri Devi Nilaya’, Kodi Kanyana, Udupi Taluk has set up a fish peeling shed at Sy. No. 13/1P2 of Kodi Village in an extent of 0.25 acre, taken on lease for 10 years from the owner Smt. Thungamma Marakalthi W/o Koosa Maraka, Kodi Village, Udupi Taluk. He has taken trade license No. 49/09-10 from Kodi Grama Panchayath which is under renewal. The aforesaid site is in CRZ III at about 20 Mts from the HTL of Sea, hence falls within NDZ of CRZ-III. As per provisions of CRZ notification 1991 and 2011 no new industries can be set up in area notified as CRZ. Hence establishment of fish peeling unit in CRZ area is a prohibited activity and hence the above activity is a violation of CRZ notification. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 03.12.2011. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

Page 62 of 75

The RD submitted the proposal along with RTC, copy of lease agreement, tax license no. 49/09-10, 22/2011-12, tax paid receipts dated 07.12.2010, 06.04.2011 and draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of construction.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 15.02.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue directions to concerned Regional Director to examine the present status of violation and if there is violation then to submit a report regarding which para of CRZ notification, 2011 has been violated. After placing the same in the District Committee.

15.7.17. Construction of building at Sy. No. 104 of Parampalli Village, Udupi Taluk by Sri. Dayananda Salian S/o Chandu Mendon - regarding (FEE 269 CRZ 2012).

Sri. Dayananda Salian S/o Chandu Mendon has set up fish cutting shed in agriculture land in Sy. No. 104 of Parampalli Village in the river bank. The said area (N 13 0 29. 356’ E 74 0 41. 751’) has been inspected by concerned RD. It lies adjacent to Kodi hole (Seethe nadi) at a distance of 20 mtr from the HTL of river on western side and touching a small creek on the northern side. A kaccha road has been made to the site disturbing the mangroves along the river. No new construction is permitted in CRZ-I except those enlisted in para 8 (i) I CRZ-I of the notification. The proposed agricultural shed or the alleged fish cutting shed is prohibited as per CRZ Notification 2011. The Chief Officer, Saligrama Town Panchayath has withdrawn the license granted for building agricultural shed and has directed to stop the construction work as per Karnataka Municipal Act 1964. There was no reply from the applicant for the notices issued by RD on 22.11.2012 and notice issued by Saligrama Town Panchayath on 09.11.2012, 26.09.2012 and 26.06.2012. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 28.11.2012. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

Page 63 of 75

The RD submitted the proposal along with copy of the Sale deed dated:12.06.2012, Sy. Map of the site, CZMP sheet, draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of violation and extract of the DCZMC meeting.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 29.02.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

15.7.18. Construction of building “Sagar Vandana” at Sy. No. 61/1 of Hejamadi Village, Udupi Taluk by Smt. Shanthi Ramesh Pai W/o Dr. Ramesh Pai - regarding (FEE 57 CRZ 2013).

Smt. Shanthi Ramesh Pai W/o Dr. Ramesh Pai, ‘Dev Ashish’, Lakshmindra Nagar, Indrali, Post Manipal has constructed the following in violation of CRZ guidelines in Maruthi Road, Hejamadi Village of Udupi Taluk.

• R.C.C. building of approximately 10m height – with ground floor area of 140 m 2 and first floor of 120m 2. • Small tiled roof building. • Swimming pool. • Compound wall.

The above site is 42m from the sea and falls within NDZ of CRZ-III and hence a notice was issued seeking records. In reply, Smt. Shanthi Ramesh Pai has stated that she along with her son Sri. Avinash Pai have bought 0.12 acre in Sy. No. 61/1 of Hejamadi Village by sale deed dated:10.06.2005, along with total extent of 65.60 cents in Sy. No. 61/2F, 61/1A, 61/1B, 61/2E. In her reply dated:12.11.2009 she claims that she has modernized the old house. But on verification of records, the old building was a godown which has been modified to residential nature without CRZ Clearance. The old house bearing House No. 9- 19 was in the name of Smt. Sharada in the sale deed dated 10.06.2005 and there is no mention of old building in the sale deed. The Panchayath has issued license

Page 64 of 75

for construction of 47.60 sq. mt. of building. It is found that the plinth area has been exceeded beyond the area mentioned in sanctioned plan. As per CRZ notification 1991 there is provision for repair of authorized building not exceeding the existing plinth area and not for reconstruction. New construction of structures as above and reconstruction exceeding the plinth area, modifying the godown building to residential purpose is clear case of violation. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 03.12.2011. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action. The RD submitted the proposal along with CZMP sheet, draft CRZ map showing the site of violation, abstract copy of DCZMC proceeding held on 03.12.2011 and photos of building.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 29.02.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

15.7.19. Construction of residential house at Sy. No. 12/1B1 of Kodi Village, Udupi Taluk by Sri. Aitha Thingalaya S/o Bedu Marakala - regarding (FEE 118 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Aitha Thingalaya S/o Bedu Marakala, ‘Sri Shanka’, Kodikanyana Post, Udupi Taluk has constructed a residential house in Kodi Village Sy. No. 12/1B1 (0.05 acre out of 0.62 acres) without obtaining prior CRZ Clearance. The G.P.S. readings of the site is N 13 0 29’ 10.0’ E 74 0 41’ 21.5’. The site is at 110 mts from HTL of Sea. Records are sought from the applicant and on verification of records it is found that the applicant has constructed the house obtaining license from the Panchayath. The issue was placed in DCZMC meeting held on 23.11.2015 and it was decided to instruct the concerned PDO to withdraw the license issued and demolish the violated portion of the building. Since no action was taken by PDO, the subject was again placed in DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016 and further Page 65 of 75

recommended for initiating necessary action against the concerned PDO for not following the directions of DCZMC and also for action against violation committed (NDZ of CRZ III of Notification).

The RD submitted the proposal on 03.03.2016 along with RTC, Sy. Map of site, CZMP sheet, draft digitized map of the area, building sketch, photos and license of Grama Panchayaths.

15.7.20. Reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 25/10-B of Paduthonse Village, Udupi Taluk by Sri. Mohan Mokashi and Meera Hudhar - regarding (FEE 11 CRZ 2013).

Sri. B. Rajeev Shetty S/o Shivarama Shetty, 11-2-70E, ‘Padmaja’, Pragathinagaram, Upupi-576101 (GPA Holder of Smt. Meera Hudhar W/o Aruna Hudhar, No. 54, ‘B’ Cross, Alens Layout, Ashwath Nagar, Bangalore-560094 has applied seeking CRZ Clearance for re-construction of residential house no. II-219 in Sy. No. 25/10-B of Paduthonse Village. The said land of 0.48 acre was purchased from Thukaram Salian and others by Sri. Mohan Mokashi and Meera Hudhar with a dilapidated tiled house building measuring about 300 sq. ft. plinth area. The owners approached RD’s office through a GPA holder seeking CRZ Clearance for re-construction of the building. The G.P.S. readings of the site is N 13 0 24. 406’ E 74 0 41. 908’ and the site falls within NDZ of CRZ-III and the building was prior to 1991. CRZ Clearance was issued on site inspection for reconstruction not exceeding the plinth area (300 sq. ft) subject to being traditional coastal community. On site inspection it was found that a huge building (more than 1000 sq. ft plinth area) was being constructed with compound wall on all sides. Hence, a notice was issued to applicant and when no reply was received from him, CRZ Clearance issued earlier was withdrawn. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 28.11.2012. The DCZMC recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

Page 66 of 75

The RD submitted the proposal along with copy of letter of Thonse Grama Panchayath, coy of show cause notice dated:28.09.2012, CZMP sheet, draft digitized map showing the area of violation, extract of the DCZMC meeting and photos of newly constructed building.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 15.02.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

15.7.21. Construction of residential building at Sy. No. 212/2B of Kotathattu Village, Udupi Taluk by Smt. Vijayavani W/o Srinivas - regarding (FEE 137 CRZ 2013).

Smt. Vijayavani W/o Srinivas, No. 201, 68 th Cross, 5 th Block, Rajaji Nagar, Bangalore has constructed residential building at Sy. No. 212/2B (0.58 acre) near the sea shore flouting the CRZ norms. The site of construction is around 50 mts from Sea (N 13 0 30. 811, E 74 0 41. 215’) and the area is classified as CRZ-III as per approved CZMP. The site is fenced at sea front and on sides by concrete structures. There is newly built overhead tank, outside shower bath, concrete flooring has been completed on the passage. The owner claims that there was an old house bearing door no. 5-53 with floor area of 800 sq. ft in the name of Manja Marakala from who she purchased that property on 28.05.2009, and she claims that the existing door no. 5-32 was repaired because of its dilapidated condition for which neither gramapanchayath permission nor CRZ Clearance was obtained. There is an entry of farm house in sale deed document with a mention of 1500 sq. ft. with mud and laterite wall. Smt. Vijayavani does not belong to the traditional coastal community as per the address furnished by the concerned. In addition, overhead water tank and concrete fencing at sea front and on either sides, concrete flooring are new structures built. Hence this case qualifies as violation. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 23.08.2012. The DCZMC

Page 67 of 75

recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with latest photographs, CZMP sheet and draft digitized map showing the site.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 29.02.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

15.7.22. Construction of building at Sy. No. 289/309 of Kodavoor Village, Udupi Taluk by M/s. Paradise Isle Beach Resort - regarding (FEE 64 CRZ 2003).

M/s. Paradise Isle Beach Resort has constructed buildings at Kodavuru Village, Udupi Taluk in violation of CRZ notification 1991 and the buildings are in operation. As per the applicants letter dated 26.08.2011 the ownership of this place is in the name of KSTDC and one building was constructed in 1986. As per the decision of the State Government and as per the agreement between KSTDC and Brigade Gardens, Bangalore the place was transferred in the year 2002 to Brigade Gardens. The KSTDC has constructed a Beach Resort at Malpe Beach much prior to 1991 CRZ Notification in Sy. No. 289/309 of Kodavoor Village of Udupi Taluk which is in CRZ-III NDZ area. It was not fully completed and now it was given on lease to M/s Paradise Isle Beach Resort, Bangalore. Since the work of construction of this building commenced much before the CRZ Notification, 1991, completing the unfinished work as per the original sanctioned plan and license is not a Violation of CRZ Notification. But as seen on the ground, the lessee has constructed additional paragola type RCC structures to the north of this building in Sy. No. 319 of Kodavoor Village, which is in CRZ-III NDZ areas and it amounts to violation of CRZ notification. Necessary records was sought from KSTDC, but full information and records are not yet furnished by KSTDC. The issue was deliberated in DCZMC meeting held on 23.08.2012. The DCZMC

Page 68 of 75

recommended the case as CRZ Violation and requested for further necessary action.

The RD submitted the proposal along with necessary documents.

Further, latest report regarding the violation was received from the concerned RD on 01.03.2016 and in this report violation was confirmed again along with latest photo of the structures.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue direction to concerned Regional Director to submit a status report of the structures exesting prior to 1991 and structures constructed after 1991 till date for taking appropriate decision by the Authority.

15.7.23. Reconstruction of building at Sy. No. 20-1, 20-2 and 20-3 of Bolur Village, Mangalore by M/s Yenepoya Moideen Kunhi and Co., - regarding (FEE 1059 CRZ 2014).

M/s. Yenepoya Moideen Kunhi and Co. had requested for the postfacto approval of the re-construction made in Sy.No. 20-1, 20-2 and 20-3 of Bolur Village, Mangalore. RD had reported that the building existed since 1958 was about to be collapsed during the Monsoon in the year 2008. The building was therefore re-constructed. RD inspected the spot and recommended for issue of CRZ Clearance as there were old structures on either side of the renovated building and the area is classified as CRZ-II. The KSCZMA in its meeting held on 27.11.2009 had asked the occupier to submit the details of the built up area of the old building, built up area of the renovated/reconstructed building and the permissions obtained for such renovation/reconstruction. The issue was again discussed in the DCZMC meeting held on 15.09.2014 and the committee have decided to address letters to the concerned departments and officers for further necessary action. The occupier appeared before the Authority during the meeting held on 28.05.2015 and explained the circumstance under which the renovation was done. The RD reported that the occupier is dumping waste from the sawmill and polluting the adjacent river in violation of the provisions of para 3 (V) (VI) and (VII). The Authority in its meeting held on 28.05.2015, decided to get a site inspection report from the Deputy Commissioner, Dakshina Kanada about the

Page 69 of 75

latest status of the land use and violations if any. Further, the Authority also decided to get report on next course of action to be initiated in case of any violations. Letter was addressed to DC, Mangalore on 18.09.2015, but no inspection report has been received from DC.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to direct and authorize the concerned Regional Director to file a case as per the Section 19 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 after conducting spot mahazar and recording statement of the violator.

15.7.24. Construction of residential house at Sy. No. 2/16 of Sasihithlu Village, Mangalore Taluk by Dr. Dayas - regarding (FEE 76 CRZ 2004).

Dr. Dayas has constructed a residential house during 2002 at Sy. No. 2/16 at Sasihithlu Village Mangalore Taluk, Dakshina Kannada District in violation of provisions of CRZ Notification since the building in question comes under CRZ-I. The building is located at a distance of 60m from HTL. The construction includes one RCC house (of area 112.96 Sqm). Total area is 126.46 Sqm. The RD has inspected the site along with the Office Surveyor on 23.09.2005, the RCC Building at Sy. No. 2/16 Sasihithlu Village, Mangalore Taluk, Dakshina Kannada District having total built up area of 126.46 sq.mtrs located at a distance of 60 mtrs from the HTL of Sea towards south and at a distance of 180 mtrs from the HTL of Pavanje River towards east is constructed by Dr. Lionel Dias is in violation of the provisions of the CRZ notification. As per the CZMP of Karnataka approved by MoEF, GoI vide letter dated:27.09.1996 the above said area come under CRZ-I and as per the para 6(2) under marginal heading CRZ-I of CRZ notification no new construction shall be permitted in CRZ-I except those mentioned there under and construction of the RCC building by applicant is an activity in violation of the said CRZ notification. The report submitted by RD dated:21.08.2006 states that he had inspected the site and that a RCC building measuring (1361 sq.ft) 126.46 sq.mtr was newly constructed and it comes under CRZ-I & that the CRZ notification has been violated. The issue was discussed in the KSCZMA meeting held on 30.01.2008. The Authority decided to issue directions to DC & RD, Mangalore to inspect and take action to demolish the violation if any, especially with regards to the newly constructed building which comes under CRZ-I and Page 70 of 75

accordingly directions were issued to DC and RD, Mangalore on 09.04.2008, but no report has been received from DC and RD, Mangalore regarding demolition of building.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue direction to the concerned Deputy Commissioner to take credible action as per the directions already issued by the Authority during its meeting held on 30.01.2008.

15.7.25. Construction of bridge across the Gurupura River of Tannirbhavi Village by Mangalore Mahanagara Palike - regarding (FEE 86 CRZ 2009).

Sri. Lawrence D’souza has given a complaint that Mangalore Mahanagara Palike has unlawfully constructed a bridge across the Gurupura River of Tannirbhavi Village, Mangalore Taluk. The said place falls under CRZ-I as per the CRZ notification. In this regard, AEO, RO Office, KSPCB and RD (Env) have made spot inspection and have made report of the same to the Commissioner of Mahanagara Palike Office, Mangalore to stop the construction work and to take the CRZ Clearance. The concerned DC, RD and Regional Office, KSPCB have been requested to take action under Section 19 of Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, but no report has been received from DC, RD and Regional Office, KSPCB, Mangalore.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to direct the concerned Regional Director to obtain a proposal from Mangalore Mahanagara Palike for the above project and to submit for consideration of the Authority.

15.8 Payment of sitting fees for KSCZMA members as per Government of India - reg

In the KSCZMA meeting held on 11.06.2014, the following points were brought to the notice of the Authority.

1. DFEE is making a payment of sitting fees of Rs. 1500 with TA/DA to the members as per the G.O No. FEE 39 CRZ 2014 dated 05.05.2014.

Page 71 of 75

2. As per the Order No. F.No. J-15012/1/2005-1AI, dated 14.06.2010 by The MoEF, Government of India, there is provision for payment of honorarium of Rs. 3000/- per day for the Non-official members/co-opted experts/independent nominated expert attending the committee meetings/site visits and road mileage as per Government Rules. 3. The Government of Andhra Pradesh vide G.O dated 17.02.2009 has enhanced the sitting charges to Rs. 3000/- per day besides TA/DA excluding local conveyance and accommodation to the Chairman and members of SEIAA and SEAC. 4. The Boards and corporations such as KSPCB, KIADB, EMPRI etc are paying sitting fees of Rs. 1000 to the official members also and that there is a request from DCZMC members for enhancing their sitting fees to Rs. 1000/- from the existing Rs. 250/-.

After deliberation, the Authority had decided to provide a sitting fees of Rs. 3000/- (excluding TA/DA as applicable) for both official and non official members of the KSCZMA and to issue necessary G.O in this regard.

Further the Authority also decided to provide sitting fees of Rs. 1000/- (excluding TA/DA as applicable) for official and non-official members of DCZMC and to issue necessary G.O in this regard.

This proposal was submitted to Finance Department for concurrence before issuing necessary Government Order. But the Finance Department vide its Note No. FD 49 expenditure -5/2016 dated 20.05.2016 (in the file No. FEE 931 CRZ 2014) has rejected the proposal stating that the sitting fees of non-official members of the Authority has been revised vide order dated 05.05.2014 and there is no proper justification to revise the same again and the revision done in 2013 is proper.

The Authority noted the opinion of Finance Department dated 20.05.2016 (on the file No. FEE 931 CRZ 2014) regarding the payment of sitting fees for KSCZMA Members.

15.9 Delegation of powers to DCZMC to take decision regarding reconstruction/repairs of residential buildings and also regarding violation cases pertaining to residential buildings.

The Authority after discussion decided that the issue of Provisional CRZ Clearance for construction/re-construction/repairs of dwelling units in CRZ- II & CRZ III( 200 to 500m) area and outside CRZ limits shall be decided appropriately Page 72 of 75

as per Rules at DCZMC itself and the action taken shall be reported to Authority for ratification.

Similarly the Authority also decided to authorize the DCZMC to consider and take appropriate action as per Rules regarding CRZ violation cases regarding residential buildings and the action taken shall be reported to KSCZMA for ratification.

15.10 Other issues discussed

Authority after deliberation decided to make all correspondence in Kannada the official language of Government of Karnataka Accordingly the followings decision were taken.

1. Translate all formats in to Kannada. 2. Request MoEF & CC to incorporate Kannada Language in their portal, which is going to be lannched for processing of CRZ application from next month.

The meeting ended with thanks to the Chair.

Sd/-

(T.M. Vijaya Bhaskar) Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Forest, Ecology & Environment Department & Chairman, Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority.

No. FEE 236 CRZ 2013

Special Director (Technical Cell) & Secretary, KSCZMA Forest, Ecology and Environment Department.

Page 73 of 75

Meeting of the 15 th Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority (KSCZMA) held on 08.07.2016 at 11.00 A.M. at Room No. 253, 2 nd Floor, 2 nd Gate, M. S. Building, Bengaluru under the chairmanship of Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Forest, Ecology & Environment Department.

LIST OF MEMBERS/OFFICERS PRESENT

1. Sri T.M. Vijaya Bhaskar IAS., Chairman, KSCZMA & Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Present Department of Forest, Ecology & Environment, M S Building, Bangalore – 560 001 2. Joint Secretary to Government, Tourism Department, Present Vikasa Soudha Bangalore. 3. Deputy Director, Industries and Commerce Department, Present Vikasa Soudha, Bangalore 4. Sri. Ramachandhra, IFS, Secretary to Govt. (Ecology & Environment) Present Forest, Ecology and Environment Department Bangalore- 560 001. 5. Sri. S.Shanthappa, IFS., Member Secretary, Karnataka State Pollution Control Board, Present No. 49, Parisara Bhavan, Church Street, Bangalore- 560 001. 6. Sri. Saswathi Mishra, CCF & Director, Environment Management and Policy Research Institute (EMPRI), Present Hasiru Bhavana', Doresanipalya Forest Campus, Vinayaka Nagara Circle, J. P. Nagar, 5th Phase, Bangalore-560 076. 7. Sri. Veerappa Gowda H.S. Director, Present Animal Husbandry and Fisheries Department. 8. Dr. Shridhara, Scientist, Karnataka State Remote Sensing Application Centre, Present KSRSAC, BMTC-Central Office Building TTMC ‘B’ Block, 4th Foor, Shanthinagar, KH Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

Page 74 of 75

9. Dr. B.K. Shivaprasad Rai, Consultant Surgeon and former Commandant of Home Guards, - Shourya, Martin Pais Road, Hat Hill, Bejai Post, Mangalore-575004. 10. Dr. Subba Rao, Professor Department of Applied Mechanics and Hydraulics, - National Institute of Technology, Karnataka, Suratkal, Manalore. 11. Dr. Gangadhara Gowda Professor and Head, - Aquatic Environment Management Department, College of Fisheries, Mangalore. 12. Dr. K.S. Jayappa Professor, Department of Marine Geology, Present Mangalore University, Mangala Gangothri, Mangalore. 13. Sri Vijayakumar, IFS., Special Director (Technical Cell) and Secretary, Present Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority, Forest, Ecology and Environment Department. 14. Regional Director (Environment), Forest, Ecology & Environment Department, Present Corporation Commercial Complex, I Floor, Lalbagh, Mangalore-575 003. 15. Regional Director (Environment), Forest, Ecology & Environment Department, 1st Floor, C Block, Rajathadri, Present District Administrative Centre, Manipal- 576104, Udupi District. 16. Regional Director (Environment), Forest, Ecology & Environment Department, Meera Building, I Floor, Kajubagh, Karwar, Present Uttara Kannada District.

** *** **

Page 75 of 75