OMFIF Bulletin Global Insight on Official Monetary and Financial

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

OMFIF Bulletin Global Insight on Official Monetary and Financial OMFIFOMFIF BULLETIN GlobalOfficial MonetaryInsight on and Official Monetary and Financial Institutions Financial Institutions Forum September 2012 Race against time for the euro Beyond ECB action, we need political will Frank Scheidig, Deputy Chairman, Advisory Board e are still waiting for a cure recession-hit south, could over time for some kind of official financing for Wfor the woes of economic and lead to a calming of financial markets. Spain and conceivably, too, for Italy in monetary union (EMU). Necessary The problem is that, left to their own coming months. steps have been put into place by devices, the markets will take fright at European governments to improve the large volume of financing that still The fate of Greece can be expected to euro area decision-making. A start is has to be done for the under-performing dominate Europe’s political calendar, being made in healing the worst of the south in the next few months. but the real story focuses on the third intra-EMU economic imbalances. But and fourth economies of the euro area. this is a race against time. Given the scale of the current and The conditionality advanced by the capital account imbalances that still European Central Bank is useful and A rebalancing of European need to be financed, and the sharp necessary, but beyond that we need economies, with the relatively better- rise in bond market interest rates for political will to put taxpayers’ money performing northern economies losing the most heavily exposed countries, on the table to forestall excessive competitiveness against the necessarily Italy and Spain, there is no substitute behaviour. (continued on page 8 ...) Conflicting signals from Berlin: ingenuous chaos meets ingenious ambiguity The ebb and flow of bad economic news has wreaked havoc on European yield curves, but the Anglo- American camp is more riled about conflicting signals from Germany and the lack of decisive steps to end the crisis, writes Michael Burda, Advisory Board, from Berlin. Chancellor Angela Merkel, in contrast, insists on petit pas and quid pro quos. (continued on page 8...) ContentsContents ChallengesChallenges forfor centralcentral banksbanks PhilPhil MiddletonMiddleton 33 US politics rules BanksBanks andand thethe newnew environmentenvironment MichaelMichael LaffertyLafferty 55 Beijing may react LongLong shadowshadow ofof EuropeanEuropean crisiscrisis JamesJames BullardBullard 66 Kishore Mahbubani, Singapore Structural,Structural, social,social, greengreen AngelAngel GurríaGurría 99 CautiousCautious approachapproach onon growthgrowth StefanStefan BielmeierBielmeier 108 he decision by the New York State Department of Financial China’sChina's nextnext reformreform phasephase LindaLinda YuehYueh 1111 TServices to make public its strictures against the UK bank Standard Chartered could spark off similarly heavy-handed GuideGuide toto marketmarket sentimentsentiment AllanAllan LaneLane 1313 action by China. MonetaryMonetary lawlessnesslawlessness onon riserise BrendanBrendan BrownBrown 1515 DutchDutch SocialistsSocialists toto thethe forefore RoelRoel JanssenJanssen 1717 Benjamin Lawsky, the department’s superintendent, should EuroEuro moneymoney supplysupply boostboost neededneeded GabrielGabriel SteinStein 1919 have considered the possibility that his action may encourage Beijing to use its growing economic clout to take similar Debate on stimulus grows sharper Darrell Delamaide 24 Debate on stimulus grows sharper Darrell Delamaide 24 unilateral action against US banks. OMFIFOMFIF AdvisoryAdvisory BoardBoard 2626 MomentumMomentum dropsdrops worldwideworldwide StatisticalStatistical forecastforecast 2929 Lawsky’s decision to go after Standard Chartered appears to have been driven by domestic political considerations, not by TheThe shiftshift toto externalexternal lawyerslawyers PoomaPooma KimisKimis 3131 the merits of the case. In the US political climate, anyone who HighHigh stakesstakes inin euroeuro dramadrama MichaelMichael KaimakliotisKaimakliotis 3232 stands up to Iran is a hero. The superintendent has enhanced ArchiveArchive InsightInsight GermanGerman bondbond spreespree 3434 his reputation. Dow’sDow's lessonlesson ofof pastpast recessionsrecessions WilliamWilliam KeeganKeegan 3636 Additionally, he has undermined the move to create global co-operation among financial regulators. Finance is not ThisThis documentdocument mustmust notnot bebe copiedcopied a domestic industry. The only way to regulate it is through OMFIFOMFIF andand isis onlyonly toto bebe mademade availableavailable OfficialOfficial MonetaryMonetary andand FinancialFinancial InstitutionsInstitutions ForumForum toto OMFIFOMFIF members,members, prospectiveprospective global norms and processes. However, New York’s unilateral membersmembers andand partnerpartner organisationsorganisations decision has further undermined confidence in American judgments. (continued on page 8 ...) www.omfif.org 1 OMFIF 2012-09_08.indd 1 8/30/2012 10:02:06 AM OMFIF Official Monetary and Financial Institutions Forum Letter from the chairman Official Monetary and Financial Institutions Forum Tensions in the air One Lyric Square London W6 0NB United Kingdom September – when things happen t: +44 (0)20 3008 8415 f: +44 (0)20 3008 5262 David Marsh, Chairman Advisory Board Meghnad Desai entral bankers and market participants return from their holidays with a sense *Chairman, Advisory Board Cthat something is about to happen. The tensions in the air – whether over the euro debt crisis, the US presidential elections or the slowdown in the Chinese economy – are John Nugée Frank Scheidig palpable. September is often the time, on foreign exchange and capital markets as well Songzuo Xiang as in the wider political arena, when the ‘balloon goes up.’ ** Deputy Chairmen, Advisory Board (see p. 26-28 for more details) In this edition, coinciding with the annual DZ Bank-OMFIF central banking seminar, this Management Board time in Berlin, Frank Scheidig calls on his native Germany to take greater responsibility David Marsh for the euro area as a whole. Official financing is a necessity for peripheral countries Chairman under great strain from economic rebalancing. Michael Burda says Angela Merkel's [email protected] tactics remind him of a Grimm fairy-tale. Roel Janssen looks at prospects for a change of Michael Lafferty government and shift to the left in the Netherlands, the No. 2 creditor in the euro area Deputy Chairman [email protected] after Germany, and asks what this means for consensus on euro area economic reform. Gabriel Stein Chief Economic Adviser Michael Kaimakliotis outlines the pressure on the Swiss authorities to hold the peg [email protected] against the euro in the face of massive upward foreign exchange pressure on the Swiss franc. Gabriel Stein analyses whether the European Central Bank is serious about Evelyn Hunter-Jordan [email protected] money, pointing to the disappointingly slugging growth in broad money since the worst of the financial crisis. Brendan Brown ponders on the implications of what he sees as a John Plender [email protected] rise in ‘monetary lawlessness’ in Europe and the US. Allan Lane explains how Exchange Traded Funds can offer a way out of uncertainty. OMFIF Secretariat Edward Longhust-Pierce Angel Gurría, secretary-general of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Dalin Hamilton Vikram Lopez Development, sets out the OECD’s plans to get economies moving again, including Nikolai Blackie through ‘green growth’. James Bullard of the Federal Reserve Bank of St Louis expounds [email protected] [email protected] on how the euro crisis has a deeper impact on the world economy and offers suggestions [email protected] for remedial action. We take an in-depth look at China. Linda Yueh points to the need [email protected] for a new phase of outward Chinese investment that will direct foreign technology Sanjay Ujoodia flows into the country, but says the authorities will take their time over renminbi Chief Financial Officer internationalisation. Stefan Bielmeier says the Chinese remain cautious on economic [email protected] +44 (0)20 3008 8421 stimulus measures and Beijing will not match the heady pace of recovery in 2009-10. Darrell Delamaide US Editor Darrell Delamaide in his monthly round-up on the Fed surveys growing evidence that [email protected] the US will move into easing mode in coming weeks, with the public ‘hawks v. doves’ +1 (0)202 248 1561 debate between Federal Open Market Committee members sharpening in tone. Phil Sales Middleton gives details on a new report by Ernst & Young and OMFIF on the changing Pooma Kimis Christopher Goodwin shape of international central banks, due to be launched in coming weeks. [email protected] On the vexed issue of banking and financial market irregularities, Kishore Mahbubani [email protected] says heavy-handed American action over Standard Chartered risks encouraging Thomas Heap China to take similar retaliatory action over US and other banks. Michael Lafferty Production Editor [email protected] warns emerging market economies with new outward-facing regimes against adopting western-style integrated banking systems. Pooma Kimis reports on how many banks and Strictly no photocopying is permitted. It is illegal to reproduce, store in a central retrieval system or transmit, financial firms are replacing in-house lawyers with external legal advisors, throwing electronically or otherwise, any of the
Recommended publications
  • DEFENDING the WOLF the Useful Contradiction of the Bundesbank Carlo Bastasin
    DEFENDING THE WOLF The Useful Contradiction of the Bundesbank Carlo Bastasin SEP Policy Brief No. 1 - 2014 The Deutsche Bundesbank, the German central bank, is commonly regarded as the Euroarea's boogeyman. The pressure imparted by the German monetary authority, for instance, rendered the European Central Bank reluctant to follow the footprints of the Federal Reserve and of other central banks, and engage in non- standard monetary policy measures that might rapidly put an end to the crisis that has been plaguing the euro zone. At several stages, during the current crisis, the ECB has been forced to take actions and prevent severe economic and financial dislocations. Given the institutional vacuum at the area-wide level and the lack of political capacity of the other institutions, the European Central Bank had often to move across the borders of its traditional domain. This has given reason to a slew of criticisms repeatedly and loudly voiced by the Bundesbank. Being also the most vocal policy actor evoking the fiscal risks associated with effecting implicit cross-border transfers via the ECB's balance sheet, the Bundesbank has appeared to have a “non- monetary” hidden agenda or even a “national political” mission. In fact, the Bundesbank has regularly appealed to two fundamental principles of sound economic and monetary policy management that cannot be easily overlooked by anybody concerned that monetary policy may lose its ability to preserve price stability. Should monetary independence be eroded by the increasing tasks devolved to the central banks, wider economic and political consequences might then arise. The first principle is the need to avoid fiscal dominance, not allowing inflation to be determined by the level of fiscal debts; the second is the “principle of responsibility” that sees a contradiction if individual responsibility is blurred by the intervention of joint liability as in the case of a State running unsound fiscal policies and being automatically bailed out by the mutualization of its liabilities.
    [Show full text]
  • Mr. Tietmeyer Reviews the Central Bank Council of the Deutsche Bundesbank on Its 50Th Anniversary Address Delivered by the President of the Deutsche Bundesbank, Prof
    Mr. Tietmeyer reviews the Central Bank Council of the Deutsche Bundesbank on its 50th anniversary Address delivered by the President of the Deutsche Bundesbank, Prof. Hans Tietmeyer, during the ceremony marking the 50th anniversary of the first meeting of the Central Bank Council at the Land Central Bank of Hesse in Frankfurt/Main on 5/3/98. On March 8, 1948, eleven men gathered next door in the building of the then Land Central Bank of Hesse. The Central Bank Council - which at that time was still “provisional” - of the Bank deutscher Länder, which had been established on March 1, was meeting for the first time. An American officer of the Allied Banking Commission (appropriately named Mr. Freeman) convened the first meeting at 10.30 a.m. There will be quite a few fiftieth anniversaries in the coming weeks and months occasioned by the flood of major events relating to Germany which took place in 1948 and 1949. Many of these events were certainly more dramatic and spectacular than the first meeting of the Central Bank Council. Yet, if we remember this meeting now, it is because a crucial decision for the future began to take shape at that time. If that which was begun on March 8, 1948 had not met with success, the history of the D-Mark (and perhaps also the history of our country) would have taken a different course. It is true that the preparations for the introduction of the D-Mark were carried out elsewhere and by others, particularly by the Allies themselves. Yet, with monetary reform on June 20, when the first D-Mark banknotes came into circulation, the fate of the new currency began to be linked to the viability and the stability orientation of the German Central Bank Council.
    [Show full text]
  • The Bundesbank Ellen Kennedy
    Key Institutions of German Democracy Number 4 THE BUNDESBANK ELLEN KENNEDY GERMAN ISSUES 19 American Institute for Contemporary German Studies The Johns Hopkins University THE BUNDESBANK ELLEN KENNEDY GERMAN ISSUES 19 The American Institute for Contemporary German Studies (AICGS) is a center for advanced research, study, and discussion on the politics, culture, and society of the Federal Republic of Germany. Established in 1983 and affiliated with The Johns Hopkins University but governed by its own Board of Trustees, AICGS is a privately incorporated institute dedicated to independent, critical, and comprehensive analysis and assessment of current German issues. Its goals are to help develop a new generation of American scholars with a thorough understanding of contemporary Germany, deepen American knowledge and understanding of current German developments, contribute to American policy analysis of problems relating to Germany, and promote interdisciplinary and comparative research on Germany. Executive Director: Jackson Janes Research Director: Carl Lankowski Director of Development: William S. Stokes IV Board of Trustees, Cochair: Steven Muller Board of Trustees, Cochair: Harry J. Gray The views expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) alone. They do not necessarily reflect the views of the American Institute for Contemporary German Studies. ©1998 by the American Institute for Contemporary German Studies ISBN 0-941441-17-2 ISSN 1041-9810 Additional copies of this AICGS German Issue are available from the American Institute for Contemporary German Studies, Suite 420, 1400 16th Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036-2217. Telephone 202/332-9312, Fax 202/265-9531, E-mail: [email protected], Web: http://www.aicgs.org ii FOREWORD Professor Ellen Kennedy’s short study is the fourth in the Institute’s series on key institutions of German democracy.
    [Show full text]
  • German Monetary Policy in the Second Half of the Twentieth Century
    German Monetary History in the Second Half of the Twentieth Century: From the Deutsche Mark to the Euro Robert L. Hetzel tarting in January 2002, citizens of the European Monetary Union (EMU) replaced their national currencies with the Euro, issued by the S European Central Bank (ECB). Europeans created a new pan-European central bank as a symbol of a future united Europe. However, what historical process explains the broad monetary policy of the ECB, that is, its objective of price stability and its strategy for achieving that objective? The short answer is that its founders designed the ECB to look like the Bundesbank. How then did the Bundesbank evolve? To answer that question, I survey German monetary policy in the second half of the twentieth century. I divide this history into three main sections.1 The first treats the Bretton Woods system of fixed exchange rates. The second treats the floating exchange rate period that began in 1973. It chronicles the Bundesbank’s ultimate deci- sion to accord primacy to reducing inflation rather than unemployment. The last explains how the Bundesbank dealt with the pressures created by move- ment toward a single European currency. The evolution of the Bundesbank into an institution now identified as a modern central bank is fundamental to the article. A modern central bank This article follows Hetzel (2002), which summarizes German monetary policy in the first half of the twentieth century. The author gratefully acknowledges helpful comments from Michael Dotsey, Martin M. Fase, Andreas Hornstein, Thomas Humphrey, Joachim Scheide, and Alex Wolman. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond or the Federal Reserve System.
    [Show full text]
  • Presseinformationen 60 Jahre Deutsche Bundesbank
    Presseinformationen 60 Jahre Deutsche Bundesbank © Deutsche Bundesbank © Image Source/Corbis © Wolfilser – Fotolia © Deutsche Bundesbank Presseinformationen 60 Jahre Deutsche Bundesbank Seite 2 Inhaltsverzeichnis 1. Die Aufgaben der Deutschen Bundesbank 2. Daten zum rechtlichen Rahmen der Deutschen Bundesbank von 1948 bis 2016 3. Die Präsidenten der Deutschen Bundesbank 4. Stimmen aus Wissenschaft und Politik 5. Die Deutsche Bundesbank in Zahlen 6. Wussten Sie,… 7. Terminplan der Veranstaltungen im Jubiläumsjahr Presseinformationen 60 Jahre Deutsche Bundesbank Seite 3 Die Aufgaben der Deutschen Bundesbank Presseinformationen 60 Jahre Deutsche Bundesbank Seite 4 Die Deutsche Bundesbank nimmt als unabhängige geld- und währungspolitische Institution sowie als nationale und europäische Aufsichtsinstanz viele Aufgaben rund um das Thema Geld wahr. Gemeinsam mit der Europäischen Zentralbank und den anderen Zentralbanken des Eurosystems trägt sie Verantwortung für die Geldpolitik im Euro-Raum. Der Präsident der Bundesbank wirkt als Mitglied des EZB-Rats an den geldpolitischen Entscheidungen mit. Als Grundlage für die Entschei- dungsfindung erstellt die Bundesbank umfassende Analysen. Die Umsetzung der Geldpolitik ist in Deutschland Aufgabe der Bundesbank. Außerdem erläutert sie der deutschen Öffentlichkeit die Geldpolitik des Eurosystems und bezieht Position dazu. Neben der Beteiligung an der Geldpolitik erfüllt die Bundesbank weitere wichtige Aufgaben auf nationaler und internationaler Ebene. Eine dieser Kernaufgaben ist die Bankenaufsicht. Um
    [Show full text]
  • OMFIF Bulletin Global Insight on Official Monetary and Financial Institutions
    OMFIF BULLETIN Global Insight on Official Monetary and Financial Institutions January 2013 Abe relies on BoJ arm-twisting Growth plans aimed at securing power in upper house Shumpei Takemori, Advisory Board hinzo Abe, the new Japanese would be the last major poll for three as planned in December. Enacting the Sprime minister, is relying on Bank years, would enable the prime minister measure depends on Japan’s economic of Japan (BoJ) arm-twisting and big to pursue pet projects like rewriting the condition in the second quarter of public spending measures amounting Japanese constitution. 2013. In the event of a major slump, the to Y11tn to provide sufficient Government would probably decide to momentum to win crucial elections Abe has little substance to offer. withdraw the tax increase. in the upper house of the Japanese His growth strategy was patched parliament this summer. together at the last minute before Since 2005, the life expectancy of a the December election. He appears Japanese prime minister has been less Following victory for his Liberal confident of the success of his magic than a year. The ‘pro-growth’ LDP in fact Democratic Party (LDP) in December’s formula: pressure on the Bank of Japan has a miserable record. For 18 years lower house elections, Abe needs to governor to raise its inflation target and when it was in power, from 1990 to secure a majority in the upper house, print more money. These short-term 2007, Japan’s average nominal growth too, to prevent politics becoming utterly measures will have long-term effects, was a mere 0.8%.
    [Show full text]
  • “A Somewhat Awful Procedure”: Otmar Emminger, the West German Bundesbank, and the Final Days of Bretton Woods (1968-1973)
    1 “A Somewhat Awful Procedure”: Otmar Emminger, the West German Bundesbank, and the Final Days of Bretton Woods (1968-1973) Mark Gyourko Undergraduate Thesis Department of History Columbia University April 17, 2020 Seminar Advisor: Elisheva Carlebach Second Reader: Volker Berghahn 2 Table of Contents Acknowledgements 3 Introduction 4 Chapter 1: West Germany in Bretton Woods 13 Chapter 2: Emminger and the Unraveling 22 Chapter 3: Temporary Break or New Normal? 33 Conclusion 41 Bibliography 43 Appendix: Monetary Policy Primer 46 3 Acknowledgments I am fortunate to have had the support of many wonderful people in reaching the finish line of my undergraduate education. First and foremost, I want to thank the friends and family whose love and encouragement kept me going during the most difficult moments of my senior year, time at Columbia, and college experience, more broadly. The past six years have been a wild ride, and I am very lucky to have loved ones whose faith in me could always be counted on as a source of inspiration. I am also tremendously grateful to the School of General Studies for providing a home for students like me who took non-traditional paths to Columbia. There are days when I look back and truly cannot believe I am here. In the context of this project, I have benefitted from an exceptional degree of support from faculty and peers. Professors Adam Tooze and Anders Stephanson provided extremely useful guidance in formulating my project as a junior. I was the fortunate recipient of a research grant from the President’s Global Innovation Fund to do archival research in European archives last summer.
    [Show full text]
  • The Great Inflation and Early Disinflation in Japan and Germany
    The Great Inflation and Early Disinflation in Japan and Germany∗ Edward Nelson Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis This paper considers the Great Inflation of the 1970s in Japan and Germany. From 1975 onward, these countries had low inflation relative to other large economies. Traditionally, this success is attributed to stronger discipline on the part of Japan and Germany’s monetary authorities—e.g., more willingness to accept temporary unemployment, or greater determination not to monetize government deficits. I instead attribute the success of these countries from the mid-1970s to their governments’ and monetary authorities’ acceptance that inflation is a monetary phenomenon. Likewise, their higher inflation in the first half of the 1970s is attributable to the fact that their policymakers over this period embraced non- monetary theories of inflation. JEL Codes: E52, E58, E64, E65. 1. Introduction This paper considers the Great Inflation of the 1970s in Japan and the Federal Republic of Germany. These countries are notable for the fact that their peaks in inflation came earlier in the decade—in 1974—than in many other countries, while their inflation rates in ∗I am indebted to the editor, an anonymous referee, and Otmar Issing for com- ments; to Christina Gerberding, Heinz Herrmann, Johannes Hoffmann, Andreas Worms, and the staff of the Deutsche Bundesbank Fachbibliothek for help in obtaining material on Germany; and to Takushi Kurozumi, Michael Nelson, Katrina Stierholz, and Julia Williams for help with other material. Justin Hauke and Faith Weller provided research assistance. The views expressed in this paper are those of the author and should not be interpreted as those of the Federal Reserve Bank of St.
    [Show full text]
  • OMFIF Bulletin Global Insight on Official Monetary and Financial
    OMFIFOMFIF BULLETIN Official Monetary and GlobalFinancial Insight Institutions on OfficialForum Monetary and Financial Institutions March 2010 IMF staff paper gets it wrong Blanchard ideas add to government bond uncertainty Stewart Fleming, Board of Contributing Editors ith government debt levels soaring Many will regard this as playing with Blanchard’s paper seems likely to add Wto oppressive levels on both fire. Some policy-makers, as well as to European divisions about the correct sides of the Atlantic, the International many market participants, are already ‘exit strategy’ from the financial crisis. Monetary Fund’s chief economist has wondering how long it will be before made a radical, yet wrong-headed, a combination of zero interest rates, There is a wider dimension, too. The suggestion. Central banks should massive liquidity injections and huge IMF is charged with promoting global consider raising their inflation targets budget deficits will either directly trigger stability through its surveillance of the to 4% from 2% – tantamount to inviting inflation or lead to intense political major economies. Some official asset politicians to ratchet up inflation as a pressure for the same outcome. managers are tiring of buying floods way of reducing the burden of public of sovereign debt at current interest (and private) debts. Indeed, the just-published Barclays rates. There may be ‘technical’ reasons Bank Equity Gilt Study 2010 concludes why China dumped a record $34bn The recommendation – in a paper bleakly: ‘According to our demographic of US government paper in December, by Professor Olivier Blanchard, the bond models, long term government according to official US figures. But Fund’s chief economist – comes at an yields in both the US and the UK are Blanchard’s paper seems calulated to acutely sensitive time.
    [Show full text]
  • Research.Stlouisfed.Org/Wp/2006/2006-052.Pdf
    Research Division Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Working Paper Series The Great Inflation and Early Disinflation in Japan and Germany Edward Nelson Working Paper 2006-052E http://research.stlouisfed.org/wp/2006/2006-052.pdf September 2006 Revised September 2007 FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF ST. LOUIS Research Division P.O. Box 442 St. Louis, MO 63166 ______________________________________________________________________________________ The views expressed are those of the individual authors and do not necessarily reflect official positions of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, the Federal Reserve System, or the Board of Governors. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Working Papers are preliminary materials circulated to stimulate discussion and critical comment. References in publications to Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Working Papers (other than an acknowledgment that the writer has had access to unpublished material) should be cleared with the author or authors. The Great Inflation and Early Disinflation in Japan and Germany Edward Nelson* Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis October 26, 2007 Abstract This paper considers the Great Inflation of the 1970s in Japan and Germany. From 1975 onward, these countries had low inflation relative to other large economies. Traditionally, this success is attributed to stronger discipline on the part of Japan and Germany’s monetary authorities—for example, more willingness to accept temporary unemployment, or greater determination not to monetize government deficits. I instead attribute the success of these countries from the mid-1970s to their governments’ and monetary authorities’ acceptance that inflation is a monetary phenomenon. Likewise their higher inflation in the first half of the 1970s is attributable to the fact that their policymakers over this period embraced nonmonetary theories of inflation.
    [Show full text]