Regioselectivity of Aniline and Toluidine Nitration with HNO3 And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Regioselectivity of aniline and toluidine nitration with HNO 3 and H 2 SO 4 in acetic acid Ângelo F. Sousa, João P. Telo, Pedro P. Santos [email protected] Técnico Lisboa, Universidade de Lisboa, Av Rovisco Pais, s/n, 1049 - 001 Lisboa, Portugal ABSTRACT: The goal of this work is to study how the regioselectivity in aniline and toluidine nitration is affected by the resonance and induction effects of N - acetyl and N - succinimidil groups. Starting materi als were protected with acetic and succinic anh ydride, and nitration occured via S E Ar with a HNO 3 /H 2 SO 4 mixture in AcOH. Nitrated products were hydrolyzed and a sample of each experiment was analysed by HPLC. Aniline results show product distribution is controlled by both functional groups’ ortho/para directing and +R effects, yielding similar percentages of 2 - nitroaniline (23%) and 4 - nitroaniline (76%). For 4 - methylacetanilide, regioselectivity control is once again established by the +R effect, favoring the ortho - substituted product (97%). Since succi nimi de group is less activating than the acetamide group, reaction control is taken over by the methyl group, yielding 94% 4 - methyl - 3 - nitroaniline. 3 - methylacetanilide nitration yielded 91% 3 - methyl - 4 - nitroaniline, which is a product favored by both +R eff ect of the acetamide group and +I effect of the methyl group. For N - (3 - methylphenyl) - succinimide, the yield of 3 - methyl - 6 - nitroaniline increased to 62% since the succinimide group has a weaker activating effect due to the electronic pull of its two carbony l groups. For the N - (2 - methylphenyl) - succinimide, product distribution was controlled by the alkyl group, with the main products being ortho / meta substituted, yielding 29% 2 - methyl - 3 - nitroaniline and 55% 2 - methyl - 5 - nitroaniline. This is due to the non - plan ar position between the succinimide group and the aromatic ring, nullifying its +R effect. For the acetanilide derivative, regioselectivity is controlled by its +R effect (45% 2 - methyl - 4 - nitroaniline) and by the +I effect of the methyl group (33% 2 - methyl - 5 - nitroaniline). Overall it was shown that the +R effect of the acetamide groups is stronger than that of the succinimide group. This is due to the presence of one more carbonyl group in the latter, which pull s electrons away fro m the aromatic ring by indu ction ( - I effect) and by resonance ( - R effect) deactivating the starti ng material to an EAS reaction. Experiments with the N - acetyl derivative also showed that +R effect is more important to regioselectivity control than the +I of the alkyl group. This was an expected result, as the non - shared electron pair of the nitrogen atom has a greater importance to the stabilization of the aromatic ring than the e lectron - donating role of the CH 3 . Keywords: nitration, aniline, regioselectivity, Ele ctrophilic Aromatic Substitution 1. Introduction synthesis [3] , to dye [4] and pesticide [5] precursors 1.1 State of the art and many other uses. Given the large number of substracts used as starting mate rial in these Nitration of aromatic compounds has been heavily industries, and th e even larger number of isomers studied since the 19th century due to its importance that can be obtained during nitration, several in several chemical industries. Nitro aromatic synthetic routes have been developed with the species are present in a wide range of value chains objecti ve of maximizing overall conversion of the worth millions of E uros [1] , from the pharmaceutical reaction , as well as the selectivity of the desired industry [2] , us ed as intermediary in benzi midazole 1 isomer. The classical nitration method is the use of 1.2. Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution an HNO 3 /H 2 SO 4 mixture in acetic acid, chloroform EAS is an organic reaction where an atom or group or dichloroethane. Th is synthetic route originates a connected to the aromatic ring is subs tituted by great amount of acid effluents , hazardous to the ano ther. This reaction occurs by a nucleophilic environment. This generally leads to effluen t attack by the electron - rich aromatic ring o n an treatment, which results in an extra cost to the electron - depleted electrophile in a two - step company, reducing its profit. In order to keep up mechanism. The first step is the nucleophilic attack, with the always growing environmental issues, new connecting the aromatic ring to the electroph ile, ways to produce nitro aromatic compounds at an forming an arenium ion, stabilized by resonance. industrial scale are being studied with the main This is a slow step due to the momentary loss of concern b eing the necessity of synthesizing these aromaticity, and it determines the reaction’s overall compounds in mild conditions. The main processes rate. The second step is the loss of the proton include the use of transition - metal complexes as connected to the carbon atom where substitution catalyst s [6] [7] , nitration salts [8] [9] and ozone occurred , thus reestablishing aromaticity. mediated nitration [10] . Other nitro group sources have been investigated , such as VO(NO 3 ) 3 [11] . All these processes enable aromatic compound nitration in mild conditions that do not require the use of concentrated acids, extremely diminishing the environmental impact caused by the reaction. Other concern associated with the development of Scheme 1 - EAS mechanism these new ways of producing nitro aromatic Regioselectivity is mainly affected by the aromatic comp ounds is the desire to establish atom ring’s functional groups. These can either be economical reactions t hat substantially reduce , or activating or deactivating groups. Activating groups elim inate , the amount of effluents that have to be are electron donors by resonance (+R) or by treated before they can be discharged. induction (+I) and speed up the reaction by However, the use of more expensive reactants and increasing the aromatic ring’s electron density, catalysts increases the pro cess’ overall cost . making it more prone to attack an electrophile. Moreover , these new synthetic routes have a much Examples of these groups are NR 2 , NH 2 , OH and narrower range of application when compared to NHCOR . Activating groups are usually ortho / para the classic HNO 3 /H 2 SO 4 method, and are more directors due to the fact that ortho and para difficult to control, leading to unwanted and substituted species have one or more resonance hazardous multi - nitrated sub - products, as show n by contributors where all the atoms have a full octet. the process using VO(NO 3 ) 3 [11] . These problems are the reason why the classical nitration method which uses a mixture of concentrated nitric and sulfuric acid s is still used worldwide in a great number of nitro aromatic compound industries [12] even with the associated environmental issues it carries. 2 The fact tha t the NO 2 group is a deactiv ating group also explains why almost none multi nitrated byproducts were detected during every experimental procedure, since the presence of this group severely deactivates the aromatic ring for further nitration. Regioselectivi ty is also affected by the steric hindrance stablished by both the functional group Scheme 2 - Resonance contributors in an EAS mechanism with an activating group and the electrophile. Bulky groups tend to favor para substituted products, maximizing the distance These resonance contributors are very stable, between the functional group and the electrophile. which considerably decreases the activation energy necessary to form the intermediate complex. This significantly increases the reaction’s overall rate, as 1.3. Nitration via HNO 3 /H 2 SO 4 in acetic acid EAS is kinetically controlled . The exception to this Using a mixture of concentrated nitric and sulfuric are halogen atoms, which form more stable acids as nitrating agents is the ideal way of studying inter mediates in ortho and para substitution. the reaction’s regioselectivity since the reagents However, they act as deactivating groups, due to a used are cheaper than those needed for other more high electronegative property, attracting the complex processes. Furthermore, the reaction’s aromatic ring’s electron cloud, hence slowing the m echanism is well known, simple (EAS) and does reaction . not require a catalyst. The occurrence of multi - In contrast, deactivating groups are meta directors, nitrated byproducts was very limited in all of the sinc e ortho and para substituted products generate experiments, which means the isomeric distribution resonance contributors with a positively charged is more reliable. Since this experiment took place at carbon atom connect ed to the deactivating group, a labo ratory scale, the amount of effluents was not highly destabilizing the arenium ion. G roups such a major concern, as the reactions were prepared with small amounts of reagents which led to small as NO 2 , SO 3 H or CO OR are extremely electronegative and attract electrons from the quantities of acid effluents that were neutralized or aromatic ring, decreasing its e lectron density. This diluted in water prior to discharge. This synthetic resul ts in a less activated ring , consequently leading route is also a quite easy and quick nitration mean, to a much slower reaction. therefore allowing multiple experiments with the same starting material to ensure result repeatability. Given the main objective of this work was to understand how different functional groups affect the nitrat ion of aniline and toluidine, and also because the amine group is very sensitive to harsh acidic conditions, the starting materials were protected via acetylation in the presence of acetic and succinic anhydride prior to nitration to prevent amine oxidatio n. Scheme 3 - Resonance contributors in an EAS mechanism with a deactivating group 3 Scheme 4 – Experimental sequence Acetylation with acetic anhydride has been used in many research works, either with nitration being carried out by HNO 3 /H 2 SO 4 , as well as by the aforementioned processes.