Botanica Marina 54 (2011): 551–556 © 2011 by Walter de Gruyter • Berlin • Boston. DOI 10.1515/BOT.2011.066

Life history of valida (, ) in culture

Yunyan Deng 2,3 , Xiaorong Tang4 , Bingxin Huang1,2 Kü tzing in 1845, there have been several reports of both sexual and Lanping Ding 1,2, * and asexual reproduction, primarily in six marine species, viz., C. linum (Mueller) Kü tzing (Sinha 1958 , Kornmann 1972 ), 1 Shantou University , Shantou 515063 , China, C. aerea (Dillwyn) Kü tzing (Rosenvinge 1892 , Hartmann e-mail: [email protected] 1929 , Sinha 1958 , Price 1967 , Patel 1971 , Kornmann 1972 ), 2 Institute of Oceanology , Chinese Academy of Sciences, C. spiralis C. melago- Qingdao 266071 , China Okamura (Chihara 1958 , Hori 1994 ), nium C. norvegica 3 Graduate University of Chinese Academy of Sciences , (Weber et Mohr) Kü tzing (Patel 1972 ), et C. antennina Beijing 100049 , China Leliaert Rueness (Leliaert et al. 2009 ) and 4 Key Laboratory of Marine Genetics and Breeding (Ocean (Bory de Saint-Vincent) Kü tzing (Leliaert et al. 2011 ). University of China) , Ministry of Education, Qingdao Chaetomorpha valida (Hooker et Harvey) K ü tzing, a 266003 , China marine species originally described from Tasmania, Australia, has been recorded in Australia (Womersley 1984 ), New * Corresponding author Zealand (Womersley 1984 ) and Fiji (South and Skelton 2003 ). It typically grows on mid- to supralittoral rocks that are surf-exposed or subject to strong surge. The species grows Abstract unattached or attached by basal holdfasts. It occurs as scat- tered individuals or as clumps of fi laments. Occasionally, it The marine green alga Chaetomorpha valida (Cladophoraceae, is an understory species (Guiry and Guiry 2011 ). In China, ) has been found for several years foul- the species was fi rst reported from sea cucumber aquacul- ing aquaculture ponds along coasts of the cities Dalian and ture ponds in coastal Dalian, Liaoning province (Chi et al. Rongcheng, P.R. China. Using unialgal culture and micro- 2009 ). As a bloom-forming alga in China, it often dominates C. valida scopic observation, we completed the life history of aquaculture ponds and grows more luxuriantly in spring and and discovered fragment regeneration for the fi rst time. The summer than in winter. Massive occurrence of C. valida is a life history comprised an isomorphic alternation between signifi cant nuisance for aquaculturists, especially when loose gametophytes and sporophytes typical of most other members mats accumulate and decompose. Large quantities of thalli of the Cladophorales. Male and female gametes fused into directly interfere with the growth and movement of abalone zygotes then developed into sporophytes. Quadrifl agellate and sea cucumbers. Decomposing algal mats also consume zoospores produced by mature sprophytes gave rise to new dissolved oxygen, producing a hostile physico-chemical envi- gametophytes that yielded bifl agellate gametes. Germination ronment for mariculture. Seasonal abundances of macroalgae of zygotes and zoospores was of the bipolar erect type, as greatly affect water quality and sometimes cause great loss in observed in some other species of Chaetomorpha . Fragment aquaculture (Chi et al. 2009 ). regeneration occurred in both gametophytes and sporophytes Very little is known about the biology of C. valida . This via production of polar algal fragments, which directly devel- study was performed to investigate its life history and thus oped into entire fi laments to give a self-replicating gene- to gain better insight into mechanisms of colonization and ration. The results improved understanding of the seasonal excessive growth. Our results aid in understanding processes abundances of C. valida in spring and summer. underlying differences in algal abundance between spring and summer. Keywords: Chaetomorpha valida; China; fragment regen- eration; life history.

Materials and methods Introduction Chaetomorpha specimens were collected from an aquaculture Chaetomorpha is a common and widespread green seaweed pond in Rongcheng, Shandong Province, China on 30 October genus in the order Cladophorales, characterized by unbranched 2008. Specimens were transported in seawater to the labora- fi laments. The life history of Chaetomorpha consists of an tory where healthy individuals were selected and rinsed with alternation between isomorphic gametophytes and sporo- sterilized seawater to remove epiphytes. Initially, thalli were phytes: gametophytes release gametes, which, after fusion, incubated in sterilized seawater at 20° C. Sterilized seawater germinate and develop into sporophytes. Mature sporophytes was renewed every day during the fi rst week after collection. discharge zoospores that give rise to new gametophytes After one week, thalli were cut into small pieces (about (Burrows 1991 ). Since the genus was fi rst established by four cells long) and cultured in enriched seawater (Table 1 ) 552 Y. Deng et al.: Life history of Chaetomorpha valida in culture

Table 1 Enrichments to seawater (for a total of 150 ml). The species was abundant in spring and summer in aqua- culture ponds, less so in winter; it was present year-round. All Component Amount (g) collected specimens were reproductive.

NaNO 3 6.375 Gametophytic stage NaH2 PO4 ·2H 2 O1.080 Tris 9.085 KI 0.125 After several days in culture, heavily pigmented gametangia

H3 BO 3 4.635 were formed (Figure 3 ). Each vegetative cell except that of

FeC 6 H5 O7 0.039 basal cells was able to transform into a gametangium. Over

Vitamin B1 0.038 100 gametes were produced per gametangium; these were Vitamin B 0.075× 10-3 12 released through one or two (sometimes three) papilla-shaped Method: 1.5 ml of the above enrichments was added to 1l seawater. liberation pores (Figure 4) along the lateral cell wall. Most gametes swam rapidly after passing through the liberation pores; sometimes when shed explosively, large number of (Deng et al. 2011 ) in an incubator at 25° C and under 72 µ mol gametes massed in a temporary loose cluster. Gametes were photons m-2 s -1 with 10:14 h L:D cycle. Irradiance was mea- ovoid, measuring 4.5– 7 × 8 – 10.5 µm, and each of them had sured with a quantum photometer (LI-COR, LI-250, Lincoln, a red eyespot and a chloroplast with many pyrenoids. There NE, USA). Gametes were released several days later. Zygotic were two equal fl agella at the anterior of gametes which pro- discs (discoid sporophytes) developing from zygotes were pelled gametes before fusion (Figure 5). There was no mor- removed from the substrata with a micropipette and trans- phological differentiation among gametes. ferred into petri dishes. Unialgal cultures were established by isolation of the zygotic discs. Subsequent cultures were Isogamy derived from them. Enriched seawater used for unialgal culture was renewed every fi ve days. Growth and develop- After being released, gametes were so active that they occa- ment were observed regularly under a light microscope. ssionally collided. When two heterosexual gametes met, Observation and microphotography were conducted with they kept in contact and fused together gradually (Figure 6). Nikon E400 (Tokyo, Japan) and Zeiss Stemi 2000-c (Wetzlar, Gametogamy took place not only between swarmers derived Germany) microscopes, and a Nikon Coolpix 4500 (Tokyo, from different fi laments, but also between those produced Japan) camera. in a single fi lament or even from the same gametangium. Isogamete fusion resulted in quadrifl agellate zygotes, 6 – 10 × 9 – 14 µm in size with two-eyespots. Zygotes could be Results clearly distinguished from gametes by fl agellum number at the early fusion stage. Morphology and phenology of Chaetomorpha valida Some abnormal fusions were also observed in our study. More than two gametes sometimes fused to form an excep- Thalli of C. valida were light green in color; they were tionally large zygote (Figure 7). Zygotes sometimes fused fi rm and crisp in texture. Uniseriate unbranched fi laments with other zygotes to form a much larger fusion cell. But (Figure 1 ) entangled to form a spongy mass. Filaments were almost all unusually derived zygotes disintegrated shortly unattached or attached with basal holdfast discs. Cells were after fusion. cylindrical without marked constrictions at septa (Figure 2). Cells of unattached fi laments were 265 – 475 µ m in diameter, Germination of zygotes 150 – 700 µ m long and 0.5– 2.1 times long as broad. Cell walls were 10 – 25 µ m thick, striated and lamellated. Chloroplasts Zygotes lost motility after several minutes and became were parietal and reticulate with numerous pyrenoids. spherical or subspherical after settling on the substratum

12

Figures 1 – 2 Chaetomorpha valida : morphology in culture. (1) General morphology. Scale bar: 1 mm. (2) Cylindrical cells without obvious constrictions at septum. Scale bar: 500 µ m. Y. Deng et al.: Life history of Chaetomorpha valida in culture 553

3 4

5 67

8 910 11

12 13 14

15

Figures 3 – 15 Chaetomorpha valida : reproductive events observed in culture. (3) Early stage of the formation of gametangia. Note gametangia (arrows). Scale bar: 500 µ m. (4) Emptied gametangia. Note liberation pores (arrows). Scale bar: 300 µ m. (5) Gametes with two fl agella. Scale bar: 10 µ m. (6) Two gametes fusing at their posterior ends. Scale bar: 10 µ m. (7) A zygote and a gamete fusing. Scale bar: 10 µ m. (8) A settled zygote. Scale bar: 10 µ m. (9) A zygote elongating to form apical and basal por- tions. Scale bar: 20 µm. (10) A germling with an apical cell and a basal cell. Scale bar: 40 µm. (11) A quadrifl agellate zoospore. Scale bar: 10 µm. (12) Clusters of sporophyte germlings. Scale bar: 300 µ m. (13) Overgrowth of a cell by a neighboring cell (arrow). Scale bar: 500 µ m. (14) Stretch cell transforming into a basal cell of a new fragment; both fragments have same apico-basal polarity. Note stretch cell (arrow). Scale bar: 500 µ m. (15) A long fi lament with three cells undergoing fi lament propagation. Note cells initiating propagation (arrows). Scale bar: 500 µ m. 554 Y. Deng et al.: Life history of Chaetomorpha valida in culture

(Figure 8). They began to germinate within a few days. fi laments sometimes formed several propagation fragments Germination of zygotes was of the bipolar erect type. Cells simultaneously (Figure 15). All polar fragments were able to contained many pyrenoids on laminated chloroplasts elon- survive and develop into new thalli. gating upwards and downwards to form apical and basal portions (Figure 9). Initial cells began a fi rst division and divided into two differentiated cells; one was an apical cell Discussion and the other a basal cell (Figure 10). With this develop- ment, the germlings had obvious apico-basal polarity. The The life cycle of C. valida in our culture is summarized in apical and basal cells formed unbranched fi lamentous and Figure 16 . It is an isomorphic alternation between gameto- basal portions, respectively. The apical cell divided continu- phytes and sporophytes, typical for most other members of ously to form erect uniseriate fi laments; the basal cell elon- the Cladophorales. Both gametophytes and sporophytes were gated to produce a discoid holdfast defi cient of chloroplasts. capable of fragment regeneration. Germinations of both zoo- All the zygotes in our culture germinated and developed into spores and zygotes were of the bipolar erect type, as observed sprophytes. in C. linum (Kornmann 1972 ), C. aerea (Hartmann 1929 , Price 1967 , Kornmann 1972 ), C. spiralis (Chihara 1958 , Sporophytic stage Hori 1994 ) and C. melagonium (Patel 1972 ). Previous studies have also revealed apomixis in C. aerea (Hartmann 1929 ) in Almost all cells of mature sprophytes were able to transform which parthenogenetic development of gametes occurred to into zoosporangia. The unreleased zoospores were barely dis- repeat the gametophytic stage. Such reproductive behavior tinguishable morphologically from gametes. Zoospores were was not observed in our experiment. 5 – 8 × 9 – 12 µ m in size. The shape and behavior of zoospores Sexual reproduction was isogamous, with no morphologi- resembled those of gametes except zoospores had four fl a- cal or behavioral differentiation of gametes as reported in gella (Figure 11) and their sizes were between those of gam- Chatomorpha aerea by Hartmann (1929) and Patel (1971) , etes and zygotes (Table 2). and in C. spiralis by Chihara (1958) . Some Chaetomorpha species have dioecious gametangia (Hartmann 1929 , Chihara Germination of zoospores 1958 , Price 1967 , Kornmann 1972, Burrows 1991 ). Hartmann (1929) reported that all cells in a single fi lament were of the After being released, zoospores swam and settled on the cul- same sex in marine Chaetomorpha species. However, in our ture disk. They often settled extremely close to each other, study, gametogamy took place not only between swarm- forming clusters of new germlings (Figure 12). Germination ers derived from different fi laments, but also between those of zoospores was similar to that of zygotes, giving rise to produced within a single fi lament. The results demonstrated gametophytes. physiological differentiation among gametes of C. valida released from different gametangia on one fertile fi lament, Fragment regeneration but also among those produced by a single gametangium. In this study, we used cut thallus pieces to examine repro- Both gametophytes and sporophytes in our cultures were able duction and development of C. valida. In addition to the for- to replicate through fragment regeneration. Fragment regene- mation of gametes and zoospores, thalli were also capable of ration was achieved via production of polar algal fragments, fragment regeneration allowing rapid proliferation of the spe- which developed into new fi laments. cies. This has not been reported previously in Chaetomorpha Propagation always commenced in cells within healthy fi la- species, but has been observed in Bryoposis hypnoides ments, usually in an intercalary position. It began with syn- thesis of a cell wall leading to cell elongation. The stretch part usually formed at an angle to the neighboring cell (Figure 13). Zoospores Then, detachment occurred between the stretch cell and its neighbor, leading to formation of two algal fragments. The Gametophytes Fragment Fragment Sporophytes regeneration stretch cell transferred into basal cell of the new thallus. regeneration The two fragments in culture maintain apico-basal orienta- Sporophytic Gametophytic stage tion, indicating the existence of polarity (Figure 14). Long stage

Gametes Zygotes Table 2 Chaetomorpha valida : swarmer dimensions in culture. Gametes

Swarmer The number Length (µ m) Width (µ m) of fl agella Figure 16 Chaetomorpha valida : life history in culture. ± ± Zoospore 4 10.2 0.93 6.3 0.79 Male and female gametes discharged from gametophytes fused into ± ± Gamete 2 9.5 0.75 5.6 0.54 zygotes. Zygotes settled and developed into sprophytes, which then ± ± Zygote 4 11.1 1.68 7.8 1.24 released zoospores. Zoospores germinated and developed into new Values are means± SD; n = 30. gametophytes to complete the life cycle. Y. Deng et al.: Life history of Chaetomorpha valida in culture 555

Lamouroux (Wang and Tseng 2006 ) and Ulva prolifera Chihara, M. 1958. Studies on the life-history of the green algae in the (O.F. Mü ller) J. Agardh (Lin et al. 2008 ). Because of human warm seas around Japan. 6 on the life-history of Chaetomorpha activities or grazing by herbivorous animals, formation of spiralis Okamura. J. Jap. Bot. 33 : 183 – 189. thallus fragments is common in nature. According to our David, G.R., A.R. John and J.P. Lynda. 1998. Ecological impact observations, these thallus pieces could either develop into of green macroalgal blooms. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol. Annu. Rev. 36 : 97 – 125. new fi laments directly through fragment regeneration or form Deng, Y.Y., X.R. Tang, L.P. Ding and S.X. Lian. 2011. A new record numerous reproductive cells, which would give rise to numer- from China of the epiphytic marine algae, Acrochaete leptochaete ous new germlings. Both of the two differentiation processes (Chaetophoraceae, Chlorophyta) with its primary experimental contributed signifi cantly to forming new individuals, which biology. Chin. J. Oceanol. Limnol. 29 : 350 – 355. may be partly responsible for the rapid growth and prolifera- Guiry, M.D. and G.M. Guiry. 2011. AlgaeBase. World-wide elec- tion of C. valida under favorable conditions in nature. Waste tronic publication, National University of Ireland, Galway. products from industry release signfi cant quantities of nutri- http://www.algaebase.org (last accessed 20 September 2011). ents for algal growth in aquaculture ponds. Chaetomorpha spe- Hartmann, M. 1929. Untersuchungen ü ber die Sexualit ä t cies have a high surface area-to-volume ratio, which enhances und Entwicklung von Algen. III. ü ber die sexualitä t und light interception (Littler and Littler 1980 , Carpenter 1990 ). Generationswechsel von Chaetomorpha und Enteromorpha . Ber. When temperature and photoperiod are optimal in spring and Deutsche Bot. Ges. 47 : 485 – 494. summer and associated with nutrient-enriched seawater, this Hori, T. 1994. An Illustrated atlas of the life history of algae Volume 1, Green algae. Uchida Rokakuho, Tokyo. pp. 190 – 198. green alga is able to reproduce and grow rapidly to form large Kornmann, P. 1972. Ein Beitrag zur Taxonomie der Gattung biomass accumulations. Chaetomorpha (Cladophorales, Chlorophyta). Helgol. Wiss. Several species of Chaetomorpha have been reported Meeresunters. 23 : 1 – 31. as bloom forming algae (Lavery and McComb 1991 , Krause-Jensen, D. and B.P. Christensen. 1999. Oxygen and nutri- Rysgaard et al. 1995 , McGlathery et al. 1997 , David et al. ent dynamics within mats of the fi lamentous macroalga 1998 , McGlathery and Pedersen 1999 , Krause -Jensen and . Estuaries 22 : 31 – 38. Christensen 1999 , Pranovi et al. 2000 , Menendez et al. 2002 , Lavery, P.S. and J.A. McComb. 1991. The nutritional eco- Menendez 2005 ) that may cause great damage to aquaculture physiological of Chaetomorpha linum and Ulva rigida in Peel and natural ecosystems. Small quantities of Chaetomorpha Inlet, Western Australia. Bot. Mar. 34 : 251 – 260. biomass are usable as biofi lters to reduce nutrient load in Leliaert, F., J. Rueness, C. Boedeker, C.A. Maggs, E. Cocquyt, H. effl uents; they are also useful as indicator species to monitor Verbruggen and O. De Clerck. 2009. Systematics of the marine pollution in coastal environments (McGlathery et al. 1997 , microfi lamentous green algae Uronema curvatum and Urospora microscopica (Chlorophyta). Eur. J. Phycol. 44 : 487 – 496. Serfor-Armah et al. 2006). When outbreaks occur, it is impor- Leliaert, F., S. D ’ hondt, L. Tyberghein, H. Verbruggen and O. De tant to control the biomass of this alga. Future studies on the Clerck. 2011. Atypical development of Chaetomorpha anten- interplay between the physico-chemical factor variation and nina in culture (Cladophorales, Chlorophyta). Phycol. Res. the growth of this nuisance alga are certainly warranted. 59 : 91 – 97. Lin, A.P., S.D. Shen, J.W. Wang and B.L. Yan. 2008. Reproduction diversity of Enteromorpha prolifera. J. Integr. . Biol. Acknowledgements 50 : 622 – 629. Littler, M.M. and D.S. Littler. 1980. The evolution of thallus form and This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation survival strategies in benthic marine macroalgae: fi eld and labo- of China (No. 31070185, 40876081 and 31093440), the Knowledge ratory tests of a functional form model. Am. Nat. 116 : 25 – 44. Innovation Program of Chinese Academy of Sciences (No. KSCX2- McGlathery, K.J. and M.F. Pedersen. 1999. The effect of growth YW-Z-018), the Science and Technology Plan Project of Guangdong irradiance on the coupling of carbon and nitrogen metabolism in Province (No. 2011B031100010), the Team Project of Natural Chaetomorpha linum (Chlorophyta). J. Phycol. 35 : 721 – 731. Science Foundation of Guangdong Province (No. S2011030005257), McGlathery, K.J., D. Krause-Jensen, S. Rysgaard and P.B. the Agricultural Welfare Project of China (No. 201003068) and Christensen. 1997. Patterns of ammonium uptake within dense the Startup Project of Shantou University (Nos. 09400133 and mats of the fi lamentous macroalga Chaetomorpha linum . Aquat. 09400134), P.R. China. Sincere thanks are due to Mr Lian Shaoxing Bot. 59 : 99 – 115. for sample collection and Ms Qiu Xinyuan for valuable advice on Menendez, M. 2005. Effect of nutrient pulses on photosynthesis the experiments. of Chaetomorpha linum from a shallow Mediterranean coastal lagoon. Aquat. Bot. 82 : 181 – 192. Menendez, M., J. Herrera and F.A. Comin. 2002. Effect of nitro- References gen and phosphorus supply on growth, chlorophyll content and tissue composition of the macroalga Chaetomorpha linum Burrows, E.M. 1991. Seaweeds of the British Isles. Natural History (O.F. Muller) K ü tzing in a Mediterranean coastal lagoon. Sci. Museum Publications, London. pp. 238. Mar. 66 : 355 – 364. Carpenter, R.C. 1990. Competition among marine macroalgae: a Patel, R. 1971. Cytotaxonomical studies of British marine species of physiological perspective. J. Phycol. 26 : 6 – 12. Chaetomorpha – I Chaetomorpha linum K ü tz. and Chaetomorpha Chi, Y.X., L.M. Wang, R.X. Luan and H.W. Wang. 2009. aerea K ü tz. Phykos 10 : 127 – 136. Chaetomorpha valida, a new recorded green alga species in Patel, R.J. 1972. Cytotaxonomical studies of British marine species genus Chaetomorpha Kü tzing in China. Fisheries Science 28 : of Chaetomorpha – II K ü tz. Phykos 162 – 163. 11 : 17 – 22. 556 Y. Deng et al.: Life history of Chaetomorpha valida in culture

Pranovi, F., D. Curiel, A. Rismondo, M. Marzocchi and M. Scattolin. seaweed species for monitoring pollution in the coastal environ- 2000. Variations of the macrobenthic community in a seagrass ment of Ghana. J. Radioanal. Nucl. Ch. 269 : 711 – 718. transplanted area of the Lagoon of Venice. Sci. Mar. 64 : 303 – 310. Sinha, J.P. 1958. Chromosome numbers and life-cycles in members Price, W.M. 1967. Some aspects of the biology and of the of Cladophorales. Brit. Phycol. Bull. 1 : 24 – 27. unbranched Cladophorales in the British Islands . PhD Thesis, South, G.R. and P.A. Skelton. 2003. Catalogue of the marine ben- University of Liverpool. pp. 107. thic macroalgae of the Fiji Islands, South Pacifi c. Aust. Syst. Bot. Rosenvinge, L.K. 1892. Om nogle vaextforheld hos slaegterne 16 : 699 – 758. og Chaetomorpha . Bot. tidsskr. 18 : 29 – 64. Wang, G.C. and C.K. Tseng. 2006. Culturing the segments of Rysgaard, S., P.B. Christensen and L.P. Nielsen. 1995. Seasonal Bryopsis hypnoides Lamouroux thalli regenerated from proto- variation in nitrifi cation and denitrifi cation in estuarine sediment plast aggregations. J. Integr. Plant. Biol. 48 : 190 – 196. colonized by benthic microalgae and bioturbating infauna. Mar. Womersley, H.B.S. 1984. The marine benthic fl ora of southern Ecol. Prog. Ser. 126 : 111 – 121. Australia. Part I. Government Printer, Adelaide. pp. 329. Serfor-Armah, Y., D. Carboo, R.K. Akuamoah and A. Chatt. 2006. Determination of selected elements in red, brown and green Received 24 July, 2011; accepted 13 October, 2011 Copyright of Botanica Marina is the property of De Gruyter and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.