The Human Biodiversity in the Middle of the Mediterranean Study of Native and Settlers Populations on the Sicilian Context
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Human Biodiversity in the Middle of the Mediterranean Study of native and settlers populations on the Sicilian context Gabriele Lauria Università degli Studi di Palermo – Universitat Politècnica de València PhD Thesis Supervisor Prof. Luca Sineo OCTOBER 2020 Biodiversità Mediterranea – Internazionale-Europeaus Dipartimento di Scienze Agrarie, Alimentari e Forestali Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Biologiche Chimiche e Farmaceutiche BIO/08 Ciencia y Tecnología de la Producción Animal Departamento de Ciencia Animal The Human Biodiversity in the Middle of the Mediterranean Study of native and settlers populations on the Sicilian context PhD CANDIDATE PhD COORDINATOR GABRIELE LAURIA PROF. MARIA ANTONIETTA GERMANA’ SUPERVISOR CO-SUPERVISOR PROF. LUCA SINEO PROF. VICENTE ESTRUCH-FUSTER TUTOR PROF. MIGUEL JOVER-CERDA’ CICLO XXXII OCTOBER 2020 I This page was intentionally left blank II The Human Biodiversity in the Middle of the Mediterranean Study of native and settlers populations on the Sicilian context PhD Thesis Gabriele Lauria 0000-0002-0122-7093 Department of ‘’Scienze Alimentari Agrarie e Forestali’’ (SAAF) Department of ‘’Scienze Biologiche Chimiche e Farmaceutiche’’ (STEBICEF) University of Palermo (UNIPA) Department of ‘’Ciencia Animal’’ Polytechnic University of Valencia (UPV) III Thesis submitted by Gabriele Lauria to get the Europeaus PhD in ‘’Mediterranean Biodiversity-International’’ (UNIPA) and the in PhD in ‘’Science and Technology of Animal Production’’ in Co-Tutorship with the (UPV) Supervisors Prof. Luca Sineo (UNIPA) Prof. Vicente Domingo Estruch-Fuster (UPV) Tutor Prof. Miguel Jover-Cerdá (UPV) PhD Coordinators Prof. Maria Antonietta Germana’ (UNIPA) Prof. Maria del Pilar Hernández-Pérez (UPV) Special Thanks to Dr. Emiliano Bruner (CENIEH) Prof. Armando González-Martin (UAM) Prof. Oscar Cambra-Moo (UAM) IV «'O brothers, who amid a hundred thousand «"O frati," dissi, "che per cento milia Perils,' I said, 'have come unto the West, perigli siete giunti a l'occidente, to this so inconsiderable vigil a questa tanto picciola vigilia Which is remaining of your senses still d'i nostri sensi ch'è del rimanente be ye unwilling to deny the knowledge, non vogliate negar l'esperïenza, Following the sun, of the unpeopled world. di retro al sol, del mondo sanza gente. Consider ye the seed from which ye sprang; Considerate la vostra semenza: Ye were not made to live like unto brutes, fatti non foste a viver come bruti, But for pursuit of virtue and of knowledge.» ma per seguir virtute e canoscenza".» Divine Comedy Divina Commedia Hell- canto 26° (vv 112-120) Inferno- canto 26° (vv. 112-120) “Dante Alighieri” “Dante Alighieri” Traslated by Henry Francis Cary - 1814 Virgilio (Virgil) shows Dante Alighieri the flames of the fraudulent advisers. Illustration by Paul Gustave Doré - 1861 V To my Family that always gives me the strength to never give up and for the indefatigable support. To my Friends who tolerate me every day. To all who suffer in these sad moments. VI This page was intentionally left blank VII Index Index .................................................................................................................................. 8 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................... 10 1.1 Human Biodiversity and the Sicilian Context ........................................................ 10 1.2 Aim of the Study ..................................................................................................... 13 1.3 Teeth – Genesis, Evolution and Structure ............................................................. 15 1.4 Odontology in Anthropological Studies ................................................................ 18 1.5 Cranium – Structure and Development ................................................................. 19 1.6 Craniofacial Sutures ............................................................................................... 24 1.7 Measurement of the Cranium – Craniometry ....................................................... 28 1.8 Photogrammetry – History and Basic concepts .................................................... 32 1.9 Geometric Morphometrics – Key concepts ........................................................... 38 1.10 Multivariate Statistical Analysis in Physical Anthropology ................................ 49 1.11 Stature and Secular Trend .................................................................................... 57 1.12 Biological Distance from Skeletal Remains ......................................................... 61 2. Materials and Methods ........................................................................................... 62 2.1 Materials ................................................................................................................. 62 2.1.1 Teeth 2D Measurements ................................................................................. 70 2.1.2 Craniofacial 3D Geometric Morphometrics ..................................................... 72 2.1.3 Secular Trend of Stature .................................................................................. 75 2.2 Methods .................................................................................................................. 77 2.2.1 Dental Metrics .................................................................................................. 78 2.2.2 Geometric Morphometrics .............................................................................. 81 2.2.3 Secular Trend ................................................................................................... 93 3. Results and Discussion ......................................................................................... 96 3.1 Dental Metrics ........................................................................................................ 96 3.1.1 Preliminary Studies .......................................................................................... 96 3.1.2 Recent Data ...................................................................................................... 99 3.1.3 PCA ................................................................................................................. 100 3.1.3 MANOVA/CVA and MDS ................................................................................ 109 3.1.3 Neighbour Joining .......................................................................................... 112 3.2 Geometric Morphometrics .................................................................................. 113 3.2.1 Craniofacial Geometric Morphometrics in Sicily ........................................... 114 8 3.2.2 PCA ................................................................................................................. 120 3.2.3 MANOVA/CVA ................................................................................................ 129 3.2.4 Neighbour Joining .......................................................................................... 131 3.2.5 Groups’ Geometric Morphometrics ............................................................... 132 3.2.6 Groups’ PCA ................................................................................................... 138 3.2.7 Group’s Neighbour Joining ............................................................................. 148 3.2.8 Comparison Sample ....................................................................................... 150 3.2.9 Precis .............................................................................................................. 155 3.3 Secular Trend ........................................................................................................ 160 3.3.1 Canonical Statistics ........................................................................................ 161 3.3.1 Multivatriate Statistics ................................................................................... 167 4. Conclusion .............................................................................................................. 170 Bibliography ................................................................................................................ 173 Appendix1 .................................................................................................................... 243 Appendix2 .................................................................................................................... 248 Acknowledgements ................................................................................................... 251 9 1. Introduction 1.1 Human Biodiversity and the Sicilian Context Humans are subjected to adaptations and evolutionary process ruled by the environment. During the last 200,000 years, human species has spread throughout Earth, adapting his morphology and physiology to a wide range of habitats (Kuzawa & Thayer 2011). The human skeleton is, therefore, a real "Biological Archive" on which are recorded several environmental effects (Mays 2010), consequently, skeletal findings assume huge importance on the investigation of the evolutionary processes. Nowadays, the study on human bones made possible to detect important data related to the "Human Biodiversity" evidently not limited to demographic and pathological studies (Ortner 2003 – Brickley & Ives 2010). Quantitative investigations of the main morphological features allow relating