DOCSLIB.ORG

Using Fan Identification to Assess Rule Change

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Using Fan Identification to Assess Rule Change Modernizing Major League Baseball: Using Fan Identification to Assess Rule Change Preferences Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Richard Laurence Bailey, M.S. Graduate Program in Kinesiology The Ohio State University 2019 Dissertation Committee Dr. Donna Pastore, Adviser Dr. Brian Turner Dr. Leeann Lower i Copyrighted by Richard Laurence Bailey 2019 ii Abstract Evaluating a sport’s fans perceptions and preferences has been an important aspect of sports research for many years. To make these evaluations many theoretical approaches have been used including; fan team identification (e.g., Wann & Branscombe, 1993), commitment (e.g., Mahony, Madrigal, & Howard, 2000), and loyalty (e.g., Backman & Crompton, 1991). These theories, and others, have been used to assess a variety of sport related phenomena such as game attendance choices (Wann & Branscombe, 1993), and expectations of referee performance (Gayton et al., 1998) among others. Ultimately, fan team identification was chosen as the focus of this study. Wann and Branscombe (1993) showed that a fan’s expectations of a team differ depending on their identification level. Additionally, the differences between individuals with low and high fan identification impact their consumption habits and behaviors. High identification has been found to have the biggest effect on enjoyment (Madrigal, 1995), and directly leads to the purchasing and consumption of more products (Fink, Trail, & Anderson, 2002). This study assessed fan identification and its influence on preferences for changes to rules in Major League Baseball (MLB) for individuals aged 18-24, an important demographic to capitalize on as baseball fans are aging and youth involvement in the iii sport has waned in recent years (Paul, 2017). All the rule changes chosen for this study have been either implemented in the minor or major leagues or have been discussed by fans, players, and media. A survey was designed and administered to undergraduate college students at a large midwestern university. These students were surveyed in their respective classrooms utilizing a convenience sample. The survey began asking demographic questions. The second section used Wann & Branscombe’s (1993) Sport Spectator Identification Scale in its entirety to create a mean identification score. Finally, the survey asked a Likert question, scaled one to eight, which said “To what extent would this rule improve MLB?” in regard to each rule changes. A panel of experts and a brief pilot study were utilized to evaluate the survey for content analysis and clarity. After reviewing the feedback and results some format and phrasing changes were made, and the full survey was administered. Overall, the study demonstrated that in some situations the level of fan identification was a statistically significant predictor of a fan’s preference to a rule change, specifically in regard to mound visits, starting extra-innings with a runner on second base, and the implementation of a pitch clock. Other demographic factors were at times statistically significant predictors as well including how many times an individual watches MLB per month, whether they participated in organized baseball or softball, and gender. Future research based on this line of inquiry can be used to evaluate other proposed rule changes, in any sport, and could focus on different demographics, such as iv older age groups, to help paint a more panoramic picture of what people are looking for in gameplay going forward. v Acknowledgments I am extremely grateful for the many people who helped me to get to this point. First, I want to thank my father, Richard W. Bailey who inspired me to learn something new every day and instilled in me the love of the law. Equally as important to my development was my mother, Laura J. Bailey, the kindest and most caring person I ever knew. She inspired me to be compassionate and showed me how helping others is the most rewarding type of work. I also want to thank my sisters, Cynthia Bailey Roberts and Pam Marinko, who I could always count on to be there for me, especially in difficult and trying times. Other important family member were my stepmother, Deborah Bailey, and my stepbrother, Mark Saunders, who looked out for me, cared for me and taught me to be inquisitive and tough. Thank you to all of you for your support. I also want to thank my friends and colleagues at Ohio State: Mickey Fraina, Chad Gerber, Sean Dahlin, Jim Evans, Mark Beattie, Daniel Wray, Carter Rockhill, Evan Davis, Ashley Ryder, Shea Brgoch, Lindsay Bond, and Danielle Daluisio). I also wanted to thank several other individuals who truly helped the process and provided significant contributions to this study (Dr. Mary Hums, and Ben Keller). Lastly, I want to thank the faculty at Ohio State I had the pleasure of working with. First, Dr. Sue Sutherland, thank you for being a great advisor and mentor and providing me with some terrific opportunities to grow and learn. Dr. Brian Turner also vi was instrumental in helping me find my passion within Sport Management and helping me to focus on theoretical development. Dr. Turner was the ideal committee member and helped push this project through to completion. I also want to thank Dr. Lee Lower who helped immensely with developing my quantitative skills as well as providing me wonderful opportunities to further my research in other areas. Finally, I want to especially thank Dr. Donna Pastore. She has been a wonderful advisor and mentor to me over the past few years and was instrumental to helping me find my passion in teaching and research. I will always be grateful for her help and guidance. vii Vita 2001……………………………………Dublin Coffman High School 2005……………………………………B.A. Political Science, The Ohio State University 2009……………………………………J.D. Barry University School of Law 2009 to 2015…………………………...Attorney at Law, Bailey & Slavin Law Firm, Bailey Law LLC 2015 to present…………………………Graduate Teaching Associate, The Ohio State University 2016…………………………………….M.S. Sport Management, The Ohio State University Field of Study Major Field: Kinesiology viii Table of Contents Abstract .............................................................................................................................. iii Acknowledgments.............................................................................................................. vi Vita ................................................................................................................................... viii List of Tables ..................................................................................................................... xi Chapter 1. Introduction ....................................................................................................... 1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 1 Background of the Problem ................................................................................................ 1 Technology and Creating Rules .......................................................................................... 3 Fan Identity and The Influence of Preference ..................................................................... 5 Statement of the Problem .................................................................................................... 8 Spectator Perceptions of Technology and Rules .............................................................. 15 Purpose of the Study ......................................................................................................... 21 Research Questions ........................................................................................................... 23 Definition of Terms........................................................................................................... 24 Overview of Remaining Chapters ..................................................................................... 26 Chapter 2. Review of Literature ....................................................................................... 27 Overview and history of identity theory ........................................................................... 27 How is Identity Theory Applied? ..................................................................................... 31 How has Identity Theory Been Used in the Sport Context? ............................................. 33 How Identity is Measured? Critique of Existing Scales and Measures ............................ 39 Chapter 3. Methods .......................................................................................................... 48 Population Characteristics/Sampling Method................................................................... 48 Scale Development ........................................................................................................... 50 Validity and Reliability ..................................................................................................... 55 Methods of Entering Predictors ........................................................................................ 56 Assumptions of Regression Analysis ............................................................................... 57 Recommended Data Collection/Analyses ........................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Report of the Ncaa Baseball Rules Committee July 17-19, 2019 Annual Meeting
    REPORT OF THE NCAA BASEBALL RULES COMMITTEE JULY 17-19, 2019 ANNUAL MEETING ACTION ITEMS. 1. Legislative items. • None. 2. Nonlegislative items. The NCAA Baseball Rules Committee approved the following rules change proposals for the 2020 season. Although it is a non-rules change year, the committee requests approval from the NCAA Playing Rules Oversight Panel (PROP) for the following items since one is health and safety related and the other is regarding a proposed rule change from 2018-19 to improve the overall image of the game: a. Protective equipment (Rule 1.15.d). (1) Recommendation. To require that all catcher’s chest protectors must bear the manufacturer’s certification indicating satisfaction of NOCSAE and SEI testing standards to protect against commotio cordis. (2) Effective date. Immediately. (3) Rationale. Commotio cordis though rare, is a typically fatal condition caused by the impact of a high velocity object (e.g. thrown or hit baseball) to the anterior chest causing cardiac arrest and death. Newly developed performance standards for the NOCSAE and SEI certification testing standards for baseball chest protectors can mitigate or eliminate the risk of this preventable condition. (4) Estimated budget impact. $65-100. (5) Student-athlete impact. None. b. Twenty-second action rule (Appendix F). (1) Recommendation. To require, a 20-second action rule be administered when runners are on base. The time limit would be kept on the field base a base umpire in the same manner the current 20-second pitch clock is administers with no runners on base. (2) Effective date. Immediately. (3) Rationale. Consistent with other sports (e.g., football and basketball), baseball benefits from having action rules to speed up pace of the game.
    [Show full text]
  • Is Major League Baseball Striking Out? In-Game Advertising and Its Effects on America’S Pastime
    IS MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL STRIKING OUT? IN-GAME ADVERTISING AND ITS EFFECTS ON AMERICA’S PASTIME by Ashley M. Anderson A thesis submitted to the faculty of The University of Mississippi in partial fulfillment of the requirements of The Sally McDonnell Barksdale Honors College. Oxford May 2017 Approved by ________________________________ Advisor: Dr. Christopher Newman ________________________________ Reader: Dr. Allyn White ________________________________ Reader: Dr. Dwight Frink © 2017 Ashley Marie Anderson ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii For my brother, Austin. “Never let the fear of striking out keep you from playing the game.” -Babe Ruth iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thank you to my advisor, Dr. Christopher Newman, for his guidance and wisdom throughout this incredibly rewarding process. Thank you to Dr. Allyn White and Dr. Dwight Frink for reading diligently. Thank you to my parents, Darrin and Chris Anderson, for always supporting me and reminding me to stay balanced. Thank you to my brothers, Austin, Brennan, and Brady, for continually encouraging and inspiring me. Thank you to my fiancé, James Danforth, for reading draft after draft of my thesis and supporting me through endless mental breakdowns. Thank you to my friends for providing me with a wonderful home away from home. You have supported and encouraged me for as long as I can remember and I’m so grateful. iv ABSTRACT IS MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL STRIKING OUT? IN-GAME ADVERTISING AND ITS EFFECTS ON AMERICA’S PASTIME (Under the direction of Dr. Christopher Newman) The purpose of this thesis is to determine the effectiveness of in-game advertisements at Major League Baseball games. Average attendance at Major League Baseball games has been steadily declining for years.
    [Show full text]
  • 2021 SCGSL Rules
    REVISED 4/22/2021 THIS EDITION SUPERCEDES ALL PREVIOUS EDITIONS SECTION 1 SCGSL RULES 1~1 SCGSL Rules are the official league rules and shall be followed as an Addendum to the Official OKKIDS Rulebook. 1~2 All hometown concession stands shall have the official SCGSL Rulebook readily available for reference. Proof of umpire certification will be made available through each town coordinator upon request. 1~3 League rules, scheduling information, standings and brackets are available at http://washitavalley.org/cgi-bin/softball/ SECTION 2 PLAYERS 2~1 Eligible Players: Open to all girls within the SCGSL member town’s school district. 2~2 We are currently in the 2021 season. The softball "year" for SCGSL runs from August 1 to July 31. All league games scheduled after August 1 are considered 2022 events and in order to participate in them a team must be registered for 2022. In short, all the teams that were created and all rosters that were submitted for the 2021 season expired on July 31, 2021. Teams must "age up" or drop older players to stay in their Spring Age group. 2~3 AGE cut off dates: 6 & Under: Not to be 7 prior to January 1 of the current season “year”. 8 & Under: Not to be 9 prior to January 1 of the current season “year”. 10 & Under: Not to be 11 prior to January 1 of the current season “year”. 12 & Under: Not to be 13 prior to January 1 of the current season “year”. This can be verified at: http://www.usssa.com/baseball/AgeCalculator/ A.
    [Show full text]
  • VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL MEMORANDUM September 22, 2010 TO: NCAA Baseball Head Coaches, Conference Commissioners and Coordinators Of
    VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL MEMORANDUM September 22, 2010 TO: NCAA Baseball Head Coaches, Conference Commissioners and Coordinators of Umpires. FROM: Jim Paronto, secretary rules-editor NCAA Baseball Rules Committee. SUBJECT: Final Rules Changes. Included with this communication are several documents that have recently been approved by the Playing Rules Oversight Panel (PROP). These rules changes and directives included will be in place for the next two seasons (2011 and 2012) as part of the NCAA’s two-year cycle for rules changes. Please share this information with any interested parties in the college baseball community. Division III institutions should note that the Panel denied a request by the committee to allow reentry rules on an experminetal basis. PROP believes strongly that the issue of rules differences by division needs further discussion and consideration before approving such proposals. Thank you for your time and attention to these documents and please contact me directly at [email protected] if you have any questions. Thank you and good luck with your preparations for the 2011 season. JP:nb Attachments NCAA BASEBALL RULES COMMITTEE FINAL RULES CHANGES – EFFECTIVE FOR 2011 AND 2012 SEASONS INTRODUCTION On September 20, the Playing Rules Oversight Panel approved the following changes that were proposed by the Baseball Rules Committee after its July meeting. One rules proposal was denied: The Division III experimental rule to allow reentry rules to be used when both teams agree. The Panel does not believe allowing divisional differences would be appropriate at this time. 1. SIGNIFICANT CHANGES. Rule 1-13c, A.R. 2: Revise to read: The pitcher’s glove must be black or brown.
    [Show full text]
  • Mlb Pace of Game Guidelines
    MLB PACE OF GAME GUIDELINES 20‐SECOND PITCH TIMER Timer Between Pitches. There shall be a 20‐second pitch timer between each pitch. Except as otherwise described in the Rules, the pitcher must deliver each pitch of an at‐bat prior to the expiration of the 20‐second timer. The pitcher must begin his windup motion or the motion to come set before the 20‐second timer expires. The batter must be in the batter’s box and alert to the pitcher at the 5‐second mark of the pitch clock timer. The 20‐second timer shall start after each pitch of an at‐bat, beginning with when the pitcher has possession of the ball in the dirt circle surrounding the pitcher’s rubber, and the catcher is in the box. START & STOP OF TIMER ● Timer Begins After First Pitch of At‐Bat. The 20‐second pitch timer only starts after the first pitch of an at‐bat and each subsequent pitch of that at‐bat. ● Pickoff Play, Wild Pitch or Passed Ball. The timer shall reset to 20 seconds when the pitcher is in possession of the ball in the dirt circle and the catcher is in position. ● Pitcher Feints a Pickoff Attempt or Steps Off Rubber With Runners on Base. The timer shall immediately be reset to 20 seconds. ● Foul Ball/Dead Ball. The timer shall not be used on the next pitch. ● Mound Visit/Catcher Leaves Box. The timer shall stop and not be used on the next pitch. ● Umpire Calls “Time". The timer shall stop and not be used on the next pitch.
    [Show full text]
  • Major League Baseball Tests Ways to Speed up Slow Games by Bill Brink, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on 11.10.14 Word Count 1,267
    Major League Baseball tests ways to speed up slow games By Bill Brink, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on 11.10.14 Word Count 1,267 Pittsburgh Pirates starting pitcher Edinson Volquez throws against the San Francisco Giants in the first inning of the wild- card playoff baseball game on Oct. 1, 2014, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Photo: AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. — Baseball, the only major sport without a time element, could soon be on the clock. Football has a play clock. Basketball has a shot clock. Under experimental rules Major League Baseball is currently testing in the Arizona Fall League (AFL), baseball could have a pitch clock. And a pitching-change clock. And an inning-break clock. Violations will result in automatic balls and strikes, applying a pace-of-play and penalty structure to a game played at its own pace for more than 150 years. The rule changes, born of the Pace of Game Committee departing Commissioner Bud Selig created, are intended to address the increasing periods of inactivity that some fear could turn away younger viewers. “In the major leagues is where the problem is,” said Pittsburgh Pirates special assistant to player development Frank Kremblas, who is managing in the fall league. “That’s why they’re doing it. We’re the experimental people.” Baseball games consistently have increased in length in the past few decades. The time of an average game has increased from 2 hours, 23 minutes in 1950 to 2:33 in 1981 to more than three hours this season. The first three games of the World Series took 3:32, 3:25 and 3:15.
    [Show full text]
  • Baseball by Dan Sapone “There Are Only Two Seasons - Winter and Baseball.” — Bill Veeck
    Baseball By Dan Sapone “There are only two seasons - Winter and Baseball.” — Bill Veeck. “Baseball is ninety percent mental and the other half is physical" — Yogi Berra = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = Baseball Here in February, the day Lou Seal shows up at my granddaughter’s school in San Francisco, in full uniform, you KNOW baseball is just around the corner. Why did he appear at Quinn’s school? Was it to introduce young people to the magic of baseball and the optimism that spring training embodies? The timing is clear: Spring Training is about to begin and, once again, it’s magic. All you have to do is say the words “Spring Training” and serious baseball fans can feel the magic. Disclaimer: I was a basketball player. It was the only sport I was any good at, but I grew up loving baseball — I watched it ever since 1961 when my brother-in-law Joe Faletti took me and my nephews to my first Giants’ game at Candlestick Park; I listened to Russ Hodges and Lon Simmons describe it on the radio; I lived and died by the fortunes of My Giants. Baseball mattered to a kid growing up in the 1950s/60s in Antioch, CA. It became personal. [Click here for my personal, brief playground baseball history.] In baseball, the approach of Spring Training is a hopeful time — no scores yet, no losses, no strikeouts or disappointments. Even after My Giants’ dreadful 2017 season (we’re not gonna talk about that) the slate is clean and all things are possible. In 2016, my son Matt and his wife Nou took Gretta and me to our first Spring Training in Arizona.
    [Show full text]
  • Ready … and … Action!
    BASEBALL 2020 A supplement to the NCAA Baseball Rules • Prepared by the editors of Referee Ready … And … Action! Rule Change Puts 20-Second Action Clock Into Effect n their ongoing quest to improve Ipace of play, the NCAA Baseball Rules Committee and the Playing Rules Oversight Panel (PROP) have approved the expanded use of a 20-second action clock in all NCAA divisions starting with the upcoming 2020 season. Not to be confused with a pitch clock, the action clock mandates that, once the home-plate umpire signals play, or the pitcher has possession of the ball in the circle surrounding the pitcher’s rubber, the catcher is in the catcher’s box and the batter is in the batter’s box, the pitcher shall be allowed 20 seconds to begin the activity preceding each pitch. The pitcher does not necessarily have to release the ball within 20 seconds; however, the pitcher must begin his windup motion or otherwise begin the motion to come set in order to comply with the rule. Upon a first violation, the pitcher shall be warned by the umpire. There is one warning per pitcher. Each subsequent violation shall result in the award of a ball to the batter without the pitcher having to deliver the pitch. The ball is dead and no runners may advance, unless the ball awarded by the umpire is the batter’s fourth and the batter is entitled to advance to first. Conversely, batters shall enter and remain in in the batter’s box in accordance with rule 7-1-d and BOB MESSINA not delay entry to gain an undue If there is no visible play clock on the fi eld, NCAA umpires will need to use a stopwatch to advantage.
    [Show full text]
  • Minor League Baseball Announces Pace of Play Regulations for 2018
    For Immediate Release March 14, 2018 Minor League Baseball Announces Pace of Play Regulations for 2018 Minor League Baseball to begin extra innings with runners on base, mound visits to be limited, and Triple-A and Double-A to use 15-second pitch timers with no runners on base ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — Minor League Baseball today announced rule and procedure changes aimed at reducing the length of extra innings games and the number of mound visits during a game throughout Minor League Baseball. In addition, the Triple-A and Double-A levels will use a 15-second pitch clock with no runners on base. The procedures, created in partnership with Major League Baseball, aim to reduce the number of pitchers used in extra innings and the issues created by extra innings games, including, but not limited to, shortages of pitchers in the days to follow, the use of position players as pitchers and the transferring of players between affiliates due to pitching shortages caused by extra innings games. “We believe these changes to extra innings will enhance the fans’ enjoyment of the game and will become something that the fans will look forward to on nights where the game is tied late in the contest,” said Minor League Baseball President Pat O’Conner. “Player safety has been an area of growing concern for our partners at the Major League Baseball level, and the impact that lengthy extra innings games has on pitchers, position players and an entire organization was something that needed to be addressed.” EXTRA INNINGS -At all levels of Minor League Baseball, extra innings will begin with a runner on second base.
    [Show full text]
  • * Text Features
    The Boston Red Sox Saturday, June 27, 2020 * The Boston Globe MLB’s pandemic rules mean big changes for Red Sox TV and radio coverage Chad Finn In Major League Baseball’s packet of rules and regulations for restarting the season even as the COVID-19 virus refuses to yield the field, the effects the pandemic will have on the way media members do their jobs may as well be footnotes. That’s understandable given the wholesale changes required to the schedule and the implementation of complex protocols just to get a 60-game season started. Still, the changes with the media are significant, and will have a noticeable effect on what viewers and listeners receive for a game broadcast. A few notable rules: Only 35 media members per game will be allowed in the ballpark, including photographers but not including broadcasters; interviews with players and other personnel will be done via video conferencing; reporters must leave the ballpark within an hour of the end of postgame interviews. The rules for the television and radio teams are unlike anything that has been done before. Home teams will provide a “neutral” feed for each game, with instructions to show players on both teams equally; television commentators will not be in the ballpark for road games, instead calling them off a feed, but radio announcers will be permitted in road booths. The Red Sox broadcast teams for WEEI radio and NESN are in the process of figuring out their approaches, but some groundwork has already been laid for the targeted July 23 or 24 restart.
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 NCAA Division I Baseball Game Officials Manual
    2018 NCAA DIVISION I BASEBALL GAME OFFICIALS MANUAL NCAA Division I Baseball Game Officials Manual 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................. 3 SECTION 1: CONTACT/RESPONSIBILITIES INFORMATION .............................................................. 4 SECTION 2: 2018 IMPORTANT DATES ............................................................................................ 8 SECTION 3: CHAMPIONSHIP ASSIGNMENT PROCEDURES ............................................................ 10 SECTION 4: ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS FOR UMPIRES ............................................................. 14 SECTION 5: DIVISION I CHAMPIONSHIP TRAVEL ......................................................................... 15 SECTION 6: DIVISION I PRE-TOURNAMENT INFORMATION ......................................................... 17 SECTION 7: AROUND THE STADIUM .......................................................................................... 19 SECTION 8: ON THE FIELD ........................................................................................................... 21 SECTION 9: OFF THE FIELD .......................................................................................................... 33 APPENDIX A: 2018 NCAA BASEBALL UMPIRE CLINICS ............................................................ 37 APPENDIX B: BACKGROUND CHECK AND SPORTS WAGERING INFORMATION .......................... 38 APPENDIX
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 BASEBALL SURVEY REPORT July 10, 2020
    Canadian Baseball Hall Of Fame and Museum: 2020 BASEBALL SURVEY REPORT July 10, 2020 1 IMI International Overview CORE PURPOSE LOCATIONS ABOUT US 70 PEOPLE 100+ CLIENTS 45 COUNTRIES POINT OF DIFFERENCE THOUGHT LEADERSHIP COMMITMENT TO EXCELLENCE 50,000+ Case Studies If, for any reason, IMI International does R Y G • What’s now, and what’s next? not satisfy the objective • Thousands of studies since 1971 • Dedicated team + SMEs defined in the agreed-to proposal, the project will What’s now, and what’s next? • Immersed in ongoing exploration be refunded in full. Thousands of studies since 1971 • Provide fact-based guidance for the next 12-24 months 2 What we’ll cover 4 Background & Methodology 5 Executive Summary 6-7 Respondent Profile 8-13 Baseball Today: Engagement Landscape 14-20 Baseball Moments & Experiences That Matter Most 21-22 Baseball Tomorrow: The Future 3 Background & Methodology Objectives Screening Criteria Provide the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum Canadian Residents aged 18+ recruited through CBHFM’s email (CBHFM) with insightful, but fun fact-based data regarding database and social media pages Canadian baseball fans from across the country to gain a A public survey link was also posted by CBHFM on its social media pages better understanding in the following areas: Timeline (field dates) Methodology 1. Baseball Participation & Pro League Engagement June 18th to June 30th, 2020 15-minute survey online 2. Baseball Today – Fans’ perspective of the sport 3. Baseball Tomorrow – Most desired changes moving Sample forward for the game Total n=904 Note: Sample for this survey is comprised of more passionate (avid) baseball fans vs.
    [Show full text]