Delta and Aqueduct Tastes & Odors and Bluegreen Algal
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DeltaDelta andand AqueductAqueduct TastesTastes andand OdorsOdors andand AlgalAlgal CyanotoxinsCyanotoxins JeffJeff Janik,Janik, Ph.D.Ph.D. California Department of Water Resources Delta Nutrient Water Quality Modeling Workshop March 25, 2008 AdverseAdverse effectseffects ofof nuisancenuisance algaealgae ReductionReduction inin waterwater productionproduction (filter(filter clogging)clogging) FormationFormation ofof tastetaste andand odorodor productsproducts IncreaseIncrease inin organicorganic mattermatter (DPB(DPB’’s)s) CyanotoxinsCyanotoxins (Cyanobacteria)(Cyanobacteria) HigherHigher operatingoperating costscosts forfor WTPWTP’’ss HigherHigher chemicalchemical useuse ShorterShorter filterfilter runrun timestimes 2 StateState WaterWater ProjectProject 3 SacramentoSacramento SanSan JoaquinJoaquin DeltaDelta 4 CliftonClifton CourtCourt ForebayForebay 5 ConditionsConditions forfor AlgalAlgal GrowthGrowth HighHigh PhosphorusPhosphorus levelslevels (>(> 5050 ug/lug/l TP)TP) 1 ug/L TP = approx. 1 ug of chlorophyll a StableStable stratifiedstratified conditionsconditions (plankton)(plankton) ContinuousContinuous nutrientnutrient supplysupply (flowing(flowing systems,systems, recycling,recycling, internalinternal loading)loading) CyanobacteriaCyanobacteria presentpresent HigherHigher affinityaffinity forfor NN && PP (outcompete(outcompete others)others) SomeSome speciesspecies fixfix atmosphericatmospheric NN (heterocytes)(heterocytes) 6 Dissolved Inorganic Nitrogen 2000 Dissolved inorganic N (ug/L) BPP 1800 CK 13 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 7 Total Phosphorus 300 BPP Total Phosphorus (ug/L) CK 13 250 200 150 100 50 High protection potential 0 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 8 BlueBlue--greengreen AlgaeAlgae (The(The Cyanobacteria)Cyanobacteria) 150 Genera with approx. 2000 species T&O Producers (approx. 3%) Toxin Producers (approx. 1-1.5%) Very few T&O producers also produce toxins 9 TasteTaste andand OdorOdor CompoundsCompounds •• Earthy/mustyEarthy/musty tastestastes andand odorsodors •• GeosminGeosmin •• 22--methylisoborneomethylisoborneo (MIB)(MIB) •• DirectDirect measurementmeasurement (no(no surrogates)surrogates) •• ProducedProduced byby CyanobacteriaCyanobacteria 10 TasteTaste andand OdorOdor AlgaeAlgae BlueBlue--greengreen algaealgae (Cyanobacteria)(Cyanobacteria) MIB and geosmin most difficult to treat FrequentlyFrequently minorminor componentscomponents (hard(hard toto find)find) BenthicBenthic oror planktonicplanktonic StrainStrain specificspecific PhotosyntheticPhotosynthetic –– lightlight controlscontrols distributiondistribution Nutrients:Nutrients: PP andand NN (N(N--fixers)fixers) OpportunisticOpportunistic (like(like allall algae)algae) 11 ConsequencesConsequences ofof MIBMIB andand GeosminGeosmin inin DrinkingDrinking WaterWater Public perception “If the water tastes and smells bad, then it’s not safe to drink” Analytical detection limit (SPME) <1 ng/L Detection by sensitive individuals <5 ng/L Expect complaints/ 10 ng/L Implication: narrow window for detection and response 12 DWRDWR TT && OO MonitoringMonitoring ProgramProgram •• WeeklyWeekly monitoringmonitoring –– EarlyEarly WarningWarning –– IsolateIsolate sourcesource ofof productionproduction •• AdditionalAdditional samplesample duringduring ““episodesepisodes”” •• SolidSolid PhasePhase MicroextractionMicroextraction (SPME)(SPME) –– ReportingReporting levellevel == 11 ng/Lng/L (=ppt)(=ppt) •• DataData distributeddistributed –– 11--33 daysdays 13 TasteTaste andand OdorsOdors –– BanksBanks PumpingPumping PlantPlant 60 MIB Geosmin 50 40 30 20 10 0 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 14 BanksBanks PPPP –– T&OT&O EventsEvents 30 MIB > 10 ug/l 25 Geosmin > 5 ug/l 20 Weeks 15 10 5 0 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 15 AlgalAlgal BiomassBiomass –– BanksBanks PPPP Fluorescence (planktonic) 60.0 MIB 50.0 Geosmin Algae (x10) 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 0.0 Jan-01 Jan-02 Jan-03 Jan-04 Jan-05 Jan-06 Jan-07 16 TT && OO ImpactsImpacts onon WaterWater TreatmentTreatment •• IncreasedIncreased PowderedPowdered ActivatedActivated CarbonCarbon (PAC)(PAC) •• IncreasedIncreased ozoneozone dosedose •• HigherHigher costscosts forfor chemicalschemicals andand operationsoperations 17 18 SouthSouth BayBay AqueductAqueduct –– WTPWTP’’ss (MGD) Trtm Service Area Zone 7 Del Valle WTP 36 PAC Livrermore - Amador valley Patterson Pass (Conv) 21 PAC (Delta Supply = 100%) Patterson Pass (Mem) 8 ACWD Mission San Jose 8.5 Ozone Fremont, Newark, Union City WTP Number Two 21 Ozone (Delta Supply = ca 55%) SCVWD Penitencia 40 Ozone Milpitas Rinconada 80 PAC Los Gatos, Santa Clara & vic. Mountain View & vicinity Santa Teresa 100 Ozone South San Jose Total 315 19 30 25 MIB at Zone 7 20 customer complaints (8), 7/18, 7/20, 7/24, 15 7/25 10 2007 T&O Season - MIB PAC dose (mg/L) & MIB concentrations (ng/L) 5 DVWTP 0 15-May 22-May 29-May 5-Jun customer 12-Jun complaint (1), 8/16 19-Jun 26-Jun 3-Jul 10-Jul 17-Jul 24-Jul plant inlet 31-Jul customer complaint (1), 7-Aug 9/5 clearw ell inlet 14-Aug Date 21-Aug 28-Aug PAC dosage 4-Sep 11-Sep 18-Sep MIB thr es hold 25-Sep 2-Oct 9-Oct 16-Oct 23-Oct 30-Oct 20 PACPAC –– CostsCosts toto removeremove MIBMIB andand geosmingeosmin 300 Days - 250 addition PAC (x $1000) 200 150 100 50 0 2006 2007 21 TasteTaste andand OdorOdor ControlControl -- PACPAC 120 PAC addition -SCVWD 90 Days 60 30 0 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 22 OzoneOzone andand T&OT&O Applied Ozone Dose 2006 6 5 5.5 4.5 5 4 4.5 1/ 4/1/ 00 4/ 001/ 4/ 00 1/ 4/ 001/ 4/ 001/ 4/ 001/ 4/ 00 1/ 4/ 00 1/ 4/ 001/ 4/ 00 1/ 4/ 00 1/ 4/ 00 3.5 4 3 3.5 2.5 3 2 Applied Ozone Dose (mg/ Dose L) Ozone Applied 2.5 1.5 Energy Cost based on KWh and $0.10/ and KWh on kWh based Cost Energy 2 1 1.5 0.5 1 0 4/ 1/ 2006 5/ 1/ 2006 6/ 1/ 2006 7/ 1/ 2006 8/ 1/ 2006 9/ 1/ 2006 10/ 1/ 2006 O3 APPLIED DOSAG CuSO4 Treatment En er gy Co st 23 WTPWTP FilterFilter RunRun TimesTimes Filter Run Times (Headloss & NTU & >70 hrs running) 80 70 60 50 40 Runtime (hr) 30 20 10 0 1/1/06 2/20/06 4/11/06 5/31/06 7/20/06 9/8/06 10/28/06 12/17/06 4 CuSO4 Treatment 24 JonesJones TractTract 25 JonesJones TractTract ChronologyChronology -- 20042004 •• JuneJune 33 UpperUpper JonesJones LeveeLevee failedfailed – Inflow of 150,000 – 200,000 AF •• JuneJune 2020 LeveeLevee breachbreach closedclosed – High carbon water isolated •• JulyJuly 1212 StartStart ofof pumppump--offoff – 800 cfs •• DecemberDecember 1818 EndEnd ofof pumppump--offoff 26 JonesJones TractTract –– 20042004 27 (ng/L) MIB JT&CC MIB JT&CC 10000 1000 100 10 1 6/2/04 6/9/04 6/16/04 6/23/04 6/30/04 7/7/04 7/14/04 7/21/04 7/28/04 8/4/04 8/11/04 MIB 8/18/04 8/25/04 9/1/04 9/8/04 9/15/04 9/22/04 9/29/04 10/6/04 CC Inlet JT Lower Upper JT 28 28 Jones Tract Delta CCF 29 JonesJones TractTract -- ImpactsImpacts ImmediateImmediate –– elevatedelevated T&OT&O levelslevels inin thethe SBASBA LongLong TermTerm “Seeding” the SWP with a potent MIB producer Skinner Lake annual MIB episodes beginning in 2005 30 TasteTaste andand OdorOdor producerproducer-- JonesJones TractTract •• PlanktothrixPlanktothrix perornataperornata 31 CyanotoxinsCyanotoxins ProducedProduced byby CyanobacteriaCyanobacteria (bluegreen(bluegreen algae)algae) ApproxApprox 3030 speciesspecies containcontain toxinstoxins FormedFormed asas secondarysecondary metabolitesmetabolites (extra(extra stuff)stuff) WithinWithin cellscells oror releasedreleased toto waterwater 32 CyanotoxinCyanotoxin producersproducers Microcystis Anabaena 33 MicrocystisMicrocystis ---- CliftonClifton CourtCourt AugAug 20072007 34 MicrocystisMicrocystis aeruginosaaeruginosa X 84 X 280 35 Cyanobacteria that produce toxins (WHO, 1999) 36 RelevanceRelevance ofof AlgalAlgal ToxinsToxins toto HumansHumans •• SeveralSeveral documenteddocumented outbreaks,outbreaks, somesome deathsdeaths •• SomeSome toxinstoxins knownknown toto bebe tumortumor promoterspromoters •• PossiblePossible linklink toto liverliver cancercancer inin ChinaChina 37 HighHigh PriorityPriority CyanotoxinsCyanotoxins BasedBased onon EPAEPA criteriacriteria (May(May 2001)2001) Occurrence in United States Health effects Susceptibility to drinking water treatment Toxin Stability CyanotoxinsCyanotoxins Microcystins (LR, YR, LA, RR) are most common Anatoxin – a cylindrospermopsin 38 CyanotoxinCyanotoxin -- GuidelinesGuidelines NoNo enforceableenforceable regulatoryregulatory standardsstandards EPAEPA consideringconsidering requiringrequiring monitoringmonitoring (Unregulated(Unregulated ContaminantsContaminants MonitoringMonitoring Rule)Rule) WorldWorld HealthHealth OrganizationOrganization (WHO)(WHO) Provisional Guideline – 1 ug/L microcystin-LR AustraliaAustralia Microcystin-LR 1.3 ug/L Anatoxin –a 3.0 ug/L CellCell abundanceabundance guidelinesguidelines -- useuse withwith cautioncaution 39 CyanotoxinsCyanotoxins -- inin sourcesource waterwater U.S.U.S. SurveySurvey (Carmichael,(Carmichael, 2001)2001) MicrocystinMicrocystin ––LRLR inin 539/677539/677 (80%)(80%) 4.3%4.3% exceededexceeded WHOWHO guidelineguideline (1(1 ug/L)ug/L) 40 DWRDWR CyanotoxinCyanotoxin monitoringmonitoring •• Monitoring - analyzed 60 samples /year – Sampled weekly (2006) to twice monthly (2007) – June to October – Microcystins (LR, LA, YR, RR) – Analyzed by UC Davis CAHSF Lab •• 2006 (3 sites) – Delta -- Inlet to Clifton Court Forebay (Old River) – San Luis Reservoir - Pacheco Pumping Plant – O’Neill Forebay – outlet (Check 13) •• 2007 (5 sites) – 2006 three locations – Banks Pumping Plant – North Bay Aqueduct at Barker Slough Pumping Plant 41 DWRDWR CyanotoxinCyanotoxin monitoringmonitoring 42 DWRDWR CyanotoxinCyanotoxin resultsresults •• 2006 -- – Delta: CCF inlet (n=22) – San Luis Reservoir: Pacheco Pumping Plant (n=19) – O’Neill Forebay outlet (n=19) •• 2007 – Delta: CCF inlet (n=15) – Banks Pumping Plant (n=15) – San Luis Reservoir: Pacheco Pumping Plant (n=9) – O’Neill Forebay outlet (n=10) – North Bay Aqueduct: Barker Slough Pumping Plant (n=10) •• **All microcystin results below reporting level (< 1 ppb) 43 Thanks to Bill Taylor, Rich LoseeLosee andand GeorgeGeorge IzaguirreIzaguirre Metropolitan Water District Lago Frio, near Bariloche Argentina Photo by Jeff Janik 44.