WATERBLOMMETJIE (APONOGETONDISTA CHYOS, APONOGETONACEAE), A RECENTLY DOMESTICATED AQUATIC FOOD CROP IN CAPE SOUTH WITH UNUSUAL ORIGINS1

ROBERT W. PEMBERTON

Pemberton, Robert W. (Aquatic Management Laboratory, Agricultural Research Ser- vice, United States Department of Agriculture, 3205 College Ave., Lauderdale, Florida 33314 USA). WATERBLOMMETJIE (APONOGETONDISTACHYOS, APONOGETONACEAE) A RECENTLY DOMESTI- CATED AQUATIC FOOD CROP IN CAPE WITH UNUSUAL ORIGINS. Economic Botany 54(2):144-149, 2000. The inflorescence of distachyos, an endemic Cape South African aquatic herb, known as waterblommetjie, has been a traditional wild-gathered vege- table. This plant has been brought into cultivation as a food crop during the past twenty years. The reasons for its domestication were the loss and decline in wild populations because of herbicide runoff from agriculture, urban expansion that reduced the plant's habitat, and over- collection. Domestication also began because a pop song, celebrating this vegetable as an Afrikaans cultural symbol, started a food fad that greatly increased demand. Waterblommetjie cultivation, widespread marketing, and the general popularity of this unique food continues in the Mandela Era of South Africa.

WATERBLOMMETJIE (APONOGETONDISTACHYOS, APONOGETONACEAE)UNA COSECHA ACUATICARE- CIENTAMENTE DOMISTICADO EN SUDAFRICA CON ORIGENES NO COMUN. Za inflorecencia de Apon- ogeton distachyos, una hierba dcuatica endgmica al Cabo de Buena Esperanza, Africa, cono- cido como waterblommetjie, ha sido una vegetal silvestere tradicional. La planta se ha adop- tada para la cultivacirn dentro los ffltimos veinte a~os. Las razones por domesticarla fueron la perdida y el declino de las poblaciones silvestres por cause del escurrimiento de los her- bicidas de dreas agrfciolas, la expansirn urbana la qual redujo et drea de hdbitat deIla planta, y su cosecha excesiva. Ademrs, su domesticacirn empez6 porque una cancirn popular la cual celebr6 esta verdura como un sfmbolo cultural africaans empez6 una moda en la comida la cual aument6 mucho la demanda. La cultivacirn de waterblommetjie, el mercado extendido, y la popularidad general de esta ffnica comida continuan durante la era de Mandela en Suddf- rica. Key Words: ; ; Cape South Africa; crop origins; food symbol; popular culture; waterblommetjie; wild-gathered vegetable.

Usually we are unable to witness the domes- logical processes that placed wild food in tication of food plants since most were brought human habitats, enabling them to grow in rub- into cultivation so long ago. The ancestors of bish heaps, latrines and around houses (Ander- many crop plants have been identified (Zohary son 1952; Schmida and Whittaker 1981), or as and Hopf 1994: 8), but the reasons why people weeds of crop fields according to Vavilov (Zo- started to cultivate them are unknown. We can hary and Hopf 1994: 11). But domestication of theorize about the processes and the plant attri- wild food plants does not necessarily relate to butes that may have promoted cultivation. Wild needed resources or occur because of other such plant characteristics such as self pollination pre- logical factors or processes. Unlike long domes- adapted some to domestication (Zohary and ticated food plants, the reasons for the domes- Hopf 1994: 16). Domestication also may have tication of Aponogeton distachyos L.f. are been promoted by collection techniques or eco- known. In this report I document the recent do- mestication, cultivation, and food use of A. dis- tachyos in the Cape region of South Africa. 1Received 24 March 1998; accepted 1 February During a 1996 visit to the Cape, I examined 1999. A. distachyos cultivation and learned about the

Economic Botany 54(2) pp. 144-149. 2000 2000 by The New York Botanical Garden Press, Bronx, NY 10458-5126 U.S.A. 2000] PEMBERTON: APONOGETON 145

Fig. 1. Aponogetondistachyos, waterblommetjie, plants in cultivation. Note floating lance shaped and inflorescences projecting above water surface.

plant's domestication. I interviewed people who kaans and Cape hawthorn, Cape pondweed, and participated in the domestication and/or who Cape asparagus in English. tracked and reported it. The most important Waterblommetjie is a herbaceous perennial sources of information were: Eddie Laubscher, rooted in the hydrosoil in waters usually 1 to 2 an agronomist formerly of Stellenbosch Univ., meters deep. It has starchy storage corms also who did research on the domestication and who in the hydrosoil. Its lance shaped leaves resem- organized two symposia related to the cultiva- ble those of pondweed (Potamogeton spp., Po- tion and marketing of the plant; Danie van Tub- tamogetonaceae) and float on the water's surface bergh, Riverside Farm, Worcester, one of the (Fig. 1). Projecting just above the water's sur- largest and most important growers; and Stephen face are forked inflorescences that bear small McVeigh, a journalist at Farmer's Weekly, a clusters of small inside overlapping South African agricultural trade magazine pub- white fleshy bracts. After the fragrant flowers lished in Cape Town. No technical literature re- are pollinated by bees and other insects, they lated to the domestication or cultivation of A. develop into groups of small green fruits. Whole distachyos appears to have been published. inflorescences (hereafter called flowers) are col- Aponogeton distachyos is endemic to the rel- lected and used as a vegetable both in the atively dry Mediterranean climate area of the and fruit stages. Cape of South Africa (Bond and Goldblatt Three other Aponogeton species occur in the 1984). It is one of 44 Aponogeton species be- Cape including two, A. angustifolius Aiton and longing to the monogeneric Aponogetonaceae, a A. junceus Lehm. ex Schldl., that are also called family restricted to the Old World tropics (Mab- waterunintjie (Bond and Goldblatt 1984), which berley 1993). The common name of the plant is suggests similar food use. Aponogeton angusti- waterblommetjie, which means water flower in folius has smaller flowers that have had some Afrikaans. Waterblommetjie is also known as use as food in the Cape (S. McVeigh, pers. waterunintjie (water onion) or vleikos in Afri- comm.), but the scant information suggests mi- 146 ECONOMIC BOTANY [VOL. 54 nor use. The corms of A. junceus are used in recent rather than traditional. Louis Leipoldt, other parts of Africa (Peters, O'Brien and Drum- however, included a recipe for a waterblomme- mond 1992). tjie souffle in his writings on Cape cookery prior Waterblommetjie plants are attractive and the to World War II (Goosen 1981). The Cape Ma- flowers are pleasantly scented. The plant has lays (people of Indonesian origin who came to been cultivated as an ornamental in temperate the Cape in the 1700s) have also adopted wa- water gardens for many years and still is com- terblommetjies to their unique waterblommetjie monly listed in specialty nursery catalogues. bredies (Gerber 1957). Hortus Third (Bailey and Bailey 1976) mentions I was able to eat two waterblommetjie bredies three named ornamental selections. The plant during my visit. These were pleasant, hearty has escaped gardens and has naturalized in Ar- homemade stews with a long-cooked green bean gentina, New Zealand, France, Peru, and Eng- taste component. Since my visit ended at the be- land (Van Bruggen 1995). Waterblommetjie ginning of the flowering season (March to Oc- "completely established itself as if it were na- tober), the waterblommetjie used in the bredies five" in areas of southern England during the were largely canned and frozen. Fresh water- last century (Paxton and Lindley 1883) and has blommetjie are superior products (Robins 1994). been growing in the Lez River of southern I also ate freshly dug corms, which were very France for about 150 years (Van Bruggen 1995). irregularly shaped, from 1.5 to 6 cm in length and covered with dense black hair. Even after Fooo UsE boiling, the hair and tough skins were difficult The Bushman or San, now extinct in the to remove. The peeled, cooked corms were a Cape, consumed the plant (Fox and Norwood creamy white with an appealing nutty, slightly Young 1982). Early European settlers probably sweet taste and dense texture. At least seven oth- learned to use the plant from them. The Swedish er Aponogeton species have edible corms, in- Botanist Carl Thunberg visited the Cape in the cluding the esteemed A. monostachys of tropical 1770s and noted that the roasted corms were East Asia (Hedrick 1919; Tanaka 1976; Peters, considered a great delicacy (Thunberg 1795). O'Brien, and Drummond 1992). Aponogeton The settlers also used the flowers to make a junceus occurs in the Cape, but reports of human pickle of high repute (Hooker 1831) and as an use of its corms are from other parts of Africa asparagus-like vegetable (Fox and Norwood (Peters, O'Brien, and Drummond 1992). Young 1982). Watt and Breyer-Brandwijk (1962) reported CULTIVATION that the rootstock (the corm) is eaten by people The following description of cultivation is of African origin, but none of the informed based on interviews with Laubscher, McVeigh South Africans I spoke with knew of any present and van Tubbergh; and articles in Farmer's day use of the corm. The flower is the part that Weekly (McVeigh 1989, 1994; and Viljoen has been used as a food source for many years. 1994). Cultivation is in shallow (1 to 1.5 m) The most common way waterblommetjie flowers ponds (usually 50 by 50 m or less) created by are prepared is in a lamb or mutton stew called earthen dams. The corms are planted in regularly a waterblommetjie bredie. This is similar to spaced rows late in the South African summer Dutch green bean stew in which the waterblom- (January or February). Then the ponds are filled metjie flowers are used instead of green beans artificially or by autumn rains. First picking of (D. van Tubbergh, pers. comm.). A waterblom- the flowers begins in March or April (Fig. 2). metjie bredie recipe described as traditional in- Production declines in winter (May to July) and cludes mutton, onions, potatoes, a large quantity then increases to peak production from August of sorrel, white wine, salt, pepper and 'water- to October, depending on the area. In early sum- blommetjie (Robins 1994). The wife of an early mer (usually November) the ponds are allowed grower of waterblommetjie wrote an Afrikaans to dry or are drained. The soil is then plowed to language cook book rifled "Waterblommetjie," remove most or all of the corms; if too many which has recipes that use the flowers in salads, are left they will produce high densities of souffles, casseroles, fritters, sweet cakes and on smaller plants with smaller flowers. Many cul- toast (Louw 1981). The unusual variety of rec- tivation practices are intended to produce larger, ipes in this book suggests that many of these are heavier flowers. They bring higher prices and 2000] PEMBERTON: APONOGETON 147

Fig. 3. Canned waterblommetjie from Riverside Fig. 2. Newly harvested waterblommetjie inflores- Farmer, Worcester, Cape Province, south Africa. Inflo- cences from plants cultivated in earthen dams. rescences are used as a green bean like vegetable. are more economical to harvest since a worker ten or so largest growers, has 17 ha of water- can pick a kilogram of large flowers more quick- blommetjie, which produce 5-10 tons of edible ly than a kilogram of small flowers. When har- flowers per ha/year. He markets these to chain vesting waterblommetjie, the flower stem is supermarkets and cans them under the Riverside pulled vertically which snaps it at the hydrosoil Farm label (Fig. 3). Van Tubbergh has sold as surface. This practice stimulates another stem to much as 800-900 kg/week to one of the chains. grow, enabling repeat harvests throughout the Waterblommetjie cultivation is a good comple- season. It is important to pick the flowers after ment to other crops such as wheat or wine pollination and seed set but before the seed are grapes since its labor intense harvest occurs in shed into the water. This results in larger flowers late winter and early spring when labor is less and reduces the seedling population of the fol- needed for other crops. lowing year. Fertilizers are used to induce faster growth and larger plants with more tender flow- DOMESTICATION ers. Flowers are picked when the bracts are During the relatively brief cultivation history green. Harvested flowers ripen to shades of pink, of waterblommetjie for food, the average size yellow, and red. During the harvest, guards are and weight of the flowers has increased substan- needed to protect the flowers from Egyptian tially. The branches of the inflorescences and in- geese and ducks which eat them. Algae, pond- fructescences in cultivated plants are longer, at weeds, and insects are also troublesome prob- times more than double the maximum lengths of lems which are worsened by the plant's sensitiv- 4.5 and 7 cm reported for those of wild plants ity to herbicides and insecticides. Corms for (Van Bruggen 1985). These increases might be propagation are selected from the dry ponds or due to both fertilization and the control of plant nursery beds planted with seed from the largest densities instead of genetic change. But since the flowers. In both cases, larger corms with single number of flowers per inflorescence can be 16 growth points (or cut to have a single growth or 17 in the cultivated plants compared to 7-12 points), are selected because these will produce and 10-15 flowers reported for wild plants larger plants. Danie van Tubbergh, one of the (Bond and Goldblatt 1984; Van Bruggen 1985), 148 ECONOMIC BOTANY [VOL. 54 there may have already been some genetic dif- comm.). This song is about the pride of living ferentiation in the cultivated plants. The practice in the western Cape (die Boland) and mentions of selecting seed from the largest flowers to famous places in the region. The chorus of the grow for seed corms is likely to promote genetic song is: change. It is unclear how much change has been selected in waterblommetjie's brief period of Waterblommetjie, let's make a stew of it, food crop domestication. One wonders if this Tell me you love me before we sleep. economically driven selection for large flowers The waterblommetjie food craze and associated has affected their taste. Stephen McVeigh (pers. increased cultivation of the plant may have been comm.) commented that they may not be as stimulated, in part, by Sonja Hergoldth's hit re- tasty as they used to be. Cultivation probably cording of this song (Gossen 1981). Not sur- increases the availability and decreases the cost prisingly, some of the Cape people of mixed of waterblommetjie. race and of English ancestry with whom I spoke, Traditionally, waterblommetjie was collected had little fondness for the song, even though from fresh water marshes and other shallow wa- they may enjoy waterblommetjie. ter bodies for private use or to sell at roadside But waterblommetjie still has prominence in stands and markets. Cultivation began during the new South Africa, a time when Afrikaans cul- late 1970s (S. McVeigh and E. Laubsher, pers. ture is subdued. The plant is promoted as a comm.). A waterblommetjie symposium involv- unique South African food that is pictured in ing growers, agronomists, and others interested recent South African Government tourist litera- in the food and marketing aspects of the plant ture. Waterblommetjie appears in upscale restau- first met at Stellenbosch in 1981 (Gossen 1981) rants, such as the Kaapse Tafel in Cape Town, and then again in 1986. and is common in chain supermarkets and pro- Domestication of waterblommetjie as a crop duce stands, when it is in season (primarily Au- appears to have begun for a variety of reasons, gust-October). Leisure magazines such as Coun- some of which must be novel in the history of try Life (March 1996) write about the plant and agriculture. Habitat loss due to urban develop- give recipes. Despite the enormous richness of ment, particularly in the Cape Flats, greatly lim- the Cape's flora (Bond and Goldblatt 1974), rel- ited collections of the flowers from wild popu- atively few plants are edible, arid no other native lations of the plant (S. McVeigh, pers. comm.). plant that I am aware of is cultivated for food. The urban expansion onto the Cape Flats was a Rooibos, Aspalathus linearis (Burm. f.) R. Dahl- product of the housing apartheid segregation gren (Leguminosae), is a shrub that is cultivated mandated by the South African Government. for use as tea. The fruits of sea fig, Caprobrotus Herbicides used in agriculture made their way edule (L.) N.E. Br.(Aizoaceae), are gathered and into water bodies where wild waterblommetjie sold in Cape Town markets. The claimed grew and killed the plants (E. Laubscher, pers. uniqueness of waterblommetjie is real. Water- comm.). In addition, a greatly increased demand blommetjie is an unlikely crop, a new crop not for waterblommetjie, described as a craze, based on nutritional need, but selected for cul- caused severe over-collecting of wild plants tivation by and because of the complex cultural- which threatened the plant's continued existence historical and technological-environmental (Gossen 1981). changes of its homeland. It is likely that other While waterblommetjie has a long history of food plants have been domesticated because of use in the Cape, it evolved into a kind of cultural the influences of politics and culture, including symbol of the Cape, particularly for Afrikaners. popular culture. People of English descent are more urban than Afrikaners and saw waterblommetjie as unso- phisticated country fare, at least prior to its tran- ACKNOWLEDGMENTS sition into a new gourmet food (D. van Tub- I wish to thank Danie van Tubbergh for inviting me to see his water- blommetjie ponds and for providing information and fruitful discussion, bergh, pers. comm.). Two Afrikaans language and his wife for making me a waterblommetjie hredie. I thank also Ste- singers, Sonja Hergoldth and Anton Gossen, phen McVeigh and Eddie Laubscher for helpful information and discus- made recordings of a song called "Waterblom- sion. I acknowledge the use of the libraries and kind help of the librarians at the Kirstenbosch Botanical Garden and the Department of Botany and metjie in die Boland" which were popular hits Zoology, University of Cape Town. I thank Yvette Ogle and David Sutton in the early 1980s (D. van Tubbergh, pers. for helpful reviews of an early version of the manuscript. 2000] PEMBERTON: APONOGETON 149

LITERATURE CITED 1994. Dedicated to quality on the shelf. Farm- er's Weekly (South Africa), May 20, pp. 48-49. Anderson, E. 1952. Plants, man, and life. Univ. Cal- Paxton, J., and P. Lindley (revised by T. Baines). ifornia Press, Berkeley. 1883. Paxton's flower garden. Vol. 2. Cassell and Bailey, L. H., and E. Z. Bailey and the staff of the Co. Ltd., London. Liberty Hyde Bailey Hortorium (Cornell Uni- Peters, C. P., E. M. O'Brien, and R. B. Drummond. versity). 1976. Hortus Third, a concise dictionary 1992. Edible wild plants of Sub-Saharan Africa. of plants cultivated in the United States and Can- Royal Botanical Gardens, Kew. ada. MacMillan, New York. Robins, M. 1994. The Cape cookbook. Chameleon Bond, P., and P. Goldblatt. 1984. Plants of the Cape Press, Diep River, South Africa. Flora, a descriptive catalogue. Journal of South Af- Sehmida, A., and R. It. Whittaker. 1981. Pattern and rican Botany Supplementary vol. no. 13. biological microsite effects in two shrub commu- Fox, F. W., and M. E. Norwood Young. 1982. Food nities, Southern California. Ecology 62:234-351. from the veld. Delta Books, Craighall, South Af- Thunberg, C. P. 1796. Travels in , Africa, and rica. Asia, made between the years 1770 and 1779.3rd. Gerber, H. 1957. Traditional cookery of the Cape Ma- ed., vol. 2-4, London. lays. A.A. Balkema, Amsterdam and Cape Town. Van Bruggen. 1985. Monograph of the genus Apon- Gossen, H. 1981. Cape water flowers bloom. South ogeton (Aponogetonaceae). Bibliotheca Botanica African Panorama (South Africa), Dec. 19-23. (Stuttgart, Germany) 33 (137):52,53,69. Hedrick, U. P. 1919. Sturtevant's edible plants of the Viljoen, B. 1994. Waterblommetjies for extra cash. world. Dover, New York. Farmer's Weekly (South Africa), Sept. 9, pp. 44- Hooker, W. J. 1831. Botanical miscellany, vol. 2. 45. London. Watt, J. M., and M. G. Breyer-Brandwijk. 1962. Louw, M. 1981. Waterblommetjies. Cumboeke Roo- Medical and poisonous plants of southern and east- depoort, Pretoria, South Africa [in Afrikaans]. ern Africa. 2nd ed. Livingstone, Edinburgh and Mabberley, D. J. 1993. The plant book. Cambridge London. Univ. Press, Cambridge, U.K. Zohary, D., and M. Hopf. 1994. Domestication of McVeigh, S. 1989. Viable waterblommetjie. Farmer's plants in the Old World. Oxford Univ. Press, Ox- Weekly (South Africa), April 14, pp. 18-19. ford.