Onchocerciasis, and Other Simulium ~Cies in Southem Sudan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
- .. ~ " ..... .J \, "'...!~ _t' .... ~ ....... lnsect predators of JarvaJ Simuilum damnosum Theobald, vector of onchocerciasis, and other Simulium ~cies in Southem Sudan . .' by -' Judith A. Schorscher Department of Entomology McGill University, Montref4, @ February 1985 A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research in partial fulfll1ment of the requirements for the degree of <9 Master of Science. f -1 - M.Sc. Judith A. Schorscher Dept. of Entomology , Insect predators of larval Simulium damnosum 5.1. Theobald, vector of oncho<:erciasis, and other Simulium spedes in Southem Sudan. ABSTRACT Over 800 aquatic jnsects associated ..vith the, larval stages of Simulium damnosum s.l. eollected' from Wau (Bahr-el-Ghazal Province), Southern Sudan, were disseèted and thek gut contents analysed to determine the importance of larval <:> 1 , black flies in their diet. , Rates of predation, numbers of different prey items in the diet, prey, preferences, variation of diet with age and seasonal distribution of the predaton were recorded. ln Southern Sudan the inseet exerting the greatest pressure on Jarval - Simuliidae is Cheumatopsyche digitata (Hydropsychidae: Trichoptera). It's j~portance may be attributed to it's high carnivory, it's preference for black fly larvae ôver other prey ite"ms and it's abundance. It is followed by 1 Ch. copiosa, a less carnivorous $pecies whose impact is due 'l'ainly to it's ~igh densities. Other insects with the potential to reduce blaek tly populations are Zygonyx Spa (t.ibellulidae: Odonata), Neoperla sp. (Perlidae: ~Iecoptera), and Cheumatopsyche Spa VlIJ. These three species, consumed the highest mean numt?er of black fly larvae pcr individual, and did not prey extensively on other important predators. Ali age :.---~ classes of Zygonyx were highly carnivorous and fed preferentially on Simulium Jarvae. However, Zygonyx, as weil as Neoperla and Cheumatopsyche Spa VIII , occurred in relatively low densities. ,----._-_ ........., _.._.- -_.-- -11- Les insectes pré dateur~ des larves de Simullum damnosum ,:tneobald, le vectetl( de l'onchocercose, et d'autres espèces de SjmuÎium, dans le Sud ~ Soudan. - . , RESUME Plus de 800 insectes aquatiques associé s aux stades pré imaglnaux de Slmultum damnosum 5.1. et collectlonés dans la région de Wau, province du Bahr~el-Ghazal (Sud Soudan), furent disèqués et leurs contenus stomacaux examtné!; pour détermtner l'importance des larves de Simulies dans leuf' régime alimentaire Les taux de prédation, le nombre de différentes protes dans l'estomac, les proies préferées, la variation du régime alimentaire avec l'age er la dlstnbutlon • '> saisonière des pré dateurs furent étudié s. L'espèce exerçant-la plus grande'- pression sur les populations pré imaglnales de Simulies est Cheumatopsyche digitata (Hydropsychldae: Trlchoptera). 50n_ importance . - stexplique par sa grande ,voracité, sa p~éterence pour les larves de Simulies et ses grands> nombres: Cette espèce est suivie par Cheumatopsyche copiosa, un I~secte moins vorace que son prOChe parent et dont l'impac~ peut surtout être attribué a sa haute densité. D'autes espèces q~,i ont te potentiel de réduire les populations de SlmulJes sont: Zygonyx $p. (libeUuJidae: Odonata), Neoperla sp. (Perlidae: Plecoptera) et CheumatopsYche sp. VItI. Ces trois espèces consomment les taux les plus é I,evé s de Simulies et ne se nourissent que rarement d'autres pré dateurs Importants. Les Zygonyx de toutes tailles sont exclusivement carnivo,res et se nourissent preterentieUement de larves de Simulium. Toutefois les dens! té s de Zygonyx amsl que de Neoperla et CheumatopsYche sp. VlII, sont relativement peu élevées. ------_ .._ ..... -. -----_._- _.. _--- -.- ---------- ~J -111- " Short title: PREDATORS OF LARVAL 8LACK PLIES IN SUDAN. by Judith A. SCHORSCHER " - .. "",< " i!''l,1 i ~ ~', f' 1 _" ":lV- AKNOWLEDGEMENTS The field work for this project was performed in Wau (Bahr-el-Chazal Region), Southern Sudan, in cooperation with the WHO (World Health Organization) project ~n "Research into the Effectivenes5 of LocaHzed Onchocerciasis Vector Control in Bahr-el-Ghazal Region, Sudan". The author was supported trom 1981 to 1983 by a Postgraduate Scholarship awarded by the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada. Throughout this project 1 received support and help from a large number of people. 1 would like to express my gratitude to the followmg persons: Dr. DavId J. LEWIS of McGill University, my thesis supervisor, for hlS support, cooperation and guidance. Dr. Frusal T. ABUSHAMMA, Deputy-Vice Chancellor, UnIVersity of Khartoum, my co-supervisor overseas, for his moral support and help with logistics and the organization of my research. Dr. Osman ABDELNUR, Senior Government Entomologist, National Public Health Laboratories, Khartoum and principal investigator of the onchocerciasis control project in Wau, who we1comed me to the project and provided me wlth information and Iiterature. Dr. Richard BAKER, WHO Consultant Entomologist, who shared with me ail the- facilities at his disposaI, his collections 'of associated fauna and his wealth of knowledge of Simullum ecology. 1 am grateful for his constant encouragement, fruitful discussion, enthusiasm and friendship. ! 1 , .-------- -v- " Dr. Kt.\MBAL from the Department of Zooiogy, University of Khartoum for hls kindness and praétlcal assistance wlth -nany mmor problems. The graduate students of the Departme"nt of Zoology, UnIversity of Khartoum, who welcomed me warmly and assisted me wherever they could. "'y special thanks go ta Ahmed e.l BAKRI, ABU GASM and HOUDA. "'Ir. Paul OCfLO, Mr. BatIsta 'JORO, \Ar. ElunaJ Ka}okole YOBü50N, \1r. John Joseph UCIN and \Ar. Nixon Ali MATTHEW k,mdly asslsted n'le tn the collection of specimens tram the river. Mr. OelLO and Mr. NORO also helped wlth the sortlng of specimens in the laboratory. would Iike ta express my appreclatlOn of thelrO thoroughness and competence. ~r. Splritu LEONE and Saeed Awad 15\1AIL participated as chauffeurs to most samplJng expeditlons. Mr. Ali Gasm el SID, felJow student m Wau for his kmdness tn provldmg me with extra specimens of Plecoptera nymphs from hls personal collection. 1 Dr. Terrie TAYLOR 0.0. physiclan wlth the Michigan State UnIversity Onchocercisis project in Wau, for her stimulating friendship and spint of sClentiflc " cooperation as weIl as her cheerful hospltality both in Khartoum and Wqu. Michigan State University for the loan of a binocular mIcroscope and laboratory space. J', Herr Rolf HAASE of the "Abili Girls Senior Secondary School, (\1bili, Bahr-el-Ghazal Province) for his generous hospitality and friendship, which greatly enhanced sampHng expeditions on the Sue River. The members of the JUR communities of Mbdi and 1\Iyiduk for their welcome and assistance in collecting specimens. -v~- Dr. T .R.E. SOUTHWOOD, Oxford University, England, for his welcome and assistance. The following members of the British Museum of Natural History, London for their prompt identification of specimens: Dr. P.C. BARNARD (Trichoptera), Dr. P.S. CRANSTON (Chironomidae), Dr. S.J. BROOKS (Odonata and Ephemeroptera). Dr. 'L. LANDS BURY of the Hope Department of Entomology, Oxford University, for identification of the Hemiptera. Dr. P.J. BOON, University of the West Indies, Kingston, for his interesttng corespondanre and for. forwarding me a copy of a manuscript in print as well as. ,J EM photographs of Trichoptera proventricular teeth. Dr. H.P. ZWICK, Limnologische Flussstation des Max-Plank-Instltüts fur Limnolo~}e, in Schlitz, West Germany, for identification of Plecoptera nym~hs. -, For numerous repr~nts on the taxonomy. of tropical HydrQpsychidae, Dr. B. /' STA TZNER, Zoologische Institut, Karlsruhe University, West Germany and nr. K. SCOTT, Albany Museum, Grahamstown, South Africa. Dr. René LeBERRE, Director WHO' Vector Control Unit, Geneva, for stimulating discussion, encouragement and support. Dr. J.-M. ELOUARD and Mr. F. GIB~N, Université de Paris-Sud, for sjlaring their extensive knowledge of ,aquatic invertebrates associated with the larvae of Simù1ium damnosum and providing me with unpublished manuscripts. -------- -vii - ~ r. P. LANGLOIS, Senior technician, Department of Entomology, \AcGill ,1 University, far;~'hls advice and assistance wlth ail aspects of photography. '1 '11 .. In Khartoum, Didier and Corinne RE'v\Y, for their frendship and help through dlfficult moments. Pascal GINAILHAC for his invaluable assistance with logistics, and Father Hubert BARBIER for his ald in shippmg equipment down ta Wau. David LEYIN- for his friendship, constant moral support and patient preof rèading of the text. DaVid GORDON and Gérald LAFLEUR, fellow students in the Department of Entomology, for. their assistance with statistics and the use of the computer. '\Ars. J. TAYLOR, Department of Entomology, Macdonald College, for patience and helpfulness. in printing the text. \ 1 Wayne FAIRCHILD and Richard WEBBER, feHow laboratory companions in the Department of Entomology, for théir ~e<tication ta providing entertaining ahd lively working conditions. " - - -_.. _--~_ .._,---_.-.~----- --------------------~ f' -vi i i- TABLE OP CONTENTS ABS'TRA.CT ••••••••' •••••••••• _ "le .................. ., ........................ i B!S1JItE •••••••• ., •••••~ •••••••••••••••••••••••••• ~ ••••••••••••••••••••• i'i ~ •••••••••••• _ ••••••••••.• _ ............................ iv . , ". LIST OF lICO'BBS ............. _ ....................- ......................... xi 1 LIST OP T.ABt.Es ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••xiii