Vena Dan 201810 Phd
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNFINISHED BUSINESS: THE NEW WAVE OF WOMEN’S HORROR CINEMA by Dan Vena A thesis submitted to the Graduate Program in Cultural Studies in conformity with the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario, Canada (December, 2018) Copyright © Dan Vena, 2018 Abstract My doctoral dissertation, “Unfinished Business: The New Wave of Women’s Horror Cinema,” responds to early considerations in feminist horror studies via the recent surge of horror films directed by women filmmakers for a primarily female audience. Placing this new wave of horror cinema in dialogue with the canonical works of Linda Williams, Carol Clover, and Barbara Creed, I re-evaluate the assumption that horror forecloses the possibility of female spectatorship in favour of male audiences. I argue that a change in authorship from almost exclusively male directors to women artists produces a markedly different form of address previously underrepresented in American and Canadian horror cinemas. Now, for the first time in the genre’s history, women directors are developing a globally substantial body of work that explicitly centres the ‘feminine’ and uses the conventions of horror to bridge topics such as sexuality, menstruation, virginity, gender-based violence, trauma/PTSD, eating disorders, pregnancy, and motherhood all from a woman’s perspective and for a female audience. The result is a cinema that affirms women’s experiences of fear, paranoia, anxiety, and desire, and addresses the ways in which living within patriarchy constitutes its own horror. Given this unprecedented development, the primary aim of this dissertation is to document the ways in which this new body of women-authored/women-driven horror re-inscribes the genre’s primary mode of address as distinctly female/feminine and constructs a tenable subject position for the female spectator. I stake a claim in recording this phenomenon as a crucial cultural moment in the genre’s development and suggest more work needs to be done to account for this cinema’s representational and political offerings. ii Acknowledgements This project emerged from a conversation I had with my colleague and dear friend Angie Fazekas. Many thanks go to Angie for encouraging me to pursue this line of inquiry and for permitting me to share her ideas. A deep amount of gratitude goes to my supervisor and mentor, Dr. Eleanor MacDonald. She has given me an incredible wealth of emotional support, intellectual guidance, and professional confidence over the course of my graduate career. Additionally, I thank her for her willingness to discuss and dissect the gory details of horror cinema with me, given her trepidation at the genre. She has shaped me, both as a person and as a scholar, for the better. I also offer thanks to my committee members and examiners, who have all provided insightful feedback on this project. To Dr. Scott MacKenzie, who came on board in the home stretch and graciously shared his passion for the genre with me. To Dr. Allison Morehead, who has always encouraged me to pursue the macabre. To Dr. Annette Burfoot and Dr. Christie Milliken, who both encouraged me to develop my scholarship in exciting directions. And to Dr. Samantha King, who weighed in during the early stages of my doctoral work and expressed enthusiasm for this project. Thanks also goes to all those who have taken care of me during the ups and downs of this process. Without them I would not have had the emotional, physical or financial resolve to complete this work. To my parents and grandparents, thank you for your sacrifice and for your love. To my compatriots – especially, Angie Fazekas, Aarzoo Singh, Robin Alex McDonald, and Tama De Szegheo Lang – for showing me endless supplies of care, compassion, and motivation. May I offer the same. Special thanks also go to Brittainy Bonnis, Stéfy McKnight, and Michelle Smith. I would also like to thank the staff and faculty at Queen’s Film and Media, who treated me as a welcomed colleague, especially Stephanie Wilson, Denise Arsenault, Professor Gary Kibbins and Professor Emily Pelstring. They have offered me employment, a space to work, and emotional support throughout this process. Also, I am appreciative of the passion and enthusiasm my students in FILM 331 and FILM 302 have shown for horror. I am particularly grateful to Erika Weir for her assistance in this project and to Patrick Woodstock. Lastly, I owe thanks to Colette Steer and Associate Dean Dr. Marta Straznicky, who have helped secure funding and have organized copious amounts of dissertation boot camps (at which a number of these chapters were written). This doctoral project was funded by Vanier Canada, Social Science and Humanities Research Council, Ontario Graduate Scholarships and Queen’s School of Graduate Studies. iii Table of Contents Abstract ......................................................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................................... iii Chapter 1 The Changing Face of Horror .......................................................................................................1 “What’s your favorite scary movie?” ......................................................................................................13 Chapter 2 Final Girls and Monstrous Women: Theorizing Female Representation and Spectatorship in Horror Cinema .............................................................................................................................................21 Cavernous Maws and Bloody Chain Saws ..............................................................................................22 Like Looking in a Mirror… .....................................................................................................................36 Chapter 3 Girls Just Want to Have Fun: Escaping Restriction in Kimberly Peirce’s Carrie (2013) ..........48 The Monstrous-Feminine .........................................................................................................................52 Beginnings ...............................................................................................................................................61 Entrances ..................................................................................................................................................65 Discoveries ...............................................................................................................................................73 Returns .....................................................................................................................................................79 Endings ....................................................................................................................................................84 Chapter 4 Hail Mary, Full of Rage: Avenging the Female Body in Jennifer and Sylvia Soska’s American Mary (2012) .................................................................................................................................................86 The Woman’s Revenge Film ...................................................................................................................89 Representing Rape ...................................................................................................................................92 Enacting Revenge ..................................................................................................................................100 Securing Victories ..................................................................................................................................113 Chapter 5 Taking a Bite: Horror as Female Fantasy in Catherine Hardwicke’s Twilight (2008) .............116 Staking a Claim to Horror ......................................................................................................................118 “I Know What I Want” ..........................................................................................................................128 Chapter 6 Don’t Stand So Close to Jennifer: Addressing Questions of Proximity, Spectatorship, and Genre with Karyn Kusama and Diablo Cody’s Jennifer’s Body (2009) ...................................................146 “Smart Bombs” ......................................................................................................................................150 “Someone’s Snack Pack” .......................................................................................................................154 Chapter 7 Unfinished Business: Concluding Thoughts on the New Wave of Women’s Horror Cinema .163 Filmography ...............................................................................................................................................173 Bibliography ..............................................................................................................................................177 iv Chapter 1 The Changing Face of Horror Typically qualified as a masculinist genre, the canon of English-language horror cinema has been historically dominated by auteurs such as Alfred Hitchcock, Brian De Palma, Roman Polanski and David Cronenberg, as well as independent artists like Tobe Hooper, Wes Craven, John Carpenter and George A. Romero, and celebrated B-producers