By Donald Matthew Moore Bachelor of Science Georgia Institute of Technology, 2005 Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requir

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

By Donald Matthew Moore Bachelor of Science Georgia Institute of Technology, 2005 Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requir THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF SOUTH CAROLINA'S 2012 REPUBLICAN PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY by Donald Matthew Moore Bachelor of Science Georgia Institute of Technology, 2005 Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of Master of Arts in Economics Darla Moore School of Business University of South Carolina 2014 Accepted by: Douglas P. Woodward, Director of Thesis Joseph C. Von Nessen, Reader Lacy Ford, Vice Provost and Dean of Graduate Studies © Copyright by Donald Matthew Moore, 2014 All Rights Reserved. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Three generations of South Carolina political leaders have promoted South Carolina’s “First in the South” presidential primary. With its early primary date, South Carolina receives considerable national and international publicity and would otherwise likely be “flyover country” for most presidential candidates. Instead, South Carolinians in both political parties now have a significant impact on picking the American president. Governor Jim Edwards (1975-1979) was a major force in giving the state Republican Party enough credibility to host a primary. His friend and campaign manager, former South Carolina Republican Party Chairman Dan Ross (1976-1980), shepherded the earlier primary date through the state Republican Party’s executive committee in September 1979. Over the three decades following, many political and media figures have made major contributions to South Carolina’s “First in the South” presidential primary status. I thank them for their guidance and interviews. I would also like to thank the talented researchers at the University of South Carolina for their valuable methodological guidance. Thank you also to the Federal Election Commission, the South Carolina Republican Party, various South Carolina political operatives, local chambers of commerce, Democracy in Action’s Eric Appleman, and Smart Media Group’s Kyle Roberts for providing valuable insights. iii ABSTRACT The 2011-2012 South Carolina Republican presidential primary cycle affected the state’s economy in multiple ways. Presidential campaigns, political parties, third party groups, and so-called Super PACs spent millions in television and radio advertisements. These entities and news networks also purchased goods and services and hired staff. Much of their spending originated from outside of South Carolina. Charleston, Greenville, Myrtle Beach, and Spartanburg hosted four economically significant, nationally televised presidential debates attended by thousands. A large degree of presidential primary activity, including the debates and staffing, took place in these four cities plus the capital city of Columbia. The primary also brought valuable marketing opportunities to the state, colleges, universities, and other areas that hosted events. The key finding of this thesis is that the 2012 South Carolina presidential primary generated a total of $19.5 million in statewide, value-added economic activity and supported approximately 289 full-time equivalent (FTE), non-permanent jobs earning approximately $10 million in employee compensation. Every ten FTE, non-permanent jobs during the 2012 South Carolina Republican presidential primary supported approximately five FTE, non-permanent jobs in the South Carolina economy over the twelve-month primary period. Finally, the presidential primary generated nearly $30 million in statewide marketing value. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................................ iii ABSTRACT .......................................................................................................................... iv LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................................. vii LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..................................................................................................... ix CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND ..................................................................... 1 CHAPTER 2: REVIEW OF EXISTING RESEARCH ..................................................................... 4 CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................... 6 CHAPTER 4: IMPLAN INPUTS ............................................................................................. 9 4.1 PUBLICLY REPORTED SPENDING BY CANDIDATES .............................................. 11 4.2 SPENDING ON TELEVISION AND RADIO ADS ....................................................... 11 4.3 PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY DEBATES ..................................................................... 12 4.4 OTHER EVENTS ................................................................................................... 15 4.5 EMBEDDED REPORTERS ...................................................................................... 16 CHAPTER 5: TOTAL ECONOMIC IMPACT ............................................................................. 17 5.1 STATEWIDE ESTIMATE ........................................................................................ 17 5.2 REGIONAL REPORT - LOWCOUNTRY ................................................................... 19 5.3 REGIONAL REPORT - MIDLANDS ......................................................................... 21 5.4 REGIONAL REPORT – PEE DEE ........................................................................... 21 5.5 REGIONAL REPORT – ROCK HILL ....................................................................... 22 5.6 REGIONAL REPORT – UPSTATE ........................................................................... 23 v CHAPTER 6: MARKETING VALUE ....................................................................................... 24 CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSION .................................................................................................. 28 REFERENCES ...................................................................................................................... 29 APPENDIX A – INTERVIEWS ............................................................................................... 31 vi LIST OF TABLES Table 4.1 – Regional Definitions within South Carolina .................................................... 9 Table 4.2 – 2011-2012 Primary Spending in South Carolina by Candidate ..................... 11 Table 4.3 – 2011-12 South Carolina Presidential Primary TV & Radio Buys ................. 12 Table 4.4 – Est. Spending on January 16, 2012 Myrtle Beach Debate ............................. 13 Table 4.5 – Estimated Presidential Debate Spending ....................................................... 15 Table 4.6 – Estimated Special Events Spending ............................................................... 15 Table 5.1 – Statewide Economic Impact of the 2012 S.C. Republican Presidential Primary .................................................................................................................. 17 Table 5.2 – Top 10 Industry Sectors by Value Added ...................................................... 20 Table 5.3 – Statewide Economic Impact of the 2012 S.C. Republican Presidential Primary in the Lowcountry ................................................................................... 21 Table 5.4 – Statewide Economic Impact of the 2012 S.C. Republican Presidential Primary in the Midlands ........................................................................................ 21 Table 5.5 – Statewide Economic Impact of the 2012 S.C. Republican Presidential Primary in the Pee Dee ......................................................................................... 22 Table 5.6 – Statewide Economic Impact of the 2012 S.C. Republican Presidential Primary in Rock Hill ............................................................................................. 22 Table 5.7 – Statewide Economic Impact of the 2012 S.C. Republican Presidential Primary in the Upstate .......................................................................................... 23 Table 6.1 – Estimated Marketing Value of the January 16, 2012 Myrtle Beach Presidential Debate ............................................................................................... 25 Table 6.2 – Applicants to Wofford College by Year ........................................................ 26 Table 6.3 – Nielsen Ratings of South Carolina Primary Debates ..................................... 26 vii Table 6.4 – Estimated Marketing Value of South Carolina Primary Debates .................. 27 viii LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS FTE ...................................................................................................... Full-time Equivalent FEC ........................................................................................ Federal Election Commission IMPLAN .............................................................................. IMpact analysis for PLANning MBACC ........................................................... Myrtle Beach Area Chamber of Commerce PAC ........................................................................................... Political Action Committee RNC ................................................................................... Republican National Committee SCGOP .............................................................................. South Carolina Republican Party ix CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND This thesis aims to assess the statewide economic impact of the 2011-2012
Recommended publications
  • 2020 Silver Elephant Dinner
    SOUTH CAROLINA REPUBLICAN PARTY THE ROAD TO THE WHITE HOUSE 53rd ANNUAL SILVER ELEPHANT PRE-RECEPTION SOUTH CAROLINA REPUBLICAN PARTY THE ROAD TO THE WHITE HOUSE 53rd ANNUAL SILVER ELEPHANT GUEST SOUTH CAROLINA REPUBLICAN PARTY THE ROAD TO THE WHITE HOUSE 53rd ANNUAL SILVER ELEPHANT STAFF SOUTH CAROLINA REPUBLICAN PARTY THE ROAD TO THE WHITE HOUSE 53rd ANNUAL SILVER ELEPHANT PRESS SOUTH CAROLINA REPUBLICAN PARTY THE ROAD TO THE WHITE HOUSE 53RD ANNUAL SILVER ELEPHANT DINNER • 2020 FTS-SC-RepParty-2020-SilverElephantProgram.indd 1 9/8/20 9:50 AM never WELCOME CHAIRMAN DREW MCKISSICK Welcome to the 2020 Silver Elephant Gala! For 53 years, South Carolina Republicans have gathered together each year to forget... celebrate our party’s conservative principles, as well as the donors and activists who help promote those principles in our government. While our Party has enjoyed increasing success in the years since our Elephant Club was formed, we always have to remember that no victories are ever perma- nent. They are dependent on our continuing to be faithful to do the fundamen- tals: communicating a clear conservative message that is relevant to voters, identifying and organizing fellow Republicans, and raising the money to make it all possible. As we gather this evening on the anniversary of the tragic terrorists attacks on our homeland in 2001, we’re reminded about what’s at stake in our elections this year - the protection of our families, our homes, our property, our borders and our fundamental values. This year’s election offers us an incredible opportunity to continue to expand our Party.
    [Show full text]
  • Haley Confirmed As UN Ambassador
    IN SPORTS: Lakewood basketball plays host to Hartsville B1 PANORAMA Christian Charities celebrates 35 years Volunteer organization SERVING SOUTH CAROLINA SINCE OCTOBER 15, 1894 focuses on feeding hungry C1 WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2017 75 CENTS Haley confirmed as UN Ambassador Then-S.C. Governor McMaster takes over as governor nation letter immediately made Lt. Gov. Henry Nikki Haley testifies McMaster the 91st governor of South Carolina. on Capitol Hill in COLUMBIA (AP) — Gov. Nikki Haley re- Before McMaster was officially sworn in, Washington on Jan. signed Tuesday as South Carolina’s CEO to be- Haley addressed a crowd in the Capitol lobby. 18 at her hearing come the U.S. ambassador to the United Na- “There’s lots of work to do, but we have the before the Senate tions, giving the state’s helm to an early back- right person to do it,” she said about McMas- Foreign Relations er of President Donald Trump. ter. “It’s an absolute privilege and honor to Committee. Haley’s Haley turned in her resignation letter min- turn over the reins to you.” nomination was ap- utes after the U.S. Senate confirmed her as The South Carolina-born daughter of Indian proved. Trump’s Cabinet pick. THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Under the state constitution, Haley’s resig- SEE HALEY, PAGE A6 SCHOOL DISTRICT $22M loan a standard tax anticipation note Money needed earlier this year because of debt crisis BY BRUCE MILLS [email protected] Given its debt crisis and low general fund balance, Sumter School District will need to issue a larger operations loan than usual and also do it sooner than usual this year, according to outside finance consultant Scott Allan.
    [Show full text]
  • Boeing Workers Vote 'No'
    IN SPORTS: East Clarendon takes on Scott’s Branch in girls’ basketball playoffs B1 RANGER OF THE YEAR Thomas McCants wins national award for 2016 A3 FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 17, 2017 | Serving South Carolina since October 15, 1894 75 cents Boeing workers vote ‘no’ Union bid fails in South; facility set to host Trump COLUMBIA (AP) — Boeing workers’ over- against representation. whelming anti-union vote at the aviation gi- It was a massive victory for union oppo- ant’s 787 Dreamliner plant in South Carolina nents, in line with longstanding Southern is a big victory for Southern politicians and aversion to collective bargaining. At 1.6 per- business leaders who have lured manufactur- cent, South Carolina maintains the lowest ing jobs to the region on the promise of keep- percentage of unionized workers in the coun- ing unions out. try, according to U.S. Bureau of Labor Statis- It’s also a win for the company that will tics. host President Trump at its North Charleston In a statement on the union election, Boeing facilities Friday. vice president and general manager Joan Nearly 3,000 workers were eligible to vote Robinson-Berry looked past the decisive vote THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Wednesday on representation by the Interna- to Trump’s visit. An engine and part of a wing from the 100th 787 Dreamliner that’s tional Association of Machinists and Aero- “It is great to have this vote behind us as we being built at Boeing of South Carolina’s North Charleston facility space workers. According to Boeing, nearly 74 come together to celebrate that event,” she are shown Tuesday outside the plant.
    [Show full text]
  • SCGOP 2011 Fourth Quarter Minutes
    South Carolina Republican Party Fourth Quarter Executive Committee Meeting Minutes IT-ology, October 15, 2011 On Saturday, October 15, 2011 the Fourth Quarter South Carolina Republican Party Executive Committee meeting was called to order at 10:00am by SCGOP Chairman Chad Connelly. The invocation was given by Mrs. Jo Ann Burroughs, the Executive Committeewoman from Greenwood County, and the Pledge of Allegiance was given by Mr. KT Ruthven, Executive Committeeman from Aiken County. The Republican Creed was led by Mr. Moye Graham, the Chairman from Clarendon County. Following the creed, DeLinda Ridings, SCGOP Secretary, reported that 34 counties were represented and that a quorum was present. On a motion by Mr. McCall, seconded by Mr. Johnson, the agenda was approved without objection. On a motion by Mrs. Costa and a second by Mrs. Aiken the minutes from August 27, 2011 were approved without objection. Chairman Connelly recognized Mr. Stacey Swimp to speak for three minutes. Mr. Swimp is the President of the Frederick Douglass Foundation of Michigan and was visiting South Carolina. He spoke on the importance of black voters not being recognized by their color but by their conservatism. Treasurer’s Report Chairman Connelly recognized Mr. Dan Herren, the Executive Committeeman from Greenville County, to give the SCGOP Treasurer’s Report. Mr. Herren stated that the party was in good financial footing for the year. The year-to-date income was $800,342 ($746,850 projected) which 107% of the budget. Mr. Herren further stated that Chairman Connelly is operating under budget and doing a great job in saving the party’s resources.
    [Show full text]
  • The Governorship of Mark Sanford
    PICKING WINNERS AND LOSERS: THE GOVERNORSHIP OF MARK SANFORD by DANIEL KANSO (Under the Direction of Charles S. Bullock III) ABSTRACT Focused from 2003 to 2011, I argue that the flawed execution of executive leadership under Governor Mark Sanford directly contributed to his administration’s failure to accomplish his central goal of reforming South Carolina’s fiscal policies. By evaluating Sanford’s two terms in office, I demonstrate that he contributed to a legislative dynamic that divided Republican leaders and ultimately weakened the authority held by the governor’s office. This thesis relies on an analysis of media coverage, and most directly, draws upon independently conducted interviews with: Mark Sanford, his chiefs of staff Fred Carter, Tom Davis, and Scott English, legislative liaison Chip Campsen, and more than thirty individuals, ranging from legislators to party chairmen. INDEX WORDS: South Carolina; Republican Party; Governor; Executive power PICKING WINNERS AND LOSERS: THE GOVERNORSHIP OF MARK SANFORD by DANIEL KANSO BA, The University of Georgia, 2015 A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree MASTER OF ARTS ATHENS, GEORGIA 2016 © 2016 DANIEL KANSO All Rights Reserved PICKING WINNERS AND LOSERS: THE GOVERNORSHIP OF MARK SANFORD by DANIEL KANSO Major Professor: Charles S. Bullock III Committee: Susan B. Haire M.V. Hood III Electronic Version Approved: Suzanne Barbour Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia December 2016 TABLE
    [Show full text]
  • Retirement Celebration Longtime Morris College President Luns Richardson Steps Down After 43 Years by BRUCE MILLS [email protected]
    IN SPORTS: Sumter baseball opens playoffs with 1-0 victory over Blythewood B1 ART OPENING Pair of young artists’ exhibits challenge viewers A3 THURSDAY, APRIL 27, 2017 | Serving South Carolina since October 15, 1894 75 cents Officers cleared PHOTO PROVIDED Morris College President Luns Richardson, left, is greeted by alum and state Rep. David Weeks, D-Sumter, on Tuesday night. Retirement celebration Longtime Morris College President Luns Richardson steps down after 43 years BY BRUCE MILLS [email protected] “Where there is no vision, the people perish PHOTOS BY RICK CARPENTER / THE SUMTER ITEM ... “ is an often-cited Biblical proverb. Many Third Judicial District Solicitor Ernest “Chip” Finney III points to evidence Wednesday from a Sumter police officer’s dignitaries who spoke Tuesday night during body camera that illustrates the suspect had an automatic weapon when he was tackled by a police officer. Police offi- Luns Richardson’s retirement celebration at cers fired 19 shots into Waltki Cermoun Williams’ body after they think he fired the weapon during a foot chase. Morris College portrayed him as the leader needed to provide the proper direction for the college when he arrived on campus in 1974 as 3 Sumter policemen justified in deadly shooting the school’s new president. At that time, the college was non-accredited and struggling to keep its doors open. BY ADRIENNE SARVIS “It takes vision to see a way out of nowhere,” [email protected] said Roy Jones, executive director of the Call Me Mister program headquartered at Clemson Third Judicial Circuit Solicitor University. “President Richardson has been a Ernest “Chip” Finney III an- man of that vision.
    [Show full text]
  • How to Stay Married (And Why) by Belinda Luscombe
    JUNE 13, 2016 How To Stay Married (and why) By Belinda Luscombe time.com VOL. 187, NO. 22 | 2016 4 | Conversation The View 6 | For the Record Ideas, opinion, The Brief innovations News from the U.S. and 21 | Jeffrey Kluger around the world on the death of 9 | What’s behind a Harambe the gorilla The Gospel According recent spate of digital and the fallacy of to Trump bank heists parent-shaming 10 | Mass pardons 22 | A book about the throughout the world present—as seen from the future 12 | Ian Bremmer: By Elizabeth Dias 30 Why Brexit could 25 | Behind the trigger turmoil idea of Islamic exceptionalism 14 | Some states end the tampon tax 26 | E-bikes face an uphill battle in the U.S. 14 | The cell-phone- cancer link 28 | Joe Klein on how Hillary Clinton can 15 | Will Brazil pull off beat Donald Trump at the Olympics? winning the news cycle 16 | Ethiopia’s megadam 18 | A deadly start to summer intensifes the migrant crisis Time Of 59 | Paul Simon’s great What to watch, read, latest album see and do Trump is endorsed by Jerry Falwell Jr., president of Liberty University 60 | Movies: Popstar 53 | ESPN docu O.J.: and The Fits Made in America 61 | Quick Talk with 55 | Emma Cline’s Emilia Clarke; a review Cover Story debut novel, The Girls of Me Before You How to Stay Hitched 56 | New music from 63 | Susanna Tegan and Sara and Schrobsdorff on Chance the Rapper learning to talk like a college student TRUMP: PATRICK SEMANSKY—AP; SIMPSON: SPORTING NEWS/GETTY IMAGES By Belinda Luscombe 36 64 | 13 Questions for General Motors CEO Mary Barra Trailblazers for the Next Generation 42 O.J.
    [Show full text]
  • Sumter Senior Services WEDNESDAY, MAY 3, 2017 $1.00 Council Parnell Wins Dem Primary Approves GOP Candidates Norman, Pope Head for Runoff in SC-5 Race
    LOCAL: He’s ba-ack! Lizard Man heading to big screen A2 PANORAMA Hop downtown Microbrew Festival returns May 12 to raise money for C1 SERVING SOUTH CAROLINA SINCE OCTOBER 15, 1894 Sumter Senior Services WEDNESDAY, MAY 3, 2017 $1.00 Council Parnell wins Dem primary approves GOP candidates Norman, Pope head for runoff in SC-5 race BY JIM HILLEY Goldman Sachs tax adviser was easily “Tonight’s results show there is so zoning [email protected] outdistancing his Democratic prima- much energy and support across the ry opponents with more than 70 per- 5th Congressional District,” Parnell Democrat Archie Parnell will have cent of the vote, meaning he will said. “I’m proud to be your nominee.” to wait two weeks to see who his Re- avoid a runoff against either Alexis In the 5th Congressional District changes publican opponent will be in the Frank (21 percent) or Les Murphy (7 Republican primary, two York County South Carolina 5th Congressional percent). Those results were as of 10 residents, former state Rep. Ralph District election set for June 20. p.m. Tuesday with nine of 11 counties BY JIM HILLEY The Sumter resident and former reporting. SEE RESULTS, PAGE A6 [email protected] Sumter City Council breezed through a light agenda at its regular meeting in Sumter Opera House’s City Council Hitching a ride Chambers on Tuesday. Council received an update from City Manager Deron Mc- Cormick on progress on the budget for fiscal year 2018, which begins July 1. He said staff was spending a lot of its time working on the general PHOTO PROVIDED MCCORMICK fund and through After casting their votes, Sumter native cost-cutting mea- and 5th Congressional District candidate Ar- sures had reduced chie Parnell and his wife, Sarah, greeted vot- the projected deficit to $2.2 mil- ers at Cut Rate Drugs, where a number of lion.
    [Show full text]