The Unsung Hero Character: a Harbinger Device of Misfortune
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
East Tennessee State University Digital Commons @ East Tennessee State University Electronic Theses and Dissertations Student Works 5-2019 The nsU ung Hero Character: A Harbinger Device of Misfortune Eutimio Talavera East Tennessee State University Follow this and additional works at: https://dc.etsu.edu/etd Part of the American Film Studies Commons, Folklore Commons, Indian and Aboriginal Law Commons, Indigenous Studies Commons, and the Other Theatre and Performance Studies Commons Recommended Citation Talavera, Eutimio, "The nU sung Hero Character: A Harbinger Device of Misfortune" (2019). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. Paper 3564. https://dc.etsu.edu/etd/3564 This Thesis - Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Works at Digital Commons @ East Tennessee State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ East Tennessee State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Unsung Hero Character: A Harbinger Device of Misfortune A thesis presented to the faculty of the Department of Curriculum and Instruction East Tennessee State University In partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree Master of Arts in Reading with a concentration in Storytelling by Eutimio Talavera, Jr. May 2019 Amber Kinser, PhD, Chair Delanna Reed, PhD Ed Dwyer, PhD Keywords: indigenous, storytelling, narratee, abreactor, prefiguration, cinelogue, mentation ABSTRACT The Unsung Hero Character: A Harbinger Device of Misfortune by Eutimio Talavera, Jr. This thesis introduces an obscure storytelling device, The Unsung Hero character, as one way of examining how movies function as stories. This character is often overlooked, as it frequently cloaks its idiosyncrasies, thus it lacks any apparent signs of internal conflict. This analysis foregrounds the character’s overall functionality, found only in rare instances and typically in the story of a movie. With effective implementation in a story, as a functional harbinger device, brief appearances of The Unsung Hero character demonstrate flashpoints or disclosures of a forthcoming misfortune in the story. This movie analysis shows how The Unsung Hero character functions effectively as a harbinger device in stories. 2 DEDICATION To all whom I care for, especially those who have passed on. 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT......................................................................................................................................2 DEDICATION..................................................................................................................................3 Chapter 1. INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................................6 Le Révolution de Scruffee...................................................................................................12 Alienation and Misrepresentation........................................................................................16 2. REVIEW OF LITERATURE.....................................................................................................23 The Sacred...........................................................................................................................24 Purging Pragmatism..............................................................................................25 The Secular.........................................................................................................................35 Realistic Realizations............................................................................................36 Reconstructing Realism.........................................................................................38 Synthesizing Shamanism....................................................................................................41 Performance Storytelling.......................................................................................41 The Shamanism Complex.........................................................................47 Cinematic Effusions..............................................................................................51 3. METHODS.................................................................................................................................54 4. ANALYSIS.................................................................................................................................61 Content Analysis: The Warriors (Gordan & Hill, 1979) ....................................................62 Story.......................................................................................................................62 Flawless Entrance: The Unsung Hero.................................................................................64 The Matriarchal Co-optation of the Masculine Archetype.................................................64 The dramatis personae: Cyrus...............................................................................65 Indirectly Inducing the Feminine Archetype by the Trickster Character............................66 The dramatis personae: Cleon...............................................................................66 The dramatis personae: Fox..................................................................................67 The dramatis personae: Ajax................................................................................67 The dramatis personae: Policewoman......................................................68 4 The dramatis personae: The NYPD......................................................................69 The dramatis personae: Swan...............................................................................71 Swan’s Dagger Motif.................................................................................72 The dramatis personae: D.J..................................................................................73 The dramatis personae: The Lizzies.....................................................................74 The dramatis personae: Rembrandt......................................................................75 The dramatis personae: The Furies......................................................................76 The dramatis personae: Mercy.............................................................................78 5. DISCUSSION and CONCLUSION...........................................................................................81 Enter the Harbinger...........................................................................................................81 Exit the Device..................................................................................................................83 Storytelling Essence of the Movie Apparatus...................................................................84 The dramatis personae: Masai.............................................................................84 Shadow of the Harbinger..................................................................................................85 Idiosyncratic Robustness of the Harbinger: The Lack Thereof........................................87 Character and Conflict..........................................................................................87 The dramatis personae: Candy Store Girl................................................89 Trickster Catharsis............................................................................................................90 Endnote.............................................................................................................................92 6. LIMITATIONS..........................................................................................................................98 Adverse Ramifications to the Analysis.............................................................................98 Sex: Gender Relations.......................................................................................................99 Performance Storytelling Ramifications..........................................................................101 Vocalization Ramifications.................................................................................101 Cultural Ramifications........................................................................................102 7. FUTURE DIRECTIONS..........................................................................................................103 “‘Transmodern’” Challenges...........................................................................................104 REFERENCES..............................................................................................................................105 APPENDIX: Integral Members of The Warriors..........................................................................111 VITA.............................................................................................................................................112 5 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION I am an enrolled member with a Federally recognized Native American tribal nation, but I did not always know this about myself. My upbringing consisted of a slew of migrations with my immediate family members back and forth to Chicago, Illinois to many random locations throughout the United States. At about the age of eight, I would encounter the first in