Verbatim Transcription of the 170Th CFMC Virtual Meeting
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 2 3 Table of Contents .............................................. 1 4 5 Table of Motions ............................................... 3 6 7 Call to Order and Roll Call .................................... 4 8 9 Swearing in of New Council Members ............................. 8 10 11 Election of Officers ........................................... 9 12 13 Adoption of Agenda ............................................. 9 14 15 Consideration of the 169th Meeting Verbatim Transcription ...... 12 16 17 Executive Director’s Report ................................... 12 18 19 Queen Conch Model Presentation ................................ 17 20 21 SSC Report .................................................... 22 22 23 Ecosystem Technical Advisory Panel Member Discussion .......... 29 24 25 Ecosystem-Based Fishery Management Technical AP Report ........ 34 26 27 Southeast Fisheries Science Center Update ..................... 37 28 29 Gear Discussion - Allowable Gear Types ........................ 56 30 31 Best Fishing Practices Presentation ........................... 86 32 33 Anchoring Discussion - Grammanik Bank ......................... 96 34 35 Public Comment Period ........................................ 111 36 37 Island-Based Fishery Management Plans Update ................. 118 38 39 Options Paper for Updating Spiny Lobster Annual Catch Limit on 40 Island-Based Fishery Management Plans Based on SEDAR 57 ...... 119 41 42 Discussion of Yellowtail Snapper Recreational Bag Limit Under 43 the St. Croix Fishery Management Plan ........................ 143 44 45 Outreach and Education Advisory Panel Report ................. 152 46 47 Enforcement Reports .......................................... 156 48 Puerto Rico DNER ........................................ 156 1 1 USVI DPNR ............................................... 158 2 U.S. Coast Guard ........................................ 158 3 NOAA Fisheries Office of Law Enforcement ................ 159 4 5 Other Business ............................................... 162 6 7 Adjournment .................................................. 170 8 9 - - - 10 2 1 TABLE OF MOTIONS 2 3 PAGE 30: Motion to nominate Dr. Edwin Cruz-Rivera as a member 4 of the TAP. The motion carried on page 31. 5 6 PAGE 33: Motion to nominate Dr. Michelle Scharer as a member of 7 the SSC. The motion carried on page 33. 8 9 PAGE 76: Motion that the council requests staff begins work on 10 an amendment to the island-based FMPs that would allow for the 11 use of the deep-water snapper buoy gear with no more than 12 twenty-five hooks per line. The motion carried on page 78. 13 14 PAGE 81: Motion that the council request staff to begin work on 15 an amendment to each of the IBFMPs to consider whether gill and 16 trammel nets or any other applicable gear should be authorized 17 gears when fishing for managed species. The motion carried on 18 page 86. 19 20 PAGE 138: Motion that the council request the SSC to coordinate 21 with the Science Center to provide a constant ABC for spiny 22 lobster for each island group based on SEDAR 57 and based on the 23 first three years of the ABC projection from 2021 to 2023. It 24 is the council intent to request an interim assessment to be 25 conducted in 2023 to set catch levels for 2024 and beyond. The 26 motion carried on page 140. 27 28 PAGE 151: Motion to instruct the staff prepare an options paper 29 for the yellowtail recreational fishery of St. Croix that would 30 be considered at the spring meeting of the CFMC meeting 2021. 31 The motion carried on page 151. 32 33 - - - 34 3 1 CARIBBEAN FISHERY MANAGEMENT COUNCIL 2 170TH REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 3 Webinar 4 5 AUGUST 11-12, 2020 6 7 The Caribbean Fishery Management Council convened via webinar on 8 Tuesday morning, August 11, 2020, and was called to order at 9 9:00 o’clock a.m. by Chairman Marcos Hanke. 10 11 CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL 12 13 MARCOS HANKE: Today is August 11, and it’s 9:02 a.m., and we’re 14 going to start the meeting. Natalia, can you start with the 15 roll call first? 16 17 NATALIA PERDOMO: Yes. First, I have Graciela Garcia-Moliner. 18 19 GRACIELA GARCIA-MOLINER: Graciela Garcia-Moliner, council 20 staff. Good morning. 21 22 NATALIA PERDOMO: Liajay Rivera. 23 24 LIAJAY RIVERA: Liajay Rivera, council staff. Buenos dias. 25 26 NATALIA PERDOMO: Miguel Rolon. 27 28 MIGUEL ROLON: Miguel Rolon, council staff, present. 29 30 NATALIA PERDOMO: Jack McGovern. 31 32 JACK MCGOVERN: Jack McGovern, NOAA Fisheries. Good afternoon. 33 34 NATALIA PERDOMO: Roy Crabtree. 35 36 ROY CRABTREE: Roy Crabtree, NOAA Fisheries. 37 38 NATALIA PERDOMO: Alida Ortiz. 39 40 ALIDA ORTIZ: Alida Ortiz, Outreach and Education Advisory 41 Panel. Buenos dias. 42 43 NATALIA PERDOMO: Bill Cordero. 44 45 BILL CORDERO: Bill Cordero, language interpreter 46 extraordinaire. Good morning. 47 48 NATALIA PERDOMO: Carlos Farchette. 4 1 2 CARLOS FARCHETTE: Carlos Farchette, council member, present. 3 4 NATALIA PERDOMO: Carlos Velazquez. 5 6 CARLOS VELAZQUEZ: Good morning. Carlos Velazquez, commercial 7 fishermen, President of the Fishermen’s Incorporation in 8 Naguabo. 9 10 NATALIA PERDOMO: Chelsea. Christina Olan. Damaris Delgado. 11 12 DAMARIS DELGADO: Damaris Delgado, Puerto Rico DNER, Good 13 morning. 14 15 NATALIA PERDOMO: Edward Schuster. 16 17 EDWARD SCHUSTER: Edward Schuster. Good morning. DAP Chair. 18 19 NATALIA PERDOMO: Thank you. Jocelyn D’Ambrosio. 20 21 JOCELYN D’AMBROSIO: Jocelyn D’Ambrosio, NOAA Office of General 22 Counsel. 23 24 NATALIA PERDOMO: Jorge Torez. Julian Magras. 25 26 JULIAN MAGRAS: Julian Magras, DAP Chair, St. Thomas/St. John. 27 Good morning. 28 29 NATALIA PERDOMO: Loren Remsberg. 30 31 LOREN REMSBERG: Loren Remsberg, NOAA Office of General Counsel. 32 Good morning. 33 34 NATALIA PERDOMO: Manny Antonaras. 35 36 MANNY ANTONARAS: Good morning. Manny Antonaras, NOAA Office of 37 Law Enforcement. 38 39 NATALIA PERDOMO: Marcos Hanke. 40 41 MARCOS HANKE: Marcos Hanke, present. 42 43 NATALIA PERDOMO: María de los Irizarry. 44 45 MARIA DE LOS IRIZARRY: Good morning. María de los Irizarry, 46 council staff. 47 48 NATALIA PERDOMO: Maria Lopez. 5 1 2 MARIA LOPEZ: Good morning. Maria Lopez, NOAA Fisheries. 3 4 NATALIA PERDOMO: Matthew Wailea. 5 6 MATTHEW WAILEA: Good morning. Matt Wailea, NOAA Office of Law 7 Enforcement. 8 9 NATALIA PERDOMO: Michelle Scharer. 10 11 MICHELLE SCHARER: Buenos dias. Michelle Scharer, independent 12 contractor. 13 14 NATALIA PERDOMO: Morgan Corey. Nelson Crespo. 15 16 NELSON CRESPO: Good morning, everyone. Nelson Crespo, DAP 17 Chair, Puerto Rico. 18 19 NATALIA PERDOMO: Nelson Earhart. 20 21 NELSON EHRHARDT: Nelson Ehrhardt, University of Miami and 22 independent contractor. Good morning. 23 24 NATALIA PERDOMO: Nicole Angeli. 25 26 NICOLE ANGELI: Nicole Angeli, USVI, Division of Fish and 27 Wildlife, here. 28 29 NATALIA PERDOMO: Orian Tzadik. 30 31 ORIAN TZADIK: Orian Tzadik, the Pew Charitable Trusts. 32 33 NATALIA PERDOMO: Ricardo Lopez. 34 35 RICARDO LOPEZ: Ricardo Lopez, Puerto Rico DNER Fisheries 36 Research Lab. 37 38 NATALIA PERDOMO: Richard Appeldoorn. 39 40 RICHARD APPELDOORN: Rich Appeldoorn, SSC Chair. 41 42 NATALIA PERDOMO: Robert Copeland. 43 44 ROBERT COPELAND: Lieutenant Robert Copeland, U.S. Coast Guard, 45 District 7, present. 46 47 NATALIA PERDOMO: Sarah Stephenson. 48 6 1 SARAH STEPHENSON: Good morning. Sarah Stephenson, NOAA 2 Fisheries. 3 4 NATALIA PERDOMO: Shannon Calay. 5 6 SHANNON CALAY: Good morning. Shannon Calay, NOAA Fisheries, 7 Miami. 8 9 NATALIA PERDOMO: Vanessa Ramirez. 10 11 VANESSA RAMIREZ: Good morning. Vanessa Ramirez, council 12 member, commercial fisherman, Puerto Rico. 13 14 NATALIA PERDOMO: I have a Caller 2, but I don’t know if it’s 15 somebody that already stated their name, if Caller Number 2 can 16 say their name. 17 18 MIGUEL BORGES: It’s maybe myself. This is Miguel Borges, NOAA 19 Office of Law Enforcement. 20 21 NATALIA PERDOMO: Thank you. That’s it. 22 23 IRIS OLIVERAS: Excuse me. Iris Oliveras, council staff. 24 25 TONY BLANCHARD: Good morning. Tony Blanchard, CFMC, Vice 26 Chair. 27 28 MARCOS HANKE: Thank you, Natalia. I want to recognize that 29 Tony Blanchard is together with Julian Magras in St. Thomas, and 30 thank you for very for both of you to connect that way, which 31 last time was very efficient, and, like I mentioned, on this 32 170th CFMC virtual meeting, again, it’s 9:08 a.m. 33 34 The meeting rules for participation are you have to state your 35 name every time you participate, that you ask for participation. 36 Use this chat to ask for your turn, turn to speak, and use the 37 little emoji with the hand up. All votes are going to be made 38 by roll call, and state your full name and yes or no or abstain. 39 40 Public comments will have five minutes on the end of the meeting 41 for participation, and the meeting will be recorded at all 42 times, and simultaneous translation is available, like we stated 43 at the beginning of this meeting. The next item on the agenda 44 is the swearing-in of new council members. 45 46 MIGUEL ROLON: Marcos, before you go into that, the roll call is 47 when you are going to submit something to the Secretary, but, in 48 this case, you may have a motion, and, if there is no 7 1 opposition, then you can declare the motion approved. That way, 2 you will save some time. For the swearing-in, we have you and 3 Dr. Roy Crabtree, and I believe that you received your 4 documents, and so you may read it for the record. 5 6 SWEARING-IN OF NEW COUNCIL MEMBERS 7 8 MARCOS HANKE: Yes, I have it here. Thank you, again, for the 9 opportunity to serve on the council. I, Marcos Hanke, as a duly 10 appointed member of the regional fishery management council 11 established under the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and 12 Management Act, hereby promise to conserve and manage the living 13 marine resources of the United States of America by carrying out 14 the business of the council for the greatest overall benefit of 15 the nation.