DOCSLIB.ORG

I WORK-FAMILY BALANCE AMONG MOTHERS WHO ARE MID

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
I WORK-FAMILY BALANCE AMONG MOTHERS WHO ARE MID WORK-FAMILY BALANCE AMONG MOTHERS WHO ARE MID-CAREER STUDENT AFFAIRS ADMINISTRATORS AT INSTITUTIONS RECOGNIZED FOR WORK-LIFE POLICIES BY LAURA ISDELL Submitted to the graduate degree program in Educational Leadership and Policy Studies and the Graduate Faculty of the University of Kansas in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Education. ________________________________ Chairperson Lisa Wolf Wendel ________________________________ Susan Twombly ________________________________ Marlesa Roney ________________________________ John Rury ________________________________ Michael Vitevitch Date Defended: February 19, 2016 i ProQuest Page ii The Dissertation Committee for Laura Isdell certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: WORK-FAMILY BALANCE AMONG MOTHERS WHO ARE MID-CAREER STUDENT AFFAIRS ADMINISTRATORS AT INSTITUTIONS RECOGNIZED FOR WORK-LIFE POLICIES ________________________________ Chairperson Lisa Wolf-Wendel Date approved: April 21, 2016 iii Work-Family Balance among Mothers who are Mid-Career Student Affairs Administrators at Institutions Recognized for Work-Life Policies The purpose of this study was to understand the work-family balance experiences of mothers, in mid-career student affairs administrator roles, at institutions known for work-life supports. This study asked: how do these women describe their experiences managing work and family roles? What knowledge of existing work-life policies do these administrators have? How do these existing policies influence the perception of workplace culture and norms? How does perceived work-family balance influence the intended career trajectory, or desire for professional advancement, of those women? Through a qualitative research design, I explored the work- family experiences of 15 administrators through participant interviews. Several major findings were uncovered. First, the majority of these administrators saw themselves as the primary caregiver to their child. Second, work-life supports, such as flexible leave time and university run childcare, contributed to the women’s ability to manage the student affairs role with motherhood. Third, feeling supervisor support and flexibility to attend to personal responsibilities, as the women saw fit, contributed to workplace loyalty. Conversely, the absence of support and flexibility fueled a desire to seek employment outside of the institution. Fourth, when the participants’ perceived inequities existed related to who had access to flexible work arrangements, the feelings they expressed about their workplace were more negative, even when their own personal experience was positive. Fifth, women do not understand FMLA policies, which was specifically apparent in relationship to maternity leave. Finally, some policies have good intentions, but no actual impact. The best example was providing tuition remission for higher education, but only for bachelor’s degrees, a credential that was a job requirement when the administrators were hired into their existing roles. iv Acknowledgments The completion of this work occurred alongside a marriage, the birth of two children, and employment at two different institutional types, in two different states. It not only took endurance on the part of myself, but the support of my partner in life, who willingly gave me any time I needed to research or write, while being an amazing father to our children. Learning about the experiences of other mothers who were likewise balancing family, work, educational aspirations, and personal goals was an incredibly rewarding experience. I am forever grateful for the women who participated in this study and appreciate the ways in which they inspired me to embrace duality when it comes to wearing my mom and administrator hats. Lastly, I want to thank my entire committee for their feedback and flexibility, particularly after I was no longer on the University of Kansas campus every day. And to my advisor, who challenged me throughout this entire process, the final outcome of this work is far superior as a result of your ongoing influence. v Table of Contents Abstract ......................................................................................................................................... iv Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................ v Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................... vi List of Tables .............................................................................................................................. viii Chapter One – Introduction & Background ................................................................................... 1 Purpose of the Study .......................................................................................................... 1 Definitions .......................................................................................................................... 2 The Workplace and Work-Family Balance ....................................................................... 4 Institutions Recognized for Work-Life Supports ............................................................... 5 Workplace Culture and Norms .......................................................................................... 9 Importance of the Study ................................................................................................... 10 Chapter Two - Literature Review ................................................................................................ 14 Student Affairs Administrators Navigating Work-family Balance ................................. 14 Balance and Career Trajectory for Female, Mid-career Student Affairs Administrators 17 Differential Impacts of Work-Family for Moms and Dads ............................................. 19 Ideal Worker Norms and the Role of the Workplace ...................................................... 22 Work-Life Policies ........................................................................................................... 23 Workplace Culture and Norms ........................................................................................ 25 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 29 Chapter Three – Methodology ..................................................................................................... 31 Research Design ............................................................................................................... 32 Research Site Selection .................................................................................................... 33 Participants ....................................................................................................................... 38 Procedures ........................................................................................................................ 38 Limitations ....................................................................................................................... 45 Chapter Four – Results ................................................................................................................. 46 Participant Overview ....................................................................................................... 46 Caregiving and the Primary Caregiver ............................................................................ 49 Role of Student Affairs Administrators ........................................................................... 54 Juggling Act of Work and Family ................................................................................... 55 Workplace Formalized Work-life Supports ..................................................................... 69 Workplace Flexible Leave Policies and Practice ............................................................. 78 Institutional Culture ......................................................................................................... 84 Participant Recommendations ......................................................................................... 89 Chapter Five – Conclusions ......................................................................................................... 92 Summary of the Study ..................................................................................................... 92 Major Findings …………................................................................................................. 93 Implications for Institutions ………................................................................................. 99 Recommendations for Student Affairs Administrators .................................................. 104 Limitations of the Study and Future Research ............................................................... 106 vi Closing Remarks …………............................................................................................ 109 References .................................................................................................................................. 111 Appendix A Emails to Solicit Participation .............................................................................. 121 Appendix B General Interview Guide .....................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Textual Analysis of Contemporary Mother Identities in Popular Discourse Katherine Mayer Marquette University
    Marquette University e-Publications@Marquette Master's Theses (2009 -) Dissertations, Theses, and Professional Projects Mother: A Textual Analysis of Contemporary Mother Identities in Popular Discourse Katherine Mayer Marquette University Recommended Citation Mayer, Katherine, "Mother: A Textual Analysis of Contemporary Mother Identities in Popular Discourse" (2012). Master's Theses (2009 -). 142. https://epublications.marquette.edu/theses_open/142 MOTHER: A TEXTUAL ANALYSIS OF CONTEMPOARY MOTHERING IDENTITIES IN POPULAR DISCOURSE by Katherine Marie Mayer, B.A. A Thesis submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School, Marquette University, in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts Milwaukee, Wisconsin May 2012 ABSTRACT MOTHER: A TEXTUAL ANALYSIS OF CONTEMPOARY MOTHERING IDENTITIES IN POPULAR DISCOURSE Katherine Marie Mayer, B.A. Marquette University, 2012 For centuries, women have struggled to understand the meaning of one of their most important roles in society, mother. Internet discussion boards have become an important venue for women to participate in ongoing discussions about the role of mothering in contemporary society and serve as a means by which they are actively shaping society’s understanding of the role of mothers. A textual analysis of a popular mothering discussion board yielded two dominate mothering identities, tensions that exist for each mothering type and how mothers resolve those tensions through the mothering discourse. The study ultimately revealed the ways in which the mothering discourse serves as an important part of the identity construction process and is used as a means of negotiating, managing and ultimately reinforcing a mother’s own identity. i TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION 1 Contemporary Conceptions of Mothers in Society 2 Rationale for Study 3 Preview of Thesis 4 II.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Childhood Staff's Understandings and Practices of Parent Involvement in Private Early Childhood Services: an Exploratory Study
    Technological University Dublin ARROW@TU Dublin Masters Applied Arts 2010-2 Early Childhood Staff's Understandings and Practices of Parent Involvement in Private Early Childhood Services: an Exploratory Study Maria McDermott Technological University Dublin Follow this and additional works at: https://arrow.tudublin.ie/appamas Part of the Pre-Elementary, Early Childhood, Kindergarten Teacher Education Commons, and the Social and Behavioral Sciences Commons Recommended Citation McDermott, M. (2010). Early Childhood Staff's Understandings and Practices of Parent Involvement in Private Early Childhood Services: an Exploratory Study. Masters dissertation. Technological University Dublin. doi:10.21427/D7KW4Z This Theses, Masters is brought to you for free and open access by the Applied Arts at ARROW@TU Dublin. It has been accepted for inclusion in Masters by an authorized administrator of ARROW@TU Dublin. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 4.0 License Early Childhood Staff's Understandings and Practices of Parent Involvement in Private Early Childhood Services: Maria McDermott Bachelor of Arts Dublin Institute of Technology School of Social Science Supervisor: Anne Fitzpatrick Submitted: February 2010 Abstract In modem Western society growing numbers of parents are employed in the labour market and while they work, parents and early years practitioners (EYPs) share responsibility for raising children. Attention to the quality of children's and families' experiences in these settings is increasing rapidly (Walsh, 2003; OECD, 2006). Parent involvement, has been identified as an indicator of quality, and the benefits that accrue from this involvement for children, parents and EYPs have been widely reported.
    [Show full text]
  • Our Gender Pay Gap Report
    Closing the gap Our gender pay gap report March 2018 2 Closing the gap: Our gender pay gap report Foreword Chris Ireland Neil Murray Virginia Rothwell UK CEO CEO UK HR Director EMEA Corporate Solutions Our common shorthand is to talk about JLL as a ‘property In collating the data for this report, we’ve identified a clear company’. But, of course, our organisation is made up of people, gap between the average earnings of men and women in our not properties. Without the talent, motivation and energy of our organisation, and the reason is clear and unambiguous: employees, we wouldn’t have the successful business we’re so men hold four-fifths of the most senior roles in our organisation. proud of. Our mean gender pay gap is currently 36.7%. But we’re working At JLL, ensuring that everyone in our business is paid fairly is on it. We believe the best way to address the gap is by having fundamental to the way we go about things. It’s part of our more women in our senior roles and we’re pleased to report strategy to create an inclusive environment to attract and that over the last two years, the number of women in JLL’s top retain the best people regardless of gender, age, ethnicity or positions has increased by around one-third. Over the same background. But gender pay gap reporting helps to highlight period, our mean and median gender pay gaps have fallen. something else: the imbalance between the numbers of men and women employed at different levels of an organisation.
    [Show full text]
  • A Child-Focused Paid Parental Leave Policy for the U.S. By: Rachel Anderson and Lyman Stone
    Policy Brief May 2020 A Child-Focused Paid Parental Leave Policy for the U.S. By: Rachel Anderson and Lyman Stone Executive Summary A highly contagious coronavirus has led communities to shutter businesses, schools, and public places, requiring families to undertake multiple roles at once: caregivers, educators, and workers. As our society relies on the health and capability of families right now, policymakers should consider future measures that strengthen families, particularly in their childrearing role. Prior to and during the COVID-19 crisis, politicians on both sides of the aisle recognized the need for a better family leave policy in America. In March, Congress secured emergency paid leave policy for families affected by COVID-19, including the closure of hundreds of thousands of schools and places of childcare. Once the crisis subsides, policymakers should look again at more permanent approaches to providing paid family leave. Family leave policies can be structured in widely divergent ways and aimed at very different ends. With a proliferation of proposals, it is vital that policymakers make evidence-based decisions with clear pathways to implementation and reasonable expectations of achieving specific policy outcomes. In order to have a family leave policy that fits such a demanding criteria, it is important to first survey existing literature to identify the range of effects that policymakers might expect to see from an expansion in paid family leave. This paper does so with a focus on paid parental leave, a topic that has garnered a sizeable body of research. Across the academic literature on family leave policies, especially maternity or paternity leave for new children, a variety of outcomes have been identified.
    [Show full text]
  • Is Childcare Affordable?
    Is Childcare Affordable? Key findings The cost of non-parental childcare is high in many OECD countries, e.g. about half of women’s median full-time earnings for a two-earner family with two children in care in Japan, and the United Kingdom. Support programmes often reduce the costs for low- income families, but out-of-pocket costs often still sum to a large share of earnings for low- paid parents, including single mothers (e.g. Ireland, the Slovak Republic, and the United Kingdom). The widespread closure of childcare facilities during the unfolding COVID-19 crisis only highlights the importance of access to affordable care. In the absence of special measures to deal with unforeseen childcare needs during lock-down periods, many working parents are struggling to balance their work and family responsibilities (OECD, 2020[1]). Childcare affordability is likely to remain a key concern as parents gradually return to their workplaces. High childcare costs are one of the factors contributing to inequalities in childcare use across income groups. In European OECD countries, children under the age of 3 in low- income households are one-third less likely to participate in early childhood education and care (ECEC) than those in high-income households. Childcare costs can substantially weaken employment incentives for parents. On average across OECD countries, a low-paid single mother, who takes up full-time work, loses almost two-thirds of her in-work earnings to childcare costs, taxes and the loss of social benefits. Accessible, affordable and good-quality ECEC carries many positive social and economic benefits.
    [Show full text]
  • Life's a Balancing Act: How Men and Women Experience the Work-Home Interface Across the Life Course
    Life's a Balancing Act: How men and women experience the work-home interface across the life course by Katherine Y. Lin A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Sociology) in the University of Michigan 2015 Doctoral Committee: Associate Professor Sarah A. Burgard, Chair Associate Professor Renee R. Anspach Professor Mary E. Corcoran Professor Yu Xie © Katherine Y. Lin 2015 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS While it might be cliché to begin an acknowledgements section with “it takes a village,” I cannot imagine a more fitting phrase to describe the process of completing a dissertation. I would not have been able to do the research for this dissertation, and successfully complete graduate school, had it not been for the support and friendship of my mentors, family, and friends. First, the patient and careful mentoring from my advisors, whose belief in my abilities as a researcher as well as relentless expectation for me to do better, has given me a foundation in social science research that I hope to build on moving forward. My deepest thanks go to my dissertation committee chair, Sarah Burgard, whose ability to wrangle research sense out of my first drafts should be award-winning. She is the epitome of a mentor, whose strong belief that research and mentorship go hand-in-hand is something I hope to emulate in the future. Yu Xie’s core belief in matching research question to method and data has brought me back to the drawing boards of projects many times, and always for the better.
    [Show full text]
  • A Duty of Both Revising Eu's Legal Framework On
    IUSLabor 3/2017 A DUTY OF BOTH REVISING EU’S LEGAL FRAMEWORK ON MATERNITY, PATERNITY AND PARENTAL LEAVE FOR EFFECTIVE GENDER EQUALITY IN EMPLOYMENT Sara Etulain Gómez LL.M. European Law graduate, University of Leiden (Leiden, The Netherlands). Postgraduate student in Centre for Transnational Legal Studies (London) and ESADE Law School (Barcelona). Abstract The European Union has been one of the main propellants for gender equality, and has contributed to build awareness amongst its Member States of the difficulties that combining work and family life is for working women. Even in its efforts to come up with a legal framework to battle for women’s equality, in 2015, the European average employment rate of women was eleven points lower than men’s rate, which was especially accentuated when women had children under the age of six. Estimations of the EU are that the gender employment gap will still be of nine points difference between the sexes by 2055, which is extremely worrying. The present thesis will first analyse the current EU’s family leave policies, concretely the Maternity Leave, Recast and Parental Leave Directive, which will serve as a basis to understand the new European Commission’s Proposal for a Directive on work-life balance for parents. Such in-depth analysis will help us identify the reasons why the current legal framework on family leave have failed to ensure gender equality in the labour market, and if the new proposal on introduction of paternity leave and improvements on parental leave would help solve or reduce women’s misrepresentation and less favourable treatment in employment.
    [Show full text]
  • April, 2016 Preliminary Draft
    The Impact of Parenthood on the Gender Wage Gap – a Comparative Analysis of European Countries and Family Policies Ewa Cukrowska-Torzewska* Anna Lovasz** April, 2016 Preliminary draft Abstract We use cross-national data to assess how much children and the responsibilities related to them contribute to the gender wage gap, and how family policies affect this relationship. Our analysis is based on a decomposition that reveals what portion of the gender wage gap may be attributed to the existence of: (1) the motherhood wage penalty, (2) the fatherhood wage premium, and (3) the gender wage gap among childless individuals. Our findings suggest that in countries where female employment is low, the gender wage gap is small, and mostly driven by a high positive fatherhood premium. Among the remaining countries, variations are mainly explained by family policies. Countries with high childcare coverage and moderate length paid leaves report small, slightly positive motherhood wage gaps that play a small role in the overall gender gap. On the other hand, the highest motherhood wage penalty is found in countries where long leaves coexist with the low accessibility to childcare facilities, explaining approximately one third of the total gender wage gap. Keywords: Family Gap, Gender Wage Gap, Family Policies JEL codes: J13, J22 The authors would like to thank members of the Virtual Research Collaboration on Gender and Families (Andrea Kiss, Barbara Pertold-Gebicka, Mariann Rigó, Ágnes Szabó-Morvai) for valuable comments. Data was provided by the Data Bank of the Centre for Economic and Regional Studies of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences. * University of Warsaw, ecukrowska@wne,.uw.edu.pl ** Institute of Economics, Centre for Economic and Regional Studies of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, and Eotvos Lorand University, [email protected] 1.
    [Show full text]
  • A Reasonable Solution for Working Parents: Expanding Reasonable Accommodation Under the Americans with Disabilities Act to Parents of Children with Disabilities
    William & Mary Journal of Race, Gender, and Social Justice Volume 25 (2018-2019) Issue 3 Article 8 April 2019 A Reasonable Solution for Working Parents: Expanding Reasonable Accommodation Under the Americans with Disabilities Act to Parents of Children with Disabilities Katherine Lease Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/wmjowl Part of the Disability Law Commons, Labor and Employment Law Commons, and the Law and Gender Commons Repository Citation Katherine Lease, A Reasonable Solution for Working Parents: Expanding Reasonable Accommodation Under the Americans with Disabilities Act to Parents of Children with Disabilities, 25 Wm. & Mary J. Women & L. 709 (2019), https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/wmjowl/ vol25/iss3/8 Copyright c 2019 by the authors. This article is brought to you by the William & Mary Law School Scholarship Repository. https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/wmjowl A REASONABLE SOLUTION FOR WORKING PARENTS: EXPANDING REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION UNDER THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT TO PARENTS OF CHILDREN WITH DISABILITIES The obligation for working mothers is a very precise one: the feeling that one ought to work as if one did not have children, while raising one’s children as if one did not have a job.1 ABSTRACT There is a growing intersection between a woman’s child-rearing and work responsibilities, but federal law inadequately addresses this issue. For mothers who have a child with a disability, they face increased parenting demands, which often lead to detrimental changes in their employment status and negative perceptions of their work ability and commitment. Many women face expectations to simulta- neously be the perfect mother and the ideal worker, but this is largely unattainable when faced with the demands of raising a child with a disability.
    [Show full text]
  • It's Good to Be a Working Parent in Europe
    It's good to be a working parent in Europe http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/17/pf/working-parents-paid-leave/index.html by Jeanne Sahadi @CNNMoney February 19, 2016: 12:36 PM ET It's no secret that European countries have more generous paid leave policies for working parents than the United States. But just how much more is eye-opening, as a new report from Glassdoor and Llewellyn Consulting shows. While the U.S. mandates no paid leave whatsoever, the European Union mandates paid maternity leave, and separately requires more time be given to all parents so they can spend time with their children as they grow up. Many E.U. countries also offer paid paternity leave, but there is no requirement to do so. Maternity leave Employers in E.U. countries must offer a minimum paid maternity leave of 14 weeks uninterrupted. But several E.U. countries are far more generous, the report notes. For example, the United Kingdom offers 52 weeks, 39 of which are partially paid; Ireland offers 42 weeks, of which 26 are paid at a flat rate of 230 euros per week; and Italy offers 22 weeks, all of which are paid at 80% of earnings. Paternity leave Neither the E.U. nor the United States mandate paternity leave, paid or unpaid. But many E.U. countries offer it, although the terms are all over the place. Finland is the most generous by far, offering new fathers 45 days off, with pay dependent on the man's salary and varying over the period of the leave.
    [Show full text]
  • Brief Overview of Measures Related to Work-Life Balance in the European Union
    January 2018 Brief overview of measures related to work-life balance in the European Union Country sheets Dalila Ghailani Dalila Ghailani Senior researcher European Social Observatory After the withdrawal of the Maternity Leave Directive, the Commission has decided to take a broader approach to addressing women's underrepresentation in the labour market. The 'New Start' initiative to address the work-life balance challenges faced by working parents and carers, presented on April 2017 as a deliverable of the European Pillar for Social Rights, takes into account the developments in society over the past decade, aiming to enable parents and other people with caring responsibilities to better balance their work and family lives, and to encourage a better sharing of caring responsibilities between women and men. It is based on the results of a public consultation and two-stage European social partner consultations, and on an analysis of the accompanying impact assessment. The Communication, entitled ‘An initiative to support Work-Life Balance for Working Parents and Carers’, sets out a broad package of complementary legal and policy measures, which will reinforce each other1. The initiative aims, among other things, at modernising the existing EU legal framework in the area of family-related leave and flexible working arrangements. The proposal for a Directive on Work-Life Balance for Parents and Carers2 includes: . the introduction of paternity leave: fathers/second parents would be able to take at least 10 working days of paternity leave at around the time of birth of the child, remunerated at least at the level of sick pay; . the strengthening of parental leave: the 4 months period should be remunerated at least at sick pay level and non-transferable from one parent to another.
    [Show full text]
  • Role Satisfaction in Stay-At-Home Fathers: Impact of Social
    ROLE SATISFACTION IN STAY-AT-HOME FATHERS: IMPACT OF SOCIAL SUPPORT, GENDER ROLE ATTITUDES, AND PARENTAL SELF-EFFICACY A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE TEXAS WOMAN'S UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF PSYCHOLOGY AND PHILOSOPHY COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES BY SARAH JOHNSON, M.A. DENTON, TEXAS AUGUST 2016 TEXAS WOMAN'S UNIVERSITY DENTON, TEXAS June 22, 2016 To the Dean of the Graduate School: I am submitting herewith a dissertation written by Sarah Johnson entitled “Role Satisfaction in Stay-at-Home Fathers: Impact of Social Support, Gender Role Attitudes, and Parental Self-Efficacy.” I have examined this dissertation for form and content and recommend that it be accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy with a major in Counseling Psychology. ____________________________________ Dr. Sally D. Stabb, Ph.D., Major Professor We have read this dissertation and recommend its acceptance: ______________________________ Dr. Linda Rubin, Ph.D. ______________________________ Dr. Lisa Rosen, Ph.D. ______________________________ Dr. Jeff Harris, Ph.D. ______________________________ Department Chair Accepted: __________________________________ Dean of the Graduate School DEDICATION For all the parents who are bravely trying to balance the demands of life, making difficult choices for the sake of their families. May you be able to navigate the twists and turns of life and arrive at a place of peace, contentment, and joy. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to gratefully acknowledge the many individuals who have contributed to this dissertation. I would like to thank my committee chair Dr.
    [Show full text]