Practices of Inclusion and Exclusion in Premodern Culture

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Practices of Inclusion and Exclusion in Premodern Culture Practices of Inclusion and Exclusion in Premodern Culture erokirja.indd 1 12.1.2005, 14:14 erokirja.indd 2 12.1.2005, 14:14 PRACTICES OF INCLUSION AND EXCLUSION in Premodern Culture k&h Edited by Eva Johanna Holmberg & Tom Linkinen Cultural History — Kulttuurihistoria 5 Turku, Finland erokirja.indd 3 12.1.2005, 14:14 CULTURAL HISTORY — KULTTUURIHISTORIA 5 Published by k&h, kulttuurihistoria, Turun yliopisto, Turku Finland ISBN 951-29-2865-5 ISSN 1458-1949 University of Turku Cultural History 20014 Turku Finland http://www.culturalhistory.net © authors Cover Maija Mäkikalli Layout Henri Terho Printed by Dark Oy, Vantaa Finland, 2005 erokirja.indd 4 12.1.2005, 14:14 CONTENTS Acknowledgements 7 EVA JOHANNA HOLMBERG Introduction: Constructions of difference / Thinking with difference 9 I INCLUSION MAARIT PÖSÖ Melancholy Nuns and Proud Noblewomen: Separating Oneself from Others in Religious Life According to Saint Teresa 21 ANU KEINÄNEN ‘Elect People of God in Scorn Called Quakers’: The Early Society of Friends as Different 45 PAULIINA PEKKARINEN The Rhetoric of Difference in a Renaissance Preface: Angelo Poliziano and the Problem of Irony 70 TAIKA HELOLA Twixt Two Suns: John Donne’s Poetic Perception Of The Solar System 101 II EXCLUSION ISTO VATANEN The Naked Seaman: Making a Difference with Nudity in Ancient Roman Imagery 137 EVA JOHANNA HOLMBERG Indecent roaring: Reading irreverence and confusion in Jewish worship in Early Modern England 170 erokirja.indd 5 12.1.2005, 14:14 SATU LIDMAN The importance of honour: Differences based on having or losing honour in Early Modern German society and law 201 LEENA ROSSI Keeping the Whores Recognizable: Segregating and Identifying Prostitutes in Late Medieval Europe 229 Contributors 255 6 erokirja.indd 6 12.1.2005, 14:14 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS For their efforts and co-operation with the realisation of this project, thanks are due to many individuals. The editors would especially like to mention the ideas, suggestions and criticisms given by Dr Marjo Kaartinen and Dr Anu Korhonen. We believe it was originally Marjo who suggested the compilation of this collection one cold afternoon, when the premodern research group was having one of its gatherings in the wing of the building of political history in Turku. After that the col- lection began to take shape with the tightest of schedules possible, and over the summer the editors spent long hours reading, writing and com- menting on the achievements (fortunately it rained almost all summer, so we were happy sitting inside the Cultural History building and its immediate vicinity…). The last stages of editorial work were conducted in a rather unusual manner and surroundings, by e-mail and sms con- necting the cities of York and London in the UK and Turku in Finland. We hope that these peculiarities have only increased our experience of editing, not resulted in too many errors. Ellen Valle corrected our ”fi nglish” witticisms with precision and enormous effectiveness. Henri Terho is thanked for the layout and Maija Mäkikalli for giving the book its outward appearance. The red colour of the cover conceals an inside joke: The working title of this volume was for many months ”Punainen erokirja” (”Red book of ”sepa- ration” or ”difference”, since the word ”ero” has several meanings in Finnish) after the novel by Pirkko Saisio which won the Finlandia prize for 2003. Saisio donated her prize to SETA (the foundation for promot- ing sexual equality), and we fi nd this gesture more than suitable to be erokirja.indd 7 12.1.2005, 14:14 mentioned as an afterthought to our collection. Since the themes of difference and otherness, and the cultural narratives surrounding these, all form part of our research project on premodern English experiences of otherness, we the editors would like to thank all the writers of this volume for enriching our views and challenging our preconceptions. In addition, the writers would individually like to acknowledge the help given by Anu Korhonen and Hanna Järvinen from the Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies, Marjo Kaartinen, Liisa Lagerstam, Sakari Ollitervo, Ritva Hapuli, Taika Helola, Teemu Immonen and Marika Räsänen from Cultural History, University of Turku, Stefan Breit, the Bayerisches Hauptsstaatsarchiv, München, Jenni Meriläinen from General History, University of Turku, and Jutta Vuorio from Åbo Akademi, Turku. We are also grateful to Professor Kari Immonen, who gave permission to publish the result of our work in the Cultural His- tory series. Eva Johanna and Tom, in London and York, January 2005 8 erokirja.indd 8 12.1.2005, 14:14 INTRODUCTION: CONSTRUCTIONS OF DIFFERENCE/ THINKING WITH DIFFERENCE Eva Johanna Holmberg Good vines grow in that country; there the women drink wine and not men. And women shave their beards, and not men. —The Travels of Sir John Mandeville1 In this passage from Sir John Mandeville’s famous travelogue, the author is playing with our understanding of the proper practices of men and women. He tells of a strange land in India, where the normal customs are the reverse of his own and even human corporealities are strange and divergent from the norm. Mandeville is constructing a dif- ference between his own culture and the culture of the strange land. This he does by telling a story and by suggesting an interpretation of it. While doing so, he makes it possible for the historian to take a brief glimpse at his cultural world, a world that may seem to us as strange and foreign a country as the one Mandeville himself is describing.2 This collection of articles focuses on the constructions and experi- 1 The Travels of Sir John Mandeville (1983), 124. 2 On the past as a foreign country see Catherine Brown’s thought-provoking article “In the middle”. Brown 2000, 548–49. erokirja.indd 9 12.1.2005, 14:14 Eva Johanna Holmberg ences of difference in Premodern cultures by posing such questions as “what was difference” and “how was it constructed”. How can we recognize or trace these differences in the past? What were the motives behind these constructions, and what kind of trajectories did difference take? It is perhaps already clear that we approach culture both as a structure and as a communicative process, in which people took part by sharing and simultaneously creating knowledge of their surrounding reality. Experiences and preconceptions were equally involved in these processes; thus questions as to whether these culturally constructed differences were ‘real’, or what ‘actually’ took place, are less relevant.3 Premodern people construed and conceptualized difference and we want to grasp what these phenomena meant to them. In each article in the volume, questions of difference are situated in a historical setting. This is done in order to interpret the meanings, con- sequences and practices that were involved in the process. As cultural historians, we tend to think that in order to make a past culture under- standable we need to look at meanings, experiences and discourses in their cultural milieu and fi nd keys to an understanding of practices and rhetoric in the specifi c cultural context. We try to make the thoughts of people in the past understandable and fi nd a logic in their thinking, but not to impose our logic on them.4 This means that constructions of difference fi nd their meanings through the empirical study of a given period and its cultural and social practices, in our case the cultures and peoples that lived before modernity. The problem of difference has been posed many times, and the schol- arly discussion surrounding it is as varied as ever. The postcolonial situ- ation and the discussion of gender have made the constructed nature of history visible, and the consequences of cultural imaging and imagin- ing even more so. Difference, its constructions and fi ctions were also part of peoples’ lives before modernity, postmodernity, and – if you will – post-postmodernity. People divided themselves and their others into groups: nationalities, genealogies, religions and professions. They tried to exclude otherness, to make it invisible or even extinct. By defi ning 3 On cultural construction and constructivism see Tuohela & Korhonen 2002, 136–37. 4 See eg. Kaartinen 2002, 1–2. 10 erokirja.indd 10 12.1.2005, 14:14 Introduction: Constructions of difference/ Thinking with difference and outlining difference they tried to delineate their realities into com- prehensible and communicable entities.5 Otherness can be seen as a con- struction that has many sides, and, against which it is easier to defi ne oneself. These practices and phenomena can also be detected in the Premodern cultural world, even if people in the past hardly thought of otherness, difference and sameness in the way they have been described by Edward Said, Gayatri Spivak or Simone de Beauvoir.6 In the Middle Ages, for example, the ideal state of society was a peaceful and unifi ed one, a Christian community bound together by hierarchical relationships. In its ideal state, this community formed a perfect symmetry and shape, since its foundation and ideals were created by God. Premodern European cultures may have been more communal than nowadays, where we might characterise our own cul- ture as a mosaic structure that constantly reforms and reinvents itself, creating subcultures, countercultures and complex identity-formations. The divide between the Premoderns and ourselves, however, must not lead us to see that culture as more solid or simpler than our own. Pre- modern people had their own ways of challenging the ideals of their societies, and of being active and even rebellious agents in their lives. They could create their own (sub)groups, challenging the values of the surrounding society that tried to exclude them.7 Women could drink 5 Boundaries between communities, selves and their others can be approached in the manner that was outlined by Mary Douglas in her seminal Purity and Danger.
Recommended publications
  • The Ab Urbe Condita Construction in Latin
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Papers from the University Studies series (The University of Nebraska) University Studies of the University of Nebraska 1936 The Ab Urbe Condita Construction in Latin Otto William Heick Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/univstudiespapers Part of the Classical Literature and Philology Commons Heick, Otto William, "The Ab Urbe Condita Construction in Latin" (1936). Papers from the University Studies series (The University of Nebraska). 122. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/univstudiespapers/122 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the University Studies of the University of Nebraska at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Papers from the University Studies series (The University of Nebraska) by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. VoL. XXXVI · 1936 UNIVERSITY STUDIES • PUBLISHED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA COMMITTEE ON PUBLICATION J. E. KIRSHMAN C. S. HAMILTON T. M. RAYSOR H. H. MARVIN G. W. ROSENLOF R. J. POOL , FRED W. UPSON LOUISE POUND GILBERT H. DOANE THE AB URBE CONDITA CONSTRUCTION IN LATIN BY OTTO WILLIAM HEICK, Ph.D. LINCOLN, NEBRASKA 1936 THE UNIVERSITY STUDIES OF THE UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA VOLUME XXXVI LINCOLN PUBLISHED BY THE UNIVERSITY 1936 UNIVERSITY STUDIES VoL. XXXVI Nos. 1-4 THE AB VRBE CONDITA CONSTRUCTION IN LATIN BY OTTO WILLIAM HEICK, Ph.D. CONTENTS CHAPTER PAGE l. INTRODUCTION 9 THE NATURE OF THE Ab Urbe Condita CoNSTRUCTION 9 PREVIOUS WoRK ON THE SUBJECT 10 AIMS AND METHOD OF THE PRESENT STUDY 11 II. ARCHAIC AUTHORS.
    [Show full text]
  • La Germanie Tacite (0055?-0120?)
    1/10 Data La Germanie Tacite (0055?-0120?) Titre principal : Germania (latin) Langue : Latin Genre ou forme de l’œuvre : Œuvres textuelles Date : 98 Note : Ouvrage ethnographique Domaines : Archéologie. Préhistoire. Histoire ancienne Autres formes du titre : Description de la Germanie et des moeurs de ses habitants (français) Moeurs des anciens Germains (français) Moeurs des Germains (français) De moribus et populis Germaniae libellus (latin) (De) moribus et populis Germaniae libellus (latin) De moribus Germanorum (latin) (De) moribus Germanorum (latin) De origine et situ Germaniae (latin) (De) origine et situ Germaniae (latin) De origine et situ Germanorum (latin) (De) origine et situ Germanorum (latin) De origine, situ et moribus ac populis Germanorum (latin) (De) origine, situ et moribus ac populis Germanorum (latin) De situ, moribus et populis Germaniae (latin) (De) situ, moribus et populis Germaniae (latin) Altertümerskunde von Germanien (allemand) Germanische Alterthümer (allemand) Über Germanien (allemand) Über Lage, Sitten und Völkerschaften Germaniens (allemand) Von den Sitten der alten Deutschen (allemand) Von Deutschlands Lage, Sitten und Völkern (allemand) I costumi de'Germani (italien) Détails du contenu (2 ressources dans data.bnf.fr) Table des matières (2) Paris : Garnier frères , 1875 Paris : Garnier frères , 1875 (1875) (1875) data.bnf.fr 2/10 Data Éditions de La Germanie (96 ressources dans data.bnf.fr) Livres (96) De moribus germanorum , Tacite (0055?-0120?) Germania , Tacite (0055?-0120?), libellus Leipzig : Insel Verl. , [19 ] La Germanie , Tacite (0055?-0120?), La Germanie , Tacite (0055?-0120?), (2011) [Clermont-Ferrand] : Éd. (2009) Paris : Arléa , impr. 2009 Paleo , impr. 2011 La Germanie , Tacite (0055?-0120?), Germania , Tacite (0055?-0120?), (2001) Paris : Arléa , impr.
    [Show full text]
  • Illinois Classical Studies, Volume I
    r m LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN 880 v.l Classics The person charging this material is re- sponsible for its return to the library from which it was withdrawn on or before the Latest Date stamped below. Theft, mutilation, and underlining of books are reasons for disciplinary action and may result in dismissal from the University. UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS LIBRARY AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN DEC la 76 199^ hwvi (JCTl2«n Mil TO JUL 08 1938 SFP 1 3 19 '9 mi 1 4 15'^1), ^JUL s 5 ^f FES 2 i U84 JAIIZ2 m 3 1939 L161 — O-1096 ILLINOIS CLASSICAL STUDIES, VOLUME I ILLINOIS CLASSICAL STUDIES VOLUME I 1976 Miroslav Marcovich, Editor UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS PRESS Urbana Chicago London [976 by the Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois Manufactured in the United States of America ISBN: 0-252-00516-3 •r or CLASSICS Preface Illinois Classical Studies (ICS) is a serial publication of the Classics Depart- ments of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and Chicago Circle which contains the results of original research dealing with classical antiquity and with its impact upon Western culture. ICS welcomes scholarly contributions dealing with any topic or aspect of Greek and/or Roman literature, language, history, art, culture, philosophy, religion, and the like, as well as with their transmission from antiquity through Byzantium or Western Europe to our time. ICS is not limited to contributions coming from Illinois. It is open to classicists of any flag or school of thought. In fact, of sixteen contributors to Volume I (1976), six are from Urbana, two from Chicago, six from the rest of the country, and two from Europe.
    [Show full text]
  • "Immoderate Superstition": Christian Identity in the First Three Centuries
    University of Kentucky UKnowledge Theses and Dissertations--History History 2013 MORE THAN AN "IMMODERATE SUPERSTITION": CHRISTIAN IDENTITY IN THE FIRST THREE CENTURIES Edward Mason University of Kentucky, [email protected] Right click to open a feedback form in a new tab to let us know how this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Mason, Edward, "MORE THAN AN "IMMODERATE SUPERSTITION": CHRISTIAN IDENTITY IN THE FIRST THREE CENTURIES" (2013). Theses and Dissertations--History. 20. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/history_etds/20 This Master's Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the History at UKnowledge. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations--History by an authorized administrator of UKnowledge. For more information, please contact [email protected]. STUDENT AGREEMENT: I represent that my thesis or dissertation and abstract are my original work. Proper attribution has been given to all outside sources. I understand that I am solely responsible for obtaining any needed copyright permissions. I have obtained and attached hereto needed written permission statements(s) from the owner(s) of each third-party copyrighted matter to be included in my work, allowing electronic distribution (if such use is not permitted by the fair use doctrine). I hereby grant to The University of Kentucky and its agents the non-exclusive license to archive and make accessible my work in whole or in part in all forms of media, now or hereafter known. I agree that the document mentioned above may be made available immediately for worldwide access unless a preapproved embargo applies. I retain all other ownership rights to the copyright of my work.
    [Show full text]
  • Revista Anos 90 N 30.P65
    Ética, Retórica e Poética no Diálogo dos Oradores e a concepção de História em Tácito Fábio Duarte Joly* Resumo: Este artigo busca analisar o Diálogo dos Oradores, de Tácito, relacionando sua estrutura compositiva e temas a uma discussão acerca da concepção de História que norteia a obra taciteana em geral. Aponta-se a inserção de Tácito na tradição filosó- fica da Nova Academia, com sua ênfase na equidade, e a aproximação entre a história e a tragédia no tocante a suas finalidades éticas. Palavras-chave: Diálogo dos Oradores. Tácito. Retórica. História. Introdução O Diálogo dos Oradores, de Tácito, cujo tema – o declínio da elo- quência – é tratado mediante aproximações entre a poesia e a ora-tória, possibilita uma avaliação da concepção de História de Tácito, em paralelo com suas outras obras, como as Histórias e os Anais. Tal perspectiva é pouco aplicada à análise do Dialogus, embora permita discutir as relações entre retórica e história, tão candentes na produ-ção acadêmica sobre historiografia antiga.1 * Professor adjunto de História Antiga e Medieval na Universidade Federal do Recôn- cavo da Bahia. Membro do Laboratório de Estudos sobre o Império Romano (LEIR). E-mail: [email protected] Anos 90, Porto Alegre, v. 16, n. 30, p. 19-43, dez. 2009 Ética, retórica e poética no Diálogo dos Oradores e a concepção... Durante longo tempo sustentou-se que o Dialogus seria a pri- meira obra de Tácito, escrita em 97 e antes da publicação da Vida de Agrícola e da Germânia. Contudo, a dedicação da obra a um certo Fábio Justo (Dialogus, I, 1),2 cônsul em 102 e governador da Síria em 106, levou estudiosos a localizar a obra entre este período, privile- giando-se a primeira data.3 Pierre Grimal, em seu estudo sobre Tácito, reforçou esta hipótese ao considerar o Dialogus como um 20 elogio da monarquia de Trajano, colocando então sua publicação nos primeiros anos deste reinado (GRIMAL, 1990, p.
    [Show full text]
  • Revista Anos 90 N 30.P65
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Archives of the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine UFRGS Ética, Retórica e Poética no Diálogo dos Oradores e a concepção de História em Tácito Fábio Duarte Joly* Resumo: Este artigo busca analisar o Diálogo dos Oradores, de Tácito, relacionando sua estrutura compositiva e temas a uma discussão acerca da concepção de História que norteia a obra taciteana em geral. Aponta-se a inserção de Tácito na tradição filosó- fica da Nova Academia, com sua ênfase na equidade, e a aproximação entre a história e a tragédia no tocante a suas finalidades éticas. Palavras-chave: Diálogo dos Oradores. Tácito. Retórica. História. Introdução O Diálogo dos Oradores, de Tácito, cujo tema – o declínio da elo- quência – é tratado mediante aproximações entre a poesia e a ora-tória, possibilita uma avaliação da concepção de História de Tácito, em paralelo com suas outras obras, como as Histórias e os Anais. Tal perspectiva é pouco aplicada à análise do Dialogus, embora permita discutir as relações entre retórica e história, tão candentes na produ-ção acadêmica sobre historiografia antiga.1 * Professor adjunto de História Antiga e Medieval na Universidade Federal do Recôn- cavo da Bahia. Membro do Laboratório de Estudos sobre o Império Romano (LEIR). E-mail: [email protected] Anos 90, Porto Alegre, v. 16, n. 30, p. 19-43, dez. 2009 Ética, retórica e poética no Diálogo dos Oradores e a concepção... Durante longo tempo sustentou-se que o Dialogus seria a pri- meira obra de Tácito, escrita em 97 e antes da publicação da Vida de Agrícola e da Germânia.
    [Show full text]
  • Forma Mentis: Apariencia Y Realidad En La Germania De Tácito ( )
    FORMA MENTIS: APARIENCIA Y REALIDAD EN LA GERMANIA DE TÁCITO ( ) RICARDO GABRIEL CAPUTO Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina 112 Ricardo Gabriel Caputo FORMA MENTIS: APARIENCIA Y REALIDAD EN LA GERMANIA DE TÁCITO* Resumen: el objetivo de este trabajo es interpretar la Germania de Tácito en tanto texto etnográfico y autoetnográfico, i.e. como crítico de la sociedad romana. Se rechazan los presupuestos filosóficos de “No Place like Rome: Identity and Difference in The Germania of Tacitus” de Ellen O’Gorman (§1), se analiza la escritura etnográfica de Tácito a través de la guerra y el comercio, enfatizando las ideas de forma, belleza, materia, mores y mente (§2). Por último, se destaca el uso utópico y de crítica interna que adquiere el texto de Tácito (§3). Palabras clave: mente, forma, apariencia, realidad, eternidad. FORMA MENTIS: APPEARANCE AND REALITY IN THE GERMANIA OF TACITUS Abstract: The aim of this paper is to analyze the Germania of Tacitus as an ethnographic as well as an autoethnografic text, i.e. as a criticism of the Roman society. After rejecting the philosophical presuppositions that underlie Ellen O’Gorman’s “No Place like Rome: Identity and Difference in The Germania of Tacitus” (§1), we analyze the ethnographic writing of Tacitus and its Roman context (war and trade), emphasising the ideas of form, beauty, matter, mores and mind (§2). Finally, we conclude underlining the utopian and critical possibilities that gave and give shape to this text (§3). Keywords: Mind, Form, Appearance, Reality, Eternity. Fecha de recepción: diciembre 16 de 2015 Fecha de aceptación: agosto 13 de 2016 Forma de citar (APA): Caputo, R.
    [Show full text]
  • Annales Tacite (0055?-0120?)
    1/15 Data Annales Tacite (0055?-0120?) Titre principal : Annales (latin) Langue : Latin Genre ou forme de l’œuvre : Œuvres textuelles Date : 110 Note : Oeuvre historique, sans doute en 18 livres. Nous sont parvenus les livres I à IV, des fragments des livres V et VI et les livres XI à XVI Domaines : Archéologie. Préhistoire. Histoire ancienne Autres formes du titre : Ab excessu divi Augusti (latin) Annalium ab excessu divi Augusti libri (latin) Annalium libri XVI (latin) Annals (anglais) Annalen (allemand) Éditions de Annales (165 ressources dans data.bnf.fr) Livres (164) Annales, livres IV, V et VI , Tacite (0055?-0120?), Tacite. Annales, texte , Tacite (0055?-0120?) Paris : Hachette , [s.d.] latin... Tacite. Annales. Texte latin , Tacite (0055?-0120?) Annales. Histoire , Tacite (0055?-0120?), (S. publié avec des arguments l. n. d.) et des notes en français... Nouvelle édition Les Annales, traduction , Tacite (0055?-0120?), Tacite. Annales , Tacite (0055?-0120?), française revue par A. Paris , (s. d.). In-18 Corbeil , [s.d.] Lebobe Tacite. Annales , Tacite (0055?-0120?), The Annals of Tacitus , Tacite (0055?-0120?), [S.l.n.d. ?] (2018) Cambridge (GB) ; New York ; Melbourne : Cambridge university press , 2018 data.bnf.fr 2/15 Data Annals 15 , Tacite (0055?-0120?), Tacitus Annals XVI , Tacite (0055?-0120?), (2018) Cambridge (GB) : (2018) London : Bloomsbury Cambridge University Press Academic , 2018 Vie de l'empereur Claude. - [2] The Annals of Tacitus , Tacite (0055?-0120?), (2017) (2016) Cambridge (GB) ; New York ; Melbourne : Cambridge university press , 2016 The Annals of Tacitus 11 , Tacite (0055?-0120?), Annales , Tacite (0055?-0120?), (2013) Cambridge : Cambridge (2012) Clermont-Ferrand : Éd.
    [Show full text]