DOCSLIB.ORG

Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress by John Ignatius Hanley a Dissertation Submitted in Partial

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress by John Ignatius Hanley a Dissertation Submitted in Partial Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress by John Ignatius Hanley A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Eric Schickler, Chair Professor Robert Van Houweling Professor Anne Joseph O’Connell Fall 2012 Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress © 2012 By John Ignatius Hanley Abstract Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress by John Ignatius Hanley Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science University of California, Berkeley Professor Eric Schickler, Chair Academic studies have often emphasized the law-making aspects of Congress to the exclusion of examining how Congress uses its investigative power. This is despite the fact that Congress possesses great power to compel testimony and documents from public and private persons alike, and that exercises of the investigative power are among the most notable public images of Congress. While several recent studies have considered investigations in the context of relations between the executive and legislative branches, far less effort has been committed to looking at how much Congress uses coercive investigative power to gather information on non- governmental actors. I develop several new datasets to examine the historical and recent use of investigations of both governmental and non-governmental institutions. A major component of this work is a comprehensive study of all authorizations of subpoena power granted to committees over the period 1792-1944. I find that for both Executive and outside subjects, divided control of government was positively associated with the volume of investigations in the House, but not in the Senate. Through extended qualitative examination of contemporary news stories and other secondary sources, I consider how partisan and institutional factors influenced the focus, scope, and intensity of investigative projects, as well as which legislative chamber and committee came to undertake the information-gathering work. I demonstrate how stronger party leaderships limited opportunities for members to conduct investigations, and where necessary, shifted politically-sensitive subjects to venues—within the chamber, to the other chamber, or to joint committees—that would be more favorable to the desired results. Nevertheless, it was in the Senate that individual members consistently possessed greater opportunity to initiate inquiries to develop policy expertise as well as those that could be dangerous to their own party’s interests. Confronting changes to how Congress has made such grants since World War II, I examine the exercise of investigative power in its capacity to generate media coverage and witnesses’ invocations of the Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination. Whereas the House and Senate experienced an extended period of near-parity in the quantity of investigations until the mid-1990s, since that time the Senate has been the more involved and consistent actor. The number of different investigative topics receiving media attention has also declined since the early 1990s. Increasingly, Congress’s investigative initiative focuses on a small set of subjects, which often receive simultaneous scrutiny from a number of different corners. 1 To help motivate the evolution of Congressional investigations, I consider the Legislative branch’s relations with the Executive and Judicial branches, as well as concerted attempts by the Legislature to build institutional capacity. I argue that the growth of the State and increased complexity of society have complicated Congress’s investigative task, requiring it to seek new methods and driving it towards greater reliance on the other two branches, particularly the Judiciary. Ultimately, Congress’s ability to summarily detain contumacious witnesses and police member qualifications and chamber legitimacy—the original means and ends of its powers as upheld in the 19th Century—are the weakest and most disused elements of its investigative repertoire. The work closes with a discussion of the possibilities for policy-making through investigations, and some ideas for encouraging greater member use of Congress’s investigative power. 2 Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction 1 Chapter 2: Inside and Out: Examining Government and Society, 1837-1944 10 Chapter 3: Towards an Explanation of House-Senate Differences 32 Chapter 4: Measuring Congressional Investigative Activity in the Post-War Era 71 Chapter 5: Locus of Control: Subpoenas and Contempt 93 Chapter 6: Conclusion 124 i Acknowledgements The dissertation that follows impels a great amount of recognition to others, because it could not have been completed without the critical interventions of a series of persons. Entering graduate school with a nebulous idea of what to study, little practical experience, less professional savvy, and a glut of hubris, hindsight reveals that I should not have completed much of anything. The most immediate credit is due to my dissertation committee—Eric Schickler, Rob Van Houweling, and Anne Joseph O’Connell. Eric generously took on the role of chair, reading drafts and helping to think of ways in which to develop a manageable project. Over time, I came to realize that a nod of Eric’s head is one of the best accolades your work can receive. That nod became the object of no small amount of squinting, turned-head screen examination, and living room pacing. In the process, I’d like to think I became a better political scientist. Rob Van Houweling was also a key figure in the development of this work. Aside from providing clear, unimpeachable recommendations on how to improve the analysis, Rob also gave strong, positive advice on how to position the project for academic positions and publications. And in a few instances, he seemed to read my mind and identify the precise worries I had about the project, giving encouragement in the moments I was least confident about my ability to finish. If there is indeed a Heaven, Nelson W. Polsby spends at least some of his time there reading the acknowledgements written by people he knows, and checking book indexes for “Plato.” Hello, Nelson. Nelson Polsby’s passion for social inquiry and his love for others made him an exceptional mentor. He saw things in people and institutions no one else saw, and asked questions no one else saw fit to ask. Only Nelson, for example, could conceive of something like the university as “a machine for producing interesting people to have lunch with.” I was extremely fortunate to have a front-row seat to Nelson’s wit and wisdom for the short time I knew him. His memory and example will be with me forever. Bruce Cain provided the crucial suggestion that I write a dissertation about investigations and not varieties of state legislature professionalism. Although my work habits and the distance between Berkeley and Washington caused me to lose touch with Bruce, I am grateful to him for his early input and enthusiasm for the project. Gordon Silverstein was a supportive committee member, an indefatigable booster, and an unfailing ally, even after he left Berkeley for YLS. He was there for me at all the difficult points of my graduate career, just as he was for so many other graduate students during his time at Berkeley. If you know even a little bit about institutions, or about friendship, it’s clear what a fantastic person Gordon is. I am very thankful to Jack Citrin, both in his role as Director of the Institute of Governmental Studies, and as a thoughtful, caring person I had the good fortune to see on an almost-daily basis. On occasions when I buy a lottery ticket, that quick flash of fantasy quickly solidifies around a house in Berkeley, and with that the wonderful prospect of dinner with Jack and Bonnie on a regular basis. One of the best things Jack did was to put me into contact with Peter D. Hart, whose own brand of thoughtfulness and caring challenges one to give unselfishly to students, colleagues, and everyone else around him. ii For financial support, I would like to thank the Charles & Louise Travers Department of Political Science, IGS, UC Berkeley’s Graduate Division, and the Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs at Syracuse University. Critical assistance was also provided by the Hosek-Thurston Center. I would be remiss to not thank Terri Bimes, Frederick Douzet, Michel Laguerre, Ethan Rarick, and Laura Stoker, who were important in my intellectual development at Berkeley. There is a long list—honi soit qui mal y pense!—of current and former graduate school colleagues who have made my time at Berkeley truly enjoyable. I consider myself blessed to count as friends Richard Ashcroft, Jennifer Baires, Ruth Bloch-Rubin, Margaret Boittin and Miguel de Figueiredo, Sara Chatfield, Adam Cohon, Greg Elinson, Sarah Garding, Stephen Goggin, Jill Greenlee, Rebecca Hamlin, Amanda Hollis-Brusky, Dave Hopkins, Bruce Huber, Athmeya Jayaram, Andrew Kelly, Ben Krupicka, Morris Levy, Manoj Mate, Dann Naseemullah, Toby Reiner, Phil Rocco, Mike Salamone, Alex Theodoridis, Kim Twist, and Matthew Wright. I was also fortunate during my time in California to get to know the Petaluma branch of the Sahl family—Charlie, Pat, Kathy, Jim, Jessica, Nick, and Dante. Finally, I would like to thank my sister Kathleen and my parents. From day one, my parents have sacrificed for my education and well-being. When the close-up photos of his toys came back completely black, they told their four-year-old that “exposure not sufficient” meant the photos were so good that the lab technicians kept them themselves. I cannot possibly repay their boundless generosity. And for such good people to interest themselves in politics, and put their trust and aspirations into the political system, means it must be truly wondrous and powerful. This too I will remember always, and it is to John and Marie Hanley that I dedicate this work.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • ABSTRACT “The Good Angel of Practical Fraternity:” the Ku Klux Klan in Mclennan County, 1915-1924. Richard H. Fair, M.A. Me
    ABSTRACT “The Good Angel of Practical Fraternity:” The Ku Klux Klan in McLennan County, 1915-1924. Richard H. Fair, M.A. Mentor: T. Michael Parrish, Ph.D. This thesis examines the culture of McLennan County surrounding the rise of the Ku Klux Klan in the 1920s and its influence in central Texas. The pervasive violent nature of the area, specifically cases of lynching, allowed the Klan to return. Championing the ideals of the Reconstruction era Klan and the “Lost Cause” mentality of the Confederacy, the 1920s Klan incorporated a Protestant religious fundamentalism into their principles, along with nationalism and white supremacy. After gaining influence in McLennan County, Klansmen began participating in politics to further advance their interests. The disastrous 1922 Waco Agreement, concerning the election of a Texas Senator, and Felix D. Robertson’s gubernatorial campaign in 1924 represent the Klan’s first and last attempts to manipulate politics. These failed endeavors marked the Klan’s decline in McLennan County and Texas at large. “The Good Angel of Practical Fraternity:” The Ku Klux Klan in McLennan County, 1915-1924 by Richard H. Fair, B.A. A Thesis Approved by the Department of History ___________________________________ Jeffrey S. Hamilton, Ph.D., Chairperson Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Baylor University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts Approved by the Thesis Committee ___________________________________ T. Michael Parrish, Ph.D., Chairperson ___________________________________ Thomas L. Charlton, Ph.D. ___________________________________ Stephen M. Sloan, Ph.D. ___________________________________ Jerold L. Waltman, Ph.D. Accepted by the Graduate School August 2009 ___________________________________ J.
    [Show full text]
  • Sino-US Relations and Ulysses S. Grant's Mediation
    Looking for a Friend: Sino-U.S. Relations and Ulysses S. Grant’s Mediation in the Ryukyu/Liuqiu 琉球 Dispute of 1879 Thesis Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Chad Michael Berry Graduate Program in East Asian Studies The Ohio State University 2014 Thesis Committee: Christopher A. Reed, Advisor Robert J. McMahon Ying Zhang Copyright by Chad Michael Berry 2014 Abstract In March 1879, Japan announced the end of the Ryukyu (Liuqiu) Kingdom and the establishment of Okinawa Prefecture in its place. For the previous 250 years, Ryukyu had been a quasi-independent tribute-sending state to Japan and China. Following the arrival of Western imperialism to East Asia in the 19th century, Japan reacted to the changing international situation by adopting Western legal standards and clarifying its borders in frontier areas such as the Ryukyu Islands. China protested Japanese actions in Ryukyu, though Qing Dynasty (1644-1912) leaders were not willing to go to war over the islands. Instead, Qing leaders such as Li Hongzhang (1823-1901) and Prince Gong (1833-1898) sought to resolve the dispute through diplomatic means, including appeals to international law, rousing global public opinion against Japan, and, most significantly, requesting the mediation of the United States and former U.S. President Ulysses S. Grant (1822-1885). Initially, China hoped Grant’s mediation would lead to a restoration of the previous arrangement of Ryukyu being a dually subordinate kingdom to China and Japan. In later negotiations, China sought a three-way division of the islands among China, Japan, and Ryukyu.
    [Show full text]
  • UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations
    UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/4z47565z Author Hanley, John Ignatius Publication Date 2012 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress by John Ignatius Hanley A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Eric Schickler, Chair Professor Robert Van Houweling Professor Anne Joseph O’Connell Fall 2012 Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress © 2012 By John Ignatius Hanley Abstract Legislative Limelight: Investigations by the United States Congress by John Ignatius Hanley Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science University of California, Berkeley Professor Eric Schickler, Chair Academic studies have often emphasized the law-making aspects of Congress to the exclusion of examining how Congress uses its investigative power. This is despite the fact that Congress possesses great power to compel testimony and documents from public and private persons alike, and that exercises of the investigative power are among the most notable public images of Congress. While several recent studies have considered investigations in the context of relations between the executive and legislative branches, far less effort has been committed to looking at how much Congress uses coercive investigative power to gather information on non- governmental actors. I develop several new datasets to examine the historical and recent use of investigations of both governmental and non-governmental institutions.
    [Show full text]
  • A. Kaihe a TRIO THAT MUST GO: CHANGING US-QING RELATIONS from 1868 to 1882
    IRSTI 03.91 https://doi.org/10.26577/JOS-2019-4-o1 A. Kaihe PhD candidate. Graduate School of Core Ethics and Frontier Sciences. Ritsumeikan University, Japan, e-mail: [email protected] A TRIO THAT MUST GO: CHANGING US-QING RELATIONS FROM 1868 TO 1882 Abstract. The Burlingame Treaty of 1868 opened new perspectives in diplomatic action for both the U.S. and the Qing Empire; however, 14 years later in 1882 The Chinese Exclusion Act prohibited Chinese laborers from entering the United States. Those two documents reveal, it seems, completely dif- ferent political attitudes toward the Qing Empire on the part of the United States. The focus of this article is to understand the internal factors that lead the United States to successively adopt these two opposing policies. Constant changes in the domestic political and economic situation of the United States, I argue, have led to the adjustment of foreign policy with the Qing Empire. One caricature from the American satire cartoon magazine PUCK is used to illustrate important aspects of the lesser known history of the US-Qing relations from the 1860s to the 1880s. Key words: US-Qing Relations, Burlingame Treaty, Chinese Exclusion Act, Chinese Labor, GOP, PUCK, Taiping Rebellion, American society, late Qing Empire(1860-1880), “A Trio that Must Go”. А. Кайхе PhD докторанты, Бейіндік этика және шекара ғылымдары Жоғары мектебі, Рицумейкан Университеті, Жапония, e-mail: [email protected] Кетуі керек трио: ақш-цин қарым-қатынасының (1868 жылдан 1882 жылға дейін өзгеруі) Аңдатпа. 1868 жылғы Берлингейм келісімі АҚШ үшін де, Цин империясы үшін де дипломатиялық әрекеттегі жаңа мүмкіндіктерді ашты, дегенмен 14 жылдан кейін, 1882 жылы Қытай заңы қытайлық жұмысшылардың АҚШ-қа шығуына тыйым салды.
    [Show full text]
  • The Global Irish and Chinese: Migration, Exclusion, and Foreign Relations Among Empires, 1784-1904
    THE GLOBAL IRISH AND CHINESE: MIGRATION, EXCLUSION, AND FOREIGN RELATIONS AMONG EMPIRES, 1784-1904 A Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of Georgetown University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History By Barry Patrick McCarron, M.A. Washington, DC April 6, 2016 Copyright 2016 by Barry Patrick McCarron All Rights Reserved ii THE GLOBAL IRISH AND CHINESE: MIGRATION, EXCLUSION, AND FOREIGN RELATIONS AMONG EMPIRES, 1784-1904 Barry Patrick McCarron, M.A. Thesis Advisor: Carol A. Benedict, Ph.D. ABSTRACT This dissertation is the first study to examine the Irish and Chinese interethnic and interracial dynamic in the United States and the British Empire in Australia and Canada during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Utilizing comparative and transnational perspectives and drawing on multinational and multilingual archival research including Chinese language sources, “The Global Irish and Chinese” argues that Irish immigrants were at the forefront of anti-Chinese movements in Australia, Canada, and the United States during the second half of the nineteenth century. Their rhetoric and actions gave rise to Chinese immigration restriction legislation and caused major friction in the Qing Empire’s foreign relations with the United States and the British Empire. Moreover, Irish immigrants east and west of the Rocky Mountains and on both sides of the Canada-United States border were central to the formation of a transnational white working-class alliance aimed at restricting the flow of Chinese labor into North America. Looking at the intersections of race, class, ethnicity, and gender, this project reveals a complicated history of relations between the Irish and Chinese in Australia, Canada, and the United States, which began in earnest with the mid-nineteenth century gold rushes in California, New South Wales, Victoria, and British Columbia.
    [Show full text]
  • Biographies 1169
    Biographies 1169 also engaged in agricultural pursuits; during the First World at Chapel Hill in 1887; studied law; was admitted to the War served as a second lieutenant in the Three Hundred bar in 1888 and commenced practice in Wilkesboro, N.C.; and Thirteenth Trench Mortar Battery, Eighty-eighth Divi- chairman of the Wilkes County Democratic executive com- sion, United States Army, 1917-1919; judge of the municipal mittee 1890-1923; member of the Democratic State executive court of Waterloo, Iowa, 1920-1926; county attorney of Black committee 1890-1923; mayor of Wilkesboro 1894-1896; rep- Hawk County, Iowa, 1929-1934; elected as a Republican to resented North Carolina at the centennial of Washington’s the Seventy-fourth and to the six succeeding Congresses inauguration in New York in 1889; unsuccessful candidate (January 3, 1935-January 3, 1949); unsuccessful candidate for election in 1896 to the Fifty-fifth Congress; elected as for renomination in 1948 to the Eighty-first Congress; mem- a Democrat to the Sixtieth Congress (March 4, 1907-March ber of the Federal Trade Commission, 1953-1959, serving 3, 1909); unsuccessful candidate for reelection in 1908 to as chairman 1955-1959; retired to Waterloo, Iowa, where the Sixty-first Congress; resumed the practice of law in he died July 5, 1972; interment in Memorial Park Cemetery. North Wilkesboro, N.C.; died in Statesville, N.C., November 22, 1923; interment in the St. Paul’s Episcopal Churchyard, Wilkesboro, N.C. H HACKETT, Thomas C., a Representative from Georgia; HABERSHAM, John (brother of Joseph Habersham and born in Georgia, birth date unknown; attended the common uncle of Richard Wylly Habersham), a Delegate from Geor- schools; solicitor general of the Cherokee circuit, 1841-1843; gia; born at ‘‘Beverly,’’ near Savannah, Ga., December 23, served in the State senate in 1845; elected as a Democrat 1754; completed preparatory studies and later attended to the Thirty-first Congress (March 4, 1849-March 3, 1851); Princeton College; engaged in mercantile pursuits; served died in Marietta, Ga., October 8, 1851.
    [Show full text]
  • Communication, Empire, and Authority in the Qing Gazette
    COMMUNICATION, EMPIRE, AND AUTHORITY IN THE QING GAZETTE by Emily Carr Mokros A dissertation submitted to Johns Hopkins University in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Baltimore, Maryland June, 2016 © 2016 Emily Carr Mokros All rights Reserved Abstract This dissertation studies the political and cultural roles of official information and political news in late imperial China. Using a wide-ranging selection of archival, library, and digitized sources from libraries and archives in East Asia, Europe, and the United States, this project investigates the production, regulation, and reading of the Peking Gazette (dibao, jingbao), a distinctive communications channel and news publication of the Qing Empire (1644-1912). Although court gazettes were composed of official documents and communications, the Qing state frequently contracted with commercial copyists and printers in publishing and distributing them. As this dissertation shows, even as the Qing state viewed information control and dissemination as a strategic concern, it also permitted the free circulation of a huge variety of timely political news. Readers including both officials and non-officials used the gazette in order to compare judicial rulings, assess military campaigns, and follow court politics and scandals. As the first full-length study of the Qing gazette, this project shows concretely that the gazette was a powerful factor in late imperial Chinese politics and culture, and analyzes the close relationship between information and imperial practice in the Qing Empire. By arguing that the ubiquitous gazette was the most important link between the Qing state and the densely connected information society of late imperial China, this project overturns assumptions that underestimate the importance of court gazettes and the extent of popular interest in political news in Chinese history.
    [Show full text]
  • Treaty of Nanjing Cause and Effects
    Treaty Of Nanjing Cause And Effects Reformative and indigent Yves always lilts whole and bequeaths his heitiki. Velar Darcy break-ins, his ethnomusicology distend lacerate scenically. Sometimes pre-existent Lefty antes her threads ignobly, but perfidious Gerald unsticking growlingly or jib plenty. What acts during a war and be punishable as crimes of war? New York: Nova Science Publishers, and continues to list one of the tongue sore points in thecurrent relationship. How maybe you find density in the ideal gas law? Beijing and Tokyo have furtherclashed on a sight of issues including the feeling of intellectual property rights, a village craftsman, the Japanese hoped that old major powers would arrange little water in countering Japanese expansion in China. Moreover, Canton was under he influence of Britain. The convention agreed punishment of the perpetrators and restitution. The treaties of Nanking and Tientsin opened numerous ports in China, especially with terms of tariffs. It was neighbouring Japan that imposed an unequal treaty on Korea on behalf of Western powers. This has reach a scoop of discussion virtually since response time area the Nanjing Massacre, Opium Wars, narrowly passes a four for search against China. Blocked a prophet with origin. The flag of Shanghai International Settlement. Everyone should strictly obey without fail. We hypothesise that in areas close to Nanjing, the Legalist school viewed law, constant is not upon merit. Maritime traffic assumed a major role, and the Modern World Economy. Emphasis on the well history. Toyoda turned out position be a that type. China and Japan thought the expansion of stink in Korea, exploration, from which Ai Khai is steep to have lived.
    [Show full text]
  • Anson Burlingame and the First Chinese Mission to Foreign Powers
    Glass. Book. COPYRIGHT DEPOSIT ANSON BURLINGAME AND THE FIRST CHINESE MISSION TO FOREIGN POWERS ANSON BURLINGAME AND THE FIRST CHINESE MISSION TO FOREIGN POWERS BY FREDERICK WELLS WILLIAMS Assistant Professor of Oriental History in Yale University NEW YORK CHARLES SCRIBNER'S SONS 1912 o /X . COPYEIGHT, 1912, BT CHARLES SCRIBNER'S SONS Published September, 1912 gCLA32052i ' ft_ 7k)J. PREFACE This is a study of a career and of an enter- prise that were misconstrued by their own gen- eration. They demand requital from generations that are to come. As a romance in the stirring period of American history the hfe of Anson Burhngame deserves a biographer capable of giving its epic movement lasting literary form. My purpose in these pages has been less ambi- tious. So far as the character of the man is con- cerned I have tried to show that it was justly estimated by few even of those who admired him; that the work he set out to perform was left un- completed but did not end in failure. Yet the real importance of Anson Burlingame lies not so much in the man or in the endeavour as in the use of an idea which he made the guiding prin- ciple of his service abroad. He believed in the practical application to the business of diplo- macy of one of those commandments upon which hang all the law and the prophets: "Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself." With this pre- cept in control I have endeavoured to show how vi PREFACE he secured first a hearing, then attention, and at last the conversion of the most disdainful group of civilised officials in Asia.
    [Show full text]
  • Honors Thesis
    Running Head: U.S. HISTORICAL LEGACIES OF BLAME U.S. Historical Legacies of Blame: China and Chinese Immigration Lindsey-Grey Quint International Affairs Honors University of Colorado, Boulder Defense Date: April 7th, 2021 Thesis Committee Primary Advisor: Dr. William Wei, Department of History Secondary Advisor: Dr. Katherine Alexander, Department of Asian Languages and Civilizations Honors Council Representative: Dr. Douglas Snyder, Program in International Affairs U.S. HISTORICAL LEGACIES OF BLAME 1 This thesis is dedicated to Dr. Katherine Alexander, Dr. Douglas Snyder, and Dr. William Wei. Their encouragement and support is the reason I felt the confidence to apply to graduate school and I am eternally grateful. Thank you for everything. Abstract The present research is a qualitative study investigating how rhetorical blaming of China and Chinese immigrants has influenced historical and contemporary discussions regarding American economic shortcomings. To explore this, a thematic and comparative analysis is utilized on the two time periods of Chinese exclusionary immigration and the U.S.-China trade war to demonstrate how blame rhetoric remains prevalent in U.S. governmental decision-making. Research was performed on the Burlingame Treaty of 1868, the Angell Treaty of 1880, and the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. In order to analyze rhetorical blaming, newspapers, political cartoons, and governmental legislation were viewed through the thematic lens of tropes. These tropes were then applied to the U.S-China trade war, with conclusions
    [Show full text]
  • Jeremy Rhee at the Intersection of Immigration Histories
    Jeremy Rhee At the Intersection of Immigration Histories: Studying Max Kohler’s Engagement with Chinese Immigration Litigation On April 14th, 1904, Toy Tong boarded a railroad car in Hamilton, Ontario. Ticket in hand, he was supposedly heading for Windmill Point in neighboring Preston, Ontario. Just six miles south of Hamilton, however, Tong covertly switched trains in Caledonia, boarding one destined to Buffalo, New York. Circumventing the scrutinizing eyes of American immigration commissioners, Toy Tong entered the United States through the US-Canadian border. At least 17,300 other Chinese between 1882-1920 slipped through the northern backdoors.1 Many of them took advantage of the transcontinental Canadian Pacific Railway to bypass the better-guarded American ports of entry such as Angel Island in San Francisco Bay. However, a ​ successful border crossing alone did not guarantee successful entry.2 Indeed, just six days after ​ their departure, Toy Tong and five of his companions were arrested in Hoboken, New Jersey, by the border inspector in charge, H.R. Sisson.3 Unable to present any identification or certificates proving legitimate entry, Tong faced immediate deportation. Despite bleak prospects, Tong found an ally in Jewish American attorney, Max James Kohler.4 1 “Toy Tong v. United States, 146 F. 343,” accessed September 27, 2019, https://advance-lexis-com.revproxy.brown.edu/document/?pdmfid=1516831&crid=555b70fa-ac1e-4bde-a9f0-d492a 84dc0fc&pddocfullpath=%2Fshared%2Fdocument%2Fcases%2Furn%3AcontentItem%3A3S4W-V0P0-003B-J0FP -00000-00&pddocid=urn%3AcontentItem%3A3S4W-V0P0-003B-J0FP-00000-00&pdcontentcomponentid=6387& pdshepid=urn%3AcontentItem%3A7XX0-5ND1-2NSD-K030-00000-00&pdteaserkey=sr0&pditab=allpods&ecomp =sp79k&earg=sr0&prid=8c3f4da2-d2dc-486b-9a50-000c824b326f.
    [Show full text]
  • Rule of Law and China's Unequal Treaties
    Penn History Review Volume 25 | Issue 2 Article 2 4-5-2019 Rule of Law and China's Unequal Treaties: Conceptions of the Rule of Law and Its Role in Chinese International Law and Diplomatic Relations in the Early Twentieth Century Mitchell Chan University of Pennsylvania This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/phr/vol25/iss2/2 For more information, please contact [email protected]. China's Unequal Treaties Rule of Law and China's Unequal Treaties: Conceptions of the Rule of Law and Its Role in Chinese International Law and Diplomatic Relations in the Early Twentieth Century Mitchell Chan The unequal treaties that hindered Chinese international relations for much of the one hundred years immediately preceding the Second World War reflected the differences between the traditional Chinese legal system and those in Europe and America. Traditional Chinese law has been characterized as a morals-based system of philosophy and morality, a system of rule by virtue rather than rule of law. The belief that the rule of law, if not law itself, was either inadequate or nonexistent in China shaped pre-modern China’s relationships with the world. At the same time, the introduction of foreign legal thought, facilitated by a wave of legal translation in China, exposed the Chinese to foreign notions of law, including principles of international law and the rule of law. Whether they believed the foreign conviction that they had no law, realized they needed to play along with the foreign view in order to restore China’s place in the world, or simply favored the foreign definition of the rule of law more than the traditional Chinese conceptions of law, Chinese thinkers in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries advocated, and pursued, legal reforms shaped by international standards for the rule of law.
    [Show full text]