Effects of Dam Construction in the Wang River on Sediment Regimes in the Chao Phraya River Basin
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
water Article Effects of Dam Construction in the Wang River on Sediment Regimes in the Chao Phraya River Basin Warit Charoenlerkthawin 1,2, Matharit Namsai 1,3, Komkrit Bidorn 2, Chaipant Rukvichai 1, Balamurugan Panneerselvam 4 and Butsawan Bidorn 1,2,* 1 Department of Water Resources Engineering, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok 10330, Thailand; [email protected] (W.C.); [email protected] (M.N.); [email protected] (C.R.) 2 WISE Research Unit, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok 10330, Thailand; [email protected] 3 The Royal Irrigation Department, Bangkok 10300, Thailand 4 Department of Civil Engineering, M. Kumarasamy College of Engineering, Karur, Tamilnadu 639113, India; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: The Wang River is one of the major tributaries of the Chao Phraya River (CPR) system in Thailand as the key riverine sediment source supplying the Chao Phraya Delta that has experienced severe shoreline retreat in the past six decades. Historical and observed river flow and sediment data measured during 1929–2019 were used to assess the variation in total sediment load along the Wang River and evaluate the effects of three major dam constructions on sediment supplied from the Wang River to the CPR. Results indicated that sediment loads increased toward downstream. Variation in long-term total sediment load (TSL) along the river suggested that construction of the Citation: Charoenlerkthawin, W.; Kiew Lom Dam in 1972 did not cause a reduction in sediment yield in the Wang River Basin because Namsai, M.; Bidorn, K.; Rukvichai, C.; it impounded less than 20% of the average annual runoff, while the Mae Chang and Kiew Koh Ma Panneerselvam, B.; Bidorn, B. Effects Dams caused downstream sediment reduction. These three dams are located in the upper and middle of Dam Construction in the Wang river basins, and their effects on sediment load in the Wang River are ameliorated by additional River on Sediment Regimes in the sediment supplied from the lower basin. Results confirmed that construction of these three major Chao Phraya River Basin. Water 2021, 13, 2146. https://doi.org/10.3390/w dams in the Wang River did not greatly impact sediment supply from the Wang River to the CPR 13162146 system. The dam site and sediment load variation along the river are the primary factors controlling the impact of the dam construction. Academic Editor: Bommanna Krishnappan Keywords: riverine sediment processes; sediment load; bedload; suspended sediment load; hu- man activity Received: 28 June 2021 Accepted: 2 August 2021 Published: 4 August 2021 1. Introduction Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral During the past several decades, changes in riverine sediment flux have been re- with regard to jurisdictional claims in ported due to human activities such as deforestation, damming, water diversion, and sand published maps and institutional affil- mining [1–5]. Modification of riverine transport patterns directly affects sediment load iations. carried to coastal oceans. Dams are one of the common structures widely used in water management systems worldwide. Dam construction disturbs river flow regimes, resulting in a change in sediment transport processes [6–32]. Different degrees in sediment reduction due to damming were observed in many major rivers around the world. For example, Copyright: © 2021 by the authors. construction of the Three Gorges Dam in the Yangtze River [11–18], the High Aswan Dam Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. in the Nile River [19–21], the Hoa Binh Dam in the Red River [22–25], and many dams This article is an open access article in the Mekong River such as the Manwan Dam [26–32] has caused sediment reduction distributed under the terms and of 60%, 98%, 61–70%, and 40–96%, respectively. Dams impound sediment behind the conditions of the Creative Commons structure and alter river flow and sediment loads downstream; differences in geological Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// setting and hydrological conditions, including dam location, may cause different impacts creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/). on sediment load in a river. Regarding the adverse effects of damming on sediment supply Water 2021, 13, 2146. https://doi.org/10.3390/w13162146 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/water Water 2021, 13, 2146 2 of 20 Water 2021, 13, 2146 2 of 20 different impacts on sediment load in a river. Regarding the adverse effects of damming on sediment supply to coastal environments, it has been questioned whether a dam is still to coastal environments, it has been questioned whether a dam is still a proper tool for a proper tool for serving sustainable water management. Therefore, understanding serving sustainable water management. Therefore, understanding changes in sediment changes in sediment transport regimes responding to damming is crucial to develop sus- transport regimes responding to damming is crucial to develop sustainable water and tainable water and coastal management [33–43]. coastal management [33–43]. The Chao Phraya River Basin (Figure 1), the largest in Thailand, has delivered fluvial The Chao Phraya River Basin (Figure1), the largest in Thailand, has delivered fluvial sediments into the Gulf of Thailand forming the Chao Phraya Delta at a progradation rate sediments into the Gulf of Thailand forming the Chao Phraya Delta at a progradation rate of of 1.5 km2/y during the past 2000 years [33]. However, the Chao Phraya Delta has under- 1.5 km2/y during the past 2000 years [33]. However, the Chao Phraya Delta has undergone gone severe shoreline retreat, with an average recession rate of over 7 m/y during the last severe shoreline retreat, with an average recession rate of over 7 m/y during the last six six decades [41]. Many studies have suggested that construction of major dams in the CPR decades [41]. Many studies have suggested that construction of major dams in the CPR tributaries (thetributaries Bhumibol (theand BhumibolSirikit Dams and in Sirikit the Ping Dams and in Nan the PingRivers, and respectively) Nan Rivers, has respectively) has caused a 75–85%caused reduction a 75–85% in sediment reduction yield in sediment to the Chao yield Phraya to the D Chaoelta and Phraya is responsible Delta and is responsible for delta shorelinefor deltarecession shoreline [44–47]. recession Recently, [44 –Namsai47]. Recently, et al. [5] Namsai reported et al.that [5 ]construction reported that construction of the Bhumibolof theDam Bhumibol caused only Dam about caused a only5% reduction about a 5% in reduction sediment in supplied sediment from supplied the from the Ping Ping tributary tributaryto the CPR. to The the CPR.Wang The River Wang is one River of fou is oner major of four CPR major tributaries CPR tributaries that sup- that supplies plies water andwater sediment and sedimentto the Chao to thePhraya Chao Delta. Phraya Construction Delta. Construction of three large of three dams large as dams as the the Kiew Lom KiewDam in Lom 1972, Dam Mae in Chang 1972, Mae Dam Chang in 1979 Dam, and in Kiew 1979, Koh and Ma Kiew Dam Koh in Ma 2008 Dam on in 2008 on the the Wang RiverWang deviated River sediment deviated loads sediment to the loads CPR to by the some CPR degree. by some degree. Figure 1. MapFigure of the 1. Map Chao of Phraya the Chao River Phraya Basin, River Thailand: Basin, Thailand: (a) Wang River(a) Wang Basin River and Basin location and of location dams in of the dams Chao Phraya River system;in (theb) locationsChao Phraya of hydrological River system; stations (b) locations operated of by hydrological the Royal Irrigation stations Department operated by (RID) the Royal and observation Irri- sites in this study.gation Department (RID) and observation sites in this study. Rivers are complicatedRivers are nonlinear complicated dynamic nonlinear systems dynamic [48] systems and changes [48] and in changesgeological in geological and and hydrologicalhydrological features along features each along river eachbasin river influence basin sediment influence sedimentcharacteristics. characteristics. River River sedi- sediment data mentare vital data for are water vital resources for water resourcesmanagement management and environmental and environmental impact eval- impact evaluation. uation. In Thailand,In Thailand, sediment sediment data collected data collected in most in mostrivers rivers are insufficient are insufficient for forwater water re- resources plan- sources planningning and and assessment assessment of of the anthropologicanthropologic impact, impact, especially especially the the effects effects of damof construction dam constructionon fluvialon fluvial sediment sediment loads. loads. Moreover, Moreover, sediment sediment characteristics characteristics along along the the Wang River have Wang River havenot beennot been studied studied and documented. and documented. Therefore, Therefore, the objectives the objectives of this study of this were to (1) exam- study were to (ine1) examine sediment sediment characteristics characteristics of the Wang of the River Wang based River on river based observations, on river ob- (2) evaluate the servations, (2) temporalevaluate the variation temporal of sediment variation loads of sediment along the loads Wang along River, the and Wang (3) systematicallyRiver, assess and (3) systematicallythe impacts assess of threethe impacts major dams of three (Kiew major Lom, dams Mae (Kiew Chang, Lom, and KiewMae Chang Koh Ma), on sediment and Kiew Koh supplyMa) on fromsediment the Wang supply River from to the the Wang CPR system. River to the CPR system. Water 2021, 13, 2146 3 of 20 Water 2021, 13, 2146 3 of 20 2. Materials and Methods 2. Materials and Methods 2.1. Study Area 2.1. Study Area The Wang River Basin is one of the four river basins forming the Chao Phraya River systemThe (Figure Wang 1) River with Basin a drainage is one area of the of fourapproximately river basins 10,800 forming km2 the. The Chao Wang Phraya River Riverorig- system (Figure1) with a drainage area of approximately 10,800 km 2.