DOCSLIB.ORG

Methodism: One Peopledoi: 10.1177/1744136606063377 in All the World? 357 © 2006 SAGE Publications (London, Thousand Oaks CA and New Delhi)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Methodism: One Peopledoi: 10.1177/1744136606063377 in All the World? 357 © 2006 SAGE Publications (London, Thousand Oaks CA and New Delhi) Ecclesiology 2.3 (2006) 357–363 Methodism: One PeopleDOI: 10.1177/1744136606063377 in all the World? 357 © 2006 SAGE Publications (London, Thousand Oaks CA and New Delhi) http://ECC.sagepub.com Article Review Methodism: One People in All the World? DAVID TRIPP David Hempton, Methodism: Empire of the Spirit (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2005), xiii + 278 pp. ISBN 0–300– 10614–9 (hbk). £19.95/US $30.00. Kenneth Cracknell and Susan J. White, An Introduction to World Methodism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005), xii + 283 pp. ISBN 0–521–52170–X (pbk). £16.99/US $24.99. ISBN 0–521–81849–4 (hbk). £45.00/US $65.00. oth these books investigate Methodism sympathetically, but with coolly critical eyes, consciously avoiding what all the authors agree on calling B‘hagiography.’ In consonance with the historic stance of Methodism, they all abstain from polemic against other traditions. Their methods differ, as their respective disciplines (in which they are all eminent) are different. Hempton is a social historian; White’s husband, Cracknell, a Methodist minister and theologian of missions and history of religion; White (formerly an Episcopalian) a liturgical historian. Their books are correspondingly addressed to different readerships: Hempton primarily to social historians, White and Cracknell to all students of religion, but most directly to ecumenists and church historians. Their common concern is to combine accuracy with accessibility. White and Cracknell omit all foot- or end-notes, and rely for further guidance on a full bibliography. Both books are skilfully illustrated with apt pictures – most of them not from the conventional stock found in most works on Methodist history. Cracknell and White pursue a familiar format. The first four chapters outline succinctly, and with delicate balance, the history of world Methodism: the beginnings with the Wesley brothers and their ‘United Societies’ in eighteenth- century England; British and American developments after the Wesleys, with 358 Ecclesiology careful interpretation of the ways in which these branches of the Wesleyan family diverged in ethos, ecclesiastical structure, worship and theology; and the situation of the world Methodist community at the opening of this new century. These historical chapters have to do justice to remarkably different stages of growth, in which social, ethnic, cultural and doctrinal and liturgical factors are duly noted. The characterization on p. 99 of the smaller British Methodist denominations (New Connexion, Primitive Methodists, Bible Christians and United Methodist Free Churches, whose title ought to be correctly given) as ‘sectarian’ is an untypical lapse in an account, which is otherwise even-handed and sympathetic. The authors have to choose one of the conflicting theories as to when Methodism began, and they incline to agree with Maximin Piette about John Wesley’s first conversion (linked with reading The Imitation of Christ and similar challenging works), and they see the Holy Club at Oxford as the start of the movement – although John Wesley himself describes that event as the first rise of Methodism, ‘so called’ (Wesley’s own term). White and Cracknell also join those who maintain that the conversion experiences of the two brothers in 1738 fade from prominence in their teaching of later years. This is a tenable position, but we must observe that the structure of the 1780 Collection of Hymns for the Use of the People called Methodists continues to lead seekers through the same sort of pilgrimage which the two brothers, under Moravian tutelage, had undergone. The authors note justly that the Wesleyan movement was neither the whole nor the beginning of the Evangelical Revival. They also deal wisely with the ambivalence in the early British Methodists’ stance towards the Established Church (though we cannot follow them in seeing separatist intentions in the plan of the New Chapel in City Road, which is a typical example of the eighteenth-century ‘proprietary chapel’). The following chapters examine phenomenologically the principal aspects of Methodism throughout the world, and seek the unifying principle that holds together a remarkably diverse assortment of churches. The order of the chapters is carefully planned. Chapter 5 considers ‘Methodist Theology’, that it is to say, the doctrinal formulations (among which the Confession of Faith inherited by the present American United Methodist Church from the Evangelical United Brethren should be added on p. 93), and the varied paths which theological interpretation has taken throughout Methodism, with British theologians concentrating on biblical and historical research, and American scholars favouring philosophical approaches. One problem which Cracknell and White notice is the debated status of John Wesley’s (and others’) Notes on the New Testament (p. 115). The discussions of this matter have suffered from the failure to notice the distinctive character of this work: it is not a historical-critical exegesis, but a dynamic reading, designed to enable the growing apprehension that led the Scripture writers to choose and order their words and sentences and paragraphs to be reproduced in the personality of the hearers and readers. Cracknell and White sum up Methodist .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Mission Studies As Evangelization and Theology for World Christianity
    Mission Studies as Evangelization and Teology for World Christianity Refections on Mission Studies in Britian and Ireland, 2000 - 2015 Kirsteen Kim DOI: 10.7252/Paper. 000051 About the Author Kirsteen Kim, Ph.D., is Professor of Teology and World Christianity at Leeds Trinity University. Kirsteen researches and teaches theology from the perspective of mission and world Christianity, drawing on her experience of Christianity while living and working in South Korea, India and the USA, with a special interest in theology of the Holy Spirit. She publishes widely and is the editor of Mission Studies, the journal of the International Association for Mission Studies. 72 | Mission Studies as Evangelization and Theology for World Christianity Foreword In 2000 and in 2012 I published papers for the British and Irish Association for Mission Studies (BIAMS) on mission studies in Britain and Ireland, which were published in journals of theological education.1 Tese two papers surveyed the state of mission studies and how in this region it is related to various other disciplines. Each paper suggested a next stage in the development of mission studies: the frst saw mission studies as facilitating a worldwide web of missiological discussion; the second suggested that mission studies should be appreciated as internationalizing theology more generally. Tis article reviews the developments in Britain and Ireland over the years which are detailed in these articles and bring them up to date. It further argues that, while continuing to develop as “mission studies” or “missiology”, the discipline should today claim the names “theology for world Christianity” and “studies in evangelization.
    [Show full text]
  • Clinton Bennett
    Clinton Bennett approach allows him to treat Islamic traditions and their Muslim interpretations with sensitivity and respect, not often found among Christian writings on Islam.'[1] Ben- nett became a US citizen during 2012. 1 Biography 1.1 Background Bennett was born in Tettenhall then an Urban District in Staffordshire, England. In 1966, he migrated to Aus- tralia with his parents, Howard Bennett (1922–1997) and Joan Bennett (1922–2007) and his two siblings. He com- pleted his final year of primary education in Australia then attended Maclean High School, Maclean, New South Wales. He was a member of the School Debating Team taking part in inter-school competitions, a member of the Radio Club, Student Leader of the Inter-School Christian Fellowship chapter and represented his class for a year on the Student Representative Council. He won prizes for acting and for History. After gaining his School Cer- tificate, he worked in Sydney as an officer in the state civil service 1972–1973.[2] Originally an Anglican, Ben- nett was baptised into membership of the Lower Clarence Baptist Church in 1969. He was active in the Christian Endeavor movement and as a youth camp leader. Clinton Bennett Clinton Bennett (born 7 October 1955) is a British 1.2 Education American scholar of religions and participant in interfaith dialogue specialising in the study of Islam and Muslim- non-Muslim encounter. An ordained Baptist minister, he was a missionary in Bangladesh before serving as the sec- ond director of interfaith relations at the British Council of Churches in succession to Kenneth Cracknell.
    [Show full text]
  • Publications of the Committee for Relations with People of Other Faiths and the Churches' Commission for Inter Faith Relations 1978-2004 Compiled by Elizabeth Harris
    Publications of the Committee for Relations with People of Other Faiths and the Churches' Commission for Inter Faith Relations 1978-2004 compiled by Elizabeth Harris (I have not been able to find copies of all the publications below and so some lack ISBN numbers. Some publications are not dated. I have guessed the date of publication in these cases from internal evidence. If I have missed out publications, the fault is entirely mine)) • 1976, David Brown, A New Threshold: Guidelines for the Churches in their Relations with Muslim Communities, British Council of Churches (BCC) and the Conference of British Missionary Societies. • 1980, Kenneth Cracknell, Why Dialogue?: a first British comment on the W.C.C. Guidelines, BCC, ISBN 0 85169 075 0 • 1980, The Use of Church Property in a Plural Society, Community and Race Relations Unit (CRRU)/BCC • 1981, Relations with People of Other Faiths: Guidelines for Dialogue in Britain, BCC, revised in 1983. ISBN 0 85169 088 2. • 1982, Mixed Faith Marriages: A Case for Care • 1983, Can We Pray Together: Guidelines for Worship in a Multi-Faith Society, CRPOF/BCC, ISBN: 0 85169 098 X • 1984, Kenneth Cracknell (transl), Christians and Muslims Talking Together, by a working party of the Churches' Committee on Migrant Workers in Europe, BCC, ISBN 0 85169 110 2 • 1984, Christopher lamb and Kenneth Cracknell, Theology on Full Alert, BCC (revised in 1986) • 1986, Educational Principles in Religious Education • 1986, Roger Hooker, What is Idolatry? CRPOF/BCC (the first in a series of occasional papers papers published
    [Show full text]
  • 117 American Methodism
    Methodist History, 52:2 (January 2014) AMERICAN METHODISM: A COMPACT HISTORY, DENOMINATIONAL HISTORY, AND AN AUTHOR’S RESPONSE RUSSELL E. RICHEY (ON BEHALF OF KENNETH E. ROWE AND JEAN MILLER SCHMIDT) I want to address two substantive critiques that are offered in Benjamin Hartley’s review of our American Methodism: A Compact History, as well as the other two volumes in this project (Methodist History 51.4 [July 2013]: 292-294). These revolve around the title that Abingdon gave the book, both reflective of the approach we have taken in our three volumes, and both quite legitimate issues. My coauthors endorse this reply to the review. Hartley offers the critiques that we chose to focus on North American rather than world-wide Methodism (requiring, of course, attention to Meth- odism’s missionary spread) and that we treat African American Methodist and holiness churches only through their founding and not in their subse- quent development. He is certainly correct that our volume concerns “North American/U.S. United Methodism and its Predecessor Denominations.” Could we have fit the history of global Methodism and the array of Meth- odist-Wesleyan bodies into 250 pages? Perhaps. It took Emory S. Bucke’s collaborators three 700 page volumes (The History of American Methodism) a half century ago and they gave slight treatment to the smaller Methodist churches. And the Methodist/United Methodist missionary history series runs to eleven volumes, each lengthy. The synthetic Wesleyan/Methodist project that Dr. Hartley calls for is certainly a worthy one and Susan White and Kenneth Cracknell have shown the way with their quite manageable An Introduction to World Methodism.
    [Show full text]
  • ECM Collections of the Revd. Kenneth Cracknell for the World Mission
    ECM Collections of the Revd. Kenneth Cracknell for the World Mission Conference, Edinbugh 1910 and on 19th-century missionaries 259 items, 1969-1992 Apparently presented c.1994-1997, probably at the time of Mr. Cracknell’s generous ‘permanent loan’ of 600 volumes of his collection of missionary books for the Henry Martyn Library (Acc. 19/20) Catalogued by Graham Kings and Sue Sutton 2001-03; introduction added and new top level description by Philip Saunders April 2017 Kenneth Cracknell (b.1935) is a Methodist minister who began his career in Nigeria through the Methodist Church Overseas Division, then served as Director of Interfaith Relations in the British Council of Churches 1978-87. From 1987 or 1988 to 1996 or 1997 he held the Michael Gutteridge Chair in Theology and the position of Senior Tutor at Wesley House, Cambridge. In this period he was evidently frequently in touch with Revd Graham Kings, Henry Martyn Lecturer in Missiology (first Director of the Henry Martyn Centre) and appears to have made the original suggestion, in 1992, supported by Mr Kings (GRK 8/53p.3), to bring together on one site the HM Library books with those from his own ‘large personal collection’ and mission books from the four Federation colleges. The last element of happened only in part, but the Trust’s books were moved to a Westminster College in Autumn 1995 and were then or shortly after joined by Cracknell’s books and in 1997 250 volumes from Ridley Hall, where Kings had had his office. The present papers probably arrived simultaneously with the printed books (catalogued by Philippa Mahood in 1995); ECM 1 was definitely there by August 1994 (GRK 8/84, p.3).
    [Show full text]
  • 6 X 10.Long New.P65
    Cambridge University Press 978-0-521-81849-0 - An Introduction to World Methodism Kenneth Cracknell and Susan J. White Index More information General index Act of Uniformity 5, 6 biblical criticism 115, 205 affections, religious 148–51 bishops, see episcopacy Africa University 78 Bohemian Brethren 96 African Methodist Episcopal Church 54–5, 63, Bolivia 86, 88, 242 64, 73, 76, 137, 189, 193, 202, 229 Book of Common Prayer 5, 154, 173, 174–6, 177, African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church 55, 178, 182, 188, 191, 207 63, 64, 73, 189, 202, 229, 234 Boston personalism 116 Albania 89 Boston University School of Theology 218 alcohol, Methodist attitude toward, see Botswana 76 temperance Brazil 3, 85–6, 87–8 Aldersgate 9, 14–15, 31, 97, 99, 106, 108, 110, 148, British Council of Churches 239 165 British Evangelical Alliance 39 All Africa Council of Churches 77 Bulgaria 66, 89, 132 AME Review 64 burial of the dead 174, 175, 176, 190, 207 American Anti-Slavery Society 56, 57 Burma, see Myanmar American Revolution, see Revolutionary War Angola 74 calendar, see church year Antigua 69–70 Called to Love and Praise 138–9 Apostolic Faith movement 167 Calvinism ix, 21, 24, 100, 101, 108, 114, 115, 165, Argentina 86, 210, 240–1, 257 256 Arminian Magazine 24, 30, 100, 101, Cambodia 66 154 Cambridge Platonists 98 Arminianism, see Evangelical Arminianism camp meetings 37, 48, 49–51, 52, 59, 60, 61, 121, Articles of Religion 63, 92, 176, 247 146, 148, 165, 192, 197–8, 200, 231–2 Asia Methodist Council 83 Canada viii, 52, 68, 71–2, 82, 90, 256 Australia viii,
    [Show full text]
  • Martin CONWAY: One Christian's View of Interreligious Dialogue
    MOZAIK 2004/2 Talking through the Word MOZAIK 2004/2 Martin CONWAY Moreover, as mentioned above, we will not expect only and THE MEDIUM OF AUTHENTIC WITNESS always to be discussing “religious things”; we will want to In dialogue, there is no question of expecting one anoth- talk about whatever is mattering to each of us, as believers er to abandon one’s own convictions or upbringing or One Christian’s View of Interreligious Dialogue yet also as ordinary people, at that particular time. sticking-points, etc. The whole point is to become aware This means in turn that there is an important distinction of each other and what each brings by way of such things between the kind of “dialogue,” which a Muslim mother into the exchange. and her Christian neighbour are likely to have over the This too is very much a matter of mutual listening and of garden fence and that which bigger groups of people may mutual enrichment. We meet, not to manipulate each My purpose in this article is to lay out the large field of article I am deliberately trying to maintain a view from wish to have when, for instance, a Muslim imam and a other, but as fellow-pilgrims into the fullness of truth and interreligious dialogue as a whole and as I have come to inside the tradition to which I belong. Christian minister each ask ten of their members to share purposes each has become aware of in her or his own faith. understand it, in hopes that one can think the matter Third, each of the major faiths (I am not trying to include in a “dialogue evening.” So the moment will almost certainly come, if never at a through freshly and carefully.
    [Show full text]
  • The Internationalization of the Protestant Missionary Movement Between the World Wars Dana L
    The First Globalization: The Internationalization of the Protestant Missionary Movement Between the World Wars Dana L. Robert he global vision intrinsic to Christianity-one world, internationalism withthe kingdom of God. Particularlyin North Tone kingdom of God under Jesus Christ-has been the American mainline Protestant churches it became difficult to motive and purpose behind much missionary fervor. Driven by distinguish internationalism from the mission impulse itself. this idealistic vision, the mission of the church nevertheless has Although internationalism was central to mainline Protes­ beenconductedwithinhumanhistory. Modemmissionsemerged tant missions in the 1920s and 1930s, scholars have not used it as in the context of the Enlightenment, the industrial revolution, an interpretive framework for the missionary issues of the era. and the subsequent expansion of capitalism and modernization. Many have preferred to interpret the interwar period in light of With its internal logic of universalism, or catholicity,' Christian the Kraemer/Hocking debate or in relation to the tension be­ mission of necessity finds itself in dialogue with the secular tween evangelistic and social gospel approaches to missions. globalizing tendency of the historical moment-whether Euro­ This essay explores the relationship between internationalism pean expansionism, Western capitalism, or the World Wide and indigenization in the mission movementbetween the world Web. 2 wars, with primary reference to a North American conversation. The Anglo-American Protestant missionary movement of I hope to demonstrate that internationalism and indigenization the 1920s and 1930s functioned within the globalizing discourse were two sides of the same coin. of "internationalism"-amoral vision of oneworld thatemerged The globalizing vision of one world stood in tensionwith the after the horrors of World War I and stemmed from the idealism cultural particularities that emerged in relationship to the global ofWoodrowWilson'sFourteenPoints.Internationalismlaunched context itself.
    [Show full text]
  • Alan Coates Bouquet (1884–1976): Twentieth-Century Foundations for an Anglican Theology of Religion
    ATR/96.1 Alan Coates Bouquet (1884–1976): Twentieth-Century Foundations for an Anglican Theology of Religion Kenneth Cracknell* In 1984 the General Synod of the Church of England cordially received the report Towards a Theology for Inter-Faith Dialogue, which affirmed the presence of God with people of other faiths. Many varied influences had led to this positive stance, and this paper notes them. But it seeks primarily to highlight the part played by a Cambridge parish priest, Alan Coates Bouquet (1884– 1976), in shaping Anglican attitudes over many decades. His fre- quently reprinted Pelican books, Comparative Religion (1941) and Sacred Books of the World (1954), were the most accessible sources of information about the world religious traditions in that period. Less widely known is a series of books and pamphlets on what is now known as the theology of religion. In these writings Bouquet set out his own position (“measured tolerance and faith- ful exclusiveness”) and mediated the Logos theologies of F. D. Maurice and B. F. Westcott. The second half of the twentieth century may be seen as a time when Western Christians truly began to come to terms with religious pluralism. On the international level, the World Council of Churches (founded only in 1948 and very much the creature of the theological streams converging in the earlier part of the twentieth century) set up its Sub-Unit on Dialogue with People of Living Faiths and Ideologies in 1971, and moved with some speed to promulgate its Guidelines on * Kenneth Cracknell is a Methodist minister and specialist in interfaith dialogue and theology.
    [Show full text]
  • A Conversation with Dana Robert on Mission, Ecumenism, and Global
    Beyond Unity and Diversity: A Conversation with Dana Robert on Mission, Ecumenism, and Global Christianities By Dana Robert and Aaron Hollander aron Hollander, for Ecumenical Trends: Professor At the same time, many people have been loath to give Robert, thank you so much for speaking with me. up the singular of “World Christianity.” Andrew Walls and AIt was a pleasure to see you again at the 2019 Lamin Sanneh were some of the fathers of the field’s rebirth Global Christianities conference, and to hear your fascinat- who wanted to continue using the singular term, because ing lecture on the historical entanglement between Global of the operating assumption that Christianity does in fact Christianities and Mission Studies. I’d like to begin with a remain one religion with a two thousand year tradition. question on this big picture level. “Global Christianities” There are many ways to frame it, and different phenomena is a discourse and intellectual framework that is generating within it, but it is still one religion, inclusive of its diversity. a great deal of excitement across the academy of religion, Unity-in-diversity or diverse-unity, we might say. If we start but it’s a comparatively new framework, relative to “World using the plural (Christianities), Sanneh and Walls worried, Christianity,” and each of these terms has its own distinc- tive connotations. Would you speak a little to the difference it would cause newer forms of Christianity to be seen as between these two frameworks: “World” vs. “Global,” secondary, sectarian manifestations of the “great tradition”; “Christianity” vs. “Christianities.” What’s at stake here? it would imply that some “Christianities” should be treated as better as or more authentic than others.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Protestant Evangelism Or Catholic Evangelization?
    Protestant Evangelism Or Catholic Evangelization?: A Study in Methodist Approaches, Kenneth Cracknell, Methodist Sacramental Fellowship, 1992, 0951259989, 9780951259986, . DOWNLOAD HERE , , , , . Terms of Sale: New customers pay in advance. Accept Visa, Mastercard, Sterling or U.S. Dollar cheques. All books are Very good used copies with defects as noted. Postage is charged extra at cost.For larger orders (normally 5 books or more)we have contracts with the British Post Office giving us rates significantly lower than the public tarrif.Items may be returned if not as decribed but please contact us first. Store Description: Established in 1971 we sell all kinds of theological books by mail order. In addition to our on-line listings, we issue a comprehensive range of printed catalogues, which we are happy to send on request. We are always interested in purchasing large collections of theological books. Portions of this page may be (c) 2006 Muze Inc. Some database content may also be provided by Baker & Taylor Inc. Copyright 1995-2006 Muze Inc. For personal non-commercial use only. All rights reserved. Content for books is owned by Baker & Taylor, Inc. or its licensors and is subject to copyright and all other protections provided by applicable law. fifth grade novel studies, folk song of bihar, ford hydraulic brake system, flitch plate beams, flexibility manufacturing system, financial peace university lesson 1 workbook, football position evaluation form, financial accounting 8th edition hoggett solution manual, figurative language basketball games, feedback comments examples, financial market homework, ford e super duty air conditioning diagram, food for today first canadian edition, fmc 4100 parts list, ford e 450 wiring diagram, Book Description: Churches Together in Britain and Ireland (CTBI).
    [Show full text]
  • FREEDOM and WITN~SS in a Mul TI-REUGIOUS SOCIETY a BAPTIST PERSPECTIVE PART I
    FREEDOM AND WITN~SS IN A MUlTI-REUGIOUS SOCIETY A BAPTIST PERSPECTIVE PART I THE NEED FOR A BAPTIST CONTRIBUTION: Writing in 1967 from his vantage-point as Secretary of the Department of Studies in Mission and Evangelism of the World Council of Churches, the Baptist missiologist, Victor Hayward, drew attention to the increasingly global interpenetration of religions and cultures and noted the changes in the Christian theology and practice of inter­ religious dialogue which had occured in parallel with this global process. Hayward went on to argue, however, that to achieve a fully developed ecumenical theology and practice, it would be necessary for contributions to be made from within the confessional traditions of Christianity: Few confessions have brought their theological thinking up to date in this regard. Neither this new and more realistic attitude, nor the early fruit of actual encounter at spiritual and more generally intellectual levels, has modified traditional theologies. There is, therefore, great need that theologians working within their confessional traditions should take up afresh questions relating to the place of other religious systems and the place of other religious communities in the economy of God's purposes for mankind. Only as this is done shall we be able to develop an 'ecumenical theology' in this field. 1 The 1970s and 1980s saw a number of British Christian theologians responding to the challenge of interpreting the diverse religious world which Commonwealth immigration had brought to our shores,2 but comparatively few took up Victor Hayward's challenge to work creatively on these issues from within their various confessional traditions.
    [Show full text]