AGENDA HERITAGE ADVISORY COMMITTEE February 5, 2020 at 6:30 P.M
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AGENDA HERITAGE ADVISORY COMMITTEE February 5, 2020 at 6:30 p.m. River Plate Room, Town Hall Meeting No.1 Online Agenda: Anything in blue denotes an attachment/link. By clicking the links on the agenda page, you can jump directly to that section of the agenda. To manoeuver back to the agenda page use the Ctrl + Home keys simultaneously OR use the “Bookmark” icon on the navigation panel to the left of your screen. Alternative formats available upon request by contacting: [email protected] or 905-619-2529 ext. 3347 1. Call to Order 2. Disclosure of Conflict of Interest 3. Approval of Minutes 3.1 November 6, 2019 .......................................................................................................... Page 3 4. Presentation/Discussion Items 4.1 Workmen’s Circle Panel Installation [M. Sawchuck] (5 minutes) 4.2 DD Palmer Plaque Casting [M. Sawchuck] (5 minutes) 4.3 Westglen Property (1733 Westney Rd N) Updates [M. Sawchuck] (5 minutes) 4.4 456 Kingston Road West Development Concept [M. Sawchuck] (10 minutes) 4.5 Nicholas Austin House (775 Kingston Rd E) CHER [M. Sawchuck] (20 minutes) ........ Page 6 4.6 Update on Ajax Historical Minute Video Project [P. Pryjma] (10 minutes) 5. Correspondence 6. Update from Council 7. Standing Items 7.1 Work Plan ....................................................................................................................... Page 46 7.1.1 2020 Display Case Change 7.1.2 Community Event Participation 7.2 Heritage Permit Updates [M. Sawchuck] 7.2.1 William Hartrick House (22 Linton Ave) Door Replacement (5 minutes) 7.2.2 William St. George’s Anglican Church (77 Randall Dr) Roof Replacement (20 minutes) 7.3 Ajax Archives Update [B.Kriz] 7.3.1 Lambard Crescent Rededication Ceremony 7.3.2 Ajax Archives – Co-op Placement Support 7.3.3 80th anniversary of the Battle of the River Plate Documents Authored by Johnathan Harwood: 7.3.3.1 South America 2019 – Historical Narrative ...................................... Page 50 7.3.3.2 History of the Royal Navy in South America ..................................... Page 58 7.3.3.3 Earthquake at Concepcion – January 1939 ...................................... Page 65 7.3.3.4 HMS Ajax, Exeter, Achilles and Cumberland ................................... Page 75 7.3.4 HMS Ajax & River Plate Veterans’ Association Newsletter, Dec. 2019 ......... Page 86 8. Other Business 9. Adjournment Next Meeting Date: Wednesday, March 4, 2020 at 6:30 p.m., River Plate Room, Town Hall DRAFT MINUTES Heritage Advisory Committee November 6, 2019 River Plate Room, Town Hall Alternative formats available upon request by contacting: Meeting No. 7 [email protected] or 905-619-2529 ext. 3347 Committee Members: Councillor Lisa Bower Bruce Balsdon Neil Burnett Beverley Briggs Camille Graham Paul Hébert Anderson Mendonca Pam Pryjma Stephen White Wayne Hingston Staff: Brenda Kriz, records and FOI Coordinator Michael Sawchuck, Senior Planner Sarah Moore, Committee & Accessibility Coordinator Regrets: Jeff Wood 1. Call to Order Chair Balsdon called the Meeting to order at 6:30 p.m. 2. Disclosure of Conflict of Interest None. 3. Approval of Minutes Moved By: L. Bower Seconded By: B. Briggs That the October 2, 2019 Meeting Minutes of the Heritage Advisory Committee be approved. CARRIED 4. Presentation/Discussion 4.1 November 18, 2019 Report/Presentation to Council M. Sawchuck and B. Kriz led the Committee through a detailed review and discussion of the draft presentation slides prepared by P. Pryjma for the Committee’s report to Council on November 18, 2019. Members contributed suggested edits and content to finalize the draft, focusing the presentation on core elements of the committee’s mandate. Actions supporting 3 Heritage Advisory Committee November 6, 2019 Page 2 the mandate taken over the past seven months of the Committee’s existence were highlighted. Chair Balsdon will present on behalf of the Committee, with other Members planning to attend in support. S. Moore noted that she would inform the Committee where on the agenda the presentation will be scheduled once the agenda is posted. 4.2 775 Kingston Road East – Potential for Part IV Designation M. Sawchuck provided the Committee with an update on the status of 775 Kingston Road East, following an enquiry from a resident. He noted that the property has been evaluated by the Committee and meets the criteria for designation. M. Sawchuck shared photos of the property noting its significant features and its declining condition. Members asked questions relative to ownership and whether the property is occupied. M. Sawchuck noted he will be looking into the ownership of the property further, as it has recently changed. He reviewed the summary sheet from when the Committee reviewed the property for the Heritage Register. He noted there has been no development application, nor demolition permit for the property, and the land cannot be severed as it is in the provincial Greenbelt. M. Sawchuck reviewed opportunities for the Committee including the opportunity to have a qualified consultant complete a cultural heritage evaluation report (CHER). He also outlined opportunities for the Town to pursue property standards by-law violations if the building is not brought into an improved state of repair. Members discussed whether or not to undertake a CHER given the current condition of the property. Staff responded to questions from Members relative to the cost of a CHER, the requirement to contact the property owner to conduct a CHER, the potential for heritage designation, and the process for By-law Services to serve notice regarding property standards infractions. Moved by: P. Pryjma Seconded by: P. Hébert That the Town retain a qualified heritage consultant to complete a cultural heritage evaluation report for 755 Kingston Road East. CARRIED 5. Correspondence None. 6. Update from Council In the interest of time, Councillor Bower deferred her report. 7. Standing Items 4 Heritage Advisory Committee November 6, 2019 Page 3 7.1 Work Plan Review & Brainstorming This item was discussed in detail during Item 4.1. November 18, 2019 Report/Presentation to Council. 7.2 Heritage Permit Updates In the interest of time, discussion of this item was deferred. 7.3 Ajax Archives Update B. Kriz shared information on a recent donation to the Ajax Archives of a binder of materials and photos from Pickering Public School. B. Briggs exited the meeting (8:23p.m.) 8. New/Other Business 8.1 Sale of 57 Cameron Street M. Sawchuck informed the Committee that 57 Cameron Street, a property within the Pickering Village HCD, is currently for sale. 8.2 New Use for 244 Kingston Road East M. Sawchuck noted that there is a new tenant for 244 Kingston Road East (McKay House), which will change the use to a fine dining establishment. Interior and exterior changes to the property may be forthcoming. 8.3 Workmen’s Circle Commemorative Plaques M. Sawchuck informed the Committee that the commemorative plaques will be installed early December 2019 at the Workmen’s Circle site. 8.4 Westglen Update M. Sawchuck shared a photo of the construction and restoration of Westglen. He noted that the addition has been constructed, and that the siding will be reclad and the roof replaced with enviro-shakes (replica cedar shakes). Now that the surrounding houses in the subdivision have been built, the focus will be on the restoration of the heritage property. 9. Adjournment Moved By: C. Graham Seconded By: L. Bower That the November 6, 2019 Meeting of the Heritage Advisory Committee be adjourned. (8:25p.m.) CARRIED 5 Nicholas Austin House Cultural Heritage Evaluation Report 775 Kingston Road East Ajax, Ontario January 21, 2020 6 PREPARED FOR: Michael Sawchuck Senior Planner | Planning & Development Services Town of Ajax 65 Harwood Avenue South Ajax, ON L1S 2H9 E: [email protected] T: 905-619-2529 x. 3200 PREPARED BY: Branch Architecture 2335 County Road 10 Picton, ON K0K 2T0 T: (613) 827-5806 ISSUED: 2020.01.20 DRAFT 2020.01.21 Cover Image: 775 Kingston Road East, 2019. (Branch Architecture, BA) 7 CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION 1 1.1 Project Framework & Background 1.2 Site Location and General Description 2 775 KINGSTON ROAD EAST 3 2.1 Early Colonial Settlement 2.2 Property Boundary 2.3 Property Ownership: Lot 1, Con. 1, Original Township of Pickering 2.4 Property Ownership: Lot 2, Con. 1, Original Township of Pickering 2.5 Building Descriptions 2.6 Cultural Heritage Evaluation 3 FINDINGS & RECOMMENDATIONS 21 APPENDICES Appendix 1: Bibliography Appendix 2: Land Abstract, Lot 1, Concession 1, Township of Pickering Appendix 3: Land Abstract, Lot 2, Concession 1, Township of Pickering Appendix 4: Property Photos 775 KINGSTON ROAD EAST, AJAX - CHER i 8 775 Kingston Rd E - Property Context PROJECT NORTH Legend Ajax Border Town Roads Rivers Ownership (PIN) Parcel Assessment Parcels Heritage Properties Designated Adjacent to Designated Non-Designated Schedule G Area Policies Section 2.2.4.2 f) vi) Section 3.3.4 h) Section 3.3.6 Section 3.5.4 Section 3.5.6 a) Section 6.1 Section 6.11 Section 6.12 775 Kingston Rd E - Building Context Section 6.13 Section 6.14 Section 6.15 Section 6.16 Section 6.17 1. Location of subject property indicated in red. (Town of Ajax) Section 6.18 Section 6.19 Section 6.2 Legend 1: 8,000 Section 6.20 Notes A order Section 6.21 T R 406.4 0 203.20 406.4 Metres Section 6.22 This map is a user generated static output from an Internet mapping site and is for HouseAddress reference only. Data layers that appear on this map may or may not be accurate, Section 6.3 NAD_1983_UTM_Zone_17N current,R or otherwise reliable. Section 6.4 © Town of Ajax THIS MAP IS NOT TO BE USED FOR NAVIGATION O IN arcel Assessment arcels H roperties Ded Adjacent Ded N-Ded S G A olicies Stable Sect/ 2.4.