DOCSLIB.ORG

Housing Policy and Services Kaupapa Inquiry (Wai 2750) Pre-Casebook

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Housing Policy and Services Kaupapa Inquiry (Wai 2750) Pre-Casebook Wai 2750, #6.2.2 Housing Policy and Services Kaupapa Inquiry (Wai 2750) Pre-Casebook Research Discussion Paper Keir Wotherspoon and Suzanne Woodley July 2020 Waitangi Tribunal Unit Authorship Keir Wotherspoon is responsible for the design and authorship of this discussion paper apart from Chapter 3: Housing on Māori Land, which was authored by Suzanne Woodley. Both authors are responsible for the recommendations made in the final chapters. This discussion paper has been prepared by the authors for the Chief Historian Cathy Marr at the direction of Judge Coxhead. It has been reviewed by the Chief Historian. Dr Keir Wotherspoon is a research historian with a long-standing association with the Ministry of Justice. He began his career as an intern in the former Department for Courts in the 1990s, working on the pilot programme for restorative justice in the courts system. Keir graduated with First Class Honours in History from Victoria University of Wellington. In the 2000s, he worked on several district inquiries as a contractor in the report writing and research sections of the Waitangi Tribunal Unit. Between 2008 and 2019, he worked internationally at universities in Australia and the United Kingdom, most recently lecturing and supervising at Master’s level at the Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies at the University of Warwick. He has a PhD in History from the University of Melbourne. He currently holds the position of Senior Researcher Analyst/Kaitātari Rangahau Matua in the Research Services Team of the Waitangi Tribunal Unit. Suzanne Woodley is a Principal Researcher Analyst/Kaitātari Rangahau Aporei in the Research Services Team of the Waitangi Tribunal Unit and has held this position since 2017. She holds a Bachelor of Arts from Canterbury University and a Bachelor of Arts with Honours in History from Victoria University of Wellington. In the 1990s, Suzanne worked for the Waitangi Tribunal Unit where she wrote a number of research reports including the first general report on Native Townships for the Tribunal’s Rangahaua Whanui National Themes series. Between 1997 and 2004 she worked at The National Archives in London as project manager and senior archivist. In 2005, Suzanne returned to treaty research, most recently authoring research reports for the Taihape Rangitikei ki Rangipo and Porirua ki Manawatū inquiries. Acknowledgements Keir and Suzanne would like to offer their grateful thanks to Researcher Analysts/ Kaitātari Rangahau Brittany Whiley, Max Nichol and David Lewis for their assistance on the pre-casebook research discussion paper. Thanks also to Senior Facilitator/Kaituitui Uiuinga Matua Hinetaapora Moko-Mead for her assistance and support. 2 Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................................. 6 Commencing the Housing Policy and Services Kaupapa Inquiry (Wai 2750) .............................. 6 Further Evidential Information for the Inquiry................................................................................. 9 Crown Statistics Programme .............................................................................................................. 10 Methodology for the Pre-Casebook Research Discussion Paper ................................................. 12 Chapter 1: Māori Home Ownership ...................................................................................................... 16 1.1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 16 1.2 Range of Claims Relating to Māori Home Ownership ............................................................ 16 1.3 Key Sources .................................................................................................................................... 22 1.4 Historical Context .......................................................................................................................... 24 1.5 Recent Legislative Changes and Policy Developments from 2018 ........................................ 29 1.6 Recent Housing Disparities for Māori ........................................................................................ 32 1.7 Access to Home Ownership ........................................................................................................ 34 1.8 Security of Tenure and Affordability .......................................................................................... 38 1.9 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................................... 45 Appendix: Measures of Affordability ................................................................................................ 47 Chapter 2: Māori Renting and Special Housing Needs ....................................................................... 50 2.1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 50 2.2 Range of Claims Relating to Māori Renting and Special Housing Needs ............................. 50 2.3 Key Sources .................................................................................................................................... 59 2.4 Historical Context .......................................................................................................................... 60 3 1840s – 1935 ..................................................................................................................................... 61 1935 – 1945 ....................................................................................................................................... 63 1945 to 1960s .................................................................................................................................... 64 1970s -1992 ....................................................................................................................................... 68 1993 to 2017 ..................................................................................................................................... 71 2.5 The Rental and Special Housing Sector System Since 2017 .................................................... 74 2.6 Housing Disparities for Māori ..................................................................................................... 76 2.7 Access to Housing Services .......................................................................................................... 79 2.8 Security of Rental Tenure for Māori ........................................................................................... 88 2.9 Rental Affordability and Severe Housing Deprivation for Māori .......................................... 95 2.10 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 99 Access to Data and archives? ....................................................................................................... 100 Chapter 3: Housing on Māori Land ..................................................................................................... 102 3.1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 102 3.2 The Claims .................................................................................................................................... 103 3.3 Key Sources .................................................................................................................................. 104 3.4 Historical Context – A Brief Overview .................................................................................... 106 Late Nineteenth and Early Twentieth century .......................................................................... 106 Lending Schemes, 1985 to 2008 .................................................................................................. 109 Partitioning and Zoning ................................................................................................................ 110 3.5 The Current System – a Brief Overview .................................................................................. 111 3.6 Evidential Coverage ..................................................................................................................... 115 4 3.6.1 Finance and the ability to borrow ...................................................................................... 116 3.6.2 Local Government planning regulations including zoning ............................................ 133 3.6.3 Rates ....................................................................................................................................... 137 3.6.4 Infrastructure ........................................................................................................................ 140 3.6.5 Security of Tenure ................................................................................................................ 143 3.7 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 149 Chapter 4: Proposals and Recommendations ....................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Volume 30 Issue 8
    OCTOBER 2017 VOLUME 30 – ISSUE 8 ISSN 1032-6170 Responding to Homelessness in Aotearoa New Zealand Contents Council to Homeless Persons Editorial — Ten Years On | 3 Auckland Council’s Role | 32 Jenny Smith Chief Executive Officer Jenny Smith, Chief Executive Officer, in Addressing Homelessness Kate Colvin Manager — Policy and Council to Homeless Persons The Community Empowerment Unit and Communications Glossary | 4 Community and Social Policy Teams, Ian Gough Manager — This glossary has been prepared using the online Auckland Council Consumer Programs version of Te Aka Māori–English, English–Māori | 34 Dictionary and Index. This glossary is not definitive, Housing First Auckland City Centre Lynette Deakes Office Manager and refers to this publication only. Programme: Responsiveness to Māori Noel Murray Parity Editor | Sophia Beaton (Kāi Tahu, Kāti Mamoe) Kia hiwa rā, Kia rite 5 and Sarah Greenaway Lanie Harris Communications Jade Kake, Poutohu Mātua, Coordinator Te Matapihi, National Māori Housing Advocate Housing First: | 37 Belinda Lack Digital Communications Introduction | 6 People Working with People Officer Brook Turner, Head of Community Services Angela Kyriakopoulos HAS Coordinator Chapter 1: Development, VisionWest Community Trust Cassandra Bawden Peer Education and Understanding Homelessness The Role of Local Government | 39 Support Program Team in Aotearoa New Zealand in a Homeless Response Leader The People’s Project: | Trish Westmore Capacity Building Understanding Homelessness 8 A Collaborative Community Response in Rural Aotearoa
    [Show full text]
  • Economics and Financing of Housing for Māori Literature Review
    NTRC: CONTEMPORARY RESEARCH DIVISION – CRD0000 SERIES: INDIGENOUS SOCIAL, ECONOMIC & POLITICAL DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS AND FINANCING OF HOUSING FOR MĀORI LITERATURE REVIEW DIANE MENZIES, JAY WHITEHEAD, GRACE WALKER, JOHN REID & ANGUS MACFARLANE ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED: Report for Building Better Homes, Towns and Cities NSC. ! ! CONTENTS 1! Overview of literature!..................................................................................................................!4! 2! Introduction!...................................................................................................................................!6! 2.1! Background!.............................................................................................................................!6! 2.2! Project brief!.........................................................................................................................!6! 2.3! Coverage!.............................................................................................................................!7! 2.4! Methodology!.......................................................................................................................!7! 3! Literature Review!.........................................................................................................................!8! 3.1! Historical Context!....................................................................................................................!8! 3.2! Demographic change and Māori economic agency!.....................................................!11!
    [Show full text]
  • ER4 Meeting the Housing Needs of Multi-Generational Households
    External Research Report Report ER4 Issue Date: 31/07/2015 ISSN: 2423-0839 Meeting the housing needs of multi-generational households Penny Lysnar and Ann Dupuis Project LR0461 The University of Auckland and Massey University funded by the Building Research Levy 1222 Moonshine Rd, RD1, Porirua 5381 Private Bag 50 908 Porirua 5240 New Zealand branz.nz © BRANZ 2015 Meeting the housing needs of multi-generational households A research report prepared for BRANZ and funded from the Building Research Levy Penny Lysnar Transforming Cities, University of Auckland Ann Dupuis School of People, Environment and Planning, and Regional Director, College of Humanities and Social Sciences, Massey University, Auckland Disclaimer Access to the data used in this study was provided by Statistics New Zealand under conditions designed to give effect to the security and confidentiality provisions of the Statistics Act 1975. The results presented in this study are the work of the authors, not Statistics New Zealand. Technical information All figures in tables presented in this report are randomly rounded to base three to conform to Statistics New Zealand’s confidentiality requirements. Figures, percentages and derived data/ statistics are produced from rounded data. © This publication is copyright. Apart from any fair dealings for the purpose of private study, research, criticism or review as permitted under the Copyright Act, and no part may be reproduced without prior permission of the authors. July, 2015 ISBN 978-0-473-33022-4 (pdf) ii Table of Contents Acknowledgements 5 Executive Summary 9 1. Introduction 12 2. Objectives 14 3. Research Methodology 15 4. Literature Review 17 4.1 Defining multi-generational households 18 4.2 The rise in multi-generational household living 19 4.3 The New Zealand literature 22 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Monitoring Human Rights in the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery a Report by the Human Rights Commission
    Monitoring Human Rights in the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery A report by the Human Rights Commission Whakaora Rü Whenua Waitaha he Aroturuki Tika Tangata He pürongo nä te Kähui Tika Tangata December 2013 Human Rights Commission InfoLine 0800 496 877 (toll free) Fax 09 377 3593 (attn: InfoLine) Email [email protected] www.hrc.co.nz Language Line and NZ Sign Language interpreter available If you have a hearing or speech impairment, you can contact the Commission using the New Zealand Relay Service. NZ Relay is a telecommunications service and all calls are Brooklands Community Farewell Sunday September 9 confidential. www.nzrelay.co.nz On 9 September 2012, Brooklands community, which has been Tämaki Makaurau – Auckland zoned red, held a goodbye celebration for residents. It was a Level 3 Zurich House, 21 Queen Street bittersweet occasion for residents and featured performances PO Box 6751, Wellesley Street, by local school children and a memory walk through the Tämaki Makaurau/Auckland 1141 suburb that included the dairy, the play centre and the fire Waea/telephone 09 309 0874 station. Residents were invited to ‘individualise their memory Waea whakaahua/fax 09 377 3593 boats’ and to use these “as a symbol of your journey – from the Brooklands that was … to your new hopes and dreams.” Te Whanganui ä Tara – Wellington The walk ended at the lagoon where people released their Level 1 Vector Building, 44-52 The Terrace boats into the water. PO Box 12411, Thorndon, A senior fire fighter at Brooklands Volunteer Fire Brigade Te Whanganui ä Tara/Wellington 6144 is featured on the cover launching his boat at the lagoon.
    [Show full text]
  • Gordon Wilson Flats Heritage Assessment-Final
    314 the terrace, gordon wilson flats_heritage assessment-final archifact architecture & conservation limited www.archifact.co.nz 64 khyber pass road grafton auckland 1023 po box 8334 symonds street auckland 1150 new zealand p 09. 966 6940 [email protected] figure 1 gordon wilson flats, archifact architecture & conservation ltd., 2014) gordon wilson flats 314 the terrace wellington heritage assessment on behalf of wareham cameron + co may 2015 prepared for: victoria university of wellington c/o andrew croskery at wareham cameron + co po box 3531 wellington 6140 copyright © archifact-architecture and conservation ltd, 2015 all rights reserved. without limiting the rights under copyright above, no part of this report may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise), without the prior written permission of the copyright owner. auckland, may 2015 2015-05-06__2141007- heritage assessment-final 314 the terrace, wellington 2 contents 1.0 executive summary ..........................................................................................4 2.0 description of the place ...................................................................................5 2.1 ownership ...........................................................................................................5 2.2 address ..............................................................................................................5 2.3 legal description
    [Show full text]
  • The New Zealand Housing Strategy for the 21St Century
    HOUSINGNEW ZEALAND MORTGAGE HOUSING & HOUSING STRATEGY TRANSACTION FOR 21ST CENTURY IN CHINA The Remaking of Housing Policy: The New Zealand Housing Strategy for the 21st Century By David C. Thorns, Director of the Social Science Research Centre and Professor of Sociology at the University of Canterbury (New Zealand) Introduction of New Zealand’s welfare development to its Through these policies New Zealand was ‘second way’, which was constructed more firmly integrated into the global Analysing shifts in policy requires us to around a strong neo liberal agenda. The economy in a way that was thought would appreciate that they are embedded in the current post 1999 agenda, then can be improve its competitive edge and internal past as well as in the present. Parsons in a interpreted as New Zealand’s version of a efficiency. Improved productivity would recent examination of policy development ‘third way’ influenced by movements in then lead to faster rates of economic growth argues that “it is existing policies which set other social democratic societies and and improved overall financial performance. the agendas for new problems and provide particularly articulated by the Blair Thus, like a number of other developed the discourse within which problems will be Government in the United Kingdom and the western countries during this period, state constructed” (Parsons 1995:231). Clinton Administration in the USA (Dalziel assets were privatised, new forms of Understanding the development of New 2001, Giddens 2001). management for state enterprises were Zealand’s housing strategy for the 21st introduced creating state owned enterprises century requires us to understand both the In order to explore these changes first an (SOE’s), to be run as private companies and past transformations that occurred through identification of the significant return a dividend to the government.
    [Show full text]
  • Māori Renter's Views on Renting
    DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH DEPARTMENT OF MEDICINE Kimihia Ngā Whare Māori Ōranga Pai Towards Healthy Māori Rental Housing Māori Renter’s Views on Renting in the Wellington Region A report prepared for Renters United and the Department of Public Health University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand Group A1 August 2017 Abstract Introduction In the midst of New Zealand’s housing crisis there is an increased requirement to know how renters are affected. While there has been significant research into both renters’ and Māori experiences with housing in New Zealand, the specific views and experiences of Māori renters have not yet been sufficiently explored. Renters United and ActionStation are working together to investigate the experiences of renters in New Zealand. This study proposes to add to their findings by specifically investigating the housing quality and the challenges faced by Māori renters in the Greater Wellington region. Only once these views and challenges are identified and understood can interventions be proposed. Methods There were two components to this study, both targeting Māori renters in the Wellington region. The first consisted of qualitative interviews that collected data on renting experiences in the form of narratives or stories. Interviews were transcribed and analysed through thematic analysis. 12 interviews were conducted. The second component was a quantitative online survey that was conducted and analysed through Qualtrics and distributed through Facebook. We obtained a sample of 77 participants and collected self-reported data on housing quality and renting experience. Data was analysed through descriptive analysis. Results The narrative interviews demonstrated renters’ issues with finding a house which included competition with other renters, gentrification, power imbalances with the landlord, and discrimination.
    [Show full text]
  • Inadequate Housing in New Zealand and Its Impact on Children
    Thematic snapshot report to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child: Inadequate Housing in New Zealand and its impact on children. He Kainga Oranga/ Housing and Health Research Programme, University of Otago, Wellington and Human Rights Commission www.healthyhousing.org.nz www.hrc.co.nz August 2016 Whatungarongaro te tangata, Toitu te whenua People come and go The land remains INTRODUCTION 1. The prevalence of New Zealand children living in substandard housing conditions has developed into a major public health and children’s rights issue, with multiple effects on the health and wellbeing of children.i This supplementary thematic report identifies key areas of concern and suggests a number of recommendations intended to bring about substantive improvement for affected children. 2. Many children live in cold, damp homes. This contributes to a greater burden of disease and poorer outcomes, particularly amongst those who live in lower-income households, amongst one parent families of all ethnicities, and Māori and Pacific children.ii The 2016 Families and Whānau Status report produced by the Social Policy and Evaluation Unit (SUPERU) has found that improving well-being for children aged under 18 requires a policy focus on the economic security and housing of single parent families of all ethnicities (72% of the single parents being women) and of Māori, Pacific and Asian two parent familiesiii 3. The causes for the current situation are multi-faceted. Housing supply, rising property prices and rents in urban centres, an outdated regulatory framework governing housing quality and security of tenure for private tenants, and income poverty are all contributory factors.
    [Show full text]
  • “I'm Lucky to Have a House”
    “I’m lucky to have a house” A critique of current and past housing policy and practice, and the effects on a group of Invercargill residents and housing providers. Lorraine Johnston A thesis submitted for the degree of Master of Social Work University of Otago Dunedin, New Zealand March, 2019 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ___________________________________________ First, I would like to thank the participants who so generously gave up their time to tell their stories and offer their experiences of what housing is like for them in Invercargill. The residents in particular who shared their experiences, and often their struggles, were generous in letting me record this part of their lives. I appreciate also the insights offered by the housing providers, all of whom work in pressured, sometimes impossible situations trying to meet housing needs in a difficult time. Secondly, I would like to thank Dr Peter Walker for his guidance and support during the process of undertaking this study. Finally, thank you to Dr Shayne Walker for stepping in at the last minute, and to the other staff of Otago University Department of Sociology, Gender Studies and Social Work for the ongoing support. As a distance student, that support was particularly appreciated. 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS ___________________________________________ ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………….. 4 Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION...…………………………………………… 6 Chapter 2: METHODOLOGY…………………………………………… 12 Method……………………………………………………………… 15 Ethical considerations……………………………………………... 20 Strengths and limitations………………………………………..… 21 Implications and discussion…………………………………....... 23 Chapter 3: LITERATURE SEARCH…………………………………….. 24 A history of housing in New Zealand…………………………… 25 The current rise of inequality and housing distress……. 32 A global perspective……………………………………..… 39 Looking ahead……………………………………………… 40 Overview of housing theories………………………………...…… 42 A Human Rights approach………………………………… 42 Understanding the discourses…………………………….
    [Show full text]
  • Canterbury Wellbeing Index June 2014
    Canterbury Wellbeing Index June 2014 PUB145.1407.00 Published in July 2014 by Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority Christchurch, New Zealand Contact Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority Private Bag 4999, Christchurch 8140 [email protected] 0800 7464 2372 toll-free www.cera.govt.nz Citation Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority (2014). Canterbury Wellbeing Index June 2014. Christchurch: Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority. ISSN 2324-5158 (Print) 2324-5166 (Online) Crown copyright © This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 New Zealand licence. You are free to copy, distribute, and adapt the work, as long as you attribute the work to The Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority (CERA) and abide by the other licence terms. Please note you may not use any departmental or governmental emblem, logo, or coat of arms in any way that infringes any provision of the Flags, Emblems, and Names Protection Act 1981. Use the wording ‘Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority’ in your attribution, not the CERA logo. Section Summary Knowledge and skills Participation in education ............................................................................................. 1 Educational achievement: NCEA Level 2 pass rate ..................................................... 2 Economic wellbeing Employment outcomes ................................................................................................. 3 Household income .......................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Ten Perspectives on Housing 2 Foreword
    Progressive thinking perspectives ten on housing Published August 2017 Edited by Sarah Austen-Smith and Sarah Martin Design and layout by Dan Phillips Printed by Pivotal Thames This resource is also available online at www.psa.org.nz/housingbooklet New Zealand Public Service Association Te Pūkenga Here Tikanga Mahi PSA House, 11 Aurora Terrace, PO Box 3817, Wellington. Phone 0508 367 772 Email [email protected] www.psa.org.nz ISBN 978-0-908798-11-7 Authorised by Erin Polaczuk, Public Service Association Te Pūkenga Here Tikanga Mahi, 11 Aurora Terrace, Wellington, New Zealand. Contents 3 Foreword 7 Housing and health 29 Luck and love: Philippa Howden-Chapman housing and disability 11 Affordability – Where next? Dr Esther Woodbury John Tookey 32 No country for young 15 Innovating our way men or women out of New Zealand’s Dr Andrew Coleman housing disaster 36 The forgotten 50% Dr Jess Berentson-Shaw Robert Whitaker 24 Case study: Māori housing movements Jade Kake, edited by Victoria Crockford 18 The soft privatisation 39 Local government of state housing and the housing crisis Alan Johnson Shamubeel Eaqub 21 Beyond the quarter 43 The human right acre section: to adequate housing Bill McKay David Rutherford 42 Author bios Progressive thinking: ten perspectives on housing 2 Foreword At certain times over the course of New a proud history of advocating for high Zealand’s history, it has become clear quality public services that contribute that a fundamental shift in thinking to the health and wellbeing of our is needed. We believe that such a shift communities.
    [Show full text]
  • He Kainga Oranga/Housing and Health Research and New Zealand Centre for Sustainable Cities Submission to the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
    He Kainga Oranga/Housing and Health Research and New Zealand Centre for Sustainable Cities submission to the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights This submission was prepared by researchers from He Kainga Oranga/Housing and Health Research Programme, and the New Zealand Centre for Sustainable Cities, both in the Department of Public Health, University of Otago, Wellington. The research team comprises a large group of multi-disciplinary scientists and researchers led by Professor Philippa Howden- Chapman. The research of both groups has been seminal in demonstrating the links between housing, urban form, and health, and is both internationally and nationally acclaimed. The submission relates primarily to the right to an adequate standard of living in terms of housing, and touches on the rights to work, social security, family life, health, and education. It draws on a recently completed report for the new Minister for Housing and Urban Development, authored by Alan Johnson, Philippa Howden-Chapman, and Shamubeel Eaqub, “A Stocktake of New Zealand’s Housing.”1 We proceed in eight sections: homelessness; social housing; housing assistance; market renting; housing quality; home ownership; indigenous housing; and we finish with some comments about urban form and accessibility. 1. Homelessness: 1.1.Homelessness rose significantly between the 2006 and 2013 censuses, from one in 120, to one in 100 people. There were an estimated 4,197 people without habitable accommodation, and 37,010 in temporary accommodation, or sharing in severe overcrowding in 2013. 1.2.Disproportionately high numbers of Māori and Pacific people are homeless, compared to people of European descent.
    [Show full text]