Neuroendoscopic Choroid Plexus Coagulation for Pediatric Hydrocephalus
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
32 Review Neuroendoscopic Choroid Plexus Coagulation for Pediatric Hydrocephalus: Review of Historical Aspects and Rebirth Coagulação Neuroendoscópica do Plexo Coróide: Revisão de Aspectos Históricos e Renascimento Roberto Alexandre Dezena1 Carlos Umberto Pereira2 Leopoldo Prézia de Araújo1 Monique Passos Ribeiro3 Helisângela Alves de Oliveira3 ABSTRACT This study aims to review historical aspects and rebirth of the neuroendoscopic choroid plexus coagulation (NCPC) for pediatric hydrocephalus. The literature covering this topic in PubMed was reviewed. The first NCPC procedure goes back to early 1930s. After the development of other treatment methods and the understanding of CSF dynamics, the application of NCPC dramatically decreased by 1970s. In 2000s, there was a rebirth of NCPC in combination with endoscopic third ventriculostomy (ETV). NCPC remains one of the options for the treatment of pediatric hydrocephalus in selected cases. NCPC might provide a temporary reduction in CSF production to allow a further development of CSF absorption in infant. Adding NCPC to ETV for infants with communicating hydrocephalus may increase the shunt independent rate thus avoiding the consequence of late complication related to the shunt device. This is important for patients who are difficult to be followed up, due to geographical and/or socioeconomic difficulties. Besides, adding NCPC to ETV for obstructive hydrocephalus in infant may also increase the successful rate. Furthermore, NCPC may be an option for cases with high chance of shunt complication such as multiloculated hydrocephalus, extreme hydrocephalus and hydranencephaly. In comparison with the traditional treatment of CSF shunting, the role of NCPC needs to be further evaluated in particular concerning the neurocognitive development. Key words: Pediatric hydrocephalus; Neuroendoscopic choroid plexus coagulation; Endoscopic third ventriculostomy. RESUMO Este trabalho objetiva revisar aspectos históricos e o renascimento da coagulação neuroendoscópica do plexo coróide para tratamento da hidrocefalia pediátrica. A literatura sobre o tema foi revisada na base PubMed. A primeira coagulação neuroendoscópica do plexo coróide ocorreu na década de 1930. Após o desenvolvimento de outros métodos de tratamento e um melhor entendimento da dinâmica liquórica, a utilização da coagulação endoscópica diminui dramaticamente em meados da década de 1970. Nos anos 2000, ocorreu um renascimento da metodologia em combinação com a terceiroventriculostomia endoscópica, permitindo sua utilização em casos selecionados de hidrocefalia pediátrica. A lógica de sua utilização é permitir uma redução temporária na produção liquórica, de modo que haja maturação da capacidade absortiva do cérebro da criança, permitindo a independência das derivações liquóricas e suas complicações. Isso é um fator de extrema relevância nos países em desenvolvimento. Indicações atuais incluem hidrocefalia comunicante, hidrocefalia multiseptada e hidrocefalia máxima/ hidranencefalia. Ainda não existem dados prognósticos acerca do desenvolvimento cognitivo das crianças tratadas com coagulação neuroendoscópica do plexo coróide. Palavras-chave: Hidrocefalia pediátrica; Coagulação neuroendoscópica do plexo coróide; Terceiro ventriculostomia endoscópica. are the main treatment since 1940s. However, sometimes INTRODUCTION shunt dependency in children with hydrocephalus is a terrible problem, and is more dangerous in emerging countries than Pediatric hydrocephalus is one of the most frequently diagnosed developed countries because of the difficulties that prevent diseases in pediatric neurosurgical practice. Approximately 60% access to prompt neurosurgical intervention, in cases of of the total cases of hydrocephalus in children are congenital infection or shunt malfunction8,22,23. In this scenario, mainly or acquired in childhood. It is a typical surgical disease, and in obstructive hydrocephalus, neuroendoscopic techniques if left untreated, most cases are lethal. Traditionally, shunts 1MD, PhD - Disciplina de Neurocirurgia, Programa de Pós-Graduação em Biociências Aplicadas – Universidade Federal do Triângulo Mineiro, Uberaba, MG 2MD, PhD - Disciplina de Neurocirurgia – Universidade Federal de Sergipe, Serviço de Neurocirurgia – Hospital Cirurgia, Aracaju, SE 3Bolsista de Iniciação Científica – Curso de Medicina – Universidade Federal do Triângulo Mineiro, Uberaba, MG Received Sept 9, 2014. Accepted Sept 15, 2014 Dezena RA, Pereira CU, Araújo LP, Ribeiro MP, Oliveira HA. - Neuroendoscopic choroid plexus coagulation for pediatric J Bras Neurocirurg 25 (1): 30 - 35, 2014 hydrocephalus: review of historical aspects and rebirth 33 Review such as endoscopic third ventriculostomy (ETV) become CSF shunts. In a review, from 1934 to 1957, there were 95 vitally important in the management of these patients. ETV cases of NCPC. The mean mortality rate was 15 %, while the is successful in about 80% of children older than 1 year of mean success rate was 60% with an average follow-up period age, regardless of the cause of obstructive hydrocephalus. of 8 years. On the other hand, there were 1087 cases of various For infants younger than 1 year of age, isolated ETV remains kinds of CSF shunt, including 230 ventriculoperitoneal shunts controversial, probably because of a deficiency in CSF (VPS). The mean mortality rate was 10%, and the mean initial absorption. success rate was 60% with an average follow-up time of 2 years. The result of the reviews showed a shift from NCPC to shunts, Benjamin C. Warf, at CURE Children´s Hospital of Uganda, perhaps due to poor, and limited and poor technology. On the hypothesized that the addition of neuroendoscopic choroid other hand, the late complication rate for shunt was 57%17,30. plexus coagulation (NCPC) at the time of the ETV, to Scarff, in 1970, published the first large series of NCPC cases, simultaneously reduce the rate of CSF production, might his own series of 39 children treated during 23-year period, with improve the outcome22. This old neuroendoscopic procedure 67% of success18. Milhorat, in 197413, reported his series of 12 of the early 20th century, abandoned due to limited technology cases underwent choroid plexectomy. Among 11 survivors, 8 and complications, has been reinvented and adapted to current (72%) failed and required further shunt13. After this report, that neurosurgery. NCPC in rhesus monkeys reduced CSF production by only 40%, it declined in favor of the shunts30. In neuroendoscopic literature from the 1980s to 2004 the success rate of NCPC HISTORICAL ASPECTS was between 30 and 52%9,10,16. In small series, two out of three cases were successful1,14,30. Griffith, in 1986, gave a detailed Faivre, in 1854 and Luschka, in 1855 were the first researchers account of endoscopic intracranial neurosurgery, through a to suggest that the choroid plexus is the source of CSF3,29. report of the results of 71 patients who received NCPC with or 9 Cushing supported this hypothesis through intraoperative without shunt from 1972 to 1982 . The selection criteria were observations4. Extrachoroidal fluid production was suggested infants with hydrocephalus who had progressively enlarging by Weed in 1914, by animal studies29. Dandy, in 1918, head circumference with ventricles grossly dilated and absent demonstrated in an animal study that unilateral hydrocephalus superficial CSF space on CT scan. Behavioral changes were was produced when the 4th ventricle was blocked together with also considered. In his series, 30 % were not shunt dependent. the access through the foramen of Monro to the contralateral The success rate was 54, 58, and 22 % for myelomenigocele, plexectomized lateral ventricle5,30. Furthermore, in the same communicating, and obstructive hydrocephalus groups, 10 year, he also demonstrated that CSF is produced by the choroid respectively. The same author, in 1990 , further reported the plexus in an animal study. Based on this result, he performed results of 32 childhood hydrocephalus cases treated by NCPC choroid plexus extirpation in four infants with communicating between 1985 and 1988 with CT scan examination. Eighteen hydrocephalus by open surgery. In this series, one infant with cases were below the age of 6 months. Patient selection moderate hydrocephalus and myelomenigocele was well on was the same as in his previous report. In addition, all cases 10 months follow-up, and the other three infants with severe showed marked ventricular dilatation on preoperative CT hydrocephalus died until 4 weeks after the operation5,30. After, scan. Different to his previous series, he added postoperative in 1932, Dandy also used a rigid Kelly cystoscope to inspect the perfusion of the ventricular system with artificial CSF to lateral ventricles in two hydrocephalic children6. Cauterization clear the postcoagulation blood and protein released to the of the choroid plexus was attempted in one case. He further CSF. The average follow-up time ranged from 1 to 4 years. detailed the technique of endoscopic coagulation of the Fifty-two percent of the patients were shunt independent. choroid plexus in 19387,30. Isolated NCPC was first described Those required shunting was all in an interval of ≤12 weeks by Putnam, in 193430. In the subsequent years, besides NCPC, except one. Among the successful group, most of the patients other surgical treatments of hydrocephalus were introduced showed a head circumference similar to the preoperative 30 16 including endoscopic third ventriculostomy and extrathecal size . Pople