sign in sign up
<<
Home , Ajoy Mukherjee, Biplab Dasgupta, Debi Prasad Pal, Dilip Singh Judeo, Golam Yazdani, Gulab Chand Kataria

NIta' .. ~. V.I. I, No 1 MODay, t Dec.mh«J18. 1989 Agraha)a.. 27. 1911 (Sata)

LOK SABRA DEBATES (English Version)

First SessiOD (Ninth Lok Sabba)

(VoJ I contains NOl. I to ~)

LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT NEW DELW

Price I B.s. 6.00

[O&lonw., BNOLIIB Pl.OCJ!mlMOS lJiCLUDD IN 1bI0LIIII V..... AND OMOIMAL Hnml PaOCBBOINOlINCLUDm Df HINDI VDJICBf WILL • 1'UATID AS AUTIIGJUT4TfQ AlII) HOT TBB TRANlL.\TlOli 'I'B8IUIOI'.] CONTENTS

[Ninth Series, Vol I, First Session, 198911911 (Saka)]

No.1, Monday, December 18, 1989/Agrahayana 27, 1911 (Saka)

COLUMNS

Observance of Silence 1-2

List of Members Elected to -Laid on the Table 2-47

Panel of Chairmen 47

Resignation by Members 47-48

Members Sworn 49-70

LOKSABHA

The Speaker *

Shri

The Deputy Speaker

(Vacant)

Panel of Chairmen **

Shri Purushothaman

Dr. Thambi Durai

Shri

Shri Jaswant Singh

Shri Nirmal Chatterjee

Shrimati Gaeta '

Secretary-General

Dr. Subhash C. Kashyap

~t 1989 er 20,198' GOVERNME:NT OF

MEMBERS OF THE CABINET

Prime Minister and also Shri incharge of the Ministries/ Departments of Defence; Personnel; Public Grievances and Pensions; Science & Technology; Atomic Energy; Electronics; Ocean Development: Space; Environment & Forests and other subjects not allocated to any other Cabinet Minister or Minister of State (Independent charge).

Deputy Prime Minister Shri Devi Lal and Minister of Agriculture

Minister of Finance Prof. Madhu Dandavate

Minister of Railways Shri

Minister of Industry Shri

Minister of T extifes with Shri Sharad Yadav additional charge of the Ministry of Food Processing Industries

Minister of Home Affairs Shri Mufti Mohammad Sayeed

Minister of Com merce and Shri Arun Nehru Tourism

Minister of Energy with Shri Arif Mohd. Khan additional charge of the Ministry of Civil Aviation

Minister of Labour and Welfare Shri

Minister of Health and Family Welfare Shri

Minister of External Affairs Shri I.K. Gujral

Minister of Petroleum and Chemicals Shri M.S. Gurupadaswamy

Minister of Food & Civil Supplies Shri Nathu Ram Mirdha (ii) (iii) Minister of Information & Shri P. Upendra Broadcasting and Parliamentary Affairs.

Minister of Surface Transport Shri K. P. Unnikrishnan with additional charge of the Ministry of Comm unications

Minister of Steel and Mines with Shri Dinesh Goswami additional charge of the Ministry of Law and Justice

Minister of Urban Development Shri Murasoli Maran

MINISTERS OF STATE

Minister of State (Independent charge) Shri Manobhai Kotadiya of the Ministry of Water Resources

Minister of State in the Ministry of Smt. Environment and Forests

Minister of State in the Ministry Prof. M.G. K. Menon of Science and Technology

LOK SABHA DEBATES

Vol. I First day of the First Session of the Ninth Lok Sabha No.1.

LOKSABHA on such an occasion, we all stand in silence for a short while before we begin our pro­ ceedings. Monday, December 18, 1989/Agrahayana 27, 1911 (Saka) The Members then stood in silence for a short while. The Lok Sabha met at Eleven of the Clock

[THE SPEAKER Pro tem (PROF. N.G. RANGA) in the Chaiij 11.02 hrs.

OBSERVANCE OF SILENCE LIST OF MEMBERS ELECTED TO LOK SABHA [English] Laid on the Table MR. SPEAKER: We meet today on a solemn occasion. A new Lok Sabha has [English] been elected under the Constitution charged SECRETARY GENERAL: Sir, I lay on with great and heavy responsibilities for the the Table a Book, presented to the Speaker welfare of the country and our people. by the Chief Election Commissioner, con­ taining the list of Members elected tethe Lek It is fit and proper that, as is customary Sabha at the General Election of 1989.

LIST OF MEMBERS ELECTED TO LOK SABHA

No. and name of Name of elected member Constituency

2

1 . ANDHRA PRADESH

1. Srikakulam Shri Viswanatham Kanithi

2. Parvathipuram (ST) Shri Vijayaramaraju Satrucharla

'3. Bobbili Shri Kemburi Rama Mohana Rao

4. Visakhapatnam Smt. Uma Gajapat~i Raju Poosapati 3 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Elected 4

1 2

5. Bhadrachaiam (5T)' Smt. Kariyeddula Kamala Kumari

6. Anakapalli Shri Konathala Ramakrishna alias Appalaswamynaidu

7. Kakinada Shri Mallipudi Mangapathi Pallam Raju

8. Rajahmundry Smt. Jamuna

9. Amalapuram (SC) Shri Kusuma Krishna Murty

10. Narasapur Shri Bhupatiraju Vijaya Kumara Raju

11. Eluru Shri Krishna

12. Machilipatnam 5hri Sambas iva Rao Kavuri

13. Vijayawada Smt. Chennupati Vidya

14. Tenali Shri Basavapunnayya Singam

15. Guntur Shri N.G. Ranga

16. Bapatla Shri Salagala Benjamin

17. Narasaraopet Shri Kasu Venkata Krishna Reddy

18. Ongole Shri Rajmohanareddy Mekapati

19. Nellore (SC) Shri Putchalapalli Penchalaiah

20 Tirupathi (SC) Shri Chinta Mohan

21. Chittoor Shri Ganendra Reddy

22. Rajampet Shri Annsiahgari Sai Prathap

23. Cuddapah Shri Y.S. Raja Sekhar Reddy

24. Hindupur Shri S. Gangadhara

25. Anantapur Shri Anantha Venkata Reddy

26. Kurnool Shri Kotla Vijaya Bhaskara Reddy

27. Nandyal Shri Bojja Venkata Reddy

28. Nagarkurnool (SC) Shri Anantha Ramulu Mallu

29. Mahbubnagar Shri Maflikarjun 5 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Elected 8

1 2

30. Hyderabad Shri Sultan Salah uddin Owaisi

31. Secunderabad Smt. T. Manemma

32. Siddipet (SC) Shri Yellaiah Nandi

33. Medak Shri Baga Reddy, M.

34. Nizamabad Shri T aduri Bala Goud

35. Adilabad Shri P. Narasa Reddy

36. Peddapalli (SC} Shri G. Venkat Swamy

37. Karimnagar Shri Chokka Rao Juvvadi

38. Hanamkonda Shri Kamaluddin Ahmed

39. Warangal Shri 'Surender Reddy Ramasahayam

40. Khammam Shri Jalagam Vengal Rao

41. Nalgonda Shri Chakilam Srinivasa Rao

42. Miryalguda Shri B.N. Reddy

2.

Arunachal West Shri Pram Khandu Thungon

2. Arunachal East Shri Laeta Umbrey

3.

1. Bagaha (SC) Shri Mahendra Bartha

2. Bettiah Shri Dharmesh Pro Verma

3. Motihari Shri

4. Gopalganj Shri Rajmangal Mishra

5. Siwan Shri Janardan Tiwari

6. Maharajganj Shri

7. Chapra Shri Laloo Prasad

8. Hajipur (SC) Shri Ram Vilas Paswan

9. Vaishali Smt. Usha Singh 7 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Elected 8

1 2

10. Muzaffarpur Shri George Fernandes

11. Sitamarhi Shri Hukumd90 Narayan Yadav

12. Sheohar Shri Hari Kishore Singh

13. Madhubani Shri Bhogendra Jha

14. Jhanjharpur Shri Devendra Prasad Yadav

15. Darbhanga Shri Shakeeul Rahman

16. Rosera (SC) Shri Dashai Chaudhary

17. Samastipur Shri Manjai Lal

18. Barh Shri

19. Balia Shri Surya Narayan Singh

20. Saharsa Shri Surya Nr. Yadav

21. Madhepura Shri Ramendra Kumar Yadav Ravi

22. Araria (SC) 5hri 5ukhdeo Paswan

23. Kishanganj 5hri M.J. Akbar

24. Pumea 5hri Taslimudin

25. Katihar Shri Yuvraj

26. Rajmahal (5T) 5hri Simon Marandi

27. Dumka (5T) 5hri

28. Godda Shd Janardan Yadav

29. Banka Shri Pratap Singh

30. Bhagalpur Shri Chun Chun Pra. Yadav

31. Khagaria Shri Ram Sharan Yadav

32. Monghyr Shri Dhanraj Singh

33. Beg usar ai Shri Lalit Vijoy Singh

34. Nalanda Shri Ram Swaroop Prasad 9 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27, 1911 (SAKA) El9cted 10

1 2

35. Patna Prof. Shailendra Nath Shrivastava

36. Arrah Shri Rameshwar Prasad

37. Buxar Shri T ej Narain Singh

38. Sasaram (SC) Shri Chhedi Paswan

39. Bikramganj Shri Ram Prasad Singh

40. Aurangabad Shri Ram Naresh Singh

41. Jahanabad Shri Ramashray Prasad Singh

42. Nawada (SC) Shri Prem Pradeep

43. Gaya (SC) Shri Ishwar Chaudhary

44. Chatra Shri Upendra Nath Verma

45. Kodarma Shri Ritlal Prasad Verma

46. Giridih Shri Ram Das Singh

47. Shri A.K. Roy

48. Hazaribagh Shri Yadunath Pandey

49. Ranchi Shri Subodh Kant Sahay

50. Jamshedpur Shri Shailendra Mahto

51. Singhbhum (ST) Shri Begun Sumbrui

52. Khunti (ST) Shri Karia Munda

53. Lohardaga (ST) Smt. Sumati Oraon

54. Palamau (SC) Shri Jorawar Ram

4.

1. Panaji Shri Gopal Mayekar

2. Mormugao VACANT

5.

1. Kutch Shri Babubhai Meghji Shah 11 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Eleded 12

, 2

2. Surendranagar Shri Koli Patel Somabhai Gandabhai

3. Jamnagar Shri Koradiya Chandreshkumar Valjibhai (Chandresh Patel)

4. Rajkot Shri Vekaria Shivalal Nagjibhai

5. Porbandar Shri Manvar Balvantbhai Bachubhai

6. Junagadh Shri Shekhada Govindbhai Kanjibhai

7. Amreli Shri Manobhai Kotadiya

8. Bhavnagar Shri Jamod Shashikant Mavjibhai

9. Dhandhuka (SC) Shri Ratilal Kalidas Varma

10. Ahmedabad Shri Harin Pathak

11. Gandhinagar Shri Vaghela Shankarji Laxmanji

12. Mehsana Dr. AK. Patel

13. Patan (SC) Shri Chavda Khemchandbhai Somabhai

14. Banaskantha Shri Shah Jayantilal Virchandbhai

15. Sabarkantha Shri Maganbhai Manibhai Patel

16. Kapadvanj Shri Gabhaji Mangaji Thakore

17. Dohad (ST) Shri Somjibhai Darnor

18. Godhra Shri Patel Shantilal Purushottamdas

19. Kaira Shri Chauhan Prabhatsinh Hathisinh

20. Anand Shri Patel Nathubhai Manibhai

21. Chhota (ST) Shri Rathawa Naranbhai Jamlabhai

22. Baroda Shri Koko alias Prakash Kanubhai Brahmbhatt (Koko)

23. Broach Shri Deshmukh Chandubhai Shanabhai

24. Surat Shri Kashiram Rana

25. Mandvi (ST) Shri Gamit Chhitubhai Oevjibhai 13 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27, 1911 (SAKA) Elected 14

1 2

26. Bulsar (ST) Shri Arjunbhai lallubhai Patel

6.

1. Ambala (SC) Shri Ram Parkash

2. Kurukshetra Shri Gurdial Singh Saini

3. Kamal Shri Chiranji lal

4. Sonepat Shri Kapil Dev

5. Rohtak Shri Devi lal

6. Faridabad Shri Bhajan LaI

7. Mahendragarh Shri Birender Singh

8. Bhiwani Shri Bansi Lal

9. Hissar Shri Jai Parkash

10. Sirsa (SC) Shri Het Ram

7.

1. Shimla (SC) Shri Krishan Dutt Sultanpuri

2. Mandi Shri Maheshwar Singh

3. Kangra Shri

4. Hamirpur Thakur

8. JAMMU AND KASHMIR

1. Baramulla Prof. Saif-ud-din Soz

2. Sri nagar Shri Mohammad Shafi Bhat

3. Anantnag Shri Piyare 1aI Handoo

4. Ladakh Shri Mohd. Hassan Commander

5. Udhampur Shri Dharam Pal

6. Jammu Shri Janak Raj Gupta

9.

1. Stdar (SC) Shri Narsing Rao Suryawanshi 15 List of Members DECEMBER 18. 1989 Elected 16

1 2

2. Gulbarga Dr. B.G. Jawali

3. Raichur Shri R. Ambanna Nayak Dore

4. Koppal Shri Basavaraj Patil

5. Bellary Smt. Basavarajeswari

6. Davangere Shri Channaiah Odeyar

7. Chitradurga Shri C.P. Mudalagiriyappa

8. Tumkur Shri G.S. Basavaraj

9. Chikballapur Shri V. Krishna Rao

10. Kolar (SC) Shri Y. Ramakrishna

11. Kanakapura Shri M.V. Chandrashekara Murthy

12. North Shri C.K. Jaffer Sharief

13. Bangalore South Shri R. Gundu Rao

14. Mandya Shri G. Madegowda

15. Chamarajanagar (SC) Shri Srinivasa Prasad, V.

16. Mysore Shri Srikantadatta Narasimharaja Wadiyar

17. Mangalore Shri Janardhana Poojary

18. Udupi Shri Oscar Fernandes

19. Hassan Shri H.C. Srikantaiah alias Annaiah

20. Chikmagalur Shri D.M. Puttegowda

21. Shimoga Shri T.V. Chandrashekarappa

22. Kanara Shri Devaraya Naik

23. Dharwad South Shri Mujahid B.M.

24. Dharwad North Shri O.K. Naikar

25. Belgaum Shri Sidnal Shanmukhappa Bassappa

26. Chikkodi (Se) Shri B. Shankaranand 17 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27; 1911 (SAKA) Elected 18

1 2

27. Bagalkot Shri Patil Subhas Tammannappa

28. Bijapur Shri Gudadinni Basagondappa Kadappa

10.

1. Kasargod Shri M. Ramanna Rai

2. Cannanore Shr; Mullappally Ramachandran

3. Badagara Shri K.P. Unnikrishnan

4. Calicut Shri K. Muraleedharan

5. Manjeri Shri Ibrahim Sulaiman Sait

6. Ponnani Shri G.M. Banatwalla

7. Palghat Shri A. Vijayaraghavan

8. Ottapalam (SC) Shri K.R. Narayanan

9. Trichur Shri P.A. Antony

10. Mukundapuram Prof. Savithri Lakshmanan

11. Ernakulam Prof. K. V. Thomas

12. Muvattupuzha Shri P.C. Thomas

13. Kottayam Shri Ramesh Chennithala

14. Idukki Shri Palai K.M. Mathew

15. Alleppey Shri Vakkom Purushothaman

16. Mavelikara Prof. P.J. Kurien

17. Adoor (SC) Shri Kodikunnil Suresh

18. Quilon Shri S. Krishna Kumar

19. Chirayinkil Shri Thalekunnil Basheer

20. Trivandrum Shri A. Charles 19 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Elected 20

2

11.

1. Morena (SC) Shri Chhaviram

2. Bhind Shri Narsingh Rao Dixit

3. Gwalior Shri Madhav Rao Scindia Jiwaji Rao

4. Guna Smt. Vijaya Raje Scindia

5. Sagar (SC) Shri Shankar Lal

6. Khajuraho Kumari Umabharti

7. Damoh Shri Lok'endra Singh

8. Satna Shri Sukhendra Singh

9. Rewa Shri Yamuna Prasad Shastri

10. Sidhi (Sn Shri Jagannath Singh

11. Shahdol (Sn VACANT

12. Surguja (Sn Shri Larang Sai

13. Raigarh (ST) Shri

14. Janjgir Shri

15. Bilaspur (SC) Shri Resham Lal Jangde

16. Sarangarh (SC) Shri Parasram Bhardwaj

17. Shri

18. Mahasamund Shri Vidyacharan Shukla

19. Kanker (ST) Shri Arvind Netam

20. Bastar (ST) Shri Mankuram Sodi

21. Durg Shri Purushottam Kaushik

22. Rajnandgaon Shri Dharampal Singh Gupta

23. Balaghat Shri Kankar Munjare

24. Mandla (ST) Shri Mohan'al 21 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Elected 22

1 2

25. Jabalpur Shri Baburao Paranjpe

26. Seani Shri Prahlad Singh Patel

27. Chhindwara Shri Kamalnath

28. Betul Shri Arif Beg

29. Hoshangabad Shri Sartaj Singh

30. Shri Sushil Chandra Verma

31. Vidisha Shri Raghavji

32. Rajgarh Shri Pyarelal ,

33. Shajapur (SC) Shri Phoolchand Verma

34. Khandwa Shri Amratlal Tarwala (Manni Bhai)

35. Khargone Shri Rameshwar Patidar

36. Dhar (ST) 5hri 5urajbhanu Shivbhanu Solanki

37. Indore 5mt. 5umitra Mahajan

38. Ujjain (SC) 5hri Satya Narayan Jatiya

39. Jhabua (5T) Shri Dileepsingh Shuria

40. Mandsaur Dr. Laxminarayan Pandey

12.

1. Rajapur Prof. Madhu Dandavate

2. Ratnagiri Shri Govindrao Nikam

3. Kulaba 5hri Antulay A.A.

4. Bombay South Shri Deora Murli

5. Bombay South Central Shri Vamanrao Mahadik

6. Bombay North Central Shri Vidyadhar Sambhaji Gokhle

7. Bombay North East Shrimati Mehta Jayawanti Navinchandra

8. Bombay North West Shri Sunil Dutt 23 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Elected 24

1 2

9. Bombay North Shri

10. Thane Shri Kapse Ramchandra Ganesh

11. Dahanu (ST) Shri Damodar Barku Shingada

12. Nashik Dr. Aher Daulat Sonuji

13. Malegaon (ST) Shri Mahale Haribhau Shankar

14. Dhule (ST) Shri Bhoye Reshma Motiram

15. Nandarbar (ST) Shri Gavit Manikrao Hodlya

16. Erandol Shri Patil Uttamrao Laxmanrao

17. Jalgaon Shri Mahajan Yadav Shivram

18. Buldhana (SC) Shri Kale Sukhdeo Nandaji

19. Akola Shri Phundkar Pandurang Pundlik

20. Washim Shri Deshmukh Anantrao Vitthalrao

21 . Amravati Shri Sudam Deshmukh

22. Ramtek Shri P. V. Narsimharao

23. Nagpur Shri Purohit Banwarilal Bhagwandas

24. Bhandara Dr. Khushal Parasram Bopche

25. Chimur Shri Shiwankar Mahadeorao Sukaji

26. Chandrapur Shri Potdukhe Shantaram Rajeshwar

27. Wardha Shri Sathe Vasant Purushottam

28. Yavatmal Shri Uttamrao Deorao Patil

29. Hingo'i Shri Uttam Rathod

30. Nanded Dr. '(abde Venkatesh Rukhmaji

31 . Parbhani Shri Deshmukh Ashok Anandrao

32. Jalna Shri Pundlik Hari Danwe

33. Aurangabad Shri Moreshwar Save 25 List of Members AGRAHA YANA 27. 1911 (SAKA) Elected 26

1 2

34. Beed Shri Dhakane Babanrao Dadaba

35. Latur Shri Patil Shivraj Vishwanath

36. Osmanabad (SC) Shri Kamble Arvind Tulshiram

37. Solapur Shri Sadul Dharmanna Mondayya

38. Pandharpur (SC) Shri Thorat Sandipan Bhagwan

39. Ahmednagar Shri Gadakh Yeshawantrao Kankarrao

40. Kopargaon Shri Vikhe Ekanathrao Vitthalrao

41. Khed Shri Bankhele Kisanrao Baburao

42. Pune Shri Gadgil Vitthalrao Narhar

43. Baramati Shri Pati! Shankarrao Bajirao

44. Satara Shri Bhosale Prataprao Baburao

45. Karad Smt. Chavan Premlabai Dajisaheb

46. Sang Ii Shri Patil Prakashbapu Vasantrao

47. Ichalkaranji Shri Mane Balaso alias Rajaram Shankarrao

48. Kolhapur Shri Gaikwad Udaysingrao Nanasaheb

13.

,. Inner Manipur Shri N. Tombi Singh

2. Outer Manipur (S' Shri Meijinlung Kamson

14. MEGHALAYA

Shillong Shri Peter G. Marbaniang

2. Tura Shri Sanford Marak

15.

Mizorarn (ST) Dr. C. Silvera

16.

Nagaland Shri Shikiho Serna 27 List of Members DECEMBER 18. 1989 Elected 28

2

17. ORISSA

1. Mayurbhanj (ST) Shri Bhagey Gobardhan

2. Balasore Shri Samarendra Kundu

3. Bhadrak (SC) Shri Mangaraj Mallik

4. Jajpur (SC) Shri Anadi Charan Das

5. Kendrapara Shri Rabi Ray

6. Shri Srikanta Jena

7. Jagatsinghpur Shri Lokenath Choudhury

8. Puri Shri Nilamani Routray

9. Bhubaneswar Shri Shivaji Patnaik

10. Aska Shri Ananta Narayan Singh Deo

11. Berhampur Shri Gopinath Gajapathi Narayan Deo

12. Koraput (ST) Shri Giridhar Gomango

13. Nowrangpur (ST) Shri Khagapati Pradhani

14. Kalahandi Shri Bhakta Charan Das

15. Phulbani (SC) Shri Nakul Nayak

16. Bolangir Shri Balgopal Mishra

17. Sambalpur Shri Bhawani Shankar Hota

18. Deogarh Shri Ravinarayan Pani

19. Dhenkanal Shri Bhajaman Behera

20. Sundargarh (ST) Shri Debananda Amat

21. Keonjhar (ST) Shri Govinda Chandra Munda

18.

1. Gurdaspur Smt. Sukhbans Kaur

2. Shri 29 List of Members AGRAHA Y ANA 27. 1911 (SAKA) Elected 30

1 2

3. Tarn Taran Shri Simranjit Singh Mann

4. Jullundur Shri I. K. Gujral

5. Phillaur (SC) Shri Harbhajan Lakha

6. Hoshiarpur Shri Kamal Chaudhary

7. Ropar (SC) Smt. Bimal Kaur

8. Patiala Shri Atinder Pal Singh

9. Ludhiana Smt. Rajinder Kaur Bulara

10. Sangrur Shri Rajdev Singh

11. Bhatinda (SC) Shri Sucha Singh

12. Faridkot Shri Jagdev Singh

13. Firozepur Shri Dhial] Singh

19.

1. Ganganagar (SC) Shri Bega Ram

2. Bikaner Shri Shopat Singh Makkasar

3. Churu Shri Daulat Ram Saran

4. Jhunjhunu Sh ri Jagdeep Dhankhar

5. Sikar Shri Devi Lal

6. Jaipur Shri Girdhari Lal Bhargaya

7. Dausa Shri Nathu Singh

8. Alwar Shri Ramjilal Yadav

9. Bharatpur Shri Vishwendra Singh

10. Bayana (SC) Shri Than Singh Jatav

11. Sawai Madhopur (ST) Shri Kirodi Lal

12. Ajmer Shri Rasa Singh

13. Tonk (SC) Shri Gopal Pacherwal 31 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Elected 32

2

14. Kota Shri Dau Dayal Joshi

15. Jhalawar Smt. Vasundhara Rajey

16. Banswara (ST) Shri Heera Bhai

17. Salumbdr (ST) Shri Nandlal Meena

18. Udaipur Shri

19. Chittorgarh Shri Mahendra Singh

20. Bhilwara Shri Hemendra Singh

21. Pali Shri Gumanmal Lodha

22. Jalore (SC) Shri Kailash Meghwal

23. Barmer Shri Kalvi

24. Jodhpur Shri Jaswant Singh Sio Sardar Singh

25. Nagaur Shri Nathu Ram Mirdha

20. SIKKIM

Sikkim Shri Nandu Thapa

21. TAMIL NADU

1. Madras North Shri Pandian, D.

2. Madras Central Shri Anbarasu, Era

3. Madras South Smt. Vyjayantimala Bali

4. Sriperumbudur (SC) Smt. Maragatham Chandrasekhar

5. Chengalpattu Shri Kanchee Paneer Chelvam

6. Arakkonam Shri Jeevarathinam, R.

7. Vellore Shri Abdul Sarriad. A.K.A.

8. Tiruppattur Shri Jayamohan, A.

9. Vandavasi Shri Balaraman, L.

10. Tindivar.am Shri Eramadass, R. 33 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Elected 34

2

11. Cuddalore Shri Venkatesan, P.R.S.

12. Chidambaram (SC) Dr. Vallalperuman, P.

13. Dharmapuri Shri Sekhar, M.G.

14. Krishnagiri Shri Ramamurthy, K.

15. Rasipuram (SC) Shri Devarajan, B.

16. Salem Shri Rangarajan Kumaramangalam

17. Tiruchengode Shri Palanisamy, K.C.

18. Nilgiris Shri Prabhu, R.

19. Gobichettipalayam Shri Narayanan, P.G.

20. Coimbatore Shri Kuppusamy, C.K.

21. Pollachi (SC) Shri Raja Ravi Varma, B.

22. Palani VACANT

23. Dindigul Shri Srinivasan, C.

24. Madurai Shri Rambabu, A.G.S

25. Periyakulam Shri Muthaiah, R.

26. Karur Shri Thambi Durai, M.

27. Tiruchirapalli Shri Adaikalaraj, L.

28. Perarnbalur (SC) Shri Asokaraj, A.

29. Mayiladuturai Shri Pakeer Mohamed Hajee E.S.M.

30. Nagapattinam (SC) Shri Selvarasu, M.

31. Thanjavur Shri Singaravadivel, S.

32. Pudukkottai Shri Sundararaj. N.

33. Sivaganga Shri Chidambaram, P.

34. Ramanathapuram Shri Rajeshwaran. V.

35. Sivakasi Dr. Kalimuthu, K. 35 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Elected 36

1 2

36. Tirunelveli Shri Janarthanan, M.R.

37. T enkasi (SC) Shri Arunachalam, M.

38. Tiruche-ndur Shri Dhanuskodi Athithan, R.

39. Nagarcoil Shri Dennis, N.

22.

1. Tripura West Shri Santosh Mohan Dev

2. Tripura East (ST) Maharaja Manikya Kirit Bikram Kishore Deb Barmd Bahadur

23. UTIAR PRADESH

1. Tehri Garhwal Shri Brahmdutt

2. Garhwal Shri Chandra Mohan

3. Almora Shri Harish Chandra Singh Rawat

4. Naini Tal Shri Mahendra Singh Pal

5. Bijnor (SC) Kum~ri

6. Amroha Shri Har Govind

7. Moradabad Shri Ghulam Mohammad Khan Haji

8. Rampur Shri Zulfiqar Ali Khan

9. Sambhal Shri S.P. Yadav

10. Budaun Shri Sharad Yadav

11. Aonla Shri Raj Veer Singh

12. Bareilly Shri Santosh Kumar Gangwar

13. Pilibhit Smt. Maneka Gandhi

14. Shah jahanpu r Shri Satya Pal Singh

15. Kheri Smt. Usha Verma

16. Shahabad Shri Dharmgaj Singh

17. Sitapur Dr. Rajendra Kumari Bajpai 37 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Elected 38

1 2

18. Misrikh (SC) Shri Ramlal Rahi

19. Hardoi (SC) Shri Parmai Lal

20. Shri Mandhata Singh

21. Mohanlal~anj (SC) Shri Sarju Prasad 'Saroj'

22. Unnao Shri Anwar Ahmad

23. Rae Sareli Smt. Sheila Kaul

24. Pratapgarh VACANT

25. Amethi Shri -

26. Suitanpul Shri Ram Singh

27. Akbarpur (SC) Shri Ram Awadh

28. Faizabad Shri Mitra Sen Yadav

29. Sara Banki (SC) Shri Ram Sagar

30. Kaiserganj Shri Rudra Sen Chaudhary

31. Sahraich Shri Arif Mohd. Khan

32. Balrampur Shri Fasiurrahman alias Munnan Khan

33. Gonda Shri Anand Singh alias Annu Bhaiya

34. Basti (SC) Shri Kalpa Nath Sonkar

35. Domariaganj Shri Brij Bhusan Tiwari

36. Khalilabad Shri Ram Prasad Chaudhary

37. Bansgaon (SC) Shri Mahabir Prasad

38. Gorakhpur Shri Abedya Nath

39. Maharajganj Shri Harsh Vardhan

40. Padrauna Shri Baleshar (Baleshwar)

41. Deoria Shri Raj Mangal

42. Salempur Shri Harikewal

43. Ballia Shri Chandra Shekhar 39 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Elected 40

1 2

44. Ghosi Shri Kalp Nath

45. Azamgarh Shri Ram Krishna

46. Lalganj (SC) Shri Ram Dhan

47. Machhlishahr Shri Sheo Sharan

48. Jaunpur Raja Yadvendra Datt

49. Saidpur (SC) Shri Ramsagar

50. Ghazipur Shri Jagdish

51. Chandauli Shri Kailash Nath Singh Yadav

52. Varanasi Shri Anil Shastri

53. Robertsganj (SC) Shri Subedar

54. Mirzapur Shri Yusuf Beg

55. Phulpur Shri Ram Pujan Patel

56. Allahabad Shri

57. Chail (SC) Shri Ram Nihor Rakesh

58. Fatehpur Shri Viswanath Pratap

59. Banda Shri Ram Sajiwan

60. Hamirpur Shri Ganga Charan

61. Jhansi Shri Rajendra Agnihotri

62. JaJaun (SC) Shri Ram Sewak Bhatia

63. Ghatampur (SC) Shri Keshari Lal

64. Bilhaur Shri Arun Kumar Nehru

65. Kanpur Smt. Subhasini Ali

66. Etawah Shri Ram Singh Shakya

67. Kannauj Shri Chhotey Singh Yadav

68. Farrukhabad Shri Santosh Bhartiya 41 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Elected 42

2

69. Mainpuri Shri Udai Pratap Singh

70. Jalesar Ch. Multan Singh

71. Etah Shri Mahadeepak Singh

72. Firozabad (SC) Shri Ramji Lal Suman

73. Agra Shri Ajay Singh

74. Mathura Shri Manvendra Singh

75. Hathras (SC) Dr. Bangali Singh

76. Aligarh Shri Satya Pal Malik

77. Khurja (SC) Shri Bhagwan Dass

78. Bulandshahr Shri Sarwar Hussain

79. Hapur Shri K.C. Tyagi (Kishan Chand)

80. Meerut Shri Harish Pal

81. Baghpat Shri Ajeet Singh

82. Muzaftarnagar Shri Mufti Mohammad Sayeed

83. Kairana Shri Har pal

84. Saharanpur Shri Rashid Masood

85. Hardwar (SC) Shri Jagpal Singh

24.

1. Cooch Behar (SC) Shri

2. Alipurduars (ST) Shri

3. Jalpatgun Shri Manik Sanyal

4. Oarjeeling Shri Inderjeet

5. Raiganj Shri

6. Balurghat (SC) Shri Palas Barman

7. Maida Shri Abul Barkat Ataul Ghani Khan Choudhury 43 List of Members DECEMBER 18, 1989 Elected 44

1 2

8. Jangipur Shri Abedin Zainal

9. Murshjdabad Shri Masudal Hossain Syed

10. Berhampore Shri

11. Krishnagar Shri Ajc)' Mukherjee

12. Nabadwip (SC) Shri Asim Bala

13. Barasat Shri

14. Basirhat Shri Monoranjan Sur

15. Joynagar (SC) Shri Sanat Kumar Mondal

16. Mathurapur (SC) Shri Radhikaranjan Pramanik

17. Diamond Harbour Shri Amal Datta

18. Jadavpur Smt. Malir1i Bhattacharya

19. Barrackpore Shri Tarit Baran Topder

20. Dum Dum Shri Nirmal Kanti Chatterjee

21. Calcutta North West Shri

22. Calcutta North East Shri

23. Calcutta South Shri

24. Howrah Shri Sushanta Chakrabortty

25. Uluberia Shri

26. Serampore Shri Sudarsan Raychoudhuri

27. Hooghly Shri

28. Arambagh Shri

29. Panskura Smt. Gita Mukherjee

30. Shri Satyagopal Misra

31. Contai Shri Sudhir Giri

32. Midnapore Shri 45 List of Members AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Elected 46

1 2

33. Jhargram (ST) Shri Matilal Hansda

34. Purulia Shri Chitta Ranjan Mahata

35. Bankura Stlri Acharia Basudeb

36. Vishnupur (SC) Shri Khan Sukhendu

37. Durgapur (SC) VACANT

38. Asansol Shri Haradhan Roy

39. Burdwan Shri Sudhir Ray

40. Katwa Shri Saifuddin Chowdhury

41. Bolpur Shri Chatterjee Somnath

42. Birbhum (SC) Shri Dome Ramchandra

25. ANDAMAN & NICOBAR ISLANDS

Andaman & Nicobar Islands Shri Manoranjan~Bhakta

26 CHANDIGARH

Chandigarh Shri Harmohan Dhawan

27. DADRA & NAGAR HAVELI

Dadra & Nagar Havel; (ST) Shri Delkar Mohanbhai Sanjibhai

28. DAMAN & DIU

Daman and Diu Shri Tandel Devji Jogibhai

29.

1. Shri lal Krishna Advani

2. South Delhi Shri S/o Shri S.D. Khurana

3. Outer Delhi Shri Tarif Singh

4. East Delhi Shri H.K.l. Bhagat

5. Chandni Chowk Shri Jai Prakash Aggarwal 47 Resignation by DECEMBER 18, 1989 Members 48

1 2

6. Delhi Sadar Shr; Vijay Kumar Malhotra

7. Karol Bagh (SC) Shri Kalka Das

30. LAKSHADWEEP

Lakshadweep (ST) Shri P.M. Sayeed

31. PONOICHERRY

Pondicherry Shr; P. Shanmugam

11.03 hrs. Sikar constituency of Rajasthan and the Rohtak constituency of Haryana, has re­ PANEL OF CHAIRMEN signed his seat in Lok Sabha from the Rohtak constituency and his resignation has been [Eng/ish] accepted by the Speaker with effect from the 5th December, 1989. MR. SPEAKER: I have to inform the House that under Rule 9 of the Rules of I have also to inform the house that Shri Procedure, I have nominated the following Chandra Shekhar, an elected member of Members as members of the Panel of Chair­ Lok Sabha from two constituencies viz. Ballia men:- constituency of and Ma­ harajganj constituency of Bihar, has resigned (1) Shri Indrajit Gupta his seat-in Lok Sabha from the Maharajganj constnuency and his resignation has been (2) Shr; Ebrahim Sulaiman Sait, and accepted by the Speaker with effect from the 8th December, 1989. (3) Shrimati Vijaya Raje Scindia I have further to inform the House that on 11 th December, 1989, Shr; Parma; Lal who had been elected to Lok Sabha from Hardoi constituency of the State of Uttar 11.04 hrs. Pradesh and also to the Legislative Assem­ bly of the State of Uttar Pradesh from Ahrori RESIGNATION BY MEMBERS constituency, handed over his letter of resig­ nation from membership of Lok Sabha from Hardoi constituency of Uttar Pradesh to [Eng/ish] Secretary-General, Lok Sabha personally. The Speaker accepted his resignation with MR. SPEAKER: I have to inform the effect from 11th December, 1989. House that ShriOeyi Lal, an elected member of Lok Sabha from two constituencies viz. 49 Members Sworn AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Members Sworn 50

11.05 hrs. Shri Manoranjan Bhakta (Andaman & Nicobar Islands) MEMBERS SWORN Shri Viswanatham Kanithi (Srikakulam) [Eng/~~h) Shri Kemburi Rama Mohana Rao (Bobbili) MR. SPEAKER: The names of Mem­ bers will now be. called by the Secretary­ Shrimati Uma Gajapathi Raju Poosapati General for the purpose of making and (Visakhapatnam) subscribing oath or affirmation. The Prime Minister will be called first followed by the Shrimati Kariyeddula Kamala Kumari (Shad­ Deputy Prime Minister. Then the Ministers of rachalam) Cabinet rank/Leader of the Opposition will be called. After that, Ministers of State fol­ Shri Konathala Ramakrishna alias lowed by the Membms of Panel of Chairmen Appalaswamynaidu (Anakapalli) will be called. Thereafter, the names of other Members will be called State-wise. The Shri Mallipudi Mangapathi Pallam Raju names of Members whQ are not able to take (Kakinada) the oath or make the affirmation at the first call will be called again at the end. If the Shrimati J. Jamuna (Rajahmundry) name of any Member is not pronounced correctly, he may kindly excuse. Shri Kusuma Krishna Murty (Amalapuram)

Shri Vishwanath Pratap Singh (Fatehpur) Shri Bhupatiraju Vijaya Kumara Raju (Narasapur) Shri Devi Lal (Sikar) Shri Krishna (Eluru) Prof. Madhu Dandavate (Rajapur) Shri Sambasiva Rao Kavuri (Machilipatnam) Shri George Fernandes (Muzaffarpur) Shrimati Chennnupati Vidya (Vijayawada) Shri Sharad Yadav (Budaun) Shri Basavapunnayya Singam (Tenali) Shri Arun Kumar Nehru (Bilhaur) Shri Kasu Venkata Krishna Reddy Shri RamVilas Pas wan (Hajipur) (Narasaraopet)

Shri Nilamani Roatray (Puri) Shri Rajmohanareddy Mekapati (Ongole)

Shri I.K. Gujral (Jullundur) Shri Putchalapalli Penchalaiah (Nellore)

Shri Nathu Ram Mirdha (Nagaur) Shri Chinta Mohan (Tirupathi)

Shri K.P. Unnikrishnan (Badagara) Shr; Annsiahgari Sai Prathap (Rajampet)

Shri Rajiv Gandhi (Amethi) Shri S. Gangadhara (Hindupur)

Shri Manobhai Kotadia (Amreli) Shri Anantha Venkata Reddy (Anantapur)

Shri Indrajit Gupta (Midnapore) Shri Kotla Vijaya Bhaskara Reddy (Kurnoal) Sbri Ebrahim Sulaiman Sait (Manjeri)

Shrimati Vijaya Raje Scindia (Guna) Shri Anantha Ramulu Mallu (Nagarkurnool) 51 Members Sworn DECEMBER 18, 1989 Members Sworn 52

Shri Mallikarjun (Mahbubnagar) Shri Shakeeul Rahman (Oarbhanga)

Shri Sultan Salah uddin Owaisi (Hyderabad) Shri Oashai Chaudhary (Rosera)

Shri Vellaiah Nandi (Siddipet) Shri Manjai Lal (Samastipu.r)

Shri Saga Reddy. M. (Medak) Shri Nitish Kumar (Barh)

Shri Taduri Bala Goud (Nizamabad) Shri Surya Narayan Singh (Balia)

Shri P. Narasa Reddy (Adilabad) Shri Ramendra Kumar Vadav Rav; (Madhepura) Shri G. Venkat Swamy (Peddapalli) Shri Sukhdeo Paswan (Araria) Shri Chokka Reo Juvvadi (Karim nagar) Shri M.J. Akbar (Kishanganj) Shri Kamaluddin Ahmed (Hanamkonda) Shri Yuvraj (Katihar) Shri Surender Reddy Ramasahayam (Warangal) Shri Janardan Yadav (Godda)

Shri Jalagam Vengal Rao (Khammam) Shri Pratap Singh (Banka)

Shri Chakilam Srinivasa Rao (Nalgonda) Shri Chun Chun Prasad Vadav (Bhagalpur)

Shri B.N. Reddy (Miryalguda) Shri Ram Sharan Yadav (Khagaria)

Shri Arif. Mohd. Khan (Bahraich) Shri Dhanraj Singh (Monghyr)

Shrimati Maneka Gandhi (Pilibhit) Shri Lalit Vijoy Singh (Begusarai)

Shri Prem Khandu Thungon Shri Ram Swaroop Prasad (Nalanda) (Arunachal West) Prof. Shailendra Nath Shrivastava (Patna) 12.00 hrs. Shri Tej Narain Singh (Buxar) Shri Dharmesh Prasad Verma (Bettiah) Shri Chhedi Paswan (Sasaram) Shri Mahendra Baitha (f3agaha) Shri Ramashray Prasad Singh (Jahanabad) Shri Radha Mohan Singh (Motihari) Shri Ram Naresh Singh (Aurangabad) Shri Rajmangal Mishra (Gopalganj) Shri Prem Pradeep (Nawada) Shri Laloo Prasad (Chapra) Shri Ishwar Chaudhary (Gaya) Srimati Usha Singh (Vaishal;) 12.25 hr•• Shri Hukumdeo Narayan Vadav (Sitamarhi)

Shri Devendra Prasad Vadav (Jhanjharpur) [SHAI INDRAJIT GUPTA in the Chair]

Shri Bhogendra Jha (Madhubani) Shri Upendra Nath Verma (Chatra) 53 Members Sworn AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Members Sworn 54

Shri Ritlal Prasad-Verma (Kodarma) Shri Jamod Shashikant Mavjibhai (Bhavnagar) Shri Ram Das Singh (Giridih) Shri Ratilal Kalidas Verma (Dhandh'uka) Shri A.K. Roy (Dhanbad) Shri Harin Pathak (Ahmedabad) Shri Yadunath Pandey (Hazaribagh) Shri Vaghela Shankarji Laxmanji Shri Subodh Kant Sahay (Ranchi) (Gandhinagar)

Shri Begun Sumbrui (Singhbhum) Shri Chavda Khemchandbhai Somabhai (Patan) Shr; Surya Nara;n Yadav (Saharsa) Shri Shah Jayantilal Virchandbhai Shri Karia Munda (Khunti) (Banaskantha)

Shri Jorawar Ram (Palamau) Shri Maganbhai Manibhai Patel (Sabarkantha) Shri Harmohan Dhawan (Chandigarh) Shri Gabhaji Mangaji Thakore (Kapadvanj) Shri Delkar Mohanbhai Sanjibhai (Dadra and Nagar Haveli) Shri Somjibhai Damor (Dohad)

Shri Patel Shantilal Purushottamdas Shri Tandel DevjiJogibhai (Daman and Diu) (Godhra)

Shri Lal Krishna Advani (New Delhi) Shri Patel Nathubhai Manibhai (Arand)

I Shri Madan Lal Khurana (South Delhi) Shri Rathawa Naranbhai Jamlabhai (Chhota Udaipur) Shri Tarif Singh (Outer Delhi) Shri Kokoalias Prakash Kanubhai Shri Jai Prakash Aggarwal (Chandni Chowk) Brahmbhatt (Koko) (Baroda)

Shri Vijay Kumar Malhotra (Delhi Sadar) Shri Deshmukh Chandubha,i Shanabhai (Broach) Shri Kalka Dass (Karo! Bagh) Shri Kashiram Rana (Surat) Shri Gopal Mayekar (P~naji) Shri Gamit Chhitubhai Devji~ai (Mandv;) Shri Shibu Soren (Dumka) Shri Arjunbhai Lalfubhai Patel (Bulsar) Shri Koli Patel Somabhai Gandabhai • (Surendranagar) Shri Babubhai Meghji Shah (Kutcll)

Shri Koradiya Chandreshkumar Valjibhai Shri H.K.L. Bhagat (East Delhi) (Chandresh Patel) (Jamnagar) Shri Taslimudin (Purnea) Shri Vekaria Shivlal Nagjibhai (Rajkot) MR. CHAIRMAN :'Members from those Shr; Manvar Balvantbha; Bachubhai States or UniOf.} terntories from which the (Porbandar) Members hav.& /already been called to take 55 Members Sworn DECEMBER 18. 1989 Members Sworn 56 •• oath or make affirmatIon and who were not Shri Shekhada Govindbhai Kanjibhai (Ju­ present at that time, will be given preference nagadh) now. Hany such Member is here, he can take oath or make afirmation now. Dr. A.K. Patel (Mehsana)

Shri Laeta Umbrey (Arunachal East) Shri Prabhatsinh Hathisinh Chauhan (Kaira)

Shri Ram Prasad Singh (Bikramganj) Shri Ram Prakash (Ambala)

13.00 hrs. Shri Gurdial Singh Saini (Kurukshetra)

SHRIMATI SUMATI ORAON (Lohard­ Shri Chiranji lal (Karnal) aga): Shri Bhajan La' (Faridabad) MR. CHAIRMAN: Hon. Members, now we shall adjourn for lunch and continue the Shri Birender Singh (Mahendragarh) oath-taking after lunch. I would request the hon. Members who have already taken the Shri Bansi Lal (Bhiwani) oath, or made the Affirmation, to make it conventient to be present in the House when Shri Jaj Parkash (Hissar) our other friends take the oath or make the Affirmation. Shri Krishan Outt Suttanpuri (Shimla)

[ Translation] Shri Maheshwar Singh (Mandi)

Now the House is adjourned for lunch till 2.0 Shri Shanta Kumar (Kangra) p.m. Shri Thakur Prem Kumar Dhumal (Hamirpur) 13.01 hrs. Prof. Saif-ud-din Soz (Baramulla) The Lok Sabha then adjOurned for lunch till Fourteen of the Clock Shri Mohammad Shati Bhat (Srinagar)

Shri Piyare lal Handoo (Anantnag)

14.06 hrs. Shri Narsing Rao Suryawanshi (Bidar)

The Lok Sabha reassembled after Lunch Shri R. Ambanna Nayak Dore (Raichur) at six minutes past Fourteen of the Clock Shrimati Basavarajeswari (BeJlary) [SHRI tNDRAJIT GUPTA· in the Chait1 Shri Channaiah Odeyar (Devangere) [English] Shri C.P. Mudalagiriyappa (Chitradurga) MEMBERS SWORN - Contd. Shri G.S. Basavaraj (Tumkur) MR. CHAIRMAN : Secretary-General may cal out the names of the Members who are to take Oath or make Affirmation. Shri Y. Ramakrishna (Kolar)

Shri Ajit Singh (Baghpat) Shri R. GUndu Rao (Bangalore South)

Shrimatl T. Manem"maj (S9cunderabac,). Shri G. Madegowda (Martdya) 57 Members Sworn AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Members Sworn 58

Shri Srikantadatta Narasimharaja Wadiyar Shri Kodikunnil Suresh (Adoor) (Mysore) Shri Thalekunnil Basheer (Chirayinkil) Shri Janardhana Pobjary' (Mangalore) Shri A. Charles (Trivandrum) Shri H.C. Srikantaiah «lias Annaiah I, (Hassan) Shri Chhaviram (Morena)

Shri D.M. Puttegowda (Chikmagalur) Shri Narsingh Rao Dix~ (Bhind)

Shri B. M. Mujahid (Dharwad Sou~h) Shri Shankar Lal (Sagar)

Shri D.K. Naikar (Dharwad North) Kumari Umabharti (Khajuraho)

Shri Sidnal Shanmukhappa Basappa Shri Lokendra Singh (Damoh) (Belgaum) Shri Sukhendra Singh (Satna) Shri B. Shanakaranand (Chikodi) Shri Yamuna Prasad Shastri (Rewa) Shri Patil Subhas Tammannappa (Bagalkot) Shri Jagannath Singh (Sid hi) Shri Gudadinni Basagondappa Kadappa (Bijapur) Shri Larang Sai (Surguja)

Dr. B.G. Jawali (Gulbarga) Shri Nand Kumar Sai (Raigarh)

Shri M. Ramanna Rai (Kasargod) Shri Dilip Singh Judeo (Janjgir)

Shri Mu"ap~ally Ramachandran Shri Resham Lal Jangde (Bilaspur) (Cannanore) Shri Ramesh Bais (Raipur) Shri K. Muraleedharan (Calicut) Shri Vidyacharan Shukla (Mahasamund) Shri G.M. Banatwalla (Ponnani) Shri Arvind Netam (Kanker) Shri A. Vijayaraghavan (Palghat) Shri Mankuram Sodi (Bastar) Shri K.R. Narayanan (Ottapalam) Shri Purushattam Kaushik (Durg) Shri P.A. Antony (Trichur) Shri Dharampal Singh Gupta (Rajnaqdgaon) Prof. Savithri Lakshmanan (Mukundapuram) Shri Prahlad Singh Patel (Seoni) Prof. K.V. Thomas (Ernakulam) Shri Arif Beg (Betul) Shri P.C. Thomas (Muvattuf.)uzha) 15.00 hrs. Shri Ramesh Chennithala (Kottayam)

Shri Palai K.M. Mathew (Jdukki) Shri Sushi! Chandra Verma (Bhopal)

Shri Vekkom Porushothaman (Alleppey) Shri Surajbhanu Shivbhanu Solanki (Ohar) 59 Membsrs Swom DECEMBER 18, 1989 Members Swom 60

Shrirnati Sumitra Mahajan (Indore) Shri Sathe Vas ant Purushottarn (Wardha)

Shri Satya Narayan Jatiya (Ujjain) Shri Uttarnrao Deorao Patil (Yavatrnal)

Shri Dileepsingh Bhuria (Jhabua) Shri Uttarn Rathod (Hingeli)

Dr. laxrninarayan Pandey (Mandsaur) Dr. Kabde Venkatesh Rukhmaji (Nanded)

Shri Madhavrao Scindia (Gwalior) Shri Deshmukh Ashok Anandrao (Parbhani)

Shri Govindrao Nikam (Ratnagiri) Shri Pundlik Hari Danwe (Jalna)

Shri Vamanrao Mahadik (Bombay South Shri Moreshwar Save (Aurangabad) Central) Shri Dhakane Babanrao Dadaba (Beed) Shrimati Jayawanti Navinchandra Mehta (Bombay North East) Shri Patil Shivraj Vishwanath (Latur)

Shri Ram Naik (Bombay North) Shri Kamble Arvind Tulshiram (Osmanabad) Shri Kapse Ramchandra Ganesh (Thane) Shri Sadul Dharmanna Mondayya (SoJapur) Dr. Aher Oaulat Sonuji (Nashik) Shri Vikhe Ekanathrao Vitthalrao Shri Mahala Haribhau Shankar (Malegaon) (Kopargaon)

Shri Bhoye Reshma Motiram (Ohule) Shri BankhoJe Kisanrao Baburao (Khed)

Shri Gavit Manikrao Hodlya (Nandurbar) Shri Patil Shankarrao Bajirao (Baramati)

15.14 hrs. Shri Bhosale Prataprao Baburao (Satara)

[MR. SPEAKER in the Chair] Shri Patil Prakashbapu Vasantrao (Sangli)

Shri Mahajan Yadav Shivram (Jalgaon) Shri Mane Balaso alias Rajaram Shankarrao (Ichalkaranji) Shri Kale Sukhdeo Nandaji (Buldhana) Shri Gaikwad Udaysingrao Nanasaheb Shri Phundkar Pandurang Pur.dlik (Akola) (Kolhapur)

Shri Deshmukh Anantrao Vitthalrao Shri Het Ram (Sirsa) (Washim) Shri T.V. Chandrashekarappa (Shimoga) Shri Sudam Deshmukh (Amravati) Shri G. Devaraya Naik (Kanara) Shri P. V. Narasimha Rao (Ramtek) Shri S. Krishnakumar (Quilon) Or. Khushal Parasaram Bopche (Bhandara) Shri Baburao Paranjpe (Jabalpur) Shri Shiwankar Mahadeorao Sukaji (Chimur) Shri Sartaj Singh (Hoshangabad) Shri Potdukhe Shantaram Rajeshwar (Chandrapur) Shri Rabhavji (Vidisha) 61 Members Sworn AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Members Swom 62

S-hri Pyarelal Khandelwal (Rajgarh) Shri Bhakta Charan Das (Kalahandi)

Shri Phoolchand Verma (Shajapur) Shri Nakul Nayak (Phulbani)

Shri Amratlal Tarwala (Khandwa) Shri 8algopal Mishra (80langir) (Manni Bhai)

Shri Murli Deora (Bombay South) Shri Bhawani Shankar Hota (Sambalpur)

Shri Rameshwar Patidar (Khargone) Shri Ravinarayan Pani (Deogarh)

Shri Vidyadhar Sambhaji Gokhle (Bombay Shri Bhajaman Behera (Ohenkanal) North Central) Shri Debananda Arnat (Sundargarh) Shri Sunil Outt (Bombay North West) 16.00 hrs. Shrimati Chavan Premlabi Dajisaheb (Karad) Shri Govinda Chandra Munda (Keonjhar) Shri N. Tombi Singh (Inner Manipur) Shrimati Sukhbans Kaur (Gurdaspur) Prof. Meijinlung Kamson (Outer Manipur) Shi Kirpal Singh (Arnritsar) Shri Peter. G. Marbaniang (Shillong) Shri Harbhajan Lakha (Philtaur) Shri Sanford Marak (Tura) Shri Bega Ram (Ganganagar) Dr. C. Silvera (Mizoram) Shri Shopat Singh Makkasar (Bikaner) Shri Shikiho Sewa (Nagaland) Shri Daulat Ram Saran (Churu) Shri Bhagey Gobardhan (Mayurbhanj) Shri Jagdeep Dhankhar (Jhunjhunu) Shri Samarendra Kundu (Balasore) Shri Nathu Singh (Dausa) Shri Mangaraj Mallik (Bhadrak) Shri Ramjilal Yadav (Alwar) Shri Anadi Charan Das (Jaipur) Shri Vishwandra Singh (Bharatpur)

Shri Rabi Ray (Kendrapara) Shri Than Singh Jatav (Sayana)

Shri Srikanta Jena (Cuttack) Shri Kirodi Lal (Sawai Madhopur)

Shri Lokenath Choudhury (Jagatsinghpur) Shri Rasa Singh (Ajmer)

Shri Shivaji Patnaik (Bhubaneswar) Shri Gcpal Pacherwal (Tonk) Shri Dau Dayal Joshi (Kota) Shri Ananta Narayan Singh Dec (Aska) Shrimati Vasundhara Rajey (Jhalawar) Shri Gopinath Gajapathi Narayan Dec (Berhampur) Shri Heera Bhai (Banswara)

Shri Khagapati Pradhani (Nowrangpur) Shri Nandlal Meena (Salumber) 63 Members Sworn DECEMBER 18, 1989 Members Sworn 64

Shri Gulab Chand Kataria (Udaipur) Shri Rangarajan KumaramangaJam (Salem)

Shri Mahendra Singh (Chittorgarh) Shri K.C. Palanisamy (Tiruchengode)

Shri Hemendra Singh (Bhilwara) Shri P.G. Narayanan (Gobichettipalayam)

Shri Gumanmal Lodha (Pali) Shri B. Raja Ravi Varma (Pollachi)

Shr~Kailash Meghwal (Jalore) Shri C. Srinivasan (Oindigul)

Shri Kalyan Singh Kalvi (Barmer) Shri A.G.S. Rambabu (Madurai)

16.19 hrs. Shri R. Mauthaiah (Periyakulam)

[SHRI IBRAHIM SULAIMAN SAlT in the Shri M. Thambi Durai (Karur) Chair] Shri L. Adaikalaraj (Tiruchirapalli) Shri Dharam Pal (Udhampur) Shri A Ashokaraj (Perambaluar) Shri Janak Raj Gupta (Jammu) Shri E.S.M. Pakeer Mohammed Hajee Shri AR. Antulay (Kulaba) (Mayiladuturai)

Shri V.N. Gadgil (Pune) Shri M. Selvarasu (Nagapattinam)

Shri Parasram Bhardwaj (Sarangarh) Shri S. Singaravadivel (Thanjavur)

Shri D. Pandian (Madras North) Shri N. Sundararaj (Pudukkottai)

Shri Era Anbarasu (Madras Central) Shri V. Rajeswharan (Ramanathapuram)

Shrimati Maragatham Chandrasekhar Dr. K. Kalimuthu (Sivakasi) (Sriperumbudur) Shri M.R. Janarthanan (Tirunelveli) Shri Kanche PaneerChelvam (Chengalpattu) Shri M. Arunachalam (Tenkasi) Shri R. Jeevarathinam (Arakkonam) . MR. CHArRMAN: Any addition to the Shri A.K.A. Abdul Samad (Vellore) oath will not go on record.

Shri AJayamohan (Tiruppattur) Shri R. Dhanuskodi Athithan (Tiruchendur)

Shri L. Balaraman (Vandavasi) Shri N. Dennis (Nagarcoil)

Shri R. Eramadass (Tindivanam) Shri C.K. Kuppuswamy (Coimbatore)

Shri P.R.S. Vankatesan (Cuddalore) Shri Santosh Mohan Dev (Tripura West)

Dr. P. Vallalperuman (Chidambaram) Maharaja Manikya Kirit Bikram Kishore Deb Barma Bahadur (Tripura East) Shri M.G. Sekhar (Dharmapuri)

Shri K. Ramamurthy (Krishnagiri) Shri Chandra Mohan (Garhwal) 65 Members Sworn AGRAHAYANA 27,1911 (SAKA) Members Sworn 66

Shri Mahendra Singh Pal (Naini Tal) Shri Ram Dhan (Lalganj)

Kumari Mayawati (Bijnor) Shri Shea Sharan (Machhlishahr)

Snri Zulfiqar Ali Khan (Rampur) Raja Yadvendra Datt (Janunpur) sh~i Raj Veer Singh (Aonla) Shri Ramsagar (Saidpur)

Shri Santosh Kumar Gangwar (Bareilly) Shri Jagdish (Ghazipur) Shrimati Usha Verma (Kheri) Shri Kailash Nath Singh Yadav (ChandauU) Shri Dharmgaj Singh (Shahabad) Shri Suladar (Robertsganj) Dr. Rajendra Kumari 8ajpai (Sitapur) Shri Ram Pujan Patel (Phulpur) Shri Ramlal Rahi (Misrikh)

Shri Mandhata Singh (Lucknow)

Shri Sarju Prasad 'Saroj' (Mohanlalganj) [ Translation] Shrimati Sheila Kaul (Rae Bareli) SHRI (Ghosi): Madam Shri Anwar Ahmad (Unnao) Chairman, on a point of order, Swearing-m­ Ceremony is on but there is no Minister of the Shri Dinesh Singh (Pratapgarh) Cabinet present here in the House.

Shri Ram Sagar (Bara Banki) SHRI MANVENDRA SINGH (Mathura): The Ministers of State are present here. 17.05 hr•. SHRI KALPNA TH RAI: Why there is no [SHRIMATI VIJAYA RAJE SCaNDIA in the Cabinet Minister present here (Interruptions) Chair] SHRI MANVENDRA SINGH: You Shri Rudra Sen Chaudhary (Kaiserganj) should not raise such things.

Shri Anand Singh alias Annu Bhaiya (Gonda) ( Interruptions) Shri Kalpa Nath Somkar (Basti)

Shri Brij Bhusan TIWari (Domariaganj) SHRI KAlPNATH RAI: Swanng-in­ Ceremony ;s on and there is no Minister of Shri Ram Prasad Chaudhary (Khalilabad) Cabinet rank present here. (Interruptions) Madam, you should direa a Minister of the Shri Mahabir Prasad (Bansgaon) Cabinet rank to be present here. This is a question of the cfegnity of the House. Shri Baleshar (Bateshwar) (Padrauna) MR. CHAIRMAN: They had soughtthe Shri Raj Mangal (Deoria) permission and the Chair grante(f'1he same. When they have been given permission ... Shri Kalp Nath (Ghosi) SHRI KAlPNATH RAI: Have aU the Shri Ram Krishna (Azamgarh) Ministe~ t_en permission? 67 Members Sworn DECEMBER 18. 1989 Members Swom 68

[English] Shri Ch~otey Singh Yadav (Kannauj)

SHRt Shri Mahadeepak Singh (Etah) (Bolpur): This is you constructive opposi- tionl Shri Manvendra Singh (Mathura)

[Tnms/ation] Dr. Bengali Singh (Hathras)

MR.CHAIAMAN: When they have been Shri Amar Roy Pradhan (Cooch Behar) granted permission, the ceremony may continue in their absence. Shri Piyus Tiraky (Alipurduars)

SHRI KAlPNATH RAI: This is not Shri Manik Sanyal () proper. This is against the dignity of the House. Swearing-in-Ceremony is taking Shri Golam Yazdani (Raiganj) place in the House. (Interruptions) Shri Abedin Zainal (Jangipur) MR. CHAIRMAN: Order ptease. Shri MasudaJ Hossain Syed (Murshidabad) SHRI MANVENDRA SINGH: Madam Chairman, when you have given your miling Shri Nani Bhattacharya (Berhampore) ... ( Interruptions) Shri (Krishnagar)

MR. CHAIRMAN: Now, you take your Shri Asim Bala (Nabadwip) seat and tet me speak. When the Chair has given permission, proceedings may go on Shri San at Kumar Mondal (Joy nagar) even in the absence of a Minister. If you want them to be present here, you may send them Shri Radhikaranjan Pramanik (Mathurapur) a word and call them here. There no use in making fuss over it. The-precious time of the Shri Amal Datta (Diamond Harbour) House is being wasted. I would like to re- quest you to keep quiet as it is of no use of Shrimati Malini Bhattacharya (Jadavpur) create fuss over such a petty issue. Shri Tarit Barn Topder (Barrackpore) [English] Shri Nirmal Kanti Chatterjee (Dum Dum) SHRI SONTHOSH MOHAN DEV (Tripura West): Madam, please continue. Shri Debi Prasad Pal (Calcutta North West) We accept your ruling. Shri Ajit Kumar Panja (Calcutta North East)

Shri Biplab Dasgupta (Calcutta South) MEMBERSSWORN----CONTD Shri Sushanta Chakrabortty (Howrah) (Eng/ish) Shri Hannan Mollah (Uluberia) Shri Janeshwar Mishra (Allahabad) Shri Sudarsan Raychoudhuri (Serampore) Shri Ram Nihor Rakesh (Chait) Shri Rupchand Pal (Hooghly) Shri Keshari Lal (Ghatampur) Shri Ani! Basu (Arambagh) 69' MernI»rs Sworn AGRAHAYANA 27, 1911 (SAKA) Members Swom 70

Shri Satyagopal Misra (Tamluk) Shri R. Prabhu (Nilgiris)

Shri Sudhir Giri (Contai) Smt. Vyjayanthimala Bali (Madras South)

Shri MaUlal Hansda (Jhargram) Shri Jagpal Singh (Hardwar)

Shri Chitta Ranjan Mahata (Purulia) Shri Udai Pratap Singh (Mainpuri)

Shri (Bankura) Shri Ram Singh Shakya (Etawah)

Shri Khan Sukhendu (Vishnupur) Shri Sudhir Roy (Burdwan)

Shri Haradhan Roy (Asansol) Shri Patil Uttamrao Laxmanrao (Erandol)

Shri Saifuddin Chowdhury (Katwa) Shri Ghulam Mohammad Khan Haji (Moradabad) Shri Somnath Chatterjee (Bolpur) Shri B. Devarajan (Rasipuram) Shri Dome Ramchandra (Birbhum) Shri Mohd. Hassan Commander (Ladakh) Shri Chitta Basu (Barasat) MR. CHAIRMAN: Now the House Shri P. Shanmugam (Pondicherry) stands adjourned to meet tomorrow at 11 AM. Shri P.M. Sayed (Lakashadweep)

Shri V. Krishna Rae (Chikballapur) 17.57 hrs.

Shri Basavaraj Patil (Koppal) The Lok Sabha then adjoumed till Eleven of the Clock on TU9sday, D9Cember 19. Shri V. Srinivasa Prasad (Chamarajanagar) 1989/Agrahayana 28, 1911 (Saka)

Printed at : S. Narayan & Sons. Delhi-11 0006