The Effect of Perpetual Usufruct on Single-Family Houses in Poznań
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Trojanek, R., Tanaś, J., & Trojanek, M. (2019). The effect of perpetual usufruct on Journal single-family house prices in Poznań. Journal of International Studies, 12(3), 212-221. of International doi:10.14254/2071-8330.2019/12-3/17 Studies © Foundation The effect of perpetual usufruct on single- of International Studies, 2019 family house prices in Poznań © CSR, 2019 Papers Scientific Radosław Trojanek Poznań University of Economics and Business, Poznań, Poland [email protected] Justyna Tanaś University of Gdańsk, Gdańsk, Poland [email protected] Maria Trojanek WSB University in Poznań, Poznań, Poland [email protected] Abstract. The paper explores the influence of the perpetual usufruct (a form of Received: March, 2019 owning the ground similar to a long-term lease in Poland) on house prices in 1st Revision: Poznań. The research is based on a data set of 1074 geo-coded single-family May, 2019 houses transactions for the years 2010 to 2015. In this research, the hedonic Accepted: September, 2019 method was used in Ordinary Least Squares (OLS), Weighted Least Squares (WLS) and Median Quantile Regression (Median QR) models. We found DOI: substantial evidence that single-family houses constructed on perpetual usufruct 10.14254/2071- lots are discounted on average at 4.1%. 8330.2019/12-3/17 Keywords: ground lease, perpetual usufruct, house prices. JEL Classification: R31 1. INTRODUCTION Ground leases are a policy instrument the purpose of which is to a time-limited division of the bundle of rights between a public landowner and the ground leaseholder, who becomes the owner of the facilities on the land for a defined time (Gerber, Nahrath, & Hartmann, 2017; Löhr, 2017). Ground leases are often used for retail, office, and industrial developments in the U.S. and many other countries (M. Trojanek, Anholcer, Banaitis, & Trojanek, 2018). In addition, the construction of privately-owned housing on leased public land as a way of implementing land use policy is typical in a number of countries and specific cities (Głuszak, 2008). Perpetual usufruct is one of the forms of management of the public real estate. In the Polish legal system, perpetual usufruct was legally regulated in 1961 when state ownership was the dominant form of ownership. This right was intended by the legislature to regulate the relations of ownership between the 212 Radosław Trojanek, Justyna Tanaś, The effect of perpetual usufruct on single-family Maria Trojanek house prices in Poznań state and private sector entities. Current perpetual usufruct regulations differ significantly from those introduced in 1961 by the Law on Land Economy in Cities and Settlements (Sejm Rzyczypospolitej Polskiej, 1961; Truszkiewicz, 2006). Besides, despite the dwindling presence of the political reasons for the introduction of this right, perpetual usufruct continues to play a crucial role in the real estate rights system and affects various aspects of social and economic life. However, as the right can now be legally converted, its scope has steadily diminished since 19971; and in 2018, the right of perpetual usufruct of the land developed for housing purposes was converted ex officio into the property right (art. 1, par. 1 of the Act of 20 July 2018 on the Conversion of the Right of Perpetual Usufruct of Developed Land for Housing Purposes – the Journal of Laws 2018, item 1716). The right of perpetual usufruct of land played a considerable role in the process of the system transformation of the economy and the state administration (the process of enfranchising state legal persons). The right of perpetual usufruct of land as a housing policy instrument provided investors (private individuals and housing cooperatives) with land on favourable terms. The perpetual usufructuary is charged an initial and annual fees for transferring land property into perpetual usufruct. The amounts charged depend on the development purpose of the transferred property. In the case of land property transferred for housing purposes, the initial amount is 15% and the annual fees are 1% of the property value. The amount of the annual fees for perpetual usufruct is regularly updated, but no more often than once in every three years, on condition that the property has risen in value. The right of perpetual usufruct of land shares the same attributes with the property right (it is a transferable, portable and hereditary). However, some other attributes of this right (as shown in Table 1) make this right less favourable/less effective than the property right. Hence, the following question: how does the property market value those two rights? Are the prices of houses built on the land transferred for perpetual usufruct any lower, and if so – how much, than those of the houses developed on the land that belongs to the investor? The right of perpetual usufruct of land is the right to property owned by others (land that belongs to the State Treasury, local governments and their units) that provides the perpetual usufructuary (natural persons or individual persons) with powers similar to those of the property right. The right in question, like the property right, is a transferable right (which means it can be sold), portable (which means it can be used to make in-kind shares), and hereditary (which means it can be used to make donations or heritage). However, the property right and the right of perpetual usufruct of land share a number of noticeable differences which concern: - the duration of those rights. The right of perpetual usufruct of land is a temporary right with land being provided for 40 or 99 years, or extended, optionally, - the property of the buildings and structures founded on the land, - the possibility to extend the duration of the right, - the way of financial settlements of the buildings or structures founded on the land, - bearing the fees for land use, - the rules for calculating the fees for land use, - the possibility to terminate the agreement early, - the subject of turnover, - the subject of right. A comparison of those rights is presented in Table 1. 1 Cf. the Act of 4 September on the conversion of the perpetual usufruct available to natural persons into the property right (the Journal of Laws 1997, No. 123, item 78). 213 Journal of International Studies Vol.12, No.3, 2019 Table 1 Comparison of the perpetual usufruct of land and the property right The attributes of the rights Perpetual usufruct of land (PUL) The property right 1. Subject of right The subject of PUL is land only. The The subject of property right is buildings and structures founded on land along with the buildings and the land are sole property of the structures founded on it perpetual usufructuary (they are of building property status) 2. The land and the buildings The land – the property of the State The land and the buildings and and structures founded on it Treasury and local government units structures founded on it as the component part of the property constitute the component part of the land 3. The duration of the right 40 or 99 years, depending on the Without time limitations purpose 4. Possibility to be extended For 40 or 99 years It is a right of unlimited duration 5. The way of settling the The amount of remuneration ought They are a component part of the investment outlays relating to to reflect the market value of those land and belong to the person the buildings or other buildings and structures on the date who has the right to the land structures developed or of the PUL expiration acquired by the perpetual usufructuary 6. Determining the way of The agreement on transferring the The owner can use the land under using the land within the land into perpetual usufruct the rules set out in acts and the duration of the right determines the way and date limit of principles of social coexistence its development, including the date limit of its development following the purpose for which the land was transferred 7. The fees charged The amount of fees depends on the Not applicable initial fee purpose for which the property was annual fees developed 8. Rules for calculating fees The amount of the initial fee is 15% Not applicable to 25% of the land property price; The amount of annual fees, depending on the purpose, varies between 0.3% to 3% of the price. This fee can be updated every 3 years or less often, on condition that the property value has increased 9. The possibility to terminate if the perpetual usufractuary Not applicable the agreement prior to the misuses the property by violating date set out in the agreement the terms of the agreement if the perpetual usufractuary fails to develop the land within the date limit detailed out in the agreement 10. The right to use the land and transferable transferable the buildings and structures portable portable founded on it hereditary hereditary 11. The subject of turnover The subject of the transaction is the The subject of the transaction is right of perpetual usufruct and the the property right to the land and property right to buildings and the buildings and structures structures (building property) founded on it 214 Radosław Trojanek, Justyna Tanaś, The effect of perpetual usufruct on single-family Maria Trojanek house prices in Poznań 12. The subject of right The subject of PUL is land only. The The subject of the property right buildings and structures founded on is the land along with the buildings the land are property of the perpetual and structures founded on it usufructuary (they enjoy the building property status) Source: own elaboration. 2. LITERATURE REVIEW There is an extensive body of literature investigating characteristics influencing the real estate prices.