Looking Upstream: an Analysis of Low Water Levels in Lake Powell And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Colorado Law School Colorado Law Scholarly Commons Getches-Wilkinson Center for Natural Books, Reports, and Studies Resources, Energy, and the Environment 2016 Looking Upstream: An Analysis of Low Water Levels in Lake Powell and the Impacts on Water Supply, Hydropower, Recreation, and the Environment: A Companion Report to The Bathtub Ring Michael Johnson Lindsey Ratcliff Rebecca Shively Leanne Weiss Yale University. School of Forestry and Environmental Studies See next page for additional authors Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.law.colorado.edu/books_reports_studies Part of the Environmental Policy Commons, Natural Resources and Conservation Commons, Natural Resources Management and Policy Commons, Public Policy Commons, Water Law Commons, and the Water Resource Management Commons Citation Information Michael Johnson, Lindsey Ratcliff, Rebecca Shively, Leanne Weiss & Western Water Policy Program, Looking Upstream: An Analysis of Low Water Levels in Lake Powell and the Impacts on Water Supply, Hydropower, Recreation, and the Environment: A Companion Report to The Bathtub Ring (Getches- Wilkinson Ctr. for Nat. Res., Energy, & the Env't, Univ. of Colo. Law Sch. 2016). Authors Michael Johnson; Lindsey Ratcliff; Rebecca Shively; Leanne Weiss; Yale University. School of Forestry and Environmental Studies; University of Colorado Boulder. Getches-Wilkinson Center for Natural Resources, Energy, and the Environment; and Western Water Policy Program This book is available at Colorado Law Scholarly Commons: https://scholar.law.colorado.edu/books_reports_studies/ 169 MICHAEL JOHNSON, LINDSEY RATCLIFF, REBECCA SHIVELY, LEANNE WEISS & WESTERN WATER POLICY PROGRAM, LOOKING UPSTREAM: ANALYSIS OF LOW WATER LEVELS IN LAKE POWELL AND THE IMPACTS ON WATER SUPPLY, HYDROPOWER, RECREATION, AND THE ENVIRONMENT: A COMPANION REPORT TO THE BATHTUB RING (Getches-Wilkinson Ctr. for Nat. Res., Energy & the Env’t, Univ. of Colo. Law Sch. 2016). Reproduced with permission of the Getches-Wilkinson Center for Natural Resources, Energy, and the Environment (formerly the Natural Resources Law Center) at the University of Colorado Law School. Looking Upstream: Analysis of Low Water Levels in Lake Powell and the Impacts on Water Supply, Hydropower, Recreation, and the Environment A Companion Report to The Bathtub Ring: Implications of Low Water Levels in Lake Mead on Water Supply, Hydropower, Recreation, and the Environment Michael Johnson | Lindsey Ratcliff | Rebecca Shively| Leanne Weiss Yale School of Forestry & Environmental Studies Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut Faculty Advisor Brad Gentry, Associate Dean Yale School of Forestry & Environmental Studies External Advisors Eric Kuhn | Season Martin Client Douglas Kenney | Western Water Policy Program 1 | LOOKING UPSTREAM Disclaimer This report was prepared on behalf of the Western Water Policy Program of the Getches-Wilkinson Center at the University of Colorado Law School by four master's students at the Yale School of Forestry & Environmental Studies. All research, analysis, views, opinions and recommendations are those solely of the authors and do not state or reflect those of any of the entities consulted including: Colorado River Conservation District Glen Canyon National Recreation Area Interstate Streams Division, Wyoming State Engineer’s Office National Park Service Intermountain Regional Office The Nature Conservancy New Mexico Office of the State Engineer, Interstate Stream Commission United States Bureau of Reclamation Utah Division of Water Resources Western Area Power Administration All photos, illustrations, figures and tables are those of the authors or in the public domain unless otherwise cited. i | LOOKING UPSTREAM Acknowledgements This project would not have been possible without the generous assistance of many individuals. Our grateful recognition goes to our client Doug Kenney for agreement to work with us, his knowledge of the Colorado River Basin and guidance on this project. Additionally, our faculty advisor Brad Gentry lent wisdom and support that helped push this project forward. Eric Kuhn gave critical guidance as we began to understand the complexity of the Colorado River system. Season Martin provided first hand knowledge as a co-author to The Bathtub Ring to help us produce this companion study. Leah Michaelsen shared her masterful graphic design skills in the creation of the executive summary. In addition to our advisors, we had significant assistance from many professionals across the Colorado River Basin. We’d like to thank the following individuals for their time, patience, expertise, and feedback on our analysis: Colorado River District Eric Kuhn Colorado River Energy Leslie James Distributers Association Chris Cook Carl Elleard Glen Canyon National Recreation Area Rosemary Sucec Teri Tucker National Park Service Rob Billerbeck Intermountain Region Jennifer Rebenack Season Martin The Nature Conservancy Robert Wigington New Mexico Office of the State Kristin Green Engineer, Interstate Stream Commission Kevin Flanigan United States Bureau of Reclamation Ken Nowak University of Montana Christopher Neher Utah Division of Water Resources Eric Mills Public Utilities Western Area Power Administration Specialists from the CRSP Office Wyoming State Engineers Office, Beth Ross Interstate Streams Division Steve Wolff Yale School of Forestry and Mathew Shultz Environmental Studies Yale School of Management Kolin Loveless Yale Statistics Lab Henry Glick ii | LOOKING UPSTREAM Table of Contents Disclaimer ............................................................................................................................................. i Acknowledgements .............................................................................................................................. ii Table of Contents ................................................................................................................................ iii List of Tables ........................................................................................................................................ v List of Figures ..................................................................................................................................... vii Project Significance .............................................................................................................................. 1 Project Objectives ................................................................................................................................ 5 Water Supply .................................................................................................................................... 5 Hydropower ..................................................................................................................................... 5 Recreation ........................................................................................................................................ 6 Environment ..................................................................................................................................... 6 Background Information ....................................................................................................................... 7 Upper Colorado River Basin Governance .......................................................................................... 7 Long-Range Operating Criteria ............................................................................................................. 9 Colorado River Interim Guidelines for Lower Basin Shortages ............................................................ 9 Water Supply ..................................................................................................................................... 13 Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 13 Methods ......................................................................................................................................... 15 Hydrologic Factors .......................................................................................................................... 15 Upper Basin Water Use ................................................................................................................... 19 Historical Water Demands ................................................................................................................. 19 State Profiles .................................................................................................................................. 24 Colorado ............................................................................................................................................. 24 Wyoming ............................................................................................................................................ 27 Utah .................................................................................................................................................... 30 New Mexico ........................................................................................................................................ 33 Future Water Demands .................................................................................................................. 36 Legal Factors ..................................................................................................................................