ISRAEL JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICS 169 (2009), 417–444 DOI: 10.1007/s11856-009-0017-x ELLIPTIC CURVES OF ODD MODULAR DEGREE BY Frank Calegari∗ and Matthew Emerton∗∗ Northwestern University, Department of Mathematics 2033 Sheridan Rd. Evanston, IL 60208 United States e-mail:
[email protected],
[email protected] ABSTRACT The modular degree mE of an elliptic curve E/Q is the minimal degree of any surjective morphism X0(N) E, where N is the conductor of E. → We give a necessary set of criteria for mE to be odd. In the case when N is prime our results imply a conjecture of Mark Watkins. As a technical tool, we prove a certain multiplicity one result at the prime p = 2, which may be of independent interest. 1. Introduction Let E be an elliptic curve over Q of conductor N. Since E is modular [3], there exists a surjective map π : X (N) E defined over Q. There is a unique such 0 → map of minimal degree (up to composing with automorphisms of E), and its degree mE is known as the modular degree of E. This degree has been much studied, both in relation to congruences between modular forms [38] and to the Selmer group of the symmetric square of E [14], [15], [35]. Since this Selmer ∗ Supported in part by the American Institute of Mathematics. ∗∗ Supported in part by NSF grant DMS-0401545. Receved August 11, 2006 and in revised form June 28, 2007 417 418 FRANKCALEGARIANDMATTHEWEMERTON Isr. J.Math. group can be considered as an elliptic analogue of the class group, one might expect in analogy with genus theory to find that mE satisfies certain divisibility properties, especially, perhaps, by the prime 2.