SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 238.1 Sarah Buist Support in Considers that the number of heritage buildings and items Add significant heritage buildings, including houses, to and Items part in SCHED1 should be increased to include all significant SCHED1. heritage buildings district wide as a first step to prevent further loss of the character of our district. This includes houses. It is preferable to retain them in their entirety but retaining the facade would be preferable to demolition especially in the CBD's of towns. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.100 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add New Plymouth Technical School Technical Engineering and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Building (Former) (99 Liardet Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.101 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Overdale (1/130‐6/130 Carrington Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.102 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Pahitere Blockhouse (Former) (16 Koru Road, Ōākura) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.103 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Parsons Cool Store (5 Hakirau Street, New Plymouth) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.104 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Pukekura Park Superintendents' Residence (Former) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. (25 Victoria Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.105 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Pukekura Park Ticket Boxes (2) (Pukekura Park Sports and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Ground, Liardet Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.106 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Pukekura Park Victoria Road Entrance Gates (Victoria and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Road/Pukekura Park, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.107 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Queen Street Takeaways (34 Queen Street, Waitara) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.108 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Rahui Boarding House/Seaspray House (Former) (13 and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Weymouth Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.109 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Regina Place/Victoria Esplanade Retaining Wall (Regina and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Place, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.110 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Reid Residence/Mulberry Cottage (139 Powderham and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.111 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Rennell's Villa (46 Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.112 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Reo Moana Flats (10 Weymouth Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.113 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Rev. Drew's Villa (Former) (7 Pendarves Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.114 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Robertson Residence (Former) (14 Wakefield Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.115 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Soffe House (99 Inland North Road, Tikorangi) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.116 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Retaining Wall and Wrought Iron Fence (11 Vivian and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1.

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1337 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.117 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add T. S. Weston Residence (Former) (26 Weymouth and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.118 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Taranaki Producers' Freezing Works Butter Store (5 and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Hakirau Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.119 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Taranaki Producers' Freezing Works Produce Store (5 and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Hakirau Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.120 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Taranaki Producers' Freezing Works Engine Room (5 and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Hakirau Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.121 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add 'Tea‐pot' Roberts Store (Former) (70 Eliot Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.122 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Thomas Sole's Cottage No. 1 (251 Courtenay Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.123 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Thomas Sole's Cottage No. 2 (253 Courtenay Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.124 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Tiromoana (68 Whiteley Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.125 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Taranaki Jockey Club Caretakers Residence (Former) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. (130 Coronation Avenue, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.126 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Taranaki Jockey Club Sand Roll (131 Coronation and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Avenue, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.127 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Urenui Post Office (Former) (24 Ngakoti Street, Urenui) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.128 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add W. J. Shaw Residence (Former) (3 Rogan Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.129 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Waitara Lock‐Up (1875) (Memorial Place, Waitara) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.130 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Waitara Lock‐Up (1911) (Memorial Place, Waitara) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.131 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Waldyve King Residence (Former) (30 Brooklands Park and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Drive, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.132 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Walker's Workers' Dwelling (23 Paynters Avenue, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.133 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Wareham‐Morris Homestead (Former) (976 South and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Road, Ōākura) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.134 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add White's Workers' Dwelling (29 Paynters Avenue, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.135 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Woon House (149 Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.44 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that under SCHED1: Research and list further heritage buildings and items and Items Bruce ● Protecng 143 sites, mostly within the CBD, is too few district wide. and far from representative across the district. The submitter has prepared more than 90 draft heritage ● NPDC has been pragmac with its budget and assessments (see attachments to submission) covering a concentrated new listings in the CBD, largely ignoring the diverse range of buildings and structures from across the smaller centres meaning that buildings outside of the CBD district, which they consider should be treated as a

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1338 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No will more likely be lost and may not have access to funding representative sample of a much larger group of sources. unprotected items deserving protection. These ● Despite an increase in listed buildings (formerly A), the assessments are dealt with as individual submission points. delisting of hundreds of B and C's amounts to a loss of public visibility and increases the likelihood that they will be lost. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.45 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add 1 Hau Lane, Ōākura to SCHED1. and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.46 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add 25 Standish Street, New Plymouth to SCHED1. and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.47 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add 240 Devon Street West, New Plymouth to SCHED1. and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.48 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add 242 Devon Street West, New Plymouth to SCHED1. and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.49 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add 294 Devon Street West, New Plymouth to SCHED1. and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.50 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Airlie House (161 Powderham Street, New Plymouth) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.51 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Alsop's Workers' Dwelling (25 Paynters Avenue, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.52 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Ambury Residence (Former) (98 Liardet Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.53 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Amoore Residence (Former) (25 Vivian Street/73 and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Brougham Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.54 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Arnold's Cottage No. 1 (129 Lemon Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.55 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Arnold's Cottage No. 2 (31 Lemon Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.56 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Barron's Cottage (4 Hempton Street, New Plymouth) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.57 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Bridger Residence (Former) (96 Lemon Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.58 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Captain Rogers Cottage No. 3 (75 Eliot Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.59 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Captain Rogers Residence/Scrimgeour's Store (Former) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. (77 Eliot Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.60 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Carr Residence (17 Barrett Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.61 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Carrington Street Horse Trough (Lower Carrington and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.62 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Cassell's Cottage (99 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.63 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Charteris' Workers' Dwelling (27 Paynters Avenue, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1.

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1339 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.64 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Chew Chong's Villa (Former) (272 Courtenay Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.65 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add David Teed Residence (Former) (12 Weymouth Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.66 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Davie House (19 Robe Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.67 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Douglass Residence (Former) (51 Dawson Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.68 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add F T Bellringer Residence (Former) (363 Devon Street and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. East, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.69 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add First Church of Christ, Scientist (81 Courtenay Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.70 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Fitzroy Post Office (Former) (512 Devon Street East, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.71 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Frankley Road School (Former) (419 Frankley Road, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.72 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Frankley Road School Teachers' Residence (Former) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. (407 Frankley Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.73 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Hall‐McCaul House (181 Kairau Road East, Brixton) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.74 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Harlin's Cottage (63 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.75 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Heard Residence (Former) (23 Hine Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.76 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Hinemoa Private Maternity Hospital (Former) (240 and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.77 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Inglewood BNZ (Former) (22 Matai Street, Inglewood) and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.78 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Inglewood Railway Hotel (Former) (23 Rata Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Inglewood) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.79 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Issey Manor (32 Carrington Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.80 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Kebbell‐Quilliam Residence (Former) (59 Vivian Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.81 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Kerr Residence (Former) (84 Brougham Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.82 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Kibby's Cottage (15 Clemow Road, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.83 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Kincora Private Maternity Home (Former) (23 Mt and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Edgecumbe Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.84 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Knox Church and Hall (Former) (27 Cutfield Street, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Inglewood) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.85 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add L. A. Nolan Hide Store (15 Liardet Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1.

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1340 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.86 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Lacey's Cottage (94 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.87 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Langman's Cottage (105 Molesworth Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.88 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Lawson's Cottage No. 2 (92 Lemon Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.89 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Llantwit Cottage (35 Gilbert Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.90 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Lock's Cottage (23 Standish Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.91 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Lomas Residence (Former) (83 Brougham Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.92 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Mannix Villa (Former) (284 Devon Street West, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.93 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add McAllum Residence (Former) and Retaining Wall (17 and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.94 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Messenger House (219 Gill Street, New Plymouth) to and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.95 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Miss Lane's Cottage (105 Pendarves Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.96 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Morley Street Tram Shelter (NPDC Road Reserve, and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Morley Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.97 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Mrs Cooper's Cottage (49 Gilbert Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.98 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add Neal Residence (Former) (162 St Aubyn Street, New and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.99 Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be Add New Plymouth Railway Bridges (Pari, Eliot, Hobson and and Items Bruce listed in SCHED1. Devon Street East, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 317.5 Hamish Crimp Support in Supports the listing of all 143 heritage items in SCHED1, Retain 143 heritage items in SCHED1 as notified [inferred]. and Items part with heritage buildings and structures being important, Add significantly more heritage items to SCHED1, tangible links to our district's rich history. Considers that specifically: these are too few and far from representative of the • Residential dwellings from right across the district. district’s rich history and is concerned that: • Items (both commercial and residential) in smaller district • Very few heritage items located outside New Plymouth’s towns (especially Waitara and Inglewood). central area are scheduled. • Items in rural areas of the district (such as farm • Very few residential buildings (right across the district) homesteads, outbuildings and dairy factories). are scheduled – this is especially problematic given increasing intensification and development of older residential areas within New Plymouth, Waitara and Inglewood. • The lack of scheduled buildings within the district’s smaller towns (especially Inglewood and Waitara) may unfairly disadvantage building owners who wish to seek funding grants for earthquake strengthening through

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1341 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No organisations such as Heritage Equip, where heritage listings may either be a pre‐requisite, or increase applicants’ chances of securing funding.

SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.128 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that new information should be added to Amend SCHED1 by inserting new information (through new and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part SCHED1 and the planning maps because it will help to columns or as otherwise achieved to integrate content) per Rachlin understand the features and extent covered for each place heritage building or item to address: and improve the ability to locate them on the planning • Site type and a description of the values for each heritage maps. building or item. • Specifying the map and/or integrating a link to the relevant map. • Setting. • Feature Description. • Amend the planning maps notation for all scheduled heritage buildings and items to show the extent of the setting/site. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.129 Heritage New Zealand Support in Supports inclusion of a schedule which clearly details each Retain a heritage buildings and items schedule (SCHED 1) and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part place identified for recognition of heritage significance and within which places listed with Heritage New Zealand are Rachlin protection. The RMA requires the protection of historic identified. heritage from inappropriate subdivision, use and development. SCHED1 combined with SCHED2 for interior elements will help to clearly identify those to be protected. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.130 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that a column title in SCHED1 should be Amend the column in SCHED1 titled HNZPT Ref to HNZPT and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part amended to more clearly link the reference to the New List Number. Rachlin Zealand List. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.131 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers a full check of the addresses in SCHED1 should be Amend any address errors in SCHED1. and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part done for accuracy. Examples of issues include: Rachlin • Site 38, Plas Maw (should be 26 Standish Street, not 236 Standish Street). • Site 28, Inglewood Town Hall. • Site 48, St Andrew's Presbyterian Church. • Site ID 57, TSB Bank. • Site ID 32, Mangorei Power Station (more accurate to describe as 9 Hydro Road not 37 Hydro Road). • Site ID 35, Memorial Gateway, New Plymouth Boys' High School. • Site ID 55, Camp House. • Site ID 49, St Aubyn Chambers. • In some cases the "address" column uses the format "New Plymouth District New Plymouth." These should be in the same format as other addresses.

SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.138a Heritage New Zealand Oppose Considers that there are some mapping errors relating to Amend any mapping errors relating to SCHED1. and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline SCHED1, e.g. Cob Dairy, Ferngrove and Hurworth Cottage. Rachlin

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1342 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.138b Heritage New Zealand Oppose Considers that protecting the surrounding/extent of Add extents of 'sites' to the planning maps for heritage and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline heritage buildings and items in SCHED1 is based on the buildings and items listed in SCHED1. Rachlin 'site' and that this should be shown on the planning maps. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.145 Heritage New Zealand Support in Supports inclusion of List entry information directly within Retain all proposed heritage buildings and items in SCHED1 and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part SCHED1 as required by the RMA, which states that district which are also listed with Heritage New Zealand (as Rachlin councils are required to have regard to the New Zealand notated in SCHED1). Heritage List/Rarangi Korero when preparing their plans. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.146 Heritage New Zealand Support in Supports inclusion of places in SCHED1 which are proposals Retain Site ID 62a (Nga Motu Methodist Mission Church, and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part because Heritage New Zealand has carefully assessed them 453 St Aubyn Street, Moturoa, New Plymouth) in SCHED1 Rachlin against thresholds for entry on the New Zealand Heritage as notified, which is not listed with Heritage New Zealand List/Rarangi Korero and considers they are good but is a proposal with Heritage New Zealand. candidates. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.147 Heritage New Zealand Support in Supports inclusion of places in SCHED1 which are proposals Retain Site ID 11 (Egmont Stream Flour Mill, 2 Courtenay and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part because Heritage New Zealand has carefully assessed them Street State Highway 45, New Plymouth) in SCHED1 as Rachlin against thresholds for entry on the New Zealand Heritage notified, which is not listed with Heritage New Zealand but List/Rarangi Korero and considers they are good is a proposal with Heritage New Zealand. candidates. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.148 Heritage New Zealand Support in Supports inclusion of places in SCHED1 which are proposals Retain Site ID 77 (Cottage, 55D Karina Road, Merrilands, and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part because Heritage New Zealand has carefully assessed them New Plymouth) in SCHED1 as notified, which is not listed Rachlin against thresholds for entry on the New Zealand Heritage with Heritage New Zealand but is a proposal with Heritage List/Rarangi Korero and considers they are good New Zealand. candidates. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.149 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 Methodist Parsonage (Former) (48 Princess and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. Street, Waitara ‐ 815 Category 2) which is listed with Rachlin Heritage New Zealand but not proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.150 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 St Paul's Church (Anglican) (25 Ngakoti and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. Street, Urenui ‐ 817 Category 2) which is listed with Rachlin Heritage New Zealand but not proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.151 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 Deem and Shearer Building (1 Kelly Street and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. and Matai Street, Inglewood ‐ 870 Category 2) which is Rachlin listed with Heritage New Zealand but not proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.152 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 Waipuku Stream Bridge, Marton‐New and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. Plymouth Line (Waipuku Stream, Tariki ‐ 878 Category 2) Rachlin which is listed with Heritage New Zealand but not proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.153 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 Te Henui Primitive Methodist Church (505 and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. Devon Street East, Strandon, New Plymouth ‐ 899 Category Rachlin 2) which is listed with Heritage New Zealand but not

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1343 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.154 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 Taranaki Education Board Offices (Former) and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. (16 Lemon Street, New Plymouth ‐ 912 Category 2) which is Rachlin listed with Heritage New Zealand but not proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.155 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 Okato Primary School (Former) (2333 South and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. Road, Okato ‐ 935 Category 2) which is listed with Heritage Rachlin New Zealand but not proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.156 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 House (7 Ridge Lane New Plymouth ‐ 7147 and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. Category 2) which is listed with Heritage New Zealand but Rachlin not proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.157 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that places on the New Zealand Heritage Add to SCHED1 Public Trust Office (Former) (52 King Street and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part List/Rarangi Korero should be included in SCHED1. and 29 Queen Street, New Plymouth ‐ 7237 Category 2) Rachlin which is listed with Heritage New Zealand but not proposed in SCHED1, include on the planning maps and include List Number and Category where relevant. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.158 Heritage New Zealand Support in Supports inclusion of the places in SCHED1 which form part Retain in SCHED1 the places which form part of the Hirst and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part of the Hirst Family "Hen and Chickens" Historic Area, Family "Hen and Chickens" Historic Area, Category 2 Rachlin Category 2 Historic Places with Heritage New Zealand. Historic Places with Heritage New Zealand. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.159 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that a two group categorisation of heritage Did not state. and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part buildings and items should be used to recognise and Rachlin protect historic heritage but the single group approach will work given the size of the list, no thresholds are proposed for any differentiation in significance, and the nature of the policies and rules. However, a tiered approach may be required if there are more additions.

SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.160 Heritage New Zealand Support in Supports the listing of Boer War Memorial in SCHED1. Retain Boer War Memorial in SCHED1 as notified [inferred]. and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part Rachlin SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.161 Heritage New Zealand Support in Supports the listing of Devonport Flats in SCHED1. Retain Devonport Flats in SCHED1 as notified [inferred]. and Items Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part Rachlin SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 542.12 J M Hellyar Support in Considers that Lemon Street, New Plymouth was a lovely Did not state. and Items part unique street of mostly pre 1900 villas and too many have been altered unsympathetically or replaced by new building and business, including the submitter's grandparents' home 1904‐1955 that was replaced by a car sales yard. Does not wish the Council to permit further

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1344 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No changes or inappropriate house colours such as bright red yellow or orange or black. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.132 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that Rahiri Lodge, National Park should be added Add to SCHED1 Rahiri Lodge Egmont National Park and and Items / New Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part to SCHED1 because: include on relevant planning map. Rachlin ● Heritage New Zealand has received a nominaon for it to be entered on the New Zealand Heritage List/Rarangi Korero. It has carefully assessed it against thresholds for entry and considers it is a good candidate. ● It is the only surviving tollgate in New Zealand. ● It was built in 1929 to house the park board's gatekeeper who collected a toll to the entrance to the national park. This assisted the then, one way road, into the park to be gradually developed over the years. ● It has an aracve "gingerbread house" appearance. The clinker brick portion is the extent of the original lodge, with later additions in timber to the rear. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.134 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that Tongaporutu River baches should be added Add to SCHED1 and the planning maps Tongaporutu River and Items / New Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part as a heritage area to SCHED1 with an associated policy and baches Historic Area (List Number 9318) as a Historic Rachlin rules framework because: Heritage Area. ● They have historical significance at naonal and local Make associated and consequential changes to the policies level and the landscape has important cultural values. and rules to ensure heritage area provisions are included to ● Inappropriate development within this area could impact ensure protection and appropriate conservation of this on the integrity of the area. area. ● Guidelines should be developed to help inform acvies As an alternative to adding the area to SCHED1 add a new in this area and to ensure the values are maintained. schedule specifically for heritage areas. ● Supporng informaon on the List entry is aached in the submission. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.135 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that Hirst Family "Hen and Chickens" Historic Add to SCHED1 and the planning maps Hirst Family "Hen and Items / New Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part Area should be added as a heritage area to SCHED1 and Chickens" Historic Area (List Number 7202) as a Rachlin because: Historic Heritage Area. ● This group of interrelated places and features have Make associated and consequential changes to the policies significance not only on an individual basis but as a whole. and rules to ensure protection and appropriate ● Without adequate protection development proposals conservation of this area. may be treated in isolation and risk the overall integrity of As an alternative to adding the area to SCHED1 add a new the group. schedule specifically for heritage areas. ● Supporng informaon on the List entry is aached in the submission. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 522.139 Heritage New Zealand Support in Considers that Pukekura Park should be added as a Add to SCHED1 and the planning maps Pukekura Park as a and Items / New Pouhere Taonga ‐ Caroline part heritage area to SCHED1 because: Historic Heritage Area. Rachlin ● It was established in 1876 and for over 140 years has Make associated and consequential changes to the policies played a significant part in the recreational life of New and rules to ensure heritage areas provisions are included Plymouth. to ensure protection and appropriate conservation of this ● It covers an area of approximately 52 hectares (128 area. acres), is one of New Zealand's premier botanical gardens, As an alternative to adding the area to SCHED1 add a new and is a garden of National Significance. schedule specifically for heritage areas.

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1345 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No ● Within it there are places listed with Heritage New Zealand including: Kiosk Historic Place Category 2 No. 897; Band Rotunda Historic Place Category 2 No. 882; Queen Victoria Monument [1897] Historic Place Category 2 No. 908; The Poet's Bridge [1883] Historic Place Category 2 List 7238; and the Gables (Colonial Hospital), Historic Place Category 1 (List No. 29). ● Recognion as a historic area would be in line with other significant New Zealand parks and gardens and recognises the significant heritage values of landscape design and gardens within a wider historic site. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 532.1 Friends of Pukekura Park Support in Considers that features within Pukekura Park should be Add to SCHED1 the following features within Pukekura and Items / New New Plymouth Inc ‐ part added to SCHED1. Park: Adrienne Tatham ● Fernery Tunnels ● Waldyve King residence (Brooklands Park Drive) ● Curator's residence (25 Victoria Road) ● Liardet Street gates (Sanders) ● Waterfall ● Former Park Office (Walter Graham) ● Don Driver Cats sculpture ● Water Wheel ● Torii gate ● King Plaque ‐ Brooklands ● Rifle Bus ● Moon Gate ● Kunming Pavilion ● Ticket Boxes (2) Sportsground ● Queen Elizabeth II Fountain and Plaque ● Hughes Gates Victoria Road ● Saw pit [inferred]. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 582.54 New Plymouth District Support in Considers that the historic fire hydrant outside 46 Egmont Add historic fire hydrant outside 46 Egmont Street, New and Items / New Council ‐ Juliet Johnson part Street, New Plymouth should be added to SCHED1 Plymouth to SCHED1. because: ● It is over 100 years old and was used to suck water straight out of the river below to put out fires. ● It is understood to be the only fire hydrant of its type sll standing in the district. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 582.55 New Plymouth District Support in Considers that the grave site of Charles Armitage Brown Add grave site of Charles Armitage Brown located on and Items / New Council ‐ Juliet Johnson part (friend of Keats) located on Marsland Hill should be added Marsland Hill to SCHED1. to SCHED1 because it is associated with a notable historic figure and has heritage value. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 317.8e Hamish Crimp Support Considers that further heritage character areas should be Add further heritage character areas including those listed and Items / New Heritage identified. by Heritage NZ such as the Hirst Family 'Hen and Chickens' Character Areas

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1346 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No Historic Area and the Tongaporutu River Baches Historic Area. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.3b Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that: Revisit the decision to not schedule the 17 areas (4.1.3.2 and Items / New Heritage Bruce ● Heritage character areas should not be limited to the Heritage Character Areas) outlined in the Section 32. Character Areas CBD. ● The 17 previously recognised heritage character areas should be included. It is not accepted that their site loss is so extensive that smaller areas of contiguous heritage buildings couldn't be considered. The site loss described in the section 32 report only addresses residential areas and the reasons for not including the commercial and bach areas are not addressed. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.3c Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that: Add those heritage areas recognised by Heritage New and Items / New Heritage Bruce ● Heritage character areas should not be limited to the Zealand Pouhere Taonga, such as the Tongaporutu bach Character Areas CBD. area and the Hen and Chicken houses historic area ● At a minimum, those heritage areas recognised by HNZPT [inferred]. should be included, such as the Tongaporutu bach area and the Hen and Chicken houses historic area. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.3d Heritage Taranaki Inc ‐ Ivan Support Considers that: Investigate including areas of contiguous archaeological and Items / New Heritage Bruce ● Heritage character areas should not be limited to the sites, such as the Waitara battleground. Character Areas CBD. ● No consideraon appears to have been given to archaeological heritage, such as the Waitara Road battleground from Kairau to Pukerangiora. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 317.8b Hamish Crimp Support Considers that further heritage character areas should be Add further heritage character areas including Brooklands and Items / New Heritage identified. State Housing area (substantially intact but removal of Character Areas some buildings is beginning so this should be prioritised). SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 317.8c Hamish Crimp Support Considers that further heritage character areas should be Add further heritage character areas including smaller and Items / New Heritage identified. groups of 2 or more buildings (especially residential Character Areas buildings). For example a continuous row of villas or a row of bungalows, or a representative mixture of dwellings. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 317.8d Hamish Crimp Support Considers that further heritage character areas should be Add further heritage character areas including extension of and Items / New Heritage identified. the CBD heritage character area along Devon Street East to Character Areas just beyond the Gover Street intersection to include a large number of older buildings, mostly with no existing heritage protection. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 459.100 Te Kotahitanga o Te Atiawa Oppose Opposes the inclusion of the Eastern Wing of the Barrett Clarify the assessments that have determined Site ID 3 (the and Items / Site ID 3 Trust ‐ Hemi Sundgren Street Hospital Nurses Home in SCHED1 because: Eastern Wing of the Barrett Street Hospital Nurses Home, ● The s32 Report and supporng technical reports do not 34 Barrett Street, New Plymouth) to be a significant provide an assessment or supporting arguments in relation heritage building warranting identification in SCHED1. to Policy HH‐P1. Remove it from SCHED1 if no assessments can be provided. ● Clarificaon is sought in relaon to the assessment Should Council not accept the relief sought, the removal or matters that have determined it to be a significant heritage relocation of a heritage building should be a RDIS activity building that would warrant identification in SCHED1. not a NC activity. The inclusion of matters of discretion ● It has fallen into significant disrepair, both internally and relating to effects on historic heritage in the RDIS activity

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1347 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No externally, and has significant presence of asbestos and associated objectives and policies will still enable throughout the structure, consequently being a health and Council to make a determination on whether historic safety risk to the public. heritage is protected from inappropriate subdivision, use ● The cost of remediang it to some form of usable and development (as per S6(f) of the RMA). standard is economically unfeasible. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 393.1 Bruce Neale Support in Considers that the Council should: The submitter pays the same rates as the "west side" so and Items / Site ID 134 part ● Assist to earthquake strengthen heritage buildings. wants some work done to the east side. There has been a ● Be open to verandah post opons. lot of investment up this end of town by business, now its ● Provide financial assistance/rates reduction for listed Council's turn. properties. ● Show the eastern end of town some love because it is a shambles compared to the rest of town. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 360.1 Edward Jane Investment Oppose Considers that Site ID 135 (Boon Bros) at 11 Gover Street, Remove Site ID 135 (Boon Bros, 11 Gover Street, New and Items / Site ID 135 Trustee Company and Isle New Plymouth should be removed from SCHED1 because: Plymouth) from SCHED1. Investment Trustee ‐ ● It is not of any outstanding historical significance. Boon Anthony Vincent Bros were one of many construction firms in the city in the 20th century and they constructed it for their commercial needs. It was designed for practical purposes, not for effect ‐ one frontage has rough concrete with the outline of previous outbuildings still visible. ● There have been many changes over the years. The entry has been moved several times, the veranda removed, a suspended tile ceiling has replaced the original wooden tongue and groove ceiling, the below ground paint workshop has been filled in and the lumberyards are no longer present. ● There are no other heritage buildings in the vicinity, so it is not part of a historic streetscape. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 125.1 Taranaki Anglican Trust Oppose Opposes the listing of St Mary's Peace Hall in SCHED1 Remove Site ID 137 (St Mary's Peace Memorial Hall, 40 and Items / Site ID 137 Board ‐ Jenny Goddard because: Vivian Street, New Plymouth) from SCHED1. ● The lisng will impact all opons for this property: 1. Sale Allow the owner to make decisions on its future without to assist with Cathedral earthquake strengthening. 2. this serious restriction. Repurposing (potentially with a partner) to ensure it The owner is the original builder of the structure so has an provides a realistic return on capital. 3. Retain as a hall with understanding of what makes it important for its people. irregular and infrequent use and hireage. Potentially retention or removal of the facade (Peace Hall ● The sale price will be less than could be expected 1924) on to another site may be considered but the burden otherwise. A buyer cannot demolish or alter without of demanding that of the owner is unacceptable. resource consent which may not be granted. The risk and uncertainty lowers the price. Repurposing sees the same uncertainties. ● It will need a Detailed Seismic Assessment parcularly if a Change of Use is considered. Earthquake strengthening would need to be done in an unintrusive manner which is likely to cost more than utilising a technique that was external to the building fabric.

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1348 Provision Sub No/ Submitter Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No ● It has had significant alteraon to its roof with terracoa tiles replaced and roof vents removed. Internally there have been multiple changes around the toilets and kitchen areas. It is poorly maintained because the Church has other priorities and little means. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 124.1 Taranaki Anglican Trust Oppose Opposes the listing of St Mary's Community Centre in Remove Site ID 138 (St Mary's Community Centre, 36‐40 and Items / Site ID 138 Board ‐ Jenny Goddard SCHED1 because: Vivian Street, New Plymouth) from SCHED1. ● Architecturally the few original windows (east side) and Heritage protection under the District Plan is not desired. gable roof form are not rare or good examples of their type. Many early timber church buildings repeat this Gothic Revival style, e.g. St Pauls Anglican Church in Okato. There the interior adds to the experience of the architecture but that is not the case here where the interior has had multiple alterations and is unrecognisable as Gothic Revival. ● Lisng the building will impact the only two opons for the community centre: 1. Divestment of the property to release funds to safeguard the Cathedral. 2. Repurposing/redevelopment (potentially in partnership with others) of the property because its uses are no longer relevant or will be replicated on the Cathedral site. ● Architecturally this is not an aracve building that an enthusiastic buyer will repurpose while maintaining its current form. The large flat site with great visibility, just outside of the pedestrian area with high traffic numbers is very attractive for its redevelopment potential but a listing will restrict new development adjacent to the heritage building. The zoning supports vehicle orientated commercial development. The uncertainties, costs and delays a purchaser would face should they alter or demolish the building to ensure a return on investment will impact the saleable value. The owner is already financially stretched attempting to earthquake strengthen a nationally significant building.

SCHED1 – Schedule of Heritage Buildings and Items │ 1349