Race, Color, and Nationalism in Aruban and Curaçaoan Political Identities

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Race, Color, and Nationalism in Aruban and Curaçaoan Political Identities Thamyris/Intersecting No. 27 (2014) 117–132 Race, Color, and Nationalism in Aruban and Curaçaoan Political Identities Michael Orlando Sharpe This chapter focuses on the development and instrumentalization of race and color based Aruban and Curaçaoan nationalisms within processes of decolonization and reconstitution in the context of Dutch sovereignty and Dutch liberal democracy. I argue this instrumentalization of race and color as markers of national identity takes place within an overall framework of white supremacy. The following will describe the current political construction of the Dutch Kingdom and examine Aruban and Curaçaoan national myths of origin along with a brief history of Dutch colonialism and slavery including the 20th century relevance of oil refinement on these islands. Next, there will a discussion of the significance of the 1954 Charter for the Kingdom of the Netherlands or Statuut and the key role of Curaçao’s labor unrest of 30 May 1969 or “Trinta de Mei” in the development and deployment of racially and color based Aruban and Curaçaoan nationalisms as “invented traditions” and “social engineer- ing.” The chapter will conclude with an examination of the ways in which these notions of race and racism are reified in the Netherlands today. This discussion centers on developments around the Netherlands Antilles prior to its dissolution on 10 October 2010. Before 10/10/10, the Kingdom of the Netherlands was made up of the Netherlands, the Netherlands Antilles, and Aruba. The Netherlands Antilles was a federation of the five island states of Curaçao (admin- istrative capital), Bonaire, Saba, St. Eustatius, and St. Maarten. The current Dutch Kingdom consists of the Netherlands, Aruba, Curaçao, and St. Maarten. The smaller former Dutch Antillean islands of Bonaire, Saint Eustatius, and Saba have been fully integrated as “special municipalities” of the Netherlands (Netherlands Ministry of the Interior and Kingdom Relations; “Nederlandse Antillen opgeheven”). Race, Color, and Nationalism in Aruban and Curaçaoan Political Identities | 117 The Dutch Leeward islands of Aruba, population 103,484 (Central Bureau of Statistics of Aruba 1), Curaçao, 130,627, and Bonaire, 10,791, are located just off the coast of Venezuela and the Dutch Windward islands of Saint Eustatius, 2,292, Saba, 1,349, and St. Maarten (Dutch side), 30,594, are located just easterly from Puerto Rico (Central Bureau of Statistics of the Netherlands Antilles 15). As mem- bers of the Dutch Kingdom, the populations of these islands are legal Dutch nation- als with Dutch/European Union passports. Hence, the total population of the Netherlands Antilles (175,653) and Aruba (103,484) in 2006 was approximately 279,137. In 1986, Aruba obtained status aparte from the Netherlands Antilles mak- ing it an integral self-governing part of the Dutch Kingdom, but independent of Curaçao and the Netherlands Antilles. Although Aruba was scheduled to become fully independent from the Kingdom of the Netherlands in 1996, this idea was rather unpopular among its population. The notion of independence proved unpopular as people reflected on the poverty and political chaos of Suriname after its independ- ence from the Netherlands in 1975 as well as other newly independent states in the region. Hence, Aruba remains a part of the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Initially, the Netherlands Antilles was to be dissolved on 15 December 2008, with Curaçao and St. Maarten as separate countries similar to Aruba’s status aparte within the Kingdom, and Bonaire, Saba, and Saint Eustatius as “special municipalities” of the Netherlands. But this was postponed and, as mentioned earlier, finally realized on 10 October 2010. In light of Aruba’s secession from the Netherlands Antilles in 1986, these Dutch islands remain in a state of negotiation and flux around their dis- solution and reconstitution as states and national identities, where race, ethnicity, and language are employed as claims to “authentic” national identity. Legacies of racism have played an important role in the construction of these identities. Dutch (up until more recently) is the official language with Papiamento, a Portuguese Creole combining Spanish, Dutch, English, and African influences, serving as the lingua franca of the Dutch Leeward islands of Aruba, Curaçao, and Bonaire. English func- tions as the vernacular of the Dutch Windward islands of St. Eustatius, St. Maarten, and Saba. These are multicultural and multiracial societies with varying degrees of historical influence from Africa, indigenous Indian Caribbean peoples, Europe, Latin America, and elsewhere. Founding Facts and Myths Following 19th century French observer Alexis de Tocqueville, political scientist James Hollifield (L’Immigration; “Immigration and Integration”) has written about what he calls “national founding myths” or “national models.” These “national found- ing myths” typically refer to essentialist narratives about the founding of the nation that are in some way supposed to be representative of the identities and values of that nation. These national founding myths can be seen in examples ranging from 118 | Michael Orlando Sharpe.
Recommended publications
  • 'Good Governance' in the Dutch Caribbean
    Obstacles to ‘Good Governance’ in the Dutch Caribbean Colonial- and Postcolonial Development in Aruba and Sint Maarten Arxen A. Alders Master Thesis 2015 [email protected] Politics and Society in Historical Perspective Department of History Utrecht University University Supervisor: Dr. Auke Rijpma Internship (BZK/KR) Supervisor: Nol Hendriks Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 2 1. Background ............................................................................................................................ 9 1.1 From Colony to Autonomy ......................................................................................................... 9 1.2 Status Quaestionis .................................................................................................................... 11 Colonial history .............................................................................................................................. 12 Smallness ....................................................................................................................................... 16 2. Adapting Concepts to Context ................................................................................................. 19 2.1 Good Governance ..................................................................................................................... 19 Development in a Small Island Context ........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Netherlands 2019 Human Rights Report
    THE NETHERLANDS 2019 HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Kingdom of the Netherlands, a parliamentary constitutional monarchy, consists of four equal autonomous countries: the Netherlands, Aruba, Curacao, and Sint Maarten. The kingdom retains responsibility for foreign policy, defense, and other “kingdom issues.” The Netherlands includes the Caribbean islands of Bonaire, Saba, and Sint Eustatius, which are special municipalities. The six Caribbean entities collectively are known as the Dutch Caribbean. The Netherlands has a bicameral parliament. The country’s 12 provincial councils elect the First Chamber, and the Second Chamber is elected by popular vote. A prime minister and a cabinet representing the governing political parties exercise executive authority. Aruba, Curacao, and Sint Maarten have unicameral parliamentary systems, and each island country has one minister plenipotentiary representing them in the Kingdom Council of Ministers. Ultimate responsibility for safeguarding fundamental human rights and freedoms in all kingdom territories lies with the kingdom’s ministerial council, which includes the Dutch government and the plenipotentiary ministers of Curacao, Aruba, and Sint Maarten. (Note: The adjective “Dutch” throughout this report refers to “the Netherlands.”) Elections for seats in the European Parliament on May 23 and the Netherlands’ First Chamber on May 27 were considered free and fair. The national police maintain internal security in the Netherlands and report to the Ministry of Justice and Security, which oversees law enforcement organizations, as do the justice ministries in Aruba, Curacao, and Sint Maarten. The kingdom’s armed forces report to the Ministry of Defense and are responsible for external security but also have some domestic security responsibilities.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix 1 Political Forms of the Caribbean Compiled by Yarimar Bonilla, Rutgers University
    Appendix 1 Political Forms of the Caribbean Compiled by Yarimar Bonilla, Rutgers University Jurisdiction Political Status and Important Historical Dates Monetary Unit * = on UN list of non-self- governing territories Constituent country of the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Seceded from the Aruba Netherlands Antilles in 1986 with plans for independence, but independence was Aruban florin (AFL) postponed indefinitely in 1994. Constituent country of the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Former seat of the Antillean guilder N Curacao Netherlands Antilles central government. Became an autonomous country within (ANG) E the kingdom of the Netherlands in 2010. T Constituent Country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Part of the Windward H Sint Maarten Islands territory within the Netherland Antilles until 1983. Became an autonomous ANG E country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands in 2010. R L Special municipality of the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Formerly part of the A Bonaire Netherlands Antilles. Became a special municipality within the Kingdom of the US dollar (USD) N Netherlands in 2010. D Special municipality of the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Part of the Windward S Saba Islands territory within the Netherland Antilles until 1983. Became a special USD municipality within the Kingdom of the Netherlands in 2010. Special municipality of the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Part of the Windward Sint Eustatius Islands territory within the Netherland Antilles until 1983. Became a special USD municipality within the Kingdom of the Netherlands in 2010 Overseas territory of the United Kingdom. Formerly part of the British Leeward Island colonial federation as the colony of Saint Cristopher-Nevis-Anguilla.
    [Show full text]
  • Technical Assistance Program for Disaster Risk Financing and Insurance in Caribbean Overseas Countries and Territories
    Technical Assistance Program for Disaster Risk Financing and Insurance in Caribbean Overseas Countries and Territories The Technical Assistance Program for Disaster Risk Financing and Insurance (DRFI) in Caribbean Overseas Countries and Territories (OCTs) launched in 2019, is a partnership between the European Union (EU), the World Bank Group, and the Global Facility for Disaster Reduction and Recovery (GFDRR). The Program is part of the EU-funded Caribbean OCTs Resilience, Sustainable Energy and Marine Biodiversity Program (ReSEMBiD), implemented by Expertise France, the World Bank and GFDRR. The objective of the Technical Assistance Program for DRFI in Caribbean OCTs is to enhance long term resilience and adaptation capacity in the Caribbean OCTs to adapt to extreme and recurrent natural events, to the benefit of the most vulnerable. | What we do | The Program supports the development of innovative disaster risk financing options, capacity building within OCTs on use of existing risk transfer mechanisms like the Caribbean Catastrophe Risk Insurance Facility (CCRIF) and working with the OCTs to promote informed decision-making on disaster risk financing. Specifically, activities focus on carrying out gap analysis for disaster risk financing, including both financial and policy considerations, and assessing demand for sovereign disaster risk financing products, identifying the financial exposure or contingent liability to geophysical and climate related disasters, enhancing the understanding of different yet complementary disaster risk financing tools, such as indemnity insurance, parametric products and contingency South-south knowledge exchange on disaster funds among others, to help them manage their risk financing products and budget classification fiscal risks related to natural disasters. will also be conducted, and activities.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Methodist Education and Sociopolitical Development in Montserrat the Absence of Sustained Missionary Efforts Towards the Devel
    Methodist Education and Sociopolitical Development in Montserrat The absence of sustained missionary efforts towards the development of educational institutions for African slaves in the Caribbean has been documented.1 A closer analysis, however, credits the Wesleyan contribution to education in Montserrat with being a significant agent of societal transformation, certainly by effect if not by design. This was in some sense linked to the movement's self-understanding related to its mission to spread scriptural holiness for the transformation of the nation. While "the nation" referred in principle to Britain, the mandate to transform would, a century later, be extended to the Caribbean where the Methodist movement was pioneered in 1760 by Nathaniel Gilbert, an Antiguan born planter of British parentage, after his 1759 encounter in England with John Wesley. As early as 1809, Anne Gilbert had defied authorities and established a school at English Harbour in Antigua, from where Methodism made its way to the nearby island of Montserrat.2 In Montserrat as in the Leeward Islands generally, the Methodist missionary support for education was at odds with that of the Establishment which was essentially an extension of the Anglican Church and which fostered a certain parochialism that extended British ecclesiastical feuds into the Caribbean. The insistence on conformity to church discipline adversely affected the development of formal education which was vitally important to the social elevation of non- white populations. While the Wesleyans were intentional concerning a religious focus in education, they did not forcibly promote denominationalism in schools to the same extent.3 Methodism's direct involvement in primary education in Montserrat preceded the abolition of slavery, since general education classes had been conducted at Bethel in the east and at Cavalla Hill in the north west of the island since the 1820s.
    [Show full text]
  • Recommendation 3 ISO Country Code for Representation of Names of Countries
    Recommendation 3 ISO COUNTRY CODE for Representation of Names of Countries At its first session, held in January 1972, the Group of The Working Party on Facilitation of International Trade Experts on Automatic Data Processing and Coding de- Procedures, cided to include in its programme of work the following Being aware of the need of an internationally agreed code task: system to represent names of countries, “To define requirements for country codes for use in Considering the International Standard ISO 3166 “Codes international trade, to be forwarded to ISO and to be for the representation of names of countries” as a suitable pursued in co-operation with it”. basis for application in international trade, It was entrusted to the secretariat to pursue this task. Recommends that the two-letter alphabetic code referred to in the International Standard ISO 3166 as “ISO AL- At a Meeting of the relevant ISO body, Working Group 2 PHA-2 Country Code”, should be used for representing of Technical Committee 46 “Documentation” in April the names of countries for purposes of International Trade 1972, it was agreed to set up a Co-ordination Committee whenever there is a need for a coded alphabetical desig- with the task to prepare proposals regarding a list of nation; entities, candidate numerical and alphabetical codes and maintenance arrangements. This Committee was com- Invites the secretariat to inform the appropriate ISO body posed of one representative each from ISO and ITU and responsible for the maintenance of ISO 3166 of any of the UNCTAD Trade Facilitation Adviser. amendments which the Working Party may suggest.
    [Show full text]
  • 6 Characterization of the Kingdom Order Under International L Aw
    Political decolonization and self-determination : the case of the Netherlands Antilles and Aruba Hillebrink, S. Citation Hillebrink, S. (2007, February 28). Political decolonization and self-determination : the case of the Netherlands Antilles and Aruba. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/11003 Version: Corrected Publisher’s Version Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the License: Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/11003 Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable). 6 Characterization of the Kingdom Order Under International L aw B etw een 19 5 1 and 19 5 5 the UN dis cu s s ed the relations hip b etw een the N ether- lands and its Carib b ean territories in s ome detail, and a nu mb er of au thors hav e w ritten ab ou t the Kingdom Charter in E nglis h, F rench, and G erman, for w hich reas ons the formal as p ects of the relations hip are w ell k now n among the ex p erts on ov ers eas territories and au tonomy regimes .1 N onetheles s , the Kingdom of the N etherlands is categorized in many different w ay s in the foreign literatu re. T hree main s trands of reas oning are p rev alent, namely that the Carib b ean Cou ntries are integral p arts of the Kingdom, as s ociated w ith the N etherlands or non-s elf-gov erning. I w ill dis cu s s thes e v iew s , and the UN deb ate of the 19 5 0 s , and try to determine how the Kingdom cou ld b e character- ized u nder international law on the b as is of the conclu s ions draw n in the p rev iou s Chap ters .
    [Show full text]
  • Constitutional Reform of the Dutch Antilles
    Client Briefing December 2010 Constitutional reform of the Dutch Antilles Having the emblematic date '10-10-10' as its juncture, the recent constitutional Contents reforms have reshaped the structure of The Kingdom of the Netherlands (“the Kingdom”). During a 10 year process of contemplation and self-determination, Reforms the islands of the former Dutch Antilles had the opportunity to design their own role within the Kingdom. As a result, the former Netherlands Antilles have been Applicable laws split into two separate countries (Curaçao and Sint Maarten) with the remaining Financial regulation islands (Bonaire, Sint Eustatius and Saba, the BES Islands) becoming public bodies (gemeenten) of the Netherlands. Aruba had already achieved the same Currency status as Curaçao and Sint Maarten in 1986. The following is a brief overview of the main changes to what used to be Netherlands Antilles law and its judicial Judicial system system. Reforms The Netherlands Antilles have been dissolved as of 10 October 2010. The Kingdom of the Netherlands (the Kingdom) now consists of four independent countries; Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten and the Netherlands, each country having its own jurisdiction. The BES Islands fall under the jurisdiction of the Netherlands. Although Curaçao and Sint Maarten have become autonomous countries within the Kingdom, their financial independence might actually be lessened because of the reforms. During the preparatory stage of the reforms, the Board of financial supervision (College financieel toezicht, Cft) has been entrusted with the supervision on government spending in the former Dutch Antilles, a role it will retain for the coming years. This budgetary supervision is a result of a compromise whereby the Netherlands promised to pay off the majority of government debt of Curaçao and Sint Maarten.
    [Show full text]
  • Executive Summary for Canada, Barbados, Bermuda, Jamaica and the Netherlands Antilles 2 Capitalizing on Complexity
    Capitalizing on Complexity Insights from the Global Chief Executive Officer Study Executive Summary for Canada, Barbados, Bermuda, Jamaica and the Netherlands Antilles 2 Capitalizing on Complexity Introduction How are leaders responding to a competitive and economic environment unlike anything that has come before? To find out, we held face-to-face interviews with 1,541 chief executive officers, general managers and senior public sector leaders, including 72 respondents from Canada and the Caribbean – specifically, Barbados, Bermuda, Canada, Jamaica and the Netherlands Antilles. In this report, we refer to this group collectively 1 Figure 1 as “Canadian CEOs.” These conversations offer valuable insight into the Performance analysis framework agendas and actions of global leaders. Standouts represent organizations from different industries and from all In our past three global CEO studies, CEOs consistently said that coping geographies. with change was their most pressing challenge. In 2010, we identified a new primary challenge: complexity. CEOs told us they operate in a world that is increasingly volatile, uncertain and complex. Many shared the view that incremental changes are no longer sufficient. e c n Standouts Top 50 percent 50 Top a m r fo We carried out extensive statistical and financial analyses, including a r e p comparison of responses from CEOs based on financial performance. e e t m r Organizations that performed well during both good and bad economic e t g ady-sta conditions – we call them “Standouts” – approach complexity differently e Top 50 percent Lon St than those that performed less robustly. Figure 1 illustrates how Short term Standout organizations ranked in the top 50 percent for both the Crisis performance long-term period of 2003 to 2008 and the short-term period of 2008 to 2009.
    [Show full text]
  • Tier 1 Countries Andorra Antigua and Barbuda Argentina Aruba Australia
    Tier 1 Countries Tier 1 Countries Tier 2 Countries Tier 3 Countries Tier 4 Countries (continued) Andorra Qatar Albania Angola Afghanistan Antigua and Barbuda San Marino Algeria Anguilla Benin Argentina Saudi Arabia American Samoa Bangladesh Burkina Faso Aruba Seychelles Armenia Bhutan Burundi Australia Singapore Azerbaijan Bolivia Central African Rep. Austria Sint Maarten Belarus Cabo Verde Chad Bahamas Slovak Republic Belize Cambodia Comoros Bahrain Slovenia Bosnia/Herzegovina Cameroon Dem. Rep. of Congo Barbados South Korea Botswana Congo Eritrea Belgium Spain Brazil Cook Islands Ethiopia Bermuda St Kitts/Nevis Bulgaria Côte d’Ivoire Gambia British Virgin Islands St Martin China Djibouti Guinea Brunei Darussalam Sweden Colombia Egypt Guinea-Bissau Canada Switzerland Costa Rica El Salvador Haiti Cayman Islands Taiwan Cuba French Guiana Liberia Channel Islands Trinidad/Tobago Dominica French So. Territories Madagascar Chile Turks and Caicos Dominican Republic Georgia Malawi Croatia United Arab Emirates Ecuador Ghana Mali Curacao United Kingdom Equatorial Guinea Guadeloupe Mozambique Cyprus United States Fiji Honduras Nepal Czech Republic Uruguay Gabon India Niger Denmark Virgin Islands Grenada Indonesia North Korea Estonia Guatemala Kenya Rwanda Faroe Islands Guyana Kiribati Senegal Falkland Islands (Malvinas) Iran Kosovo Sierra Leon Finland Iraq Kyrgyz Republic Somalia France Jamaica Lao PDR South Sudan French Polynesia Jordan Lesotho Syrian Arab Republic Germany Kazakhstan Mauritania Tajikistan Gibraltar Lebanon Mayotte Tanzania Greece
    [Show full text]
  • INDIAN ARUBA in the HISTORICAL AGE Luc Aio F S
    TH(1636-1795E PEASANT) AMP THE REBEL: INDIAN ARUBA IN THE HISTORICAL AGE Luc Aio f s Abstract The Aruban population is proud of its Amerindian cultural legacy, which acts as a 'reinvented tradition' in Aruba's national identity. In this paper, I analyse the myth and facts of this Indian heritage in the colonial age (1636-1795). On one hand, Aruba was a place of refuge to Indian settlers on the almost but forgotten island. Aruba was a safe haven or a reserve to some of the last surviving Indian populations in the Caribbean archipel­ ago. On the other hand, during the 17"1 and 18™ century, Christianization took place and the formation of a unique Caribbean peasant type -'the cunucero'- occurred. The increasing presence and pressure by the Dutch administration resulted in protest and rebellion from the side of the Aruban Indians. During the 19^ century, the Amerindian population assimilated into the colonial society. Résumé La population d'Aruba estfière de son patrimoine culturel amérindien qui figure comme une 'tradition réinven­ tée' dans l'identité nationale d'Aruba. Ici je sépare le mythe des faits dans cet héritage de l'époque coloniale (1636-1795). D'une part Aruba était un refuge pour les Indiens qui voulaient s'établir dans l'île quasi oubliée à cette époque. Aruba a servi d'abri ou de refuge pour quelques-unes des dernières populations amérindiennes qui ont survécu dans l'archipel caraïbe. D'autre part, pendant le 17e et le 18e siècle la christianisation a pris pied et on a vu apparaître un type unique de paysan caraïbe nommé 'cunucero'.
    [Show full text]
  • AIC Hotel Group Amresorts Amstar Anguilla Tourist Board Aruba
    August 13 – 16, 2017 Hyatt Ziva | Hyatt Zilara – Montego Bay, Jamaica Supplier Participant List AIC Hotel Group Hilton Barbados Resort AMResorts Hilton Hotels & Resorts of San Juan Amstar Hilton Rose Hall Resort & Spa Anguilla Tourist Board Hyatt Ziva & Hyatt Zilara Aruba Tourism Authority Iberostar Hotels Bahia Principe Hotels Innovation DMC Barbados Tourism Marketing, Inc. Island Routes Barceló Hotel Group Jamaica Tourist Board Bermuda Tourism Authority Jamaica Tours Limited Blue Sea Anguilla Kantours Breathless Montego Bay Resort & Spa Karisma Hotels & Resorts British Virgin Islands Tourism Kimpton Seafire Resort & Spa Caribbean Concierge Services Le Blanc Spa Resorts Cayman Islands Department of Tourism Maui Jim Sunglasses Condado Vanderbilt Meet Puerto Rico Delta Air Lines Melia Hotels International Destination Puerto Rico Melia Hotels International - Punta Cana Dominican Republic Tourism Board Naples Marco Island Everglades Eco Destination Management Services Aruba Nassau Paradise Island /Curacao Palace Resorts El Embajador, A Royal Hideaway Hotel Palladium Hotel Group Four Seasons Resort & Residences Anguilla Park Hyatt St. Kitts Four Seasons Resort Nevis Peter Island Resort & Spa Grand Fiesta Americana Coral Beach Private Jet Services Grand Hyatt Baha Mar Punta Cana Resort & Club Half Moon Red Sail Aruba DMC Hilton Aruba Caribbean Resort & Casino Red Sail Sports Grand Cayman Destination Hilton at Resorts World Bimini Management August 13 – 16, 2017 Hyatt Ziva | Hyatt Zilara – Montego Bay, Jamaica Supplier Participant List RIU Hotels & Resorts Sandals and Beaches Resorts Santa Barbara Beach & Golf Resort Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina Sonesta St. Maarten St. Kitts Tourism Authority St. Martin Tourist Board Sugar Bay Resort & Spa Sunlinc Sunsplash Events, Ltd. The Harbor Club The Palms & The Shore Club Turks and Caicos The Westin Dawn Beach Resort and Spa St.
    [Show full text]