AUCKLAND UNITARY PLAN OPERATIVE IN PART

PROPOSED PLAN CHANGE 42 (Private)

Auckland Regional Landfill : Wayby Valley

SUMMARY OF DECISIONS REQUESTED

Enclosed:

• Explanation • Summary of Decisions Requested Explanation

• You may make a “further submission” to support or oppose any submission already received (see summaries that follow). • You should use Form 6. • Your further submission must be received by 3 September 2020. • Send a copy of your further submission to the original submitter as soon as possible after submitting it to the Council.

Summary of Decisions Requested

Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary 1 Withdrawn Withdrawn Withdrawn 2 2.1 Robyn Lorraine Brown [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 3 3.1 Richard Brown [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 4 4.1 Elizabeth Ann Foster [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 5 5.1 Lyn Morrison [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 6 6.1 Yvette Urlich [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 7 7.1 Mary-Jane and John Appleby [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification No Mega Landfill In Dome Valley facebook page 8 8.1 c/- Alton Crisp [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 9 9.1 Daniel Mohr [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 10 10.1 Gaylene Gaffney [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 11 11.1 Graham Conroy Harris [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 12 12.1 Stop the tip, save the dome c/- Jacquie Stokes [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 13 13.1 Richard Griffiths [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

Council should work to reduce sedimentation of the Hoteo River and Kaipara Harbour through land 13 13.2 Richard Griffiths [email protected] purchases, reforestation, and planting river banks.

14 14.1 Bins R Us c/- Richard Holt [email protected] Accept the Plan Modification

Add criteria to I617.9 to ensure that any potential effects on the Kaipara Harbour (including sedimentation and lechate) are the matter of further research and reporting (including possible compensation or bond amounts) 15 15.1 Kaipara District Council [email protected] when considering a resource consent for a landfill.

1 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Add a condition to the Plan Change to require the preparation and implementation of a Construction Traffic Management Plan in relation to Crowther Rd and its 15 15.2 Kaipara District Council [email protected] intersection with SH1.

Add criteria to I617.9 to require further information that assesses the potential ecnomic effects on the Kaipara economy - particularly transport of goods and services, road safety/congestion, and the potential clean up costs 15 15.3 Kaipara District Council [email protected] associated with a catastophic event.

16 16.1 Michael Gerard Sweetman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 17 17.1 The Board Limited c/- Tony Edmonds [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

18 18.1 Debra Searchfield [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 19 19.1 David Cunningham [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 20 20.1 Kerry Allen [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 21 21.1 Bridget Moir [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 22 22.1 Sami Meyers [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 23 23.1 David Smith [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

24 24.1 William Foster [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

If the plan change is not declined, as alternative relief the plan change should be amended to provide fair and sufficient mitigation and compensation (as outlined in the 24 24.2 William Foster [email protected] submission) to communities in the proposed area. 25 25.1 Hans Peter Ottow [email protected] Accept the Plan Modification

2 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary 26 26.1 James Isaacs [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 27 27.1 Thomas Ian Macfarlane [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 28 28.1 Wendy Sheffield [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 29 29.1 Matt Lomas [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 29 29.2 Matt Lomas [email protected] Convert the site to water reservoirs. 30 30.1 Julie Cook [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 31 31.1 Grant Agnew [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 32 32.1 Kenneth William Harcombe c/- Ken Harcombe [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 33 33.1 Kipi Sarich [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 34 34.1 Ruth Lois Minton [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Environs Holding Ltd environmental subsidy of Te 35 35.1 Uri o Hau Settlement Trust c/- Fiona Kemp [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

If the plan change is not declined, as alternative relief the plan change should be amended to address the environmental effects (outlined in the submission) as Environs Holding Ltd environmental subsidy of Te well as cultural and environment mitigation, offsetting, 35 35.2 Uri o Hau Settlement Trust c/- Fiona Kemp [email protected] and compensation. 36 36.1 Colin Graham Minton [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 37 37.1 Lemon Tree Bay Partnership c/- Greg Martin [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Waste Management NZ Limited 38 38.1 c/- Rachel Signal-Ross [email protected] Accept the Plan Modification

39 39.1 Susan Debra Thorne Speedy [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 40 40.1 Denise Civil & Ian Civil [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 41 41.1 Rohan Arlidge [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

42 42.1 Lisa Outwin [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

3 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

43 43.1 Kate Leslie [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

44 44.1 Anna Ingham [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] 45 45.1 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

Provide Ngati Whatua Orakei the opportunity to co- create a partnership that will assist our communities to Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] manage waste in a way that puts Papatuanuku and our 45 45.2 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] community at the centre of decision making.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] methods, and rules to address adverse effects on the 45 45.3 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] whenua and awa of the Kaipara Harbour.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, methods, and rules to address adverse effects on the Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] exercise of kaitiakitanga by mana whenua iwi, hapu and 45 45.4 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] whanau.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] methods, and rules to address adverse effects on future 45 45.5 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] generations. If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, methods, and rules to address adverse effects on the Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] exercise of rahui by mana whenua iwi, hapu and 45 45.6 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] whenua.

4 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] methods, and rules to address adverse effects on the 45 45.7 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] terrestrial, aquatic and esturarine environments.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] methods, and rules to address adverse effects on 45 45.8 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] climatic destruction.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] methods, and rules to address adverse effects on 45 45.9 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] natural character and landscape.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, methods, and rules to address adverse effects on Ngati Whatua Orakei c/- Renata Blair and [email protected] communities in close proximity to the landfill, in relation 45 45.10 c/- Andrew Brown [email protected] to traffic, amenity, odour and noise.

46 46.1 Jung Hee Kwak [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

47 47.1 Cushla Salt [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

48 48.1 Leon Salt [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

49 49.1 Brendda Salt [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

5 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

50 50.1 Greg Doherty [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

51 51.1 Florian Juergen Rolf Primbs [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

52 52.1 Rhonda Whitehead & Quentin Jukes [email protected] Oppose the plan modification

53 53.1 Anna Harriet Pendred [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 54 54.1 Lance Taylor [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 55 55.1 Rachel Stansfield [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 56 56.1 Rachel Honey [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 57 57.1 Kathryn Elizabeth Evans [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

Fight the Tip Tiaki te Whenua Incorporated c/- 58 58.1 Michelle Carmichael [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

59 59.1 Chelsea Benita Joanne Solomon-Waikawa [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

60 60.1 Sarah Mcpherson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

61 61.1 Melanie Marnet [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

62 62.1 Bioenergy Association c/- Brian Cox [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 63 63.1 Rochelle Rodgers [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

64 64.1 Michelle Carmichael [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 65 65.1 Graham Chan and Sue Perry [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 66 66.1 Jodi Ellis [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

6 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary If the plan change is not declined, as alternative relief the plan change should be amended to require 500m of riparian planting along the Hoteo River (regardless of 66 66.2 Jodi Ellis [email protected] who owns the land). 67 67.1 Patrick Joseph Wildermoth [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 68 68.1 Haley Clarke c/- Haley Hinewai Clarke [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 69 69.1 Maurice and Karen Purdy [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 70 70.1 Mary HauTai Tepuea Wirihana [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Warkworth Country House c/- Alan Gilbert von 71 71.1 Tunzelman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

72 72.1 Penelope Jane Smith [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 73 73.1 William Graham O'Meara [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 74 74.1 Results Plus Limited c/- Peter Foster [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 75 75.1 Antony Pai [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

76 76.1 Tracy Isobel New c/- George New [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Manuel-Pou Family Whanau c/- Francis Jackie Pou 77 77.1 Maroroa [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

78 78.1 Angela Bridson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 79 79.1 Catherine Braham [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 80 80.1 Oxana Haque [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 81 81.1 Nick Merwood [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 82 82.1 Ian Sarney [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

83 83.1 Denis Bourke [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

7 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

84 84.1 Sylvia Taylor [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification The site should instead be used for a dam harvesting 84 84.2 Sylvia Taylor [email protected] water. Add a new objective which states "The Auckland Regional Landfill recognises the importance of the existing pipeline infrastructure as assets which are regionally and nationally significant and will ensure that 85 85.1 First Gas Limited c/- Nicola Hine [email protected] they are protected and enabled"

Amend I617.2 as follows (new text underlined) "The overlay, Auckland-wide and zone objectives apply in this precinct in addition to those specified above, except where there is conflict, in which case these objectives take precedence excepting those objectives contained 85 85.2 First Gas Limited c/- Nicola Hine [email protected] with Chapters B3 and E26."

Add a new policy which states "The Auckland Regional Landfill is designed, constructed, upgraded, and operated so that adverse effects on existing 85 85.3 First Gas Limited c/- Nicola Hine [email protected] infrastructure are avoided or mitigated."

Amend I617.3 as follows (new text underlined) "The underlying zone, Auckland-wide and overlay policies apply in this precinct in addition to those specified above, except where there is conflict, in which case these policies take precedence excepting those policies 85 85.4 First Gas Limited c/- Nicola Hine [email protected] contained with Chapters B3 and E26."

8 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Support the retention of activities A4, A5 and A15 in the 85 85.5 First Gas Limited c/- Nicola Hine [email protected] precinct table as notified

Amend I617.6.1 and I6`7.6.2 to include the standard "Any activity within 20m of existing infrastructure shall require the written authorisation from the infrastructure 85 85.6 First Gas Limited c/- Nicola Hine [email protected] assest owner." 86 86.1 F J and J Shewan [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 87 87.1 Keita Miru [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 88 88.1 Dave Salisbury [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 89 89.1 Grahame Powell [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 90 90.1 Thomas Gregory Parsons [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 91 91.1 Duncan Johnson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 92 92.1 David Fletcher c/- Dave Fletcher [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 93 93.1 Melanie Mayall-Nahi [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 94 94.1 Jeff Smith [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

95 95.1 Alexander Robert Doig Woodward [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

96 96.1 Bridgit Bretherton-Jones [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

97 97.1 Lee Laughton [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 98 98.1 Steven Pigott [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 99 99.1 Irihaapeti Tewhata [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 100 100.1 David Bruce Mason [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

9 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Amend the plan change provisions after further technical work to establish the appropriate ARI, the size of the associated rainfall event, and the capability of the 100 100.2 David Bruce Mason [email protected] proposed design to accommodate such an event.

Amend the plan change provisions so that Waste Management NZ retains full responsibility for the site until the flow of lechate and methane has been 100 100.3 David Bruce Mason [email protected] demonstrated to be permanently finished.

Amend the plan change provisions to ensure there are minimum periodic maintenance requirements for the 100 100.4 David Bruce Mason [email protected] grass cap.

Amend the plan change provisions so that storm water defences used for the live phase of the landfill can be retained to screen physical debris from flowing 100 100.5 David Bruce Mason [email protected] downstream.

Amend the plan change provisions so that methane and letchate are determinted to have ceased when they have 100 100.6 David Bruce Mason [email protected] returned to background levels for 24 months continuous.

Amend the plan change provisions so that a fund to facilitate ongoing maintenance in perpetuity is provided based on external advice of its size once the 100 100.7 David Bruce Mason [email protected] maintenance costs are fully identified.

10 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Amend the plan change provisions so that a bond (separate from the fund) is provided to remediate unexpected events (using external risk management 100 100.8 David Bruce Mason [email protected] advice).

101 101.1 Mark Oliver [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 102 102.1 R Krieg [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 103 103.1 Dean Yarndley [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 104 104.1 Caroline Milner [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 105 105.1 Janne Radtke [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 106 106.1 Karma Cooper [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

107 107.1 Mikaera Miru [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 108 108.1 Paul Surman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

109 109.1 For the Love of Bees c/- Sarah Smuts-Kennedy [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

110 110.1 Dedrie Trnjanin [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 111 111.1 Alistair de Joux [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification If the plan change is not declined, a smaller 111 111.2 Alistair de Joux [email protected] landfill(below 25m tonnes) should be considered.

If the plan change is not declined, changes should be made to protect the full root zone of large significant 111 111.3 Alistair de Joux [email protected] trees (that could be damaged by roading activities).

11 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

If the plan change is not declined, the ecological benefits and compensation package should be increased, to require an exemplary programme of forest management to incorporate: harvessting the commerical pine plantation with a way which will minimise hydrological impacts of clear felling, management of wattle forest with the aim of eventually restoring these areas to native vegetation and habitat, and full conservation of the pine 111 111.4 Alistair de Joux [email protected] plantatio to permanent native forest.

If the plan change is not declined, there should be a limit imposed for the future catchment areas (i.e. where 111 111.5 Alistair de Joux [email protected] waste comes from) for the landfill.

112 112.1 Shannon Greenwood [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification The New Zealand Transport Agency 113 113.1 c/- Evan Keating [email protected] Support the retention of I617 Objective 3

Support the retention of the discretionary status for The New Zealand Transport Agency construction and operation of landfills and ancillary 113 113.2 c/- Evan Keating [email protected] activities in Activity Table I167.4.1

The New Zealand Transport Agency Support the requirement for public notification of any 113 113.3 c/- Evan Keating [email protected] application for landfill activities in I617.5

The New Zealand Transport Agency Support the insertion of a precinct plan (I617.10) into the 113 113.4 c/- Evan Keating [email protected] Auckland Unitary Plan Stargazers B&B and Astronomy Tours 114 114.1 c/- Alastair Brickell [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 115 115.1 Fern Sutherland [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

12 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Amend the objectives, policies, and assessment criteria to incoporate address traffic effects on the wider roading network (particularly in regards to the SH1/Goatley 116 116.1 Skywork Helicopters Limited c/- Burnette O’Connor [email protected] Rd/Kaipara Flats Rd intersection) Amend the objectives, policies, and assessment criteria to incoporate address traffic effects on the wider roading network (particularly in regards to the SH1/Goatley 117 117.1 Goatley Holdings Limited c/- Burnette O’Connor [email protected] Rd/Kaipara Flats Rd intersection) 118 118.1 Phillip Tomlinson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

119 119.1 Julie Pescud [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

Amend the precinct provisions to appropriately recognise the importance of the Regional Aquifer for the municipal Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & water supply for Wellsford, Warkworth and other 120 120.1 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] northern towns now and in the future.

Amend the precinct provisions to recognise and protect against the potential cumulative adverse effects of Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & multiple filling pits on the recharge of the Regional 120 120.2 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] Aquifer.

Amend the precinct provisions to recognise and protect against the risk of contamination of the Regional Aquifer Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & arising from the additional bores required for future 120 120.3 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] landfills.

13 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Amend the precinct provisions to require Watercare to be notified immediately of any contamination breach to the Regional Aquifer arising from activities within the precinct, and timely reporting on the mitigation or Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & minimisation of the effects arising from the breach as per 120 120.4 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] the approved contingency plans.

Add text (underlined) to the precinct description to state "The precinct anticipates that future landfill activities may utilise the Waitemata Regional Aquifer for water supply. Watercare uses (or has plans to use) the Waitemata Regional Aquifer to provide municipal water supply to the rapidly growing towns of Warkworth, Wellsford and other northern towns. The precinct provisions protect this aquifer from potential contamination or adverse water quantity effects that may compromise this municipal water supply, and through that the health and wellbeing of the residents of these towns. The objectives and policies of this precinct require an assessment of Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & potential adverse effects on this aquifer and for future 120 120.5 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] landfill activities to avoid adverse effects on the aquifer."

Add a new objective (underlined) to the precinct to recognise the significance of, and protect the Regional Aquifer with the suggested wording "Adverse water Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & quality and quantity effects on the Waitematata Regional 120 120.6 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] Aquifer from activities within the precinct are avoided."

14 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Amend the precinct policies (underlined/struckthrough) as follows "1. Enable the development and continued operation of the Auckland Regional Landfill, and the Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & associated renewable energy generation where it does 120 120.7 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] not result in unacceptable adverse effects."

Amend the precinct policies (underlined/struckthrough) as follows "3. Discharges of contaminants into water, land and air from the Auckland Regional Landfill's construction and operations shall avoid where practicable, and otherwise minimise: … d. adverse effects on the water quality of catchments and aquifers that provide water for domestic and municipal supply; and ... X. activities with the precinct shall avoid any adverse effects on the water quality and quantity of the Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & Waitemata Regional aqifer that provides water for 120 120.8 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] domestic and municipal supply."

Amend the precinct policies (underlined/struckthrough) as follows "6. Where effects cannot be avoided, remedied or mitigated, provide for offsetting or compensation, thereby enabling the Auckland Regional Landfill as infrastructure, while recognising that: ... c. offsetting and compensation is not appropriate in relation to adverse effects on the water quality and quantity of Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & catchments and aquifers that provide water for domestic 120 120.9 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] and municipal supply."

15 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & Support a Discretionary activity status for new landfills in 120 120.10. Lindsay Wilson [email protected] Sub-precinct A (Table I617.4.1 (A1))

Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & Support a Non-complying activity status for new landfills 120 120.11 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] outside Sub-precinct A (Table I617.4.1 (A4))

Support a Non-complying activity status any landfill activity that does not comply with the restricted Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & discretionary or discretionary activity standards (Table 120 120.12 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] I617.4.1 (A15))

Clarify that under Table I617.4.1 (A3) discharges to land and water from landfills in Sub-precinct A are a Non- complying activity when the land use consent is Non- Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & complying (including when the precinct standards are not 120 120.13 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] met).

Clarify what activities the term "landfill activity" is Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & intended to cover (including assurance that it does not 120 120.14 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] cover water take activities).

Clarify that the provisions of Chapter E2 of the Unitary Plan (which address water quantity, allocation, and use) continue to apply to the precinct OR if this is not the case add additional policies and activity standards to Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & ensure that activities within the precinct do not result in 120 120.15 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] adverse effects on the quantity of the Regional Aquifer.

16 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Amend I617.5 so that discharges to land and water from new and existing landfills in Sub-precinct A are subject to public notification (new text underlined): "I617.5 Notification … 2. Any application under Rule I617.4.1. Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & (A1), (A2), (A3), (A4), (A5), (A7), or (A15) will be publicly 120 120.16 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] notifed."

Amend the Restricted discretionary and Discretionary activity standards (I617.6(1) and (2)) to protect the Regional Aquifer, provide scope for Watercare to meet its obligations under the Health Act, and the Council to meet its obligations under the NES. The amended standards must include (but are not limited to): monitoring requirements (including detail on frequency, parameters, trigger levels, and contingency planning with consideration of the NZ Drinking Water Standards and the Australian and NZ Guidelines for Fresh and Marine Water Quality (ANZG); and management plan requirements for future landfill consents, including Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & provision for consultation with and notification to 120 120.17 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] Watercare.

Amend the matters of discretion in I617.8.1 (new text underlined) as follows: "2. For other discharges from all restricted discreiontary activities (A7): … x. the ability to Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & avoid adverse effects on the water quality and quantity of 120 120.18 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] the Regional Aquifer supplying municipal water."

17 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Amend the assessment criteria in I617.8.2 (new text underlined, deleted text struckthrough) as follows: "The Council will consider the relevant assessment criteria below for restricted discretionary activities: 1. Potential adverse effects (including cumulative effects) are Watercare Services Limited c/- Shane Morgan & appropriately minimised or mitigated avoided, taking into 120 120.19 Lindsay Wilson [email protected] consideration the following"..." 121 121.1 Nicholas Dunning [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 122 122.1 Kevin and Dawn Bayliss c/- Dawn Bayliss [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 123 123.1 Anne Smith [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Forest and Bird Warkworth Area 124 124.1 c/- Roger Lewis Williams [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

If the plan change is not declined, then carbon emissions Forest and Bird Warkworth Area should be significantly reduced by carrying as much of 124 124.2 c/- Roger Lewis Williams [email protected] the waste as possible by rail.

If the plan change is not declined, then amend the Forest and Bird Warkworth Area conditions of consent to meet the submitter's concerns 124 124.3 c/- Roger Lewis Williams [email protected] over transparency. 125 125.1 Lorraine Brien [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 126 126.1 Marie Esther Alpe [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

127 127.1 Joanne Mary O'Sullivan [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 128 128.1 Deborah Sarney [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Trustee, T B Ross-Wood Family Trust 129 129.1 c/- Tracy Belinda Wood [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 130 130.1 Elizabeth Joan Dowling [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

18 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

131 131.1 Fiona Penetana [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

[email protected] and 132 132.1 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, [email protected] and methods, and rules to address adverse effects on the 132 132.2 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] whenua and awa of the Kaipara Harbour.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, methods, and rules to address adverse effects on the [email protected] and exercise of kaitiakitanga by Ngati Whatua iwi, hapu and 132 132.3 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] whanau.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, [email protected] and methods, and rules to address adverse effects on future 132 132.4 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] generations of Ngati Whatua people.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, methods, and rules to address adverse effects on the [email protected] and exercise of rahui by Ngati Whatua iwi, hapu and 132 132.5 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] whenua.

19 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, [email protected] and methods, and rules to address adverse effects on the 132 132.6 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] terrestrial, aquatic and esturarine environments.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, [email protected] and methods, and rules to address adverse effects on 132 132.7 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] climatic destruction.

If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, [email protected] and methods, and rules to address adverse effects on 132 132.8 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] natural character and landscape. If the plan change is not declined, then substantial amendments to the description, objectives, policies, methods, and rules to address adverse effects on [email protected] and communities in close proximity to the landfill, in relation 132 132.9 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] to traffic, amenity, odour and noise.

Council halt discussions with WMNZ and provide iwi the opportunity to co-create a partnership that will assist our communities to manage waste in a way that puts [email protected] and Papatuanuku and our community at the centre of 132 132.10 Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua c/- Rob Enright [email protected] decision making.

133 133.1 Northfork Farms Ltd c/- Wendy Crow-Jones [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

20 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Amend the objectives and policies to include the following additional objective and policy: "Objective - The Auckland Regional Landfill is designed and operated so as to avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse effects on the transport network" "Policy - Require any development to provide access and manage operations so as to support safe and efficient movement of vehicles, in particular heavy vehicles, accessing the site to or from the public road 134 134.1 Auckland Transport c/- Katherine Dorofaeff [email protected] network."

Retain the discretionary activity status for (A1) Landfill in 134 134.2 Auckland Transport c/- Katherine Dorofaeff [email protected] Sub-precinct A. Amend I617.9 Special information requirements to include the following: "Information about how the proposed use or occupation of any legal roads within the precinct, including any informed or partly formed roads will be managed. Where any legal roads are affected, information about consultation and/or applications for road stopping undertaken with Auckland Transport, including any recommendations or decisions from 134 134.3 Auckland Transport c/- Katherine Dorofaeff [email protected] Auckland Transport." 135 135.1 Susan Lewis [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 136 136.1 Leane Makey [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

180 Monarch Downs 137 137.1 Alex Schenz Warkworth 0982 Decline the Plan Modification

138 138.1 Ngati Manuhiri Settlement Trust c/- Pieter Tuinder [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

21 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Complete an assessment to establish the age of the cottage and farm building to determine the presence of Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga any 19th century structural elements of archaeological 139 139.1 c/- Susan Andrews [email protected] and heritage values.

Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga Assess the cottage and farm building in relation to 139 139.2 c/- Susan Andrews [email protected] broader historic heritage values.

Record any heritage features on the Auckland Council Cultural Heritage Inventory and (for any pre-1900 Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga c/- Susan features) recorded as an archaeological site on the NZ 139 139.3 Andrews [email protected] Archaeological Association database.

140 140.1 Uriah Lee [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

141 141.1 Miriama Marion Walters [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

142 142.1 Murray Macdonald [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 143 143.1 Te Ohu Kaimoana c/- Monique Holmes [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

144 144.1 Riley Hathaway [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

145 145.1 Jodi Pretscherer [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

146 146.1 Leihia Wilson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

If the plan change is not declined, as alternative relief the plan change should be amended to address the environmental effects (outlined in the submission) as well as cultural and environment mitigation, offsetting, 146 146.2 Leihia Wilson [email protected] and compensation.

22 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

Federated Farmers of New Zealand (Auckland 147 147.1 Province) Incorporated c/- Peter Richard Gardner [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

148 148.1 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

If the plan change is not declined, any precinct should not cover the whole site as "landfill" but be identified at a more appropriate scale and avoid Natural Stream Management Areas, Wetlands Management Areas, and 148 148.2 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] Signficant Ecological Areas. If the plan change is not declined, then the use of the term "landfill" should be reconsidered as it may hinder other waste management related acitivites (e.g. waste 148 148.3 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] sorting for reuse).

If the plan change is not declined, then a clear rationale 148 148.4 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] needs to be provided for Sub-precinct 2. If the plan change is not declined, the tests that are applied to acitivites within waterbodies and their margins (and Natural Stream Management Areas) should not be 148 148.5 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] relaxed.

If the plan change is not declined, then the boundaries of the aeras of ecological significance within the site should be subject to being redrafted based on ground-truthed 148 148.6 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] assessments.

23 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

If the plan change is not declined, then the provisions should reflect that in some instances avoidance of adverse effects is required to protect values and should 148 148.7 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] not be subject to caveats.

If the plan change is not declined, then it should be amended so that it is not at the applicant's discretion to decide whether residual adverse effects are 148 148.8 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] compensated. If the plan change is not declined, further jusitifcation is required as to why the overarching provisions in the Unitary Plan (e.g. ecology) are not appropriate for the 148 148.9 Department of Conservation c/- Chris Rendall [email protected] precinct. Ngā Māunga Whakahii o Kaipara Development 149 149.1 Trust c/- Jane Sherard [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

150 150.1 Hayley Gillespie [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

151 151.1 Susan Tomlinson c/- Susan Lorraine Tomlinson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 152 152.1 Ella Rickit [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

153 153.1 Heidi Burchett [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Waterfall farm (Waiwhiu) Limited c/- Bridgit 154 154.1 Bretherton-Jones [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 155 155.1 Kim Lewin [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 156 156.1 Craig Watson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 157 157.1 Nicola Kaye Morrison [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

158 158.1 Dean Gerrard [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

24 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

159 159.1 Shona Oliver [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification All of the area required to operate the private airfield 160 160.1 Andrew Wallace [email protected] should carry a separate airport precinct.

If the plan change is not declined, amend the plan change to require the airfield to be subdivided from the 160 160.2 Andrew Wallace [email protected] rest of the property. 161 161.1 Chloe Thompson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 162 162.1 Gareth Moon [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 163 163.1 New Zealand Native Riverwood c/- Glenn Ruddell [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 164 164.1 Ricardo Castillo [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

165 165.1 Charlotte King [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 166 166.1 Susan Crockett [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 167 167.1 Linda M Clapham [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

168 168.1 Donald George Scandrett [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 169 169.1 Emma Woolcock [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 170 170.1 Ruth Morrow [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 171 171.1 Corene Humphreys [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 172 172.1 Hanna Kloosterboer [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 173 173.1 John Taylor [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 174 174.1 Lawrence Bruce Whistler [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 175 175.1 Christopher Paul Riley [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 176 176.1 Craig Purvis [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

25 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

177 177.1 Kirstin Lawson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 178 178.1 Kathleen Smith [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 179 179.1 Andrew Scott [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 180 180.1 Sylvia Irene Adams [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

181 181.1 Fleur Tomlinson c/- Phil Tomlinson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 182 182.1 Lesley Munro [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Making Everything Achievable Ltd 183 183.1 c/- Kaye Maree Dunn [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

184 184.1 Ngadia Jones [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 185 185.1 Reina Penney [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 186 186.1 Susan Elizabeth Stevens [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 187 187.1 Haley Rebecca Warman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 188 188.1 Eliana Darroch [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

189 189.1 Chris Jensen [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 190 190.1 John Tiernan [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification [email protected] 191 191.1 Glenn Clark Decline the Plan modification

192 192.1 Zoe Duffy [email protected] Oppose the plan modification

192 192.2 Zoe Duffy [email protected] DevelopFind an alternative a culture of site. waste recycling and build the 192 192.3 Zoe Duffy [email protected] industry to generate energy from waste. 193 193.1 Barbara Just [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

193 193.2 Barbara Just [email protected] Investigate other options to dispose of waste.

26 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary 194 194.1 Paul Shepherd [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification [email protected] 195 195.1 Charlotte Rudolph Decline the Plan Modification

196 196.1 Till Schlimme [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

197 197.1 Russell Braham [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

198 198.1 Mr Allen and Mrs Dorothy Dove [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 199 199.1 Lisa Knight [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

200 200.1 Anna Steedman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Council should delay deciding this matter so the public 200 200.2 Anna Steedman [email protected] can understand it better 201 201.1 Alex Natiso [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

202 202.1 Cassandra Kingi - Waru [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 203 203.1 Christiane Anania [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 204 204.1 Dallas Taylor [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 205 205.1 Darren Povey [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

206 206.1 Hanuere Nicholls [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 207 207.1 Hemi Tapurau [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 208 208.1 Hugh Wilson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 209 209.1 Irena Roulston [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

210 210.1 Janice Gradner [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

27 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary 8 King Court Ave 211 211.1 Kathleen Helen Phillips Dargaville 0310 Decline the Plan Modification

212 212.1 Kelly Retimana [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 213 213.1 Lynette Chapman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

3132 Kaipara Coast Highway 214 214.1 Marama Pairania Glorit RD4 Warkworth 0984 Decline the Plan Modification

215 215.1 Michael Waru [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

216 216.1 Nikau Nicholls [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

217 217.1 Sam Nathan [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

218 218.1 Toko Retimana [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

219 219.1 Virginia Wati [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 220 220.1 Waimarie Povey- Nicholls [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Kotare Research and Education for Social Change in Aotearoa Charitable Trust 221 221.1 c/- David Parker [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

222 222.1 Christopher James Fulop [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

223 223.1 Daniel Vladimir Fulop [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

224 224.1 Jacquelene Rahera Tibbits [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

225 225.1 Janaya Stephens [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

28 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

226 226.1 Jeremy Joseph Fulop [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

227 227.1 Kathryn Joy Fulop [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 34 Kaihu Wood Road 228 228.1 Gary Dixon Kaihu 0379 Decline the Plan Modification

229 229.1 Fraser Jordan Brown [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

230 230.1 Patricia Mary Curtis [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

231 231.1 Karen-Ann Ward [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

232 232.1 Elizabeth Grace Dempster Tree [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 76 Wilson Road 233 233.1 Kevin Ward Wellsford 0972 Decline the Plan Modification

234 234.1 Julia Ruth Nevill [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

235 235.1 Michael John Tree [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

236 236.1 Ryan Breen [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

37 Queen Street 237 237.1 Kiern Wood Riverhead 0820 Decline the Plan Modification

238 238.1 Joshua Taitimu Moore [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

3 Beachcomber Road 239 239.1 Grant McCarthy Mangawhai Heads 0505 Decline the Plan Modification

28 Taylor Road 240 240.1 Wade Alan Cornish Waimauku 0882 Decline the Plan Modification

29 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

17 North Crescent 241 241.1 Luka May Staveley Kaukapakapa 0873 Decline the Plan Modification

15 Puriri Street 242 242.1 Donna Marie Tapurau Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

3 Jordan Road 243 243.1 Martika Panui Kaukapakapa 0984 Decline the Plan Modification 3 Jordan Road 244 244.1 Fraserina Panui RD 4 Warkworth 0984 Decline the Plan Modification 3 Jordan Road 245 245.1 McCaela Panui Kaukapakapa 0984 Decline the Plan Modification

26 Makiri Street 246 246.1 Edith Samson Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

247 247.1 Te Kahuiiti Ote Haahi Ratana Morehu [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

248 248.1 David & Marietta Van Dam [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 249 249.1 Alex Van Dam [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 99B Rautawhiri Road 250 250.1 Justus Lanigan Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

99B Rautawhiri Road 251 251.1 Simon Perawiti Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification RD3 Mcpike Road 252 252.1 Moana Beazley RD3 Waimauku 0883 Decline the Plan Modification

253 253.1 Angela Pauline Perawiti [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

220 Centreway Road 254 254.1 Leslie King Noda Orewa 0931 Decline the Plan Modification

30 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary 255 255.1 Judith Mary Standing [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

256 256.1 Waratah Taogaga [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

257 257.1 June Taipeti [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

258 258.1 Kelly Taipeti [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

259 259.1 April Jan Ashton [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

260 260.1 Carmel Rata [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 261 261.1 Otere Tapurau [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Appartment IA/19 Fleet street 262 262.1 Clay De Boer Eden Terrace 1021 Decline the Plan Modification

263 263.1 Therese Van Dam [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 264 264.1 Linda Gail Wichman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

265 265.1 Topeora Penetana [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 266 266.1 Dianne Kidd [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

267 267.1 Mercer RT Family [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 28 Puriri Street 268 268.1 Kura Goere Watson Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

269 269.1 Suzanne Clark Taipete [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

270 270.1 Irene Hogan [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

16 Hethering Road 271 271.1 Ahannon Povey Ranui Auckland 0612 Decline the Plan Modification

31 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

49 Waimolco Glen 272 272.1 Quentin Povey Swanson 0614 Decline the Plan Modification

33 Chic Gardens 273 273.1 Deveraux Nachyes Christan Tangaroa Preea Parakai 0830 Decline the Plan Modification

274 274.1 Connie Povey [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

275 275.1 Linsey Smith [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

276 276.1 Te Rongopai Ote Haahi Ratana Morehu [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 33 Chic Gardens 277 277.1 George Samson Parakai 0830 Decline the Plan Modification

278 278.1 Glendith Mercia Samson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

26 Makiri Street 279 279.1 Isaac Samson Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

2324A State Highway 16 280 280.1 Shirley Welsby Te Pua Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

281 281.1 Amisha O'Brien [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

F1/S Rata Street 282 282.1 Horowai Hereora Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

20 Leigh Terrace 283 283.1 Wayne Rnodes Glenfield 0629 Decline the Plan Modification

284 284.1 Rachel Stirling [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

104 Haranui Road 285 285.1 Terina Rapana Hemana Southhead Parakai 0874 Decline the Plan Modification

32 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary 116 Burnside Road 286 286.1 Henry Benjamin Rameka RD3 Kaukapakapa 0873 Decline the Plan Modification 12 Blackridge Road 287 287.1 Jeremy Clark Karaka 2850 Decline the Plan Modification

116 Burnside Road 288 288.1 Robert Kelly Hautawaho Rameka RD3 Kaukapakapa 0873 Decline the Plan Modification 20 Leigh Terrace 289 289.1 Maraea Rameka Glenfield 0629 Decline the Plan Modification

116 Burnside Road 290 290.1 Teihana Wremu Rameka RD3 Kaukapakapa 0873 Decline the Plan Modification 116 Burnside Road 291 291.1 Catherine Ann Rameka RD3 Kaukapakapa 0873 Decline the Plan Modification

4/5 Rata Street 292 292.1 Ripeka Nahi Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

116 Burnside Road 293 293.1 Shani Jana Kinikini RD3 Kaukapakapa 0873 Decline the Plan Modification 42 Northfield road 294 294.1 Temiringa Sherman Waitakere Auckland 0614 Decline the Plan Modification

19 Mangakura Road 295 295.1 Campbell Tapurau Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification 296 296.1 Angela Susan Dickson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 297 297.1 Rebecca Inwood Mohe [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

298 298.1 Waratah Hinerangi Eruera [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

299 299.1 Tearohanui Hatley [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

33 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

300 300.1 Judy Kennedy [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 9/9 Springs Road 301 301.1 Barbara Te Pou Henana Parakai 0830 Decline the Plan Modification

302 302.1 Deborah Anne Pickstone [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

12 Blackridge Road 303 303.1 Darlene Ann Clark Karaka 2850 Decline the Plan Modification

2294 Kaipara Coast Highway 304 304.1 Graham Brian Patrick Dawson RD4 Warkworth 0984 Decline the Plan Modification

305 305.1 Teresa Rose Wilson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

Cathill 295 M Gubb Road Port Albert 306 306.1 Arthur Geoffrey Pickstone Wellsford 0973 Decline the Plan Modification

2296 Kaipara Coast Highway 16 307 307.1 Lavinia Komene RD4 Warkworth 0984 Decline the Plan Modification 2296 Kaipara Coast Highway 16 308 308.1 Kapowairua Komene RD4 Warkworth 0984 Decline the Plan Modification

309 309.1 Sharon L Robertson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

F1/S Rata Street 310 310.1 Gessie Moki Rice Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification Unit 2 Reweti Marae 1285 State Highway 16 311 311.1 Pute Kidwell Waimanuku 0881 Decline the Plan Modification

34 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

312 312.1 Dianne Sheryle Clark [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 42 Northfield road 313 313.1 Nathan James Iti & Nate Tapurau Waitakere 0614 Decline the Plan Modification

Unit 4 1285 South Highway 16 314 314.1 Keverne Vaughan Clark Waimauku Auckland 0883 Decline the Plan Modification 315 315.1 Te Inu Muru [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 316 316.1 Gerald Panui [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 317 317.1 Josie Porter [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

318 318.1 Obe Simeon Porter [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 319 319.1 Louise Ann Porter [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

320 320.1 Janice Rae Porter [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

321 321.1 Annabelle Rose Porter [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 322 322.1 Eruera Manu Emery Berg Mackinven [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

323 323.1 Hoani Neri Porter [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 1/1285 State Highway 16 324 324.1 Joe Warren Timoti Waimauku Auckland 0883 Decline the Plan Modification

Unit 2/1285 State Highway 16 325 325.1 Ana Miria Kidwell Waimauku Auckland 0883 Decline the Plan Modification

17 Mcpike Road 326 326.1 Eujene Robert Nathan RD3 Waimauku 0883 Decline the Plan Modification

35 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

17 Mcpike Road 327 327.1 Lydia Jane Nathan RD3 Waimuku Auckland 0883 Decline the Plan Modification 17 Mcpike Road 328 328.1 Louis Nathan RD3 Waimauku 0883 Decline the Plan Modification

1457 State Highway 16 329 329.1 Jeanine Ngaioma Davis RD3 Waimauku 0883 Decline the Plan Modification 10 Empressa Heights 330 330.1 Bernette Rosalie Malizia Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

12 Nelson Street 331 331.1 Ronald Robert Cowper Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

12 Nelson Street 332 332.1 Noelene Trorence Cowper Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

333 333.1 Julie Urquhart [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

2324 State Highway 16 334 334.1 Daryn Ray Holloway Helensville 0875 Decline the Plan Modification 335 335.1 Eileen Taogaga [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

11/9 Springs Road 336 336.1 Bethany Thurston Parakai Helensville 0830 Decline the Plan Modification 337 337.1 Don Urquhart [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

2294 Kaipara Coast Highway 338 338.1 Lovinia Tearoha Hatley Kaukapakapa 0984 Decline the Plan Modification

5/9 Springs Road 339 339.1 Amiiria Hemana Parakai 0830 Decline the Plan Modification

36 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary 340 340.1 Rita Lorraine Olsen [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 341 341.1 Gail VauReemst [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

21 Willjames Avenue 342 342.1 Robert Bradley Sutcliffe Algies Bay 0920 Decline the Plan Modification 343 343.1 David Allan Beattie [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 344 344.1 Pamela Beattie [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 345 345.1 Kate Blenkinsopp [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 346 346.1 Miriam Connor [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 347 347.1 Sarah Blenkinsopp [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

129 Mairetahi Road 348 348.1 Helen Smith Helensville 0874 Decline the Plan Modification

349 349.1 Jeannete Forde [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

76 Wilson Road 350 350.1 Lyn Cajne-Ward Wellsford 0972 Decline the Plan Modification

3539 Kaipara Coast Highway 351 351.1 Teresa Kawena RD4 Warkworth 0984 Decline the Plan Modification 352 352.1 Sheryl Isobel Pilkington [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

353 353.1 Satya Donna Foster [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

354 354 .1 Glorit War Memorial Hall Committee [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

355 355.1 Wendy Carr [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 356 356.1 Rupert Harvey Mather [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

37 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary

356 356.2 Rupert Harvey Mather [email protected] Reduce the size of the area to be zoned [precinct area] 356 356.3 Rupert Harvey Mather [email protected] Reduce capacity of landfill and number of users

356 356.4 Rupert Harvey Mather [email protected] Have a defined life expectancy of the operation

457 Kiwi Tahi Road 357 357.1 Grant Barry Hope RD2 Helensville 0875 Decline the Plan Modification

457 Kiwi Tahi Road 358 358.1 Bridget Leonard RD2 Helensville 0875 Decline the Plan Modification 359 Not allocated 114 Parkhurst Road 360 360.1 Izaac Povey Parakai 0830 Decline the Plan Modification

361 361.1 Pautahi Marae c/- Cherie Dawn Povey [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 362 362.1 Dennis Winston Shepherd [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 363 363.1 Valerie Shepherd [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 364 364.1 Holly Southernwood [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

365 365.1 Judith-Anne Newman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 366 366.1 James Alexander Newman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 367 367.1 Rita Carol Donovan [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 368 368.1 Daniel Robert Donovan [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

369 269.1 Jesse Williams [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

370 370.1 Dr Dory Reeves [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

371 371.1 Jessica Jane Donovan [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

38 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary Sir Graeme Dingle and Jo-anne Wilkinson, 372 372.1 Lady Dingle [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

373 373.1 Peter Graeme Stretch [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Require the applicant to build a grade 2 cycle trail that is more than 500m from the operational landfill, including 373 373.2 Peter Graeme Stretch [email protected] access and service roads

374 374.1 Paenui Tapurau 1a Mangakura Road, Helensville 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

375 375.1 Andrew Short [email protected] Consider alternative technologies for waste disposal 376 376.1 Alan Riwaka [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

377 Not allocated

Aotearoa (NZ) Sustainability Foundation 378 378.1 c/- Dudley Edgar James Ward [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification Aotearoa (NZ) Sustainability Foundation If PC42 is not declined, then amend to be consistent with 378 378.2 c/- Dudley Edgar James Ward [email protected] the points raised in submission.

Clarify whether this precinct would set a precedent for 379 379.1 D C Webster [email protected] other landfills 380 380.1 Penne-Ann Huston [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 12 Downer Street 381 381.1 Raewyn Anita Huston Helensville, Auckland 0800 Decline the Plan Modification

382 382.1 Rosilyn Gelderman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

383 383.1 Craig William MacPherson [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 384 384.1 Kura Foreman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

385 385.1 Clarence Foreman [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

39 of 40 Plan Change 42 (Private) - Auckland Regional Landfill Wayby Valley Summary of Decisions Requested

Sub Sub # Point Submitter Name Address for Service Summary 386 386.1 Katherine Rean [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

387 387.1 Alby Rean [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification 10 Higham Road 388 388.1 Graeme Stuart McLeod RD1, Helensville, Auckland 0874 Decline the Plan Modification

389 389.1 TRT Maori Flag c/- Kare Rata and Anthony Sinclair [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

390 390.1 Renoir Tapurau [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

33A Springs Road 391 391.1 Mikaere Tapurau Parakai, Auckland 0830 Decline the Plan Modification

392 392.1 Andrew John South [email protected] Decline the Plan Modification

33 Chic Gardens 393 393.1 Daniel Foreman Parakai Auckland 0830 Decline the Plan Modification

40 of 40