December 2009/January 2010 | Vol. 3 | No. 1
VirtualizationReview.com The Ultimate Virtualization
+ VDI Muscle Tussle: VMware vs. Citrix Mastering
Management
Project2 10/13/09 9:30 AM Page 1
Smarter technology for a Smarter Planet: Can an entire business be given a nervous system?
Today, instrumented devices connected by powerful service management systems are infusing intelligence into things like production equipment and supply chains, redefining the role of the infrastructure at the core of the enterprise. On a smarter planet, the datacenter is not simply the heart of IT—it’s also the central nervous system of the entire business. IBM is helping companies view their extended infrastructure not as a collection of disconnected pieces, but as an integrated system that connects the datacenter to all of the digital and physical assets of the business, creating a more dynamic infrastructure. From railway systems that can predict and schedule their own maintenance to power grids that match supply and demand, we’re already helping customers improve service, increase flexibility and reduce operating costs by as much as 50%. A smarter business needs smarter software, systems and services. Let’s build a smarter planet. ibm.com/infrastructure
IBM trad Project2 10/13/09 9:31 AM Page 2
IBM, the IBM logo, ibm.com, Smarter Planet and the planet icon are trademarks of International Business Machines Corp., registered in many jurisdictions worldwide. Other product and service names might be trademarks of IBM or other companies. A current list of IBM trademarks is available on the Web at www.ibm.com/legal/copytrade.shtml. © International Business Machines Corporation 2009. All rights reserved. Project1 10/13/09 9:52 AM Page 1
Start with Citrix XenServer™, the enterprise-class, cloud-proven virtualization platform — for free. Then, simply add Citrix Essentials™ for XenServer™ for the advanced management capabilities you need to maximize the scalability, resiliency and manageability of your virtualized environment.
• Streamline Accelerate application delivery; provision workloads on demand • Protect Implement cost-effective high availability and disaster recovery • Integrate Better leverage existing storage capacity and feature sets • Save Reduce license costs; consolidate servers; repurpose administrators
And if you’ve decided to go with Microsoft® Hyper-V™, you’ll want to add Citrix Essentials™ for Hyper-V™ to get advanced virtualization management capabilities for your Hyper-V and System Center environment.
Visit our Web site at www.citrix.com/XenServerVRACH and download our free white paper, Achieving the Lowest Server Virtualization TCO. And while you're there, if you haven't already, get started by downloading Citrix XenServer, for free.
© 2009 Citrix Systems, Inc. All rights reserved. Citrix® and Citrix Essentials™ are trademarks of Citrix Systems, Inc. and/or one or more of its subsidiaries, and may be registered in the United States Patent and Trademark Office and in other countries. All other trademarks and registered trademarks are property of their respective owners. VISIT VIRTUALIZATIONREVIEW.COM contents In order to help you make 14 the best virtualization choices, we have compiled and now offer this year’s version of The Ultimate Virtualization Buyer’s Guide.
“I’ve gotten to know readers through my blog, your comments in stories and your e-mails, and even met you face-to- face at various shows. You are what make this magazine worthwhile.”
Keith Ward, departing editor in chief of VR 32 PHOTO BY TERRY POWELL
DECEMBER 2009/JANUARY 2010 | VIRTUALIZATION REVIEW | VOL. 3, NO. 1
4 Online TOC FEATURES 28 Storage Virtualization 31 Ad/Edit Index 14 The 2010 Ultimate & Management Virtualization Buyer’s Guide 29 Thin Client UPFRONT The industry’s most 8 Point comprehensive print guide to 29 Virtual Networking XenDesktop: High Performance virtualization products. and Flexibility 29 Miscellaneous 16 Application Virtualization Virtualization 8 Counterpoint VMware View: A True End-to-End Solution 16 Automation
12 Opinion 18 Business Continuity 2010: What’s Hot and What’s Not 19 Cloud Computing
COLUMNS 19 Desktop Virtualization 6 Hoard: BRUCE HOARD Mastering Management 20 Management & Optimization
32 Take 5: KEITH WARD 26 Virtualization Security Things I’ll Miss Most 27 Server Virtualization 32 COVER IMAGE BY RYAN ETTER RYAN BY IMAGE COVER
VirtualizationReview.com | Virtualization Review | December 2009/January 2010 | 3 VIRTUALIZATIONREVIEW.COM what’s online DECEMBER 2009/JANUARY 2010 ■ VOL. 3 ■ NO. 1 @virtualizationreview.com EDITORIAL STAFF
Vice President, Editorial Director Doug Barney Editor in Chief Bruce Hoard Managing Editor Wendy Gonchar Speaking out Against Associate Managing Editor Katrina Carrasco
COLUMNISTS
Server Virtualization David Strom Jon William Toigo In this special online-only opinion column, Jon William Toigo,
CEO of consultancy and research fi rm Toigo Partners LLC, ART STAFF goes against popular industry sentiment and questions the Creative Director Scott Shultz value of server-virtualization products. Writes Toigo: Art Director Brad Zerbel
“That virtualization of servers, storage and networks is inevitable should be ONLINE/DIGITAL MEDIA
taken as a given. It’s only logical that, as hardware becomes commoditized, Editor, software should scale independently of the kit … A corollary to this inevitability VirtualizationReview.com Michael Domingo Director, Online Media Becky Nagel thesis is also true. Perpetuating a tight coupling of software to hardware Site Administrator Shane Lee eventually hobbles engineers and IT administrators alike with respect to Designer Rodrigo Muñoz important things like design improvement, scaling of performance and capacity, and management. Tight coupling leads to unwieldy and proprietary stovepipe products that obfuscate heterogeneous management and drive up cost of
ownership in heterogeneous environments. In the end, IT costs too much.” President Henry Allain Vice President, Publishing Matt N. Morollo Read Toigo’s arguments and join the discussion online at Director, Marketing Michele Imgrund VirtualizationReview.com/Toigo1209. Online Marketing Director Tracy S. Cook
President & Want to know more about the Chief Executive Offi cer Neal Vitale Senior Vice President best virtualization products & Chief Financial Offi cer Richard Vitale available today? Go to Executive Vice President Michael J. Valenti VirtualizationReview.com/ Vice President, Finance & Christopher M. Coates Administration HoardA1209 to download an Vice President, Audience Abraham M. Langer Marketing & Web Operations extended PDF version of this Vice President, Information Erik A. Lindgren Technology & Web Operations issue’s cover story, “The 2010 The Ultimate Virtualization Chairman of the Board Jeff rey S. Klein Buyer’s Guide.” You’ll fi nd Hoard Facts Check out new Editor in Chief Reaching the Staff additional products, more detailed Staff may be reached via e-mail, telephone, fax, or mail. A list of editors and contact information is also available descriptions for each product Bruce Hoard’s blog at online at VirtualizationReview.com. VirtualizationReview.com/ E-mail: To e-mail any member of the staff , please use the entry, and all the information you following form: [email protected] HoardB1209. Recent topics Framingham Offi ce (weekdays, 9:00 a.m. – 5:00 p.m. ET) need to select the best Telephone 508-875-6644; Fax 508-875-6633 discussed include the 600 Worcester Road, Suite 204, Framingham, MA 01702 virtualization tools for your Irvine Offi ce (weekdays, 9:00 a.m. – 5:00 p.m. PT) possible collapse of the Telephone 949-265-1520; Fax 949-265-1528 business. Stay ahead of the game 16261 Laguna Canyon Road, Suite 130, Irvine, CA 92618 Oracle/Sun merger, the Corporate Offi ce (weekdays, 8:30 a.m. – 5:30 p.m. PT) and get informed about all your Telephone 818-814-5200; Fax 818-734-1528 virtualization options, and check Citrix Ready Open Desktop 9201 Oakdale Avenue, Suite 101, Chatsworth, CA 91311 The opinions expressed within the articles and other contents out the extended PDF today. Virtualization program and herein do not necessarily express those of the publisher. multiple hypervisors.
VirtualizationReview.com • Redmondmag.com • RCPmag.com • RedDevNews.com VisualStudioMagazine.com • MCPmag.com • CertCities.com • TCPmag.com • ENTmag.com RedmondEvents.com • ADTmag.com • ESJ.com
4 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com Project1 10/13/09 9:23 AM Page 1
Smarter technology for a Smarter Planet: How to manage thousands of things you can’t touch. Today, many companies are finding out the hard way that virtual image sprawl can be just as complicated as the physical server sprawl virtualization was meant to solve. IBM can help you manage, simplify and even automate your virtual environment with a broad range of solutions designed to give you visibility and control over all of your virtual resources—servers, storage, applications, etc. So you can provision and configure resources in minutes instead of days, driving up efficiencies and setting the stage for new delivery models like cloud computing. Our open approach to virtualization has helped customers reduce capital and operating costs by up to 30% and is an essential building block of a smarter, more dynamic infrastructure. A smarter business needs smarter software, systems and services. Let’s build a smarter planet. ibm.com/virtualize IBM, the IBM logo, ibm.com, Smarter Planet and the planet ibm.com, the IBM logo, IBM, icon are trademarks of International Business Other product and registered in many jurisdictions worldwide. Machines Corp., service names might be trademarks of IBM or other companies. A current list of IBM trademarks is at www.ibm.com/legal/copytrade.shtml.Web available on the © International Business Machines Corporation 2009. All rights reserved. ED NOTEHOARD
Talk about a recipe for disaster: You install Bruce Hoard this disruptive technology that touches your servers and networks, and then you realize you don’t have the means to manage it. What happens if there are major problems? How can you resolve them if you lack the necessary tools and information? Meanwhile, virtualization technology continues to improve and proliferate. The Network Instruments survey went on to note Mastering that in 2009, an estimated 27 percent of applications are sitting on virtual servers. The Management survey also predicted that number would rise to 44 percent in 2010 and 60 percent by 2011. Thomas Bittman, vice president and Just in case you haven’t caught one of my blogs, please allow me to distinguished analyst at Gartner Inc., is also introduce myself as the new editor in chief of Virtualization Review. forecasting bullish numbers. He says that the My name is Bruce Hoard, and to put bookends on my career, I installed base of virtual machines (VMs) will started out with Computerworld back in the early ’80s and was increase by a factor of 10, reaching 58 million founding editor of Network World. I then spent 20 years as a VMs by 2012. freelance writer and editor before being hired into this new role by Asked what decision makers such as CIOs Doug Barney—who obviously has an eye for talent, not to mention dislike about virtualization, Bittman cites “a craggy good looks. new layer of complexity” that requires them to Prior to taking this job, I wrote a few white papers and magazine be very careful about how they manage their articles on virtualization. But all that was really only dabbling resource pools. In his worst-case scenario, compared to what I’ve been doing in my fi rst few weeks on the job: companies that mismanage their virtualization a fl urry of vendor briefi ngs, user interviews and immersing myself installations run the risk of undoing key in all things virtual. confi guration-management and performance- It didn’t take long for me to get a handle on the importance of management processes that may have been managing and controlling virtualization environments. In fact, it defi ned—and refi ned—over the course of years. seems like almost every day a new survey drives home that idea. “All those processes have to change when I Case in point: This past summer, Network World reported on a virtualize,” he notes. “I have to change how I survey conducted by Network Instruments LLC, a vendor of do capacity planning; how I deal with speed network-analysis software tools. In this survey, 442 IT pros revealed and virtualization; how I deal with offl ine that while 75 percent of respondents were deploying virtualization, images. I have to change all my processes, so “They lacked the adequate tools, visibility or information about their it’s very disruptive.” virtual environments to troubleshoot their problems.” It is with these challenges in mind that we Entitled “Security and Trust: The Backbone of Doing Business over offer our 2010 Ultimate Virtualization Buyer’s the Internet,” this survey discovered that respondents might not have Guide, which is included in this issue. In the money required to invest in the tools they needed to manage addition to offering a slew of management tools PHOTO BY TERRY POWELL TERRY BY PHOTO their advanced environments. Why? Because 73 percent were being from a variety of vendors large and small, it asked to do more with fewer resources. Among those tightening contains a wealth of other helpful products that budgets, more than half of those polled said the reduction in fi nancial cover the virtualization market from A to Z. resources could lead to IT degradation and failures. Check it out, and let us know what you think. VR
6 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com Project1 12/1/09 10:35 AM Page 1
Smarter technology for a Smarter Planet: Thinking outside the box depends on what’s in the box. The systemic inefficiencies in many server rooms today, in terms of both energy consumption and utilization, are becoming unsustainable. A recent study found that an estimated half of all businesses experience IT outages due to power and cooling issues.1 Smarter tools like the IBM BladeCenter ® HS22 can help. It’s designed to give you greater efficiency at every level, from its highly efficient design and Intel® Xeon® Processor 5500 Series to its advanced management software like IBM Systems Director that actively monitors and limits power consumption. All of which can add up to 93% in energy savings over the previous generation of rack servers. Learn how you can see a return on your investment in as little as three months2 at ibm.com/hs22 Systems, software and services for a smarter planet.
1Source: IDC Market Analysis #215870,Volume 1, December 2008,Worldwide Server Energy Expense 2008–2012 Forecast. 2Return on investment and power savings calculation based on 11:1 consolidation ratio scenario of 166 Intel 1U 2 socket servers to 14 BladeCenter HS22 servers and savings in energy costs, software license fees and other operating costs. Actual costs and savings will vary depending on individual customer configurations and environment. For more information, visit www.ibm.com/smarterplanet/claims. IBM, the IBM logo, ibm.com, BladeCenter, Smarter Planet and the planet icon are trademarks of International Business Machines Corp., registered in many jurisdictions worldwide. Other product and service names might be trademarks of IBM or other companies. A current list of IBM trademarks is available on the Web at www.ibm.com/legal/copytrade.shtml. Intel, the Intel logo, Xeon and Xeon Inside are trademarks or registered trademarks of Intel Corporation in the United States and other countries. © International Business Machines Corporation 2009. All rights reserved. news • trends • analysis
POINT COUNTERPOINT XenDesktop: VMware View: A True High Performance End-to-End Solution and Flexibility By Patrick Harr By Harry Labana
s our industry defi nes best practices for large- esktop virtualization is quickly changing how scale deployment of desktop virtualization, user businesses are delivering desktops to end users. Aexperience has become the proving ground for DDesktop virtualization should deliver a seamless IT and end users. XenDesktop provides advanced HDX experience for all applications and media to a range of technologies to deliver a high-defi nition experience on end users, while enabling IT to easily secure and manage any device, over any network. When comparing features, desktops. To achieve these benefi ts while meeting the VMware View lacks several capabilities that users expectations of end users requires a tightly integrated expect to see, including PC-like Flash experience, broad solution that can also provide a superior user experience. smartcard support, voice, video and webcam support, VMware View, with the PC over IP (PCoIP) protocol, VoIP softphone compatibility, bi-directional audio, WAN robust feature set, platform integration, broad ecosystem optimization support, single sign-on and 3-D professional and best ROI, provides a true end-to-end solution and the graphics capabilities to name a few. best user experience for the widest range of end users. As customers quickly fi nd out, delivery protocols are In a typical enterprise, users vary from simple task just one part of the equation. Optimizations are needed workers with a fi xed set of applications and limited across the entire delivery infrastructure. graphics requirements, to knowledge workers and Here XenDesktop comes out ahead. To prove this, Citrix power users who demand an uncompromised computing conducted internal tests to measure protocol throughput. experience. Power users utilize a range of applications (Note: Tests can easily be replicated using publicly and access to content, including rich media and graphics. available tools and WAN emulators. A WAN emulator All end users demand an uninhibited, rich experience is not needed when testing in a LAN environment.) A from their desktop environments, and in many cases load-testing tool ran a series of randomized applications they demand this from a range of devices and locations. including Microsoft Offi ce, Web content, and Flash audio and video. We ran the tests for 30 minutes or more with Foundation for Virtual Desktop Delivery no Flash acceleration, redirection or throttling on either VMware View with PCoIP technology is purpose-built product. Chart 1 shows the results. for delivering an uncompromised desktop experience across the widest range of users, tasks and locations, Chart 1. Citrix HDX vs. VMware View 3 ensuring the best user experience regardless of network conditions. It is an innovative display protocol that Protocol Throughput Results compresses, encrypts and encodes the entire computing experience at the data center and transmits it across a REMOTE DISPLAY PROTOCOL BANDWIDTH standard network to end points, which can be running Citrix HDX 233 Kbps PCoIP hardware, or using VMware View’s software- VMware View 3 820 Kbps based client. The compression algorithm adapts dynamically with existing conditions to enable the best To get a view of performance requirements to address user experience for a given network connection. professional 3-D graphics users—even over the WAN—we When network parameters change, the adaptive nature tested XenDesktop and HDX 3D against the hardware of the protocol helps by progressively refi ning the desktop version of PC over IP (PCoIP). VMware has since in an effi cient manner to maintain the optimal user released a software version of Teradici’s PCoIP. HDX 3D experience; the protocol actually senses the content being consumed 90 percent less bandwidth than hardware rendered, and prioritizes based on what’s most important PCoIP—even at the lowest performance settings (see to the end user. As a result, it addresses the demanding Chart 2, p. 10). requirements of even the highest-end power users.
8 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com Project1 10/13/09 9:12 AM Page 1
(Hint: add up the dots)
Citrix XenDesktop with VMware View
Manage desktops centrally
Personalized desktops for each user
High-definition experience over any network
Best bandwidth on LAN or WAN
Delivers VDI, streamed and shared desktops
Works with any hypervisor
If you’re considering a VDI solution, you should know that Citrix XenDesktop with high-definition HDX Technology delivers a host of benefits that other products simply can’t match — like superior performance, proven scalability, and the lowest cost per desktop. It even makes migration to Windows® 7 a snap. When it comes to these benefits, our competitors just can’t connect the dots.
Learn more about what makes Citrix XenDesktop the best VDI solution. Download the VDI Comparison Kit at www.citrix.com/XD4VRM.
© 2009 Citrix Systems, Inc. All rights reserved. All names and trademarks are the property of their respective owners. UpFront Coming next issue: Private Cloud Computing
POINT COUNTERPOINT Seamless User Experience Chart 2. Citrix HDX 3D vs. Hardware VMware View includes a range of technologies to ensure PCoIP 3-D Graphics Requirements a seamless, natural user experience, even exceeding that of the traditional desktop. USB redirection simplifi es REMOTE DISPLAY PROTOCOL BANDWIDTH support for locally attached peripherals, so when plugged in to the local client, the input is automatically Citrix HDX 3D 2 Mbps mapped to the virtual desktop without user intervention. Hardware PCoIP 54 Mbps Multimedia redirection ensures top performance for the delivery of rich media by eliminating concerns related The user experience of PCoIP degraded signifi cantly as to network conditions and leveraging local computing bandwidth decreased from an open LAN to lower speeds. power for the best user experience. HDX 3D remained stable while PCoIP began to falter. At 2Mbps, PCoIP was unusable. It is logical to conclude that Platform Matters the software version of PCoIP will not perform as well as Tight integration with VMware vSphere means VMware the hardware version. PCoIP will not work in a Microsoft View users benefi t from the rich and robust feature Remote Desktop Services (RDS) environment, further set of the industry-leading virtualization platform, reducing potential total cost of ownership benefi ts. delivering high availability, fault tolerance and scalability. These capabilities, traditionally reserved for server Achieving ROI with Every Use Case infrastructures, are now extended to the desktop. To achieve strong ROI with desktop virtualization, we believe there are four factors to consider: The Ecosystem of Partners 1. On-Demand Applications: The cost and VMware’s broad partner ecosystem ensures that customers complexity of desktop management is a direct result of can deploy VMware View with their choice of components applications running on each user’s desktop. Integrating to build the best solution. Working with vendors who the capabilities of XenApp technology into XenDesktop 4 provide components ranging from PCoIP hardware end signifi cantly improves ROI by making application delivery points and other thin clients, to security, storage and an integrated part of overall desktop management. network infrastructures, means customers can implement 2. Flexible Delivery Models: VDI only serves a an end-to-end solution that delivers the right level of service subset of users. XenDesktop 4 includes FlexCast delivery to meet end-user demands. technology, allowing IT to mix-and-match delivery scenarios, which can be executed from a centrally Highest ROI managed solution. VMware View has been shown to reduce the annual 3. Network Infrastructure Costs: By optimizing cost of PC ownership by 50 percent, resulting in savings user experience at every point—endpoint, network and of $600 or more per end user. Savings result from data center—HDX provides the best user experience using signifi cant reduction in IT staff support costs and the existing network infrastructure. reduced downtime. According to research fi rm IDC, on 4. Open Architecture: XenDesktop fully supports average, customers can realize a payback period as short Citrix XenServer, Microsoft Hyper-V, VMware ESX and as 5.6 months. At $250 per seat, VMware View is also less VMware vSphere, giving customers choice. View is locked expensive than other solutions. into the VMware hypervisor platform and the required version may not match the version deployed. Complete Package Combining inadequate performance with a single, VDI- VMware View 4 provides a comprehensive solution only, locked-in architecture is not the way to improve ROI for delivering virtualized desktops and the best user and end-user satisfaction. Customers need high virtual experience for the widest range of end users. desktop performance and fl exibility that support an Together these components—the rich PCoIP protocol, increasingly distributed workforce to achieve the best robust feature set, platform integration and high ROI— ROI given the diverse requirements. Citrix XenDesktop are changing they way people deploy and interact 4 with HDX and FlexCast technologies helps customers with desktops. VR achieve this goal. VR Patrick Harr is vice president of marketing, VMware Harry Labana is CTO, Desktop Division, Citrix Systems Inc. Desktop Business Unit.
10 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com Project1 12/11/09 8:36 AM Page 1 UpFront Check out our latest blogs at VirtualizationReview.com/blogs
VM Licensing can only a server that can handle that large 2010: What’s Hot get better—or at least more a workload could be a challenge.) and What’s Not understandable. It’s hard to Look for more capable hypervisors in say who has the more inscrutable the future. As an example, VMware By David Strom licensing, Microsoft or VMware. vLockstep adds high-availability There’s a growing feature gap mirroring on two different hosts. s virtualization becomes more between free and fee versions, And the Cisco Unifi ed Computing mainstream, there are many especially once you load up your System platform allows for high- Aanticipated developments and hosts with management apps, density VM confi gurations: It can advancements on the horizon. Here’s operating systems and user- handle 384GB of RAM and doesn’t a brief lay of the land, in addition to application licenses. One of the require the purchase of four CPU players you should watch for in the advantages of going with Hyper-V licenses for hypervisors, saving some coming year. running on the Enterprise version money in the long term. Better network infrastructure of Windows Server 2008 is that you Continued maturing of management, Physical-to- can have unlimited free licenses for application-virtualization Virtual (P2V) and dynamic your guest Windows VMs, which tools. This includes layering and provisioning. There are several can add up to a signifi cant savings. applications streaming in real vendors working in these areas to We can only hope that both vendors time. It also includes protection, make it easier to deploy new virtual simplify their licensing in the so you can run multiple versions machines (VMs) and complete virtual coming year. of the same app, provide better infrastructures. One newcomer to watch is LineSider.com, as it works to There’s a growing feature gap between virtualize network infrastructures. VMware’s vNetwork Distributed free and fee versions, especially Switch in vSphere can centrally once you load up your hosts with manage virtual networking features management apps, operating systems of all of its hosts and VM instances. And Novell’s PlateSpin Orchestrate and user-application licenses. continues to be one of the best ways to start, stop, migrate or clone VMs More selection on hypervisors support for offl ine users and reduce across VMware, Microsoft and Xen that are pre-installed on licensing expenses of desktop apps. environments. Microsoft is playing servers. Dell PowerEdge, HP Microsoft App-V, Symantec Endpoint catch-up with Hyper-V, and now ProLiant and IBM BladeCenter all Virtualization Suite, Citrix XenApp includes a live migration feature to offer a selection of rack-mounted and VMware ThinApp will all see big move a VM from one host to another. servers with either VMware ESX improvements in 2010. There’s a great Better VM policy-management or Citrix XenServer. A few vendors comparison chart from Sven Huisman tools. As virtualization becomes are starting to look at pre-loading of these and a few other application- more pervasive, you may need Hyper-V, too. Look for bigger and virtualization tools available at additional granularity and security better servers from these and other http://tinyurl.com/n2k7jk. to prevent employees from gaining server vendors in the coming year. As you can see, a lot is happening, so access to your infrastructure. Hypervisor scalability and look for bigger and better virtualization This is where third-party tools performance improvements. As tools in the coming year. VR can come in handy. HyTrust’s people build larger and more complex appliance can protect access to VM infrastructures, it’s nice that David Strom ([email protected]) is the hypervisor, while VMware’s the latest versions of all hypervisor the former editor in chief of Network vShield Zone appliance protects products will come with full 64- Computing, Tom’s Hardware.com guest VMs. Finally, Microsoft’s new bit goodness inside and support and DigitalLanding.com. He’s written System Center Essentials 2010 has more CPUs. (Hyper-V supports up about networking topics for more than improvements that make Hyper-V’s to 64 logical processors and 384 20 years, and his blog can be found at policy management more fl exible. concurrent VMs, although building strominator.com.
12 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com Project1 12/11/09 8:45 AM Page 1
WHAT’S THE DEAL WITH THESE GUYS? Sometimes you have to ask, “What are they thinking?” Companies need to increase ROI without being taken to the cleaners by manufacturers selling servers featuring entry-level benefits with enterprise-level pricing.
Aberdeen gets it. Businesses are in desperate need of Network Attached Storage servers that simply deliver the best bang for the buck. Look at these features and benefits:
Dell HP Aberdeen PowerVault StorageWorks AberNAS Hot-Swap Disk Drives Hardware RAID Dual Port Gigabit Ethernet Built-in Replication Microsoft® WSS 2008 Models iSCSI Target Linux Storage System Models System Recovery Disk DAS Storage Expansion VMware® Ready Certified Independent OS Drive Out of Band RAID Management Available w/ 2TB Drives Warranty 3 Years 3 Years 5 Years
Who gives you the best bang for the buck? Dell HP Aberdeen PowerVault StorageWorks AberNAS NX300 X1400 163 Intel® Xeon® Processor E5504 2GHz E5504 2GHz E5504 2GHz Memory 3GB 2GB 3GB Drive Interface SATA SATA SATA Installed Capacity 2TB 2TB 2TB Rails Included Included Included Windows Storage Server 2008 $3,419 $4,635 $2,995 Linux Storage System Not Available Not Available $2,995
Prices for the above specific configurations obtained from the respective websites on Oct. 12, 2009. Intel, Intel Logo, Intel Inside, Intel Inside Logo, Pentium, Xeon, and Xeon Inside are trademarks or registered trademarks of Intel Corporation or its subsidiaries in the United States and other countries. VMware is a registered trademark or trademark of VMware, Inc. in the United States and/or other jurisdictions. For terms and conditions, please see www.aberdeeninc.com/abpoly/abterms.htm. vm003 800-754-3310 www.aberdeeninc.com/vm003
The 2010 Ultimate Virtualization ILLUSTRATION BT RYAN ETTER RYAN BT ILLUSTRATION
14 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com 2010 BUYER’S GUIDE
THE INDUSTRY’S MOST COMPREHENSIVE PRINT GUIDE
TO VIRTUALIZATION PRODUCTS. By Bruce Hoard and Virtualization Review Staff
s the virtualization juggernaut continues to build momentum, it’s incumbent upon both current and potential virtualization users to research the market for products that fi t their specifi c needs. It’s not just all about server virtualization Aanymore. Desktop virtualization—aka Virtual Desktop Infrastructure—storage virtualization and network virtualization are just a few of the new product categories luring users with their possibilities and challenging them with their promises. In order to help you make the best virtualization choices, we have compiled and now off er this year’s version of The Ultimate Virtualization Buyer’s Guide. Putting this mother of all virtualization buyer’s guides together involved contacting and soliciting product information across 12 diff erent categories, running the gamut from Virtualization Security to Cloud Computing. In addition to including a new crop of 2010 products, we also painstakingly reviewed submissions from last year’s guide, which involved getting in touch with many vendors to get the low-down on any changes they have made to their products. We hope you fi nd this information helpful, and we look forward to off ering even more next year. Also, be sure to check out an extended PDF of the Buyer’s Guide online at VirtualizationReview.com/Hoard1209. The extended PDF contains more listings, more product information and more insights into choosing the best products for your business.
Please send me your comments at [email protected].
VirtualizationReview.com | Virtualization Review | December 2009/January 2010 | 15 2010 BUYER’S GUIDE
APPLICATION VIRTUALIZATION and its settings into a single executable that is isolated from the OS. Plug VMware ThinApp 2X VirtualDesktopServer Microsoft Application into your existing management infrastructure 2X Software Virtualization 4.5 SP1 and accelerate your application development 1825 W. Walnut Hill Lane Microsoft and desktop deployment. Deliver and deploy Irving, TX 75038 1 Microsoft Way applications more effi ciently, more securely and 214-288-0552 Redmond, WA 98052-7329 more cost eff ectively. 2x.com 425-882-8080 Cost: $5,000 Publishes virtual desktops and applications, microsoft.com rather than local installations, letting companies Enables you to transform applications into Xenocode Virtual experience the full benefi ts of desktop and centrally managed virtual services that reduce Application Studio application virtualization by improving desktop the cost of application deployment, eliminate Code Systems Corp. manageability, security and performance. Inte- application confl icts and reboots, simplify 119 First Avenue South, 3rd Floor grates with VMware, Microsoft Hyper-V, Citrix your base image footprint to expedite PC Seattle, WA 98104 XenServer, Parallels, Oracle Virtual Iron, Sun provisioning, and increase user productivity. 877-223-3551 VirtualBox and other virtualization platforms. Cost: Contact vendor xenocode.com Cost: Contact vendor Enables applications to be deployed in light- weight, pre-confi gured virtual executables that AX Series run instantly, anywhere via the Web, USB keys A10 Networks Inc. or existing infrastructures. Xenocode virtual 2309 Bering Dr. Novell ZENworks Application applications are isolated from each another and San Jose, CA 95131 Virtualization 7 the host device, allowing enterprise desktops 408-325-8696 Novell to be locked down, and eliminating confl icts a10networks.com 404 Wyman Street associated with shared components and Helps accelerate virtual servers by offl oading Waltham, MA 02451 application upgrades. compute-intensive tasks as well as intelligently 800-529-3400 Cost: Starts at $499 distributing users among multiple virtual novell.com machines. The AX Series also allows dynamic Can now be integrated with Novell ZENworks provisioning and other tasks using the aXAPI Confi guration Management, helping customers (RESTful API) in conjunction with virtual and managed service providers reduce the costs AUTOMATION environments such as VMware vCenter. of testing, packaging and confi guring virtual Cost: Starts at $15,995 applications. ZENworks Application Virtualiza- tion eliminates application compatibility problems with Windows desktops, providing Surgient Virtual greater security and management. Automation Platform Cost: Consult vendor Surgient Inc. 8303 North MoPac, Suite C300 Citrix XenApp Radware VirtualDirector Austin, TX 78759 Citrix Systems Inc. Radware Ltd. 512-241-4699 4988 Great America Pkwy. 575 Corporate Drive surgient.com Santa Clara, CA 95054 Mahwah, NJ 07430 Leverages leading virtualization and systems 408-790-8921 201-785-3236 management technologies to automate the citrix.com radware.com deployment and management of complex IT An application virtualization solution that An application-delivery optimization solution for services. Through a patented, just-in-time, reduces the cost of Windows application the virtualized data center providing real-time, self-service approach, administrators and users management by up to 50 percent. Virtualizing dynamic allocation of data center resources access resource pools on-demand and through applications with Citrix XenApp enables organi- based on business events. This ensures optimal guaranteed reservations. zations to improve application management by user experience and SLAs, improved response Cost: Contact vendor centralizing applications in the data center, which times and increased CAPEX/OPEX savings. It reduces costs and improves security by can be deployed external to the virtual environ- encrypting access to data and applications. ment to remain independent of virtualized Cost: Advanced Edition - $350; Enterprise Edition constraints or as a virtual appliance for use in - $450; Platinum Edition - $600 fully virtualized environments. It provides visibility to the entire application even if vControl deployed in a hybrid environment with both Vizioncore Inc. physical and virtual servers. 2300 Barrington Road Cost: $35,000 single power; $40,000 dual power Ste. 700, Hoff man Estates Chicago, IL 60169 InstallFree Bridge 847-589-2222 InstallFree Inc. vizioncore.com 60 Long Ridge Road vControl is a multi-hypervisor VM management Stamford, CT 06902 VMware ThinApp solution that provides self-service provisioning, 203-276-1460 VMware Inc. multi-VM control and task-based automation installfree.com 3401 Hillview Avenue that reduces VM administration costs and A clientless and serverless platform that enables Palo Alto, CA 94304 improves consistency. vControl lets VM consumers enterprises to centrally deliver and manage 877-486-9273 build and deploy VMs for themselves, while virtual applications, add-ons and patches to end vmware.com providing administrators a single interface for users with complete transparency based on the Simplify application deployments by eliminating task-based administration of VMs. customer’s existing IT infrastructure. application confl icts through application Cost: Contact vendor Cost: Contact vendor virtualization. Package an entire application
16 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com Project1 12/11/09 8:40 AM Page 1
ADVERTISEMENT
VRVPVIRTUALIZATION REVIEWVENDOR PROFILE
Citrix: Bringing Desktop Virtualization Sumit Dhawan Vice President Product Marketing to the Masses XenDesktop
Q Who is Citrix Systems? others. With XenDesktop, customers can choose from any of A We are a software and services company focused on deliver- the popular server-side virtual desktop models, including VDI, ing applications over a network and the Internet. Centraliza- blade PCs, and traditional server-based computing, as well tion, optimization and virtualization have been the focus of as client-side virtual desktop models that execute at the end Citrix product innovation, strategic acquisitions, go-to-market point. With XenDesktop, customers no longer have to bet on partnerships, and talent development for over twenty years. just one form of desktop virtualization and can instead deliver It’s why we remain fundamentally committed to our vision— the best desktop for every user, every time. a world where anyone can work and play from anywhere. Q What are the expectations for desktop virtualization? Q Citrix has been around for 20 years, what has changed? A Today’s digital workforce won’t compromise: on one hand A Years ago, mainframe computing dominated the enterprise. they demand the flexibility to work from anywhere at any time Then came distributed computing, which brought computing using any device they’d like, yet on the other hand they power, applications and flexibility out to millions of desktops demand the high definition experience that they would get in everywhere. Today, traditional distributed computing is the office. Leveraging XenDesktop, users can access their beginning to collapse under the weight of its own complexity. desktop and corporate applications from any PC, Mac, thin Citrix allows IT to evolve from distributed computing to a client or smartphone, with better reliability and higher dramatically simpler, service-oriented model. Leveraging availability than a traditional PC—all while getting a high virtualization, cloud computing, network optimization and definition multimedia experience. This enables complete on-demand collaboration, Citrix empowers IT with the workplace flexibility, business continuity and user mobility. flexibility it needs to respond to a dynamic, changing world. The introduction of Citrix XenDesktop™ 4, Citrix’s desktop Q Can you tell us about your relationship with Microsoft? virtualization solution, represents a decision on the part of A Citrix has a rich history of embracing and extending Citrix to focus on growth, capitalizing on the opportunity of Microsoft’s platform. As such, Microsoft endorses XenDesktop accelerating adoption of desktop virtualization and an as the premier desktop virtualization solution for enterprise increasingly strategic role in our customers’ business operations. and complex environments. XenDesktop 4 strengthens our partnership and product alignment by plugging into App-V, Q Is desktop virtualization the same as VDI? Remote Desktop Services, Hyper-V Server and System Center, A VDI, or “virtual desktop infrastructure”, refers to the process providing the most comprehensive solution to virtual and of running an end user desktop inside a virtual machine that physical desktops. Microsoft shares our view that desktop lives on a server in the datacenter. However, VDI is only one virtualization is broader than VDI and shares a common vision form of desktop virtualization. Most companies have a broad of user centric computing. Together, the joint solution provides diversity of users, including task workers, power users, guest the best user experience, integrated management and the workers, contractors and mobile employees. While VDI works most comprehensive and cost effective solution to service the great for some of these use cases, it’s entirely unsuitable for different user types and business drivers.
For more information please visit: www.citrix.com/XenDesktop 2010 BUYER’S GUIDE
800-677-6268 Replay VRA – Replay 4 BUSINESS CONTINUITY quantum.com AppAssure Software Inc. The Quantum DXi Series of deduplication 1925 Isaac Newton Square E., Ste. 440 appliances reduces the typical amount of disk Reston, VA 20190 space and bandwidth needed for backup by 703-547-8686 90 percent or more, leading to lower costs and AppAssure.com Acronis Backup & Recovery 10 enabling replication-based disaster recovery. The only solution that delivers rapid local Advanced Server From 1 to more than 200TB capacity (before and cloud-based recoveries, which provide Acronis Inc. deduplication). All models include backup companies with protection from both isolated 23 Third Ave. software for VMware. hardware and application failures, as well as Burlington, MA 01803 Cost: Starting at $12,500 MSRP entire site-wide failures. Previous solutions 877-669-9749 to this problem required expensive storage acronis.com LifeKeeper for Linux hardware, complicated replication software and Features centralized disk-image-based SteelEye Technology Inc. many layers of redundancy. backup and recovery of Windows or Linux 4400 Bohannon Road, Ste. 110 Cost: Consult vendor servers—including operating systems, data- Menlo Park, CA 94025 bases, confi guration fi les and applications—for 650-213-1487 physical and virtual server environments. It’s steeleye.com available with optional deduplication and SteelEye’s LifeKeeper for Linux is a software dissimilar hardware restore modules. application that ensures the continuous availabil- SANmelody Cost: $1,469 ity of applications by maintaining system uptime. DataCore Software Corp. LifeKeeper maintains the high availability of 6300 NW 5th Way Acronis Backup & Recovery 10 Linux cluster systems by monitoring system and Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309 Advanced Server application health, maintaining client connec- 954-377-6000 Virtual Edition tivity and providing uninterrupted data access datacore.com Protects an unlimited number of VMs on a regardless of where clients reside, whether it be Delivers high availability and serves as a single physical host for one price per host and on the corporate Internet, intranet or extranet. disaster recovery (DR) solution. SANmelody off ers agent-less backup for VMware and Cost: Contact vendor software fulfi lls business continuity objectives Microsoft VMs. Optional deduplication and by preventing storage-related maintenance, dissimilar hardware/virtual machine restore Linux Multi-site Cluster upgrades, reconfi guration, expansion and modules are available. SteelEye Protection Suite for Linux Multi-site failures from disrupting IT operations. The Cost: $1,999 Cluster provides local application HA protection manufacturer-independent software automati- with a shared storage cluster plus the ability to cally updates identical copies of virtual disks Acronis Backup & host a complete disaster recovery server and stored on separate drives. Recovery 10 Workstation storage at a remote location. Should a disaster Cost: Entry-level SAN software starts at under Enables users to create an exact disk image of befall the primary data center, a complete mirror $1,000. High-availability SANmelody pair starts their offi ce workstations, while backing up the of all critical data is available at the disaster at under $10,000 (two SANmelody licenses OS, applications, key data fi les and folders. The recovery site. confi gured as a High-Availability pair). product performs a full-system or bare-metal Cost: Contact vendor restore to diff erent hardware or a VM in StorageCraft ShadowProtect minutes. The advanced workstation version Desktop Edition adds centralized management features, and StorageCraft Technology Corp. integrates an optional deduplication module. 121 W. Election Road, Suite 110 Cost: $74; the advanced workstation version Neverfail vXtender Draper, UT 84020 costs $99 Neverfail 801-545-4700 3839 Bee Caves Road, Ste. 100 storagecraft.com Backup Express (BEX) Austin, TX 78746 Provides fast and reliable disaster recovery, Syncsort Inc. 512-327-5777 data protection and system migration for 50 Tice Blvd. neverfailgroup.com Windows desktops and laptops. ShadowProtect Woodcliff Lake, NJ 07677 A new solution designed to extend the benefi ts provides hardware- independent restore for 201-930-9700 and value of virtualization to applications physical-to-physical system (P2P) recovery, and syncsort.com deployed in physical environments. Neverfail also supports conversion from physical systems Provides the tools that accelerate server vXtender cost eff ectively and effi ciently ensures to virtual environments (P2V), virtual environ- virtualization, make VMs dramatically more the continuous availability of applications that ments to physical systems (V2P) and virtual effi cient and help provide a full return on server are deployed across multiple production servers. environments to virtual environments (V2V). consolidation investments. BEX enables fast, Cost: Consult vendor ShadowProtect is complementary to VMWare low-impact data protection, near-instant and Microsoft virtualization solutions for fast recovery with BEX Instant Virtualization, highly vAppHA and reliable disaster recovery. effi cient storage utilization and customizable Neverfail’s unique application-aware availability Cost: Contact vendor virtual machine reporting. framework has established itself as the protec- Cost: Contact vendor tion tool of choice for continuous availability of STORServer Appliance Tier-1 Microsoft applications. vAppHA integrates for VMware this same technology with the VMware High STORServer Inc. Availability (HA) and VMware VMotion, compo- 485-B Elkton Dr. nents of VMware vSphere 4, to help ensure the Colorado Springs, CO 80907 DXi-Series Disk-Backup deepest level of protection against application 719-266-8777 Appliances with Deduplication outages. vAppHA continuously monitors and storeserver.com Quantum Corp. analyzes the health and state of Tier-1 applica- Incorporates VMware Consolidated Backup to 11 Innovation Drive tions running within virtual machines. improve manageability of backups and reduce Irvine, CA 92617 Cost: Pricing options vary costs by centralizing the backup of ESX servers
18 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com on the STORServer. Consolidating backups that’s up-to-date and can be immediately vSMP Foundation for Cloud of virtual machines on the STORServer also utilized in the event of physical server problems ScaleMP Inc. reduces resource utilization on production or outages. 20863 Stevens Creek Blvd., Ste. 275 ESX servers, hosts and LANs during backup Cost: $299 per CPU socket Cupertino, CA 95014 operations, and allows virtual machines to 408-342-0330 continue operating without impact during vReplicator scalemp.com backup operations. Built for short and critical recovery time objec- Enables on-demand virtual SMP provisioning for Cost: Consult vendor tives (RTOs), vReplicator provides host-level enterprise cloud infrastructures. It works replication, off -site data protection and fail-over seamlessly with existing systems in a grid or UBDR Gold v5.0 support for customers needing a fl exible, cloud, creating a new dimension of cloud fl ex- UltraBac Software cost-eff ective and reliable replication solution. ibility and increased resource utilization. 15015 Main Street, Ste. 200 Supports full, diff erential or hybrid backup repli- Tightly integrated with systems management Bellevue, WA 98007 cations of VMs to dissimilar hardware. and provisioning tools, it off ers the flexibility 425-644-6000 Cost: $499 per socket of on-the-fl y creation of VMs on a per-job, ultrabac.com per-project or per-customer basis. Using image-based technology, UBDR Gold Cost: From $500 per node provides high-performance physical or virtual restores. It executes 100 percent scripted CLOUD COMPUTING restores for unassisted recoveries, and features backup/restore to literally any type of network MaxV DESKTOP VIRTUALIZATION storage device, in addition to performing virtual MaximumASP LLC and physical dissimilar hardware restores. 752 Barret Ave., Ste. 103 2X VirtualDesktopServer Recovering is automatic, requiring no special Louisville, KY 40206 2X Software Ltd. setup, pre-confi guration, or other considerations. 502-213-7721 1825 W. Walnut Hill Lane Cost: Contact vendor maxv.com Irving, TX 75038 Powered by Microsoft Hyper-V to provide an 214-288-0552 Veeam Backup and Replication alternative to the MaximumASP’s Dedicated 2x.com Veeam Software Server off erings. Each MaxV Virtual Dedicated Improves virtual desktop security, manageability 6479 Refl ections Drive, Ste. 200 Server performs and behaves exactly like a and performance, helping companies see the full Columbus, OH 43017 stand-alone server for both users and applica- benefi ts of desktop and application virtualization. 614-339-8217 tions. Microsoft named MaximumASP Hosting The product is hosted on a variety of virtualiza- veeam.com Solution Partner of the Year for the develop- tion platforms, and helps to lower operating The fi rst enterprise-ready solution for fast ment and launch of this product. costs by delivering secure, centrally managed VMware ESX/ESXi backup and restore that com- Cost: Contact vendor access to virtual desktops and applications. bines backup and replication in a single product. Cost: Contact vendor Also features ESXi support with and without Reliance VCB support, fi le-level recovery in seconds, Univa UD database-consistent backup, faster backup and 1001 Warrenville Rd., Ste. 550 restore with synthetic backup, replica rollback, Lisle, IL 60532 and integration with VMware Consolidated 512-692-4118 Backup (VCB), all while reducing storage costs univaud.com Citrix XenDesktop with data de-duplication. Application Service Governance: The Brains Citrix Systems Inc. Cost: $499/socket (1-50 sockets) of Cloud. Reliance is an application service 4988 Great America Pkwy. governance product that provides the essential Santa Clara, CA 95054 “brains” of a cloud-based infrastructure. This 408-790-8921 unique technology automates resource citrix.com allocation based on application requirements A desktop virtualization and VDI solution that vRanger Pro 4.1 DPP to ensure SLA-based application delivery. With delivers a complete Windows desktop experi- Vizioncore Inc. Reliance, companies can run their computing ence as an on-demand service to any user, 975 Weiland Road, Ste. 200 environments as effi ciently as cloud providers anywhere. XenDesktop can quickly and Buff alo grove, IL 60089 do, while maintaining control of their own securely deliver individual applications or 847-589-2222 applications and data. complete desktops while providing a high- vizioncore.com Cost: Consult vendor defi nition user experience on any device. The 4.1 release is the next-generation version Cost: VDI - $95 per user or device; $195 per of vRanger Pro, which features a completely VMLogix LabManager– concurrent user; Enterprise - $225 per user or redesigned architecture, including plug-and- Cloud Edition device; Platinum - $350 per user or device play modularity, service-based architecture, VMLogix Inc. and signifi cantly faster virtual machine backup 2350 Mission College Boulevard, Ste. 225 and recovery operations. Santa Clara, CA 95054 Cost: $499 per CPU socket 650-451-5555 vmlogix.com vConverter DR Enables software teams to run virtual labs within Parallels Desktop 4 for Windows Provides numerous features for eff ective ongoing the public cloud. LabManager–Cloud Edition and Linux disaster recovery in existing physical environ- off ers an enterprise-class virtual lab solution Parallels ments. First, vConverter generates virtual with a utility-like, pay-as-you-go model. The 660 SW 39th Street, Ste. 205 backups for physical servers. Next, vConverter’s fl exibility of this cost model is ideal for use cases Renton, WA 98057 Continuous Protection Mode regularly updates wherein demand patterns are highly variable, 415-277-4934 these virtual backups with changes occurring including software development, testing, parallels.com on the physical server. vConverter ensures that training, demonstrations and support. Designed to enable widespread adoption of PC companies have a “virtual standby system” Cost: Pay as you go (tied to VM hours) virtualization. It can be installed on top of a
VirtualizationReview.com | Virtualization Review | December 2009/January 2010 | 19 2010 BUYER’S GUIDE
Windows or Linux host OS, and then used to corruption problems, enhances user fl exibility by Vizioncore (the VESI.org)—Virtualization run any combination of guest Windows and and delivers faster log-ons. EcoShell is enhanced by the participation of Linux OSes at the same time on one PC. Ben- Cost: Consult vendor community members. efi ts include improvement of reaction time, Cost: Free desktop application increased productivity and the enablement of SysTrack Virtual widespread adoption. Machine Planner Cost: Contact vendor Lakeside Software Inc. 40950 Woodward Avenue MANAGEMENT & OPTIMIZATION Prism Asset Manager Bloomfi eld Hills, MI 48304 New Boundary Technologies 248-686-1700 Akorri BalancePoint 3.0 1300 Godward St. NE LakesideSoftware.com Akorri Inc. Minneapolis, MN 55413 The fi rst suite of tools that addresses the full 305 Foster St. 612-379-3805 spectrum of planning needs involved in the Littleton, MA 01460 newboundary.com adoption of desktop virtualization. SysTrack 978-431-1200 A powerful, easy-to-use tool that collects and VMP provides VDI assessment, VDI capacity akorri.com analyzes data on all installed software and planning, virtualization modeling and predictive BalancePoint is a performance and capacity hardware assets—providing the information analysis, migration planning, storage throughput management software that provides analysis needed to ensure full software license compli- and space planning. across IT virtualization layers and technology ance and optimize software purchases and Cost: Contact vendor silos for both virtual and physical, server and migrations. Prism Asset Manager dramatically storage infrastructures. improves IT department productivity and re- Thin Desktop Cost: Consult vendor duces overall system costs by streamlining, ThinLaunch Software LLC simplifying and automating asset management 3432 Denmark Ave. AppManager for VMware processes. Eagan, MN 55142 NetIQ Corp. Cost: Consult vendor 612-216-5469 1233 W. Loop St., Ste. 1800 thinlaunch.com Houston, TX 77027 Enhances the overall value of virtualization by 713-418-5705 simplifying the deployment and implementa- netiq.com tion of virtual desktops at the user device. You can monitor, manage and report on your Thin Desktop replaces the local user interface, entire VMware virtual infrastructure—including Quest vWorkspace then locks down and monitors the user/client vCenter servers, host servers and virtual Quest Software device. This allows the administrator to gain machines—from one location.Consolidation of 10701 Parkridge Boulevard, Ste. 100 complete control over the client endpoint and data and correlation of events provides the Reston, VA 20191 the user experience. opportunity to proactively manage IT and more 703-709-9210 Cost: Consult vendor easily support business initiatives. vworkspace.com Cost: Consult vendor Aggregates application delivery and desktop ThinPrint .print deployments from any virtualization platform, Desktop Engine Cassatt Active Response blade PCs and Terminal Services/Remote ThinPrint AG Cassatt Corp. Desktop Services environments. vWorkspace 7600 Grandview Avenue 1740 Technology Drive is an enterprise-grade desktop management Denver, CO 80002 San Jose, CA 95110 solution that transforms the corporate desktop 303-487-1302 ext 2100 408-437-7602 infrastructure into an on-demand service with thinprint.com cassatt.com an optimized user experience for LAN and WAN Enables quick and easy printing when accessing An automated, dynamic server resource man- deployments. desktops remotely via RDP or ICA. When printing agement platform for Windows, Linux and Solaris Cost: $50/per concurrent user (Basic) in Citrix XenDesktop or VMware VDI environ- servers. It provides both for the automated ments, or when accessing a physical desktop, initial deployment of application and OS images RES PowerFuse the .print Desktop Engine ensures that users to servers, and additionally provides continuous RES Software can output the results of their work on a locally monitoring of server and application health, with 18200 Von Karman Ave. available printer at any time. the ability to reassign resources dynamically— Irvine, CA 92614 Cost: $69 per user based on administrator-defi ned performance 949-333-2299 goals—to keep application performance within ressoftware.com designated operational levels. Enables IT professionals to dynamically compose Cost: Consult vendor and manage a personalized and secure workspace for each and every user—separately from the user’s underlying applications, systems software Vizioncore EcoShell and hardware. This greatly simplifi es IT adminis- Vizioncore Inc. tration, ensures compliance and saves money. 2300 Barrington Road CiRBA Cost: Consult vendor Ste. 700, Hoff man Estates CiRBA Inc. Chicago, IL 60169 45 Vogell Rd., Ste. 600 RTO Virtual Profi les 847-590-2222 Richmond Hill, Ontario L4B 3P6 Canada RTO Software Inc. vizioncore.com 905-731-0090 6120 Windward Pkwy. A freeware desktop application that enables cirba.com Alpharetta, GA 30005 IT admins to unlock the full potential of their Provides advanced analytics and collaborative 678-987-4178 virtual infrastructures and reduce the daily capabilities that enable enterprise views of rtosoft.com operating costs of managing multi-platform capacity health for both physical and virtual Virtualizes user personality and confi guration environments. Fostered and supported by The infrastructures. data. It works with VDI, Citrix, physical desktops Virtualization EcoShell Initiative (VESI)—an Cost: Consult vendor and laptops. It eliminates user profi le data online community-driven Web site sponsored
20 | December 2009/January 2010 | Virtualization Review | VirtualizationReview.com Project1 12/3/09 10:05 AM Page 1
LOOKING FOR VDI?
TRY A STARTER KIT www.panologic.com/BUY
SPECIAL OFFER: $1,899
s &IVE