Sessional Papers 187
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Sessional Papers 187 1910. LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY. NEW SOUTH WALES. No. 1. WEEKLY REPORT OF DIVISIONS COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE (EXTRACTED FROM THE MINUTES.) WEDNESDAY, 30 JUNE, 1910. }To. 1. DISPUTES (AMENDMENT) BILL. t -: — (Resolution.) Motion made (Mr. Wade),—That the Committee agree to the following Resolution :— Resolved,—That it is expedient to bring in a Bill to amend the Industrial Disputes Act, 1908, the Industrial Disputes Amendment Act, 1908, and the Industrial Disputes (Amend- ment) Act, " 1909" ; and for other purposes. Motion made (Mr. Arthur Griffith) to insert after "1909" the words "by the repeal of sections 3 and 4 thereof." Question proposed,—That the words proposed to be inserted be so inserted. Colonel Onslow moved,—Tbat the question be now put. Question put,—" That the Question be now put." Committee divided. Ayes, 40. Noes, 33. Mr. Moore, Mr. McFarlane, Mr. Grahame, Mr. Edden, Mr. Perry, Sir James Graham, Mr. Dooley, Mr. Carmichael, Mr. Hogue, Colonel Onslow, Mr. Nielsen, Mr. Minahan, Mr. Wade, Mr. Fallick, Mr. Kearsley, Mr. Stuart-Robertson, Mr. Oakes, Mr. Downes, Mr. Estell, Mr. Arthur Griffith, Mr. Mahony, Mr. Levy, Mr. Kelly, Mr. Scobie, Mr. Leo, Mr. Parkes, Mr. Hollis, Mr..McGowen, Mr. Waddell, Mr. W. Millard, Mr. Cochrane, Mr. Beeby, Mr. Moxham, Mr. Henley, Mr. Dacey, Mr. Macdonell, Mr. Taylor, Mr. Morton, Mr. Mercer, Mr. Trefle. Mr. Davidson, Mr. Price, Mr. Peters, Tellers, Mr. Latimer, Mr. Hunt, Mr. Nicholson, Mr. McCoy, Mr. John Miller, Mr. G. A. Jones, Mr. Cann, Mr. Barton, Mr. J. C. L. Fitzpatrick, Mr. Burgess, Mr. Gus. Miller. Mr. Robson, Mr. Robert Jones, Mr. Ashford, Mr. Gilbert, Mr. Lonsdale, Mr. Lynch, Mr. Brown, Mr. Hindmarsh, Mr. Horne, Mr. Nobbs, Mr. Meehan, Mr. David Storey, Tell ers, Mr. Page, Mr. Fell, Mr. E. M. Clark, Mr. Cusack, - Mr. Thomas, Mr. Ball. Mr. John Storey, And it appearing by the Tellers' Lists that the number in favour of the motion, being a majority, consisted of "at least thirty Members," Agreed to. No. 2. Same Resolution. Question put,—That the words proposed to be inserted be so inserted. Committee divided. Ayes, 34. Noes, 40. Mr. Nielsen, Mr. Macdonell, Mr. Moore, Mr. McFarlane, Mr. Stuart.Robertson, Mr. Trefle, Mr. Wade, Sir James Graham, Mr. Daeey, • Mr. John Miller. Mr. Mahony, Mr. Fell, Mr. Mercer, Mr. John Storey, Mr. Hogue, Mr. Robert Jones, Mr. Peters, Mr. Edden, Mr. Oakes, Mr. Lonsdale, Mr. Kelly, Mr. Page, Mr. Perry, Mr. David Storey, Mr. Estell, Mr. Cochran, Mr. Lee, Mr. Price, Mr. Lynch, Mr. Nicholson, Mr. Waddell, Mr. Hunt, Mr. Hollis, Mr. Grahame, Mr. Nobbs, Mr. Barton, Mr. 0. A. Jones, Mr. Cusack, Mr. Brown, Mr McCoy, Mr. Horne, Mr. Gus. Miller. Mr. Gilbert, Mr. Falliek, Mr. Burgess, Mr. Davidson, Mr. Morton, Mr. Carmichael, Tellers, Mr. Robson, Mr. Taylor, Mr. Kearsley, Mr. Minahan, Mr. Downes, Mr. McLaurin, Mr. Meehan, Mr. Scobie. Mr. Parkes, Mr. W. Millard, Mr. Dooley, Mr. Moxham, Mr. Henley, Mr. Ashford, Colonel Onslow, Mr. Hindmarsh. Mr. Beeby, Mr. Latimer, Tellers, Mr. Cann, Mr. Levy, Mr. MeGowen, Mr. Thomas, Mr. Ball, Mr. Arthur Griffith, Mr. E. M. Clark, Mr. J. C. L. Fitzpatrick. Insertion of proposed words negatived. 73845 1— No. 3. 188 No. 3, Same Resolution. • Question again proposed,—That the Committee agree to the Resolution. Motion made (uh% Carmichael), ti insert after "1909" the words "and by the amendment of the Schedule to include clerks and other occupations not already included." Point of Order : Mr. Wade submitted that the amendment suggested an amendment of the Schedule to tt e Act of 1909, end there was no Schedule to that Act, the order of leave was sufficiently wide to cover any amendment either of the Act itself or the schedule. The amendment was entilely out of order, and not at ell required. The Chairman ruled the amendment out of order. Mr. Carmichael moved, That the Chairman leave the Chair to report ajPointeof Order, and ask leave to 'sit again so soon as the Point of Order had been decided by, the House( The Point of Order is,—That the Honorable Member for Leichhardt, Mr. Carmichael, proposed to move an amendment after the figures '•1909" as follows:---" and by the " amendment of the schedule to include clerks and other occupations not already included," the Honorable Member for Gordon took the Point of Order that as the wording of the resolution was wide enough to permit any amendment in any of the Acts mentioned ; the proposed amendthent was out of order on the ground of being superfluous and unnecessary, and that there was no schedule to the 1909 Act. The Chairman upheld the Point of Order and ruled the amendment out of order. Question put. Committee divided. Ayes, 32. Noes, 42, Mr Mercer, Mr. Page, Mr. Mallory, Sir James Graham, Mr. G. A. Jones, Mr. Kearsley, Mr. Moore, Mr. David Storey, Mr. Eaten, Mr. Dooley, Mr. Wade, Mr. Levy,. Mr. Lynch, Mr. Cochrane, Mr. Oakee, ,. Mr.Hindmarsh: Mr. Horne, Mr. Meehan, Mr Perry, Mr. 'Dow'nes, "- Mr. Peters, Mr. Cann, Hogue, Mr. Patkea, Mr. Ihicey, Mr. Gus. Miller, Waddell, Mr. Price, Mr. Kelly, Mr. Carmiehael. Mr. Brown, hir Mr. Sonic, Mr. Gilbert, Mr .McCoy, Mr. Minahan, Mr. E. M. ()lark, Mr. Hunt," Mr. Hollis, Mr. Ashford, Mr Nobbe Robert J011621, Mr. Cusack, Mr. Macdonell. Mr. Ball, • Mr. Fallick,...„‘ Mr. Arthur Griffith, Mr. Moxham, Mr. Morton, Mr. Nicholson, Mr. _Robson. Mr. Mr. ')'ref* Mr. Lonsdale, M. JolAi'M Mr. Kittle'', Mr. 3. C. L. Fitzpallridk, Mr. Grahame, Colonel Onslow; Mr. Barton, Mr. John Storey, Mr. Leo, Mr. FTedlil..:;, Mr. Burgess, Mr. Thomas, Mr. hictioweir, Mr. Collins, Mr. Beeby, . Mr. Latimer, Mr. Davidson, Mr. Stuart-Robertson, Mr. McFarlane, Mr. Naylor. Negatived. • No. 4. • it,: Same Resolution. Question again proposed,—That the Committee agree to the Resolution. ' Mr. E. M. Clark moved, That the Question be now put. Question put,—" That the question be now put." Commit:ee divided. Ayes, 41. • . Noes, 32. Mr. Mahony, Mr. Robert Jones, Mr. Minahan, Mr. Trate, Mr. Wade, Mr. Mexham , Mr. G. A. Jones, Mr. Grahame, Mr. Moore, Mr. H unt, Mr. Estell, Mr. Maedonell, Mr. Itogue, Mr. McCoy, Mr. Kelly, Mr. MeGowen, Mi. Perry; ... I Mr. Price, . Mr. Scobie, Mr. Cusack, Mr. Lee, Mr. Parkes, Mr. Decoy, Mr. RufgestrA Mr. Oakes, Mr. David Storey, lii r. Peters, ' .Mr. John Storey, Mr. Waddell, Mr. Downes, Mr. Carmichael, Mr. Edden,. Mr. Davidson, Mr. Hindmareb, Mr. Gus. Miller, Tellers, Mr. Nobbs, Mr. John Miller, Mr. Kearsley, Mr. Brown, Mr. Morton, Mr. Nicholson, Mr. Arthur Griffith, • Mr. Gilbert, • Mr. Henley,. Mr. Cochran, hlr. Hollis. Mr. Robso n, Mr. Barton, Mr. Page, Mr. tonailale, , Mr. W. Millard, Mr. Meehan, Sir Jam* P (hail-RIM Mt. hell, Mr. Cann, • Mr. Latimer, -Colonel Onslow, Mr. Ashford, Mr. McFarlane, Mr. E. M. Clark, Mr. Stuart-Robertson, Mr. Lynch, Mr. Thomas, • Tile s, • Mr. Levy. Mr. Horne, Mr. J. a L. Fitzpatrick, Mr. Ball, Mr. Mercer, Mr: Collins , Mr. Taylor. Mr. Reeby, Mr.,Fallick, Mr. Dooley, • Aralit appearing by the Tellers' Lists that the number in favour of the motion, being a majority consisted of "at least,thirty Members,"— Agreed it . , QUestion,—That the Cominittee agree to the Resolution—Tut and agreed to. • . On motion of Mr. Wade, the Chairman left the Chair to,report that the Conludhlee had come to a 19 esolution. w. s..kowLE Assistant. ,-aseaS Sydney : William Applegate Gallica, Gov,rennzadirp —191S. ti5l,n/y,ylatt .:7;tatt 189 1910. LEGISLATIVE ASSE,MilLY.. NEW SOUTH WAIAS: No. 2, WEEKLY REPORT OF DIVISIONS 111 COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE (EXTRACTED FROM THE MINUTES.) THURSDAY , 7 JULY, 1910. No. 1. CLOSER SETTLEMENT PROMOTION BILL. (Further considered.) • Clause 2 having been agreed to,— Approval of applicant and valuation of land. Clause 3. Any five three or more persons who are qualified to make and hold settlement Auulinntinn to purchases, and who desire to purchase under this Act from the same owner any private ilia, laud under • lands, not being land within a city or town, ev-viliage; may, upon entering into agreements for that purpose with such -owner, apply to the 1.1Iinister to bring the said lands under this Act, and the Minister shall thereupon notify the Commissioners that such application has been made. Such agreements, applications, and notices shall he in the prescribed form, and such applications shall be accompanied by the prescribed fee. [Read.] Motion made (Mr. W. Millard) to leave out from line 1 the word "five," and insert the word "three,".—instead thereof. And the word "five," having been left out,— Question put,—That the word proposed to be inierted, be so inserted. Committee divided. Ayes, 46. Noes, 5. Mr. Fell, Mr. Brown, Mr. Price, Mr. G. A. Jones, Mr. Wood, • Mr. W. Millard, Mr. Dooley, Mr. Barton, Mr. Wade,' Mr. Grahame, Mr. McCoy, Mr. John Miller. Mr. Moore; Mr. Oakes; Mr. Gilbert, Mr. Waddell, Mr. Lynch, Mr. Mercer, Teller*, Mr. Trefld, Mr. Brinsley Hall, Mr. Donaldson, Mr. Burgess, Mr. Scobie, Mr. McNeill, Mr. Briner, Mr. Ashford. Mr. Nielsen, Mr. Nobbs, Mr. Retell, Mr. Lonsdale, Mr. McFarlane, Mr. Meagher, Mr. Fadden, Mr. Collins, Mr. Gus. Maier, . Mr. Carmichael, Mr. David Storey, Mr. (Mlles, Mr. Lee, Mr. IVEnahau, Mr. Moxham. Mr. McGowen, ' Mr. Hindmarsh, Tellers, Mr: Hogue, Mr. Thomas, Mr. Stuart-Robertson, Mr. Hunt, Mr. Morton, 'Mr. Fallick, Mr. Robert Jones, Mr. J. C. L. Fitzpatrick. Word inserted. And the clause having been further amended as indicated,— . •. Clause,. as amended, agreed to. No. 2. • Sent Buz. Clause 4. The Minister on being satisfied— (a) that the lands the subject of such application are suitable for settlement ; Valuation of (b) that the applicants arc qualified as aforesaid ; and land. (c) that such lands do not exceed a home maintenance area for each applicant, may cause a valuation of such hands to be made " jointly " by an Advisory Board and the Commissioners.