At the University of Edinburgh
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
This thesis has been submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for a postgraduate degree (e.g. PhD, MPhil, DClinPsychol) at the University of Edinburgh. Please note the following terms and conditions of use: This work is protected by copyright and other intellectual property rights, which are retained by the thesis author, unless otherwise stated. A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge. This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author. The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author. When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given. “Is this an emergency?” What is an emergency on a school expedition? Thesis for Doctor of Education. Submitted by Douglas Briton 25th September, 2020 What is an emergency on a school expedition? Douglas Briton, December 2019 page 1 of 194 In Memoriam To Ken McCulloch, who worked so hard and so wisely to help me get my thesis ready for submission, who saw my thesis submitted, but did not get to witness my thesis defence and completion. Dedication This thesis is dedicated to all those who enable young people to have adventures on expedition, and who work hard to keep them safe whilst doing so. Acknowledgements A number of people have played major roles in getting me to this point. Some of the key people are listed below, in chronological order of their input: Stephen Bell, whose questions and suggestions led me into postgraduate research. Charles Anderson who introduced me to the Ed. D. programme at the University of Edinburgh. My fellow students and my lecturers on the Ed. D. programme, for their encouragement, support, and insight. My supervisors: Robbie Nicol, Ken McCulloch, and Gale Macleod. My examiners: Pete Higgins and Barbara Humberstone. And a special acknowledgement to my wife, Hazel, who has gone through this whole journey with me. Thanks to all for your wisdom, your support, and your patience. What is an emergency on a school expedition? Douglas Briton, December 2019 page 2 of 194 Abstract This thesis is an autoethnographic account of emergencies that occurred on expeditions I have led. The central question addressed in this thesis was: What is an emergency on a school expedition? The aim of the research was to better understand emergencies with a view to improving my own practice as an expedition leader and as a trainer of expedition staff, and with the aim of contributing to a discussion of best practice within the expedition community. There is a large and growing demand for school expeditions which spend extended periods in remote areas away from the familiar support infrastructure of school management, colleagues, parents, and a well-understood health service. An emergency on these expeditions is likely to be more demanding upon all concerned compared to a similar emergency in a familiar and non- remote setting. There is minimal existing literature concerning emergencies on school expeditions. The autoethnographic approach taken was both evocative and analytic. The evocative autoethnography comprises 28 immersive narratives of emergencies on school expeditions. These accounts include dealing with mental and physical health emergencies, responding to environmental hazards, and managing issues arising from people's actions. In the absence of an unequivocal set of criteria that would define exactly what is and what is not an emergency, emergencies were defined ostensively. The analytic autoethnography used Wittgenstein's ideas of concepts that can be categorised by their family resemblances, an emerging approach within social sciences. My research shows that emergencies are concepts with blurred boundaries that share what Wittgenstein calls “family likenesses”, i.e. most emergencies contain most of the following characteristics: unusual situations; limited duration; harm or the threat/possibility of harm; normal ways of working have suddenly become inappropriate; possibly novel or unforeseen situations; those caught up in an emergency may be emotionally affected. In addition, this study found that as well as describing a situation, saying “we are in an emergency” can also be a demand or permission for action: society can mandate actions in an emergency that are not allowed in “normal” times, for example you are not allowed to stop on a motorway except in an emergency. Emergency actions include: acting with urgency; doing things we would not normally do; changing the rules under which we operate; changing our plans; allocating extra people or resources to a task. Through analysis I identified four broad types of situation where one might need to take emergency action: a situation of heightened risk; avoiding a hazard; the immediate impact of harm being done; recovery after the hazard has passed. The thesis concludes with recommendations for practice on school expeditions. One key recommendation is that those involved at all levels with school expeditions be prepared to take emergency action during a time of what I have termed a “maybe-emergency”: if we wait until we are certain it actually is an emergency, it might be too late to prevent harm. The thesis also includes suggestions for further research. What is an emergency on a school expedition? Douglas Briton, December 2019 page 3 of 194 Table of Contents 1 Introduction.......................................................................................................................................6 1.1 Emergencies in wider society....................................................................................................6 1.2 School expeditions.....................................................................................................................7 1.3 Emergencies on school expeditions...........................................................................................7 1.4 Overview of literature................................................................................................................7 1.5 Methodology..............................................................................................................................8 1.6 Recommendations for practice..................................................................................................9 1.7 Contribution to knowledge........................................................................................................9 2 Practice context. School expeditions...............................................................................................10 2.1 Business model........................................................................................................................11 2.2 The expedition.........................................................................................................................12 2.3 A note about gender. And age.................................................................................................13 2.4 in loco parentis.........................................................................................................................14 2.5 Healthcare................................................................................................................................14 2.6 Support and supervision from the expedition company..........................................................14 3 Methodology....................................................................................................................................15 3.1 Introduction..............................................................................................................................15 3.2 Key initial research problem....................................................................................................15 3.3 Approach: Autoethnography....................................................................................................15 3.4 Pool of data for my research....................................................................................................17 3.5 Interacting with this pool of data as an expedition leader.......................................................19 3.6 Evocative autoethnography – writing narratives.....................................................................19 3.7 Analytic autoethnography using Wittgenstein's ideas of family resemblances.......................21 3.8 Criticisms of autoethnography, and my response with respect to my thesis...........................24 3.9 Ethics.......................................................................................................................................25 4 Literature review.............................................................................................................................29 4.1 Academic journals looking at emergencies within outdoor education (not just school expeditions)....................................................................................................................................29 4.2 Literature review: Emergencies in schools more widely.........................................................31 4.3 Literature review: joint leadership of expeditions, joint teaching..........................................33 What is an emergency on a school expedition? Douglas Briton, December