Continuous . VPDo MiT News Service ~U~ III1~~l~ Cambridge Since 1881 1 I MMassachusetts
Volume 106, Number 35 4-- H-i Friday, September 12, 1986
. Noble- sues for tenure Former STS professor seeking $1.5 million
By Harold A. Stern Leon Trilling. of the AAUP, said in an inter- David Noble, a former assis- They voted unanimously to view that "MIT is not legally tant professor in the department recommend that the STS depart- bound to comply with AAUP of science, technology, and soci- ment grant him tenure, he con- standards.... But the courts ety, is suing MIT over his failure tinued. frequently lean upon AAUP to receive tenure in 1984. The Despite the favorable recom- standards as the accepted norm." civil action, filed in Middlesex mendation, Kaysen, on behalf of Noble's willingness to go public Superior Court on Tuesday, re- the STS faculty, announced in unpopular with colleagues Stephen P. Berczuk quests that either Noble be rein- Feb. 1984 that the department Prof David Noble answers questions Tuesday about his stated as a tenured associate pro- would not put Noble's name for- Noble asserted that there exist- $1.5 million lawsuit against MIT while his attorney looks fessor, or he be awarded $1.5 ward, Noble said. (Please turn to page 2J on. million in damages. Noble claimed that this deci- Noble, a member of the STS sion was made on political rea- faculty from 1975 to 1984, sons. claimed that the department re- "The STS program was influ- Gorm site to be announced fused to grant him tenure be- enced by the administration to By Michael J. Garrison - there are not a lot of [poten- building MIT housing in the Sim- cause "Noble's scholarly work the extent that they felt that An outside source has pre- tial housing] sites." plex area. "From day one [MIT sharply criticized MIT as an insti-l granting David tenure would be pared a report for the MIT Plan- Only land 'along the river" is agreed to] not put anything in tution, and that the plaintiff's detrimental to the program's po- ning Office detailing possible sites zoned for institutional housing, Simplex that is untaxed," he public speech criticized MIT's ties sition in the university," Noble's for a new graduate housing fa- Dickson said. "Once you stray said. Dormitory housing is free with industry and MIT's improp- counsel said. cility, said Senior Vice President out of [MlivT's] immediate locality of property tax. er use of publicly-created univer- William R. Dickson '56. Dickson . . . you can't say, 'I'm going to Noble also accused Reintjes of Types of potential housing sity resources for private com- making slanderous statements declined to reveal the contents, build housing,' [without] a spe- mercial benefit," according to the concerning the quality of Noble's but said he will be more explicit cial permit from the city." MIT may not build a complete- deposition. work. Reintjes made statements when he speaks before the Grad- Zoning laws prohibit institu- ly new building in order to add The statement named President to the STS faculty objecting to uate Student Council meeting on tional housing in most of Cam- more housing space to the Insti- Paul E. Gray '54 as a co-defen- Noble's portrayal of Reintjes' Sept. 18. bridge, Dickson said. Exceptions tute, Dickson speculated. It is dant, along with former Provost work. in Forces of Production, "We acknowledge that gradu- can be granted by the Zoning much cheaper to renovate an ex- Francis E. Low; Carl Kayseni, di- Noble's social history of industri- ate housing is one of the higher, Board, he said, but applicants isting building, he explained. rector of the science, technology, al automation, Noble accused. if not the highest, priority issues 'shave to have a pretty strong "We are looking very seriously at and society program; and Profes- of the Institution," Dickson said. case." the likeliest of those opportuni- sor Emeritus Francis E. Reintjes. Noble denied information and re- President Paul E. Gray '54 an- The construction of housing is ties." view [For a summary of the "State- nounced the search for a gradu- 4'neither permitted nor denied" in Conversion of an existing ment of Claims," see page 11.J Noble then attempted to ob- ate housing site at a GSC meeting the area immediately surrounding building would bring the fastest Noble held a press conference tain copies of reports, to "find last spring ["Gray talks to GSC MIT, Dickson added. This "mid- solution to the problem, Dickson at the Harvard Law School to an- out who did what." He was de- members," April 29]. At that dle ground" is where MITr hopes said. "It takes about a year to nounce the suit on Tuesday. He nied access to all information, he time he said he would rank the to concentrate, he said, since the plan [the construction of a new began by reading a statement, in claimed. top four possible sites by August. City of Cambridge could grant building] and two years to build which he claimed that '/in the "I know this is in violation ... "It took a little longer than we them a permit without having to it," he elaborated. Renovation light of widely accepted academic Of AAUP [Anerican Association had anticipated," -Dickson ex- go to the.-Zoning Board. takes only 'three quarters of a standards, [lie] should have been of University Professors] guide- plained. "You can look around Dickson dismissed the idea of (Please turnl to page 15) granted tenure." lines," Noble's counsel asserted. Noble based this claim in part "I was also informed that there upon the findings of an interde- was no appeal procedure at MIT, stabbing victims recall attack partmental review committee, and on an ad hoc basis I ap- prevented by Father's Two, he to the provost, and re- By Anu Vedantham versity Campus Police then drove which was formally charged with pealed will send a formal letter of com- soliciting letters of recommenda- ceived cursory review." Noble Matthew Denesuk '87, the vic- the two students to Beth Israel plaint to the Boston Licensing tion, and "essentially compiling a then appealed to both Gray and tim of a Sept. 8 stabbing in Bos- Hospital, according to MIT ton, is in fair condition at Beth Campus Police Chief James Oli- Commission, he said. dossier on [his] record," Noble the chairman of the MIT Corpo- Brennan has returned to said. ration, with similar results, he Israel Hospital and expects to be vieri. Brennan was treated for a classes, and Denesuk has made The committee was composed said. released this weekend. cut over his left eye. Denesuk un- arrangements with his advisor of Professor of Management of Noble's attorney also criticized Denesuk and James F. Brennan derwent surgery for a punctured and teachers to compensate for Economics Lester C. Thurow; MIT's lack of formal review pro- '87 were attacked shortly after lung, said Boston Police Officer classes missed during his hospital Professor of Political Science cedures. "The fact that MIT did they left Father's Two, a Boston John Gillespie. not have certain minimal due bar at 820 Beacon St.-While in- Gillespie said he will call the stay, Denesuk said. Walter D. Burnham; Professor of Olivieri has written a letter to Science, Technology, and Society process procedures," she said, "is side the establishment, they were students into police headquarters the Boston University Campus Merritt R. Smith; and Professor very illegal." accosted by a man for no appar- in order to start a mugshot iden- Police chief, citing the action of of Aeronautics and Astronautics Joseph Kurland, staff member ent reason, according to Bren- tification of the assailants. The nan. investigation does not have a sub- Sergeant Burke as "a very very .., r , --, .a .- . . . - - - - 6 ,. , ,. ,-- I As the two students left the stantial chance of apprehending opportune move," Olivieri said. bar, the same man shoved Bren- the attackers with only a verbal 'The doctor who treated Dene- nan. Denisuk and Brennan were description from the students, suk said that he probably saved immediately surrounded by a Gillespie added. [Denesuk] from serious medical group of hostile people. "I think Olivieri said he also plans to problems, thanks to the ser- they were out there even before interview the students. If he finds geant's prompt action," he con- we left the bar. . .There were five that the attack could have been tinued. or six of them around Matt [Den- esuk] and a few more around Environmnentalist calls me," Brennan said. "Jim and I both estimated their number to be about ten," Dene- for .i its on pesticides suk said. Neither student had By Earl C. Yen ally die of cancer," he noted. seen any of the attackers before, "The federal government has He explained that the govern- he added. been derelict in banning hazard- ment legalizes too many chemi- "We were fighting them after ous chemicals," according to en- cals before their effects are they attacked,"' Denesuk contin- vironmentalist Lewis Regenstein, known. "It's impossible to know Eric N. Starkman ued. "I got hit in the head and who spoke last night in 10-250 the long-term effects of chemicals then I saw one of them pull out a before a crowd of 150 people. when they've only been around knife in front of me," he contin- Regenstein, whose lecture was for a few years." sponsored by the Coalition to ued. Denesuk guessed that at Regenstein strongly opposed End Animal Suffering and Ex- least two people attacked him the usage of many chemical fer- argued that the Food from behind at this point. ploitation, tillizers. He cited a 1979 presiden- "I'm not really sure what hap- and Drug Administration (FDA) takes an excessive amount of tial study that showed that usage pened [after the stabbing]. It of chemical pesticicdes in Amer- time in evaluating potentially happened so quickly. I was ica has increased by a factor of stabbed in the back and then in hazardous chemicals. "Four of the most toxic chemi- ten over the past thirty years. the side... Jim was knocked Over the same period, the same cals banned by the FDA, includ- out. I went over and woke him study indicated that American ing DDT, can be found in 99 per- up," he continued. farmers are losing twice as many The two students started to cent of all Americans," crops to insects compared to 30 Regenstein said. 'By the time the walk back to their fraternity years ago. house, Beta Theta Pi, on Bay FDA acts, it's often too late." State Rd, when they noticed a Regenstein attributed the Unit- "The problem is that insects Stephen P. Berczuk Boston University Police car ed States' steadily rising rate of become immune to more and Going up . . coming down. Hackers assemble a parked near Kenmore Square. cancer to the explosion in the more pesticides," he commented. house atop the great dome early Monday morning Brennan asked for help, Denesuk number of harmful chemicals He cited insect traps and the re- (top). At noon, Physical Plant personnel investigate remembered. over the past century. 'One of ev- lease of sterile insects as effective the structure before taking it down. Sergeant Burke of Boston Uni- ery three Americans will evenrtu- alternatives to pesticides. i,~~~~~~~s . S.... r _a ~PAGE 2 The Tech FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 12, rp- -4 ------s~~~~~~~~~~~~------m_ 1986 -
Latin-O's h Noble claims M IT refused to grant E 19 Brookline Street n himn tenure c for political reasons Cambridge (Continued from page 1) posed policy of requiring mainte- ed in many different ways that I ed an agreement among MIT fac- nance workers to wear identifica- was putting my career in jeop- ulty members not to go public tion badges. The dean of the Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday ardy." with their criticisms of Institute School of Humanities allegedly Noble never considered lower- We provide policy, and that he was denied threatened him, telling Noble ing his profile until after he re- tenure because he violated that that he was placing his career in ceived tenure, he said. "I am pro- Live Latin Music "gentleman's agreement." jeopardy. "In every case, whether it was tected by the Constitution. I am for your [performing research for] the Noble also actively opposed a citizen. My people fought and chemical industry . . . or [re- MIT's establishment of the died for the Bill of Rights. Why Dancing Pleasure search] on automation and bio- Whitehead Institute for Biomedi- should I have to curtail my civil technology, my first approach cal Research, which he believed liberties in order to keep my job? was always to my colleagues. would allow private corporations It never occurred to me that I And I participated quite vigor- an "advantageous inside track on should curtail my speaking out." For more information, call 492-5544 ously in debates within MIT. But public resources." Many junior faculty members ())p'n ir luInch minl diinncr 1 did not restrict my comments to I refrain from speaking out while untenured, those circles. And I believe I am There were other events similar he continued, but rce tcaturc Spanish and lMexican cuisine protected by the Constitution." to those, "they are wrong. It injures all of Noble continued. "Ev- Monday - Sunday 5:30 - 11 umn In 1977 Noble wrote a letter to ery effort I made to simply exer- us. And the sad thing is that The Tech criticizing MIT's pro- cise my civil rights, I was remind- cases like mine . . . are so few."
_ , _ -
vb04
go
NP8 lira
g E m"npq
.4)aa pa"a 0 4) X 0 I_ a w_~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I 14en
ln I1a Up0) of Ps 4i,,,
r4 N 0 Nq
E
I
!I 119kima ii Cut To Order At No Extra Charge Cushions, Mattresses, Bolsters, Shredded Foam ® All Sizes and Qualities m e Lowest Prices i m · Zip-On Covers i 0ii m PLVTFORM BEDS 0
mE
165 BRIGHTON AVE. ALLSTON FE . .. . -- - . iL 254-4819 I[ iJ L- ]&-& i OFg BI P s s c-- e L -- --p · -- ,,-, PpinA/ (VF-DTF-hA C:Q 10 ina r L. lir- I M A I- r-1 r-nlu/AT' lClVIr ftI I Z. i Y-1t Lhe Tecb PAGE 3
_-In-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~- ~~$rlr~~~eWsh3li I
Two kidnappings occur in Lebanon Kidnappers struck again in West Beirut Wednesday, ab- ducting the top official of the International Lions Club in Daniloff suggests release to embassies Lebanon and Jordan. Authorities have not yet determined who kidnapped Conngress reinstates death penalty Jailed American reporter Nicholas Daniloff reportedly Victor Kenou, a Lebanese Christian. The kidnapping The US House of Representatives voted by thinks he should be released from a Moscow jail and occurred the day after the abduction of an over- American educator Frank whelming margin (296-112) to reinstate the death penalty turned over to the US ambassador - and the accused So- Reed on a West Beirut street. Reed had written his relatives for drug dealers. The penalty specifically applies to engag- viet spy being held in New York, Gennadiy Zakharov, be in Massachusetts before the incident, informing ing in criminal enterprise which results in the death of an- turned over the custody of the Soviet Embassy. them that he was growing more fear- Daniloffs other. The House also approved legislation wife, Ruth, says her husband thinks ful and planned to return home. The Islamic Jihad allowing for this might "cool the claimed the use of illegally-obtained evidence international uproar" over responsibility for Reed's kidnapping. in cases where offi- his case and avoid upsetting a cers acted in good' faith. (AP) superpower summit. (AP) An Arab-American group in Washington claims that there are still close to 1000 Americans still in Lebanon. Foreign trade deficit drops The State Departmnent will not confirm the figure. (AP) Guerrillas attempt to raid Israel The US trade picture has improved during this second Four guerrillas in a rubber dinghy had intentions of quarter of the fiscal year, according to Commerce Depart- raiding Israel's northern coast, but their mission failed. NATO maneuvers largest in 30 years ment figures. The foreign trade deficit totaled $36.02 bil- Israel struck back Wednesday by rocketing Palestinian The US military is taking part this week in NATO's lion, which is down 1.2 percent from a $36.46 billion guerrilla positions near Sidon, Lebanon. Lebanese hospi- largest maritime maneuvers in 30 years. About 12,000 ma- shortfall in the first quarter. New figures show that im- tal officials say three women were killed and 13 other civil- rines from the United States, Britain, and the Netherlands ports hit a record of $90.02 billion in the April to June ians were wounded. Police report that nine were wounded have begun air and seaborne landings in southern Norway quarter, while exports climbed to $54.80 billion. (AP) and none were killed. (AP) as part of the "Northern Wedding" exercise. (AP)
Safety of Boston's elevators 16~8 s~i~gs MP i I=- questioned by state official It only gets better After a mixed Teachers State auditor John Finnegan has issued a report which bag today, we will see improving reach tentative contract accused the state of failing to inspect thousandas of eleva- weather for the weekend. it will be cloudy, warm Boston teachers met yesterday to ratify a tentative con- tors between July 1983 and June 1985. No deaths or in- and humid before the passage of a cold front later tract for 19.5 percent in pay raises over the next three juries can be attributed to the alleged problem, the report today. After the frontal passage, dry and somewhat years. After an all-night bargaining session Wednesday, states. The state lost at least $211,000 in fees that should cooler Canadian air will settle into our region. Boston Teachers Union President Ed Doherty said early have been collected in the course of inspections, Finnegan Friday: Although skies will be mostly cloudy, it will Thursday he recommended approval of the proposed con- Wrote. (AP) be warm and quite humid. High temperatures will tract. (AP) be near 85 ° (30° C) and there is a chance of showers and possibly a thundershower. Winds will Dukakis leads in survey Rhode Island to fight illiteracy be brisk from the southwest at 15-20 MPH (24-30 Governor Diprete KPH). According to a statewide telephone survey released announced Wednesday an aggressive campaign to eradicate Friday Tuesday night, Democrat Michael Dukakis enjoys a com- illiteracy, modernize job-training night: Showers early on, then clearing and programs, and find cooler. manding lead over Republican George Kariotis in his run promising employment for minorities Low temperatures will reach 60-65° (16- and the jobless. 19°C) by for re-election to a third term as Massachusetts governor. A task force of business, industry, and morning and winds will shift to become education leaders northwesterly The survey of 500 registered voters says Dukakis would will oversee the project, named "Work at 10-15 MPH (16-24 KPH). Force 2000." (AP) Saturday: defeat Kariotis by a margin of 65 percent to 21 percent. Basically a beauty. It will be mostly sunny and drier (AP) with highs near 75° (24°C). Continued Pilwt, 18, escapes breezy from- the northwest. injury Chancellor of higher education selected Suinday- We can expect a mixture of clouds and sun An 18-year-old student pilot, Kristine Fairfield, escaped The Board of Regents picked a New Jersey educator as with highs 70-75' (21-24°C). serious injury after the helicopter she was flying crashed the state's new chancellor of higher education yesterday. into a cornfield Forecast by Robert X. Black off Route 140 about 2 pm Tuesday. The Franklyn Jenifer will head the state's public college sys- airport manager - --r -- III------· L ------Y and Aviation Training Academy Presi- tem, dashing former Amherst state representative James dent Howard Fuller Compiled by Mbichael Gojer said that the two seat helicopter may Collins' hope that he would remain in the pgst where he Stacy have been upset by a gust of wind. (AP) had worked since June. (AP) A. Segal
- - - - - Kenyon Potter . . , V-1 aw ~~a~4er 1~~~-I~~----a ~ " ------C N -_I '~ze e ' Bac:Bk To School Deals rv-"&~ ~ ~ _
1 ne Hour Photo Lab C CMDEE TMSOLSOWC BRAKES p mongoose, Is e | N if * 1 8 ~~OILGEARS 9 on developing & printing -P| [,I CITADEL V with this coupon · I a S I PI P IIS W/CLAMP 0, a 736 Massachusetts Ave. 2495 - RESERVATIONS - " - " -"^w___w"_ s- " - J H AGENT thk p Part time House in Lexington I>ts 4901 bicycle workshop YOU CAN HAVE IT ALL! 0 Beautifully furnished, your alternative to high prices. Continue school contemporary house in .- and work part-time with one of the LARGEST ne& A s2l1e airlines in thre . wooded lot. Monday - saturda, 259 ma\a!hu.-lls usd repairs at Gnu, * Close to bus to Harvard bir ek, parts ,,mbddp,. ma 02139 Hours scheduled between 7:00arn and 3:00pm or 4:00pm and Square. accesories 876-6555 near MIT 11:00pm including weekends and holidays. - -- I 0 5 bedroom, 21/2 bath, - -- -- Four weeks LOCAL TRAINING at no cost to you. fireplace, kitchen with all Translations into your native language Averaging 20-30 hours per week at our Reservation Center adjacent facilities, and room for 4 are needed for industrial literature. You to Logan International Airport. car parking. foreign will be well paid to prepare these STARTING SALARY $5.77/hour o Can be rented to group or translations on an occasional basis. I plus a commission on sales is planned for next year. Assignments are made according to family. language to WORLDWIDE TRAVEL PRIVILEGES Call 861-9429 your area of technical knowledge. ability We are currently seeking translators for. *for you and your family for a nominal service charge. MEET r Arabic 0 ChiBnes 0 Danish * Du chI WITH OUR EMPLOYMENT REPRESENTATIVE: The Architecture TUESDAYS and THURSDAYS at 9:00am or 1:00pm of is O Farsl o French 0 German 0 Greek (sorry, no late comers can be accomodated) Fundamental * Rtagan 0 Japanese * Kobran Eastern Airlines Logan International Airport valuable! • Norwegian * Polis 9 Portusgese Mathematical Physics Main Terminal * Romanian 0 Spanish 0 Swedish Upper Level ... will present and others. Boston, hA fundamental OR theory in descriptive, but L Into-English translations from German and French. Many other languages also SEND SELF ADDRESSED, STAMPED, LEGAL SIZE ENVELOPE TO: conceptually modern terms. available. Eastern Reservations Recruitment No technical knowledge of Personnel Office Foreign language typists also needed. Logan International Airport mathematics or physics will E. Boston. MA 02128 All this work can be done in your be assumed. Precise home! formulations will be given, Linguistic Systems, Inc. is New I but derivations and proofs will England's largest translation agency, be by reference. During the located a block north of the Central Sq. first two weeks the course subway station. (18.257) will be in process of organization and background For application and test exposition, after which it will translation call Ms. proceed systematically. If Unguestic Systems, Ine. Desormeaux IBA TE 1RN4 interested please contact I. E. 116 Bishop Allen Drive I We eam our wings every day~ Segal at x3-4985 or 862-0007. Cambridge, MA 02139 864-3900 _r - .-.. . a ~~e~l7------j
''.: