Differential Diagnosis of Common Tremor Syndromes R Bhidayasiri
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
756 Postgrad Med J: first published as 10.1136/pgmj.2005.032979 on 12 December 2005. Downloaded from REVIEW Differential diagnosis of common tremor syndromes R Bhidayasiri ............................................................................................................................... Postgrad Med J 2005;81:756–762. doi: 10.1136/pgmj.2005.032979 Tremor is one of the most common involuntary movement topographical distribution. Different classifica- tions of tremor have been proposed although the disorders seen in clinical practice. In addition to the most useful and widely accepted classification detailed history, the differential diagnosis is mainly clinical divides tremor according to the behaviour it based on the distinction at rest, postural and intention, occurs, that is rest and action tremor, which is further subdivided into postural and kinetic activation condition, frequency, and topographical tremor (table 1).1–3 Action tremor, the most distribution. The causes of tremor are heterogeneous and it prevalent of these types of tremor, occurs during can present alone (for example, essential tremor) or as a sustained extension of the arm and during voluntary movements, such as writing or typing. part of a neurological syndrome (for example, multiple Resting tremor is suspected, if it occurs with the sclerosis). Essential tremor and the tremor of Parkinson’s patient sitting with his arms firmly supported disease are the most common tremors encountered in without any voluntary activities, if it increases with mental stress (counting backwards), and if clinical practice. This article focuses on a practical it is suppressed by voluntary movements. The approach to these different forms of tremor and how to most common cause of resting tremor is idio- distinguish them clinically. Evidence supporting various pathic Parkinson’s disease (PD). The most common cause of postural and kinetic tremor is strategies used in the differentiation is then presented, essential tremor (ET). Physiological tremor is an followed by a review of formal guidelines or action tremor and is present in every healthy recommendations when they exist. person under certain conditions. Tremor can present alone or as part of a neurological ........................................................................... syndrome, for example multiple sclerosis, dysto- nia, and neuropathy. This article discusses remor is one of the most common involun- different types of tremor with an emphasis on tary movement disorders seen in clinical salient features and how to distinguish them Tpractice. It is defined as an involuntary, clinically. Evidence supporting various available approximately rhythmic, and roughly sinusoidal strategies is then presented, followed by a review movement of one or more body parts. It is of established guidelines. differentiated from other involuntary movement disorders, such as chorea, athetosis, ballism, tics, http://pmj.bmj.com/ and myoclonus, by its repetitive, stereotyped ESSENTIAL TREMOR: THE MOST movements of a regular amplitude and fre- COMMON FORM OF ACTION TREMOR quency. Tremor may be confused with rhythmic Action tremor refers to any tremor that is myoclonus (incorrectly termed cortical tremor), produced by voluntary contraction of muscles, which is typically characterised by brief muscle including postural, isometric, and kinetic tremor. twitches, confined to one limb or to adjacent The last includes intention tremor. As there are body regions, associated with spike-wave com- no validated serological, radiological, and patho- logical markers in ET, the diagnosis is primarily on September 26, 2021 by guest. Protected copyright. plexes on the electroencephalogram (EEG) or 2 spinal lesions. Clonus, unlike tremor, represents based on clinical findings (box 1). Therefore, the a rhythmic movement, which is increased by examination should be comprehensive. Firstly, muscle stretching. Asterixis can be distinguished observe the patient sitting at rest to note whether from tremor on the basis of electromyographic there is evidence of a resting tremor of the head, (EMG) findings of prolonged absence of EMG hands, or legs. Then, ask the patient to stretch activity during ‘‘flapping’’ or abduction of the out the arms and hands completely and look for upper extremities. Stereotypies may have rhyth- a postural tremor, followed by checking finger- mic components, but nevertheless are domi- nose-finger movements looking for a kinetic ....................... nanted by complex movements. Lastly, epilepsia tremor. Typically, essential tremor is an action partialis continua (EPC) can produce regular tremor, either postural or kinetic in character, Correspondence to: mainly affecting the hands. It is usually bilateral Dr R Bhidayasiri, jerks of the arm or hand, which can be difficult Department of Neurology, with a frequency of 4 Hz to 12 Hz and largely to distinguish from tremor. EPC is associated 4 Reed Neurological with EEG changes (which may need to be symmetrical. The upper limbs are affected in Research Institute, UCLA about 95% of patients, followed by head (34%), Medical Center, 710 identified with back-averaging techniques), and Westwood Plaza, Los MRI changes in contralateral sensorimotor cor- Angeles, CA 90095, USA; tex. Abbreviations: EMG, electromyography; EEG, [email protected] The first step in evaluating any patient with electroencephalography; EPC, epilepsia partialis continua; PD, Parkinson’s disease; ET, essential tremor; Submitted24January2005 tremor is to characterise the tremor. Various PET, positron emission tomography; DAT, dopamine Accepted 16 April 2005 types of tremor can be distinguished clinically, transporter; DBS, deep brain stimulation; VIM, ventral ....................... based on the activation condition, frequency, and intermedius nucleus www.postgradmedj.com Common tremor syndromes 757 Postgrad Med J: first published as 10.1136/pgmj.2005.032979 on 12 December 2005. Downloaded from Table 1 Classification of tremor Box 1 Clinical criteria for essential tremor2 Type of tremor Definition Definite essential tremor Rest tremor Tremor that occurs in a body part that is not voluntarily activated and is N Postural tremor of moderate amplitude is present in at completed supported against gravity. least one arm Action tremor Any tremor that is produced by voluntary contraction of muscle, N Tremor of moderate amplitude is present in at least one including postural, isometric, and arm during at least four tasks, such as pouring water, kinetic tremor. The last includes using a spoon to drink water drinking water, finger-to- intention tremor. Postural tremor Tremor that is present while nose manoeuvre, and drawing a spiral. voluntarily maintaining a position N Tremor must interfere with at least one activity of daily against gravity. living. Kinetic tremor Tremor that occurs during any voluntary movement. It may include N Medications, hypothyroidism, alcohol, and other visually or non-visually guided neurological conditions are not the cause of tremor. movements. Tremor during target directed movement is called intention Probable essential tremor tremor. Isometric tremor Tremor that occurs as a result of N Tremor of moderate amplitude is present in at least one muscle contraction against a rigid arm during at least four tasks, or head tremor is stationary object. present. Task specific tremor Kinetic tremor that may appear or become exacerbated during specific N Medications, hyperthyroidism, alcohol, and other activities. neurological conditions are not the cause of tremor. except the tremor although signs of mild cerebellar dysfunc- 2 lower limbs (20%), voice (12%), face and trunk (5%). With tion can be seen, supported by a recent study using positron the passage of time, the frequency of the tremor decreases emission tomography (PET) showing increased cerebellar 5 and the amplitude may increase. The prevalence ranges from activation.19 When the presentation is atypical, functional 0.4% to 6.7% in persons over 40 years old so it is the most brain imaging with positron emission tomography and the 6–8 common type of tremor. Many studies have shown that ET radiotracer 18-fluorodopa (FDOPA-PET) may permit the is much more prevalent than tremor of PD (up to 20 times diagnosis of PD in early stage, recording and quantifying 910 difference). However, some experts suspected that the the deficiency of dopamine synthesis and storage within pre- 11 condition might be overdiagnosed. Although the condition synaptic striatal nerve terminals. In addition, dopamine is both clinically and genetically heterogeneous, half of the transporter (DAT) single photon emission computed tomo- cases are considered familial with an autosomal dominant graphy (SPECT), such as 123I-ß-FP-CIT, can effectively 9 12–14 pattern of inheritance. Two different chromosomal distinguish between ET and PD in an early stage of the regions have been linked to familial ET, one on chromosome disease with the results being within normal limits in ET.20 21 15 16 3q13 and another on chromosome 2p22–25. However, no Apart from excluding the possibility of early PD, a careful specific gene mutations have been identified to date. The drug history is mandatory as many drugs are capable of penetrance is thought to be high, suggesting that 89% of producing postural and kinetic tremors (box 2). These drugs http://pmj.bmj.com/ 617 patients at risk have signs of ET by the age of 65. The age include b-adrenergic agonists, valproic acid, thyroxin, tricyc- of onset is typically 60–70