1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF , BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 13 th DAY OF APRIL, 2015

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S ABDUL NAZEER

WRIT PETITION NOS.3046-3049 OF 2015 AND WRIT PETITION NOS.3432-3435 OF 2015 (GM-CON)

BETWEEN:

1. SMT.NAGAMANI.V AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS W/O.RAJEEVALOCHANA NO.265, 8 TH CROSS, M BLOCK KUVEMPUNAGAR MYSORE- 570 023 (REPRESENTED FOR HER HUSBAND SHRI.RAJEEVLOCHANA SINCE HE IS IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)

2. SMT.DEVAMMA.B.M. AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS W/O.M.K.BIDAPPA NO.20, K.BADAGA VILLAGE F.N.C COLLEGE POST MADIKERE – 571 201 (REPRESENTED FOR HER HUSBAND SHRI.M.K.BIDDAPPA SINCE HE IS IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)

3. SHRI.CHETHAN.S AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS S/O.LATE M.SHIVANNA NO.453, 1 ST CROSS, 1 ST STAGE GAYATHRIPURAM MYSORE – 570 019

2

(REPRESENTED FOR HIS MOTHER SMT., SINCE SHE IS IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)

4. SHRI.R.SRINIVASA AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS S/O.LATE M.T.RAJAIAH NO.834, 1 ST CROSS, KAMATAGIRI MANDIMOHALLA MYSORE – 570 001 (REPRESENTED FOR HIS WIFE SMT.NAGARATNAMMA SINCE SHE IS IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)

5. SHRI.R.RAMESH AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS S/O.LATE M.T.RAJAIAH NO.834, 1 ST CROSS, KAMATAGIRI MANDIMOHALLA MYSORE – 570 001 (REPRESENTED FOR HIS WIFE SMT.DAKSHAINI H.N. SINCE SHE IS IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY).

6. SMT.KUMUDA JAYAPRAKASH AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS D/O.JAYAPRAKASH NO.3047, 1 ST CROSS, 1 ST STAGE GOKULAM MYSORE – 570 002 (REPRESENTED FOR HER FATHER SHRI.JAYAPRAKASH SINCE SHE IS IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY)

7. SMT.A.M.PRATHIMA AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS W/O.A.M.MONNAPPA NO.20/41, NEAR HEALTH OFFICE MADIKERE – 571201 (REPRESENTED FOR HER HUSBAND

3

SHRI.A.M.MONNAPPA SINCE SHE IS IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY).

8. SHRI.LAKSHMI NARAYANA AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS S/O.S.ANANTHRAMAIAH NO.11/A, TEACHERS LAYOUT PARAMAHAMSA BLOCK YERAGANAHALLI MYSORE – 570 029. ... PETITIONERS

(BY SRI.VISHNU HEGDE, ADV.,)

AND:

1. SMT.CHANDRAKANTHA MAJOR IN AGE W/O.R.K.NARAYANA NO.359, 2 ND STAGE, GOKULAM 16 TH CROSS, 6-D MAIN, V.V.MOHALLA MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

2. SHRI.M.N.CHAMPA MAJOR IN AGE S/O.NAGARAJA NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

3. SHRI.M.S.ABHISHEK MAJOR IN AGE S/O.M.P.SHANKAR NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002. (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

4

4. SHRI.M.S.CHARAN MAJOR IN AGE S/O.M.P.SHANKAR NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

5. SMT.K.V.HEMAVATHI MAJOR IN AGE W/O.V.THIRUPALU NO.3606, 19 TH MAIN, 2 ND CROSS 2ND STAGE, VIJAYANAGARA MYSORE – 570 023. (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

6. SHRI.R.K.NARAYANA MAJOR IN AGE S/O.K.MASTHANAIAH NO.359, 3 RD STAGE, GOKULA 16 TH CROSS, 6-D MAIN, V.V.MOHALLA MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

7. MISS M.P.INDUMATHI MAJOR IN AGE D/O.R.PEERANNA NO.2203/195, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

8. SHRI.M.P.VENKATESH MAJOR IN AGE S/O.LATE R.PEERANNA NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

5

9. SHRI.M.N.CHAMPA MINOR IN AGE REPRESENTED BY HIS 1 ST COMPONENT S/O.M.P.NAGARAJU NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

10. SMT.VENKATAMMA MAJOR IN AGE W/O.T.VENKATADAS NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

11. SMT.M.P.NAGAVENI MAJOR IN AGE S/O.PUTTARAJU C.D.NO.HIG-8, PLOT HOUSE NEW KANTHARAJA ARAS ROAD SHARADHA DEVI NAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

12. SMT.M.P.NAGAVENI MAJOR IN AGE D/O.PUTTARAJU C.D.NO.HIG-8, PLOT HOUSE NEW KANTHARAJA ARAS ROAD SHARADHA DEVI NAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

13. SHRI.M.P.VENKATESH MAJOR IN AGE S/O.R.PEERANNA NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR

6

MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

14. MISS.M.N.HEMALATHA MINOR IN AGE D/O.M.P.NAGARAJU REPRESENTED BY SMT.VENKATAMMA NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

15. SHRI.PUTTARAJU.C MAJOR IN AGE S/O.KANCHIBOVI C.D.NO.HIG-8, PLOT HOUSE NEW KANTHARAJA ARAS ROAD SHARADHA DEVI NAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

16. SHRI.M.P.VENKATESH MAJOR IN AGE FATHER NAME NOT KNOWN TO THE PETITIONERS NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

17. SMT.M.P.NAGARATNA MAJOR IN AGE FATHER NAME NOT KNOWN TO THE PETITIONERS NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

7

18. MISS M.N.JAGRUTHI MAJOR IN AGE D/O.M.P.NAGARAJU NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

19. MR.CHETHAN MINOR IN AGE REPRESENTED BY M.P.NAGAVENI NO.HIG-8, PLOT HOUSE NEW KANTHARAJA ARAS ROAD SHARADHA DEVI NAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

20. SHRI.M.S.BALAJI MAJOR IN AGE S/O.M.P.SHANKARA NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

21. SMT.M.P.ANURADHA MAJOR IN AGE D/O.R.PEERANNA NO.2203/192, MEDARS BLOCK NEW BAMBOO BAZAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

22. SHRI.THIRUPALA SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRs SMT.K.V.HEMAVATHI W/O.V.THIRUPALU DOOR NO.3606, 19 TH MAIN, 2 ND CROSS 2ND STAGE, VIJAYANAGARA MYSORE – 570 023

8

(RELATING TO EX.PET NO.6/2011).

23. SHRI.KIRAN ARAS MAJOR IN AGE S/O.M.KANTHARAJ ARAS REPRESENTED BY SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER SHRI.M.KANTHARAJ ARAS NO.113, EWS, KHB COLONY 1ST MAIN, 3 RD CROSS – 560 079 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

24. SMT.RAMYA ARAS.M MAJOR IN AGE W/O.PRABURAJE ARAS NO.482, 18 TH CROSS 4TH MAIN, POSTAL COLONY VISHWESHWARA NAGARA MYSORE – 570 008 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

25. SHRI.KUSHI ARAS MAJOR IN AGE S/O.M.KIRAN ARAS NO.113, EWS KHB COLONY 1ST MAIN, 3 RD CROSS BASAWESHWARA NAGARA BANGALORE – 560 079 REPRESENTED BY SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER KANTHARAJ ARAS S/O.MOLLARAJE ARAS (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

26. SMT.SULOCHANA ARAS MAJOR IN AGE W/O.M.KANTHARAJ ARAS NO.113, EWS KHB COLONY 1ST MAIN, 3 RD CROSS BASAWESHWARA NAGARA

9

BANGALORE – 560 079 REPRESENTING BY SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER KANTHARAJ ARAS) (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

27. SMT.RADHIKA RAJINKANTH ARAS MAJOR IN AGE W/O.RAJINIKANTH ARAS NO.783, SATYA SADANA 9TH MAIN ROAD, D BLOCK 1ST STAGE, J.P.NAGAR MYSORE – 570 008 REPRESENTING BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER M.S.RAJAPPA S/O.M.K.SHANKU (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

28. SHRI.M.KANTHARAJ ARAS MAJOR IN AGE S/O.D.MALLRAJ ARAS NO.113, EWS KHB COLONY 1ST MAIN, 3 RD CROSS BASAWESHWARA NAGARA BANGALORE – 560 079 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

29. SHRI.DEVARAJ ARAS.S MAJOR IN AGE S/O.SIDDARAJA ARAS.N NO.19, 9 TH CROSS, 3 RD STAGE 3RD BLOCK, 3 RD PHASE BANGALORE – 560 079 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

30. SHRI.B.H.GOPALASHETTY MAJOR IN AGE S/O.HONNAPPA SHETTY NO.111, VIJAYANAGARA 3RD STAGE, G BLOCK

10

MYSORE – 570 017 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

31. KUMARI G.S.BHOOSHARA MAJOR IN AGE S/O.GOUSH SHARIFF NO.3140, K.T.STREET MANDI MOHALLA MYSORE – 570 021 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

32. SMT.SYED NOOR JAHARA MAJORI N AGE W/O.GOUSH SHARIFF NO.3140, K.T.STREET MANDI MOHALLA MYSORE – 570 021 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

33. SMT.S.P.REKHA MAJOR IN AGE W/O.S.T.VASANTHA MDA 58, OPPOSITE OF TERISHION COLLEGE 2ND CROSS, VIDYANAGAR MYSORE -570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

34. SHRI.S.T.VASANTH MAJOR IN AGE S/O.S.C.THIRUMALAPPA MDA 58, OPPOSITE OF TERISHION COLLEGE, 2 ND CROSS, VIDYANAGAR MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

35. SHRI.JAGADEESH RAJ ARAS MAJOR IN AGE S/O.T.DEVARAJ ARAS NO.1171, 4 TH STAGE, T.K.LAYOUT 1ST CROSS, PODUVANA ROAD

11

KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

36. SMT.M.SARASWATHI MAJOR IN AGE W/O.JAGADEESH RAJ ARAS NO.1171, 4 TH STAGE, T.K.LAYOUT 1ST CROSS, PODUVANA ROAD KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

37. SHRI.JAGADESH RAJ ARAS MAJOR IN AGE S/O.T.DEVARAJA ARAS NO.1171, 4 TH STAGE, T.K.LAYOUT 1ST CROSS, PODUVANA ROAD KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

38. SHRI.H.S.MALLARAJA ARAS MAJOR IN AGE S/O.H.SUBRAMANYA RAJE ARAS NO.27, 4 TH CROSS, MARUTHI TEMPLE STREET KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 009 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

39. SHRI.NARAYAN MAJOR IN AGE S/O.JAWARAPPA CHARONAHALLI, VARUNA HOBLI MYSORE – 570 010 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

40. SMT.V.VENKATESHAMMA MAJOR IN AGE W/O.V.VENKATESHALU

12

NO.181, 2 ND CROSS, ANIKETHANA ROAD KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

41. SMT.M.P.LILAVATHI MAJOR IN AGE W/O.M.S.MURTHY NO.3, HIG PLOT, SHARADADEVI NAGARA MYSORE – 570 022 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

42. SMT.V.ROHINI MAJOR IN AGE W/O.V.JAGANNATHA NO.181, 2 ND CROSS, ANIKETHANA ROAD KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

43. SHRI.C.NAGARAJA MAJOR IN AGE S/O.CHANNARAJA ARAS NO.EWS 29, NEW KATHARAJA ARAS ROAD KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET. NO.6/2011).

44. SMT.BHAGYAMANI MAJOR IN AGE W/O.C.NAGARAJE ARAS NO.EWS 29, NEW KATHARAJA ARAS ROAD KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

45. SMT.NOOR JAHAN MAJOR IN AGE W/O.SYED RIAZ NO.32, 2 ND CROSS, GOUSIA NAGAR

13

KNA PURA MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

46. SMT.MUMTAZ BEGUM MAJOR IN AGE W/O.FAROOQ KHAN NO.32, 2 ND CROSS, GOUSIA NAGAR KNA PURA MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

47. SHRI.P.R. MAJOR IN AGE S/O.RAMRAJ ARAS NO.908, MANANDAVADI ROAD LAKSHMIPURAM MYSORE – 570 004 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

48. SHRI.G.GURUSHNAKAR MAJOR IN AGE S/O.GURUVAIAH N.2203/179, SHABIR NILAYA 3RD MAIN, MEDAR BLOCK BAMBOO BAZAAR MYSORE – 570 021 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

49. MISS.G.N.HEMA D/O.G.G.GURUSHNAKAR NO.2203/179, SHABIR NILAYA 3RD MAIN, MEDAR BLOCK BAMBOO BAZAAR MYSORE – 570 021 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

50. SMT.ASHITHA PINTU MAJOR IN AGE D/O.DANIAL PINTOO

14

NO.MIG 5, HUDKO, BANNI MANTAPA 1ST STAGE MYSORE – 570 015 (RELATING TRO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

51. SMT.SELESTINE DISOZA MAJOR IN AGE W/O.BENZAMIN DISOZA NO.MIG 5, HUDKO, BANNI MANTAPA 1ST STAGE MYSORE – 570 015 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

52. SHRI.DANIAL PINTOO MAJOR IN AGE S/O.M.G.PINTOO NO.MIG 5, HUDKO, BANNI MANTAPA 1ST STAGE MYSORE – 570 015 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

53. SHRI.M.S.RUDRAMURTHY MAJOR IN AGE S/O.M.SOMASHEKAR NO.240, 5 TH MAIN, BANNIMANTAPA C LAYOUT MYSORE – 570 015 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

54. SHRI.MICHEL PINTOO MAJOR IN AGE S/O.M.G.PINTOO NO.1007, BANNIMANTAPA B.LAYOUT, S.S.NAGARA MYSORE – 570 015 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

55. SMT.H.M.VIJAYALKSMI MAJOR IN AGE W/O.JAYARAMARAJE ARAS

15

NO.586, 2 ND MAIN, 2 ND CROSS NAGARA, M BLOCK MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

56. SMT.NAGAVENI MAJOR IN AGE W/O.A.M.JAYARAJE ARAS NO.586, 2 ND MAIN, 2 ND CROSS KUVEMPU NAGARA, M BLOCK MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

57. SMT.G.SHOBHA NAIR MAJOR IN AGE W/O.DIVAKARA NAIR NO.2552, 3 RD CROSS, 4 TH MAIN KALIDASA ROAD, ONTIKOPPAL, V.V.MOHALLA MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

58. SHRI.D.DIVAKARAN NAIR MAJOR IN AGE S/O.DAMODHARAN NAIR NO.2552, 3 RD CROSS, 4 TH MAIN KALIDASA ROAD ONTIKOPPAL, V.V.MOHALLA MYSORE – 570 002 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

59. SMT.R.VANAJAKSHI @ MANJULA MAJOR IN AGE W/O.VINOD KUMAR (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

60. SHRI. KUMAR MAJOR IN AGE S/O.VINOD KUMAR (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

16

61. SHRI.VISHAL KUMAR MAJOR IN AGE S/O.VINOD KUMAR (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

62. SHRI.VISHAL KUMAR MAJOR IN AGE S/O.VINOD KUMAR (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

RESPONDENTS NO.59 TO 62 ARE RESIDING AT: 149, 1 ST BLOCK 7TH CROSS, RAMAKRISHNA NAGARA MYSORE – 570 023.

63 SMT.SHIVAMMA MAJOR IN AGE W/O.M.D.CHAMANNA NO.928, 1 ST FLOOR, 1 ST MAIN LAKSHMIPURAM MYSORE – 570 004 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

64. SHRI.B.M.BHARATH BAASVARAJ ARAS MAJOR IN AGE S/O.B.M. DESARAJE ARAS NO.432, 4 TH STAGE,2 ND MAIN, 9 TH CROSS STK LAYOUT, KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

65 SHRI.H.S.NAGARATHANAMANI MAJOR IN AGE W/O.NANJUNDARAJA ARAS NO.2953/2, 1 ST MAIN ROAD SARASWATHIPURAM MYSORE – 570 009 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011)

17

66. SMT.M.N.SHASHIKALA MAJOR IN AGE W/O.DESARAJA ARAS NO.432, 4 TH STAGE, 2 ND MAIN, 9 TH CROSS STK LAYOUT, KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023 (RELATING TO EX.PET.NO.6/2011).

67. M/S.CHANAKYA FINANCE CORPORATION REG. REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER L.NAJUNDERAJE ARAS NO.381, 1 ST FLOOR, 2 ND CROS BENKINAWAB STREET, MANDIMOHALLA MYSORE – 57001.

68. THE THASHILDAR MYSORE TALUK MININVIDHANASOUDH NAZARABAD MYSORE – 570 019.

69. DISTRICT CONSUMER REDRESSAL FORUM, MYSORE NO.1542/f, ANIKETHANA ROAD C AND D BLOCK JCST LAYOUT, KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE – 570 023.

70. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER MYSORE DISTRICT NEAR TO MYSORE UNIVERSITY MYSORE – 570 001. ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. KUMAR A.PATIL, AGA FOR R68 TO R70)

THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE IMPUGNED COMMON ORDER DATED 17.1.2015 PASSED BY THE R-69 IN EXECUTION PETITIONS NO.6/2011 TO 24/2011, 48/2011,

18

50/2011 TO 56/2011, 60/2011, 63/2011, 64/2011, 67/2011 TO 70/2011, 79/2011, 119/2011, 39/2012, 41/2012, 42/2012, 50/2012 TO 52/2012, 54/2012, 56/2012 TO 58/2012, 60/2012, 63/2012, 65/2012, 71/2012, 73/2012, 74/2012, 91/2012, 92/2012, 102/2012, 103/2012, 113/2012, 08/2013, 10/2013 AND 12/2013 (COMMON ORDERS) AGAINST THE JDR NO.3 TO 8 AND 10 i.e., ANN-A AND B.

THESE PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:

O R D E R

Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that he is not pressing prayers A and C made in the paragraph No.38 of the writ petitions. Insofar as prayer-B is concerned, he seeks permission of this Court to withdraw the writ petitions with liberty to the petitioners to approach the appropriate Authorities / Court for appropriate relief.

2. The submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners is placed on record. Writ petitions are dismissed as withdrawn with liberty as above. All contentions on merit are kept open. No costs.

Sd/- JUDGE

VMB