DOCSLIB.ORG

Should Southern Baptist Baptize Their Children?: a Biblical, Historical, Theological Defense of the Consistency Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Should Southern Baptist Baptize Their Children?: a Biblical, Historical, Theological Defense of the Consistency Of LIBERTY UNIVERSITY SHOULD SOUTHERN BAPTISTS BAPTIZE THEIR CHILDREN? A BIBLICAL, HISTORICAL, THEOLOGICAL DEFENSE OF THE CONSISTENCY OF THE BAPTISM OF YOUNG CHILDREN WITH CREDOBAPTISTIC PRACTICES A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF LIBERTY BAPTIST THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY BY ROBERT JOSEPH MATZ LYNCHBURG, VIRGINIA APRIL 2015 Copyright © 2015 by Robert Joseph Matz All Rights Reserved ii APPROVAL SHEET SHOULD SOUTHERN BAPTISTS BAPTIZE THEIR CHILDREN? A BIBLICAL, HISTORICAL, THEOLOGICAL DEFENSE OF THE CONSISTENCY OF THE BAPTISM OF YOUNG CHILDREN WITH CREDOBAPTISTIC PRACTICES Robert Joseph Matz Read and approved by: Chairperson: KEVIN KING Dr. Kevin L. King Sr. Reader: DAVID A. WHEELER Dr. David A. Wheeler Reader: SCOTT HAWKINS, PHD Dr. Scott M. Hawkins Date: 4/3/2015 iii To my wife, Jessica Without you, this goal could never have been achieved. You are my best friend, and I am continually blessed by your love, support, and encouragement. iv CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................................... ix LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................................ xii ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................. xiii INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................... 1 Research Question ...................................................................................................................... 5 Relevance of This Study ......................................................................................................... 6 Biases ...................................................................................................................................... 8 Methodology and Chapter Summaries...................................................................................... 10 Chapter Summaries ............................................................................................................... 11 Definitions and Key Terms ....................................................................................................... 13 CHAPTER ONE: THE CONTEMPORANEOUS NATURE OF SPIRIT AND WATER BAPTISM FOR CREDO-BAPTISTS .......................................................................................... 17 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 17 John the Baptist and Spirit Baptism in the Gospels .................................................................. 19 Mark 1:2-11 .......................................................................................................................... 20 Matthew 3:1-17 ..................................................................................................................... 28 John 1:19-34.......................................................................................................................... 34 Luke 3:1-22 ........................................................................................................................... 39 Synthesis on John’s Baptism and Its Relations to Spirit Baptism ........................................ 43 Spirit and Water Baptism in the New Testament Church ......................................................... 46 Spirit and Water Baptism in the Book of Acts ..................................................................... 47 Spirit and Water Baptism in Pauline Literature and 1 Corinthians 12:13 ............................ 58 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 65 v CHAPTER TWO: CHILDREN AND CHRISTIAN CONVERSION ......................................... 67 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 67 Children in the Old Testament .................................................................................................. 68 Children and Discipleship ..................................................................................................... 69 Children and Accountability ................................................................................................. 77 Children and Initiation into the Faith Community ................................................................ 87 Children in the New Testament ................................................................................................ 90 Children and Discipleship ..................................................................................................... 90 Children and Conversion ...................................................................................................... 95 Children and Accountability ............................................................................................... 106 Children and Initiation into the Faith Community .............................................................. 109 Conclusions and Application .................................................................................................. 114 CHAPTER THREE: THE HISTORY OF SOUTHERN BAPTISTS, BAPTISM, AND THE AGE OF INITIATION ............................................................................................................... 117 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 117 Early Views of Baptists in America on the Conversion and Baptism of Children ................. 120 The Views of Early Baptists Regarding Children and Baptism ......................................... 121 Age-Related Demographic Trends amongst Early Baptists ............................................... 123 Southern Baptists and the Baptism of Children: 1845-1900 .................................................. 125 The Views of Southern Baptists Regarding Children and Baptism .................................... 126 Age-Related Demographic Trends among Early Southern Baptists ................................... 133 Southern Baptists and the Baptism of Children: 1900-1950 .................................................. 136 The Views of Southern Baptists Regarding Children and Baptism .................................... 137 Age-Related Demographic Trends among Baptists 1900-1950 ......................................... 143 Southern Baptist and the Baptism of Children: 1950-2000 .................................................... 147 vi The Views of Moderate Southern Baptists Regarding Children and Baptism ................... 149 The Views of Conservative Southern Baptists Regarding Children and Baptism .............. 154 Dissertations Relating to Children and Baptism ................................................................. 160 Age-Related Demographic Trends among Baptists: 1950-2000 ........................................ 162 Southern Baptists and the Baptism of Children: Early 21st Century ...................................... 168 The Views of Southern Baptists Regarding Children and Baptism .................................... 168 Age-Related Demographic Trends among Baptists ............................................................ 172 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................. 179 CHAPTER FOUR: THE BAPTISM OF CHILDREN AND A REGENERATE CHURCH MEMBERSHIP........................................................................................................................... 180 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 180 The Psychological Inability of Children to Function as Regenerate Church Members ......... 182 The Psychological Argument against the Baptism of Children .......................................... 183 In Response to the Psychological Arguments against the Baptism of Children ................. 194 Conclusions about the Cognitive Abilities of Children ...................................................... 208 The Sociological Critiques ...................................................................................................... 209 Religious Socialization Theory ........................................................................................... 210 Social-Exchange Theory ..................................................................................................... 213 Church-Sect Theory ............................................................................................................ 216 Theological Objections to the Baptism of Children ............................................................... 217 The Sin Nature of Children: The Age of Accountability .................................................... 218 Soteriology and the Baptism of Children ............................................................................ 224 Ecclesiastical Concerns Pertaining to the Baptism of Children .......................................... 228 Evangelistic Practices Relating to the Conversion of Young Children .............................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Inventory to the Baptist World Congress Collection
    BAPTIST CONGRESS PROCEEDINGS COLLECTION AR 40 2 Baptist Congress Proceedings Collection AR 40 Prepared by: Taffey Hall, Archivist Southern Baptist Historical Library and Archives August 2004 Updated October, 2011 Summary Main Entry: Baptist Congress Proceedings Collection Date Span: 1885 – 1912 Abstract: Collection contains papers, addresses, and discussions from Baptist Congress meetings. Title page of proceedings includes list of speakers and topics. Baptist intellectual think tank from 1882 – 1912 and forum for theological, social, and ethical discussions and debates among members of Baptist churches. Modeled after the Episcopal Church Congress and existed to “promote a healthful sentiment among Baptists through free and courteous discussion of current questions by suitable persons.” Size: 1.5 linear ft. Collection#: AR 40 Biographical Sketch The Baptist Congress, a pioneering Baptist intellectual think tank and forum for theological, social, and ethical discussions and debates among members of Baptist churches, existed from 1882 to 1912. The need for an intellectual outlet through which Baptists from various traditions could discuss important and relevant issues of the time was first proposed by Providence, Rhode Island pastor Elias Henry Johnson. Johnson and thirteen other prominent Baptist scholars met in New York City November 29, 1881 and held an informal discussion panel on germane topics. At the meeting, Johnson officially proposed the formation of a Baptist Congress. The first official meeting of the organization was held in Brooklyn, New York in 1882. The Baptist Congress met annually for the next thirty years across the United States and Canada, with the exception of 1891 when no meeting was held. Due to decreasing attendance, the Baptist Congress held its last meeting in Ithaca, New York in 1912.
    [Show full text]
  • The Importance of Athanasius and the Views of His Character
    The Importance of Athanasius and the Views of His Character J. Steven Davis Submitted to Dr. Jerry Sutton School of Divinity Liberty University September 19, 2017 TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter I: Research Proposal Abstract .............................................................................................................................11 Background ......................................................................................................................11 Limitations ........................................................................................................................18 Method of Research .........................................................................................................19 Thesis Statement ..............................................................................................................21 Outline ...............................................................................................................................21 Bibliography .....................................................................................................................27 Chapter II: Background of Athanasius An Influential Figure .......................................................................................................33 Early Life ..........................................................................................................................33 Arian Conflict ...................................................................................................................36
    [Show full text]
  • The Reformation in Columbia Sionaries La- MINTS - Rev
    “‘I desire mercy, and not sacrifice.’ For I came not to call the righteous, but sinners.” Matt. 9:13 MAY 2017 Reformed mis- The Reformation in Columbia sionaries la- MINTS - Rev. Neal and Sandy Hegeman bored with faith missions, such as Wycliffe Bi- As an international URCNA missionary, I visit at least ble Translators, 9 -10 countries a year in order to teach the Bible, Reformed Latin Ameri- doctrine, ministry skills, and encourage students and teach- can Missions, ers to write courses. I have been visiting Columbia since 1999. New Tribes and In 2002, when we first started MINTS in Columbia, I could not others work- make it out of the airport in Bogota due to civil unrest in the ing with indig- streets and I had to fly to the next country. I returned three enous peoples, months later to start the first MINTS study center in Villavicen- but most of cio with the Iglesia Betania de la Reforma. Since 2002, we have these works become general evangelical churches with a bap- worked with six denominations and graduated more than 450 tistic and charismatic emphasis, on one hand, or hard-core students in our theological training program. There are three revolutionary liberation theology on the other. I only know of doctoral candidates who have written more than 15 books and one Reformed or Presbyterian church that came out of the our master level students have completed 24 Bible commen- Faith Mission approach in Colombia and that was with the taries as well as other thesis materials. MINTS has helped Re- Kubeo Indians and Iglesia Betania de la Reforma.
    [Show full text]
  • PROGRESSIVE COVENANTALISTS AS REFORMED BAPTISTS Daniel Scheiderer
    WTJ 82 (2020): 137–52 PROGRESSIVE COVENANTALISTS AS REFORMED BAPTISTS Daniel Scheiderer At least three new systems of covenant theology have arisen in Calvinistic Baptist circles in recent decades: new covenant theology, progressive covenantalism, and 1689 Federalism (Reformed Baptists). Each group has its own proponents and its own circles of influence, but churches impacted by each proposal are generally familiar to one another. Because progressive covenantalists initially described themselves as a subset of new covenant theology, arguments against new covenant theology were often simply co-opted for use against progressive covenantalists. This article aims to demonstrate that progressive covenantalists have significant points of continuity with their Reformed Baptist brothers that facilitate mutual benefit between the two camps. To demonstrate this continuity, the cov- enants of works and grace and the new covenant are examined in the two systems alongside their Particular Baptist forefathers to show that all three groups operate with a basically continuous infrastructure. The benefit of such a study is that it distinguishes the progressive covenantal proposal from the proposal of new covenant theology while avoiding simplistic read- ings that deny the real differences between progressive covenantalists and Reformed Baptists. The study does not deny the real tension that exists in progressive covenantalists’ reinterpretation of the fourth commandment, but it sets aside that debate so that points of clear commonalities may be seen for what they are. Too often conversations about covenant theology have passed one another, and so this article aims to initiate a conversation between two groups that ought to be the nearest allies. “ rogressive covenantalism” broke onto the scene in 2012 with Peter Gentry and Stephen Wellum’s book Kingdom through Covenant.
    [Show full text]
  • Reformed Baptists Progress in Colombia by Gordon Taylor “It’S Your Fault!” Said Manuel Cendales
    Winter 2014 Reformed Baptists progress in Colombia By Gordon Taylor “It’s your fault!” said Manuel Cendales. He was referring to the influence and teaching of Stan Line. Manuel, now committed to our 1689 Confession, used to be, by his own testimony, an extreme Pentecostal minister. Stan, who has labored for 50 years in Colombia, faithfully distributed Reformed literature to evangelical pastors over the years. In the case of Manuel it resulted in turning his ministry around. Now Manuel leads his church into the great truths of the The La Alborada congregation meets in Bogotá, Colombia. Christian faith. Manuel is but one example of these cities have thriving, growing of the way the Lord has worked in pastors’ and confessionally committed Reformed lives through Stan Line. Baptist churches. What I want to do in I had the privilege of interviewing this article is to introduce you briefly to the 13 pastors in two of0 the major cities of men of Bogotá, then describe the work in Colombia, Bogotá and Medellín. Bogotá, Medellín and finally describe a publishing Pastors from left, Christian Achuri, Stan the capital, has a population of almost effort for good literature in Spanish. Line and Manuel Cendales, with Gordon 8.5 million. Medellín, the second largest But before I do all of that let’s consider Taylor. city in Colombia, has 3.6 million. Both See Colombia, page 14 Inside: Lessons in sending IRBS influence in Great Britain. School of Missions report. a foreign missionary. PAGE 3 PAGE 4 PAGE 13 ARBCA Update n ARBCA Update Vol.
    [Show full text]
  • Recovering the Historical Practice of Delayed Baptism and Pre-Baptismal Instruction for the Purpose of Restoring
    LIBERTY UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF DIVINITY Recovering the Historical Practice of Delayed Baptism and Pre-Baptismal Instruction for the Purpose of Restoring the Standard of a Regenerate Church Membership in Southern Baptist Churches A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of Liberty University School of Divinity in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Alan C. McCullough Lynchburg, Virginia March 6, 2020 Copyright © 2020 Alan C. McCullough All Rights Reserved ii Approval Sheet Recovering the Historical Practice of Delayed Baptism and Pre-Baptismal Instruction for the Purpose of Restoring the Standard of a Regenerate Church Membership in Southern Baptist Churches Alan C. McCullough Read and Approved by: Chairperson: EDWARD L. SMITHER Dr. Edward L. Smither Reader: STEVEN A. MCKINION Dr. Steven A. McKinion Reader: DAVID A. WHEELER Dr. David A. Wheeler Approval: March 6, 2020 iii Acknowledgements Though the name on a dissertation and diploma represents the author’s determination and hard work, there a many people who have stood beside and behind this effort. First, I want to acknowledge my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, who called me by His grace into salvation through faith. He called me into ministry to the church and then further into pursuing my Ph.D. I pray the completion of this degree and disseration honors Him. He is worthy. Secondly, I could not have accomplished this calling without the sacrifices of my precious wife, Roben, who gave up countless time and activities to support my research over the years. Thank you for your love, believing in me and encouragement to fulfill God’s call on my life academeically.
    [Show full text]
  • The Future of Southern Baptists: Biblical Mandates for What We
    1 The Future Of Southern Baptists: Mandates For What We Should Be In The 21st Century Southern Baptists have a colorful and fascinating history by any standard of measure. From the Convention’s humble beginnings in Augusta, Georgia on May 8, 1845 (only 293 persons attended the Inaugural Convention and 273 came from 3 states: Georgia, South Carolina and Virginia),1 the Convention’s 2004 Annual could boast of 40 State Conventions, 1,194 Associations, 43,024 Churches and a Total Membership of 16,315,050. There were 377,357 Baptisms, and other additions totaled 422,350. Cooperative Program Giving for 2002-2003 was $183,201,694.14, and Total Receipts recorded was $9,648,530,640.2 This is quite impressive any way you look at it, and for all of this and more Southern Baptists give thanks and glory to God. We are grateful to our Lord for what He has done for us and through us. However, it is to the future that we must now look. In spite of periodic blips on the cultural and moral screen, our nation grows more secular and our world more hostile to “the faith once for all delivered to the saints” (Jude 3). Southern Baptists, in the midst of the swirling tides of modernity, have attempted to stake their claim and send a clear message on who we are. The Conservative Resurgence initiated in 1979 charted the course, and I would argue the Baptist Faith and Message 2000 was something of a defining moment.3 Still, I am not convinced we have a clear 1 Leon McBeth, The Baptist Heritage (Nashville: Broadman, 1987), 388.
    [Show full text]
  • Why We Are Not Reformed Baptists
    Why We Are Not Reformed Baptists “For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock. Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them. Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears.” Acts 20:29-31 Introduction: 1. Having some things in common with Reformed Baptists, especially the preaching of the sovereignty of God in salvation, we are sometimes confused with them by those lacking proper knowledge. 2. Having recently been marked as heretics by some Reformed Baptists, let us identify our differences. 3. We pursued a similar study back in 1986 identifying our differences from the Primitive Baptists. 4. It is our holy and solemn duty to identify heresy and name names to protect the church of Jesus Christ and the people of God from false doctrine, teachers, and churches (Matt 16:12; Rom 16:17- 18; Gal 1:6-9; II Thess 2:15; 3:6,14; I Tim 1:19-20; II Tim 2:16-18; Titus 1:9-14; 3:10-11; Jude 1:3). 5. The New Testament’s warnings about heresy often do not intend idolatry, paganism, or devil worship – but rather a compromised gospel involving another Jesus, spirit, and gospel, for a mixture of truth and error is harder to detect and defend against, like a counterfeit bill similar to the original. 6. Whether Reformed Baptists or any others approve of us or not does not matter to us (Acts 24:14).
    [Show full text]
  • Copyright © 2014 John Daniel Mcdonald
    Copyright © 2014 John Daniel McDonald All rights reserved. The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary has permission to reproduce and disseminate this document in any form by any means for purposes chosen by the Seminary, including, without limitation, preservation or instruction. TOWARD A BAPTIST VIEW OF METAPHILOSOPHY: AN ANALYSIS OF E. Y. MULLINS, JOHN NEWPORT, RICHARD CUNNINGHAM, AND L. RUSS BUSH A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy by John Daniel McDonald May 2014 APPROVAL SHEET TOWARD A BAPTIST VIEW OF METAPHILOSOPHY: AN ANALYSIS OF E. Y. MULLINS, JOHN NEWPORT, RICHARD CUNNINGHAM, AND L. RUSS BUSH John Daniel McDonald Read and Approved by: ____________________________________________ Theodore J. Cabal (Chair) ____________________________________________ Michael A. G. Haykin ____________________________________________ James Parker III Date________________________________ To Angie McDonald, whose sacrifice and support made this dissertation possible; to Maddie, Libby, and Emma, whose patience and understanding are beyond their years; to Charles and Shelly McDonald, who instilled in me a love of the Lord and of learning; and to Ted Cabal, who first introduced me to philosophy and its value for the service of Christian theology. TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..................................................................................... VIII PREFACE ....................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Puritan and New Covenant Baptists: Co-Defenders of the Decalogue by Martin Rizley
    Puritan and New Covenant Baptists: Co-Defenders of the Decalogue by Martin Rizley I want to speak to you this evening about an issue that has been a matter of ongoing interest and concern to me for a number of years. That issue concerns the Christian's relationship to the Law of God, and in particular, to the Decalogue or Ten Commandments as a revelation of the moral will of God. As you well know, for some time now, there has been a rather heated controversy among Reformed or Calvinistic Baptists concerning the role of the Decalogue in Christian teaching and ethical instruction. That controversy arose in the early 1980's as a number of Calvinistic Baptists who had discovered the riches of Reformed theology began to question certain aspects of that theology as it had developed in the seventeenth century through the English Puritans. Three things in particular were questioned: (1) the idea of one overarching "covenant of grace" governing all of God's covenantal dealings with man from the fall of Adam through the whole of redemptive history; (2) the strict identification of God's unchanging moral law with the Ten Words spoken by God at Mt. Sinai; and (3) the strict "sabbatarian" view of Sunday which was developed by the English Puritans and enshrined confessionally for Baptists in the Second London Confession of 1689. As some Calvinistic Baptists began to question these three tenets of historic Puritan theology, a rift developed between those who held strictly to the Puritan view of the Law and those who dissented from the Puritan view.
    [Show full text]
  • 2012-2014 Academic Catalog
    Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary 2012-2014 Academic Catalog 5001 North Oak Trafficway Kansas City, Missouri 64118-4697 Switchboard: 816-414-3700 Application Information: 1-800-944-6287 Email: [email protected] Website: www.mbts.edu While this Catalog was prepared utilizing the best information available at the time of publication, Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary reserves the right to make corrections and changes without further notice in accordance with new policies and procedures. Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission of the North Central Association of Colleges and Schools (NCA-HLC) and the Commission on Accrediting of the Association of Theological Schools (ATS) in the United States and Canada. NCA-HLC is recognized by the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA) and the U.S. Department of Education (USDE). July 2012 Academic Calendar 2012-2013 2013-2014 Fall Semester Music Placement Exams August 15 August 14 Master’s New Student Orientation August 17 August 16 Fall Semester Registration/Fall Fees Due August 20 August 19 Fall Classes Begin August 20 August 19 Labor Day – Classes Cancelled September 3 September 2 Last Day to Apply for December Graduation September 15 September 15 Fall Picnic September 13 September 12 Fall Break October 8-13 October 7-12 Thanksgiving Break November 19-24 November 25-30 Finals Week December 10-13 December 9-12 Last Day to Apply for May Graduation December 13 December 12 Christmas Recess December 14-January 6 December 13 -January
    [Show full text]
  • From Church Competence to Soul Competence: the Devolution of Baptist Ecclesiology
    Journal for Baptist Theology and Ministry Vol. 3 No. 1 (Spring 2005): 145-163 From Church Competence to Soul Competence: The Devolution of Baptist Ecclesiology John Hammett Professor of Systematic Theology Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary Post Office Box 1889 Wake Forest, NC 27588 The thesis of this paper is threefold: (1) that congregational polity in Baptist ecclesiology was undergirded, particularly in its early days, by a conviction that Christ had granted to each local church power and authority (what I call competence) to order its own affairs; (2) that over a long period of time, but particularly in the late nineteenth century, a variety of factors developed in American life that began to undermine the idea of church competence and replace it with an idea enshrined in the phrase “soul competence;” and (3) that this development should be regarded as a devolution in Baptist ecclesiology, for it seems linked to a variety of deleterious ideas and practices that have been and are continuing to weaken and trouble Baptist church life. This threefold thesis will be developed in the three main sections of this paper, with each section devoted to one of the three aspects of the thesis. As the documentation will suggest, I am looking primarily at what has happened to Baptists in North America, particularly my own context of Southern Baptists. I do not know how applicable it will be to Baptists from other geographical contexts, but I believe it will have some relevance for most evangelical groups in the North American context, because the factors that affected Baptists were not completely unique to them.
    [Show full text]